Beyond Solitaire Podcast 152: Eduardo García-Molina on Archaeogaming
Transcript
it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulation and as usual they're up to some amazing things their next game hydrologic cycle is currently on Kickstarter and you should absolutely go and check it out clgs also continues to offer classes in partnership with Gen Con the next course Jason Fury's crowdfunding with confidence starts on May 6th and we'll teach you all about board games and crowdfunding go check it out and I'll also include a final plug for myself if you like the show and want to support it you can do so by going to patreon.com beond soliter thanks to listeners like you a been ble to keep upgrading my equipment subscribing to streamyard and more uh but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson for be on solitier and this week on the Pod I have a very special guest this is Eduardo Garcia Molina he is a graduate student at the University of Chicago in Classics yes yep and um I'm just super happy to have you on the podcast because you are an expert on archo gaming among other things so uh why don't you tell us like the basics of what you do and then what archo gaming is for who don't know yeah sure so first of all thank you for having me on I'm super excited this is a great break from as we were talking about a little bit before we started recording the the dissertation kind of fatigue that I'm currently experiencing as I near the end um but yeah uh so I'm doing my uh PhD in Classics specialization in ancient history um I
mainly researched the salans uh which is one of the helenistic empires that form Dr Alex Ander kicked the bucket uh one of the bigger ones don't tell the toic historians that um uh and actually got into them through gaming because I didn't know about them at all until I played Rome Total War uh way back when oh God my age is is the the the almost the gray hair is already forming as I recount the story and I always recount it to my students when I play Rome Total War and I picked a faction they're called the salid who are these weirdos with their huge Roost their op roster that had cateracts they had elephants they had everything uh and that naturally snowballed into a fascination with them afterwards so even in my main research area I've always carried kind of gaming uh into it and then as I kind of developed in graduate school and I started noticing that these there's this community of Scholars that are incredibly invested in looking at games not only through like reception one to one but also Alo how game mechanics how the world itself that in video games can be examined as an archaological or through archaeological terms through archaeological lenses um and kind of the niche that I am currently in um that have a a chapter and an edited volume coming out I think this year possibly it's one of the things with academic
Publications you never know in what state of limbo uh one thing is until it surprises you when your box one morning um a bit so for example I'm super interested in kind of questions about in my broader research questions of state power and state infrastructure so I'm very invested in kind of transplanting that interest into the gaming world so I've looked at how ancient states are represented in kind of ludic framework so like in Grand strategy games how the power of an ancient state is is uh translated I like that word a lot uh because game mechanics you know you can't just look at it and critique it as a historian going oh that's inaccurate no you have to think about how it works in the kind of ludic environment um so yeah that's kind of the the a the broader and then the the particulars of kind of how archo gaming or or how my research kind of conforms and and fits into the greater scheme of archo gaming um but yeah so archo gaming as a term I've only started to hear it recently is this something that's older than I realized it is and when people use it what are they trying to communicate there's different facets of it I mean it it really got popularized in into kind of the the verbi the academic verbiage with Andrew reinhardt's publication where his book is just titled archo gaming I forget the the subtitle afterwards um uh but it's
really it can be applied to different things uh the one that you see it most often is that that I mentioned before kind of examining uh ludic environments as an archaeological space like you know looking at how inscriptions are so for example in um oh my God I spent by by uh fourth year of my uh when I was supposed to be writing my perspectives Elden ring like the inscriptions in Elden ring um none of my dissertation committee is is it's okay I I SP my whole dissertation year writing and then playing Skyrim all day so it's okay it's it's normal yeah it's I'm I'm bouncing around between like uh civ6 turn base games where I can you know write a little bit take a turn and go back to it which is an unhealthy kind of life balance uh thing but that's just how it works for me in writing um so yeah I think that's like the the meat and potatoes AR gaming but even there there's other broader umbrella of like reception stuff uh under it I would categorize it but yeah I think that's the main one is just kind of examining these gaming spaces as kind of archaeological spaces in of themselves but also kind of the meta like ET cartridges in the middle of the desert there's also that aspect of like material culture that's very pertinent to you know our lived in environment as well so you mentioned that you got interested in the salades through Total War um as you went from Total War
Enthusiast to history Enthusiast um how did your feelings about the game change like I know you wrote a chapter about this but I mean on a personal level did that was that upsetting or broadening or you know what did you notice first about things not being quite as you were play the game no that's actually a neat question because honestly I've always divorced the the like I've never I've never had that like kn jerk reaction that you see a lot of like Total War Reddit about like historical accurac even though it's very superficial historical accuracy some of the claims that are being levied so for example like lur segmentata idolatry when you know the stuff like that like I I I've personally I've always managed to kind of divorce the the pleasure centers of playing from the historian brain I know some people can't um I I'm very gracious that I've been able to and I can just enjoy a game and then I can just turn it on if I'm like you know if if I'm looking at it through an academic lens or a presentation or something like that I can also just sit back and like go okay flaming pigs uh against counter my elephants and Total War sure even though there's only one mention of him in you know I forget what a tactician and the the the CES once the dates are counting up my interest starts waning uh a good
old man um uh but stuff like that like I guess I can appreciate also just how much dev's mine historical accounts more for like their inspiration I guess that's one aspect that it's a positive aspect so I've never had that like negative pricity like oh they're doing it wrong and the like sure but like I'm more fascinated by like oh God they like mined plutar for this a random quote that he said about this one battle and then they turned it into a unit or like a game mechanic I'm more interested in like how they mine the historical record for information and I kind of get giddy um and I've been talking with modders about this because it for that chapter uh but also for an invited lecture that I gave um in California um uh I wanted to kind of incorporate how modders kind of you know tried to flesh out the rosters in Rome in Total War Rome or something like that I the mod one of the modders I talked to was from uh Rome Total War surrectum I believe is the name of the mod uh it's on Steam the workshop right now for Rome Total War remastered um and like they have I forget the number of factions but it's an insane number of factions that they fleshed out and a lot of them are mentioned like three times in like I I
don't know why I keep going back to flutter but I don't know Livy let's go with liby um uh and they like flesh out an entire faction based off of like these unit mentions like they really do their homework um so I'm kind of fascinated in that more than just like the oh you know the Maran reforms the uh that's another uh Flat Point uh so actually I wanted to ask also what is your how you feel as a helenistic scholar about the fact that your obsession is with a game called Rome Total War oh oh I mean you get used to it the the helenistic period is really treated as like a middle child um you don't have you know periclean Athens you can't rest your laurels on that pun intended and or and then you have Republican Rome just taking over the conversation um I mean yeah you don't see people on Tik Tok posting about how they think of the helenistic empires every day uh as much as I would like that um um but it's one of the things I kind of talk about in that chapter because it also triggers something in the players and how the game develops Notions of imperialism based on Rome because Rome is kind of seen as like you know the Endo of ancient imperialis oh this is imperialism perfect
romanization the big isation things and to a lesser extent with the helenistic empires heniz these problematic isation things that academics have largely SK skewed uh um uh but a lot of like the Imperial Frameworks are Roman based and then grafted onto like not only the helenistic empires but even like the Alexander expansion the keate Empire is given like this Roman flavor of Imperial is M where to kind of the the U what's that expression the meat and potatoes of it is just um buildings serve as kind of these like cultural conversion things so you demolish other cultures buildings and you replace them with your own cultures building and then they kind of become this font of they're even numer like given numerical which I find absolutely fascinating like every turn your city gets like three % more heniz uh at the expense of like you know local cultures when in actuality that's just not how it like that's just not how people work like we can Dawn many hats uh um and ancient empires didn't want to unless like super super like necessary you wanted to keep like local sites of worship intact because they can help you if you give the temples like money and they can and the priest can go oh this new guy is our like he's great he gives me money you know and he they can help in the
translation of local gods and deities over to like the Roman deities even though the Romans are famously like you know oh your deity oh this is our deity okay there's a little translatio going on um but stuff like that a lot of like the city stuff everything's very Urban uh because the interface demands it because Heck if you were Rome Total War I oh God the naming conventions when they switched up the what is it now Sega uh Total War Rome 2 I think is like the way that you're supposed to say it now um I don't know Rome two um they try to introduce us like oh you have your capital and then you have your little villages to kind of help out um but it's still very like weird uh way of looking at the Empire that it's just like cities and Villages and these Villages are pretty pretty high up there also uh in terms of like population everything um so like the density of rule is very focused on the urban and then you have this like demolition thing so it's very like buildup buildings it's very you know for the image that I used for the beginning of that presentation um and this was at uh Long Beach uh CSU Long Beach where I gave this because they have a uh we were talking about gaming archives they have a gaming archive there uh also um uh and the image that I used to to
kind of start off that presentation was an AI generated image of like what a Roman city was and you just see I mean it's it's like what um like the the Trad accounts on on social media think of the Roman Empire right it's all columns all pristine white statues that are self-replicating like it's exactly that and Rome kind of has that same Rome two and Rome one kind of have that same like buildings build construct Aqueduct urbanity this is how Empire is done um when you know ancient empires just didn't work on that Roman mindset uh uh they articulate themselves in a lot of different ways because just ancient States didn't have the same like capabilities that a modern nation state can when it does Empire right um so they had to be creative and kind of you know power sneaky uh uh uh I I just wrote about this actually for the dis for the introduction one of the words that I very much chameleonic the the that's how ancient empires worked uh but yeah yeah that's super interesting like you mentioned like not only did ancient empires not work you know like Rome did Rome is not the model for everybody but also Rome doesn't work the way that we make it work so what does it say about us I feel like that's where your paper was going you know you talked about things being viian and talking about like religion as being seen as a specific kind of cultural influencer um
you know what do you think the scope is for us to use I mean obviously you're studying Classics and the focus is on the ancient world but how much Freedom do you feel to like kind of push into well what does this say about us like it's the mirror of Herodotus but we're looking in it yeah no I think that's it says a lot actually um and that's one of the things because it's easy to just um say say it's easy to just you know wave it off and go ah this is just you know M no but it actually articulates how a lot of us perceive of it you know if if if if you know if we're not invested in kind of just reading this horribly dense literature on like ancient statecraft and all that that is how we naturally see it because it's what's more human than kind kind of looking at something and then trying to articulate it based on you know what we or either have experienced or at least know about or is at least you know more modern in a sense of like 19th century 20th century imperialism that still very much leaves an impression on us today um but I think Converse it can be used to great benefit to kind of have so for example I introduced this in a lot of the classes that I teach uh not only because gaming is you know it it's way more accessible it's a lot of my students that I've
taught in classes like have experience with the ancient world through gaming in one way or another it's a really good bridge to kind of talk about the problems not only in historiography you know the writing of History how we look at ancient States and how we kind of these modern systems and then try to jam them into you know an ancient framework that just didn't operate on the same function of strong weak state power uh but also it can get us talking about like archaeology like because a lot of these things are interrelated so for example this fascination with buildings as like these power generators of of culture uh has to do a lot with how Arch like how we treat material culture oh there's a Roman Temple here ah the romanitas must have been up the waza the romanization must have been you know so prevalent when like people can just walk into a space translated based on their like that's just not how culture and like and identity Works we're much more malleable all of us uh and the Ancients were no less uh that in that regard so like it can get us talking about some like actual problems with the field and how we treat things like buildings um heck how we even view the ancient world
because I talked about the the kind of top- down perspective uh in that article in video games right especially in Grand strategy games you have a top down perspective you just see like cities uh maybe you see some Villages but it's basically just like these islands over vanity and then like these little constellation of villages every once in a while then after that it's just like they may throw in a resource to kind of make the map a little bit you know more interesting visually um but that also reflects how very often in the archaeological record because of the nature of excavations right we can't excavate everywhere lands uh area surveys help with this regard a little bit to try to get up more Village Life and rurality U um as opposed to urbanity but even then like we're kind of uh uh we're largely left blind to kind of what is occurring out there you know away from the centers where we excavate and these are more often cities just because you know resources invested in there's a lot of you know the the ma the the the say you say the the infrastructure behind archaeology and archaeological Expeditions there's a lot to be said there but again these can these games can introduce us to kind of these like heavier conversations I say this as my cats decide which one's going to the window behind the show it's all good um but yeah yeah
yeah so I I think it's really interesting you mentioned that um there's a couple ways we could bran with this but I'm gonna start here um you mentioned talking about this with your classes and I will say so it's really fun to talk to you because you are about to graduate from the University of Chicago with a PhD I did my undergrad there from 2004 to 2008 M and nobody ever brought up the like real total Warr or video games or any of that in any of my classes and I think that I would have been delighted I feel like ion be is kind of changing to become more open to stuff like this uh but you know as somebody who's just gone on the job market uh you're like doing the professional launch now um what role do you feel comfortable allowing RQ gaming to play in your scholarship and how is it being treated like you and I share some of the same professors um you know are they changing too like is this like uh is it people who are kind of in our age bracket um who are bringing it in you know how what do you see I I think it is that I um so still in the department I one of these second years and first years is into it uh into you know RKO gaming and and looking at this kind these kind of topics through that lens but in terms of like the the department overall I I I think I'm usually the outlier um and it's one of the things because when you start teaching and you start you don't even have to like so for
example I was a TA for a Greek SI course uh and we would have lectures with the professor uh and then the second class of the week would break off into discussion groups and then the the class would from UH 60 people uh we would split off into two discussion sections and I would lead one in another room and the professor would lead one in another room um and even if you just put in your slides as you're having these discussions like a background image from Rome Total War or something like that you will have a student afterwards like stop you uh as you're exiting the room and you have all your graded papers and your your you know hating life and hating the paperwork aspect of it after a wonderful discussion um and they'll start talking to you about like total war and all that and but you don't even need to kind of boil it down to these like even though I I relish these human components but also in terms of just professionalization and how to posture yourself um for example the department that I'm joining uh at orbana champagne the classics Department there has a really strong reception uh component a lot of the professors there do reception um and naturally I fit in very well uh into that kind of dynamic you start seeing these um kind of older professors that
are are have done reception for a variety of things you know classical reception on a variety of aspects and they start to more and more appreciate this kind of growing momentum uh that's occurring in the incorporation of archo gaming the incorporation game studies is into kind of conversations that Classics has been having out classical receptions oh for for ages um so you start seeing that kind of uh um them being more receptive and more interested in it because not only you know their own interest in reception but it's all it also opens up departments to a lot of new students and a lot of new opportunities to kind of cross collaborate so for example the the uh Urbana champagne has a game studies uh component to it that I can naturally see myself building a class to kind of talk about more this interested overlap that I have between you know historiography archaeologic uh archaeology and the aspects there and also like game mechanics and how they're implemented in the ancient world so I do think there there is a kind of growing acceptance and and a growing a um a viability to to kind of incorporating these discussions but as in everything um in in Classics but also just in
Academia in general it's a lot it has a lot to do with how receptive the individual departments and the people there are but I feel relatively comfortable in saying that it is becoming more widespread as people start to recognize that oh you know these conversations are Salient uh they can be used not only in their own but also to kind of introduce people into these greater questions that we're having in ancient history and in Classics um yeah and it also another another angle to get students invested in what we do is never a bad thing like you present what you for example I I taught here at Chicago um uh intermediate Greek 3 uh which is based on Homer uh and I did it uh we read through book six and you know in ancient Greek uh uh I led them through homeric Greek we did it every every um every week and then the last class of that week was um dedicated to not only the Greek but also looking at a translation of the passage that we uh spent the week reading in the ancient Greek to see how you know translators handle these words and for one week I gave them the option of either reading uh The Iliad comic book uh or they could watch a
video uh because that's one of the things about archo gaming that's one of the problems and how to incorporate into the classroom is you don't you never want to uh presume that everyone has ready access even more than academic books mm you do not want to presume that everyone has the funds and the ready access so this is another kind of not a negative but a thing you must consider is like do you have a game lab does your University have a game lab like what are the resources that your un can use for you do you have to bring in your own resources um so stuff like that uh never ever is uh think that students have ready access to this kind of material so I gave them a video that kind of broke down uh Troy Total War uh this fascinating weird attempt at this like weird branching Saga thing that creative assembly tried to do and has not gone over well um for a variety of reasons I think that the Pharaoh is their newest Saga one um fascinating the reception to that one um and and I was like okay so instead of a direct translation I want you to look at the factions and look at the uh bonuses the faction bonuses that each individual homeric character has been given odys has like the stealth M like it encourages stealth because you know tricky odys uh
complicated odys very famous recent translation online was a buzz over the fact that Odus can be called complicated oh how dare you call him complicated it's complicated yeah even though the Greek reflects that um and but yeah there's there's different like angle of even for a traditional um like you can't get more traditional than intermediate gek three reading Homer but even then like it invites people to to engage with it on another like some students at the comic other students at the that's fine because that fo and student interest and they bring that interest back into the class disc discussion I didn't have to do anything in that class that that's the best thing you can do if you're leading a discussion because the student like nothing is more rewarding and no class is more uh um beneficial than a class where the instructor if it's a discussion Center class of course if it's a lecture then you're doing something wrong but if it's a discussion like Friday discussion class you want them to to go off on their own and do these things and like even bringing games into that allows for some uh to incorporate that so yeah um I think overall in Broad Strokes uh there is a heightened level of of reception to you know game reception and and
incorporating that into kind of the the toolkit of of like ancient history and Classics departments in particular yeah so Within game reception so we talked mostly about Total War um but what other games have you incorporated into this aspect of your work and what are the criteria by which you make those choices honestly just like person see the criteria for like personal Fascination I I mean that's one of the things no is that we do what we do based off of something in your brain going oh that's neat and then you wake up like 12 hours later from the rabbit hole hole that you're in oh God what if I oh no that actually happened um for I did a a panel archo gaming panel for asor another one of these like big academic conferences um and it was on archo gaming and that one was on Pokemon uh how the Pokemon games uh kind of use these ancient um er like visual cues to go oh this is old because that's one of the neat things about Pokemon right it it began in Japan and then it quickly became more and more globalized so the game after
game they have to deal with a wider audience and they have to now develop their own lore so they're going oh God oh God uh how do we make this more complex but also manageable but also complex you know um so like oh ancient stuff oh this Temple how do we make it appear oh fluted columns um so a lot of like the visual cues in Pokemon are playing up you also have like traditional Japanese so it's a hodge podge I don't want to say like oh they're just doing you know fluted columns in no it's a hodg Podge because it reflects Pokemon's you know growing glob globalization that they have to talk to a bunch of people and they have to build this like conglomeration of antiquity based on different aspects and one of those is you know Greco Roman Antiquity um yeah so really like in terms of the topics it's really that's one of the neat things about game studies is is like you will always have something to mind and there will always be something new on the horizon like every morning I do my coin search uh there's a saluk at coins online hosted by the American D mismatic society and I just put in a random thing and I go okay let's look at some coins see if there's any inspiration strikes but intended uh but then I also open up steam and I look uh to see if there's any Roman Greek to see if there's anything new that uh you know
could possibly I just found I forget the name of it off the top of my head because I found it last week and again dissertation brain um oh yeah but yeah um it's this like you know indie game um it's a doom inspired shooter FPS uh but you play the role of the ghost of Caesar who is coming back uh to get revenge on his assassins uh but it's a doom FP like you know blocky chunky graphics and and you know fastpac combat and it's yeah it's like these C have good little taglines like kaisu ton and honestly honestly I have not yet played it it's on my wish list they have a demo up uh if you search like I I I forget out to top of my head the name of but if you search like Rome or Caesar it'll pop up on the the newest theme thing I think they also did their own like heavy metal soundtrack to it you know as one must do for a doom clone um but there's a lot of rewarding experiment and there's also a thriving mod scene that like there's so much to be done that's one of the things I really want to incorporate more um you know once the this is done and you know I can get back to other projects is to see how moders tackle this kind of stuff
um but yeah no heck and we were just talking about my my growing now fascination with um Magic the Gathering as I slowly sink into it because of these Commander boosters the the I forget what it's actually called like outter worlds or not outter worlds because that's trademarked um but like Expanding Horizons or something where you know IPS are now being uh uh decks are being made with different IPS and the Caesar deck from Fallout got me into magic I bought it last week and I also bought the nekron one because I'm a Warhammer guy um and necrons are my favorite even though they're more toic based um there's not really a saled faction in Warhammer that can be a you know but I'll deal with the toames um so there's like there there's just so much and it's continually like evolving there's always something new on the horizon uh and there's always interest in it uh and so I I think like in terms of how I pick the stuff it's really just what speaks to me that's one of the great things about it too is there's a lot of room so everybody can have like um what's that super Hades Hades like I played Hades I really enjoyed it but it didn't like I I I I I didn't feel the need to research it you know what I mean I didn't I I could turn off my research brain and just like enjoy it as a thing but other people are super Ham on it and they both enjoy it and they see it as a
Reser thing which is great I I I think that's also one of the great things about like studying games but also playing them is that it natur leads to kind of these like paths or or like these these oh I know the scholar super into this type of like game uh uh and they'll be super into this so it allows for that kind of like branching path more so than even like uh um I don't know like your bog standard academic research or something like that like oh I'm into information studies or whatever what have you yeah so video games are not the only kind of recept ception you do uh we mentioned some of our pre-chat and it's just sort of on your on your online presence that you're also interested in for example you told me that you have a chapter coming up about Cuban classical reception um how so what other kinds of reception do you do just for the people uh and then also how do you think that that links up or cross-pollinate with your work in video games so it's mostly those two it's mostly like a Cuban reception and gaming reception um both of them are in formed you know by by my growth as a human being I I'm from Puerto Rico uh my my parents are Cuban my my grandmothers are and grandfathers are Cuban um and g games have always been a component of my life so it's one of these things where as I research my
primary area of research which is nevertheless informed by my you know personal experiences I mean we just talked about how the the luids uh I I came across them in Rome Total War and the questions that I ask about Empire are neverly informed but of course never dictated by the experience that I've had in Puerto Rico and you know under the US seeing how the US systems are in place on the island and how Empire develops there um but yeah so it's those two aspects primarily and uh uh um but yeah in terms of like cross-pollination kind of with the the my primary area of research and stuff like that they allow me to kind of ask question or bring in things that I can then ask questions about so for example a my dissertation not on this my dissertation's very dry it's on archives I'm very interested in how people experience State archives and how you know the process of going into an archive putting your documents how that interaction kind of shapes salid order um but kind of the second big project that I have is looking at the saluca Army as kind of a force of a culturation how you know bringing these desperate people from all over the empire into this singular body that then goes out on
campaign for prolonged periods very frequently the henis of Kingdoms oh boy um we think of the Romans as bellicose but no no no no no there was already enough bellicosity before they came into the picture uh the ancient world was just like that um a uh one of the kind of the that second project is kind of looking how this force was a force of unification of kind of social cultural unification because you're in this Armed Force Greek is kind of the main way that orders get articulated at least from the top down you can sure you can have a guy as an intermediary and you likely did have a guy going hey these are the orders blah blah blah but you have this like force that's always out there and bringing people together on campaigns and a lot of that was brought on by you know looking at the salid roster and Total War and thinking about how armies move and everything like that but also like and uh Puerto Rican soldiers in the US Army they wear the same uniform you can't distinguish them you know unless they're you know I have this one picture uh that I use I presented on this I give a keynote on this um in in November uh I have this one picture at the end um where you have these soldiers these Puerto Rican soldiers but they're in US fatigues right because you know the Army naturally forces you to to say Le to to adopt the costume of the army um Antiquity less so but still um
and they're you know having they're playing the timbales guidos and everything like that they're playing you know local instruments um and the picture was taken in Guantanamo Bay so it's like you know you join this thing you can be part of kind of the Imperial project and so like it's all these things I I I I think as much as my study of antiquity informs the questions that I ask in you know gaming stud studies uh the the the opposite is also true that a lot of the questions or at least kind of the things that I pick up as I play you know naturally you kind of let them stew and you start go it's one of those like long shower thinks where the water's too hot you're probably burning yourself but you're like thinking about this idea uh and I've had a lot of those Because of You Know It Bo both know uh uh looking at kind of a Puerto Rican Cuban material but also like game studies and you bring that into the research that you do so it's one of these things that just like you know you you comp you compartmentalize it when you're on the job market or in your CV or stuff like that but all these things are just inter you know it's the same brain you're the same person uh you don't like shut off the salid I don't Dawn my saluk hat I guess more appropriately ZM oh you can do the petasos I guess that's more back
um fascination with headgear on coins is also kind of a thing um but also coins in video games is also a thing that I'm super so see like I work on coins so it's always this like and I think that cross-pollination just makes you a better scholar as long as you realize you know as you have to sum up different ghosts for each conversation but still like you're you're a person at the end of it and and like having this stuff is is just a neat way to kind of think about it from A New Perspective um yeah yeah I like it yeah I think it's very tempting you know I think when especially when you're doing academic work to kind of presents it's like this is this is a very objective study that's based on this hard evidence like okay yes yes there's evidence but every single person who does especially I mean even if you're doing scientific work you do it because it was something you were interested in yeah everything that we do is driven by who we are in the sense that we're all going to gravitate towards what we like naturally um but it also like people have this perception as as I'm sure you know that history is kind of this like particular histories let's go with that are are um you know objective there there's never no historiography the very Act of writing a history no matter how you know 19th century Prussian you are
about it no no no no no every single time that there is a historical account being penned by an even if you're living in the moment that you're like Caesar's battles yeah you think he's impartial no no like you just even if you the people were happy right that Caesar knew what to do when he shut up and no and and now you have these people that think see kais are in Fallout you know is this like I I he's not like a villain because he's more insid Insidious than that because the thing that he's selling in the Fallout games the thing that he's selling is civilization the problem is and Rule and like order of law yeah the problem is for whom so it's just these thing where like um like yeah it has a lot to do with just the the nature of the the questions that we ask in in or how we write histories has always been informed by like our life experiences no one no human being is able to like detach themselves you're not a robot like actually no I'm kidding um so this
actually Le me to another question though which is um you know the other thing is I find very very interesting especially about video games and reception studies is that a lot of scholarship now is being sort of conducted by talking to people who are doing mods talk to people on Reddit uh looking at comment threads how how do academics need to adjust in terms of both their perspectives and how they engage now that I guess kind of like the barriers between well I'm an expert and I'm at this University and I know this research like I know what I'm doing but I'm also interacting with maybe dependent on um lay people essentially for yeah research interactions how is that going to change Academia how's it changing it now and how do we handle all of that in a way that's both respectful and responsible I think we've gotten well some have gotten better about it I I mean you always have you always see that post hi historian here at the end of the thing and it's already an appeal to you know ah I have I have read blah blah blah and and that's all fine in Dandy um the problem is that a lot of these conversations also have to do with just the the nature of the University itself and the kind of changing aspect of it as it caters you know as price sore as a departments close and shutter and you
have not only you know um this term kind of has a pejorative uh uh you know the say Le arare historians you have people on on YouTube that do video essays on this kind of material but you also have so it's not only you know again I'm I'm I'm voicing the the voice of the this is not my personal but I'm voicing the voice of the dismiss of academic you not only have the Hoy pooy um but you also have and and you know professors but you have growing and this is just an unfortunate casualty of just the nature of you know a academic Staffing and the job market you also just have a growing number of people that are no longer in the the uh say the say the um rat face or like I don't know yeah the traditional pipeline I don't some some horrid roll the die system that is like Academia in terms of where you end up and L so I think that there that is another aspect of it um that has greatly facilitated kind of bridging this Gap un unfortunately um because we would have these impassioned scholars in departments but you know as universities do what they do and hypocritically Shrink departments cut everything down become more business oriented and stuff like that um you start having this kind
of third intermediary of people that have made it more their their passion to bridge this Gap and I think that that is a wonderful thing that is s my cat is just randomly meowing as they want to do he got you know it's cool see he put himself on the tippy top of the cat tower so now he's you know he's lording over like the eye of Sauron um B uh yeah in terms of kind of extending the hand or or kind of having people more and more involved in these academic you know air quotes uh discussions you you are seeing like conferences and workshops that are attempting to bridge this Gap more and more um so as much there's always a want to to turn towards pessimism and I understand that because what you spend six years you know more than six years heck I've been in this now 10 years since I started my bachelor and then I did my masters and now I'm I'm doing the doctors everybody you know we're passionate about this uh um you have to be because you yeah you have to be to to subject yourself to this so there's always this like kneejerk of oh people haven't been doing this for 10 years uh so why who are they
to say who are they to make this horribly informed video essay on this war or something like that there are dark sides to it like some of these channels like uh uh on on YouTube and stuff they get like oh yeah we're in like fake news creepy world uh yeah I've been I've been seeing what they're doing um and like are they paying their grad students that they're having write their scripts for them well like are they because Academia is exploitative already oh yeah we don't need we don't need our graduate students then like a big YouTuber going hey write this script for me uh and then not paying them so there's always that also um but I do think in in a kind of positive way again in the background of just like the university system is is not crumbling H depending on who you talk to crumbling or re organizing itself into something more horrid um better like that also opens the room for more of this talking back and forth talking uh um and like this kind of dismissal of the Ivory Tower for what it is and again a lot of the H do generation gaps also we were talking about that when we started talking about like argue gaming study a lot of that just has to do with generation gaps also um uh but yeah um I don't know if the
the cat now has the Zoomies uh so I don't know if I got to everything there yeah no I always ask because you know I I have plenty of like internal conflict about it myself because on the one hand I put the work in uh you know I'm a l teer i know what I'm doing also my PhD is in ancient Christianity I've taught New Testament many times so the number of opinions very much Jesus um so like the number of opinions that people have about what my work right that I consider to be highly uninformed is high yeah and figuring out how to balance between resp for other people commitment to what I see as the truth the fact that sometimes you do have to put some work in to have you know I mean it's it's a really really tough spectrum and I feel like it's getting harder because we also now live in an era of like well I did my research and that means that I Googled something yeah but at the same time you know our perspectives are not the be all IND all just because we researched it um there are plenty of people who come from anywhere who could have I mean you know it's like the classic Goodwill Hunting like go to the library yeah what book do you get in the library then like because that informs yeah no you're you're absolutely right um there there is no I no I I I share your your conflicting because on the one hand yes we don't need this like ah you ineffable like
academic person you get these like academic Superstars every now once in a while pop up uh no they're not infallible like just because they wrote a book on it does not mean so I think the problem is that yes we should like that's great because because everybody should be questioning to different degrees what people are saying because it's just the nature of it okay what source did you use okay what is that the problem is that people go into Source material and Source criticism without the toolkits that because they think oh history is just reading no it is but it's it's reading reading it's not it's not like I don't know let me read some Livy uh uh let me tell you this particular date I mean you you still have that like modern thing that history is just a and some people just want it to be that an uncritical view but that's just not how history does but the problem is that people then go ah yes because I read this Wikipedia page or I don't know I read this one book on it where the author and then you don't look at the footnote or the end if it's a book it probably has a damnable end note um uh and a lot of like you start seeing like Open Access is becoming more and more of a thing some I I have yet to wait into the the publishing water so my
ability to speak on publishing practices is a little bit i' I've I've done some like talking to Publishers but nothing more than that yet again I'm still finishing the dissertation um uh so open access does help to I mean there's 's also sites where you know academic books can be gotten I'm not going to say the sites um B there's say I might have a of very legitimate PDFs hiding on my Google Drive you know yeah no I've totally always gone to the library yeah I've totally always made the physical effort to go to the library instead of you know convenience um of finding a very popular book online um but yeah it's it's um it's difficult um and especially because you know as we we know history is becoming his history is becoming more and more you know like weaponized um and and uh like what is on Authority is is being more and more questioned um because you know now it's not only you're a historian are you a woke historian and or you know as if you know no historian ever has again it's it's just the nature of what people think history is it's never been just this yeah even in the analytic tradition it's a what do you include in a date that
happened and what you you don't include in a date that any single attempt to write down information historical information is an act of like agency yes there's never judgment in some waya even on a subconscious like if you don't mean it um uh and that's one of the things that I think gets lost in this translation from you know popular history or what have you um you know if you watch a VI a YouTube video essay on on you know I don't know the pelian war or something like that um how are they framing it what in in video essay it's even more interesting what images are they using because now you don't only have the information you know you don't only have uh uh someone speaking to you but you have a kind of visual thing that goes with the audio so how is that interplaying with the there's a lot of different it's great um that you know we have these these sources on YouTube and people are producing this content however it is for YouTube it is for they become like these like Mills for production of these things because there is actual finances involved in their production uh like as much as we like question the History Channel uh and their dubious amount of content YouTube historians are no less at fault in in what they decide to talk about what they don't decide to talk about how they decide to talk about
it it's still a thing like um so yeah it's it's great that we're having this like it's complicated because it is because that's just the nature of you know historical conversations and the the the meat and potatoes problem is that you know the appeal to authority of the academic yields must yield to the fact that what we do is naturally say say it's still our own production of it so what we offer to the table is that we know kind of the nuts and bolts of how the you know the the I'm so bad with these American Expressions how the the thing gets made how the what's the how the gets made how the sausage gets made we know a little bit more about you know the trends behind it how people have viewed history like historiography is a thing I think that's one of the great things about kind of this is kind of why I'm so interested in game studies is then we can bring out these greater historiographical questions into the discussion aside from ah you know oh here the armor is wrong because of course the reform did not occur until that's great and all sure there's a time and a place for that but there's also like more substantial
conversations that we can have about just like how devs uh uh like take history and historiography and kind of fit and Translate I like translating because translating doesn't have like negative connotations they translated because they're not doing this out of malice of course yeah um but they they translated into kind of again a game a gaming framework and stuff like that um so yeah it's it's complicated it's messy uh and it's only going to get I think Messier uh because a lot of it has to do with you know the the the culture that we're in you know the the the woke Wars part two part three I don't know what we're in right now um and then you know the universities are crumbling um there's also questions about content on like on Tik Tok and YouTube like monetization what does what does that do you know to to history with a capital H um so like it's messy uh um uh but I think overall I mean you know aside from the fact that universities are crumbling and everything I I think that the fact that you know social media and everything has made these conversations at least more there's always bad faith actors um there's always going to be there's them in Academia there's always going to be um but I think having more people in the conversation is never a bad thing um the problem is then you know when people
don't know they go into the conversation midc conversation they don't realize that that conversation's been ongoing since Antiquity uh you know you know what I mean like yeah well I mean even with an Academia itself like we're forever in negotiation with each other it's always a conversation yeah yeah I like it so there's so much more we could talk about actually but uh I want to respect your time so I will just ask the question I always ask people which is what uh games have been bringing you Joy recently you hinted at it we can we can gush a little bit here there there's been a couple um what is this one called I have it in my desktop um Age of Wonders 4 I have been playing a lot because that one is just a very nice again turn-based because turnbas lets me think that I'm enjoying life and then go back to the dissertation writing afterwards so I can take a turn and go oh dopamine and or is it dopamine which yeah right yeah and oh fun oh dissertation um uh I I have now in in terms of kind of recent Fascinations um Warhammer is is looming on the horizon because the department that I'm joining has actually a fair number of people that are into Warhammer and again like like when I was a teenager I used to play a lot of it um tomb Kings and necrons I know I know the ancient
historian going with like the two most like obvious nods um B tomb Kings at least are the tallest for for uh you know more ancient Egypt and then I like my necrons because at least modern necrons are more tmeic I I will die on this hill U modern necrons are more talic uh in their regards uh but also now uh Magic um I am very quickly developing an unhealthy habit uh with it um as it appeals to my like necromantic leanings uh I just like that ever since I was a I really like Undead stuff like spooky skeletons uh and all that and black is spooky skeleton color uh so I very much enjoyed that and also just looking at how uh I was looking at them this morning how in the Caesar deck they kind of so so I I initially bought the magic the Gathering Fallout Caesar inspired deck because I'm like oh I can look at it for like reception and stuff I I tricked my brain into going oh you can make this into a work thing and then quickly spiraled into not a work thing when I bought the nekron deck and then I'm planning to go with my partner afterwards downtown to get some card stuff um but like I don't know it's really neat that like I don't know they have decimation the Roman practice of I don't know if that'll pop show up on the
camera but it's leg at laneous uh Kaiser Ace and they have they turn Kimo this like punishment uh this semi mythical because of course we can nitpick about was it actually implemented because a lot of Roman historians like to go like oh you remember when the Army was so good and So like um well ordered we still do this today with like the US Army you still have these silly conversations about like oh you know those were real Roman army gone woke back in my day the Romans did this exact same thing there's always an appeal to noic appeal to the past and and the past is always like everybody was mean and like farmers and everybody was like you know more more severe because they lived a more austere lifestyle than our decad and ways now um and you know Decat you know you nobody want work anymore yeah one every one every 10 uh kick the bucket they they pummeled the heck out of him and then they turned it into a magic the Gathering game mechanic when leg l lenius enters the battlefield each opponent sacrifices the tenth of the creatures they control rounded up um never expected that in my life uh that I would I would uh see that but it's super damn neat uh so that's that's my current uh I'm I'm now super into um magic and then eventually I will um I
already have my my toam me inspired um H tomb Kings Army because now Warhammer is going back to the old world now they did that old world thing um so I'm very much looking forward to starting back my uh my uh toic inspired tomb Kings um and speaking of mods there's a mod for Total War Warhammer 3 uh that introduces a new faction where you have just skeleton hop lights uh and stuff like that so there if you want to what is it what's his name is it Harry Howen always get Ray Harry Howen the one who did the stop motion skeletons that's super famous and he did like the stop motion Medusa he did all this clay things so if you want to do you're like I think it's Harry Howen apologies Harry yes Harry how okay it's one of those names that you think is fake uh until you say it enough um but if you want to like go back to your Jason in the Argonauts uh stop motion skeletons with you know the hoplight Shields and the little uh Things download that mod I like a forgotten king or something I forget who's the modder again another instance where modding is great um but yeah those are my current f magic the Gathering and then Warhammer will forever uh Loom on the horizon as I can actually you know get back to painting and enjoying the hobby more fantastic and if people want to follow your work online where can you be
found oh I'm on Twitter why would you oh why would you subject yourself to my puns uh but uh I'm on Twitter uh that's basically it for the moment um I have a Blog but I haven't updated in a while once I get you know all my writing Focus has to go to the dissertation and once that's defended I can get back to you know some casual writing that I hope to get back into um uh but yeah Twitter and then I'm always up for emails or anything like that um I'm on the U Chicago Classics but as I said before next year I'm going to be starting in a new Department in Urbana champagne so if you want to you know any emails or anything like that any follow-ups uh you can check on the CL I don't know my email yet they haven't given me an email yet so yeah that'll probably be the best way to contact me is to do there yeah fantastic uh I of course for those of you out there can be found anywhere as Beyond Solitaire uh Eduardo thank you so much for coming on this is absolute delight and I am very much looking forward to everything that you've got coming next no thank you thank you for having me this is great this is a really uh wonderful way to start a Saturday morning actually is really nice chat and now I'll be sending you back to the new brutalist library no no all my things are online I don't think oh shaa I think I do have to get a book I have the tab open shaa I I oh say hi to the wonderful Regan sign library for me oh I will I will
domineering facade yeah uh and for those of you who are out there thank you so much for watching or listening please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming