Skip to main content
Loading video...

The True COST of Creating a Board Game and the Mistakes We Made

Transcript 21:38

hello welcome thank you for being here today we're having a conversation about board game publishing about the stuff that you learn along the way uh Austin Harrison from thank you IV Studios you all have put me again a few a few titles yeah we've put out well do you you can't just not expand it three four veiled fate yep that's that's definitely one Mythic mischief and soon the lovely fractured Sky these are all my box Lids so the damage will be uh build the ivy Studios soon fractured Sky you've had uh quite a few campaigns that have been uh in the crowdfunding marketplace in the five to eight hundred thousand dollar range you've had one particular campaign the new expansion for moonrakers that skyrocketed almost that two million dollar Mark that was that was a big welcome surprise an old welcome surprise you're approaching will this be your fifth campaign and your fourth game fifth campaign fourth game as a as a Publishing House yep established operating surviving even through the pan we're still here so what I wanted to talk with you about today is go through each one of your titles and talk about something that you learned along the way something that that this game taught you whether that's from design to production to just The Narrative of what it's like

to be a board game publisher right moonrakers so baby number one baby number one I think the main thing that we all learned but me specifically Learned was just getting past imposter syndrome um because I mean who are we to design a board game like we played a lot of board games we loved board games but you know it's just like when you're making it we for the first three months my job of you know helping design it my like professional opinion when I submitted it to Zach and Sam the owners about what I should do next was let's stop doing this no yeah no I was like the game's not working I've working on it for three months so three months in you went to your boss and I said and close friends I should go back to just working at the animation studio like this isn't working hey guys remember when I had a career that I felt really confident yeah and I knew I had just figured that career out yeah yeah so you're now we're now we're doing this and I'm gonna be honest with you it doesn't feel right I'm failing yeah like the game was not fun objectively um you know how we do like you fulfill contracts sure that part wasn't in there you were fighting enemy ships but they all had their own decks and so half the game was just flipping over cards for people it was bad it just takes away a lot of the player agency yeah it really does in fact I've never thought about this sport but luminar kind of is like that but it's all being digitally done you're not like flipping over cards or something and stuff but they have like random abilities and stuff like that like the enemy ships do so yeah that's interesting I've thought about that before but uh came full circle anyway

yeah it just wasn't fun and like me and Max I specifically remember being at a conference for bouncy smash which was an app that we developed a long time ago and during the downtime after the show we were working on moonrakers and we were playing it in a hotel lobby and I was just like we've been playing for two hours feels like we've played a quarter of the game and this is not fun and so yeah we they Zack and say we're like no like it takes time to do this stuff just like keep going we'll keep playing it with you and yeah it just looks getting past the Imposter syndrome we eventually got it to a place that we were really proud of and we started working on Art and it's in the version that you've played now um but I like if it was up to me we would have never made any games there was definitely a point where you were like I'm I think I'm I think I'm quitting because I'm wasting your time I was gonna quit the company I just wanted to go back no just yeah yeah because you it was a big transition it was a big step it was I mean even though you were within a secure footprint you're still looking at this thing and you're like I'm in New Territory I haven't done this I don't know that this will succeed if this doesn't succeed people I care about just put a lot of investment on me yep and I know a lot of people that reach out to us and they're just like hey I'm designing a game but love some advice I've got 100 pages of lore written I'm about to do my first play test and I'm like oh well like hey like the the lore part is great and you're definitely gonna use that but don't be discouraged when that first play test is terrible or they hate it and or you hate it because I hated the game for a long time like I just didn't find it fun for four or five six months um and so like you're gonna go through

iteration after iteration after iteration before you find something that's fun and then you just hold on to that fun and you chase it you change all the rules to wrap around that thought so that's the story of Moonraker that story you got you got past the fact that you could create a board game okay and this is the opposite problem here we have veiled fate yes what's going on here it's a veiled fate you did it you accomplished we did moonrakers we're feeling pretty good delivered beautiful page everyone was telling you guys like you're one of the best I don't know about that but there was a lot of good feedback when he came to the kickstarter page oh oh the Kickstart pitch was great yeah gorgeous thank you yeah so veiled fate me and Zach were driving home from Dyson we're driving the airport from Dice Tower after going down there to show Moon Raiders we're talking about the next thing what's the next thing and veiled fate um we played a video game called hidden Plain Sight which was about like you had a person in the crowd you're moving them around and the other person would be trying to find the person you're moving around crowd so they're trying to act very natural yeah um and we were like can we make a board game experience that kind of feels like acting natural in the crowd um and so that's where the original idea for film fake came from and I designed something that was a race to Five Points okay all right played very similarly to how build fake plays now it was just first of Five Points and the the quests it was there was not too much going up too down to it was very rare it was very much going up one going down one um but overall there's more going up ones and then we're going down one So eventually somebody won't sure um the tension when multiple people were at Four Points was just out of this

world people screaming don't you dare put black on that spot like the girl to win you're not playing this right and then like the votes just being big surprises led to these huge moments and I was just like this game is awesome okay the problem was you take it outside of that core play testing group yeah those five people that were playing the game felt totally flat someone won almost just randomly like The Meta was so important to the game being good sure that playing it without people that had played it 30 times just was not good sure and Zach and Max were like Austin it cannot be erased to Five Points they need more room to breathe the game just like needs more time in general it needs to be round based because the game could range between an hour and three hours going to Five Points it was just all whether you could stop people from scoring okay um they're like it needs to be less of an unknown about how this is gonna happen I said no the best part of the game is that right Five Points is the screaming at the tension and all of that and I fought for months me and George have an amazing exactly this is my favorite game I was like the play test group that we played with loves that you don't understand hanging out with my buddies is one of the best things I ever do so the the piece of advice here and the thing that I learned is You Gotta Kill Your Darlings sometime and I hate that is my least favorite part about designing fractured Sky I have killed malt we actually I didn't kill Zack and Zach Max killed multiple things but needed to be killed that I didn't want to kill sometimes it's even admirable to

remove your darling for the sake of just yeah yeah I mean your darling might be great like that mechanic really might be great but it also might be hiding the other things that make the cohesive game work yep like in this case it really didn't work with your group worked way better without the reason why anyone else yeah exactly for the broader audience and uh and that's why it's so important for me to design with other people I am not good at taking things out sure and and you know Max and Zach just happen to be better at that that being said I don't come up with all the ideas for our games like it's not just me adding stuff and then taking it out like we all add stuff yeah yeah you just don't take any of it out no I I constantly I'm planning to keep things Mythic Mischief the follow-up the uh yeah the third in the line so you've learned that you both could make a board game as long as you didn't quit then you learned that maybe you shouldn't make the game you were hoping to make yeah amazing that's good for them to be other people now we're on we're now we're on a Mythic Mischief what what what did this game teach you man I did not think the theme could work with the gameplay I think I thought it needed to be like a battle game like an actual combat game and I I wasn't trusting the team that we could make it fun because the original idea was just clicks in a school and it wasn't the monster Mayhem okay type of thing and so I think this is tying in almost to Kill Your Darlings but in some way like I need to trust the other designers I'm working

with because everyone else saw the vision for it and I didn't and then we started getting art back and we started seeing the bank phones I was like this is actually I love the theme integration and I'm so glad we didn't make it like a straight up battle game because there are so many straight back so what were you imagining you were imagining like hunting down the leader or something like that yeah like because you don't actually interact with each other as much oh this is like pretty early like the tone keeper wasn't necessarily the only way to kill people then or like catch people then um and so this is this is really early in the in the design process on Mythic Mission this is uh Max Max's idea Max Anderson um and I love having him on board because his brain works very different see I would have done like rats in a basement that would have been fun it's just like two factions of rats yeah just two different different rotors like the rats versus the mice and they're having a war it's just different creatures yeah different different in this like scummy sewer area and I think so I think the the thing I learned is trusting the two other people I designed with I've got I've got a skin I've got a new skin for this look at me out listen all right the tone keeper okay becomes an animal sanctuary capturer okay all the factions turning to dogs and cats cats that would be kind of fun that would sell or like it's like dogs cats raccoons no no snakes no no no no no just dogs and cats that's all you need that's for the internet all what we're trying to do is dogs and cats so this this is a lesson in other people can also be right I ended up well I learned that on build fate too just in a different way other people in build it you learned you can be wrong

in this you learned other people could be wrong I just am a huge one yeah I'm just the worst you really you've really grown as a person but it's true like you you you you start off completely uncomfortable and now you have too much confidence a letter from your wife oh no but I mean it it turned out to be something I love so much yeah and had I held the reins it would never have turned out that way and so I think that's the lesson I learned it's just cool yeah all right and the one that we're working on oh man I learned the same lesson well let's actually let's take a quick pause okay let's prep this one but you did have in the middle of this an expansion wave for moonrakers and since the first three have been talking about the experience of creating in a lot of ways which I find interesting is the stuff that you've really pulled out right the the idea that you're maybe not equipped to design a board game learning that no in fact your ideas are bad and then realizing other people are better at this than you are those are the first three lessons that I got from our conversation what was the experience of going back to a title who were working on the expansion content which in my opinion transform moonrakers like it brought it from a state where it was clear that this was a first-time designer making a great game but still a first time designer to a Powerhouse like really really good you could tell the design experience and the collaboration between the team members was on was on point to create the thing that you created when it came to the Titan expansion so what what was that like yeah so for there's

two points I want to make for this one um so one is when we're talking to other designers or talking about our games we we like to establish like the spirit of the game moonraker's spirit is going on Space Adventures with your friends right like the the short-term uh Alliance stuff came from that yeah um and we really just like comparing everything that you're trying to add to the game to that to make sure it stays within the spirit of the game um and one is not just throwing content in for content's sake um but also really targeting problems that could be in the game that we could fix with expansions sure and so the first one we actually made an expansion and play tested it that has never seen the light of that it was a single used card expansion you got a um a new store that had like missiles and a bunch of other stuff and it had a lot of player interaction but it was negative player interaction and we place tested it for a while and it some of it was pretty fun but it added a new feeling to the game and it it was not the spirit of the game we're not going on Space Adventures of friends now you could argue that moonrakers breaks that because you can betray people in meanration however the game really does not encourage that and when you do betray people it feels like a friend has betrayed you exactly a enemy ship yep yeah and and on top of that like the game forces you like if you complete a contract because we want to contract together and you didn't do a

thing to help me and we both completed it I still have to give you what you negotiated for yeah and so there's things in there that make it feel like going on anyway yeah not not important so that we ended up just establishing a lot of people have asked us to make a take that element in moonrakers they wanted to be able to kill people's ship parts they wanted to be able to hurt them take away Prestige and we added it in it worked like there wasn't anything mechanically wrong with it it just felt wrong which wasn't the spirit of the game interesting so we did a different expansion interesting it was one of the original Three we had Bonnie ties overload and that and we switched it that's what it was called and that yeah actually it was called um When You Do release ammunitions highest Munitions there's somebody releasing like five years it's just gonna be called in that one yep we have the project approaching Kickstarter now fractured sky is relearning failed Fates lessons let's see let's see so fractured Sky you all are advertising as uh yeah potentially your best game it is persons like dependent on the person I personally think this is our best game and I think that it will appeal to the most people and I am I am uh so I have two thoughts around around fractured Sky when it comes to that I think this could be my favorite from what you've released because of the accessibility combined with the the environment of play I'm talking an hour 15 minutes yeah amazing player interaction uh like I have a group coming over tonight to play uh some

spotter games no I want to teach them this game nice because it fits for a group that plays 18xx and Slaughter and at the same time I want to bring this back to like a group of people that love party games right and teach them this game because it fits so it's insanely accessible uh and really really well done I need to play it more to know if it's my favorite out of the lineup but if everyone might be the second thought I have is that I could see I could especially with the retail release of this I could see this being something that is is like an evergreen because of its footprint right it's it's one to five player window the box size how easy it gets to the table how easy it plays the only question is does your weird aesthetic and art grab people does it does it pull people in that's that's the only that's the only thing in my mind yep um so what are the lessons here what have we learned all right so remember when we talked about failed fate 10 minutes ago and it was you got to Kill Your Darlings apparently I didn't learn that lesson very well even though I remembered it from field fate in this game you were placing out three ship tokens and you have 10 troop power and you have to spread out that 10 true those 10 troops among your three airships I think it's a really interesting puzzle because you know the maximum that other players can have and you can deduce you can deduce where they might have within a range of a few yep well I had on your player board upgradeable buildings that you could build on your player board almost called the Wizards Tower and one was called the barracks the Wizards Tower lets you put out another Airship and so you can think of this as like a docking Tower or something four airships so you'd have

four airships so you could spread out your ten among the four what this allows you to do you'd be weaker but you could pick up points that were just kind of floating at no regions and more resources more regions and more resources the other one let you put out two more troops the barracks every Barracks you could buy three of these go from 10 to 12. yeah you'd go from 10 to 12. well suddenly you just were like looking and like looking at the board and you're like we've got four tokens and he's got 12 or 14 or 16 troops he could put up there it just lost all meaning that the ability to deduce was at such a high skill ceiling that it just wasn't importantly and you could Brute Force way more so instead of feeling like it was it was an approachable deduction yep you then just your brain just went ah yeah it was like I can never figure this out I either I'm gonna have to win this or I'm not I'm not going to come down to the tight very very satisfying victories where you played a seven they played a six yeah and they had one Tower right like that then that happens all the time right now yeah we see Victory on the the the we see Victory happening on the tiebreaker mechanic which is how quickly you you you end your whole cycle you see Victory happening on the difference between placing on a single point Airship yep uh we see Victory happening on uh objective on the objective on bluffing someone like going to a location and directing five of their troops there because you know that sucks away the resource they need somewhere else you did that to me that last game I did that to Evan that last game but it's all because you can deduce what you think is the math is right there you can think I think that's their 10 and these two are zeros but when it's four four or

five airships and 16 troops that that math just suddenly changes so this was another lesson in killing your darling it was killing Your Darlings I loved it it was so fun to be able to like just put 16 down somewhere because you got a ten to six people like I'll just never beat that I'm like yeah you won't but I was actually about one in my six yeah so I actually had seven there and I had ten somewhere else yeah or nine somewhere else so they couldn't tell us my ten and I loved that but it was so chaotic and you just couldn't deduce anything and it they were I had Robert um uh from our from our Discord it's one of our Discord mods he said you are playing mind games that you think you are playing and no one else is playing it's not it's like I wasn't even playing the games because no one was there with with me um and he's like and that's just not like simplifying it well loud for those head games and it did it did but I was really against it and once again in my own way this has been a lesson on uh why Austin Harrison is maybe not the best at his job no thank you for watching nobody all this all of this speaks to I think what people go through and work on any artistic or creative Endeavor you have your your thing that you have to create you have to get past the barrier of uh can I even do this and I equipped and I am I able am I smart enough or is this fun enough or is this you know and then and then you get to the point where you have to start trusting people around you you have to remove some of the things like people talk about it and authors talk about it all the time their favorite chapters get cut yeah because their chapter was so good it didn't fit for the rest of the story it didn't work it took away from everything else sometimes like the thing that you're

talking about could be amazing yeah but it doesn't mean it's right for the cohesive project they'll be able to see the whole garden not just like a really beautiful rose yeah and then you follow up with that and you start talking about how you have to trust the people that you're working with but it's not all about that yeah part of game design and part of any artistic creative process is also that initial process of saying I'm good enough to make this and I trust myself to do it and it's only from that standpoint that you can then say that can be removed this can be cut because you learn that in in numerators when you go back to it where you're looking at it and you're saying hey the heart of this game like that we created is that you're going on cool adventures with your friends you can screw them over but like it's not about blowing up other ships so that doesn't work you have to be a confident game designer to be able to recognize and look at a game and say this mechanic that is mechanically sound yeah and fun to play doesn't fit with what we've created which was hard because we spent a lot of time testing that one yeah so cool this is my conversation just super fun get to talk about all my personality flaws you guys you guys make awesome products um and I think people are interested in seeing what it means to make awesome products yeah people just see a product on the shelf and they think like oh that's like but they don't they don't have very good context for What it Took what the trial and error was and the fact that board games in a lot of ways are are in an artist artistic expression in the same way that novels and video games and and and paintings are yeah like this is this is a project of love that has math and numbers and algorithms behind it yep

some of them way more than others uh but still at the at the end of the day this is this is a work of art as well it's a handcrafted experience and if you're making a game it's gonna suck until it doesn't yeah all of our games sucked until they didn't yeah and maybe you think they still do that's okay two out of three isn't bad and on that note we'll see you next time see ya bye

Progress saved