Skip to main content
Loading video...

Windmill Valley - 4p - The Discussion

Transcript 12:44

And Sarah, thank you for playing. Did I? You brought snacks. I brought snacks. You only brought one slim. I let Chip down. Yeah. So, uh, all right. So, thoughts thoughts on, uh, thoughts on windmill folder. I like this game. I do, too. I like it. The the biggest issue I have with it is there is there does not appear to me to be any kind of catch-up mechanism. Like that's a downside. Yeah. I mean for some for some people I understand if you can't lose the game on turn one, why play Yeah. Yeah. No. No. And I'm I'm not I'm not being a smartass here. Did you count your full row? Your eight points. Eight more. Eight more. 29 78 129. There we go. Got even full honors. Um but like but but so there's Yes. you make if you make a dumb move early on, but like it would have to be a really dumb move. And that really dumb move would be to go all in on windmills and then only have one way of actually putting out windmills.

That would be a really dumb move. I mean, I I feel like I let you down by not stressing how important I let my down. It's a joke because I beat you over the head about the windmills. You did what I did last game. Something stupid. Yeah. It would just I told you if you're going to take this card, build windmills. Yeah. And I absolutely did not. I absolutely did not. I thought I would have a This didn't come out until like the end of the game. This This There's only like two of these, right? There's a There's a third one. No, there's two that that got recycled. Oh, you sure? But like there's that's one, that's two, that's three. And And I just I I didn't see the other one. And that's, you know, there's a good reason for that. And so I definitely made a very very dumb move there. Um, and I don't know of any catch-up mechanism worth, you know, worth having in a game that isn't just like Mario Kart style rubber banding would be would be a good idea. So, like, you know, I live by the back of this coin, die by the back of this coin, I guess, play better. This game's catchup mechanism, so to speak, is that um there's points for those with eyes to see them there. There's just Did you just tell me the catch-up mechanism is to not be dumb? No, no, no. It's just a pivot. There's so much There's so much points in other areas. Sure. You just got to You just got to stop. Um, but I had invested so heavily in this and did not realize until halfway through the game that that it was that I had bought Yeah. Yeah. that I bought beachfront

property on Mars. To be fair though, with your setup, you earned like what, 50 points. That's how I always play, right? But I'm saying you earned 50 raw points just from your setup, which is good. Yeah. you you needed to to follow up with I needed to follow up with 35 tools and the contractor gave me points for them, right? I needed something else and I didn't do that. If if this had just been moved over to there, things would have gone way different for me, right? See, to me, I feel like I mean, I I appreciate how many points that Greg scored on that, but to me, the reason I won is because I did that. Yeah. That that's that's the second part. If if a game about building tulips and in a windmill valley getting windmills out, even if they're not on the board, that is why I won, right? I mean, my friend Mark isn't watching. I feel like that's what you said last time, too. Like, that's the key. But if he is watching, he'll be like, "Windmill Valley, huh?

I don't do windmills to win windmill valley." And he'll do it somehow. Well, I didn't build windmills and I almost won windmill valley, right? Yeah. But you did you did tulip. You built more than me. Yeah, but I didn't get that many points off of them. I did tulip because casually Yeah, tulips come out because of the the built. See, to me, I didn't have much of an engine as far as doing all the like he did gears or and and other and upgrades and he just went heavy into upgrades and they got supplemental stuff from everywhere else. me. I did what the game said I'm supposed to do. And that's Yep. Well, the the game said go to the shipyard early uh and do something that's going to break the game for you for the rest of the game that isn't the shipyard.

Because I think if the only issue I have with this card is use it two, three times I think before it's run it before going here is no longer like worth the time. Worth the effort. Yeah. Yeah. Um, what do you what do you think, sir? I think I'm so tired. I'm about to start drilling out my snack. Okay. You got more snacks in there. Keep seriously, get get her digestive system out of there. No, the the only things that I I mean, I like the the mechanism of the the gears. I like the way the work the game works. It is a fun midweight Europe. The only thing I don't like is honestly the big issue I have is the way the contracts come out. Is you can get points because you got lucky and the timing of when a contract came out and wow I went from I did I had nothing maybe six points to 24 points. Right.

Exactly. Was 28 over that which which happened because this got not hatedrafted. It it should have gotten haydrafted, I think, because that's the only way to secure contracts uh from Well, I did clear it out from you once, but then I never saw it come back and you got it. Well, the reason why it came back quick is because uh Oh, it came back super quick cuz everyone's got a bunch, right? We went through the deck. It It takes nothing. In fact, it's almost worth spending the dollar just to get back to one discarded that you uh Yeah. Sure. You're that much quicker. Yeah. And the game's about tempo as well, right? and being opportunistic. I like it. I think it's a really fun solid midweight euro. It's colorful. It's pretty expansion coming out that I'm excited for. Wait, do you any clue what it is? Didn't need it. I And I immediately bought it. Okay.

I was some of these uh contracts in powers where I I I still echo the thing you had said uh during the Patreon stream about it that I don't I don't like that I got points the way that I got the points. Okay. Um cuz I got almost 100 points just from I guess playing not even playing the game. I ignored the game and said, "I'm just going to put stuff in my gears." That doesn't seem like I should have gotten uh I think it was 72 points out of that or something. You ignored the theme and did the thing that got you the points. Yeah. Yeah. That just seems like not correct. Why would that not be correct?

cuz he want he wants to be punished because Right. Right. So there should be a punishment for for doing an optimal move. A thing that that that gives you more things shouldn't also give me points. It should make it so that the downside is this doesn't give you points. This is just you get an opportunity to continue building more. The fact that I got to have Especially because that is tied to the luck of the the of the contracts coming out. Yep. Right. Right. So I get to have a good system of getting bunch of You guys were crying about money the whole time. I literally never had an issue with cash once because half of my board is give you give you free money. Give you free money. Here's free money. Yeah. Right. And so is that is that um is that a like a skill issue on our part because we didn't we you didn't take the contract that uh popped up on my turn that lets you fish three things at a time. On a positive note, you didn't win, right?

But I No, no, but you were. It's always a positive. No, no, no. He knows what I mean. I know what you mean, too. If I Yes. If I had won and the gap had been like way bigger when I won, too. Um, that would have been really bad. This is just This is just I don't like this. Um, okay. Great great Western Trail the remake the the second edition which which version there are 74 of them those just the base they they changed one thing in it um basically when you discard a card you go back and normally you pay a dollar you go back with a train pay a dollar and remove a card from your deck they changed it so you get a dollar okay so went from being this thing where the reward is thinning out your deck and a deck deck builder. They're like, "Here's an extra reward for you. Here's an extra reward. You thin out your deck and here's a dollar in a game where a dollar goes a long way." That's how I kind of feel with this is like there there you shouldn't be constantly rewarding someone who's like doing this system uh in in this way. Like the reward should be I should be able to put out more windmills. I should be able to put out more tulips. I should be interacting more with the game. You're saying they shouldn't just like keep throwing money at you, right? Yeah, that's fair. But but at the same time, um at least from my point of view, I mean, I felt really limited in the game

moneywise, but I knew that was a conscious choice, but I was able to thread the needle enough. And yeah, I I I mean, it's it's solid. I'm not going to go out of my way to go pick up a copy, but that's because we have it in our group. I don't need to. It was um it was, you know, it was on sale at the at a big the big sale, the big online retailer sale. If they want us uh to mention them, then uh sure. Uh but you know, for the price that they were offering at Yeah, absolutely. A hearty recommendation. Yeah, I I I would totally play this again. I have no problems. For what it's worth, the the expansion, from what I can tell, they've just released information about it. It's not due out probably till the end of the year, but uh that it it turns this trading action into a whole new thing.

Okay. You go out and you sail and you can trade in your tulip bulbs and there's boat positioning and all that stuff. Okay. Uh re Rene goes to your uh comment. Not only have I uh when I play online with the second edition, it is the only thing I do and I win I'd say 70% of the time. Get the get rid of those cows. You get rid of those cows because it constantly is rewarding at those cows, right? You also have to know what you're doing. You can't just thin out your deck and go backwards. But yeah. All right. So, anything else? Sleepy head. Okay. All right. That's a wrap. That's great. Uh, no, it's not Great Western Trail. This is Sorry. Is that Oh, that's why I lost. I've been I've been executing Great Western Trail.exe on this board. No way. Windmill Per, i.e. windmill valley. Uh, thanks Paul for the bet busting out the game in the teach tonight. Uh, Sarah, thank you for the snacks. Everybody out there, uh, really appreciate you all hanging out.

All the patron support. Uh, I did want to give a special shout out. Anthony Czechus been a, uh, patron for a very long time. Really appreciate the support. So, Anthony, thank you very much for the support. It means a lot. Uh, if you all do enjoy the streams, please like and subscribe. It really does help the channel as does I mean the patron drive. patreon.comhghq. Hopefully you all found this entertaining and fun. Uh, and be back tomorrow, you and I. Uh, tomorrow at noon. We're doing a fourplayer Crystal Palace. Tell your friends. Oh boy. We're not teaching it. We've taught it enough on the channel. We're just going to roll into it. Send us your thumbs and we'll see you all later. I'm Edward. I'm Greg. Sarah Paul. All right, y'all have a good night. Bye, sleepy head. Bye.

Hey, thanks for watching y'all. Hopefully watching was as enjoyable for y'all as it was for us making it. And if so, then maybe look right above my head, like and subscribe. That helps. Maybe watch one of those other videos. Consider supporting us over on Patreon. All of those things really do help the channel. Thanks y'all.

Progress saved