Wingspan (Americas) - Board Game Expansion Review
Transcript
Hi everyone, this is the broken mele. Win or lose, I'm going to be honest with you. And finally, yes, within the UK, people are starting to get copies of their Wingspan America's expansion. So, this is a Beyond the Base game video to talk about essentially what this one brings to the table. As you can see, it took me a little while to uh bring out sadly the um the nesting box. Yes, you will notice I gave that a pretty negative review in the past. It was brought out way too early. It's not the best design box in the world. It's definitely, I think, oversized for what it needs to be, even if you were to take into account all potential future content. And it seems to have this bonkers idea that if you're going to sort out your cards in here, that you would have these dividers in order to separate out all the expansions. as if anybody who plays Wingspan religiously actually separates out all the expansion cards. They don't. I mean, this this was like a a mind-blowing like display of what WTF when it came to design. But sadly, as much as I've managed to get everything up to Asia in the base box with the folded space insert and everything to date with Americas, that's not the case. maybe buy some weird Tetrising. If you don't have an insert and you don't sleeve your cards, you might be able to get everything in the base box. But I think for the majority of people, you're either going to need to invest in this nesting box or just accept you're going to have two boxes.
Although probably not the America's box because um it's the eco style cardboard box. So, uh I don't think you're going to be wanting to keep too much in this. It's good for cheapness. It's good for, you know, shipping and that, but yeah, I wouldn't necessarily want to store stuff in here as a proper thing on my shelf. But let's pop that there for a second. So with that aside, what does Wingsman America's bring in? So a little bit of context for the other expansions. Uh we had Europe, which was just basically more cards. You buy it, you throw it in, you never take it out. Why would you separate them in the nesting box? It's more cards. It's good. Why not have it? Oceanana was the expansion I thought was damn near essential because as much as I love Wingsman, there is the problem that the base game is not necessarily 100% balanced. Go figure. You know, it has the problem of the board being a little bit too skewed towards eggs and making it very hard to get food compared to like the other stuff. So, what happened was that Oceanana basically brought in a revised board in order to correct those like misconceptions and give you more ways to spend resources to get stuff on these tracks. Adding the nectar resource so that you can play big birds easier.
And Oceanana was definitely an expansion I thought was basically pretty much a must buy for this game. Asia, on the other hand, if you check out my review for that, wasn't so good. It introduced a one to two player duet mode, which is okay, but honestly, the game worked fine at two players anyway. You didn't need this weird duet mode. Same with the solo. It introduced a six to seven player mode called flock mode, which is probably the most garbage idea I can think that the game has had to date. Who the hell is playing this game at five, let alone six and seven? Yes. Are you insane? And then on top of that, the birds were fine. It was just basically more variety. But I've had to actually remove a couple of birds from my copy of Wingspan because they are just too powerful. And if you don't believe me, play a game where the crane birds, the ones who say that you can score a bonus card immediately and then potentially draw a new one or score it again at the end of the game. Tell me that those have not won people games by themselves. They are ridiculously overpowered and they're not going to be in any of my games in the future. So yeah, Wingspan, as much as I love it, a hitand- miss arrangement. So hopefully this one does the trick at bringing it back to life.
So what exactly does it do? Well, essentially introduces the hummingbird mechanic. So you've now got these very cute little cards for hummingbirds. And if you've ever seen hummingbirds in the wild, sadly I have not, but hummingbirds are just some of the cutest little birds that you've ever seen. They are tiny, they're colorful, they're just wonderful little creatures. Um, a good, in fact, I'll put a clip up actually. You can see like the grand tour people like you know Jeremy Clarkson and that basically like looking at the hummingbirds at the moment. Is that pretty sweet?
They are absolutely beautiful, aren't they?
So these hummingbirds work in the following fashion. The idea is is that if you perform an action on your board and when you get to the end of it, there's no hummingbird there. You attract one of these hummingbirds from the face up board. And the idea is is that these hummingbirds all have a little bonus it gives you for doing it. So, might get you to lay an egg, get you another food, get you another nectar, that kind of thing. You know, they're very basic bonuses and there's only a few of them. But on top of that, they also have a symbol on the top right. You know, basic I thought it was a bit weird at first for seeing diamonds and emeralds on a symbology for these things. But it does actually explain in the rule book what theatic reasoning is for using these particular symbols. And it's like, fair play. You did your homework, so not going to fault that. At least it's based on real stuff and not like the law book from Worms Span.
