Nemesis VS Nemesis: Retaliation VS Nemesis: Lockdown - BUY THIS, NOT THAT
Transcript
Three Nemesis games, same designer, same price tier, one question everybody asks, which do you buy, which do you skip?
Let's settle it.
Okay, quick baseline for anyone new to this franchise. We've been playing all three of these extensively, and they're all Kopinski designs. All Awaken Realms, all semi-cooperative survival horror with hidden objectives, one to five players across the board. The original dropped in 2018, raised over 3 million pounds on Kickstarter, which is around 3.8 million dollars, and most of us got copies around 2020.
Lockdown came next in 2022 after a 2020 crowdfunding campaign that pulled in over 5 million pounds, roughly 6 and 1/2 million US dollars. And Retaliation just started landing with backers this year in 2025.
And the box says 90 minutes to 3 hours on the original, 120 to 180 minutes on Retaliation. Our sessions almost never hit those low ends. At four or five players, we're looking at three, four, sometimes five-hour games. That's the reality of this engine. Which matters because the commitment is real. All three have player elimination, too, which we'll get into. The big through-line is that Kopinski is iterating on the same recipe across all three. We're not comparing a worker placement to a deck builder. We're comparing three variations of one core idea. That's what makes picking between them interesting. So, let's get into what actually happens at the table because this is where the three games diverge in important ways.
The core engine is the same across all three. Every round has a player phase and an event phase. In the player phase, you draw cards up to a hand of five. Then, on your turn, you can take two actions, or one action and pass, or just pass. Once you pass, you're done for the round. Actions are paid for by discarding cards, anywhere from zero to three cards, depending on what you're doing. And movement is the decision that defines this whole system. You can move fast for one card, but you have to make a noise roll afterwards. Or, you can move careful for two cards. Instead of rolling for noise, you deliberately place a noise marker in a corridor of your choice. Noise rolls summon intruders. So, every single time you move, you're balancing economy versus safety. I remember one session in the original, I had my scientist in a dark corridor with two cards left. I moved fast because I was out of options, rolled noise, and an adult came screaming into my room. That's the engine in one sentence. And the objectives in the original are what make it mean something. You start with two secret objectives. The moment the first alien is discovered on the board, you have to pick one, and you're locked in for the rest of the game. Some objectives align with everybody, escape the ship, fix the engines. Some are nasty, be the only survivor, smuggle an alien egg back to Earth. You don't know what anyone else picked. Which is why the first alien discovery in the original is this incredible narrative moment. The whole table tenses.
Everybody's picking sides in secret. Then, Lockdown changes the setting completely. You're in an underground Mars base, a BSL-4 facility, still waking up, still disoriented, but now with power management layered on. The Mars base doesn't have enough electricity for the whole facility. You're actively redistributing power, and a lit section removes noise tokens from its corridors when no character is in a connected room. Which is huge because in the original, noise just accumulates. You cannot clean it up. By turn 10 in my four-player games, the corridors were drowning in noise tokens, every event phase spawning monsters everywhere. Lockdown gives you agency over that. You can route power, lit areas calm down, stairs are always dark and scary, elevators need power to work.
It just feels more surgical. Then, Retaliation flips the whole thing. Same engine, same two actions per turn, same event phase, but now the objective system works differently. You get two objectives, one mission objective that's broadly shared with the group, and one private objective that might pull you in a different direction, but you choose when to lock into your private path rather than being forced to commit the moment the first alien appears. And when you do lock in, you get a burst of bonus actions that turn as a reward for committing. Which completely changes the feel. In the original, you're forced into a commitment before you know what the game looks like. In Retaliation, you're picking your moment. I played the heavy gun operator in my first session, waited until turn eight to lock in because I wanted to see the map develop.
Got my bonus actions, used them to clear a room of Neoflesh. It felt strategic, not panicked. See, that flexibility is exactly why Retaliation feels like a different animal. Same bones, different soul. On complexity, all three sit at the high end. Retaliation is sitting around 3.71 on the weight scale, in that medium-heavy to heavy range, and the other two feel comparable at the table. First plays of any of them take a while. The original took our group about three rounds before people stopped asking what their cards did. Ah, the rulebooks are a franchise-wide problem. All three are dense, awkwardly cross-referenced, small fonts. If your group struggles with dense rulebooks, any of these is a rough teach. Lockdown is the heaviest teach because you're adding the power system and the CSS contingency tokens on top of the original framework. Retaliation is easier to teach than Lockdown in our sessions because the objective flexibility removes the mental overhead of that forced binary commitment. But, none of these are light evening. Player counts, all three support one to five, and all three play solo. We've played the original at two, three, four, and five. Lockdown, we've done it three and four. Retaliation, we've played it multiple counts. I want to be honest that we haven't done a full five-player Retaliation session ourselves yet, so I'll stay away from claims on that specific count. And the scaling story is the same across all three in one important way. More players means exponentially more game. Our three-player games of the original are tight, manageable, the noise is
controllable. Our four-player games push four and a half hours regularly. Five players in the original, I'll just say is a commitment. Not bad, just long. Lockdown at four players is actually more manageable than the original at four in our experience. And I think it's specifically because of the power and light system. You can actively clean up noise in connected corridors when no character is in a lit section. That keeps the late game from getting completely overwhelmed. In the original, you hit turn 12, every roll is spawning intruders. The whole table is just reacting. Lockdown lets you build little safe zones. Retaliation at the counts we've played scales differently because of how the Neoflesh cult behaves under pressure. Once someone goes down, the pressure on the survivors ramps up hard in our experience. It creates this death spiral feel that the earlier games don't have quite as sharply. And speaking of player elimination, this matters for all three. You can die, and you can die early. In a four-hour game, watching from the sideline for two hours is a real thing. All three games do this.
It's intentional. But, if you have a friend who hates being eliminated, none of these are their game. Solo mode works for all three, and solo is where a lot of people get their reps in because it's hard to schedule a five-person, four-hour evening. Okay, the depth question because there's a difference between a game that has lots of rules and a game that has strategic depth. And this franchise has real depth, but it's different in each entry. In the original, depth comes from information management and risk mitigation. You don't know where rooms are. You don't know what the intruder bag looks like. The bag starts with larvae and creepers, and as the game goes on, larvae get replaced with adults, creepers get replaced with breeders during intruder bag development and when bag tokens are drawn in encounters. So, the bag is getting meaner over time. Every choice to move fast or investigate a room is you weighing the current bag state against your deck state, against what's happening across the board. And larvae are the sneaky threat. When a larva attacks you, it places itself on your character board. You need surgical removal to get rid of it, and simultaneously, a contamination card goes into your discard pile, which will cycle back into your deck and clog your hand. Some contamination cards are infected. You cannot tell which ones without passing the card through a physical scanner sleeve. That scanner sleeve is such a clever piece of design.
It turns a passive deck penalty into an actual moment of table tension.
Lockdown keeps all of that and adds the CSS tokens on the time track as a contingency procedure. These are hidden tokens representing the corporation's backup plans. You don't know what they say. You can spend actions to investigate, and even if you complete your personal objective and think you've won, the revealed contingency at game end might flip the outcome. So, there are three sources of tension now, the aliens, your tablemates, and the corporation. And mechanically distinct from those tokens, Lockdown also has the CSS escape hatch system as one of the exit routes. Both carry the CSS label, but they're two separate mechanics. The publisher lists the CSS exit routes in the contingency procedure as distinct things. That tripped up our group the first time. Worth flagging.
Retaliation depth is different because of the objective flexibility, creates a timing puzzle the earlier games don't have. You're asking yourself every turn, do I lock in now for the bonus actions? Do I wait? Is my health going to hold? In my last session, I locked in on turn six because I had two Neoflesh in my room, and I knew I needed the action burst to survive. That timing call is the strategic heart of Retaliation. So, in the original, depth is information under pressure. In Lockdown, it's layered paranoia. In Retaliation, it's committing and timing. All three have it, just different flavors. Player interaction is where the hidden objectives do their work. In the original, the moment the first intruder appears and everybody picks their objective card, the whole social dynamic shifts. Somebody might be trying to kill you, and you don't know it. We had a game where my pilot was convinced the captain was a traitor, spent two turns blocking doors. Turned out the captain was just on the co-op objective the whole time. And then lockdown amplifies it because now the corporation might also betray you. I had a session where I completed my objective, thought I'd won, the contingency revealed demanded my character's execution, and the table lost because the escape vote went sideways. That moment stuck with me for weeks. Retaliation interaction feels different because you're all marines.
You're on the same side by default, but the private objective still pull at the group dynamic, especially with the timing of when you lock in. If I lock in early and my private objective needs the rover working, suddenly my priorities diverge from the rest of the squad.
Playtime, ignore the box. The original lists 90 to 180 minutes. Our four-player games run four to five hours. Lockdown at four players is comparable, sometimes longer because of the extra systems. Retaliation has a slightly tighter back half in our play the procedural map and escalating enemies force the pace. Pacing within a session is good in all three. Turns move reasonably fast once people know their decks. There's some downtime on big multiplayer turns, but the event phase snaps everybody back to attention because it affects everyone. Theme, the original evokes classic sci-fi horror, alien style. Your crew, you're scared, you're hunted. Lockdown is grimmer, more paranoid, BSL-4 facility vibes, survivors stripped of agency. Retaliation is the aliens shift. You're not prey, you're marines, armed, prepared, going in on purpose.
Which theme lands depends entirely on what drew you to this franchise. The mechanics reinforce theme really well in all three. In retaliation, you're actually armed and capable from turn one. In the original, you're grabbing whatever weapons you find in rooms and hoping they work. That shift in capability isn't narrative, it's mechanical. Production-wise, all three are premium boxes. The original set the standard. Large, detailed miniatures, thick room tiles, strong iconography, and that scanner sleeve for infected cards I keep coming back to, which is one of the best tactile moments in modern board game design.
Lockdown matches the original in quality. The base box uses cardboard tokens for doors and rover and main gate, which is fine, but the stretch goals box replace those with detailed miniatures. If you're going for it, the stretch goals upgrades genuinely improve the table presence. Retaliation is awaken realms at full scope. More than 50 plastic miniatures, over 350 cards, five double-layered character boards, more than 60 cardboard tiles, and over 200 other components, including dice, cardboard tokens, and acrylic cubes. The double-layered character boards in particular are quality upgrade.
Your character state is physically integrated into the board. You're not shuffling tokens around hoping they stay put. Setup though, all three are long setups. You're laying out the map, seating the intruder bag, dealing character decks, placing tokens. Our original setup at first play was close to 40 minutes. We've got it down to 20 now. Lockdown is slightly longer because of the power cables and the multi-level layout. Retaliation setup is pretty comparable in our plays. Storage is a problem for all three. These are big boxes. If you're sleeving cards and using inserts, they get bigger. We use foam inserts for all three, and even with that, our Nemesis shelf is taking up real estate.
On price, these are premium crowdfunded games. If you back a crowdfunding, you generally get better value with stretch goals. Retail prices for all three are firmly in the hundred-plus tier. For our play frequency, cost per play has worked out fine. For people who play once and shelve it, harder sell. Fun factor, this is where the three games split their audiences cleanly. The original hits hardest for people who love being outmatched. If you loved the first Alien movie, if you want survival horror at the table, if you're okay with a game that can break you through sheer variance, the original is where you go. Our friends who run horror RPGs love it. The paranoia around objectives, the bag building meaner every turn, the noise spiraling out of control, all of that lands if that's what you want.
Lockdown lands hardest for friends who love simulation and systems. The power management, the multi-level facility, the CSS contingency procedure, these feel like layers of a simulation. Our friend who's a project manager in real life loves lockdown specifically because it rewards the kind of contingency planning she does professionally. Which is a sentence that says a lot about who lockdown is for. It does. It absolutely does. And retaliation lands for our friends who want more agency and less helplessness.
The marines premise, the better weapons, the procedural map, the objective flexibility, these all combine into a game that still has genuine tension, but gives you actual tools to fight back. We played retaliation with our Aliens the Movie fans, and it was exactly right. They wanted the shooter marines experience. They wanted to be in the fight. The earlier games would have frustrated them because helplessness wasn't what they came for. The common thread for all three is that you need a group that can commit to three to five-hour sessions, can handle complex rules, and is okay with player elimination. If any of those are hard no's for your group, none of these three work. And if you hate randomness that can swing a game, the original is the most variance driven of the three. Lockdown is in the middle, and retaliation, in our experience, has the most controllable variance because of the escalating enemy system tying difficulty to player state rather than pure bag luck. Okay, the verdict, and we disagree on this, which I think is actually useful. We do. I'll go first.
If you're new to this franchise in 2025 and you can find retaliation at retail, buy retaliation. It's the most modern expression of the engine. The flexible objectives are better than the forced commitment, the double-layered boards, the item track, the procedural map. These are all genuine quality of life improvements. The marines premise is more immediately engaging for people who aren't already sold on survival horror. I'm going to push back. If you've never played any Nemesis, I still think the original is the purer version of the core idea. Yes, it's the harshest. Yes, the noise gets out of control. Yes, the bag variance can kill you, but that's the game. Retaliation is a better game by a lot of measures, but it's less distinctive. The original is unmistakably itself. Where we agree is on lockdown. If you already own the original and want your second Nemesis, lockdown is the answer. The power system, the CSS contingency tokens, the multi-level facility, these are meaningful additions, not a reskin. It's the most thematically complete game of the three.
Agreed. Lockdown is the best second purchase. Where I'd caution people is on buying all three. These games share significant DNA. One copy is a substantial investment. Three copies is overlapping experiences. Most groups who love this franchise own two at most, and that's enough. The deal-breakers. If player elimination is a hard no, skip all three. If you hate dense rulebooks, skip all three. If you don't have a group that will play three to five-hour games regularly, skip all three. None of them work as a once-a-year pullout.
If you want the purest expression of survival horror at the table, original Nemesis. If you want the most thematically rich and mechanically layered version, lockdown. If you want the most modern engine with the most player agency and the Aliens instead of Alien feel, retaliation. If budget only allows one purchase in 2025, retaliation is the strongest recommendation. Only if retail availability holds. My favorite moment across all three, and this is a weird one, was in a lockdown session. I investigated a CSS token on the time track on turn nine, spent two actions to look at it. The token said my character had to be executed on escape. I spent the next four turns pretending I still wanted to escape through the main hatch while quietly routing myself toward the rover. Nobody at the table knew why. I won, just me on the rover. And I was at that table. I was furious for days. That's why this franchise works.
Real decisions, real consequences, real moments. Three games, pick yours. Let us know which one ended up on your shelf. See you next time.