Skip to main content
Loading video...

Sushi Go, Sushi Go Party & Sushi Roll - the EVOLUTION of a best selling product line.

Transcript 10:37

i received a review copy of sushi go party from the distributor so thank you to coiled spring sushi goes round on a conveyor belt right round and round in circles while diners pick their dishes they want to consume how about a little bit of wasabi to enhance your nigiri don't forget the puddings sushi go sushi roll and sushi go party all simulate the fun and excitement of watching raw fish rotate in card or dice game format i guess that's the hook i'm adam porter i design games and i review them with a particular focus on their viability as a commercial product the sushi go family of games is a known quantity spoiler alert they're viable i reviewed the first edition of sushi go back in 2013 the year it was released and i've been along for the ride ever since in this review we're going to be looking at the first edition the famous game right edition the creepy german edition the expanded sushi go party edition and the spin-off dice game sushi roll and i'll throw in a design challenge at the end for any budding inventors out there sushi go was self-published in 2013 by the then unknown designer phil walker harding it wasn't his first game phil's earlier card game archaeology had already received plenty of praise but sushi go was certainly walker harding's first game to make a splash two years after its release in 2011 seven wonders was taking the world by storm riding high after its kenishpield as yares win pick and pass drafting was a fresh new mechanism previously

reserved for magic the gathering tournaments and an unassuming 2004 card game called fairy tale as attractive and ingenious as seven wonders was he was also a bit bloody complicated all these icons resources phases and tokens in my videos i've been advocating design thinking for some time now and here's a great example of it in action walker harding understood his market he identified a need players wanted all the excitement of seven wonders without that hefty onboarding process in hindsight the solution seems obvious smooth off all the rough edges so that anybody could be up and running with the game in no time that's easy to say right now phil walker harding was the first to spot this opportunity and sushi go is still the most accessible game in its class walker harding's other inspired decision was in identifying a fitting theme what's going on in seven wonders why exactly are these buildings rotating around the table and how do they relate to the production of my hanging gardens sushi go on the other hand with its revolving dumplings mackie and tempura just makes sense the simultaneous release of a german edition from zok verlag and an international edition from game right introduced two new packages with distinctive new artwork game right didn't stray too far from the original with increased shading lifting the previously very flat sushi cartoons a little giving them a little bit more weight and depth and it's this version which struck a chord with gamers around the world while zok's edition never

really took off sad really because that's my preferred version of the game i'm a little bit biased zok verlag is my favorite publisher i love their distinctive art and graphic design choices and their edition of sushi go stands out as particularly grotesque because it's inevitably compared to the sickly sweet art of the game right edition i am just thrilled by the melting face of the pudding or the terrified expression on the mackie roll as it faces its inevitable demise in the stomach of a hungry german businessman regardless of addition the gameplay is identical each player holds a hand of cards with different japanese dishes on them they select one dish to keep and pass the rest on to the next player hence the cards move round and round the table until all have been selected and revealed in front of the players the dishes are then scored in various different ways so nigiri are worth one two or three points but that score is tripled if they're dipped into wasabi each dumpling is worth an increasing number of points so small sets don't score you very much but larger sets score big you don't get any points for a single tempura but a pair of tempura scores five points and likewise with sashimi zero points for one or two but a set of three is worth ten the player with the most mackie rolls gets six points second place gets three and puddings are saved for the end of the game after three complete rounds the player with the most pudding scores six and the player with the fewest loses six points and finally there's a chopsticks card which is worth zero points but it

allows you to take two items instead of one when a hand of cards is passed to you and the highest scorer at the end of the game wins sushi goes scores well on my engagement ladder analysis the theme is attractive and it makes good sense the interaction is constant with plenty of options to hold cards back to deprive your opponents of the stuff that they need there's a good degree of tension as you beg fate to offer up the cards that you need to finish off a set and the feedback is constant and generous and the game only really falls down on meaningful decisions sushi go isn't a game that you play strategically it's tactical choices all the way and luck will frequently dictate the winner of the game the overall score is nine it's not quite enough to reach the highest rung but it is achingly close it's astounding that the game didn't attract the attention of the shfield as yares jury there's no doubt that it was a mega hit plotted on my idea execution matrix sushigo sits in the top right hand corner an outstanding idea masterfully executed by gameright who packaged it into an attractive little tin at a very affordable price i think the next chapter in the sushi ghost story is particularly interesting game right clearly identified that sushi go was a viable brand and growing that brand was of benefit to the publisher and to gamers alike as a tiny game sushigo was never going to lend itself to expansions but to my mind the logical next step would be a range of standalone

card games with different dishes in each one of them but the same core gameplay perhaps those standalone titles could be mixed and matched to create unique combinations of dishes zoc verlag used this model for their card game series beastie bar and we've also seen a similar thing with the game similar but game right and walker harding didn't go this route instead they produce sushi go party a much bigger tin with tons of different cards which all score in different ways where sushi go had eight varieties of card the party edition has 22 eels onigiri edamame green tea ice cream each with a unique mode of set collecting in this package walker harding has really demonstrated the breadth of scoring options for designers of set collection games in any genre it's like a textbook miraculously game right have kept the fancy tin and provided the package for just a few pounds more than the original by packing so much into this standalone product it feels like game right has stifled any further opportunity to expand the original game i wonder if that's a decision which has paid off since we'll never see the standalone expansion model i guess we won't ever know but i can't imagine it's causing game right or phil walker harding many sleepless nights regardless of what could have been sushi go party is undeniably another massive hit it's telling that zok verlag abandoned their offbeat artwork when they released the german edition of sushigo party instead opting to use the cute artwork from the game right edition it saddens me a little bit i liked seeing those little

puddings suffer but the sushi ghost story doesn't end there players wanted more or at least that's what game right were banking on but that creates something of a dilemma with sushi go party apparently covering all bases what could a publisher offer to a customer who already owned the definitive tin phil walker harding answered that call with a reimagining of the original he set about solving the dilemma by positing the question how would sushi go function if it used dice instead of cards that's a familiar old design trick quarriers was created by designers intent on replicating a deck builder with dice and my own game throne answered the question how would a trick taking game work with dice instead of cards in 2019 sushi roll was released in sushi roll players each draw dice from a bag and add them to their conveyor belt players then roll their dice and in turn order players can spend menu tokens to re-roll dice and chopsticks to swap dice with those of their opponents finally you select a die to keep and you pass the rest to the player on your left each time you receive dice from another player you roll them before making another selection and once all dice have been selected they're scored in a similar manner to the original game after three complete rounds the highest scorer wins and sushi roll is a bigger less portable package than the original the plastic components dictate a higher price point although it is still very reasonably priced but inevitably the bulk of the product takes something away from the charm of the original the package is

bigger but the gameplay is really just as slight as the card game that's not to say that sushi roll isn't fun it certainly is and if there was ever a dream combination it's game right and phil walker harding both brands that i really trust they've rarely let me down and sushi roll really is no exception to describe a game as not quite as good as sushi go might sound like a damning critique but what it really means is sushi go is exceptional and sushi roll is very good indeed the real question is will there be a chapter four game writers previously created a trilogy of games with forbidden island desert and sky but to my knowledge we've yet to see them stretch to a fourth that hasn't stopped fans inevitably calling for sushi roll party so i've got some homework for you game designers go and design the next sushi go product don't worry about phil he won't mind it's a design challenge it's not a commercial strategy i'm not suggesting you pitch this stuff but you never know what ideas it might ignite for you sushi go is an incredible foundation to build on shoulders of giants and all that remember when reincarnation evolved his famous lost cities card game into lost cities the board game well why not make sushi go the board game what would that entail how about sushi go the roll and right there's got to be some scope there sushi go the poly amino game sushi go junior it's already so slight that one feels like a real challenge so how about sushi go master edition let me know how you get on subscribe to the channel hit like and i'll see you

next time all the best

Progress saved