Beyond Solitaire Podcast 165: Marceline Leiman on Designing Solo Modes
Transcript
it's adbreak time the Beyond solitire podcast is proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as usual they are up to some amazing things they recently concluded a successful campaign on backer kit for eyeball to eyeball a lar about the Cuban Missile Crisis late pledges should be available soon clgs is also still offering a certificate in applied game design and the next class is going to be it's all in the cards designing card and card driven games taught by demon Stone he's a brilliant teacher and his students love him so you should sign up the course starts August 26th also just a quick plug for myself if you want to support the show and help you be going uh please do go to patreon.com beond soliter which page for all of my hosting and subscriptions associated with the podcast and channel thank you so much for listening and let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davids from Bon solitire and this week on the pot I have a very special guest this is Marceline Lyman and she is a solo game design Enthusiast like myself and we're gonna talk about solo game modes today how you doing Marceline I'm doing great thanks for having me I'm I'm really really excited to get started because I've been such a fan of this show uh really since since close to the beginning uh I recently learned that you started uh the podcast close to when I actually began my game design Journey as an adult um so to me I just always assumed you've always been there uh and so for me that's that's been absolutely true and so it's such an honor to be here yeah I appreciate that
also I sort of feel like I don't know the world just changed in 2020 and so really like what H What mattered before that you know um yeah I mean I had a totally different life before 2020 yeah so you mentioned your adult game design life so what was your game design life like as a child oh okay so uh when I was a kid uh I was very creative my family I've come from a family of six so I have three other siblings and we constantly you know played games with each other played pretend a lot of theater of the mind kind of things we like to uh form for our parents whenever they'd come home uh and I remember in first grade uh I made my first ever game uh it was actually an assignment from my teacher to make a board game based off of the Lion The Witch in the wardrobe which was our summer reading and so uh it was supposed to be a group assignment I'm pretty sure that I ended up doing it alone um and so uh I remember I still think this game was extremely badass I actually don't have it anymore but uh it was basically like a classic Roland move like inspired by um Candy Land or Monopoly things like that but whenever I get into this with people people are like wow that actually was a really in-depth version of
Candyland um so I was just a really really excited kid to be like exploring games cuz up until that point I had only played like video games games like Pokemon and things like that so um I think going into that space I was able to like express myself um but I but at the time I really didn't think of it as game design actually at all I didn't realize that what I did as a child because I went on to you know make Mario Party clones you know my own little like tiny games that I could show to my family trivia games um and it wasn't really until I started working as an adult in games that I realized uh that all those things that I had done as a child led me to this moment that um what I thought of as play was actually design um and so I think that's still true about me I think I still have a very playful approach when it comes to design I I have a really fun and great time whenever I make games um and so I'm yeah I'm just really really in love with with this process that's awesome so back to adulthood uh what do uh what what solo mode might people know you for and then what do you think they might know you for soon let's just get like the the overview of your work to date yeah so in uh 2019 um I was working as a video editor
and I decided I am kind of miserable doing this so uh mostly because I didn't want to be stuck looking at a screen for my entire life I kind of saw the road ahead of me and I didn't like the way it looked um of course now as I'm working on games I'm using screens a lot um when it comes to either testing or balancing sheets of numbers um but uh the game that I was tinkering with at the time was Oceans uh which is a Evolution style uh Evolution family game from Northstar games and so uh at the time oceans had been on Kickstarter and was beginning to fulfill and I was one of the backers of that Kickstarter uh shortly after I received my game I got an email from Dominic crappy shett he sent out like a general newsletter saying like Hey we're generally interested in Solo mode design if you have something we would love to see it and so this was not an email to me specifically it was just a email to the community but I took it um to Heart thinking like that actually sounds like something I could do like I actually really like Evolution I really like oceans I can try to do that um and then after months of trial and error uh I I failed I failed real hard I didn't like what I was producing um and so I shelved it um as I continued to work on other little things tinkering around and in January
2020 you know on the precipice of the pandemic uh it was my birthday and I told my partner that I wanted to go back to school for game design and so I had just missed the cut off um for applying to schools uh so I had a year to prepare and fortunately that year wound up giving me a lot of time because the pandemic happened um and so I was able to you know just prepare and in the middle of that I um you know my brain was thinking more about oceans again and so um one day after like night of thinking through what the problems were that I was suffering through in the prior iteration of the project um I woke up with like a fully a full solution like fully solved out uh and I tried it I just the first thing I did didn't even put on pants I didn't eat breakfast I just grabbed a cup of coffee set it up on my table and tried it out on the table and it worked it actually worked really really well and I was super excited about it and so uh I played two games GES just to validate that this is actually good and I took a picture of my table and I shared it on Twitter and what this ended up doing was um kind of exploding as to to the degree that my own account at the time was able to explode you know I got I was getting like 50 uh likes and I'm getting a bunch of comments and at that point it was just like an enormous amount of people that were interacting with me um on the
internet which is you know wild at the time um and so uh I knew from that moment like oh I'm doing something good like this is the first time that the internet has told me that I should do that um that what I'm doing is something that they that is that is enjoyed that that it looks cool that it sounds cool either the way I'm framing it or or what uh and then I got a DM that same day uh from Dominic and he said hey that looks really cool could we try it and I said uh yeah if you give me a week I'll write up rules and I'll send it to you um and that is basically it everything else just kind of came out of that moment uh and Dominic was so sweet he um he assigned Ben Goldman who uh used to work at the company there to work with me and kind of Mentor me uh through the development of this game Ben himself is not like a solo designer but he's one of the primary designers on oceans so he really really helped me understand the system gave me feedback um made help definitely helped me streamline things a lot um but uh yeah it wound up just being a nice year where I worked really uh intimately with Ben and got to get his feedback and I still think of him as one of my uh first mentors in the industry what is so cool about this to me is that you know we think about oh
you need to go to cons and oh you need to make sure you know people and oh you need to pitch but some times you know if you just make something and put it out there it ends up in the right hands or on the right tables yeah I think about that too with um what happened with Gloom Holden recently like um that was a a project that was uh originally posted to BGG as just like a inhand kind of game version of a of Gloom Haven and then recently got re-released as buttons and bugs and became like a full-on product so I think it's really cool seeing the track where fans can become designers um and how that is such an accessible space because you really just have to participate in um things like you know uh contests game design contests or in my case a Kickstarter where I learned about their interest in accepting design um because until that point it didn't really occur to me that a publisher is going to publish my work I I had no idea what the process of pitching was it they came to me um which was yeah a really really awesome opportunity man that's so cool um so were you always a solo gamer like did you want to design solo modes because you were already gaming solo a lot or did you just kind of see it as a fun design Challenge and go down the rabbit hole uh no actually I had never played a
solo game before designing oceans um once I started desending oceans uh I started going down the rabbit hole from there uh that's tends to be how my interest kind of go it's like oh I'm interested in doing this thing I'm G to try to make it and then I just immerse myself afterward which helps inform if the instincts I had were the right ones or not um and so with oceans uh going into it I was definitely kind of like discovering a lot of what is now known as like common knowledge but I was able to discover a lot of it either through trial and error but also by listening to voices in the industry such as uh your selfless or you know um autona Factory or you know like seeing and uh listening to and reading a lot about people's experience designing games their philosophies designing games um I was kind of able to express um my own Voice through this shared Collective knowledge that was just accessible on the internet how has your relationship with solo gaming developed since you started getting into it is it something that you now do like do you play solo games uh I actually have tapered off my in my personal play of solo games um since the pandemic but during the pandemic I was very deeply deeply into solo games um Pack's premere really like
in rapture me I would I just loved how simple it was and yet how complex of a game it was um if you I I've written some game design Diaries I wrote one on Ocean solo and in it I reference um the the design for the wakan in PX Premiere um being just a simple deck flip of a card um and all the rules for the solo mode Cascade out of that simple uh moment and and and the fact that you don't have to make any decisions um for the wakon ever uh that to me inspired so much of my own decision making I didn't realize at the time how important that that game was in in me playing it but it's something I think about all the time when I work on solo design even now uh so I know that you're working on at least one other solo design so what can you disclose yeah so uh just recently we uh I'm I'm currently working part-time at Underdog games uh they're known for making the trekking Series games so trekking the national parks trekking the world trekking through history um and so we recently released in Target trekking the national parks which is uh technically my first product ever in a big box store so that's very cool um I designed the solo for the Third Edition of this game uh which you go play now uh and it
in the philosophy for that one was very different from anything else I'd ever worked on because I knew that this specific product would be played by you know families family plus level Gamers um maybe even players who had never played a solo game before other than maybe Solitaire uh and so for that reason it had to be incredibly simple incredibly straightforward to run uh easy to understand uh the strategy around like how to thwart the AI uh and so I approached it from the same way that um I saw in the wakan where it's just the flip of a card and it shows you all the decisions that the AI is going to make uh although it being a simpler game it makes two decisions and then it's your turn again um and so and Performing those decisions is is much much simp simpler uh because it's just such a simple game but uh it wound up being an approach where I started thinking of this more as an arcade game so like I grew up a lot playing arcade games even though like I didn't grow up in the 80s there were still arcades when I was a kid at pizza places and um I love like those kind of like small bite experiences and it kind of continued into my love of video games where like I like Rogue likes today I really like these games that are um you you play
them and when you walk away you just take whatever you put in you don't um have to come back to finish a story I do love games with narratives and with these like longer campaigns but um there's something juicy to me about approaching games in this like one setting kind of uh Vibe and so with trekking the national parks I kind of approached it sort of like um either Pac-Man or Tetris or like whacka I tried to think of like what is the kind of like system that Gamers that may not have ever played a solo mode are familiar with uh and so these specific tle like 10 poles of like game design felt like familiar but also interesting because I'd never really see a lot of solo modes that uh are okay with breaking from the the mold of the the multiplayer game itself um because some games they are designed to be like more Solitaire and with only some like minor blocking and so um when you have a game that is fully solitire you sort of have to simulate those touches that the other players do um participate in even if they don't always directly impact you so things like um racing to get certain cards or um removing cards from a draft or um uh being in your way blocking
spaces you wanted to go through or step on um things like that and so it's often more important to think about like where are the touchstones that the other players will would inhabit if they were here and try to incorporate that into this game the problem was that um if I were to just try to design a otoma that is meant to be a player um a player is making way more complex decisions as far as like how what is the best way to find the line like how do they find their line and uh score those points in order to be competitive and I found that for this particular system it made it just made more sense to me uh especially for the weight of a solo mode that I'm specifically trying to create to uh abstract it away from the position of being a player and more towards being an antagonist and so uh basically these moles pop up out of holes and you need to go Flack them otherwise they're going to cause issues for you and if if you don't thwack them uh you are if if you choose to thwack them they are often uh distracting you from your like primary goal and so uh it kind of gives the same feeling of having multiple having your personal goal but then also having this other thing that is uh causing you to not just make perfect decisions um so yeah that's that was for treking the national parks and then
trekking the world which was recently on Kickstarter um I kind of it's funny because the two designs I ended up bouncing back and forth a lot between the two just because of the nature of the production schedules we had and so uh you'll see uh between the two and trekking The World Is Still fulfilling so it's not out uh now uh for the second edition but between the two there are like similarities but also key differences in the decisions that I made for like how they behave like a person um they still have like this whack-a-mole element but uh because of the um the complexity of trekking the world compared to trekking the national parks uh and also knowing that the same customer is going to be buying and playing this game and also the same possible customer this could Trek in the world could be their first solo mode ever I had to approach it even with though it's a more complex game from the same perspective of this game also needs to be simple and easy to learn easy to play um and so I approached it from that same wacka element um but instead because of the uh all of the other complex elements of the game more complex decision making um I removed some ele elements in order to balance out the cognitive load that a player might otherwise feel and so I think what
I learned between these two projects was like a person is not a perfect machine they can only you know perform and think through whatever is in front of them and it's really hard to kind of like actually think through like why is the machine doing this um especially when you're also trying to keep in in your head like what am I doing how am I trying to win and so both of these projects kind of were my own attempt to balance the cognitive load of like player decision making with um with the game itself the system and how complex each of those are and again we're talking about like family plus level complexity games but um because of the customer and who they are I had to be uh very careful with like making it too complex yeah that's a really interesting way to look at it one thing I find very interesting when I'm looking at kind of discussions of solo games um and you know you always think through through it yourself if you're a hardcore solo player is I think a lot of people say that what they want is I want to play against an automated opponent that really feels like playing against a person and operates like a person like that's sort of like the version in your mind right if you could that's what you'd have but that's never actually usually the best like decision space especially for a lighter game if you're actually making a solo design because to play against a person you
have to like actually run a bot that thinks like a person and then you have a mess like a flowchart and I mean I'll play flart Bots I don't like to make flart flart Bots yeah um I I personally can't stand them I I don't like having to look through even though there's like absolute decision being made I don't like the processing power I have to put in the energy I have to put in to process it um I know that like um I'm actually very critical of like a specific design I have never really played David tsy designs um because those are just not the games I tend to buy but I did buy um uh Mythic mischief and I was very very excited for like the solo mode there because I was like oh it's like an abstract game uh that also has like this really awesome theme so I was really excited to try it I actually found and and especially because I know that a lot of people rever his style of design of like you know uh I think he tends to do he does a couple of different systems I think he does but I'm not familiar with them so I'm not going to describe them but this one was um you have like three possible options that the AI might choose and uh a dial will determine or a flip of a card or something will determine which of the it chooses um which I totally get why people are really like that but to me it's like too much open information I like will AP if
I just see all that in front of me um I think it's good to know what's going to happen next but I think knowing that one of three things might happen next uh often stagnates my play and thus causes it uh to take longer to get back to my turn rather than uh solving the problem of predictability right I actually don't think that um predictability is a or like having perfect information is a problem like for oceans for example that game is pretty much the way I designed it is pretty much perfect information aside from your own card draws um I designed the AI so that uh that it was more inspired by games like slay the spire and other Rogue leges like that so that you're always aware of what's about to happen to you um but because of the branching factors of like what happens after that moment it's actually hard to keep in your head of like oh if it takes this plus two attack that means that it can do this it's just like a domino effect that your brain can't always you know calculate and so it feels like Randomness without actually being random um and that's sort of my preference like I prefer to get a little heads up of what's going to happen if it's possible within a specific system it worked out for oceans but um I like to get a little heads up but nothing more than that I want to I want to have
absolute information of what's going to happen and then react to it in a way that I think will be best um but yeah that's a really interesting way to put that I um I think of it in much simpler terms of things like well you know I want the logic to be simple but I need the opponent to be strong I generally tend to favor card-based opponents that are tough um but uh you know you have to really work your knowledge of the game and most of it your turn I think solo gamers are inherently selfish and I don't mean that in a bad way because I'm saying this about myself but I always want it to be my turn I always want to be engaged of the game My Turn forever actually one of the things that David and I try to do with night witches um was there is actually not an AI turn it's always your turn you're just doing different steps of your turn everything automatically Fires at you it's up to you to evade it um every you know there's there's so there's literally no upkeep um that feels like a space invader is kind of like set up like the AI is just doing its thing and you are just reacting to it yeah I mean I I don't know what we'll do next with our current game but again like we we both kind of have a design philosophy of like I want it to always be my turn uh I want it to be my turn as much as possible and like that is what I will choose um with something like oath it's
a very complex game and so Ricky Royal and I are working on like how to not create too much overhead but also to make an an automated opponent that is convincing enough that it can actually put up a fight um and so that'll be developed right like what can we shave off just how much has to be there but I think you're right about yeah that is such an enormous project yeah like I I I do not envy what you're about to do it is such an enormous project the fact that Ricky Royal was able to do what he did for wakan uh I think is also a miracle um so I know that I know that you guys can do it I'm just like wow that is an enormous project ahead of you we're getting there Ricky's always slammed though so you know he's he's in demand I love his solo modes so this actually leaves me to a new set of questions so you mentioned you were already an active game designer before going to game design school what made you feel that going into a program was going to be the right move for your career especially given that so many acting game designers never went to a game design program and just kind of do it that's a great question um I want to before I answer that question I do want to state that whenever people ask me about going to game design school like if they should go or telling me that they want to go I actually discourage it um I discourage it because um I had a
great experience first of all I want to say I love going to NYU I love my professors I love my cohort the reason why I discourage it is because I feel like a lot of people go for additional education for the wrong reason I think that um often you'll find that people go because they want to uh because they don't know what to do next or because they are bored at work or but and and so when you go in when you approach a subject like that with that mindset I don't think that you're actually ready to do what an MFA or a grad program is going to make you do because graduate programs are a lot of work a lot more than I realized before I even started um and so I whenever I say when I when I say discourage I don't mean like don't do it I mean like think about it think about whether it's the right move for you think about whether this is actually something that you could do on your own or something that you can grow you know or really need you know a boost of community a boost of um conversation with like-minded people because that's what I felt like I needed um but I also like I approached it not as a means of learning about game design but as a means of forming Community um because I already knew that
going into it that I'm a smart person I already knew going into it that like I can potentially do this without this at all um that I'm capable of teaching myself that I'm capable capable of learning from those around me um and so I tell everyone that uh what NYU did for me was do in two years what I could have done myself in four and I think that's true I think that uh if you are the kind of person who's able to put in the hours you know passionate to put in the hours for themsel you can do it um it's just going to take time and not everyone can um commit that time and so if you can't commit the time and you really need like a structure to help you if you um want to Pivot careers you have the skills um but you want to develop them further if you want Community I think those are all valid reasons to go back to um graduate school um what graduate school did for me uh being in graduate school I got to meet incredible professors um I should say that uh in my application I wrote about root so fangirling over here uh I wrote about root I wrote about um my favorite faction being the otter and so and like sort of how they have the sort of above the table conversation
that I love in games they kind of to me are like the butter for the game they make it feel so smooth and like I just love love that faction so much I love communicating with people looking each other in the eye uh being Trixie and uh so I wrote about that for as part of my application so when I when I was applying to schools um I actually only applied to NYU because I knew that it was the only school I wanted to apply to um flashback to like four years prior um when I was still in grad uh when I was still in my undergrad uh the NYU Game Center had just opened for the first time and I was already a freshman and so I had just missed the opportunity to be a student um at the game center by one year uh so um I felt like oh man maybe I could transfer but then I was like no I'm I think I'm going to be happy here I just met all these people I'm still accustom getting accustomed to my environment so applying to graduate school I knew I'm going to apply to NYU and if I don't get into NYU I'm going to do it on my own that's that's what I'm going to do and fortunately I got in um not everyone should do what I did don't apply to one school and hope you get in it just worked for me um but but yeah uh definitely took a risk there but it ended up working out
for me so what is um what kind of classes do you take in a game design program like what do they teach you yeah so um our most intensive program on our first semester is games um game design one there's a game design one class and a game design two and game design one is a TW semester course it's basically like a six credit course but they only give us four credits um the workload for that class is very intense it's taught by Eric Zimmerman so Eric uh Eric is known for having designed the 4X game Quantum um which is like a board game that came out in 2013 he also wrote um one of the first like game design books uh like a a textbook called rules of play um and so we literally learned from his textbook that like those were the readings as part of his class and just learning from him every day was such a joy he he was a tough teacher he was probably the toughest teacher I had while there um but he specifically pushed me um very hard hard because uh I think that we both have the kinds of personalities that both are the same and yet Clash um and so the way that I think that there was a mutual respect between us of like um the way we think about games the way we work um and I think
that his knowledge knowing that I'm kind of like I was kind of arrogant in my first semester of school acting like I know things which granted I did know a lot of things compared to other people at the time espe at least regarding uh non-digital games everyone else came in with more of a digital game uh mindset and background and so it felt like I was going into the program a lot with a um a strong sense of non-digital design and games uh game design one is a non-digital course and so I think he knew that I know things but he also challenged me to you know uh challenge my assumptions of like what kinds of games uh are are good what kinds of games are like actually interesting I think like I always think about um his like uh in my first assignment we redesigned card games like classic card games that have like a fundamental flaw and so I play I redesigned the game War um and so War you know the the fundamental flaw is it can potentially be played forever there's no decisions in the game and so I designed a game that I thought was really cool I still think it's really cool um and uh that that basically used War as a mechanism but not as the game anymore and so uh
his criticism of that definitely helped me realize that like oh I'm making just because some works just because a machine runs doesn't mean it's doing a task that's important or interesting uh and so uh it's not enough to just make a machine that is impressive that it works it's also important that the machine interfaces with the human to make us feel clever to give us decisions um I like to call this uh like aspect of design like white space um but Eric would have defined it as play so like I think that he distinguished games and play as two distinct things that I think are really apt where games are like a car right they are a machine they can't do anything without the intervention of a human right um and whenever you engage with the car you can turn left you can turn right um but the moment before if let's say you're maybe not driving a modern car maybe you're driving an older car and when you turn left you kind of have to turn left quite a bit before it actually the car starts to turn left um and it's sort of that space between decision and action that that exists play that's kind of the way that I was taught to think of play and
uh I think it's incredibly true I think that um um the way that I approach that philosophy is I try to create space in my games for the player I want players to feel like the game that they're playing is not the reason why they came to hang out it's the people that they are there with um I think all games should think about that um all games remember that disgusting no Jing yeah I'm sorry I'm on the wrong podcast um but I I think that it on one hand you know solo games are very much like driving a car you know uh we're just kind of like playing with machines and pieces and seeing how they run but there's still a a playful aspect between us and machine in the same way that there's playfulness between Car and Driver um what I described is between like player and player but think it's still possible to have play happen between person and machine um yeah I think you have insights into yourself why you play although I will say I think solo gamers are probably the most talkative of all Gamers it's just that we talk after the fact like yeah some people talk about the game while they're playing it but if you're a solo gamer you play the game and then you go online and then talk about it to other people online who also want to talk about
it I think that's because when you're with a group of people people you can kind of digest The Experience together being like Oh my God that moment was crazy uh but when you're alone you just want to share it with somebody else but and the thing is unlike RPGs unless unlike like sharing a story in an RPG or sharing a story that happened in a dream uh the stories that happen in board games as a solo player are very cogent they're very like easy to share and distribute because other people can also experience that and like understand like the relationship between these things and why it's cool uh unlike if you explain like an RPG story it's just going to sound like gobbly G to someone else uh like it was so cool to you but no it it can't be transferred to anyone else speaking of digesting things with others one of the things you mentioned about the the good that your program brought to you was not only it sounds like you had great instructors but also you said that you had like a supportive group of people to work with so what was the role I guess of your cohort in your development as a designer yeah um so the program very much is like seeped in group activity we were constantly working in groups in and encourag to work in different groups with different people um I had probably the largest cohort that the school had had so far I think we were like close to 40 when typical cohorts are closer to 20
or 30 so coming right out of the pandemic we were the first class that was fully in person um since then and immediately after that we're just like also the biggest and so on one hand it meant that we uh did not have as much one-on-one time with our professors because there were just so many of us with needs but it did allow us to constantly try working with new people um which was such a great thing um we can work in you know I I could have worked with a different person for each each uh project if I had wanted to but it it's sort of natural that as the semesters go on you sort of find your people you find the people who uh match your voice or your taste and enrich the kind of games that you want to make and they want to make um and so I think that it's just because of the um the okay this is actually I think a big part of the community at NYU and why I think it works so well so um Eric gives a speech really early on in our in our uh education there where he says um that critique is a way of of sharing love and appreciation with another person you want them to succeed like you were giving critique because we want the other person to succeed we don't want to tear them down we don't even want to build them up we just want them to
uh do well um and so I having myself come from more of an academic background at my my undergraduate I studied um Cinema studies and so I have a very critical background um I was often in like critique sessions I I also did like a lot of like film classes so I already was going into this program with like a strong skill in giving and receiving critique um but it it became clear to me in that moment that not everyone had uh received that same education and so uh sharing this uh specific sentiment to me I think is what everyone could equally understand um that we're not here to you know tear down each other's egos but we're here to just make each other's work the best it can be and it also fostered uh a sense of community in that like if you're working on something we're no one's stealing that it's yours you know I think that um some spaces are safer than others as far as like sharing your ideas that's at least the experience that I've had and I think that with NYU and the people I met at NYU I feel incredibly safe to express my thoughts and ideas and not fear other people uh glamming them or thinking of uh oh I could do that better so I just will without your permission um uh because I've definitely seen and
heard horror stories happen in this industry of of things like that happening and I think that um it would be great if and I and I'm not saying that this happens all the time it doesn't happen that frequently as that we hear of but it does happen um and then you know the on the flip side of the coin it's like well ideas are cheap it's about execution I think that's absolutely true as well uh a good designer can take a bad idea and make a good game a bad designer cannot take a bad bad idea and make a good game so in either case um I think that what I see most often in this space is uh that same kind of mutual respect of you're working on something and I want to see it get better uh I think our critique circles could you know stand to grow and uh become more nuanced and developed in the way that we talk about games and the way that we um Express um the way that we want games to be uh improved but I think that's not necessarily something that we can control as designers so much as our play testing communities because often when we play test we're not talking about other designers but also uh like people in the public friends family and so uh whenever I am play testing I always try to give a Spiel at the start to kind of set the mood of like this is what we're here to do this is uh you're not you're not going to hurt my feelings by like you know giving me um critique but this is the kind of critique that is most helpful to me and this is and uh if
anyone else if anyone feels uncomfortable you know I I always give people the option to opt out um and and yeah I think that the way that you run play tests will help facilitate the kind of people that you want to be playing your game and and in the way that you're trying to study it oh that's really interesting do you think that your approach to design has fundamentally changed between what you did for ocean and then your work post program uh absolutely I think I'm am a as strong I genuinely thought that I was a strong designer before this program I still think I'm a strong designer and I feel like I'm stronger and I feel like it's that self-confidence that I feel that makes me every day wake up and feel like I can do this it's hard it's it's really hard but I can do this and you know every day that I receive a rejection email or something I know that all of it is based on this one single truth which is that I am good at what I do and I know that and no one can tell me otherwise um and so uh I learned a great lesson in humility going to school that it's incredible work uh but also incredibly fruitful at the end of the journey um I was shown a lot of how my assumptions
are incorrect being in school I was shown uh so many ways that other people think about games and design games and make games that I wouldn't have designed from my own instincts uh which also has just helped me grow and inform me of and now those are Pathways that I can go down those are thoughts that I now have um and I think that the more time you spend around creative people like that and not necessarily in game design circles just creative people in general the more that their ideas are going to rub off on you and you're naturally going to just sync and share and kind of just develop into a more well-rounded uh person and designer yeah I love and I have my own thoughts about this but I'm just gonna make you talk about it so I love that in the same breath you express confidence I know I'm smart I know I'm a good game designer and I got humbled I had to learn a lot somebody showed me I was wrong how do you hold those two things in your mind and how do you think that that is important to being good at the
work I think that it's just part of being a complex human I think that when we accept that parts of us are not perfect you know um it's just creating a wound to you know grow out of right um if we if we just like take a failure take a moment of failure and that failure can come in like such a minor form but also such a large form and we and we back away from it um we're accepting it right we're accepting that we can't do better than that um but I I feel like and and this is true when you first start out as a designer too I feel like often designers have this discrepancy between what they think is good what they know is good and what they can actually produce and that causes a lot of frustration in early design um but it also means that you have good taste I think that's important to remember even if you can't make good games you have good taste you might have good taste I can't promise you have good taste oh I know I have good taste yeah you Liz you have good taste that's what I'm saying um uh but I think that um I mean I naturally feel a lot of insecurity about um whether all of this is true or if it's something that's made up in my
mind but I see so many times Reflections uh that it's not an invent not it's not an invention of my mind that um things are happening in my life people are reflecting the kind of skill that I have back to me and it's uh rewarding it's rewarding every time um but there is this very like crucial point at the very beginning of your of any any game designers game design Journey when you have to realize that that doubtful voice is just the part of you that is uh afraid and I think that being being afraid is okay especially when you're doing something new um but it takes courage to do something uh something that's creative because you're putting yourself out there and I think that it's a beautiful thing you know to share yourself with the world um to be visible I think being visible is an incredibly important thing for people especially like us Liz where like being women me being a trans person being visible people in this industry only helps other people see that they can do it too like Liz you being here uh me finding you in my early career absolutely gave me the confidence to feel like I could exist like it's just a fact uh and so whenever I see other women in this industry I just feel like
so so welcome even though there are not nearly as many women designers as there should be um and a lot of us are still you know in our hearts in our early career um every every woman I every woman I encounter is making incredibly cool stuff and making inventive things within really fresh themes that I think that the industry should be like chomping at right now um and yeah I'm just really excited and and so the duality of of my of myself um between the confidence and the um the the the the the ego cheing the knowing that I'm not perfect I'm not the I'm not yet the best designer I can be um I don't think that I ever want to be at the stage where I can say that you know uh I always want to be growing and learning and I think that that's true for my like my mind in general that's why I went back for Education because I inherently knew that I I'm dumb and I need to learn that's why I listen to podcasts this is why I attend talks it's like I know that I have a lot to learn as much as I already know um and that's what keeps me running yeah actually you know I I really appreciate that I was able to help you at various points because actually this conversation has been
really helpful for me like I so I'll be real like I have plenty of insecurities like I just picked up a job that would give anybody imposter syndrome right I'm still waiting for my first publish design to come out like David and I are waiting on night witches to be out like nobody's gotten to play my work really yet except in play test and so I bet the farm on this I gave up a study career I've moved over a thousand miles to do this job and that takes a tremendous amount of like confidence or at least willingness to roll the dice but also I'm well aware that I've got a long way to go just because I'm so early in the process and so it's fun to talk to somebody else who's like maybe a couple steps ahead on that part of the journey it's crazy that you say that I'm a couple years ahead because I genuinely feel like we're at the same Pace I feel like we're at the same Pace um like uh you've been doing podcast but you've been engaging with Community right you could see you could see behind me uh that sh that shelf has more games in the back of it but um I I still have this dream of one day being like sen Lim and just having like a whole bookshelf of my stuff you being that level of of of prolif and yeah like I I I feel like that's true for all all the women in this industry that are that we that we're you know currently currently thinking about
um that are currently making games actively I think that there's still so much to come I'm really excited for what's going to come in the future um and yeah I'm just like really excited to support more women and buy their games absolutely for sure so on that note it's time for softy questions so what games have you been playing recently that are bringing you Joy um I have been playing a lot of Sky Team with my partner it's been super fun to uh kind of go through this like limited information limited communication uh dice game um and it's s honestly L as as it's both simple and complex at the same time have you have you been able to play it Liz I've not it's on the list oh my God I highly recommend it I know it's not a solo game and it's inherently not a solo game but uh I think there have been some solo variants designed for it but as a couple's game as a you know a game to play with another person um it is incredible if especially if you could run multiple scenarios one after another um I'm honestly so impressed how they mixed uh all of these little mechanical things that are unique of dice with um so it's like a highly mechanical game but then at the same time extremely thematic every element feels like it comes out of a um something from the theme but then is ultimately very crunchy um I'm I'm very surprised that
it won the Spiel because it's a two-player game I think and so many people are saying they wouldn't have Bet On It winning but in hindsight it makes a lot of sense it's a it's an amazing game I definitely recommend anyone play it um I've also been playing a lot of NaNa which is um I'm forgetting the name of the uh release in English um but it's a memory game mixed with a uh with with Go Fish which I know that everyone who has talked about this game says that doesn't sound like a game that should work but it does work and it's entirely true what they say um but yeah I've been playing a lot of like outside of my own designs been uh especially right now playing a lot of lighter games actually I'm finding uh whenever I have the opportunity to play with um non-designers I tend to find that most people just want to play like a chill fun silly game oh I also want to shout out uh there's an oink game I love that I've been playing a lot called durian I feel like it's kind of lowkey on a lot of people's radar but it's a game that's sort of like liars dice um I think that's the best way to describe it because we are all gorillas running a fruit shop and we don't want to upset the manager that is the the setup of the game and so it has the Hanabi like thing where we place our cards um in a little holder fa away from
us so we don't know what card we have um all on the cards are like dominoes um and so one half of the Domino has like some amount of fruit of one type and another half of the Domino has some amount of fruit of another type and everyone's cards together faced towards the middle of play um contributes to the overall amount of fruit that we can sell and every turn you draw a card and you sell some fruit uh you choose which fruit to sell and which not to sell um and then there's some like you know twists and gags that are along the journey but uh if you ever feel feel like we've oversold on any single fruit you can ring a very small bell that comes with it it's like the most passive aggressive little bell and that fits right in the Oink box um and everyone loves it I think the Bell is what sells the game for a lot of people uh and ultimately uh if you upset the manager up to if you get seven points worth of Anger from the manager then you lose and every round uh the number of anger points goes up so uh it's a really great game can play up to like seven people it's like so fun that is delightful uh and then if people want to track your work um what is your next project that we should be looking for and where can we learn about it online yeah so um I guess the main thing I would want to plug is my RPG uh it's a two-player roleplaying game that is
played remotely this was in addition to Oceans my pandemic design games like these were my babies uh the game is called drifting it's a game where you and another person each have your own uh diary and you play um totally separate in your own homes and you every day you'll be given a prompt which sometimes might instruct you to call the other person on the phone and check in on them uh it's telling a story about the end of the world uh within a Multiverse and so each of you have come from your own worlds your own people um your own situation that the world is ending in uh and there is sort of this um odd sci-fi like blending of the Two Worlds I call it drift I kind of describe it as the scales of a fish that are like kind of like uh ready to fall off and so they're like they're overlapping um I really like like weird sci-fi Concepts like that and so uh and I recently someone told me I should watch the the movie uh your name which uh it turns out that director makes a lot of stuff that I think I would like too um so definitely recommend that anime um but you can check it out um at either my itch so you can go to my itch page Marceline Lyman uh I'm sure the name will be in the title of this podcast so you can spell it there um so um you could also check
out the website for my RPG where you can sign up for the mailing list um it's usually drifting.com but it seems like right now I have to like update some kind of certificate so that will be up soon and I'm sure Liz will put it in the show notes um somewhere but yeah that's where you can find me you can also find me at Marceline Lyman on X on Blue Sky and on Discord and uh feel free to reach out if you want to Cod design or need help with solo design or uh want to collaborate I'm happy to do all that kind of thing nice Marceline I'm so glad that we had this chat thank you so much for giving me some time and com on the show awesome thank you so much Liz all right everybody uh if you're looking for me online I'm everywhere as Beyond solitire uh please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming