Board Game Design: Hall of Fame
Transcript
in October I reviewed the delightful Turtle Splash from gigamic a disc flicking memory game with a gorgeous jungle setting and in September I took a look at Caesar's Empire an ultra streamlined Network building game with Fantastical tactical choices on every turn in July I took a look at Trek 12 a roll and write game with unlockable content like a legacy light dice roller these are all really good games but every now and then a product comes along which is truly great a game which will stand the test of time I don't always spot it immediately indeed the industry doesn't always spot it immediately some of these games are slow Burns but others come out the gate like a champ everdel was one of these games when it arrived in 2018 it immediately attracted a huge amount of attention it took a little time to determine whether this popularity would Wane but it never did the appeal of the game only grew with expansions culminating in a massive Kickstarter campaign for the gigantic complete collection which finally delivered in 2022 I did a deep dive into the game everdel a couple of weeks ago and in that video I said that everdel was my first game in my game design Hall of Fame and in this video I want to properly launch that Hall of Fame and let you know what it's all about I'm Adam Porter I design games and I review them on this channel with a focus on product design if you like what I do
please subscribe comment and like the video I've been reviewing games on this channel for nine years it started out with generic reviews the classic format intro rules explanation final thoughts over recent years I've taken a different tack focusing Less on the rules of a game and more on the design choices which make it engaging and the product design principles which make it commercially viable this feels like it's working out great for new games I find it exciting considering their place in the market and predicting the likelihood of generating sales it's like playing being a publisher assessing and analyzing new products without having to stump up any investment or take any responsibility but there are some games which have already proven their metal and I want to show these games some love there's so much to learn as a designer by looking at k case studies like this what are the Evergreen titles and how did they achieve that status new entries into the game design Hall of Fame will each get a deep dive similar to the recent everdale video but there are two games I want to retroactively admit primarily because I've already done a deep dive and I don't feel the need to revisit them when there are so many other great games to cover card drafting game sushigo was self-published in 2013 by then unknown designer Phil Walker Harding Sushi goes round on the conveyor belt right round and round in circles while diners pick the dishes they want to consume how about a little Wasabi to enhance your
nigiri and don't forget the puddings Sushi go sushi roll and Sushi go party all simulate the fun and excitement of watching raw fish rotate in card or dice game format I guess that's the hook and if you want to see more about the sushi go family of games click on the link above in the worker placement game viticulture you play as the owner of a growing Vineyard in Tuscany I'm often torn when trying to identify the hook of a game is it the theme the narrative the setting that draws players in or is it the mechanisms at play the design choices the unique engine which drives the game with viticulture I could make a strong case for either of those but there's a third hook and that's the game maker themselves more than any other publisher stonemire games has nurtured a community since their earliest products and published in 2012 viticulture is their earliest product a little bit of stonemire History it's a game with some clout if you haven't played it you've probably heard of it an early Kickstarter success story co-designed by a then nascent inventor Jamie stegemeyer home with expansions Community input and revised editions this is a game with a lot of heart in it history Word of Mouth famous designer critical Acclaim it might not be the only hook but it is a hook if you want to hear a bit more about viticulture follow the link I considered including bunny Kingdom and libertalia I've done detailed analysis on those titles too but they still need to prove themselves a little so that brings me to my three criteria for entry
into the game design Hall of Fame number one this is very much my haul I have enormous respect for gloomhaven and Arkham Horror Twilight Imperium and Star Wars Legion but I won't be doing a deep dive on any of them because I have no interest in playing them I don't have a team of reviewers it's just me so this is very much the Adam in Wales Hall of Fame you know what to expect number two I have no access to sales data aside from occasional media reports of rare multi-million selling games but we can deduce that a game has achieved High sales if it receives multiple expansions and even more so if it remains in print for several years after release the sad truth is that most games only get a single print run and then excess stock sits on store shelves for a few months or years before slipping out of Gamers consciousness number three a game might make it into the hall because it was influential even if it's out of print I'm not sure how often I'll invoke this particular rule most truly influential games become perennial bestsellers but the rules there if I need it sushigo is a proven seller a massive hit and a great game to boot it has two sequels in sushi go party and sushi roll and I don't see it disappearing anytime soon this is a modern classic viticulture has sold incredibly well stegmaier is very open with his sales figures it's still held in high regard a decade after its initial release and it received its most recent expansion in
2022 everdale is a newer title it only released in 2018 but it's already received five big box expansions multiple very successful Kickstarter campaigns and I think it's one of the most influential games in the hobby right now expect the recent glut of cute nature-themed games to continue over the coming years libertalia doesn't quite make the cut I love it and there seems to be a core fan base who feel as I do and when the game was released in 2012 it garnered much praise but then it fell out of print for the best part of a decade I get the impression that sales for stonemeyer's remake were disappointing and we haven't yet seen an expansion so I'm going to watch and wait on this one bunny kingdom is one of my favorite games of all time released in 2017 it's still in print and it appears to be one of yellow's leading products but it hasn't been rewarded with the wealth of expansions that you'd expect if the game had been a massive hit the singular expansion buddy Kingdom in the sky is a fun addition to the game but it's been pretty much radio silence since then again I'm keeping an eye on it and if bunny Kingdom remains in print for a few more years I'll be delighted to give it a spot so hopefully this all explains my rationale I don't know how often I'll have the time to do these deep Dives but hopefully we'll see a new entry every few weeks joining the esteemed everdel viticulture and Sushi go in the game design Hall of Fame and the goal of course is that we can learn from these products and apply similar design principles to our own projects to
maximize our chances of producing something amazing what games would you like to see me cover and do you agree with my choices so far let me know in the comments and until next time all the best