Remember that nonsense? But the idea is is that when you return one of these out, you get to level up on this track the various tokens. So you'll have a token for each on the start. And every time one of these returns, you basically level up the track here. And when you go over a bird symbol, you get to do another one of those attract um you know, little actions. And these will score you points or potentially lose your points if you don't move it at all by the end of the game. So essentially, it's a an extra little benefit you get for activating actions rather than playing birds specifically because you don't have a a hand of these. You constantly get them from this board. So this never you never sit there with a hand of these things singing, "Oh, I'll play this now. I'll play this now." No, it's what's on the board. But on top of that, it's basically another way to score points and get some little bonuses. I mean, every now and again, an egg or a nectar or, you know, an extra food here or there is going to save your bacon in one way or another. So that's essentially what the expansion adds in terms of a mechanic. On top of that, you get some extra gold cards. You get more birds. So yes, we've got, you know, a little green tray here with effectively two cubby holds worth if you sleeve the cards like I do full of new birds. And some of them are geared toward the hummingbird things. So I will mention that a little bit again later. But for the most part, the rest of them are mechanics you've seen before. You know, you've got all sorts of different birds.
They will correspond to the different goal cards as they did before. and they'll do the the same sort of stuff you've seen before, but they will have things from the other expansions. So, you're going to have round end abilities, once between turn abilities, game end abilities. So, if you haven't got any of the other expansions, you're going to see that stuff appear new now. So, you you just be warned about that. But, you'll have your own little trade to store the new cards. But, this will basically just be an additional trade that can go in your nesting box, whatever. You know, you're going to mix all these cards together. Let's face it, that's how you do it. It is just that the luxury edition has so much more eagle.
A couple of little component niggles with this. Firstly, you get some nectar tokens in this because you could feasibly play this without Oceanana, though. Why would you? But the nectar tokens in this are a lighter tone than the ones you've had before. So, if you haven't upgraded your tokens, these are going to look out of place when you use them on the others. The other thing I found a little bit confusing, I'm very surprised this got past the design stage, is that if you have the dividers from the nesting box, you'll notice they all fit a particular theme. So, they've got like the white border, they've got a very thick color banner, and they all line up pretty much. You can see they sort of line up there. And originally, it was Latin America. Here's a tip. Just hang on to this divider and don't chuck it away because they replace this with one for America's because technically this is the Americas expansion, not the Latin America expansion. Just keep this one though because
yeah, see the difference? I mean, come on. You know, it's clearly like the banner is misshaped. It's it doesn't look right. The wording is smaller and more bunched up. the color banner is shifted to the very top of the tile. As you can see, there's no white banner at the top and it just looks weird. It's completely out of sync with the rest. I know that's probably a minor blemish and most people wouldn't care. And I mean, I'm not exactly going to lose sleep over it, but you know, it's just one of those things where you look at when components for a game are done and you look at these mistakes and you just think, surely anybody with half an eye left in their in their socket would actually be able to notice that that was an issue. was like, "How does this thing get past quality control?" But oh well, like I say, they're minor things. Nobody's going to really too fuss on that. But in terms of the expansion game play, so these hummingbirds do introduce a neat little extra scoring mechanic. You know, I'm all I'm all up for other ways to score points in this game because you've got the different birds that you play.
You've got all the different powers that they have, caching food, tucking cards, and laying eggs and things like that. So, you've got that stuff, and that stuff still remains. But what the hummingbird does is you don't necessarily get points for the hummingbirds. They are still zero points at the end of the day when it comes to their individual birds. But the track that you're leveling up, I mean, if you get to the very top of a track, it's 10 points for that particular token. If you don't start at all, it's minus three. And it does like go up quite slowly. I mean, it's minus 3 0 1 2 3 4 6 8 10. So, it does quickly build up. But you could earn quite a decent amount of points from this if you were to focus a lot on the hummingbird thing and get all the tokens up in some way. It's a potential good point earner. And as a result, your points in this game are definitely going to be inflated to what you had before. I mean, you already have the base game set of points than what you can get with Oceanana. Now you're going to have this much when you throw in America's, especially on top of Oceanana. Your scores are going to easily break a hundred in most games without even breaking a sweat. It's pretty easy to do. But it's quite a neat little thing that makes the action rows a bit more enticing to do because, you know, I'm all up for playing more birds, but you know, you want to play the birds, you want to get all the powers, but sometimes you look at an action, you think, well, all I'm getting is two eggs and I don't really activate anything with these birds, so it's not that interesting. But now, because you've got these hummingbirds like constantly going back and forth with your, you know, your board and, you know, you get another one, get a little bonus, and then that returns to the board, and then another one comes in v. I mean, not only does it fit the theme of hummingbirds, but it
means you're getting lots of little bonuses every now and again. It's like little rewards on top of whatever you're already getting for the action row. And there's five of them on this board. So, you do get a decent amount of variety in there. You know, if you're trying to find a specific symbol or a specific bonus, you know, you should hopefully be able to do all right with the five that are there. Or you can just draw from the top of the deck as always. But it's nice that there's more choice and they didn't just put three on there. I think that would have been too few. Five is a good number. And there's a lot of different birds in here. I mean, there are so many different varieties of hummingbird. And all the ones in here, they're all unique. So, yeah, if you want pretty pictures of hummingbirds, this is going to make your eyes water. It's just really nice and lovely. Um, but it does mean that you've got a little bit more meat to this game. You know, a bit more like a sort of way to diversify how you're getting points. Are you just going to focus on the main birds and not care too much about the hummingbirds?
Okay, fine. But you probably want to do a little bit of it because otherwise you're going to suffer those minus three point negatives. But you could spend most of your game really focusing on the hummingbird thing. So you're scoring like 40 50 points from that board, but you're not doing much else in terms of your engine. But then let's face it, the hummingbirds don't need food. They don't need eggs. They don't even need cards. You know, they come from a board. So you don't have to have a massive row of stuff on your green, yellow, and blue track in order to do well with the hummingbirds. So, you can focus on either or pretty well, but then it doesn't hurt to diversify into each one. It's a pretty neat expansion from a gameplay perspective, and I'm all for it. That being said, I don't think it's like a must buy expansion. It's it's one of those um mechanics I think is good, but if it's not in the game, I'm not going to miss it. You know, I miss the Oceanana expansion when it's not in the game. You know, I realize that the boards are out of balance and I'm missing a bunch of birds and game end powers and the nectar resource. You know, it really did impact the game a lot, Oceanana. But if this one's not in the game, yeah, you miss you you notice that the hummingbird thing isn't there, but it doesn't really impact your game that much apart from just bringing the points down. It's like, uh, it's not there. Okay, fine. But if somebody wants to slot it in, I'm like, cool, all for it. So, it's a a good but not essential expansion. However, there are one or two caveats. Uh the biggest caveat, uh well, there two caveats. The smaller of the two caveats is that this is not necessarily an expansion I want to teach
the game with. You know, you've got now this track that you've got to level up. You've got the different bonuses that this thing has. You've got the constant like like dealing with the whole attract and return thing because it can be a little bit of a logistical nightmare sometimes because you might activate a thing and then this lets you return a hummingbird and then as a result you level up this track which then lets you do another attract and return thing which might let you return another hummingbird which might let you track another one. It's like it can get a little bit fiddly sometimes with like spamming, you know, combos with the hummingbird mechanic. And for new players, this is going to throw them off a little bit. Bear in mind that Wingspan is meant to be taught to relatively like gamers. I mean, yeah, gamers will be able to get it pretty easily, but you know, for players that are relatively new to games that are introduced to Wingspan, I think Americas would be a bit too much for them, honestly. But that's not the biggest caveat. Biggest caveat and the biggest negative of this expansion is, oh boy. Um, if you thought Wings Band was long enough already, have fun when you introduce this expansion to the mix. This easily adds a good 25% extra time to the length of the game, particularly if you are playing this with four or five. Now, on that note, four is not a common number I play this with, although I do have some friends who enjoy the game. So, we do play as a force on that on then. Um, and yeah, it's long enough with four with this expansion, it crosses a line, frankly.
