The Best Roll & Write Series | Which "Loaded" Roll & Write Board Game Should You Play?
Transcript
hello everybody my name is Ilya my name is Tyler together we make up Calvary a couple that loves to play board games and we love to roll dice and then use those Dice and heavy strategy we like to roll and write that is correct today as you as you chat about these four lovely games that are featured in The Loaded rolling right series hmm these are games by Motor City Gameworks and I think all of them are public or designed by all three right no I don't think I think Fleet is only by Matt riddle and Ben pinchback but then Adam Hill joined the rest of the game maybe three sisters as well Three Sisters just Ben pinch back and Matt riddle so yeah at least and then Eagle Griffin Motor City game where and 25th Century there's some Publishers some designers of these lovely three rolling right games and their most recent game French Quarter which is currently on Kickstarter we'll leave the link down below if you want to check that out we also did a how to play on that so if you're interested in a little bit more you can check that out as well and obviously this is a prototype and today it would just played like this because it is just the cardboard box as these games are as well but in the future it will have a beautiful side art as well so we can display all of them in a pile just like this exactly so in our video today what we're going to do is we're going to give you a quick overview
of the three games just primarily with the we're going to talk about all four of them you're right I'm so used to their big three I'm not used to the new cover yet we're gonna give you a quick overview mainly just talking about the theme and the main way to score points yeah and then after four questions to compare these four games four questions for games seems fitting seems fitting let's kick it off with Fleet the dice game Fleet the dice game you are managing a harbor essentially and a bunch of boats trying to catch a bunch of fish and you're going to do this by this is a theme throughout all of them but you'll be drafting the dice that you picked there are going to be actions associated with it the main way to score points in Fleet is through catching fish um the boats that you are able to launch the licenses you're able to get which are just like added bonuses for yourself and then there are some buildings that you're able to build alongside of some additional bonuses that you can pick up yeah I feel like the fish is a primary way to score points I feel like at least half of your points will come from all the fish yeah I would say yeah on a general and in general yeah yep now up next we have three sisters so in Three Sisters what you'll be doing is you'll be planting crops the three sisters of crops specifically and oh it's that way I thought it'd be like yes trippy okay well so in Three Sisters you're planting you're planting crops you're also
contrib planting some fruit trees contributing to the apiary you're saving the bees which is amazing and acquiring some bonuses throughout your shed majority of your points in this game will be scored from the garden garden and the perennials trying to get all those plants thriving as much as possible but there'll be some bonus points you can score in the shed as well with some of the things you acquire if you have a lawnmower maybe that's a good thing yeah exactly and last thing I'll mention too is in this game you're drafting dice but you also have a board that the dice kind of follow around with farmer Edith leading the way so that this game introduces that aspect of it they're not just loose dice on the table they're dice on a board yeah other days you end up drafting drafting are associated with an additional action that you'll be able to take exactly that also carries over into Motor City which is the next one we're going to talk about and this one is about managing a like Car Store essentially all aspects of it the engineering the production the sales and the testing to be specific and those are the ways that you'll score points there's four different areas that you'll be going into when you draft specific dice you'll be taking actions in those but you'll also be gaining round end scoring through having your speedometer go further and further up there are a bunch of different ways to make that increase but it is very crucial that you are scoring points from that and hoping to increase it over
every round will you be the master of trades in Motor City and this one also like Tyler said has a board now the dice will go on that board and you'll draft from there exactly yeah fun now the last one and the most recent one is French Quarter the theme of this game is you're essentially trying to make the most out of the eight hours you have on a Saturday in New Orleans now what this game does differently is there are Dice and carts so there'll be cards that are flipped and dice rolled relating to those cards and you'll draft based on the dice value and the card as well and in doing so you'll explore the various aspects of the city you'll do various activities you'll see various performers you'll enjoy yourself immensely because and the most most of the points here that you'll obtain is from mapping where where you are in the city corresponding to the activities that you've built as well as seeing some performers and observing the second line it is a lot of fun the main scoring points are going to happen from your experiences that you go through and you have multipliers which is very exciting so you've got to dip your toes in maybe like heavily into a couple of the uh uh social like aspects of the game to get yourself more and more multipliers because that's where it gets it gets pretty exciting the multiplier you're able to score so those are a very quick overviews of these four games what we wanted to do today was kind of provide you with a comparison of what you might
get from each of the games and that's where we come up with these four topics or game um themes that we want to go through with you today so our first one for today is so maybe you're new to the loaded rolling right series maybe you're new to heavier strategy rolling rates which one should you start with which one should you start with now I've got like two different ways with this one but I would say either start with French quarter or Fleet uh French Quarter I think is very smooth in the sense that they've managed to I don't know if it's like they've figured it out or they've progressively gotten better which I think they have progressively gotten better at these games but I think what French Quarter does really well is it hides its complexities within the game itself so it feels really smooth but there is a lot of complexity to it and it almost feels like a natural like flow with the game and so that's why I would suggest French Quarters for the first checkout the other one is Fleet and I think um Fleet is a good one to check out because it doesn't provide you with the additional actions on top of the dice draft so although it is a heavier uh complex role in right the actions itself is simply taking a diet a die and deciding how to utilize it on your sheet there's no additional actions that you have to do unless you're unlocking something that's particular to that sheet but because of that it makes the game very seamless and almost easy to
take the action draw or write on your board kind of thing that's what I would suggest you stole the words right out of my mouth it's like we're gonna maybe have a similar perspective in a lot of this yes I think my first thing was Fleet the dice game surely for that not necessarily Simplicity but the straightforwardness of everything that you're doing everything there's a sequence and more of the more often than not you're doing one or two things at most where I think some of the other games it is you are able to get this then all of a sudden get this then come back and get this and there's more of that combo chaining where I think Fleet it does happen but not to the degree of some of the other games and it is nice because I think here you can really hone in on your goal is just to get the most fish get the most boats launched get the most fish fish through various means where in other games you can really diversify in how you score the points yeah the diversification of scoring definitely happens when you jump into Motor City and three sisters I think there's more broader strategy points that you can go on to and then of course it does happen in French Quarters I think Fleet is is um just a more straightforward of the four games so I think that brings us to our next question which is complexity so does it relate to complexity would you say uh which one do you think is the least complex and which one do you think is the most complex uh I could just rank all of them I think um I think three sisters is the most complex one I think sisters okay yeah I think after three sisters it's probably motor cities uh or Motor City and then
Fleet and then French Quarter oh I think that this kind of leads to my point before where French Quarters done it so well that it seems really uh seamless the complexities are hidden within the action sequences that you are going to be taking that being said when uh when I'm ranking visas com as complex games I'm this is not me ignoring the fact that all four of these games are relatively complex rolling rights so whenever you're gonna pick one of these up do expect it to be a little bit more on the heavier side for sure definitely mine's different ah so I think the most complex in my opinion is Motor City interesting then I think it's French Quarter then I say three sisters then Fleet really yeah so I think the reason I think motor city is because you're managing for kind of almost mini puzzles or mini games in itself but they interlock or intersect so much that that is where a majority of your score can come from if you do particularly while in one but not the others you still probably will not get as high of a score as you're hoping you really have to manage those four and it'll really equal way the reason I said French Quarter second is because I think it has a lot of layers to it like I think there's the card aspect there's the fact that you're drafting both it is really smooth and seamless in the way that it flows but you also have to consider the dice placement and how the dice you get up there's a mini game with like the grid and which activities are you going to focus on which bonuses there's a lot of layers in it which I think is really
similar to Three Sisters I think those to me are kind of interchangeable between the two but I do think Fleet is the most is the simplest of the four surely for that factor if you are really focused on one thing and there's not a lot of the building certainly help and support and provide a lot of waste you can score additional points but they don't shift your strategy in a really significant way where I think some of the other games do that's fair yeah yeah I think uh three sisters just has like the most strategy available to it uh but it's extreme like at extreme points it can be a bit overwhelming so I think that's why I placed it at the high at the highest that is complexity though so let's shift into our a next topic which is kind of well which is theme which is your favorite theme uh which speaks to you the most yeah or what's the theme integration like yeah do you feel the theme in some of these games this do you want to rank them as well uh I could I could try ranking though I might um I got my ranking so I'll go first yeah so I think the one that has the most theme integration is Three Sisters mainly for the fact where you are doing things that make sense in the garden you're either planting and seeding or you're watering everything is growing you're contributing to maybe planting trees and everything feels like you know little seeds that you're smuggling in and they're really starting off a lot of your garden um the second one I think is uh French Quarter because you are going around and
you and I think particularly also I really connect to the theme you're gonna go explore and do various activities see various performers but everything you're doing makes sense in a way because you're visiting a building that in that building maybe you see a performer and that's fantastic and maybe you do an activity so everything that you cross off are things that you're doing in the game yeah um I think next stop is Motor City because you do have the four various functions of running your car business uh I don't particularly resonate super much with the theme but it does like make sense where you're doing some engineering you're doing some mapping you're trying to get some production I think the theme is a little bit more loose in this one it's not necessarily like the actions that you're taking and last but not least I think Fleet the dice game I think primarily because the fishing kind of happens naturally and that's what I want to be like contributing my dice to you're growing that you're launching the ships and you're certainly getting licenses but I feel like more of like I'm playing I'm just crossing things off I think the theme doesn't feel as connected to me for that game uh yeah that's fair I think I would probably switch Motor City and French Quarter in my ranking so Three Sisters would be first I think all of it kind of intersects with one another especially when you're talking about the shed actions that you're taking a lot of those will help you build on further actions that you're going to be taking down the road which I think is very very uh thematic like for example you can get like mason jars I think they're called so every time you're doing something with blackberries it'll benefit you
because you have mason jars or something along those lines so it kind of like intersects uh more more so than not I think the three sisters Motor City I think does a really good job of uh you need to be in order in order to be able to run any of it smoothly you need to be able to see everything else happen and because of the interconnectedness between the Departments I think it's very clear that like oh in order to be able to do this better like my engineering needs to be better so when my engineering is better I have to I have more success in production or in sales or testing runs more smoothly kind of thing I think that's really exciting for me um the French Quarter definitely has like a essence of theme for sure I think a lot of the actions that are happening speak a lot to New Orleans and even the second line for example is a pretty exciting because you're trying to like Dodge around it because you don't want to get stuck in that uh the other thing that I think is really unique about French Quarter is that just like tosses in those pieces that Ilya was talking about is like you go to a building and maybe you're going to experience something you don't know what that something is but it's there it's exciting and the performers for example will give you that like check mark on your box I think that's really cool when it all like intersects like that but it did feel just like slightly detached from compared to the other two Fleet I
think is exactly as you said it I think the the the theme is a little bit of a Miss for me because I'm not like super into the theme anyways I don't like fishing I do like fishing but I just don't necessarily know if it like resonates with me like the other three do the the other thing is it does feel like it's more just like take the dice scratch off the items and then fish when it tells you to fish because fishing is an action that is taken it definitely makes it more of like a you need to do this because it's part of the round sequence that's true um yeah I think all that is to say is if you resonate with any of these themes themes are a very personal thing so if you maybe own a car dealership and you want to experience it in the game and see how it works maybe that's something that you can do in Motor City so if any of these seems resonate with you definitely check it out theme is interesting though because it feels like it's very detailed like it's hard to rank these for because they do do a really good job in the theme regardless of which game you're talking about so just like Ilia said is if one resonates more with you more than the other then I think you'll probably lean towards playing that one strictly based on the theme kind of thing so the last one we want to talk about is our favorites that's too hard I know this one's tough for me to do are we ranking or just for sure uh I don't know do you want to rank or do you want to just pick one I don't know do you now let's just rank them rank
them oh yeah that's scary it okay I like all four of these games I would put them above like a fair bit of the Rolling rights that we have and we have over 50 uh so that being said I think my first my favorite one is actually oh geez it's either between Motor City or Fleet I think three sisters I really really like I'm gonna start by like talking about the other ones um Three Sisters I really really like the only issue I have with it it gets very overwhelming following the combos following anything that you're actually doing maintaining and not missing things is something that can happen in three sisters so if you're not like jotting everything down and I know they've given a section called the journal where you could write these things down or you can find a way to circle like stars that you access and then cross them out when you do use them I still felt like the combos can get a very a bit overwhelming and you are crossing out a lot of things even when it comes to watering for example when there's a lot of plants in your garden that you need to water you have to make sure you're getting every single one so there's possibility of missing them which can mean you're out some points or something like that was that a four that would probably be um that'd probably be my lowest actually Four French Quarter I think I can't well no French Quarter is my four because I can't really speak too much to it because I think I need to play it more to really understand like the strategies
