The Broken Meeple Show - Episode 54 - Sequels vs Originals
Transcript
you're listening to the broken meeple show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's Luke Hector best known for the broken Maple YouTube channel and I'm an everyday gamer just like you and I'll be talking about reviews top tens and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as I have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game morning everyone 24th of July 2022 with hopefully better sounding audio than the previous video I recorded on here yes it's been a bit highs and lows in terms of the channel but we'll get on to that in a minute but yeah things generally good the weather is thankfully cooled down a little bit I mean I'm only sweating slightly in my house but we did go through pretty much the worst Heat Wave the UK has ever had I think we were hotter than 98 of the world at that point and it was just horrific I just could not stand it even today the sun is out it's beaming and it's just heating up this house like crazy but not to the extent of last week so it has got more to a manageable level where I'm not quite you know dying of heat exhaustion every five minutes although it's still not great I still have to have continuous you know pint glasses of ice-filled squash and that and iced coffees when I go out you know I I have to stay cool I cannot be hot if it's not a wet heat you know I I like a sauna
steam bath give me a nice hot shower don't give me death valley don't give me you know the hot tropical climates and stuff it just doesn't sit well with me I need air conditioning I need cold I am a cold I don't want to say cold-blooded person but yeah I am certainly I I feel like I need the chills I missed a Freeze from Batman how about that but yeah I mean stuff for the channel has been pretty good for the most part uh the recent couple of videos I've done have been top tens it's been good to get those out and the subscriber count has climbed up pretty significantly actually over the last couple of weeks you know since I put those out so I put out the top 10 games no one will play with me which was a patreon um most requested video to do and clearly everybody else thought so because it is doing incredibly well thank you very much for that and then I also just recently put out the next highest devoted one which was the top 10 filler games where I talked about less than 30 30-minute games with the teach included which is certainly getting some popularity at the moment not quite to the levels of the previous one but still some good popularity and it just goes to show that top tens just Trump reviews so much on the channel I really must do more top tens and reviews frankly but I do have some reviews to do eventually I've got well it's kind of a mixed bag I I have to do the next set of top 10 soon which will be a series on two player games so light medium and heavy two-player games and I thought I needed to fill in the blanks with a few two-player games because there were some recent additions to the market that were
fairly popular and I really needed to try them out so I've asked kiander to give me a bunch of them and thankfully they did well all but one I bought one of them myself but the others I've requested so those will be reviews that I will do for Sobek the new reprint uh the Bruno game the uh Badlands or no sorry rad lands the two-player sort of a kind of Borderlands uh you know steam punk he's not steampunk uh post-apocalyptic card game that looks pretty cool and of course and also Great Planes so I will be doing micro Express reviews for those and I do mean micro like I really gotta get the term Express review down to a t so yeah they will be quick reviews of those games once I've played them which I should be doing today actually because I intend to be giving them the beans with a friend of mine later but yeah the those ones are on the horizon for review purposes but then I will be doing those top tens but there's another thing I want to mention as well oh yeah and everyone else about the top 100 that will come eventually I just think it's going to be a bit later this year so I probably won't be able to get to the top 100 until some point late August maybe I'll have it running through September we'll see I gotta get it done before s and that's the thing and that reminds me I need to start emailing some Publishers about review copies and uh meetings but yeah it's too much to do too much to do so on top of that though there is a new series that I am kind of piloting at the moment this is being requested by viewers and I figured you know what it's about time I did and this is effectively a pilot
episode talk about kickstarters so other players other people in the industry talk about kickstarters all the time and you know my thoughts when it comes to artificial Kickstarter hype I'm not a fan of how certain channels generate that so I'm more interested in when small creators do previews of certain things because I feel they haven't got as much to lose you know so they come out with some more like interesting opinions I want to hear but the I thought I'd jump in on this as well and the what I've done is I've done a pre-recorded setup like this where I browse through some Chosen kickstarters and give my thoughts and I'm good and bad so it's a bit like the crowd surfing that dice Tara do just without other people and obviously not being live the problem is I did the pilot episode yesterday and the audio is uh not up to the standard I would like it's legible I mean you can hear what I'm saying but it's muffled the problem is is that for whatever reason stream yard decided to to reset my mic settings which meant that cancellation got put on if you are aware of anything to do with audio knowledge Echo cancellation is basically what Jar Jar Binks is to Star Wars you know everything about it just ruins what you're doing and it it it basically really spoils the audio but it was a long episode and there were some good kickstarters this month I wanted to talk about like moonrakers and burn cycle and some of the print and plays and stuff I really wanted to talk about them so I have a choice between releasing it as a pilot episode and just saying look sorry
the audio was a bit rubbish but you know I don't want to re-record it or just scrapping the whole episode and waiting until August because I was going to do it as a monthly thing and just say you know what take talk to experience well I did a vote on this so I asked people from the community on this one because I thought I needed more than just uh patreons on this one I needed the whole community on YouTube to give me an indication of this and I'll just get the here we go let's show you the Paw all so it was basically to say right do I not fret over it release it anyway and emphasize the issue and just double check in future or scrap it wait a month and do a first episode then don't stress myself well 70 71 of everybody who voted 200 votes said release it as it is so yeah there are some people who said you know wait a bit and I do get it I was tempted to wait on the basis that it's not the same quality I would like but then I put the effort into that episode I want to get it out you can still hear what I'm saying it's just not going to be the best and it's a pilot episode at the end of the day I need to obviously gauge if people like what I'm doing in the first place there's no point putting out the audio may not be great but I need people to sort of watch it and go is this something you want to watch in future because if it's not worth watching then why would I bother making it again it wouldn't make a difference so I will get on with that I need to probably do that today because uh one of the projects I talked about ends in a couple of days so I kind of need to get out rather sharpish but it shouldn't
take me too long to edit it I just need to put some backing music to the track to make it a bit more nicer to hear and you know release it it's about 45 minutes I talk about I think eight or so kickstarters I talk about a fair few maybe more than I'm not sure but I took a fair few kickstarters of varying types and you know hopefully it's something you like but uh let me know your thoughts on the format and the style don't worry too much about the Audio I am aware it's not going to be fantastic but uh you know at least hopefully this audio sounds a lot better because I have turned Echo cancellation off and I will certainly be more mindful of that in the future all right let's go on the episodes there's quite a lot to do on here so we're first going to talk about I'm gonna yeah let's let's go into games I played I'm not going to talk in too much detail about each about most of these except for one I suspect but I want to there's certainly one on here that I'm sure everybody wants me to give my thoughts on so uh basically I went to well let's get on to that one later let's do the one that I did literally I think the other night and that is acquire oh yes sir the old this game's going back a bit isn't it yes I finally have actually played this so I I thought like I got a ticket off my bucket list at some point but it got to yeah when I was ever going to play who was gonna have it and so I've I've got that done and a friend of mine has it and we played this version so this is the Avalon Hill version with the
cityscape and the scaffolding and stuff like that I noticed that the cover has got a textured finish on it who does that especially back in the 1960s or whatever this game was first made but a choir is essentially a stock it was not necessarily a stock it's more a it's a money making game and it does involve stocks and shares but what you're essentially doing is you're drawing these tiles out of a bag in order to place them on this board and build up like allotments like plots of land you then start up these hotel chains with these buildings and as they get bigger they go up in value but then as soon as they merge with another hotel chain the smallest gets merged into them which means you can sell the shares off or exchange number shares in a new one it's that kind of thing in fact it gave me a very big Tigris and Euphrates Vibe actually because that's kind of the similar deal with the wars in that but this one was fine I was fine to Chuck it off my bucket list I had to accept that this was like a 1960s game so it wasn't exactly going to be the most robust mechanics in the world I can see how people would take this way too seriously and we did not I mean we played with open information for shares and things like that and money so we weren't taking it too seriously I like it fine and there's some tense decisions and there's certainly like a bit of oh you know should I merge it should I not what's the best move to do some decisions are quite you know obvious and some aren't what I wasn't a fan of were these tiles that you had to draw out of a bag because it's critical as to which tiles you have control over whether they're
blockers or mergers that you want or to throw away tiles and you draw them randomly so and you have no way to mitigate it so there's no discard and redraw or anything like that so you may just draw rubbish tiles for the whole game and my friend Matt played this with me and he ended up in a situation at the start where you just got into a point where anything that he did basically just facilitated other players and he had no way to really pull it back so that kind of made the game suck a bit for him yeah it's it's fine it's okay but I'm not gonna seek someone out it's you know I'm not gonna like acquire it yeah pun intended for my collection nor am I gonna seek out to play again it's a product of its time it's definitely one of the better games of its time I'll give it that I mean when you're talking things like you know Monopoly and everyone else used to play back in those days this is something a little bit different and something a bit more thinky but uh yeah this is it's not a game I'm not desperate to sort of sing the Praises over it's it's what it is depending which version you get it can have the most like a horrible components ever oh God that looks horrible whatever that is on screen and I'm monstrosity but yeah it's it's there it exists whatever you know you've ticked it off your bucket list you can now move on to other games you know more modern games like perhaps uh ride the rails oh dear um basically manicon I went to manicon last weekend I forgot to mention that and it was a good laugh actually I'd not been there for four to five years and it was good fun they changed the venue slightly but there was very nice food on
offer even if it got a bit pricey eating every day there was a curry night which I didn't go on because I wanted to play games but you know there was that on offer there was a Britain buy I was able to sell uh perseverance which was handy because I got that off my shelf and I've recently sold dwellings of Elder Vale as well I never I wonder what happened with those coal videos I used to do the thing is I did those uh coal videos for a while and they were fun but it was difficult to keep up with them because my my deals with culling games is very sporadic it doesn't happen on a regular basis it's like one big call on that so maybe I should do one for that but the thing is this is too much to do and they do get some views but at the end of the day I need to concentrate on what the channel does well which is you know honest reviews with top tens and of course the top 100s coming up so I can't overflow myself too much here take a drink all right but yeah I played some games at vanicon including ride the rails and some of you are probably thinking Luke what on Earth were you smoking why would you play this game it is a train game you hate train games true and true but this one I wanted to give a try because there's a little difference with this one ride the rails isn't that much of a stock market investment train game like 18xx or anything this one cares more about root connections and passenger movement granted there are stocks and chairs involved but basically all that is is that you draw a train you choose a train of a color track that's been unlocked at the start of the game and you simply just that can that is considered a share so you're reducing
the amount of tracks that they can lay but you're also getting shares in it and you maybe have like up to a maximum of six shares in any particular thing so it's it's not exactly a you know major stock game it is more about connecting up cities and moving a passenger as far as you can across various routes now I requested to play this when it was on the table because otherwise Keen to play it and I thought you know what I'll try anything once it was supposed to be a short game let's see how it goes right well sure it's an absolute waste of space I mean it was easier 90 minute game and 90 minutes I think is a bit too long for the fact that this only has about seven rounds in it but it's fairly simplistic rules I mean you basically just choose one of the trains to get a share and then you lay out a certain amount of tracks based on player account we had five of us so I think it was four tracks a turn you connect up Roots you can only share so much and then you move a passenger from one end to another and score based on how many cities it went through and how many track and what tracks it went through that's kind of it really um you know it's even though tools art and everyone keeps saying oh it's so gorgeous look at it's like really it's like basic green hexes and a brown background I mean the graphic design is nice and clear but for crying out loud it's a train game it really doesn't require that much artwork in your graphic design I feel like Eno tool was kind of wasted on here although not going to complain about the Capstone games uh uh well he was a eagle Griffin that did this one I can't remember actually let me have a look uh who made this was it I thought it was Capstone games yeah he had his own games even though it looks like something that
eagle Griffin would put out but I mean yeah so yeah I'm not going to complain about the component quality it is very nice the rules for how to score each round though are a complete mess even the simplified version which the people teaching us were using was a bit hard to understand for the first couple of rounds but this is definitely a game that you will not know how to do well from the get-go I mean it is not obvious what particular well I say it's not obvious at the start you have no idea what to do in order to do well you're just doing it and hoping for the best especially if you're new to the game but later on you start getting into a situation where it's blatantly obvious which movie you should do it's like well I better do this because that's the longest track that I can move and and it gets me the most points and that's fine I don't like the idea that well the catch-up mechanism of if you're in front points wise you go last and stuff like that I like that in some games but here it felt very punishing to be literally one point ahead of another player by complete fluke and you know suddenly that means I go last before them and they get a lot of control they just it seems to hurt a bit two other players in this game also started off fairly badly on their own route and they had no chance of winning for the entire game so it literally pseudo knocked them out from round one I felt I called it from round one that those two would not stand a chance and I was right you know this suffers from another problem that train games have these are two punishing sometimes now it is simple and I didn't hate it you know there are other train games I would probably hate more because this one is more about building Roots which is the part of train games I don't
mind too much but yeah I mean we we didn't even play this map we played the Australia map I think it was an expansion and it had these weird like mountains that you couldn't build and then it had two Side Tracks that you could build which took one track a turn to build and yet the reward seemed like not a waste of time especially when other people could simply jump on and finish it for you they it was really weird I mean those two side rules I think were just complete waste of space on the Australia map but yeah this is whatever it's it's below average for me I'm not a fan I didn't overly enjoy it it's I just felt like I was going through the motions in the late game like me and the person who was in the lead there were two of us in the lead and it basically got to the point where we were just copying each other because to diverge off with event one of us would lose I didn't like doing that so I diverged off at the end just to try something different and it cost me the game but I just I was just so bored I wanted the game to finish I didn't really care at that point so yeah not for me I I still don't get train games to this instead I would would rather play something else for 90 minutes than this but oh well at least I tried it at least I tried it all right so let's get on to a game that is pretty good for what it is and that's Acropolis this is from um was it guy gigamac gigamic games I'm not sure how you pronounce it but then uh house check games have uh brought this over actually let me see if I can pronounce that properly because that was not good uh Giga mic games well g-i-g-a-m-i-c how else would you pronounce it uh but then hasht board games is uh the people that
I think I brought it over I think it was at the UK games Expo I didn't get to go to the Expo so this is the first time I've even seen it let alone tried it and I thought okay boring cover boring title I mean it's not bad artwork but Acropolis and two pillars and a backdrop of a typical City in Greece Woody I mean come on like we haven't seen this before if I saw this on the Shelf I would gloss right past it and just think this was a Indie publisher game because I would just see the title and go oh look generic title we've seen before Oh look generic City thing in Greece we've seen before why do I care but then I got stuck into the game and we needed a filler for 30 odd minutes and I thought all right well I'll give this a try this is a tail laying game where you have a starting hex uh starting four hex board and a little bit of stone and it it takes some mechanics from other games but basically you're building up these you're collecting these freeze what's the best way to do it uh their free tiles put together in a in a cluster so you're building up these tile clusters and you're adding them to your city and they've got different colors on them for different districts so red yellow blue green each one scores in a different way and there's variance for this what you do is that you basically choose a tile from a row which takes the exact same mechanic from small world banished you for the realm uh micropolis you know where you have a row of cards and you have to pay stone in order to go further up the row you know that is essentially what we've seen in loads of other games so easy to explain but what you do is that you then add it to your
city and the idea is is that based on how they score like yellows want to be isolated and greens are just flat out points blue want to be in a big cluster red one to be on the edge of the map you know you will score points in various ways but each of their instances only scores a point to multiply that you have to get these Plaza tiles with the Stars on them and there's like two stars on all of them except the green can potentially have free and you have to basically get as many of those as you can so there's a balance between having too much of a particular color are but not enough stars to actually make a decent profit out of it it's an interesting kind of like concept and I like the fact that there's you know some good reference cards to tell you how many of the things there are so you can count between the players it tells you how they all score there's a variant there and the idea is is that if you want to build on top of the ground level you can build a second level and building on top of these gray tile spaces gets you more Stone which is the currency to buy more cards and of course getting Stone off cards that people have paid gets you the stone as well so yeah it was a interesting little filler I mean it doesn't do anything new there is no unique thing in this game really it borrows from a lot of other games it's stuff you've seen before which it does mean It suffers a little bit in that regard but it is very smooth it is very quick I mean yes it's a thinky filler but you will get this game done in about 45 minutes absolute tops 30 minutes if you haven't got to teach the game I think it I don't think you'll get it done in 30 minutes with a teach I think this is too much to think about particularly with four players two players easily but four no but yeah you
are talking about 45 minutes max this is a pretty short game and it was decent I mean the production quality is good these tiles are very thick of course the theme is non-existent I mean you could not care less what most of these are and you'd have to look closely at these pictures to even notice what type of building it is so you're not going to get any points for that but yeah it's it's fine I mean it didn't blow my mind but I thought for what it was I think 20 to 30 minutes is uh kind of a little Miss nowhere I would put that down as 30 to 45 personally but still I thought this was solid enough I know I thought it was well produced and it's certainly surprised me when I looked at the cover and title and thought this is going to suck this is going to be boring but it's short what let's get over with and then found out it's actually pretty sweet you know it's actually not bad at all so you know first impressions would be a seven out of ten uh I wouldn't say no to trying this out a bit more maybe doing a review but I don't know we'll see I mean there's so many games to look at but yeah I mean I'd say give this one a try it's not a high weight it's two to four players not a long game well produced pretty cheap less than 20 pound I think it is actually so that's something to say I know kiander has got a copy of it for less than 20 quid so yeah give it a shot it actually might be pretty sweet for you okay more drink more drink more drink okay right the last one okay endless winter endless winter this one is a Kickstarter that is fulfilling in the next couple of months I have backed this in all four and it gives me a kind of Garfield game games Vibe the way it plays but it's
definitely just the artwork by the Miko which is what essentially makes it look like those it's fun fantasia games and I got to play this three times at manicon once we'd pull with the base set and a tiny expansion thrown in uh second time we'd pull uh to have the rivers and rafts expansion thrown in and then the third time when Paul was flagging a little bit from the Heat and the tiredness and I said you know what I will teach this game to two other players so let me take over from you so I thought oh well I played it and I played a free player game with base set only I think well I know I mixed and matched characters in this time I didn't use the exact lot I just mix and match animals and characters but this is a pretty entertaining game although would it have the staying power I don't know the idea with this is that you basically have quite a lot of the table space required but you are managing a tribe of villagers and you're basically surviving in the wild you're out to get victory points but how you get victory points comes from a lot of different methods so uh this is this is somebody using the TDS thing is there something better than TTS that I could use well let's go with this so what you have is that you have a map where you put camps down and do area control for different terrain hexes and bonuses you have your player board where you can put stones for objective scoring you have camps and Villages and the megalith stones or whatever they are you know whatever they call them that you take off your board and reveal bonuses underneath that's been done a lot of times but you can collect you have a
deck of cards or villagers with different abilities and you also collect cards for different animals which can be animals that you keep which you collect for set collection bonuses at the end of the game or during with an expansion or you can kill them off uh like tap them as this one does here get food and various other bonuses but then you also so might have some something else that benefits you from using particular animals you keep them in front of you it's a lot of stuff going on and I do like firstly the production quality of this is really really good I mean yeah there are some basic elements in places but all in all it's a look around the table it's got the cool sort of white and blue aesthetic and the artwork by the Miko is gorgeous on these cards I mean they really look fantastic not gonna lie but mechanically I thought this was pretty sweet as well so there are some other bits like idols and stuff that I'm not mentioning because I can't mention everything in this game you know you've got these but mainly it's all about these cards so firstly you've got these culture cards here which give you a one-off special ability when you play it but when playing it it goes to your discard pile so it could come back again and if you acquire them they go straight to your hand and you basically get to play some at the start of your term what you're mainly doing though is that you're using the cards of the various villagers so there's five that you can choose from and you've got your basic starter deck but you can mix and match the ancestors I think it is expansion with it and that gives you more characters but in doing so what what these characters do is that you you play them and you you take a worker and you go on an action space and it doesn't block off other players it's just
choosing action you resolve the action in full but with the cards that you play you might generate some bonuses when doing a specific action or you might generate a hand symbol which is labor which is what you need in order to actually do certain symbols some characters are better at certain actions than others in providing labor so you go through free actions around one of which is a Chieftain with a special ability on it and then at the end of the round any characters that you didn't use you can put face down into what's called an eclipse pile and then when the night time phase happens after the basically the round has ended everybody reveals their Eclipse pile and gets the abilities of the of the eclipse stuff at the bottom it's a bit like doing Imperium where you keep cards behind for the combat phase well here you keep cards behind for whatever its bonuses they have you don't fight each other in this game although you do tackle each other for area control on the tile map but it's a cool like like decision making process you have to go through in order to decide what am I going to do with the cards in my hand this round am I going to use them am I going to keep them back I need to think about this it's a pretty solid game all around uh there's only so much else I can mention about this episode taking forever but I enjoyed the deck building aspect I enjoyed the card aspects for animals and the villagers I liked the culture cards you know they can give you some very useful Powers the ways that you score points you can kind of choose your path to Victory I mean you're going to go heavy on animals you're going to go Mass on the controlling the areas on the
camps or you're going to go high up in the idle track so you can exchange resources and things like that but one couple a couple of flaws I did find firstly this game is very long I mean particularly with the first players like new players to the table or four players this is going to easily take you longer than two hours I guarantee it says 60 to 120 Minutes that is if you know what you're doing if you do not know what you're doing or you've got the occasional slow player I don't think you can get this game done in two hours with four players I think you are more looking at two and a half to three potentially which is pretty long but if people get a move on and people know what they're doing I think you could do it in a two-hour time frame but yeah I think 16 minutes is pushing it even with two players I think 60 Minutes would be pushing it but that being said most Publishers lie about the timeline for their games but also I found that even if you choose a particular path to Victory you sort of end up doing everything Anyway by the end because your engine builds up to such an extent that yes I focused a lot on animals but because I did that I had so much food that I could just pump labor into other things by the end of the game I could still collect a bunch of characters I could still level up pretty high on the idol track without doing it from the beginning because it doesn't really matter if you do it at the beginning it's more about the end so I didn't feel that by the end of the game you felt that differentiated as opposed to the first half of the game it's a bit like a grickler in that respect you know agricular you can start off doing different parts but by the end of the game you will do the same as everybody else otherwise you're going to lose a bunch of points well here it's
kind of the same thing you get to the point where you just can't really do much more of the action that you've already kind of excelled in so you started doing other things in which case because you've got all the stuff from the previous engine it doesn't take you long to grab these ones it's that was a little bit like hmm the expansion were okay I mean the ancestors extra cards are something you would use every time there's some little modules the rivers and rafts was fine but it does really change up the way the terrain control aspect of the game works and what was the other one oh there's another one about drawing cave paintings on the little sideboard that looks like too much bloat and I don't think I'm gonna be that interested in that add-on but as I say so far my initial impressions are an 8 out of 10. it's decent it's great to actually but it's a great game but will it have the staying power will it start showing chinks in the armor when I play it even more we'll find out when I get my Kickstarter copy and also I'll be interested to know how this plays solo because I have not tackled that but yes there is a solo mode in it so I will be Keen to see how that goes what's this uh designer done actually Stan cordons let's have a look dice Hospital ruic lockup old west empresario and shadows kingdoms of Valeria areas top games well old west empresario is an underrated game really good dice hospital I'm like meh locker lock up I'm kind of Mayor not played rurik uh anything else it's just all endless winter Resurgence never heard of it yeah so some good stuff some not so great stuff
I mean we'll see I mean so far I think this is a great game but I'm just kind of remaining a little bit skeptical as to the stain power of it but we'll see when I get it like I say this is just introductory free games I now need to see what it's like to set it up and teach myself on you know to play as I know locally and see if it uh starts losing a bit of as lackluster we shall see right that was a lot of games I'd played and there's still a lot of this episode to do so although the discussion topic is probably not going to take me too long today so let's let's whip fire through these news quite quickly I wasn't even going to do any news and then suddenly in the last week I found like three things I wanted to talk about briefly firstly why don't we start with the small part of this which is a new announcement there's been some game announcements which is why this is the thing but first off I want to talk briefly about deal with the Devil 2022 four players three hidden roles two opposing paths only one Mighty ruler okay check game additions do some very good thematic games on occasion they really do do some quirky things and I read this blunt and it said deeply formatic competitive Euro game set in a fantasy Medieval Era each of the four pairs takes on the secret row oh well actually no this wasn't how I read it what the bit I read said deeply thematic competitive Euro game set in a fantasy mid Medieval Era and it said you are trading with other players and things like that that was the first paragraph I
read off the article I was reading and if you'd have just shown me that I would have said why do I care about this game that sounds so generic and boring here's the twist each of the four players takes on the secret role of a mortal cultist or even the Devil Due to the asymmetrical roles players experience the same game but with different game goals every play yeah this is an interesting thing because you are trading with other players because you're trying to build up the city and you need resources so it's very much that active typical theme but you are essentially trying to keep your roles hidden because one player is secretly the devil who's trying to tempt Mortals with goods for a piece of their soul the cultist nature is to sell their soul easily and there's an accompanying app that knows who's training with who okay so a hidden roll sort of social deduction game with the resource management City like a Medieval theme but some aspect of negotiation app integration I mean that's about as I know about this there's not a huge amount of extra information but I will say that concept sounds fantastic I can't say the artwork on that card is anything particular but this might be early stages but yeah it's a bit like something like dungeon pets you know check game additions do put out some really quirky games like Alchemists and that so this one really does sound interesting I'm curious how this will work it's already now going to be one of my most anticipated games for I'm
assuming Essen it will come out but yeah I want to try the stat this could be a hilarious fun I mean that theme is that works so well ah I do miss hidden roll games there hasn't been enough of those lately that aren't just straight up Social deduction games so yeah I'm down for this Jet game editions if you're watching I would love to get a copy of this to review because this sounds awesome right let's move on to something less awesome for me more awesome for you lot Dune Imperium has an expansion coming and normally I wouldn't really talk about this because I'm kind of done with doing Imperium but for those interested immortality is on the works probably for later this year and there's even less information about this one than the other one I was talking about you know I can't even pronounce half of the names on this bits here it's like the Bene tierlax Advance around agenda enjoy trading and genetic Innovations will you hire fire dancer spies uh or dare to employ people restored to life as golas bearing in mind I know nothing about the Dune law so I have no idea what golus the face dancers they're not fire dancers they're face dancers and the ballet chillax I have no idea who these people are anybody want to fill the blanks in and doom law because uh it's not like the first movie actually made a decent deal with it oh I should guess the first movie is crap um but yes but yeah so it's an expansion you get to do scientific research you get to graph cards together to empower your age agents and you get to draft apparently I think in this and there's like a
separate board that you level up I I mean if you like doing Imperium that much then oh well you're going to be loving this one but this just sounds like a a terraforming Mars turmoil situation are we going to get to the point where you're gay even that you the fans have to admit that your game is getting a little bit bloated at this point I mean the game hasn't fixed the problems from the first game where half the deck building part was rubbish because most of the cards anything that costs less than three was not worth buying for your deck because there's not enough ways to trash cards at your decks all you're doing is bloating your deck and bloating your deck in a deck builder is not a recommended idea if you can't draw through it so and there was a couple of other things I wasn't fan of and of course the artwork looks so much better on a cover than it does on anything else in the game because the artwork is terrible so yeah that's just my thoughts I mean I did like it a lot when I first played it but you know the chinks in the armor certainly showed themselves rather quickly after playing it even more and you know people say well why don't you buy the deluxe upgrades well great so I can pay 50 pounds for this game and then pay another 50 60 quid for the upgrades just to make it look bearable it's not like you can replenish the artwork I feel like this needs a second edition with a decent artist that'd be great get the Miko to do it the Miko doing June that would be pretty sweet but no I say if you're interested in more expansions for doing Imperium then by the end of this year you should have another one so look forward to that this on the other hand wow I did not expect this greater than games Spirit Island you know that Spirit Island's a game I
absolutely love well Horizons of spirit island is something they've just announced now they're already doing a nature incarnate or whatever it is expansion for the main Spirit Island cannot wait backing instantly I want I want I want I want I want this I just did not see coming this is apparently a Target exclusive which is a shame because that means me getting a copy of this is going to be extremely difficult to do but this is a one to three player Standalone simpler streamlined version of spirit Island a double-sided game board streamline setup punchable components and five new Spirits designed to be ideal for those players for the first time okay interesting I mean Spirit islands are very complex game when you get down to the nitty and gritty of it so a simpler version that can be played by all sorts of people I mean that sounds pretty sweet it looks like the same type of game I mean here's your blight pull your fair pool you've got the cards minor major Powers the icons but yeah the board is just a simpler setup so does it use events doesn't look like it uses anything from branch and Claw and jagadura so I don't think you have events and you certainly don't have all those Beast tokens and that everywhere so I think it keeps this pretty simplistic I mean this will be fun because I love Spirit Island but I'm curious about this the idea that you would have a simpler streamlined version to learn the only thing is if you bought this and then
decided you want the most complex One You're Gonna basically buy the complex one and then you probably never will go back to this one although the spirits are apparently compatible with the normal game how easily they're going to be compatible I don't know but I am totally down for getting a copy of this just so that I can have those five Spirits frankly because I mean I don't know if you could mix the cards I wonder if you could mix the cards with the other deck the minor and major powers that would be sweet as well but yeah other than that I'm down for five Spirits I mean give me five spirits to add to my collection of Spirits because it's all good but yeah the idea that I could teach this game to people who haven't played Spirit Island before and give them a simpler experience you know what I'm down for that kind of thing that just seems like a good idea but you know will it come out at Essen I don't know I mean I'm supposed to be demoing for greater than games at Essen this year with Spirit Island and uh Sentinels in the Multiverse so will this be released there will I be demoing this as well I don't know I mean that would be amazing if they could demo it and I could get a copy of it Essen that would be fantastic but I thought it was only going to Target so don't know about that one we'll have to see we'll see what they say but yeah I'm curious about this I mean mainly just give me five more Spirits I mean look at this you've got like a sort of windy glowy like kitty cat look at it it's a beautiful little kitty cat I want another kitty cat I want to play this one with the uh fangs of uh what was it called um hidden fangs the the Predator
cat I want to play this cat with the other cat I don't even know he's a cat pretty sure that's a cat um it doesn't actually say what it is but yeah I mean that does look like a cat of some description um but yeah so I mean this one in particular the Sun bright Whirlwind uh you start with zero energy or your unique Power Cards so it's a bit more explicit it's a bit more better to explain the starting setup uh play style good at handling explorers clearing newly explored lands of Invaders so they don't build there not so good at dealing with towns and cities this sounds basically like the same as the river sunlight one hmm I like to say but I don't know we'll find out more this is all the information I have but uh yeah Color Me interested right let's get off that and quickly sort of get on to the discussion topic yes so patreons have given me some ideas for discussion topics um I'll need to get a few more from them soon but uh the question on this one's I just did by Mr Tim is one that is quite an interesting concept uh basically do sequels to games improve or detract from the the enjoyment of said Series so the idea is is that there are a lot of times where games come out with their spin-offs pandemic has done it to death uh Century spice Road did the sequels where they literally just changed the theme and artwork Azul is probably the best exp example of this kind of thing because Azul has had four different things now I
mean I've not even played the fourth one because frankly getting onto this I don't particularly care that much I don't know why that's on there delete that that must have been a typo doing something else but yes so yeah I mean I've played Azul I've played stained glass as syndra and I've played some of in and I didn't like stains NASA sintra Azul is good but I've kind of done with it now and then summer Pavilion is good but it's way too long for an Azul game and I don't have really any interest in trying Queen's Garden but this is an example where the sequels have actually detracted from it because the more you start milking a cash cow the more I start to go oh God more of this would you just show some Innovation expansions to a game is fine you know Spirit Island you can give me all the spirits you like and I'll take it you can give me all the expansions to Star Wars outer rim you can give me all the heroes and sent those the Multiverse I will love it that's an expansion to the game that's already there that is not a sequel but Azul for example has three spin-offs which use the same mechanic but then twist it up a notch and honestly the original result is still the best one in my opinion so far so why did we need these spin-offs uh Sentry spice Road had the uh weird idea of saying right we're doing Century spice Road we're then gonna do two sequels and you'll be able to combine them in one giant package and how many people actually bother to do this Century spice road is a decent
enough game but I only give it a six it's fine but it out stays it's welcome it takes too long it can bog down with bad cards and I just think Splendor and various other games like Majesty of the realm and that just do this kind of thing a lot better so I don't really take much interest in it I played the sequel which was the uh what you got the I forget what it was something Waters Eastern's Waters or something you basically go around on the boat and you do essentially what you do in Century spice Road that's fine but it's very it's a bit fiddly it takes longer it's a bit more clunky I wasn't as fan of that one and then the third one let me see if I can find the titles actually it would probably be better Century Eastern Wonders that was it and the other one was a new world so a new world was fine uh that's probably my favorite of the three it had it basically had a worker placement aspect with the whole turning stuff in the Cubes but again that gets very samey and each one is is basically just doing what Sentry spice Road did and just throw in a tiny little twist on it why didn't you just play the original now I've not played it with everything combined I think that would just be a bit of a mess but I don't see anybody playing this I don't see anybody playing these sequels frankly occasionally I see Century of spice Road played I have not seen Easton wonders or a new world played in years and lit I have barely ever seen them combined so clearly I don't think this was the most popular thing that suddenly came out of it but then the sequel doesn't necessarily have to be directly linked I mean take blood rage for example blood rage technically
doesn't have sequels but you can argue that Rising Sun and Unk are essentially not the same series but they're kind of similar to each other it's all basically dudes on the map big Miniatures fighting each other through Supremacy that's what all three games do they just throw a slight Twist on it take a drink so with these I mean blood raisin wasn't as big on a fan of I do love Rising Sun but how long it will stay in a collection remains to be seen because it is a big game taking up space and it costs a lot of money but I am no interest in Arc I mean that merge rule is garbage and the Buzz for ankh that was like oh my God he's releasing the game oh it's gonna be amazing and who talks about it now flash in the pan uh yeah Flash in a pan I thank you called it pick up the phone I called it yeah so nobody really talks about ankh anymore so these ones again when you see the same kind of thing just with a slight twist it does sometimes get a little bit like stale or it's not offering enough new to the table now occasionally sequels can improve on the original formula so it's certainly as much as I'm not a fan of the zombicide series it is definitely a thing that the original zombicide was definitely improved upon by black plague which was definitely improved upon by invader others and certainly the second edition of zombicide is much better than the first edition but then some of these problems that they had in zombicide could have been fixed by them just actually taking five seconds to proofread their Rule books and actually take five seconds to
consider the impact of some of their rules I mean who remembers the controversy of the zombicide when you shoot into a mixed group you all you have to hit your friend first dumbest shooting rule ever and then the second game black plague where you had the split rule where you had to do this complicated system in order to work out what happens when you have two paths that zombies can move it's like oh my god do they not look at their Rule books and just think you know what maybe this is stupid and we should actually think about this more but that being said those blemishes aside the sequels to zombicide were better than the original zombicide another good example would probably be brass now yes I don't like brass here so whatever I mean I gave it a six when I first reviewed it it's probably now four for me I mean it's more that I give it respect I still don't like it but you know I can't deny that the artwork is gorgeous and to be fair I do have those clay chips they are very nice I use them in Majesty for the realm the other day and yes so much better I use them for Arc Nova as well but to be very I use the clay chips whenever I can use the clay chips they're just so good I love little pocket chips but I digress so brass Lancashire which was effectively the original brass there it got re-implemented by brass Birmingham which people will say oh this is a great Standalone game it is a map pack it is the same game with a slight twist but I can't deny that loads of people out there are bigger fans of Birmingham than they are Lancashire so for those people definitely brass Birmingham is a sequel
upgrade to what brass is again I just think it's a map pack where all you did was create the exact same system you just changed the names redid the connections and put beer in it that's it I mean you can easily change the connections and city names on a map pack so literally all you've done is ADD beer I mean it's basically the same as what a ticket to ride map pack does for its original game it gives you a different map and it adds a new mechanic in it it's no different so the fact that these two are Standalone and on the board game geek.com 100 I think really irks me I really hate that fact but again I digress so you know this is one though where the sequel does improve the crew you know gotta say the crew the Quest for planet nine love this game fantastic but I've sold my copy why because Mission deep sea is included and yes it is 95 the same game but that five percent difference is easier the scenarios are better the way of setting up the scenarios is better so if you're going to get one or the other you get Mission deep C you don't even look at the space one you know and yes it's a tiny little twist but there you go I mean I hope they don't make a theme of this and bring out tons of these the crew games I think this is all you need now just stick with this one and you're good but yeah it did the job uh let's see some other ones uh descent is I got a bunch written down I was literally like damn I'm possessed I wonder if I can play the accordion too when I was trying to prepare for this so descent oh God that's not it that's a what on
Earth was that it's like a weird abstract game no descent Journeys in the dark where is it come on descent here we go so I don't know about the first edition of descent but the second edition was good fun I enjoyed it uh I didn't collect it I just played it but this was the type of dungeon cool that I like you know be your hero get some cool stuff go fight monsters kick the door down you know nice frantic fast a bit of luck involved not puzzly I.E not bloomhaven so you know this one I really enjoyed descent Third Edition on the other hand though hmm that one wasn't so good I mean I Legends of the dark I gave my review of this and I stand by it I mean I give it a six overall but man the writing in this is really poor and this whole terrain thing becomes a big fat and chore very very quickly you know it really that gimmick loses its uh appeal especially when you realize how much you spent on this game so descent sequel wise is not particularly done great although Star Wars Imperial assault you can argue as a sequel effectively to descent Imperial assault I think is better than descent how much is it uh it's Star Wars I might be just looking at it with Nostalgia goggles because it's Star Wars but second edition Legends of the dark and Star Wars Imperial assault are like both um yeah I can take it or leave it but you know some people will prefer one over the other uh we mentioned Gloom Haven a second ago that's effectively doing the same thing because you had gloomhaven with the big box then you got jaws of the lion which
was effectively a sequel to the game which condensed it down and made it easier to play and now we're gonna get uh White Blue Haven oh sorry Frost Haven you know change Gloom to frost and color it into the red and brown make it white and blue that's basically what Frost Haven will be but you know it's going to be incredibly popular so like hot cakes suddenly get to number one on Board Game Geek because board game geek's ranking system is broken but you know people are certainly gonna think the sequels are better than the originals because a lot of people will play jaws of the lion rather than the big box gloomhaven even the digital version of Gloom Haven apparently is better than this big box version of what I'm hearing from Paul Grogan and various other people and I'll bet you anything that Frost Haven is going to be an improvement on gloomhaven regardless of the fact that it's basically the same game so you know there's definitely going to be sequel love for that one uh what else uh well sequels can also come from the same mechanic so uh card crafting games from John declare will technically be sequels of each other although I don't think saying that it's a sequel just because of the same mechanic well then again that's Azul for you so yeah I suppose it does count uh Mystic veil was the original one that uh John declare did with the whole card crafting system well since then we've had Edge of Darkness which I really love and now we've had dead reckoning which I like but has problems so the sequels for this I mean Edge of Darkness I prefer to Mystic Veil but I prefer Mystic Veil to dead reckoning so you know it's kind of mixed
bag on that one uh what else we got uh the exit and unlock games I wrote down I mean they're not necessarily sequels they're just more of the same eventually that had to die out really oh Dinosaur Island yes Dinosaur Island that's a good one because that Still Remains on my shelf despite the fact that the designer had to go at me on Facebook um for giving my opinion on dead reckoning apparently but the I still have this game in my collection with the expansion because it's you know one of the few games you don't know I like and I I prefer this one to I have not played dinosaur world but the you know this is already a really fun game for me dinosaur world does not look like it does anything that's going to improve over Dinosaur Island for me and the consensus I'm hearing from a lot of reviewers and a lot of people is that dinosaur world isn't as good as Dinosaur Island so why have dinosaur world and Dinosaur Island I mean dinosaur either one was the ranking on that one that was a rank what's its rank 172 dinosaur world is ranked a thousand and ten it has nowhere near the same amount of Buzz I don't think it even had that much buzz when it first came out reviews have been mixed you know not that many people are that impressed by it so we have a direct sequel to A predecessor that isn't doing anywhere near as good maybe they should have taken note for that for the Jurassic Park movies because every single sequel gets worse by the freaking minute but well I digress uh what else uh Arkham
Horror um Arkham Horror second edition Third Edition not including the card game and uh Eldritch Horror but the second edition was a very clunky but very thematic horror based game the Third Edition granted that's the one I own on the Shelf because it is technically the more streamlined and ease you're going to get to the table but it loses some of that horror Flair that the second one had and when you ask people which ones they prefer I think the general consensus is that you do find people still have a soft spot for the second edition or they prefer Eldritch Horror so I don't know which I prefer actually Arkham Horror for traditional Eldritch Horror I think part of me suggests uh Arkham our third edition because it feels more horror whereas Eldritch Horror feels more like Indiana Jones adventure with some horror bits thrown in but both of them are solid games so I can't exactly complain uh Dixit uh I mean you've got Dixit and you've got Muse and you've got detective club and you got obscurio and you got mysterium it's using the same mechanic but you can't really say those are sequels to each other that one just seems a little bit off uh Ticket to Ride similar deal Katana Pandemic those games have had spin-offs and seagulls Galore though actually in fact saying that I think actually you could argue with Katan and pandemic because a lot of the games at Katana I love Katan but I just collect the base set expansions I think a lot of the spin-offs for Katan aren't that good they're just meh why would I play this over the normal containment expansions pandemic great game to begin with and to
be fair pandemic Liberia is the one I keep on my shelf because it is a solid sequel like implementation of it but I don't own cooler Cthulhu I didn't particularly much care for fall of Rome I don't like Rising tide what else have they done the Legacy games I enjoyed but again you play them once and you're kind of done and I have no interest in Legacy season zero or whatever it was the uh Cold War one because you know I like art in my games not gray collages everywhere so I wasn't interested in that and yeah I mean pandemic has certainly milked itself to death by now and needs to just die a death you know you've had your moment you're still popular could you please stop spinning off every spin-off you can but z-man games just don't seem to have an Innovative thought in their body sometimes so yeah you are just gonna get the same stuff all the time yeah last time I drink I need to wrap this up soon uh what other one last one I can then go off uh the Garfield game series I mean West Kingdom and Raiders in the North Sea they're part of a series but I mean I suppose they are similar games that you could describe them as sequels but they're different enough I mean yes they use the same kind of setting and the same artwork and that and they've certainly got the same iconography but I don't think I could say that they're sequels you know they're yeah they are you know architects of the West kingdom is its own game and so is paladins and so is VI counts yes they use the same iconography but they are different just like Wayfarers of the South Tigris is different from all of these three games yes it uses a similar
iconography but they are different enough games and I don't think I can really class these as sequels so there's going to be some subjective measure as to what is considered a sequel to a game rather than just simply expansions or using the same publisher and Series in a sense so it'd be interesting get your thoughts uh the idea of do game sequels tend to improve on The Originals or do they tend to lose some of the appeal do they get stuff wrong or does it not capture the spirit of the original I mean you know when it comes to movies I mean you can argue this to death but a lot of the times the original tends to Trump the sequels I mean you know I would still much rather watch the original drastic part in any sequel that's ever come out for it back to the future my favorite Trilogy I do really like Back to the Future too but you kind of have to argue that Back to the Future one is the better of film even though I enjoy the sort of uh Easter eggs that are thrown into the second one you can do that with a lot of the MCU movies Marvel and DC similar deal uh Terminator Terminator is a sequel that improved let me Terminator 1 is great but Terminator 2 is like a world of its own it's fantastic uh Rambo yeah Rambo the first one compared to the other ones I don't know because they get a little bit more crazy as they go through the match rocky rocky one Rocky 2 are the two best movies out of the range even though Rocky 4 I have a soft spot for yeah I mean you could argue this to death with movies but that's for another time who knows but I'd be
interested to hear your thoughts and what you have to say on the matter so that's it for me I'll see you on the next episode of the broken meeple uh take care of yourselves and remember if you like what you see thumb up the video consider subscribing to the channel whether it's via the podcast feed or the YouTube feed uh definitely consider subscribing to the patreon to give me a hand with review copies because review copies are drying up these days and the channel needs every little bit it can just to push itself forward to afford its overheads and of course give you the content that you want to see and other than that though you can check out more content on the channel including the two top 10 lists that I just mentioned the top 10 filler games and the top 10 games no one wants to play with me take care and remember as always whether it's the original of a sequel It's still only a game bye for now take care love you all