Three, it's not too bad. And two, it's not too bad. You know, you don't notice the extra time too much in a two and three player game. So, I think it's fine at two and three. And five, let's face it, if you were playing Wingspan at five on a regular basis, you probably had Woody Woodpecker gnawing at your skull too long, you know, to the point where you've got brain damage. You've certainly, you know, Wingsband with five just did not work. Don't get me started on flock mode, you know. So, you know, it's one of those things where the publisher puts five on the box just to sell more copies without actually trying to figure out whether five was a good idea or not. It's a common thing. This has been going on for years, and I will rant about it until the cows come home, or in this case, the hummingbirds. But, you know, it does mean that games are going to be longer. Now, they do put a little variant at the back of the book, a short game variant. And the idea is is that it's optional. And we found that the hummingbirds add some extra time that is most noticeable at four to five players. Yeah. Think. But if you find yourself wishing for a shorter game, simply remove one action token from each player before the start of the game because you will still achieve just as much as a normal game because of the hummingbirds. I think that if you're playing this with two to three players, you can decide whether you want to do that or not. I don't mind either way. I can take or leave. But if you're playing this with four, and for some bizarre reason playing this with five, the short variant is a mandatory inclusion. Do not play this without that variant included at four and five. You are going to notice it and you are going to wonder why a game of Wingsman should be taking this long. You know, it's got too much going on with, you know, the
hummingbirds constantly going back and forth with four players. you know, it will make the downtime between turns longer, which for a multiplayer solitaire game, you know, I do love this game, but it's multiplayer multiplayer solitaire at the end of the game. There is very little player interaction, if any. So, the last thing I want is more downtime between turns and extended length. You need to use that variant. So, you know, I wish there was a better way to do it rather than just simply going right, you get one less action to do for the game, but that's the way it is and it's the only way they can do it. You know, I would like to know if there was a better way they could have done it. And I know other reviewers have commented that they're not a huge fan of using the variant because they don't like removing an action token, but seriously, you need to do something. You cannot just leave it as, you know, as long as it is. It's just not going to work.
No, it's the children who were wrong.
So, earlier on I said that this expansion was essentially a good but not essential one. And that's where I'm sticking with it. I'm pleased to actually get something from Stone Bar lately that I can actually recommend. You know, it's not been the greatest string of games, has it? You know, the pendulums, the tapestries, the exp the scythe expeditions, the the Vantage. You know, I think Vantage I gave a recommendation in solo only, and even then that was bare bones. So, it, you know, it's nice to actually get something that I can go, yeah, this is genuinely a good expansion, but I still stand by the fact that it is good, not essential, or good, not great. You know, I like the hummingbird mechanic. It's a bit abstract. you know, this whole leveling up tokens for points. Yes, I would have liked if it was a little bit more interesting than that, but it's still a nice cool way to score points. I love the hummingbird pictures. I love the artwork. I like the hummingbird theme that they've used with the symbology, and I like what how it makes actions better. So, from a gameplay perspective, it's a great expansion, but you got to caveat that it's not the best to teach new players, and the added time length means that you're going to have to put up with a longer game, which is not ideal for Wingspan, or use the variant they've got in the book. And the solo mode just basically adds rules for using it with there. Works fine in solo.
So to be honest, there not much change there. I think this is good, but not great. I'm giving this a solid 7 out of 10. It's a solid good expansion. If you put it in your game, I'm going to enjoy it when we play it. If you take it out and we're playing it with Oceanana, I'm not going to miss this one terribly. If you want to play Wingspan and it's just the base game form, I'm probably not going to play Wingspan because I think Oceanana is just damn near essential at this point. But, you know, I'm seeing some fairly generous scores for this one. I think, you know, nines out of tens for this is maybe forgiving the time issue a little bit much. But, you know, I still think seven solid. It's good. I'm going to keep it. I'm going to play with it if I get a chance. You know, if people are familiar with Wings Man, I'm going to throw it in, but I'm just not going to lose sleep if someone decides, you know what, we don't need it. So, that's it for me on this episode of the Broken Meble. If you like what you see, then please thumb it up here and thumb it up on board game when it goes live on the page for this expansion. I lost my sponsor recently, Kiender. sad days, you know, for them.
But, you know, the Patreons have helped me keep this channel going very easily. So, to get copies like this to review, I need the support of the Patreons to help fund the channel. And those who have supported me, I can't be more than grateful for for what you've done. So, if you do get a chance to support, and even if it's just a little bit each month, it all goes a long way. Until next time, remember, it's only a game. And I'll see you on the next Broken Meble video. Take care, everyone.