Skip to main content
Loading video...

10 Board Games Ranked & Reviewed - Episode 40

Transcript 18:25

hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video this is where I rank and give short reviews of the last 10 new to me games that I have played now before I get started on these 10 games plus an extra I would give a shout out to the show sponsor ker.com retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order before I get into the 10 games I want to give a quick mention to an exit game that we played recently this was exit the haunted roller coaster been quite some time since I played an exit game because admittedly I did get a little bit fatigued with them um but this was I know I was in the right mood it was the right place at the right time we had one of these lying around and you know what I actually quite enjoyed this one it wasn't too easy it wasn't too difficult either we did pretty well and some of the puzzles were quite interesting so out of all the ones that I played I think this was probably one of the better on so I know I like that one that was exit the haunted roller coaster but let's get into the 10 games now so at number 10 I have the seals of cthulu so this one is a strange two player only game with some bidding and some bluffing and what you're essentially doing is you're playing a card from your hand face down and then putting your kind of wage on to see you know what I'm willing to pay this much to take this card and then your opponent can either take take your offer or they

can up the bid where the decision will be reversed and then you can either take their offer or up the bid again and it keeps going until someone's out bid the other person and then they'll take all the currency and then the other person will take the actual card to put in their Tableau now these cards have different uses so number one is the actual victory points number two is the influence they're worth because you can actually use previously earned cards in order to buy future cards um and the third use is that if you get two halves of the same book typee or the card type then you will get given a particular ability which will allow you to kind of flip cards over and stuff to hurt your opponent and even like um flip your cards back over if they've hurt you that kind of thing now the game mechanically was actually pretty interesting and I think there's a lot of potential here now my issue with it was that the game didn't really kick into gear until it was nearly over so it's only a five round game and by the time you end up getting you know a couple of those cards of the same type it's normally the fourth or fifth round so you didn't really get enough time to trigger them and that flipping ability or part of the game didn't really come into play at all so it was a strange one we we were kind of struggling to find where the game was and it came down to kind of a micro decision of you know who had the most points compared to their opponent but that key mechanism of that back and forth bidding works really really well yeah all in all I think the execution was a little bit lack cluster and again we would have struggled to find where the game was we even read the rule book

again to make sure we were playing it correctly and we were so almost kind of a non-starter with this one um maybe I'm missing something and I think it's probably going to get better if you really invested in this game and kept on playing with the First with the same player so that those nuances start to build but with so many great two play games out there I'm not quite sure I'm prepared to do that so that is the seals of cthulu at number 10 at number nine I have taco cat goat cheese Peach now this is almost like a game of snap but instead of playing cards and trying to match them and whenever you play a card you are going to say those words in order and if what you've said matches the card you've played then you know it's going to be the first person to put their hand down and or the last person is going to G get those cards and the idea is to try and shed your cards there are also some bonus cards as well which add some silliness into the mix such as these like Nar walls and things where you have to make like gestures with your hands before slapping your hand down so complete nonsense know gameplay mechanically it's absolutely terrible but you cannot help but have fun with this one know we only played it the once um you know I had a relatively good time with doing so because it was so um silly and wacky um obviously nothing I'm going to sing from the rooftops about because it is just it is what it is really but you know it brought a smile to our faces so therefore it had to get some credit so that is taco cat goat cheese pizza at number eight I have Dr Panic this is another family weight Style game definitely more aim towards kids but is a real time game where you are trying to

complete all these little activities in your group which all represents some kind of medical procedure so for example you have to put the kind of ECG wir together or you have to represent the kind of stitching going through this thing in the right order those kind of things get complete silliness but that mixed with the pressure of the counter going or the timer running down and on top of that the app is throwing in these extra things to really throw you off track so for example we had one that said you need to stop what you're doing you need to get everybody into the toilet and close the door and once you've done that you can open the door again and come out and carry on with your activity so again complete silliness um but again it was so wacky and so frantic that you cannot help but have a good time so and know Dr Panic definitely an event Style game probably play it you know once or twice a year um but if you are in the right mood and have the right group with you then it's going to guarantee some so that is Dr Panic at number eight at number seven I have Lutes now this is a set collection and bidding Style game where you are bidding simultaneously with your opponents to put a claim on these different cards which will score you at your points money is quite tight in this game so every so often you have to kind of bypass actually spending money in order to collect more money which means that you cannot take a card that round um and it's kind of balancing those things now I do like this idea of you know potentially having some know Crossover with what you and your opponents want so therefore you can

bolster your bids before you reveal them in order to hopefully get or beat your opponent and then get what you want but of course you do not you do not exactly know what your opponents want so therefore you might have wasted some currency in order to secure that particular car that no one else wanted anyway it's pretty standard stuff you know this is kind of a run of- the meal set collection and bidding Style game but it is fairly clean it's unconv voluted there's no fiddly rules it kind of reminds me a bit of need of Aer but nowhere near as refined or polished but at the same times it's it's a bit more stripped back than a game like that so I'm not quite sure in 2024 if there is that kind of a market for this game it feels like there's so many other games that did what this does but a lot better but at the same time it doesn't exactly do anything bad either it just is what it is it's a solid you know five five and a half six out of 10 bidding Style game so that is a lest at number seven at number six I have Merchants Quest now this is an upcoming Kickstarter game that will be releasing later in May um and this is a a weird one because it's kind of a a bridge between more traditional roll and move style games with some Euro mechanisms put on top of it so essentially what you're doing is you're rolling a d and you're moving Your Wagon from one side of the board to the other revealing tiles as you go these tiles can be just completely empty Ts that let you carry on they can be picking up more quests they can be visiting these villages to buy goods and then you're going to

continue through the map and hopefully sell those goods for a profit because certain Villages offer you more money than what you paid for them in the first place at the same time you have to move through this mountain range which can be problematic because things are are popping up that you can't move through and all as you go on the map is getting revealed more and more when your opponents can start kind of piggybacking on your efforts to use the trade routes that you've already established um I I think this game works so well because of that roll and move mechanism mixed with the round timer because you want to be making sure you're leaving yourself enough time to get everything done because you are incentivized to take Goods to the castle right on the other side of the board to sell them for their maximum profits um but of course you want to make as much money as you can before you get to that point because once you're at the castle you can never come back so yeah this one again on paper probably shouldn't work as well as it does but it just knows what it's trying to do and it doesn't pretend to be something it's not it Just oozes charm and I enjoyed it a lot and so did everybody else I played with actually we all kind of left this game um with a big smile on my face because it was just so so Charming so um yeah if this one interests you um I probably will be releasing a review soon if I haven't done so already so keep an eye out for that one so that is Merchants Quest at number six at number five I have matches now this is a quirky card game with some hand management mechanisms going on and a degree of bluffing and wagering as well because there's kind of two main ways that

you're going to score points in this game and number one is to pass from the round and score points based on pairs of cards that you've played in front of you but the second one is to be the last man standing and end up taking a bunch of points that are built up on this kind of bonfire but the cards you're playing may be adding more gems onto the bonfire making it more lucrative and more inviting to the other players so it's all about knowing when to boost that bonfire or knowing when it's not going to be advantageous to do so and back out with the round early to stop the lasting player to collect more points um it's very it's a very slight game I don't think there's a lot of decision space but the decisions you're making do matter in the end and there's just something about it that just works and it feels a little bit different and just a little bit strange um so I'm liking this one I'm not sure if it's going to be up there with the great card games but it's going to kind of raise an eyebrow to and think you know there's something a little bit different about this game and I do really like that again that wagering of shil I how can I manage this hand to stay in this round as long as I can to make sure I'm the last man standing to claim all those riches that are built up through all the other players efforts as well so that is matches at number five at number four I have another two-player only game with yo-kai Sketch now this is a tug of war Style game another card driven game as you are playing these double-sided cars from your hand and putting them against these matching scoring piles of cards uh

those scoring cards are kind of shuffled into a deck and varying points so some of them are going to be worth as little as three points some are worth as much as seven points but in order to for that card to be distributed to the winning player you and your opponent need to have contributed that amount of cards so you know for example if I had four cards next to that scoring card and my opponent had three it'll be seven therefore that seven card will go to the winning player but the winning player will remove their bid cards out of the out of the mix but the losing players will stay there ready for the next card to come round so was all about pacing uh yourself now there's also some um additional kind of wrinkles little tricks you can pull off in this game because some of these cards allow you to mess with the decks and what points are distributed and some of them will even force your opponent to flip their card around and allocate that previously played card on the opposite side of that card so again a lots of little tricks and um little things you can do to manipulate The Bard state to your uh benefits it feels more like a traditional game it almost feels like kitan in the way that it works super smooth and pretty clever moves it at brisk pace and um comes in a tiny box as well so these little card games work for me add in a mechanically there's nothing um spectacular about it but there's also nothing I can really criti size either because again just works and it does what it does pretty damn well so that is yo-kai sketch at number four okay so let's get into the top three games now

and this is where my commendations begin and to be honest you could have put these three games in any order and I would have been happy so I definitely did find it difficult to put these uh in the positions of 3 two and one again it could have fallen either way so at number three I have the Lost Code so this is a reprint of think straight which is a an older deduction Style game of course this is I think mechanically is exactly the same but it's got a whole new fresh lick of paint uh on it so this one you are trying to find the numbers that are facing away from you that your opponents can see but you can see all their numbers we've seen that kind of thing before in deduction games but what I really love about this game is the actual um the way that you're getting points because you are using the series of these different dials which will trying to um help you what you'll use to guess the combined value of the different symbols of these tiles so each round you're going to roll some dice and then that's going to ask you you know what is the total value of those symbols added up and then you got a series of these different dials some of them will have a wide range some will have a very narrow range and basically you're trying to guess the range of numbers that those di could add up to so again if you're certain on what it is you can go for that one particular number and get a whole bunch of points or if you're not so certain then you can you know go wider range get a fewer points but maybe get some information out of that now something that this game had really kind of um messed with me is because your

information that you have in front of you does change throughout the game and you need to get that into your head when you go into this one because I've made some pretty costly mistakes um so yeah everything's always in flux at least if you're making mistakes in this one um and that's something you need to kind of drill into your brain but all in all I love that that gear system I think it's so so clever it's really clean design know you simply roll the dice guess your number and score points simple as that I think a lot of deduction games try a little bit too hard to be different and end up kind of steering away from the actual deduction part too much whereas my favorite deduction games seem to focus on just that you know the deduction itself and this one is definitely up there with my favorite deduction games that I've played again it could have been number two or one on this list cuz you know what I'm still kind of exposing myself to this one trying to learn about it and um I really am itching to get it back to the table so that is the Lost Code at number three at number two I have peblo which is the second of the mohito studios Games first of which being at the Lost Code now this is a reprint of preo from over 20 years ago now I know I've wanted this game forever um but it's been like hen teeth to get a copy of U but this is a Kramer and keying design that's I think completely unique to anything else I have in my collection you are essentially stacking these blocks on top of each other and around each other but trying to conceal your own color amongst the other blocks because each turn there's going to be this piece that

circles the board and depending on where it lands and what it can see um the players are going to get points and points in this game are a bad thing so you want to hide your pieces as much as you can sometimes you might want to you know put your blocks where other players are so that if that if you're going to take a hit they're also going to take a hit and at the same time you are not only hiding your blocks from kind of a side view when this piece hits the corners you have to make be making sure that you are covering your pieces from a bird's eye view as well so definitely a literal multi multi-dimensional Style game um highly distinct to anything else I've ever had in my collection um really enjoyed it it gets pretty competitive gets pretty brain burner at time as you try to map the timings out and where players are likely to go leaving yourself enough time to cover up your exposed pieces and you know what this game is so much fun and again very interesting you know quite it's quite different now to difficult now to find unique games this game is certainly that so that is pbl at number two and finally at number one I have Evergreen so Evergreen is the somewhat reimplementation of photosynthesis that did really well quite a few years ago now however in this one unlike photosynthesis you are not sh sharing aboard with the other players this one you have your own little Forest where you are trying to efficiently grow your Trees from Little Twigs into big ones um and try to absorb these light points as the sun moves around the board and your trees capture them bigger trees will

cause Shadows which will hide other trees and so on this is all about trying to map out as efficiently as you can to get as much light as you can at the end of every round the way you actually take your turns in this one is that you're using this card drafting system which will show you which um location or what part of the map you can actually build on but it also has a little subaction on it where you can do different things as well which aren't location specific but the actions themselves are very simple you know put new trees on the board um Sprout smaller trees into bigger trees or those medium trees to the bigot trees again and so on but there's little twist in this game which kind of conflict with each other you know that idea of getting the most like points but at the same time getting points based on your grouped trees or there even this additional Touch where the card left behind that was not drafted by the players will go into the scoring pool which means that those particular cards or that type of landscape will addition will grant you points based on the big trees in it at the end of the game and they can really ramp up so it's something that cannot be ignored and those three conflicting scoring uh mechanisms kind of buttheads with each other and it makes it a very interesting game in terms of the decision space so um a joyful play it's very relaxing in I find it's just it's just a nice game so that is Evergreen at number one so there we have it that concludes the video hopefully you have enjoyed it and discovered a new game or two on the list now if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my

channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved