Ecosystem: Coral Reefππ - Card drafting/placement, like Ecosystem?
Transcript
Hi, it's Tarrant. And Stella from Meeple University. Welcome to our review of Coral Reef Ecosystem Coral Reef. Yes. This is the follow-up uh to the game Ecosystem, which was released a couple years ago now. Must be a few years ago now, actually. I think we played it at at PAX, which must have been pre uh pre-COVID. So, they both are all really um published by Genius Games. And Ecosystem plays two to six players. Ecosystem Coral Reef plays two to six players with solo variant and two player variant. So, it's a bit different and um obviously different theme and so on. We're going to do a novel review of Ecosystem Coral Reef and what we think of it and then slightly different between the first one and the second one. So, this is a It's a sequel.
It's a sequel. Not even an expansion. It's a sequel. Stand-alone sequel. They're not combinable. It is a separate game. Yep, indeed. All right. Yes. So, the game itself is very simple and the game itself plays the same way as the original Ecosystem. It's a draft. Uh you get 10 cards. You choose one you want. And them hand them off to the next player and you flip it over and you're building a 4x5 grid of animals. Or animals and planktons. Yeah, I think they're all animals. Plankton might be. Well, protozoa or something. Yep. Um you get your 10 cards, draft it and down, you draw another 10 cards, draft in the opposite direction, and you're trying to yeah, build up a 4x5 grid that scores the most points.
That's it. That's it. So, really simple rules. And then each one each tile placement part of it, now that has got different rules to it. Yes, so the types of cards can be broken into four types. There is producers, which is your tiny little things, coral and krill and plankton, the stuff that just gets eaten. Then you've got prey, which are smaller fish that eat these tiny things but then get eaten by the bigger fish who are the predators, the eels and sharks and stuff. And then there's um a couple of other ones that don't fall into any of those types. They all score points in different ways. So, coral you want them on the bottom. Krill, you want little sets of uh sets of krill adjacent to each other.
Plankton, you want to have the most plankton. You get the get majority points for that. Uh groupers want to be next to krill. Clownfish want to be next to plankton and coral. Crab want to be in the same row as plankton. Um eels eat Eels eat any prey. Sharks eat any prey. Whales eat krill. It's quite thematic as well. Yep. Yeah. Uh oct- octopus lets you swap cards after you've placed them, which is quite nice and is worth a few points. And turtles will score if they're if they're spread apart so that every row and column has a turtle. That's where you'll get the most points for them. Um then the other the other big part is you've got to try to be balanced among these three types.
It's called the food web bonus. So, you total up all your producer points, all of your prey points, all of your predator points, and whichever of those three is the lowest, you'll double. That's the game. That's the game. So, featuring beautiful artwork of the sea life firstly, the sharks. Um I think I remember in the old Ecosystem, there's a turtle equivalent of of the game. There is. Um that is the I've got it here for comparison purposes. Let's do the comparison first then. Yeah, that's the deer. Oops. Yeah. are the turtle equivalent. Um so, yeah, that Yeah, from a comparison standpoint, it is it's the same game with different animals and a different set of scoring.
Um That's That's really all you say. It It is the same game um with a different set of scores. And there are a few similar animals and there are a few that are different. Um the big thing that Coral Reef introduces is those three categorizations, the uh producers, prey, and predators. You didn't have that in Ecosystem. And the first uh the solar and two player variant. Uh yeah, there there wasn't a two player draft variant No. No. Like it's a kind of like fake third player, which you draft together, which actually really nice for a two player because otherwise you just don't see enough animals for two players. I don't know. It just feels better three players, four players otherwise.
Yep. Um and the food web bonus uh in the original game, that was a diversity bonus where you would score negative points for each individual scoring animal type that you scored nothing from. So, this gave you an incentive to have every single type of animal. This one gives you an incentive to score evenly among your different types. So, this is more like positive reinforcement. This is more negative reinforcement. It is true though. Yeah, it is. So, have you formed which one you like better? We're going to point at the same time in the count of three, which one you like better on the count. Ready? So, as in like 1 2 3 go, right? Yep. 1 2 3 go.
All right. So, I like the Coral Reef newer version better while Tarrant like the older version better. Why do you like the older version better? Um so, I think what I what I found was with the this one is an easier entry point. And what makes it an easier entry point is that it ha- these categorizations make it easier to organize your thoughts on what card needs to be near what. The big ones are always trying trying to eat the small ones. That was kind of the case in um Ecosystem thematically, but you didn't have those categorizations. And there were a few things like streams that would score based on yeah, that would score differently. So, it was a bit harder to keep track of what combos of what in the original game.
Um That's probably why I like this one. Okay, this one That is why I like this one better. Yeah. This is interesting. All right, keep going. Yeah, cuz I think you know, it I mean, the only difference is how these these scores work. And I think what I found here was there were a few obvious um you could kind of split them in two or three and just focus on one and still score pretty well. Which I like. Like it should be like that options to just focus on a few rather than having to have all of them. Yeah, but in a drafting game, if I'm focusing on krill and you can see I'm focusing on krill, it's like, all right, I'll go and focus on plankton and then we both just get the cards we want. No, or okay, you focus on krill. I better just take some krills off you then.
But you'll get more points by by uh then I'll lose. And that's that's the way it goes. why there's a balancing here, like, you know. Uh sorry, keep going. Yeah. I mean, that's that was my thought. I remember having to think a lot harder to make this one works, yeah. playing this. This one it felt a little more straightforward. Yeah, so it's only a very slight Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, it's like I still like the original one and this one as well. It's just like it's it's slightly like in my head, oh my gosh, like I have to do this. They have a lot to remember while this one is more streamlined and more gate uh gateway. And and as you said, so I would personally like this one. It's an easy one to get to the table with really simple rules.
You basically All right, you draft 10 and then draft another 10. That's it, 20 cards. And then everyone has got really great reference cards, which I wouldn't go without it. And that's the game. Yep. Everyone enjoy it. Quite um quite a good getaway game. Might even play at Christmas, Tarrant. Maybe. I'll fast for playing this uh at Christmas with your with your family. Anyways, play six as well, which helps with higher player counts. Um I would recommend higher player counts than lower player counts as with other drafting games, I reckon. Consider it considering it's also a quick game. It's not like a lot of Like you you do things players doing it simultaneously. I like drafting at lower player counts, actually, because You so mean. cuz you can try to predict what's going to come back to you and work out do I take it?
The The question of do I take it now is not just what's my most valuable card now, it's most valuable What's my most valuable and do I think these one or two people will take it from me? Mhm. Well, Tarrant likes to be in control a little bit more than me. So, I would I would recommend both games, Ecosystem and Ecosystem Coral Reef or I just really good fillers. Play up to six. Yeah. And that's it. We haven't played the solo yet. Uh but it plays up to six. Yeah. Coral Coral Reef is definitely an easier entry point. This organization uh it will absolutely help players who haven't seen it before. Indeed. So, that That's it. Have you played Ecosystem? Have you heard of Ecosystem Coral Reef?
Maybe you have played both. Which one's your favorite? Let us know in the comments or any other games that are kind of like similar to these two. And that's it, Aaron? That's it. If you find it useful somehow, it would be really helpful as well. Please hit the like button and subscribe to us if you haven't done that. Uh we have We've done how to play review like this and then life later for the weekend. I'm also on Instagram. Follow me there as well and hopefully we'll see you next time. Thanks for watching. Bye. Bye.