Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Ultimate Showdown - Dungeon Crusade, League of Dungeoneers and Dungeon Universalis

Transcript 35:13

thank you hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive Daniel here I hope you're doing well and if you're not I hope you are soon okay today on the dungeon dive we are going to be comparing three of the kind of modern old-school big boys and this is the Battle of the modern Old School Big Boys where we are pitting dungeon Crusade against dungeon universalis against League of dungeoneers one of these games will be crowned the champion the other two will be burned in a fire okay no that's absolutely ridiculous all three of these games are awesome and it's kind of incredible that all three of these games exist right now at this time when I was first getting back into hobby board games around uh 2005. that was kind of like my third phase of the hobby uh there was really only one big Dungeon Crawl on the market and that was descent first edition and there was pretty much only one kind of big adventure game on the market and that was uh Arkham Horror's second edition both from uh Fantasy Flight games we did not have all of these amazing options that we have today now we just have an embarrassment

of riches the fact that these three just huge games can exist and are all you know somewhat available or will be made available again in the future is pretty incredible these three games they feel anachronistic it's like they're out of place in our time they seemed to have been designed without much thought given to Modern trans to other modern games um as a lot of these kinds of games move away from Dice and move away from luck and start kind of incorporating more kind of Euro elements into the Thematic uh Trend in the Thematic World these games embrace the old school design of dungeon crawls of Adventure board games each of these games utilizes or uses a standees as the official way to represent the characters heroes and monsters while dungeon universals comes with a few minis I think those were add-ons there's like eight Minis that represent kind of the uh the the story Heroes I believe those were extras and none of these games come with a huge boxes of minis to paint and store it's all about the cardboard in these games each one of these games has a kind of Overland adventuring component although each one handles that a little bit

differently with dungeon Crusade kind of doing more of its own thing when compared with dungeon universalis and League of dungeoneers each of these games has the word dungeon in the title coincidence I think not each of them is epic both in time and in the amount of space they consume each has strengths and weaknesses and while they have some similarities they also have some differences now two games that I am not including in this that could be and it's purely for kind of arbitrary reasons I am not including Shadows of Brimstone because well frankly I've already talked about that game enough I talk about Shadows of Brimstone all the time um I have something like what 40 videos and my Shadows of Brimstone series also uh it uses Minis and the games that I'm focusing on uh use standees Shadows of Brimstone is also not a traditional fantasy I'm also not including dark light Memento Mori because one it's not traditional fantasy it also focuses on Minis and the minis it uses are very big making it hard and making it a hard game to proxy for it also unfortunately seems to be a dead game and I doubt we'll ever see anything in that game again whereas I think these three games are very much alive so we are going to be comparing these games in 12 different areas this is a 12 point battle

in each of the points I will assign a place from one to two to three and I am going to assign three points to first two points to Second and one point to Third and then we'll kind of tally up the points at the end the points are just kind of for fun and then uh they don't really mean anything because like I said all three of these games are amazing and at the end of the video I will give kind of my my conclusion on what I think about each one of these games now because we're doing a 12 point comparison we will be using a D12 and I'm going to see if without any kind of camera trickery or special effects if I can roll a 1 through 12 consecutively as I get to each point so let's start with Point number one I already rolled a one so we are at Point number one Point number one is the ease of learning how easy is each one of these games to learn okay spoiler alert none of these games are easy to learn these are not simple games these are these are not simplistic games these games do not offer up effortless fun each one of these games is pretty difficult to learn in its own way however I have assigned the winner and I think and what uh let's back up I am taking into account updated

rule books so dungeon Crusade new versions of dungeon Crusade will ship with the uh the second edition of The Player's handbook the updated Edition which is fantastic dungeon universalis now has a second edition of the rulebook which is better than the first edition and we are still at first edition of League of dungeoneers so number one in the ease of learning with the updated rulebook I am giving uh first place to dungeon Crusade I'm giving second place to dungeon universalis and third place to League of dungeoneers the updated Crusaders handbook is very good for Dungeon Crusade it takes care of a lot of a lot of the issues that I pointed out in my initial review for this game it's structured better it has a fantastic index it has uh they've eliminated pages and it's just a much better rule book the second edition for Dungeon universalis is pretty good I still think there are some issues with the translation some word choice that I do not agree with but overall it's pretty good but this game is very difficult to learn there is a lot going on the rulebook explains it well but there is a lot going on uh League of dungeoneers definitely has some issues with the rule book I pointed those out in my review there are a lot of typos a lot of rule errors in the book that do make it more difficult to learn League of dungeoneers definitely needs a second edition of the rulebook

