5 Games that are BETTER than Wingspan
Transcript
so first we better talk about what I mean when I say five games that are better a lot of people will comment on my videos and they'll say you can't say that one game is better than another it depends on the person and that's true in fact when I rate games I rate them on five attributes theme mechanics components strategy and complexity and when I rate those attributes it isn't always the case that having a higher score in one attribute makes a game better for example consider complexity some people really enjoy games that are complex and have lots of rules and lots of factors to consider when making decisions whereas other people want something that's a lot less difficult to learn and easier and more relaxing to play so depending on that person they might like a more complex game a higher score or lower score either one could be better if this is something you'd like to explore more as a software developer I've actually built a tool that will help you find your perfect board game formula what it does is it allows you to choose from a collection of several games arrange them in order of your own preference and then using your preferences it will tell you what attributes you appreciate most of all which things you should avoid and give you a personalized list of games that are a match for you so you can find that on the perfect boardgame.com and of course I will also leave a link in the description so if I'm going to make a list of five
games that are better than wingspan well what exactly do I mean by that what I've done is I've looked at wingspan and I've identified a few characteristics that I and some other people think could make the game a little bit better and then I've looked for that in other games that's primarily what I'll be talking about in this video but that's not all there is one more thing that can make a game better and that all comes down to deciding which game to buy see I enjoy a lot of games but when I go out to buy games for myself I get most excited when I find something that my friends don't have or a game that they have never heard of before going out and buying copies of games that my friends have isn't a great use of my resources because if I want to play that game well I can go play with my friends and in this case wingspan is a very popular game that lot of people maybe not you but a lot of people already own wouldn't it be nice to find a new or lesser known game that is as satisfying as wingspan but maybe something new to bring to the table so I have games on this list that satisfy both of those criteria some of them which I would argue do some thing better and then others that are simply games that are very similar to wingspan but are new or lesser known now all of
the games on this list however do have gameplay characteristics in common with wingspan as well as something thematically in common with wingspan so all of these games are very beautiful pieces for the table they have excellent components and artwork as so many people Rave about when they open up the box of wingspan components thank you the first game on this list is a game that I would describe is in the same flavor as wingspan we're talking about a game that has a natural theme beautiful artwork and has a nice easy going flow to it that is complex enough to keep things interesting but not too involved to be overly heavy it's called Trailblazer the John Muir Trail in Trailblazer players are going to be advancing along the John Muir Trail collecting observations and achievements as they move along it's essentially a worker placement game where they'll be drafting cards and adding it to a tableau as well as gaining patches for their achievements that they'll put on their backpack kind of like putting birds in your portfolio in wingspan but as you acquire more patches or achievements then actions that you'll take later in the game will be augmented and improved and you'll have many resources that you'll be managing in order to make sure that you can continue your prog progress along the trail but
more than anything else Trailblazer the John Muir Trail is just so satisfying in its artistic and natural beauty the artwork in this game is just gorgeous and it creates very much the same impression that a player gets when they're playing wingspan and that's why I put that on this list along with the fact that it's also brand new so if you want to take a look at that of course there are links in the description the next game falls into a category that I very seldom cover in fact this is the first time I've ever recommended a game like this it is a print and play game meaning that you can download it right now print it out and start playing today I got a little excited about it so I ordered my print and it was done by a card printing company but the game is called birdscaping and it's only 18 cards this is actually a micro version of wingspan and it's designed by Joe clipville who does Micro versions of a lot of popular games but this one like wingspan has cards with birds on them and all of the birds have their own effect and they have a food cost just like in wingspan in fact when you attract birds what you're doing is you're attracting Birds into your backyard so you're birdscaping when you track them and you put them in your yard you're putting them in three rows
very much like wingspan but the big difference is they've trimmed down the deck to just 18 cards and they've given each card multiple purposes so every card serves as the bird that's depicted on it as well as something for food so as you're holding your hand of cards you can either add a card to your tableau or you can discard a card to use the food that's depicted on it so once you discard cards for food they go in the discard pile and after you've played the first round the first round you rotate the deck and you play the second round by taking the discard pile shuffling it and it becomes the draw pile again so you actually just go through the draw pile four times as you go through the pile and you keep adding more and more cards to your Tableau you gain enough power on your Tableau that eventually you don't have to spend so many cards from your hand that's kind of the fun this is a really elegant adaptation of a portable version of wingspan and I had to cover it even though it you know clearly it's designed in the style of wingspan so it lacks originality in that regard but the way that they were able or the way that he was able to uh make a micro version with such streamlined mechanics really impressed
me so I wanted to share that the game birdscaping with a link in the description that you can use to download and print the next game is a new game it came out in 2021 and it's gaining some traction I'm seeing it in more places these days but it's still something that I've got to let you know about if you haven't tried it out already it's the game Meadow and I have it on my shelf so Meadow is a game that I I'll be honest I judge this box by its cover I am not impressed by the cover art here at all I just don't like the layout or the font or or something about it but anyway I saw that it was a card game I like games that have a little bit more complexity usually but when I was doing the research from this video I finally decided to take a closer look at Meadow and wow this is a card drafting game and much like wingspan you're drafting cards of animals that would belong in a habitat you're putting them in a tableau in front of you and all of those cards are giving you some sort of benefit that helps you get more cards as the game gets played so a little bit of an engine builder a little bit of this card collection mechanic as well as satisfying various objectives but the way this one was done I thought was really Innovative I'm very accustomed into card drafting games where you draft cards in a line normally you pick up the card and then after you do the LIE the
line slides down and fills up the spaces but in this game you're drafting from a grid the way you draft from a grid is you have these tiles you place them along a row or a column and the tile that you place has a number on it you get to pick up the card that is that distance away from the tile you place and you're blocking that row or column from somebody else's tile so there is some really interesting competition because you're competing for the sides of this grid to get the cards that are easiest for you to build or if you can't or don't want to take a card from the grid you can use the secondary action on your tile by placing it over by the campfire and when you do this there are several actions such as being able to build two cards in one turn or drawing cards from one of the decks or taking some landscape tokens a few different things that you can do to improve your position so at the end of the game you're going to have collected victory points for Landscapes found items in the animals that you've added to your Tableau so that may sound a lot like wingspan what really makes this game better one of the things that I really enjoy about Meadow is the connection between the cards that you place every card that you get is going to require some food or resources in order to survive in your Meadow so before you can
add that card to your Meadow you have to have cards that will support it in the ecosystem and all of this is really really intuitive like for example if you wanted to add a bird to your Meadow that bird might require a tree and an insect which means you're going to have to build those cards first and then once you've added your bird to that Meadow it consumes the insect and so if you want to add more birds or other spiders or frogs or any other animal that needs to eat insects you're going to have to keep adding those so you start building your Meadow with just with just ground tiles just different kinds of Landscapes and very very basic bottom of the food chain type creatures and from there you start adding things that are a little higher on the food chain and worth a little bit more victory points eventually you're adding mammals or even predators and birds of prey so there's a really nice chaining effect and the chaining effect plays nicely with your intuition on how things should work the next game on this list is better than wingspan and better than Meadow because both of those games still have one thing that I don't find quite satisfying it's that mechanically the games are just kind of slow you spend a lot of time waiting for your turn as you play these games and there's not enough player to player interaction to make waiting for your term extremely exciting now I've played Meadow several times with my family and we've really enjoyed it but man I really like
something that keeps me engaged more even when it's not my turn now this game does that and this game is still stunning and has a natural theme it's also brand new in fact I haven't got my hands on it yet but you can play it online or you can try it out on tabletopia so I'll put some links in the description you can also pre-order this game the game is called Earth and I have some footage that I took from playing it online which I'll show you but in Earth it's another Tableau building game right the objective of the game basically is to get more cards to get victory points and satisfy objectives just like these other games we've been talking about but here's really what sets it apart first you are going to be managing just your own Island and so you start the game with Geographic and climate characteristics about your Island as well as some objectives about your ecosystem and gameplay is going to go by players taking a turn being the active player so when you're the active player you can choose one of four actions each of these actions has a different color and it has two effects the first effect is the effect that applies to you and the second effect is what applies to everybody else so on everyone's turn everyone else will always be doing something it'll be a minor effect for them much like uh
Puerto Rico or San Juan so you choose your action and simultaneously everybody performs the secondary action and then everyone gets to trigger the cards in their Tableau that match the color of the action that was chosen so you choose the red action and you can trigger all of your red cards there is a really interesting uh catch about the cards you trigger you have to trigger them going from top to bottom left to right so you go through and you're chaining these effects but the position of the cards actually matters it matters for what you can do on your turn and it matters for objectives that you're trying to satisfy so ultimately you keep playing this way with people taking an action it triggering something for everybody else as well as the cards that they've built during the game and you're trying to compete for a few object objectives that are public to everybody as well as a few private objectives and conditions on the cards you've built so really excited and thrilled to find this game definitely going to be a great one for anybody who loves wingspan but is also kind of bothered by the slow pace of the game so that is Earth before I give you my final recommendation of the five games that are better than wingspan I wanted to do a few honorable mentions I'll go through these games quickly but they may be worth taking a look at the first is Arc Nova this is another game and this one you're building a zoo and you're putting animals into their exhibits it's an
excellent game it is much more complex than wingspan and it's already very popular so I didn't want to feature it on this list but if you haven't tried it it is a game that I do recommend and I have done a video about it the next is a game called canopy canopy is another stunning Tableau building game but it is only for two players and I left that one off in favor of birdscaping which is a two-player game itself before I learned about the game Earth another recommendation I was going to put on this list is Kanagawa Kanagawa is a game where you are an artist learning skills and you use those skills to paint different uh parts of a mural that you're working on for victory points so on your turn your drafting cards either for the skill they give you or you're using the skills you've collected so far to paint that into your mural beautiful game Kanagawa the next game is actually more of a dishonorable mention it's a game that I would not recommend or I might feature it on a list of games of five games that are worse than everdel I feel bad saying that but I can't help it the game looks like it was made to be compared to wingspan and so I looked at it and I was really disappointed it's called bird watcher now bird watcher much like wingspan is a game where you get points by collecting Birds you're like a photographer but a huge problem
with this game is that you actually are incentivized to get birds that are the same type of bird you actually have a deck of cards with with multiple copies of the same bird and you want multiple copies so whereas in wingspan you want a diversity of of birds that makes a lot of sense in this game you you could actually do better if you have fewer Birds it that doesn't work for me also you're a photographer and when you take a bird's picture presumably that bird flies into your portfolio like it leaves the tree where it was at well how does that make sense that seems more like bird Taxidermy so thematically mechanically there was so much about this game that just irked me and I um would not recommend it I don't do a lot of really bad reviews but man very disappointed not a game I would recommend and given that it's a attractive Bird game I thought I would let you know however I do have an alternative about photography that I think some photography enthusiasts would love now not really my game I've got to say but oh man this is what a photography theme looks like the game is called Redwood and during the game you are actually positioning yourself and using cameras with different lenses in order to take in a view and you'll get points
for what you can fit into your photograph now the animals in the environment they don't fly into your camera like they do inside of bird watcher but you you you get points from the pictures you take just a gorgeous implementation of a game about photography a little too like technical with like the moving and and it's not really my style of game but gosh if you haven't heard of it you might really want to take a look at Redwood so that is my list of honorable mentions now let's get to the number one recommendation for a game that is better than wingspan now before I show you the game I've got a preface by saying that this game is surely the least like wingspan in how you actually play it has a very different weight whereas wingspan probably has a complexity of about four this one has a complexity of about two very simple game if you wanted something that has the same level of involvement same duration I would recommend Earth or Meadow but the thing about this game is that we've already had so much fun playing it and I only found it because I was doing research for this video yet we have played it we love it we're going to play this game until all of the cards are worn out and we run out of score pads we love this game no matter how simple it is if a game is fun
I don't have a complexity bias I'm not only playing complex games I love simple games too and if you can get behind that then this is truly the best game on this list it's called birds of a feather so birds of a feather is another Bird collection game because I wanted to be consistent with the theme like I said the game is very simple so I can go ahead and tell you all of the rules right now it plays for two to seven players although there's a slight variant for two or three players and for each game all of the cards are going to be dealt so a player is going to be holding their cards and every single card has a bird on it and an environment so this is the black throated sparrow that lives in the desert now the players are going to be playing and revealing their cards simultaneously and the card they play represents the environment they go to for bird watching so if I played this card it means I'm going to the desert we flip it over and then immediately every player scores for all revealed birds in the environment that they played so if I played the desert I would score the black throated Sparrow as well as any other desert Birds that have been played now all of those cards get moved into the center of the table and you go to the next round the next round you play another card from your hand it's exactly the same as the previous round but now and for the rest of the game you will score for the birds
that were played as well as the birds that were played in the previous round so for example another player might want to score the points for the desert so they play a desert bird and they score everyone else's desert bird and my desert bird after that the cards in the center of the table that they fly away the new cards move in we do another round now everyone is exactly like that there's a scoring card everyone gets to keep track of what birds they've seen there's one other change about the rule which is that some birds are the predatorial birds they are the Raptors if you play a raptor then the Raptor scares away all the birds in its environment so this one in the forest would scare away any other Forest birds that were left behind so you can do that if you're trying to prevent your opponents from collecting birds that were played earlier in the game that's the whole thing you get scored based on different kinds of birds you've collected if you get a full set of one environment that's worth more points and it plays very quickly we're talking less than 15 minutes it's such a light game it's such an enjoyable game and thematically I think this game is so um just beautifully done it makes so much sense you're playing a card to go to a certain environment because you're hearing about the birds that are there when you get the bird you don't take it because you're just observing it I love
that it captures the nature of observing Birds and it's it's gorgeous um it's probably a game that some people they want something a little bit heavier and if if you're looking for heavier games I'd give you plenty of options this is a great kind of like play a quick game before dinner or play a nice game after you've played a longer game I really enjoyed it birds of a feather my number one recommendation for a game that is better than wingspan so I hope that you found these recommendations useful if you'd like to check out more you can always go to the perfect board game where in addition to that quiz that I mentioned earlier in the video you can also look up the editor recommendations now as of today I'm going to be adding my recommendations for games that are better than other games out there with notes on each one so you can take a look at that um and I hope that I'll see you next time take care bye