Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 100: Thoughts on the Past, Present, and Future of Historical Gaming

Transcript 1:03:46

thank you it's ad time first off I want to remind you all that you can support the show at patreon.com Beyond Solitaire it would mean a lot to me and I've got some surprises in store for my patrons so I'll make it worth your while second the Beyond Solitaire podcast is proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations they've just wrapped up their Kickstarter campaign for Rising Waters which will be their second published game but check the landing page if you want to pledge late you should also have a look at their site for information about their certificate in applied game design which features upcoming classes from Eloy Le Santa lamara Smith and in a few months Yours Truly for now though let's get off the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and before we get on with the main show I just want to introduce podcast episode 100. the very first episode of this podcast aired in May of 2020 it is now December of 2022 and yes we have hit episode 100. I honestly cannot believe it this has been such a great ride this podcast has absolutely changed my life and introduced me to people I really care about and giving me a way to think about and talk about games that's brought me so much personal satisfaction so those of you who have been here for the whole ride or part of it I really appreciate it and I hope that we have many more episodes in the future to enjoy together but for now uh to celebrate episode 100 rather than have a traditional interview which is my usual podcast format I did a bunch of mini interviews with some favorite guests of the show so I hope

that you enjoy it we had lots of fun little conversations about historical gaming how it's developed since my podcast began and where we think it'll go in the next couple of years so stay tuned for the show enjoy all of my guests and I'll see y'all back here for season six all right everybody here we are with volca rinka he is a war game designer Aficionado hi everybody hi Liz hey how you doing welcome I'm doing very well loving life excellent it's so good to have you on the show again um I've always enjoyed our chats over the years and uh yeah yeah I wanted to talk about um how you see the state of historical games where we've been the last couple years and where are we now yeah I don't I you know I I don't have any shocker I I see a continuing trajectory and I won't say it straight line because it may be accelerating I I don't have the data to say but I mean that the general trajectory I do think is a uh a widening breadth of of of serious historical modeling in tabletop games and I why serious I don't mean uh difficult to master or Grim topics or anything like that but where a you know a central point of the game design is to take us somewhere in history and and we see that broadening and you know not only in terms of the number of games or the levels the number of Publishers the um different kinds of designers

different walks of life but what what interests me the most is just the breadth of topics but both the kinds of topics the places in the world we we visit and the kinds of situations we're looking at I I think I think we've seen what we were already seeing a few years ago this is not a you know any in any way a novel thought but I think what we're seeing is the Fulfillment of that Rising curve yeah I think that there's a lot to that and I feel like your own design work is also currently kind of undergoing some Evolution we all know you as Mr Coyne uh yes yeah but you know you've had nevsky and is it Alma Robert or Al moravid uh well it you take your pick it's an anglicization of a Spanish bastardization of Arabic so you know I don't know this as you like it's it's like vulco while I answered anything and I'm sure that you know you can love the game in many ways that's yes uh that's so that's right yeah so I have a a new series relatively new it's a few years now I guess um which is looking at um medieval military Affairs and specifically I'm aiming at the operational level meaning if the game is not about a single battle nor is the game about um High diplomacy and issues of War there there are Lords who are at war with each other uh more might join some might drop out and the main Affair is how you maneuver build and maneuver your armies levian campaign across the map so nevsky was was uh Russia and the Baltic

Frontier amaravit which came out earlier this year was uh the Iberian Peninsula so so the Spanish Christians versus the al-andalus Muslims and soon to come out is Inferno a co-design with uh Enrico cherby in Italy of uh the Tuscan um Warfare going on between towns and cities and Lourdes in the middle of 13 century dude that sounds so good do you feel like your own designs are also sort of evolving along with like the continued push into historical games or is this just a passion for you or you know or it has been a passion but I I am trying to in each case go someplace that is you know isn't is not just new to me because most projects take on I mean it's how I learn about something I'm you know I'm not an expert in it already you know I'm just researching as best I can um and and I want to do a you know a game that's not already out that's not just new to me but but new to the Hobby to bring something yeah to broaden to fill in a gap perhaps I mean there there are quite a few more um military game set in the last couple hundred years and then going way back more games set in ancient times than in you know the thousand 1500 years in between so levian campaign uh while it's not necessarily definitionally limited to the to the Middle Ages that's really where it

starts because there just aren't that many um military operational games in the latest so so that is a part of it all within military history and within war games and my this series as I would say if anything more war gamey um in terms of its topic and its focused than the coin series was which it was a bit higher level and therefore more political economic than these but it's wargamy in an in a chunk of History that you know does not have a lot of competition in it even then I'm starting out in Europe you know we're not just the way I grew up when I thought of medieval history I'm thinking of European settings but we have designs or at least projects underway they're outside that and readily I think we could do um Japan or Korea or um or India or even the new the new world pre-columbus oh that sounds really good and then just a real final question I'm asking we're going to assume that my podcast is going to make it all the way to 200 episodes if you can do 100. uh so that'll be about 2 years maybe two and a half from now where do you see our branch of the hobby going over the next couple of years and what's what do you think your place yes well I it's pretty easy to predict well not easy it's it's less fraught to predict my own future because I do have a plan we have so many projects working this series I have another series I have in mind for that you know so if I

I don't know the exact shape of it but if I achieve what I'm doing I already know that I'm going to be extending levian campaign series and and have a uh another series that's got a historical Focus after that uh the broader hobby you know again this is not a very daring prediction but I think we have seen I mean if there's any argument still that oh electronic games are going to supplant tabletop games uh I I have to question whether that theorist has their eyes open because we have fretted about that now for four decades um you know two-thirds of my life and it's never come to pass and what we've seen is that the two uh General Media feed each other and board gaming continues to grow more players more um talented designers and more high quality Publishers every year and so as as generally as sales grow and and we see more and more Young Folks come into the hobby uh you know you know what else could have is there what is it what would it be you know what would the scenario be and when in which suddenly oh that's it we've reached the end you know there's no more room to broaden what we include in board games there are no more players out there you know that's it we're stagnating I just don't see that happening I see the opposite I see

acceleration and again I don't think that's necessarily a daring prediction to make for just a you know a couple years out in the future but the only question for me is is there any kind of larger effect is there a Breaking Dam you know is there you know we had limitations by tradition or by um cloistering of our gaming communities or whatever that um you know that now washes you know that the flood washes over the dam if you will and and we get more mixing of different forms different topics different gaming communities and uh and we get in even greater acceleration than you know just the upward curve that I I think we can can fairly confidently say has been happening last few years and and suddenly we see we're to the point of we're filling in gaps and there and and it's not the case that we say yeah they're just a zillion games on this particular historical setting and almost nothing over here and it gets harder and harder to identify gee you know um you know yeah we do have a number of of cool new games that are set on this continent in this Century about this aspect of humanity you know whatever it is economic political or military yeah I I don't disagree I actually I I also I'm hoping and I believe that we're

going to see growth I think we're going to see more kind of parts of the hobby overlapping with each other and I think we're gonna see more Gamers exploring different areas of the Hobby and I hopefully I think it's all going to be good that's it's one of the things I am optimistic about at this time yeah me too me too I I do think it's going great well thank you so much for coming on welcome I know that we'll have you on again uh at some point in Seasons but it's always good to check in thanks so much well thanks uh joy for me to visit and thank you for your work that you're doing for the community hey

100th episode and also talk about historical gaming where it's been where it's going so how you do Jason yo my people's what's up well uh congratulations on 100 podcast uh it's been a really fun ride uh so you know uh you're doing a season so I didn't so you're taking a little bit longer than I thought you would because you did you take the brakes every little while don't take any breaks whatsoever Liz just keep rolling no you'll be at 200 in no time no slow and steady wins the race there you go and I feel like that's true and the the Long March of history as well so um so we've talked a lot about historical games over the last couple years on this podcast so you want to recap like some of the conversations that we have had uh so I'm not much of a war gamer you have some other guests that are going to talk about the wargaming aspect of it I'm more uh cooperative and uh Euros so Euro history gaming still in a difficult Place uh unfortunately we had our conversation station so this is a retrospective episode please refer to one of the best conversations that I've had about this stuff the historical tourism episode this happened I think in season four yeah I think it's early season like episode 61 or 62. right uh wow you actually remember the numbers fantastic uh yeah that was one of the best episodes we've done because I think it we really were able to distill what happened what is happening to the history through the prism of eurogame and Euro game uh at least as they're

developed now have their uh they have their own thing that they're doing they're not intending to present history they're presenting they're tending to leverage history uh for the benefit of sales and we're still like you know that what that conversation wasn't that long ago uh and you know since then you know Puerto Rico 1898 should be out at this point oh he's 97 sorry about that definitely not 1898. Screw The Americans uh so like I put my hat in the ring in terms of where historical gaming should go on that end our you know will companies follow suit I mean so I I'm hopeful that that project gets attention it gets sales and then that because that's what Publishers listen to at the end of the day they listen to Market forces they will put out what people will buy and you got to show them you gotta do cool projects and and do and you know go and go in that direction but we're talking about like where where we are now uh I mean Yucatan was a project from this past year and what are the you know what are the Mayans doing the Mayans are sacrificing you know uh they're sacrificing you know people bodies and all kind of stuff that's like a central feature of the game not a central feature of my Society it this it's just like there for attention and sales uh there was a a very recent game about another Mesoamerican game that just came out of Kickstarter I've got a message about it I went on to Facebook groups and what are the mesoamericans doing it's a war game and they're tribal Warriors and you know they have all sculpts are you know headdresses and

Spears and okay and so you asking about uh you know what development have we had 10 years ago they would have all been naked now they have a consultant on there to actually get some more resonant you know dress so that develop has happened but I still think we're in the Paradigm we're still in the general Paradigm of native Savages so we start so there's been a little bit of change surface change uh you know presentation change skin deep diversity as Skin Deep that has changed but we need to start really shifting some paradigms if we can really say we're making progress as a copy in the historical gaming space is there hope for the future shelf stories GBL on Twitter uh shellstorygbl.com uh cultural Consulting uh I am going to be uh what are the what's the Gandhi quote be the change you want to see in the world absolutely so I I'm hoping to Gandhi my way through some change in the board gaming space but if there wasn't hope I wouldn't bother so I there is hope yes fantastic and I hope we're together for many more seasons to keep track of it over the next hopefully lots of years yeah I'm looking forward to it thanks for always being on here Jason have interesting conversations and push that envelope thank you historically culturally it's good to have you all right everybody we are back with David Thompson a favorite guest of the show who has been on every single season how you doing David hey good as always thanks for having me so

let's have a quick look back over some of the things on the show you've been on some of which are still um the fifth platoon uh where where do you feel like you've been with historical games in the past couple years since we've started this project me personally huh yeah um oh goodness well both of those are still very much in work right those are like passion projects that are kind of always on the on the back burner uh behind something that's on contract so um yeah I think that my interest in um in historical gaming right so let's let's not say we're gonna let's just say historical gaming um it's definitely as strong as it's ever been I think the only thing that I would say that maybe is a little bit different and I see this as both myself as a designer and a gamer is I'm I'm becoming more and more interested in non-war historical gaming right so uh that now that's not a place that I've personally designed in in the past right um and maybe not as comfortable with and I don't mean like comfortable like topically I mean more like my capabilities to work in that space um but I think it's interesting and it's something I'd like to explore more for sure refer to all of that War slash historical are going I guess kind of within our hobby space and also in terms of the kinds of topics we're covering and conversations we're having yeah you know I was thinking about this when you said that uh you wanted to have a chat about

this topic and it's hard for me to know whether what I perceive where it's going it has to do with me and like my world view and what I'm interested in and so my perception is different or if it's genuinely different from my perspective it seems like um in the last like say three to five years there's been this growth and maturity of the historical Gaming Community right and so what I mean by that is um especially on on like the diversity of topics right and so there's always been games that have this sort of concept of a historical topic right and there were some that were deeper than others um but oftentimes they were like there were Euros with like honestly pasted on themes right um but but it seems like you know we've we're starting to go beyond games like Watergate or 13 gauge which I think are great I love those games um to maybe part of this is like the Zenobia award and the community is formed around it but you know now when I when I look at the games that I've got on the way games that I've backed recently and I look at stuff like Stonewall Uprising and free at last and votes for women I'm like wow this is at a pretty amazing time for historical gaming right and so um again maybe that's just my perception my interests that are sort of clouding my you know my judgment but that's what I'm excited about that's where I think we may be going and if that's right if we're if we're heading in this world of

like more more historical games that are truly based on the history and trying to evoke key historical moments especially with the diversity of topics that's something I'm super excited about yeah Sam I mean I think you know there's always a long way to go there's always more that we can do to make our hobby richer and more inclusive and more interesting um but I think that we've really had a good last couple of years and I think it's only going to get better personally I'm also really interested in maybe in the kind of mix of gaming genres that we're seeing you know even in our earliest conversations you and I talked about things like Wars and War games and historical games with more accessible mechanisms for hobby Gamers uh how do you see that developing and continuing to develop yeah I think that I think that as we see first of all a lot of the games I just mentioned I'm excited about are coming from smaller Publishers right so thankfully the you know the barrier entry continues to be pretty pretty uh small right and so these small Publishers can do a lot of exploring another game that I'm super excited about that that falls right in line with what you're talking about is Halls of hegra right which is coming in from a smaller smaller publisher it's a solitaire war game that's a Euro hybrid I mean it's just you start to sound pretty Niche when you're talking about these combinations of things but it's doing real you know it did really well and it's crowdfunding and um it's about a pretty obscure topic and so again I feel like we're the sort of golden age at least in terms of choice and like accessibility of really interesting topics and the way in which they're

they're fused from a game mechanism perspective and I just see like I see this this sort of um crossover between war games and Euro games like it's just gonna grow especially it's going to help grow the the war game and historical game side of the hobby that's exactly what I personally am hoping to see uh do you think there's anything bad about a departure from the word I guess traditional hex encounter games of old I mean those are still being made of course yeah well I think I think you just you just sort of answered your own question like if so I'm I I play hex encounter games it's not my favorite solid game I'll play them uh I think some are great uh I think just like any other game there's plenty of them that are made that aren't that great but if if we were starting to see the decline of those like if less were being made or whatever then you could argue that's a problem but that's not the case right like there's plenty of those being made um and they're being made by big Publishers and they're getting decent print runs and they're high quality so like no I don't think it's a like why would that you know if you're a hex encounter gamer you know just because other games are being made if you can still get some interesting games about topics you care about and the you know using the systems you like then I think the more the better from my lips to God's ears but what do you think is going to happen gonna happen episode 200 oh you know that's a good question so um that's a great question what do I think

is going to happen hopefully we just see more growth right we see more uh it's I would like us to get to a point where when we see a historical topic covered in a game that we can okay let me use my words do you know you remember maybe like five to ten years ago when you would see an IP game come out you're like Ugh an IP game you know it's not going to be good it's going to be just a cash crap pasted on theme and that's not the case anymore right like you you basically see an IP game and you would just assess it like any other game I think hopefully what we'll see is that when we see historical topics um we we don't think like oh this is just going to be a paste it on theme Euro that just stole a historical theme like the expectation is no Publishers understand that you know we we should treat historical topics as the important topics they are and expect that this is going to be a good game it's going to be well researched by the designer they're going to engage with you know historical um experts when the you know for the design so hopefully we just see the maturity there and then especially important I hope that we see the success of some of these games that we're talking about spur on more and more diversity of topics and you know and by extension I think diversity of the designers right so I think the zenobi award has proven that there's um something there right so that that Publishers even even Publishers who understandably like their their big concern is will the game sell can say oh

actually there's there's something here fantastic David thanks so much for coming out as always I hope to have you on every season the first many seasons as we get absolutely yeah thanks for having me all right so now we're here with Emma Bella Holland we're my absolute favorite guests of the show historical game designer extraordinaire how you doing well I'm doing great so uh you've been on the show a couple of times uh you want to kind of look back on some of the fun things we've talked about such as inappropriate Church fathers and other historical games yeah we definitely definitely have thought yeah I was on to talk about uh my game nice here I think that was the first interview I did after the name changed so that was pretty neat um and we've talked about some some Roman stuff I yep those are things we talked about and absolutely so what are you doing right now in terms of historical gaming like what's what's up in Collegeville at this exact moment in time in this exact moment the so I I took a little break from like the heavy historical games because through this whole puberty thing a second time over and it takes a lot of bandwidth um but the next one that we have on the docket that fits in the historical mold is my game endurance which is about the Shackleton expedition in 1914 to

Antarctica which went very wrong and I'm very excited about that one because actually I've been working on that often on for years like for as long as we've been homeless people I've been working on that so I finally I'm getting that to come together as a solitary game and um I'm really excited for that one actually because it's uh uh you know I I feel like with historical games there's a lot of focus on the war games on on the battles and the shooting stuff and so to do something that's not really about that uh I I think is an interesting direction for me to do so yeah I'm absolutely excited about it um and I guess I wanted to ask so you know one of hollinsfield's biggest points of Pride right is that y'all get to make whatever games you want very quirky games um and that's that's something that's like a badge of honor uh do you see the historical gaming Market shifting towards more unique topics over the next couple of years or do you think that Huntsville is going to remain kind of out at the frontier of interesting game design historically speaking well I certainly hope that overall there's a shift because there's only an appetite for it and there are certainly a lot of

new and exciting voices and ideas and perspectives and I would like to have those please on my table but whether there are things that we publish or not um I like to see larger Publishers take chances on more unusual things because they I mean they do they do and they can sell you know um and there are people who are hungry for it so you know why why not and and I'm really interested in what games can do as a form and I feel like you're gonna get more movement in that direction especially stretching it more when you're engaging with more unusual themes or more uh unusual uh approaches to themes than you are when you're doing you know roll on the CRT and apply this rain bonus sort of thing and they'll shade on those I I do those too you know and then they'll sell as well but

um now that your Antarctic game is kind of truly coming to fruition uh what are some topics that you think you might want to touch on next uh so the the big one that's kind of on the horizon for me it's a historical game is doing a game about the way the tobacco industry used misinformation to fight against uh efforts to oppose their you know influence and their their spread and that's something that's very important to me is someone who's lost people to lung cancer and whatnot um and so that's like that's the big ambitious thing on on the horizon that's historically based I'm also got some like science fiction stuff which is new for me too it's very unusual I'm I'm doing I'm doing a game about uh transplanted biker gang called gridlock I'm very excited about that uh we'll see how that goes um but yeah that's that definitely that that's the big like serious game because every year we try to do like a big end of year game this year it's it's a game about uh dinosaurs or any train company so maybe it's it's less historically based

Mary is shot she's looking at me with shock that I would dare suggest that's less historically based uh um you know and uh and we had some games from other designers that you know are in the docket there's a solitaire game uh from Brad Smith who did um NATO air Commander for us he's doing he did a game called um That Others May Live which is about combat search and rescue operations ooh Vietnam so that's a topic you have not really seen in a game before and uh he spent quite a long time working on that and we had Ryan heilman uh who designed bravewell Belgium come on as a developer to really like get it exactly the way we needed it and get it so it really supports Brand's vision and I'm really excited to get that out finally sometime next year fantastic and so since you're here for episode 100 of Beyond Solitaire hopefully I'm just gonna assume that we're gonna hit episode 200. yeah do you have that'll be about two issues from now do you have any um predictions for where historical gaming will be then

I I feel like if I don't come up with a prediction it's like not in the spirit of the thing at the same time like I'm very bad at predicting things like if you asked me like three years ago to predict like what my name would be will I be getting up to I I wouldn't predicted any of that right so like I'm I'm I do not pretend that I know anything or can guess anything I think uh 200th episode will be awesome but that's been true that'll be true of the 199 episodes previous so I mean that's not really much of a prediction fair enough well I will get born too when I was Phil has coming up next and I hope to have you as a guest on my podcast many many more times thanks for coming on Emma Bell all right everybody I'm now here with Cole Worley the one the only designer of pax Premiere and uh John company which is fulfilling uh right now actually no it's well we'll okay by the time this airs which is fulfilled recently yes yeah hopefully most people have it by the time it says yes let's hope because it's a few weeks from now it remains one of my favorites we had a really good conversation about um gaming as a historical statement and it was really really interesting for me um my abiding podcast thesis is that

games have something to say so um what is your what's your current take on the state of historical games and games or something to say well I think that they we're in a place of real strength I mean I I just got for instance in the mail yesterday uh the red Bernice uh by um hit him with a shoe and his name of the company company I've never heard I'd never heard of before I played the game this is a game about 19th century Algeria it's a Cooperative um Deck Builder and it is a you know it's a beautiful production with Innovative mechanisms about a subject I know very little about and what a delight it is to just encounter something like that in the mail and I was recently uh wandering around uh the halls of Essen and I ran into Publishers um working in areas that I hadn't seen done before both from different parts of the world and different subjects of course those things go hand in hand I saw an amazing Korean publisher uh that had a number of games about the North South Korean divide uh that were tremendously moving uh and including a game that was sort of a riff on a kind of memory almost guess who guessing game but it was entirely about the reunification of North and South Korean families it was it was so powerful and also Publishers from India who were doing fascinating things and also relying on local printing so I mean the way I think about historical games right now is we seem to be getting more of everything all at once in the best in the best way

um and so you know uh looking at the more traditional wargaming Publishers gmt's out put right now is like never been as broad uh or as deep the fact that we can be looking forward to so many games in the levy and campaign series while they're also branching out and I know one of the games I'm most anticipating is the Cross Bronx Expressway same um I cannot wait uh and so this is just a great time like finally I feel like the fever dream of games about Panzer Blitz have has broken um and and I it it feels very empowering to um to walk around and just see such fascinating subjects being tackled by a huge range of people yeah I'm kind of feeling like um we're in a golden age hopefully to go platinum here what is the story exactly exactly I mean I I I um I want whatever's Happening Now needs to keep happening right and so I'm really hoping that um really hoping that a lot of these smaller companies are just starting to have every success in the world I just had a chance to play uh 1979 um I think it's Dan Bullock who did that the uh the idea about the revolution Iran fascinating design very interesting publisher and I hope they sell every copy they print and I hope they have to keep printing it because I it's exactly the sort of game that I would love to see more of uh in in the in the broader environment yeah absolutely and I know people you know people love you for roots in your work with leader games but um what are you up to in the historical gaming sphere right now so John company has made it out of the world it exists

um it's a real thing that that exists um I uh it was a real it was a difficult press I think I've never worked on a game that big or hard and I want to do other games like it but it's going to be a bit uh so right now I am working on a couple games um the I'm working on the the new edition of Infamous traffic and then uh because John company took so much work to do uh we're actually hoping to publish some games that I didn't design next and so we have a Zenobia uh finalist who I I've been working with on a really fascinating design I was a joke game I can't say nothing oh come on I'm Betty Molly house it's a good bet uh but I I worked with a lot of the finalists and I and I'll say that um each of the finalists that I worked with could have been eminently published uh I mean it was just it was something that could certainly happen um but I'm really excited about the one that we're working on and we are in a spot where I'm basically I the design itself is solidifying it's like getting ready for testing I'm hoping uh that if anyone is at San Diego historicon uh in in a few weeks you'll be able to play it because I should have a prototype copy with me I I have a good sense of how the product profile is going to look and we need to announce it because I need to find artists and there's no better way to find artists than to say hey I'm working this project I need help and so we've been kind of like back channeling and finding people to talk to to work on the art but we haven't found the right person quite yet uh and then we've got a

really interesting City Builder and some other games that are kind of in the hopper that we're also working on uh and I I just can't wait to share to share more about it so hopefully like early next year we will have a crowdfunding campaign all set up for it yes I'm very excited to hear all of this and you know just keep this short so we made it to episode 100 of my podcast and I'm just gonna go out there and say I'm gonna make it to 200 episodes and that'll be if if if I continue my current Pace that'll be somewhere between two and two and a half years from now so where do you see historical gaming going between now and episode 200. I think we're gonna be in a place where you're going to be in I think that you talked to the very beginning about the importance of thinking about games as arguments and I think that hopefully you know 100 episodes in the argumentation of games is going to be as important as anything else and we're going to be moving through these games like we were moving through arguments I think the state of the discourse right now sometimes still gets stuck in the kind of like sticky gooey fun mechanical language which is fine because it's interesting but I think that you know you're gonna have guests on your on your show you're going to have an interesting conversation you're gonna have debates about these games and find yourself talking about almost everything but the game and the way that when you listen to a good movie podcast it's all the context it's all the the pressures that are going on the game so that I would love to see that I'd love to see the state of the discourse kind of keep Galloping forward um because Lord knows there's plenty of

other podcasts that are mostly focused on those other things and I just I want to see I mean I I have loved and I also want to see more interviews from you keep interviewing every interesting person in in this industry they are fabulous fabulous talks for now we'll see um I will thank you so much for your time it's always great to have you on your call thank you very much Liz all right now we are checking in with Christian hinz one of my absolute favorite guests of all time she was on episode 20. how you doing Christian I'm doing great I'm so glad to see you and to be here again with you because you are now the director of of Zenovia award yes so let's recap what that is and I want to just kind of hear about what we're doing with it in the future the zenobi award is a mentoring competition um to help um underrepresented game designers of History tabletop games uh up there game design chops and uh be prepared at the end be prepared to see their game ideas picked up by developers and Publishers um and so that's what we do is we have a whole system of uh in what people apply to the program to the award to the competition we walk them through a Concepts all the way down to prototyping and game testing over the course of a year

um and then uh when if you can make it all the way through to the end then the chances are close to the end even the chances of you know uh of your game being really ready to be uh presented to a publisher is very very high and we have lots of contacts so that people are able to have their work seen last year we had many many games that were picked up and published or in process of publishing now that was very successful and people got a lot out of it so we're looking to make this an institution like every two years we're going to have the Zenobia award competition mentoring program it's both it's not just a competition it's competition and mentoring yes and I personally got so much satisfaction of getting to interview all the finalists this last go around and yeah the number one question was is there going to be another one I hope there's another one when can we do this again so we are going to do it again and that is going to be 2023 is that correct 20 23. excellent and what um I know that you've been thinking really deeply about improvements to make to the process so I'd like you to speak about that for a couple minutes because I think reflection is always a good thing well one of the things that really worked well um was the workshopping of using like um the tabletop simulators like the you know teaching people how to move their game uh into a kind of a digital space so that it could be seen and test played by a lot of people and that worked really really well what we'd like to do is create similar kind of workshopping

opportunities for every phase of the project so there may be many many people who you know have great game ideas but have never written a game proposal um and you know writing something is actually very intimidating I'm a professional academic so writing is not something that intimidates me but if if you had a lousy High School experience writing and someone asks you okay we're going to write a proposal it has to do these kinds of things that may be overwhelming so we want to Workshop that we want to rock Workshop pitches we want to Workshop these various stages so so that people have a chance to practice have a community of people to like look at each other's work and offer comments so that nobody's working in isolation on any particular piece of the process so that's one part one thing that we're going to be working on that's so cool and then the other reason I love talking to you is frankly you were a badass in the classroom because you design all these really great games for your students you game world history so uh what is your perspective on pedagogy and gaming and you know where that's going in the future and how it's been developing since we last spoke so I have encountered more and more um more and more academics or Educators that's better to say it that way because Educators don't I mean this is like K through 16 or whatever right um who have dabbled with game-based learning in the classroom

um who have tried to use gamification in the classroom and encountered all the stumbling blocks right um and they're aware there's an increasing awareness that okay um something I'm doing isn't making it work the way I'd hoped which is a really good starting place any experiment right this is how it works okay and so there's more interest in talking about how to teach using games how to leverage gamification to create intrinsic motivation um in order to make it an effect these are make them into effective tools effective pedagogies which is really hopeful for me because you know when I first got into this people were treating games and gamification kind of like well like magic like oh hey my my students are going to be engaged as if engagement is the only thing that that that's like that's the only measure right so I'm I'm really pleased uh because that means there's an audience for me to to speak into um you know 10 years of designing and deploying and assessing um you know all of that gives me a lot of ideas about how I can be helpful um and that people are hungry to hear it they're not going like well I tried this game I tried to I try to use a game in a classroom and it was a disaster and so I'm just throwing the pedagogy away right it's like okay how do I use this okay that's a great question so I'm hopeful excellent and then so this is gonna be

for episode 100. I'm gonna guess it's gonna be two years and change until we hit episode 200. so what do you think could happen between now and that episode 200 that will certainly exist in the future I think that game-based pedagogy in the social sciences and Humanities will be much more common so it's not a strange thing to see it in business uh and business programs it's not a strange thing to see it in any of the kind of you know production education like engineering or that's not strange at all it's strange to see it in social sciences and Humanities and I think that actually social sciences and Humanities are a brilliant place to do it because we're interested in The Human Condition right we're interested in The Human Experience and then games allow imaginative empathy which lots of times students come to a history class and have no capacity to really find a way to empathize with the problems and the the concerns and you know the difficulties of The Human Experience in the past right and it's not that you can ever fully understand uh or empathize with people in the past but to understand what was motivating people stand in their shoes for a second simulation can give people an inkling like oh this is that was about right and then we're much more connected to each other as people if we can empathize if

we can simulate each other's lives right so I'm I'm thinking that it's going to work but that's my intention to make it work I'm with you on that and this is a feature that I very much hope to see thank you so much for coming on just to check in well thanks for popping in to see how I'm doing great to see you too hey I'm here with Sebastian Bay he is the wargamer extraordinaire and teaches war games at Georgetown and it's a favorite friend of the gaming industry how you doing Sebastian hey I'm doing great thank you for having me on here Liz yeah so we were checking the dates like we talk all the time now but I did not realize that you were on the show in 2020. yeah that seems like forever ago like pre-pandemic times I'm just like oh my God what was life like in 2020 uh I was alone in my house making me podcast it's okay I was like that was when I started making the trouble Commander alone in my house you know what I mean so I remember it seems like a forever ago I think I'm literal Commander um how have things gone for you since you were last on the show it seems like you've got a lot of game designs like a lot of irons in the fire so give us the rundown so a lot of irons in the fire uh in the sense so literal matter just went to the printer last week this week I don't know time has lost all meaning uh so very recently has gone to the printer for final proof and then it is off to like full production after uh we make sure everything is aligned right and so forth uh because who does not like you're in those counters that are like misprinted and you're like ah right so we don't we

want to avoid those kind of things but the total commanders pretty much all wrapped up the rule book is posted on Board Game Geek and we're I'm like super super excited about it because um it's been a two-year project uh it went it was out in the fleet and the Marine Corps for a while as a prototype that I made like literally like 95 copies by hand um and like Columbia blocks has like our Columbia games by the number of Columbia blocks I bought like like I spend a small fortune but it was really great because that whole process of sending out those prototypes and getting feedback from the Marines and the Navy and so forth was really enlightening because it allowed me to not only adapt the game but see how much demand there was right to the point that I was like I can't keep up right um it wasn't like oh there's like 30 people like there were people I had to like turn away constantly so I was like hey let's try to make this into a commercial game but also one of the things is that um I wanted it to be able to be accessible to normal people and to see like hey this is the kind of War games we do that are future oriented that take some analytical rigor and applied research and also like explain how we go about it so recently I've been sort of updating my designer Journal was supposed to be like two pages and now has like grown to be like six to like seven pages um of saying like hey where did the game come from what are some of the major things and why did I design the game the way it did because those are some of my favorite features of like the old SPI Avalon Hill games of those remember those like short like descriptions all like this is why we did it this way and

this is why activation works this way and so forth right so if you disagree with the game you at least know why right why I did it the way I did um and like even the maps we put so much math into it like Matt Kramer who's like this recently graduated uh undergrad um from the University of Oregon he did so much math with me on arcgis of like terrain features and doing analysis of geography and Mobility like just to produce the map that like prior to the normal game designer does understand right I wanted to highlight like hey like these colors are just not like random that I looked on Google Maps and stuff right we did a lot of great rigor and Analysis into it and we're like hey do we need to proof this I mean we're like what is our methodology and we did it systematically um that's just one of the ways we did it same thing with our combat values so I'm super excited um now Jim uh of the Diaz Foundation is like hey what about the sequel I was like uh give me like I don't know a month to like decompress um but um we're already started talking about what will uh the sqls will be so we're looking towards Europe and sort of the baltics is where I'm looking at the baltics and the high North I think are our two choices um and then that will have a new batch of units right like potentially some Army units and other Marine Corps units to be involved so very exciting and then uh if you guys have not talked to Emily yet or heard to her episode on uh Beyond Solitaire she's great she is absolutely a fantastic professional war game designer out of ran and we're working on our influence game on the line and she's

been running around all of Europe actually running it so I'm super excited about that and hopefully we'll find some way either on gamecrafter or some other means to get into the hands of people who are especially universities that want to look at influence operations and media literacy and that's really Our Hope and then I have a couple other like nascent designs um along with some other designers like P Pellegrino out of the naval war College uh he and I have a pet project looking at Naval kill chains that is looking at cards so we want to make it like a really fast version of like a car based game that requires no maps and just sort of like um is able to be played on a ship or anywhere uh without you know maybe big setups and rules and stuff so that has been uh the new project that I'm proud pivoting after literal Commander right now so those are the three pet projects and then I've been really keen on like getting my uh my junior designers at work to work on like micro games like those postcard games uh so that's been really exciting so three of them are making some uh for the center for Naval analysis at work for the state department some non-proliferation games so that's really exciting oh my gosh you've got so much going on it all sounds great so um my my last question for you for this interview then is what do you think the current state is you know I normally ask about historical giving but I'll ask about wargaming for you what's the what's the currency of wargaming including professional War gaming and where do you think it's going to be in two years when I hit episode 200 of this podcast we're gonna see if we're gonna make it yeah so yeah I think in episode

200 you'll see a lot of new designers right uh but especially on the professional side so I always refer to our current period as like the age of Titans right so like uh we like all right on the professional side particularly and even on the commercial side you have all these huge names that shaped our field especially in not only historical gaming but like War gaming right like you have volca rookie right Jason Matthews right um David Thompson you have Peter Perla on the professional side who literally wrote the book like the art of wargaming right he's still like I saw him in the office like earlier this week um and then and Barney Ruble who was just on the podcast for Georgetown right like these guys were the chairs and like really forged the wargaming community on the professional side and and they're so round right but they are slowly all retiring uh and they're leaving their Mark right and um I think as that generational shift happens right they'll see more voices more New Perspectives new people like Emily really rising to the Forefront to fill that vacuum as they become not only publish commercial games on like historical or wargaming topics but also professionally right um and I think the pool of applicants for you for the next hundred episodes will grow right so so it's not just me and others right that um that I love right but I think the podcast can look forward to a lot new voices and faces to get familiar with as they come up through the ranks right and it's really exciting like we have three young really talented Junior

designers who are very green still right um but they're uh really good they're really talented and see Bright Futures for them and I'm excited to where they will be in two years and during two more years that's what I mean what four more classes of students that I will teach at Georgetown right and each averaging about 12. so like you know hopefully one or two of them from each semester will will come out to our John R field so it's really exciting it's um I think it is that great pivot point of like the voices that you know right and find comfort in and and uh but then I think it's the excitement of finding new voices that we haven't heard from and I think the pool of our games will also increase right so one of the things we were just talking about before the podcast was this is Nobi Award right some of the things I love about is like opening the aperture of what uh wargaming is and the styles that we bring to it right um but also the topics that we explore right so I love a good Napoleon game like anyone else right and I love a good war or two game but also I think is the interesting elements of just like hey I was just reading and talking to a colleague uh down at a military pme school and he was talking about like the African experiences in the World War II right in the colonies and serving in in uh in the Allied powers or and so forth I was like wow that's a really interesting story and like African uh history is not really my forte so I learned a lot and he was talking about like yeah you know like there'll be great games to look at this stuff and I was like we're talking we're just sort of like spitballing I think those kind

of Notions will expand our pool right for our perspectives of history but our our perspectives and agency about games and how we interact with them right because I think it's really important about what Stories We Tell right and what Stories We engage with fantastic I will be looking forward to what happens over the course the next couple years then and Sebastian thanks so much for coming on it's always wonderful to hear from you all right thank you Liz all right so we're here with Dan thurow you may also know him as space Biff he is a board game review writing extraordinaire how you doing I'm doing all right how are you Liz I'm too great so delightful to talk to you always um so I brought you on because you're just one of my favorite guests over the run of the podcast oh thank you that's nice to be someone's favorite at something uh and also because you are you're known for reviewing games that have something to say so I guess I wanted to touch base with you about what is the current state of your reviewing life as somebody who's interested in games that have a point to make that's a great question uh especially because I feel like we're in kind of a sweet spot to be honest you know for a long time I I feel like games was something to say fell into basically the camp of this a message game you know and there was that big controversial example there's Brenda Romero's train right like this is not an actual functioning game it's a gotcha it's there to shock you and it's there to trick you and in a way

it perpetuates kind of a myth you know in the process but message games uh and games that are trying to uh games with a thesis message game is kind of a bad word isn't it like I hear message game and I kind of clench up but nowadays I think that there are a lot of games with a thesis and some of them are pretty solid um and more and more I think what we're seeing is games are becoming more accessible um games are becoming a little more thoughtful and and this is this I couldn't be happier uh with where games are right now in terms of that I don't think it's perfect I don't think it's perfect at all but I think we're on a really good trajectory you know um like here's an example so I I don't know if you've played Cole Worley's John company um not yet not yet so I think it's shipping I think a lot of people are finally getting their copy right now and for the second edition and when and that thing was funding I remember some people on Twitter throwing a fit because they're going oh it's another you know colonialism game it should be re-themed and you know there's always that tension especially with making a game about a hard topic where are you going to come across as advocating for this topic as opposed to challenging the topic being about the topic and but now it's coming out and I feel like all these people are going to get to experience a game that is distinctly anti-colonial despite embracing many of the trappings of colonial games and I'm

so excited because it's a Masterwork and we're seeing so many games like this that are tackling tough topics uh they're doing it thoughtfully some of them are pretty light I like I was telling you before I'm playing this wonderful little ditty of a game called persuasion which is you know it it's just about toxic Regency Era dating and it's wonderful it's wonderful and it wallows in that toxicity and it highlights it to you and there's no way to come out of this game like oh these are great relationships you come out going man these these relationships were garbage and and we're seeing this as you know these things that previously were sort of like either crappy message games or they were difficult to access war games and that barrier of Entry is just coming down and the quality of them is going up and I I think we're in a great place that's my weatherman answer to my podcast it took me about two and a half years to get to that point congratulations thank you so let's we're gonna assume that I'm gonna make it to fifteen hundred so in another couple of years uh if I was gonna ask this question again what do you think the answer will be like where do you see things going in our in our historical games games of the thesis world over the next couple years I don't I you know I think I think in

let's see so another two and a half years I think we're going to be living with flying cars we're gonna be everyone will have a palace we will have cured disease uh our historians are bad at telling the future can you tell um I hope I don't know I hope or uh I hope we're still on that trajectory two and a half years isn't very long I mean some of the games that are in production now will still they might be barely coming out in two and a half years um I hope we're I hope we're still being thoughtful you know because I think there is the potential and this is this is something I'm concerned about there's always the potential for things to backslide a bit um like I just very recently I wrote about a game uh by Taylor schust uh Stonewall Uprising which I think is actually a pretty good it's a good game as well as having a message to it and um it was interesting the that there was some pushback to it you know like people were oh I don't want to play a game about that um and I hope we're not seeing too much of that uh but I think that's something that we as designers and critics and interviewers that we need to be a little cognizant of so that's not so much a prediction as it is just a maybe a guard rail is I I'm I'm afraid that we will see some push back to message games I think there's a loud contingent that wants their games to be

frivolous play things and nothing else um and we don't need that binary a game can be fun and it can be insightful we don't need to we don't need to cut off half of what a game can be in service of gameplay but I think unfortunately there are those who would do that yeah I do think that's a risk but I also do think I mean I'm hoping that with things like the Zenobia word and yeah with an influx of games that are I think that I think what you're saying about games being more accessible and more thoughtful at the same time might be the Saving Grace here um because more access means a broader potential audience which means that naysayers will be part of that audience but not enough to overwhelm it yeah well no I I'm you know just I think it was today I got uh an email from Dr Heinz that we're we're gearing up for the second uh go through of the Zenobia award and I I just couldn't be more excited you know some of the games that came out of that first year were still waiting on seeing them release uh but having gotten to play some of them and talk to the designers and go through the mentorship process uh you know it it unlocked so much talent that otherwise wouldn't have been highlighted and I think people are are going to be really quite pleased with what came out of it yeah I mean I

mean but uh blue years in gaming if and nothing else yeah me too on the whole indeed uh and I ended episode 100 yen thank you and congratulations again that's awesome 100 come to an end but that is hardly the end of this podcast I'm gonna go on break for a little bit and then before you know it I'll be back with more interviews more interesting conversations about gaming and hopefully more awesome interactions with y'all everybody who's been here for this podcast in any way who's ever listened to an episode message me about it asked a question on Twitter every single one of you thank you so much uh and most of all happy gaming

Progress saved