in order to fix all of that stuff okay so now let's go on to point number two come on I need to use my dice rolling skills to roll a two yes I hit it all right a two okay number two is ease of play and by that I am uh incorporating all of these things in in setup in storage in teardown in game length cable space um how well does it play solo Co-op or one versus mini how easy are these games to play and in number one for this I am giving number one to League of dungeoneers number two I am giving to dungeon universalis and number three I am giving to dungeon Crusade okay so League of dungeoneers it's very easy to set up and tear down this game has the fewest components out of all of them it's easy to store it comes with good storage in the Box uh the game is not for such an epic experience it's actually pretty easy to play in just in terms of logistics of of setting it up taking it down and storing it uh dungeon Universe Solace has a good box as well that does keep things organized uh this game does take a little bit more time I think to play than League of dungeoneers I'm giving this part two main or number two mainly because I think this game is best at one versus mini and that's just not a type of game that I play often I prefer a

pure solo game and while this is you can play this purely as a solo game I think it shines as a one versus mini game uh three I'm giving dungeon Crusade three because okay let's uh be very Frank here there was pretty much no thought given to how this game is stored in the box it and there's no insert as a matter of fact like 60 of the components will never fit back into that smallish box that it comes in you need to provide a whole bunch of your own storage solution for Dungeon Crusade so it's a very hard game to store it is also a very long game even in the updated kind of shorter version you're still looking at probably you know maybe like six hours to get through an entire just one game so this is probably the hardest game to play to store to uh to keep track of logistically um out of all three of these okay Point number three let's see if I can roll a three here all right doing very good on my dice rolling skills there don't let anybody ever tell you that dice rolling is not a skill okay Point number three component quality quantity this is the hardest of the categories to to judge for me because all three of these games are very similar in the component quality none of them are triple a quality there are some caveats made some some

um there are some concessions I think that you can say knowing that these are kind of independent Productions you won't be getting you know linen finished cards like you would in a fantasy flight game uh you're not going to be getting the the the incredibly well made components and something that you might get in an awakens realm game these games they they feel old in the type of components that they come with and that's perfectly fine that's one of the things that I do like about it it's it's there's a it's a charm about all three of these games so it's really really hard to judge but um I put it like this I put League of dungeoneers at number one I put dungeon Crusade at number two and I put uh down to new universalis at three I prefer the standees that come with League of dungeoneers and dungeon Crusade more than the standees that come with dungeon universalis and that's kind of why I ended up putting them in this order the standees for League of dungeoneers or I'm sorry for Dungeon universalis they're okay but they're a lot of them kind of look like they were made with stock art they're not cut out in the shape of the hero they don't have a front or a back um the league of dungeoneers minis uh the standees they are all custom with custom art they have front and back

facing they're they're cut out they have a mini for everything you would need or a standee for everything you need and the standees in a dungeon Crusade while they don't have uh front or back they have a cut out and they're they're excellent I love the standees and dungeon Crusade so that's I I kind of looked at the standees because everything else is pretty similar the cardboard quality is similar um the the the cards in League of dungeoneers they feel substantial the cards in Dunham Crusade feel a little thin so that's why that wasn't number one but this this was a really really difficult uh category to judge okay so number four let's see if I can roll this four here and yes I hit the four all right okay number four is visual appeal uh this is one area where I think one game kind of trounces the others and for visual appeal number one is dungeon Crusade number two uh is dungeon universalis and I think in a distant third is League of dungeoneers the art and visual presentation of dungeon Crusade is off the charts great Roger did a fantastic job of getting custom art and and using art Assets in uh dungeon Crusade the map pieces the dungeons look incredible all of the

cards have unique art there is so much good art in Dungeon Crusade and it just looks it just pops on the table I love seeing this game set up dungeon universalis also has a lot of good art I don't think the art is as consistent it uses a lot of art assets from different styles and so there is some inconsistency in the art even though a lot of the art is also very good and a lot of the cards also have unique art League of dungeoneers comes kind of in a distant third and I I did mention that in my review there is a lack of Art in in League of Engineers and I think Michael knows that it was done on purpose to keep the costs down there are going to be some new things that are coming in League of Engineers that are going to add more unique art but the league of Engineers is not a very visually exciting game okay let's uh go on to point number five point number five all right can I hit that five yes hit that five all right I was practicing rolling a one through twelve consecutively for like the last two weeks so I think that practice is showing okay Point number five is the Overland Adventure component um each one of these games has an Overland Adventure component and then as you are traveling through the land you then go into dungeons these two games handle it most similarly and Lee uh dungeon Crusade does things a

little differently in Dungeon Crusade the Overland Adventure part is actually played before the game as a separate game whereas with these two the Overland component is is uh combined with the regular game and so for this one I put uh dungeon let's see uh the Overland dungeon universalis at number one League of dungeoneers at number two and a dungeon Crusade at number three so one of my ultimate wish lists for games is I love games where you get to go on an Overland Quest and then you come to a hex or a space that has a dungeon on it and then you get to go into that dungeon both of these games do that I think Lee I think dungeon universalis does it best because of how well constructed the world is when you are on that Overland map you really do feel like you are in a place that has a history that has uh political things uh going underneath the surface the the world of dungeon universalis is a very very well made and it is substantial and that Overland map does a lot to help get that across to the players League dungeoners has that amazing huge hex map but the world feels a little bit more generic I don't feel like I'm in a place that has a great history or that has a lot of depth to it and that's fine that's the way that it was designed but it still does that uh

that thing that I like really well where I can travel to a location having Adventures along the way and then get to a hex and then go on a Dungeon Crawl our dungeon Crusade is three just because it does things so differently the Avalon Adventure board game is actually a separate board game it's a game you play before the other game the two aren't combined and so I feel like it doesn't give me quite that thing that I'm looking for but I do still really enjoy the Overland Adventure quality of dungeon Crusade okay so let's see uh number six here number six all right boom okay so hit that number six number six is the dungeon crawling component how well do these games give me that feel like I am exploring a dungeon that I am in a dungeon having to deal with traps having to deal with monsters having to deal with different threats uh do they offer up a kind of a random uh mode where I never know what's coming next do they do that without the need of an app and that is a crucial Point into how I uh judged this category so at number one is a league of dungeoneers at number two is dungeon Crusade and at number three is dungeon universalis I love the dungeon crawling in League of dungeoneers because it utilizes that Warhammer Quest style of dungeon

crawling where there is true exploration there is a true random questing in the dungeons you use cards and so you're setting up a dungeon as you go and you create interesting dungeons as you go and you never know what's coming next dungeon universalis our dungeon Crusade I should say takes a more of a hero Quest approach where you have a static board even though you have four different static boards but the quest elements are randomized so you never really know where your quest elements are in those pre-constructed dungeons dungeon universalis this is where I feel dungeon Universe Solace really falls down is it does not have that kind of random questing exploration without the need of an app and because dungeon Universe Solace needs an app for that uh random questing especially for a solo player to to to have that element of surprise of exploration it kind of breaks free from this old school charm that I'm looking at in all three of these games dungeon universals in my opinion really needs a random dungeon mode using cards using nothing but the things in the Box okay let's go on to point number seven okay lucky number seven here and topic number seven is loot loot something we all enjoy okay so which one of these games has the

best loot I am giving first place two dungeon Crusade second place to dungeon universalis and a third place two League of dungeoneers dungeon Crusade has what 192 pieces of unique loot each one of those has a unique piece of art each one of those has a unique little um kind of lore sentence on the bottom with unique powers the the loot in Dungeon Crusade is so much fun I love drawing treasure the treasure deck in in Dungeon Crusade is amazing there are all kinds of cool things beyond the loot to find in the Treasure deck so uh dungeon Crusade is a is a great great for for loot um at number two is dungeon universalis it does have a lot of Loot and the loot does have a lot of unique properties and unique art I do feel it is a little harder to get those cool magic items in Dungeon universals and I would like to have access to more of them earlier the loot in in League of legendaries is pretty good especially as you start uh enchanting it but you kind of have to you have to work a little more to get to the cool stuff in League of Engineers because you do need to enchant your mundane items in order to make them magical there's not a ton of magical items to find in League of Engineers there are those legendary items and there is going to be an expansion coming out that does offer those legendary items on cards with unique art and so that will help League of engineers in

this category quite a bit okay so number eight is the bestiary okay there we go number eight the bestiary this one was hard for for two games to to uh to compare those two one of them kind of stands alone and the one that stands alone is is dungeon Crusade because dungeon Crusade doesn't really have a best series so to say it's a different kind of bestiary dungeon universalis and League of dungeoneers they both have amazing bestiaries I gave the nod to League of dungeoneers just because I find it a little more useful and it doesn't take quite as much work the bestiary in Dungeon universalis and I'm talking about the main bestiary book dungeon Universalist actually has two huge bestiary books um the best Diary book one now is made better because of the cards that you could get as an add-on that takes some of the work but I still feel like the bestiary in Dungeon Universal still requires a little bit more work and that's why I that's one of the reasons why I don't like playing this game solo because if as a one versus many the the one the dungeon master role hand if they have to put in that work that's part of their job at the table so it makes sense uh the league of dungeoneers bestiary is a very easy for a soloist to play it doesn't take a lot of effort and it's incredibly extensive and very interesting

dungeon Crusade has a lot of enemies there are only a handful of minions but then you have the Guardians and you have the the the monsters that live in the chambers and they have interesting uh abilities this does use you know three different versions of each monster so you don't get a ton of variety but you also get just enough to make things feel interesting so if this was another tight category okay let's get uh Point number nine here let me roll that lucky number nine okay here we go lucky number nine and point number nine Is Random Encounters which of these games has the best Random Encounters I am giving first place to dungeon Crusade I am giving second place two uh League of dungeoneers and third place I am giving to uh dungeon Universe solace so dungeon Crusade at number one it has a 80 80 cards I think uh encounter deck and those are awesome I love the Random Encounters in Dungeon Crusade I like that each turn you draw one so you're always going to see something and you can mix and match those in different combinations if you want to make kind of a thematic dungeon you can just randomize them so all kinds of cool Random Encounters in Dungeon Crusade there are also Random Encounters in the Treasure deck of this game comparing

these two was very difficult they are very close I gave the nod to League of legendaries just because from what I've seen I like the Overland encounters and League of dungeoneers a little more than I liked the ones in Dungeon universalis I know there's also an expansion coming out that's going to add more dungeon encounters right now there are only about 24 different dungeon encounters but both of these have very similar encounters I just I found the ones in League of Engineers just a little more a little more entertaining for me but but dungeon universalis is no slouch in this area Okay number 10 number 10 here we go lucky number 10. there we go lucky number 10 has every has anybody ever said lucky number 10 ever in their lives I don't know but hey you know what I am doing incredibly well rolling one through twelve number 10 is character creation and this is another uh category where one game completely I think completely trounces the others and that is a number one dungeon Universe Solace number two League of dungeoneers and number three dungeon Crusade again comes in three like in the Overland uh portion the Overland point because it's really doing its own thing in that there is really no character creation in Dungeon Crusade you are playing uh six characters or maybe 12 characters if you get the expansion and you have no say in their starting gear or stats or anything so so dungeon

Crusade really doesn't have any kind of character creation League of Engineers is pretty good but you only have what four different species and five or six different uh professions so the the amount of customization in League of dungeoneers is less than it is in Dungeon universalis dungeon universalis has a character creation and progression that Rivals a big RPG there are so many different races in so many different classes and so many different skills you can upgrade all of your talents and points uh I love dungeon universalis at the Character level it is super super interesting okay let's go on to point number 11.

there we go eleven okay eleven is RPG feel which one of these games feels like an RPG in the box that's a term that's kind of uh tossed around willy-nilly but one of these games really does feel the most like an RPG in the box and again that is number one with dungeon universalis number two League of dungeoneers and number three dungeon Crusade again number three dungeon Crusade is kind of doing its own thing I don't think it's trying to be an RPG dungeon Universal set number one dungeon universals I think really is an RPG with board game components that's why I think this is best played with a dungeon master to get that full experience League of legendaries can very easily be made into an RPG as a matter of fact just a couple weeks ago I featured it on the solo RPG Friday as a way that you could very easily turn League of Engineers into an RPG but for this category dungeon universalis comes on top okay here we go our final uh category number 12.

and Bam how is that for dice scale I rolled a 12 on all of the dice in just one roll amazing I've been practicing so hard on that so number 12 is the future and customization so this is a kind of a hard category to think about but I just thought about uh what's the future what does the future have in store for each one of these games and how excited am I for that future and for this category I gave first place to dungeon Crusade I gave second place to League of dungeoneers and third place to dungeon universalis I gave third place to this just because for me dungeon universalis is a game that is best played with a dungeon master role a dark player a game master and I just I just never play games like that and so when I think about spending time on a game in the future I don't think about dungeon universalis a lot even though I still really like the game and I want to get it back to the table and play it more uh League of dungeoneers I know has some more stuff coming I have a feeling that uh this game will have a lot of fan made materials and I'm looking forward to a second edition of the rule book I'm looking forward to that first kind of a card pack expansion and I'm pretty excited about the future of League of dungeoneers

dungeon Universe are dungeon Crusade I'm excited for for a number of reasons some might be self-serving I there's a chance that I will be maybe writing some quests or helping Roger with some uh a future expansion so I'm excited about that I'm excited about the dungeon challenge mode that he's creating I'm excited for the first big expansion that I know Roger is working on I'm excited for a second edition finally being released via Kickstarter so more people can experience the game uh I think dungeon Crusade has a really really bright future and this is the game that I feel the most excited about okay so that was all 12 points and like I said one of these games will be crowned the champion the other two I'm going to burn in a fire pit in my backyard no that's nonsense I love all three of these games each one of these games has things to offer that the others don't uh some of these games do things that I like better but I could see them also appealing to other people more I'm not really going to go over the point value just because it was so arbitrary and some of the some of the categories were really difficult especially that component category but let's talk about each one of these games so let's talk about dungeon universalis first uh dungeon universals is the closest thing I've seen to an RPG in a box one of the only games to really deserve that distinction if you're looking for a potential lifestyle game this is your

game this game shines for me as a one versus mini game and I feel that's how the game was designed first first and foremost it's very crunchy the combat is very tactical it has rules for everything flying jumping climbing Etc it feels like a giant toolbox rules could also be used for a the rules in this game could also be used for a point-based skirmish game for me it's hard to play solo because there is so much to remember the lack of a random dungeon mode out of the box hurts its dungeon crawling in my opinion you need to write you need to rely on an app for solo exploration or Co-op exploration and for an old school style game I think this is a mistake this game takes a a lot of work but it is rewarding and it rewards you for the work you put in I can see this game being a group's main game for many years okay League of dungeoneers if you want Warhammer Quest and 95 this is your game this is the only modern game I know of that feels like it has the potential to quench The Thirst of those wanting a Warhammer Quest reprint it has random dungeon generation with cards and tiles a thing that is oddly rare in these kinds of games it has true exploration in the dungeons as the deck of exploration card splits it has Overland travel with a settlement phase a focus on survival and character progression

rather than long rather than a long epic narrative it has a ton of random quests a few longer campaigns that feel more like novellas rather than epic novels it has a great and useful bestiary it has true open world feel to the overall design a good amount of loot it needs more Random non-combat Encounters in the dungeon and those are coming it can be pretty crunchy but there and there is a lot going on it's definitely more complex than Warhammer quests but not quite as complex as dungeon universalis It suffers in the visual Department there just isn't a lot of art or illustrations to enjoy none of the cards have any art at all on them and a lot of the art in the book are actually photos of diorama and Miniatures setups and uh dungeon Crusade if you're looking for an epic Dungeon Crawl that doesn't focus on any kind of campaign or persistent play this is your game this effect alone makes dungeon Crusade the most the most inaccurate anachronistic of the three because so many modern games tend to focus on that campaign play I think uh dungeon Crusade best plays solo it was made for solo from the ground up and especially with the new solo Crusader mode uh dungeon Crusade has amazing art and visual design this is really where dungeon Crusade shines the brightest and I put a lot of stock into a game's art

and A Game's visual design the art is off the charts and there is a ton of it it has a unique Choose Your Own Adventure style Overland game played before the main game and while not incorporated into the dungeon crawling portion it can be actually played as a standalone game and that is fun to do dungeon Crusade can take a lot of time and a lot of table space while it has preset dungeons like hero quests they feel vast and open and with the randomized quest elements they're always surprising it has a fantastic deck of random dungeon encounters and amazing treasure deck and a ton of loot dungeon Crusade feels the most unique of the three it does a lot of things its own way and I think that's why I do really appreciate dungeon Crusade sorry guys I hope you enjoyed this 12 point review this 12 point comparison between dungeon Crusade dungeon universalis and League of dungeoneers and we will talk to you later bye-bye

Progress saved