5 Games Reviews - Ezra & Nehemiah, Rock Hard, Moon Colony, Cozy Stickerville & Wayfarers Tale!
Transcript
Hey everyone, it's Rado from BoardGameCo, and today I'm doing a round up review of five games that were all pretty okay. These were all 3.5 out of fives. I'm burying the lead here. That's the rating for all these games. You should If you just want to know what my rating is, every single one of these is coming in at a 3.5 out of five. Although I still think context matters, I still think the ups and downs, the highs, the lows, the journeys I've had with all of them do matter to a certain extent, and I will be going into my thoughts in a bit more detail on all of these. And yes, despite all being 3.5 out of fives, I'll still rank them. I'll still uh go through them in order from least to most favorite, how I feel about them, and why they have that score. Some of them are much better games that just aren't too long. Some of them are just okay games. Some of them are games that were great after the first play, but then, you know, 10 games later, not quite as much so. I do have thoughts on all of these.
Let's go ahead and dive into it. Although before we do, this channel is sponsored by All Play. More about them at the end of the video. Let's start off with what probably is my least favorite, and it's honestly just because I think I think it's okay. I think it's okay, and that's Rock Hard. Rock Hard 1977 over here. This is Devir's standout title last year, 2 years ago. I think it was I think it was Gen Con last year, if I'm not mistaken. I could be mistaken, but I only got around to it this year. And I I I think part of it, and part of why it's low down on my list, is I just don't think I'm pulled in by the theme. In fact, I would argue a step further, I would say aspects of the theme I find actively distasteful. Like I understand what they're going for, but as someone who doesn't care for the rock genre, it just felt like not for me. Rock Hard 1977 is basically a worker placement game. At the core of it all, it's a worker placement game. Plays across nine rounds, journeying through your career, and all that stuff, with a bunch of throw-ins and fun facts. And like there's I I I know even before I ever played the game, I had heard about the candy aspect, the candy being effectively cocaine or whatnot. And then you take that, you get an energy boost, or you get nothing, which is actually a super annoying mechanic. Overall, the problem with Rock Hard is that once you strip past the theme of it all, and they do a great job with the theme, if you're into the theme, which I just don't think I am. Not I don't think I am. I know I'm not. I I just don't care for the overall theme of this one. It's very charming in in terms of delivery, the candy is a fun little mechanism, but after all is said and done, it's a fairly vanilla worker placement game with a strong degree of luck aspect in too many areas for it to be overly satisfying, and the worker placement itself feels too tight, and
you constantly feel locked out of areas. It's still a good game. All said and done, this is still a good game. I've enjoyed playing it. I just think that part of why I never got around to playing this in the first place is I wasn't pulled in by it. When I finally did play it, I just don't think I was pulled in by it. The other areas in terms of nods to the rock genre, I guess I'm not against adult content in games to whatever degree. Again, this is more like drugs than anything else. I'm not against it if it pulls me in, but I think I think my sensitivities are just enough that if I don't care for what it's doing anyway, then I find it off-putting cuz I'm not even charmed by the fun of it. I can see like this is an interesting one. I think when it first came out, like maybe a eight when it first landed, and slowly dropped to like a 7.9, 7.8. I think currently it's sitting at a 7.5 on BGG. I think a lot of the hype has worn off. You know, that that drug high only lasts so long. It's fine. It checks all the boxes. It does what it's supposed to do.
Uh it's a fine game. A 3.5 out of 5. Moving in next from there, let's go with uh Wayfarers Tail. A Wayfarers Tail, this is a solid one where I played the uh print and play when it first came out, and then I finally had a chance to play it. I got this at UKGE. I've had a chance to play this several times, both solo and multiplayer. I've now gone through all the maps at this point, and I've gotten to see what this game is doing. Uh and what it's doing is it's a roll and write game. It's a roll and write game where you roll dice every single round. There's a mechanism as to who has which dice as you try to go ahead and wander around whatever particular map you're trying to explore at any given point. So, you're trying to move around the boards over here, marking off your journey, trying to figure out how to create a linking path in order to be mindful of the different scoring criteria you have, getting to places first. Every map has its own scores. There's an aspect of trying to create a longer chain of all the towns you visited. There's encounters you have along the way. Overall, you roll a bunch of dice, you use those dice to go through the various journeys. You're going to have these uh tracks on your board over here where you're trying to assign which type of person you use because everyone has a different way that they operate and a different dice mechanism that you're going to use to be able to move around the board.
Ultimately, roll a bunch of dice, use them to assign to actions, and then slowly explore the map. I I've played this I want to say I've played it five times. I could be mistaken, but I think five times, maybe six, maybe six. I think the first map cuz I played it one time solo. I've played through each of the maps and I think I played through the first map a second time. This is not counting the print and play, this is since uh the final game. It's been fine enough that I've enjoyed going through it multiple times and I wanted to explore every single map and see what it has to offer. Ultimately though, I think that as much as I enjoyed the original print and play when it first came out and as much as I've enjoyed this next step production, I think it doesn't wow me. I think it does a great job, it hits every box. Uh you get to go ahead and try to figure out how to slowly get the various treasures and rewards and uh maximize your points on these tracks cuz again, every time you assign your your movement so to speak to uh which person you're using each round, which which which grid you're going on, there is a point scoring aspect as far as how to maximize your points you get out of it in addition to the map scoring itself.
Overall, it's a fun challenge. It's just one that I don't think gets significantly different play to play. The different maps don't super change up the the the the gameplay. There's an aspect of like these extra encounter characters you can utilize. So, I recommend throwing it to your game after game one, honestly. But, all of them are fine. It checks every box in terms of being a good enough roll dice and move around a map. Again, if I played it six times or whatever it's been, it's not a bad game. It's a 3.5 out of 5. It's on the lighter side. That's my biggest issue is I think it's a little too light for me based on what I'm looking for these days. From there, let's go into Moon Colony Bloodbath. Moon Colony Bloodbath is a very charming one that I want to like more than I do. I feel like the cards are popping out here, you know, we'll deal with it later. I'll do it later. They're like they're coming out the top. I can see the lid lift over here. Uh but basically, Moon Colony Bloodbath is a game of everything falling apart. That's the hook of the game. Everything is indeed falling apart as you play through this game. What's going to be happening is you're creating a shared deck. It's a deck building game. Donald X. Vaccarino, the designer of Dominion, he's building a shared deck building game which you build a deck together that's slowly going to tear apart your colony. Moon Colony Bloodbath. Basically, what's happening is you're going to have these events that show up in your game. Those can be a little different. Well, the events are actually more of the same.
It's the more the uh twist cards that'll be different that change up what you're doing. But, you're slowly building a killer colony of robots. Uh, because as the game progresses, you're going to have a very small deck that gives you four actions. You can use those four actions to mine, farm, research, build, or restock, which are basically just different ways of building your engine. But, the tricky part is you're going to have these hands of buildings that go down in front of you. And the buildings you play are kind of going to determine how you want to take your actions, which actions are most beneficial. Maybe your farming action gives you an extra two people. Maybe your mining action gives you an extra resource. Each action can be different for you as you build your own personal tableau. And so, when you draw an action card from the shared deck, you all take an action. But, then the problem is you also draw event cards and twist cards. And you're slowly adding killer robots to your colony that are slowly going to to you wiping apart your colony even as you take actions to build it up. And so, the arc of the game is you can slowly build things up, but slowly but surely the deck gets fuller and fuller and fuller of killer robots, which means the pacing of you being to build up your tableau as the game progresses starts falling with your colony slowly falling apart until you eventually have to start scrapping buildings for population.
Because once a player runs out of population, that triggers the end game and the player with the most population remaining wins. That's the basic idea. Or, you can possibly survive but I haven't seen that happen yet in my plays. I am curious. If you've ever had a game of Moon Colony Bloodbath successfully get to the end without somebody dying, I am very curious and I'd love to know. Outside of that though, the basic game is charming. The theme is charming. The idea of it is very fun. The twist cards are different. Overall, it's a rollicking good time. Is that Is it a rollicking a good word? I think rollicking is a good word, right? It's a rollicking It sounds wrong. It's a rollicking good time. I think that's the word. Anyways, that's what it is. It's charming. It's funny. You laugh as you slowly lose your population as you ache and moan and groan about the fact that you're slowly having to kill another building in order to get more population to pay the tax as your people die around you. It is fun to watch happen. I just don't think it holds my attention a super ton amount. Like I've played this several times. Each play has been as they've been spaced out for the most part. So, I've still enjoyed it, but I've never walked away from a game being like, I need to play that again.
In fact, they just announced an expansion for it. And that's always a rough thing for me because I'm like, "Ooh, do I hold on to this till the expansion?" Maybe, but I don't think I need to. I think I'm happy to play this and the expansion whenever an opportunity presents itself. But, I don't think it's one that I need to hold on to until that point. It is both a good time in a world full of great games that that just didn't hook me enough. I can see why it's charming. I can see the appeal. For me, it's a solid 3.5 out of five as all of these are. I'm sorry. I'm going to go ahead and deal with the cards. Oh, no. Oh, no, that's horrible. That's I should not be doing this mid-review, but this is going to bother me otherwise. The cards are literally all over the place. They have slowly moved away from their This is the problem. This game needs a better insert because these You know what? Bear with me. Bear with me. I will be right back with you in a second because I I need to fix these cards before This is rough. This is rough. This is not what I wanted for myself. I shouldn't have opened the box.
I just I thought it wouldn't be as bad as it is and it's it's worse than it is. Okay. Cards are back in the box. Lid lifts is gone. It'll be a problem later. This one of those games that needed the the things in the bottom, the the punch boards or whatnot. It's not going to be better. Anyways, from there, let's go to Cozy Sticker Ville. Cozy Sticker Ville is the next on this ranking list. Cozy Sticker Ville, I am overdue for a review on this one. I finished this like a while ago. It's been in my been in my shelf for a while. It's always a little harder to show these games because like how do I show the components as I've stickered everything up? But, the basic idea of Cozy Sticker Ville is it's a sticker building game. You're going to have your little farm over here where you're trying to paste stickers at not farm. You're you're Sticker Ville. Cozy Sticker Ville. You have a board which you're going to be placing stickers as you build your journey, as you kind of encounter various characters, bring them into the world, build buildings for them, or find various encounters. Uh basically just taking actions every single round across the I believe it's 10 rounds every single game. I think I have to double-check. It might not be 10 rounds. It's 10 games, and then there's some number of rounds every game. Maybe it's 12 rounds. Maybe it's 12 rounds a game. That could be right. Whatever it is, it's a variable number of rounds every game, and there's 10 game sessions you play across, and you can play through this twice in a single box. You can dive back into it for a second 10-round play through if you want. I have played through this game twice at this point because that's is what what is what one is want to do if you have a two-round game. I think Cozy Sticker Bill, if you would have asked me my rating after, I don't know, three plays, I might have even given it a 4.5. Keep in mind, we're coming in at a 3.5 out of five right now. But I might have given it a 4.5 if I if you had asked me after like game three or four. Because the game is super charming. It is the coziest of cozy games. There are so many
games out there that call themselves cozy games that are not technically cozy games, they're just cozy-themed games. This is full-on a cozy game. You are applying stickers to a board. You are telling a story. You're crafting the narrative, and you're making choices about who shows up in your town, who gets to stay, which buildings you invest in, which storylines you chase. There is so much to do and not enough to do it in one game. Hence why this two-game arc, so you can explore more of the world. The downside of that is you do feel like you're kind of forced into the thing that made sense to choose the first time round, the thing that you were more thematically drawn to. To give you a random example, let's say you find a dog. Do you take that dog in? Do you not take that dog in? Well, every part of you wants to take that dog in. That's why you did it the first game. But when you dive into the second game, you're kind of like, well, I shouldn't take the dog in cuz the whole point now is to explore different aspects of the game, right? So I'm going to play in a counterintuitive manner to what I want to play. Now, don't get me wrong, there's enough choices in the game that on your second play through, you could probably still see like 20% new stuff even if you lean into things that you are drawn to. But if you really want to explore different aspects of the game, you're going to have to play your second play through counter to how you typically would make decisions, which is not necessarily a bad thing. But for a game that's all vibes based, I think a second play through is honestly, you don't need to do it. I think the best way to play this game is to play the game once as a full 10 game arc, and then pass it off to your friend so they can do what they want on the second play through of it. I think that's the better way to do it. The completion is aspect, you're not going to get after two games anyway, so you know, you may as well just skip that completion as aspect.
Going back to the core game, my biggest problem with it isn't that. If you're like, "Oh, that's why you give it a 3.5 cuz you played it twice and you burnt yourself out. That seems silly." No, by the end of 10 games, I think I was already at a 3.5. That other whole little monologue was a minor quibble. To me, the biggest issue is that the charm of the exploration, the charm of putting stickers out, all of that was great for the first few games, but it became clear as I continued to play that there was no real sense of actual gameplay here. The game decisions here is choose a sticker path that you want to explore, and then do the thing and apply the stickers. There's a very predictable path to the way most of these things play out, and I think that for me, while the story is fun and fine, the mechanics lost their luster very, very, very quickly. A few games in, seemed like I was on a good track. We're getting those uh, you know, getting those apples, that wood. We're getting that uh, that the fishing. We're getting money. We're slowly building up our resources. But after a few games, the arc of how it's playing out is very predictable, very samey, and it's really much more about your choice of how you're going to explore and who you're going to welcome into the town of Stickerville.
Which is fine. Again, I played through a full 20 games of it, so I certainly didn't mind it. Uh, but I think it's far, far, far more about the charm than it is about the mechanics. Do I recommend it? If you're into cozy things, absolutely. Uh, if you're into mechanically satisfying things, probably not. Which leads us lastly to Ezra and Nehemiah, or Ezra and Nehemiah, depending on your pronunciation. Uh, Ezra and Nehemiah is uh, from uh, Garphill Games, and I was looking forward to this one for a while. a very satisfying, very crunchy game. Uh, I I like the the the religious theme behind it as well. Uh, personal affinity over there. But overall, it's just a satisfying, crunchy engine that the box says is 120 minutes. The box is a bald-faced liar. That is why this is getting a 3.5 out of 5. You see, Ezra and Nehemiah, not because they lied, but because more context, more context. In Ezra Nehemiah, what you're going to be doing is you're building out the temple, so to speak. The walls fell down, you're building them up. You're trying to go ahead and actually You can't really see a ton from this track over here, but you have all these priest tracks. You're trying to get various abilities over here. That's easily the most fun part of the game because there's tons of abilities and the way you change the abilities are going to lead into how you develop your own asymmetric engine in this game, which is very important.
Meanwhile, you're contributing various resources to the actual temple in the corner over here, while trying to get your priest into the track over there. Honestly, I think I said priest twice. I don't remember all the terminology. You're moving your tent along this rondel over here, and you're slowly contributing to the altar, keeping the fires burning as you go through it, all while managing your own personal player board and the hand of cards that every single round you're going to be playing six cards to define these six actions you take with a kind of increasing tableau aspect to how you play the cards. It's a very, very clever. Everything about this game, mechanically speaking, is excellent. Garphill Games knocks it out of the park on their games time and time again. For me, this is definitely up there for me. Up there as far as the mechanical satisfaction of the game, this is probably my second favorite, maybe third favorite. Depends on where you put Hadrian's Wall. I think Wayfarers is still my favorite from from the games I've played. I haven't played all of them. I still need to play Scholars and Inventors. I have not done so. But overall, from the games, I think it's Wayfarers, then Ezra Nehemiah, and then uh Hadrian's Wall. Although again, Hadrian's Wall kind of had an arc as far as how I played it. Longer story there.
Point is, Ezra Nehemiah is a phenomenally well-done Eurogame that is incredibly crunchy, incredibly satisfying, and I absolutely, totally recommend it. If you're okay with the fact that it is a much longer experience than that 2-hour on the box will tell you. I do not think this is a 2-hour experience. I think this is a 3-hour experience if you play it with three people who know what they're doing, and it's a 4-hour experience if you play it with like four players who are learning the game or whatnot. I think I think if you really, really know what you're doing, maybe. Like I I'm sure I'm wrong here. I'm sure there are players who punched this out and managed to knock it out of the park and do whatever. I'm sure there are. I'm not one of those people. For me, this is a excellent game that is far too long for the experience I get out of it. That's the balance. If it actually was a 2-hour game, I think the amount I get out of it would be proportional for what I want. Because it's significantly longer, I find myself less drawn to it relative to other games that I can get more out of it. That's my biggest complaint. It's very crunchy.
It's very satisfying. It is too long for what it for what I personally get out of the experience. So, overall, it comes in at a 3.5 out of 5 despite being my favorite game on the table because context matters to everything. Those are your five game review roundups. We have Rococo 1977, totally fine every way. I don't think it impressed me in any way. We have Waifer's Tale, again kind of same story just a different weight class. Rococo is a little heavier. Waifer's Tale is on the lighter side. We have Moon Colony Bloodbath, which is a charming charming experience that I think is very whimsical and I'm just I'm not as there for the whimsy. We have Cozy Sticker Ville, which is very cozy, very light, and not mechanically satisfying. And then we have Ezra and Nehemiah, which is incredibly mechanically mechanically satisfying and yet way too long for the experience it delivers. At the end of all of it, we have five five we have five 3.5s out of fives all for a variety of reasons. I mentioned at the beginning of this video that All Play is a channel sponsor. If you go to allplay.com, you can find a bunch of games both from themselves as well as their partner publishers.
There's a whole host of publishers out there that have joined Garphill Games you can go to not join not Garphill Games joined All Play. I believe a recent addition is Plaid Hat. So, if you want any Plaid Hat games, you can check those out. And if you're in the US, you can get $4 flat rate shipping on anything you can combine from any number of publishers on the site. And in any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. Hopefully you found these reviews helpful, and as always, I hope you have a good one.