Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ranking Uwe Rosenberg's Tile-Laying Games

Transcript 18:31

hi everyone my name is moni and i'm naveen from before you play and today we are going to be doing our final wrap-up video for the uv rosenberg tiling series yeah so monique and i we played through five of ube rosenberg's polyamino tile laying games if you are interested in seeing any of those there is a playlist over here where we chronicled all five of those games uh there is gonna be a bonus six one that we are going to talk about but it's a little different than those other five games and so the reason why we did this is because we're actually preparing for the larger ub rosenberg series which we are going to be embarking on in a couple of weeks those are the bigger the bigger box games i guess yeah because it felt kind of strange comparing this series of games to those ones yeah because some of these these title and games can be you know quick 30 minute games some of those can be two plus hour long you know heavy crunchy games and so it felt kind of apples and oranges to kind of compare them all and so these games were all published between the years of 2014 to i believe new york zoo came out last last year 2020. so they did span a seven year timeline i guess which is pretty impressive for strictly polyamino um tetris piece kind of games right yep across those years other kind of games that feature polio motels have been uh released such as isle of cats as well as um baron park stuff like that but these are games that are specifically just tetra shaped pieces you put them on on a board and you try to fill up the board exactly they all have that same basic premise but just done in a lot of different ways right and so what are some things that you have learned or do you have any kind of like concluding thoughts after playing all these games well he's definitely a master of it uh for somebody to come up with five games

that basically encompass the same exact components and he's still just putting him on a board but they he made him different enough uh when that makes it kind of very very interesting that somebody can go from games such as agricola lahav and those huge games but also design these other simpler games um that was pretty impressive yeah i agree i think that unless you really really love you know that this kind of playstyle you don't need them all right they they're all they all definitely still have the same kind of basic premise um and so you can kind of just pick and choose whichever one has the mechanics or the kind of game style that you enjoy the most but if you do collect them all they are all distinct enough to play as different games and that was the question that we were asking ourselves before we started the series specifically for the trilogy the cottage garden indian summer spring meadow trilogy are they all different enough to consider them separate games and i think the answer is yes yeah totally and it's interesting because you can actually see some of the mechanics from this series in the larger big box game exactly such as a piece for odin which is probably the most obvious of the comparisons right and unless you have anything else to add we're going to embark on our final ranking let's do it ready okay so we are going to discuss uh six actually of these games and uh we did discuss our rankings beforehand and they just happen to be the exact same ones yep they are so uh we'll be doing this together all right so starting with our honorable mention because we actually have one this time around we do yeah uh-huh yes and the reason why it's an honorable mention is because it's not quite polyamino thailand no it's thailand but it's not yeah like you said yeah

this is sagani um it was a game that we actually made a playthrough video of uh with the prototype yeah this is the prototype this is the prototype exactly and so this does feature tiles but not in the tetra c way it's not like uh strangely shaped tiles that you fit together yeah you're not trying to like lock and key and put different things into certain spots right you are trying to uh do lay out tiles in an abstract way on your table and so uh for that reason i still consider this kind of one of the tile laying games you're still laying tiles technically yes similarly he also made another game called nova luna which is kind of like the pre predecessor of this game specifically we just don't have it right but they play very similarly and between those two i i think i prefer sagani both at the time said sagani i think i still do in terms of the rest of the uh lineup where would you fit this if it weren't a kind of like a runner up or a bonus edition if it because it's not polynomial i would probably stick this somewhere in the dead center maybe it'd be like number four or number three somewhere okay amongst that i don't know exactly though we'll return to it then after we finish the whole okay let's do that okay moving on to number five so this is a game that is part of the actual trilogy and uh we both had the same opinion of it almost immediately yeah i think so and so this game is spring meadow now this one uh in a lot of comments people said this is their favorite one and so maybe maybe that's why for me uh by reading those comments i thought that this was going to be the one that stood out the most amongst the three

of those in that series but for some reason this one in particular was the least enjoyable of the three yeah i think it it had to do maybe with just the the initial just look of the board it's just that white and then you're kind of barely putting those greens on and there's no real dimension in terms of uh color scheme so there was that initial just kind of like oh because you go from indian summer to this oh yeah that's true so the marmots are really cute they remind me of dexter dog so but i totally agree um i think that this is this is the one that was most recently released aside from new york zoo and so of the the three in the series i imagine that this is the one that would get the most eyes because you know a board gaming hobby is growing and growing right otherwise it just felt not different enough from the first two that we had played right like by the time we got to the third one we were like okay so it does feature a um a new way of scoring it does do that kind of like tetris scoring where you go from the bottom to the top and that is my absolute favorite part of the game but other than that it doesn't do much else i do like that you have to win a scoring yeah phase and that is how you essentially win the game you just win two out of out of the out of the three of the three games yeah for some reason when uh playing it the first time it it had this kind of bell-shaped curve to it like the first time i played it i had that initial thought of like i don't really like it that much second and turn and third time i played it i felt like oh this is actually better than i initially thought and then as we played it more it kind of went back again to that like

okay this doesn't have that longevity or the kind of long time staying power it's probably because you realized more of the strategy and you're like oh that's a little bit better and then you're like well that's actually it so yeah that's exactly it yeah so anyway that is our number five spring meadow all right moving on to number four so this is a game that we were initially split on naveen kind of changed his mind after he heard what my number four yeah i had it ranked higher and then i thought about it more and then we came to an agreement and this game is cottage garden cottage garden yes this is the first in that stronghold uh line of the three games yes and so this one there's two scoring tracks and you are basically trying to fill out your board and and get that board flipped over and put into the into the general pool uh and you're just basically trying to score as many points as possible yeah so it's interesting it's good it looks nice um but the more i thought about it the more i i yeah i agree with you on four yeah i don't know why yeah but yeah this is this is the first one of the trilogy so this is the first time technically that we were able to play a polyamorous highlighting game by louis rosenberg that's more than two players because before this was just patchwork yeah and then suddenly it's a four-player game and so this you know the thing that i appreciate about this specifically the trilogy is that all three of them scored differently right with spring meadow it was that bottom to top you have to win a majority of scoring uh phases in this one you're trying to score the most points you're constantly flipping your fields and just trying to score as many of those as possible

but there's uh kind of like a a mini game in the way that you move your pawn on the scoring um the scoring tracks so that's a part of the game itself right i will say i do what i do like about this game is the fact that you can see all the tiles they're all laid out for you so you can kind of math out and figure out like okay if i'm able to flip this then i know that these tiles are going to go out and that's going to be perfect with my other garden because you're simultaneously managing two different gardens uh so that part i do enjoy in this game yeah so i like this game this there's a kind of a larger gap between this one and spring meadow in my opinion this is the one that if we were to go and play a polyamory game with um your parents i would bring this one because it has the the prettiest like floral theme to it yeah it's not the prettiest in my opinion of all of them but it definitely has this like really nice like floral look it does look good yeah the thing though the reason why it was lower on my list specifically is because of the flipping of the the squares like the actual player boards i prefer my thailand games with just one player board you try to fill up your own board and that's it that's good how i like to play them and so that's obviously that's like a point of preference but that's why this game wasn't higher on my list that's fair yeah i still in in my head i'm still thinking would i rank this a little bit higher than some of the other ones but i i think four is exactly yeah why did you bring it lower i just thought about the other games and i was like when we talk about three and two then i'll you know i can kind of discuss why i enjoyed those ones a little bit more than this one all right then moving on to number three we're kind of blasting through these

so um our number three is the final game in the trilogy and so you probably already know what it is it is indian summer i need summer this one is the one that looks the best i would say amongst the three of those yeah for sure i mean cottage garden is pretty in a different way the reason why i think this one is the prettiest is because it's most colorful and like very vibrant it's bold yeah it has the most vibrant color scheme and uh after we played the third in that trilogy i immediately knew that this was going to be my favorite one and the reason why is because i i really like the race elements yeah so i think that that's my preference when it comes to the polyomino tailgate laying games i don't like it when you score points i prefer it where it's just a race yeah you can build a board after we discussed it and you telling me that i was like yeah that that's probably right because there's that competition in in this versus you know sometimes in a point scoring thing it's like a tile can work out for you yeah and score you a bunch of points which is great uh but in this one it's it's like i'm competing with you and maybe maybe i want to hate draft that tile from you because i know that'll be the thing that completes your board you know and so uh this game kind of has that element there's a lot more player interaction also in this game because you can steal other people's tiles that's true and you don't have that in the other one exactly yeah so for for that reason this one then got elevated for me uh and they're also those like a bonus chits and at first when you're learning the game i found them uh kind of difficult to remember like what they all do but once you get them all down i it's it's fun it's neat there are a lot of different ways to get you to where you

need to to be i guess so there's a lot of strategy that's involved in indian summer so definitely my favorite of the trilogy but this falls uh under number three yep all right final two in our series can you imagine we played all these games there's a lot of polyamino tiles there's a lot of games um okay so number two we're both pretty much in agreement with this through and through and uh it's one of the original piling games out there it makes sense why it's number two yes for good reason it is a two-player only game a patchwork patchwork this game is sort of legendary you know like it's all like everybody's best games for two players lists and and uh it's just so well known right it's very well made it's a simple game super simple game but uh there is a lot of replayability and a lot of fun with it uh and i like the fact that there is a bunch of re-skinnings of this there's like a christmas one i did you say there's a halloween one there's halloween one coming which oh my god no she wants it yeah so we might swap this one out i don't know if they they changed anything about the gameplay but i think it's the aesthetics aesthetics yeah um i imagine it would be really hard to change to touch this design yeah don't touch it yeah so this is two player only and uh this was this came out before that trilogy this is the very first of the you know the true tiling names of uber rosenberg's entire line and uh it's simple but but very deep in strategy you know if you play against somebody who's really good at this game and they talk through their moves you'll

hear the depth in the strategy there's a lot of of like uh decision making that has to do with the buttons as a currency yeah right like if i spend uh this many buttons that i can get this and it'll only cost amount of time because you know you're you're you're managing the buttons versus time versus the shapes you're also managing the distance on the scoreboard itself because somebody if they need you know freebie buttons they can go all the way out in front and get a bunch of buttons uh and then have enough money or currency to go buy those perfect tiles that are coming up and so you can see all the tiles that are laying out there and you can kind of map out well monique cannot buy these three right here so and i'm only you know one away from her so she's only gonna net one extra button so okay fine let me just do this and put her in a position i'm not a big fan of laying out the tiles by the way so tiled circle you see that also in cottage garden with a hole and then i think there was one of uh one of the games in the trilogy that was like if you want to you can lay down the tiles for more strategies i was like no we're not doing that i think that was spring meadow i to go but we're not going to make it more strategic we're going to put them all in the lid so this does require you to lay out the tiles in a circle but uh for other people it might not bother you so would you say this is your least favorite to set up yes this or cottage garden but it is a really really good really good game this is gonna this does stand the test of time and i think it will continue to do so as you know a really solid two-player in and out kind of game right totally so that is number two patchwork which leads us to our number one the

final game in the series which you already know what it is it is a new york zoo the most recent release this one came out like we said last year and this is the one that we covered before we even started this uber rosenberg series yeah yeah actually i think it was the one that we covered before you'd even played patchwork because i played patchwork once before yeah we played patchwork once at a uh local um game oh yeah long time ago yeah i am mistaken yeah but uh but this is the one that we played pretty much before the rest of them and uh it it kind of still stuck out you know after we played all these telegrams it's still the one that stuck out from all of them i'm wondering if because it was the first one that we played other than patchwork which was a couple years before this um is that why this one stands out the most but there's no way to change that kind of cycle well for me i know why it's kind of like everything that i loved about all the other games mixed into one right it has the race element uh in order to win the game you have to be the first to completely fill up your uh your zoo essentially it has the best theme for me it's this definitely the theme is the best in this one for sure i'm not sure if i if i said it that i thought patchwork was the best theme if i said that then i was wrong this is the best theme patrick has the second best theme because it's it's cute and it's re-themeable but this one with all of the animal meeples oh it's so cute it is i know you said patchwork is your least favorite to set up this one is my least favorite to set up oh yeah you have to separate all the tiles several tiles by color uh and they're all shades of green and then you have to stack them that's

right perfectly on top of each other and so setting this one up is not the best but it's it's the only way to get it set up you know is you have to do it in this kind of manner just put the different shades of green in different bags and then you're fine otherwise it also has some good player interaction because of the way that you breed so you can kind of see where everybody's animals are on their board and then you go around the track and then you can trigger breeding when it's not convenient for other people right yes that is a very also you can see which tiles are available on that actual uh board i just think it's like a way more streamlined version of what the other games we're getting at it plays well at any player account it does yeah at two players i would probably only do for for me for a two player game i would only do the quick setup the quick set up like the quick rules that we i think we played that way yeah it just kind of gets you into the game a little faster there's less stuff that you have to cover up and you're basically not just going around the board you know a couple more rounds yeah it doesn't it doesn't extend the game out for too much longer when it's not doesn't necessarily have to be extended out that way i like the fact that there's there's that option so in the end if i had to choose one to keep it is new york zoo our number one so there you have it that is our final ranking for all of these games uh oh you wanted to know where sagan is at oh yeah where does the ghani say where did sagan he said sagani is probably four for me i think it's below indian summer but above cottage garden huh i think how about yourself interesting i would say mine would be after a cottage garden before spring oh

okay so lower a little bit lower um i do like cottage garden more than i like sagani but definitely better than than spring meadow so that's fair and last but not least what game would you bring to game night oh what game would i bring to game night i'm definitely not necessarily in new york not new york zoo it's actually not new york too uh i would bring indian summer oh yeah uh because of the fact that we said it plays best at the full complement player counts so that's game night obviously and then also because there is player interaction in that game there is that race element of i'm just trying to complete everything before you do yeah and i love the fact that you can steal other people's tiles as they're getting closer to their backpack how about yourself uh well i'm boring i would just bring new york zoo our number one yeah because of everything i already mentioned that one's my favorite through and through and so there you have it that concludes our ufa rosenberg thailand series uh we are not going to be talking about polyamorous games ever again on this channel probably until the next one comes out yeah and so next up on the horizon are the big box games which we have been waiting months and months to start although we may end up we're not we haven't decided yet but we may end up starting with uh a bonanza style game if you're familiar with that game that's right because that was another one of his really really really early popular designs not a big box but yeah we're calling it the big box series we'll see yeah so stay tuned to find out what happens well thank you so much for watching the video we hope you enjoyed it if you do have any opinions as to where you would rank all the games relative to us uh please let us know in the comments below we'd love to check it out and if you'd like to see more videos

like this in the future and want to follow along on the next set of ue rosenberg games please consider subscribing thank you bye you

Progress saved