I've had a lot of fun playing it so far but I haven't been able to well first play it with more players um and second I think we've only been able to play it like a handful of times to really be able to speak to it I think wouldn't be fair when we've played these three so many more times than that um so yeah four three sisters would be three two I think two probably would be uh Motor City um and maybe this is because I'm not as good at Motor City uh but Motor City is a lot of fun because the actions get blocked off I really like the integration of the speedometer so you can have round and scoring it's almost like intermediate scoring I do feel like it's super important in the game though and it's also very hard to get to I think you can swing the game too so you're able to get ahead of that when other people aren't then you have a significant Advantage because I don't think there's uh ways to to like save yourself from in the other zones by collecting those especially if you can score like three in the first like the in the second the third the fourth and then increase that more and more you're gonna get a lot of points that people often miss out on so I think that would be my one knock at it uh that being said it's hard to do so I can understand that people won't um well you're playing the game be able to push themselves too far ahead with
that that's really it for motor cities Fleet just it's it's smooth lit it's smooth I think the a drafting is really easy I think the the fishing just seems nice um the rounds are cut off you're only you can plan ahead for it there's a lot of different things that you can kind of go to while also maintaining the fact that you need to just stick to the fish I think uh I think maybe it's been around for so long that I just I've been attached to it for so long that that's why but yeah I would say fleet's probably my favorite I like that that was a good ranking mine I think would be similar but not quite uh maybe I'll go the other way I'll go I'll start from the top and work my way down okay so my top is so I've been kind of flipping because French Quarter has left a really good impression on me and the reason it's been just so marvelous to play is because of the flow like I think you always do this first the second this third this fourth and it feels like you're never losing track of things it was really rare in the game where I'm like oh wait did I do that did I need to do that yeah yeah so I think that aspect of it and the fact that you have kind of numerous ways like the spatial puzzle with the city the activities which one do you want to prioritize the different ways of scoring the performers and the second line like there's just a lot of ways that it all ties together quite nicely uh and then my other and I'll say which one is first in the second but Fleet will be my other one simply for the reasons that you said it's just it's
so smooth to play and I feel like it's a game that we can get to the table I never have to be like how does this work again we never really reference the rule book anymore we just know it in and out probably because we've played it so many times at this point I would say most of these though like once you get going you kind of yeah you know how to play yeah and like everything just makes sense everything just feels nice the dice are particularly probably my favorite dice out of all of them are just a very nice yeah visual presence uh but overall it's a fantastic game even though we played with the sheets reversed for the longest time which was funny don't remind me um so I think Fleet would be still my number one but then French Quarter okay then Motor City I think Motor City is because it's the most complex it's so fun when things work your way when you're able to balance to have enough money buy enough cars do enough testing do enough in this game to really feel successful and it does feel really good when you're able to collect the tire do all the achievements to score a large chunk of points through one of those I think it's in the production that they have them
yeah so like achieving those goals feels really good in this game because they're typically harder to do yeah um and three sisters I also love all these so this is not saying this is a bad game anyway whatsoever I think three sisters I get lost sometimes with like Tyler said there's just so many actions you can do and I feel like because I I wish there was one more layer to the journal where it's like here you keep track of things and you cross off or almost like Circle if you have an extra cross it off because I feel like I always create a system of like oh I have a star that I have to use I write a star but I'm like oh no did I use that star or not did I cross something that's my own fault but I wish there was a little bit of better way of some of the administration of remembering all the things you have to do when you were able to score so many although I do love how many combos can happen in this game yeah there are a lot of compost and three sisters that you can go through it's just it's like very easy to miss um and then there's no like backtracking yeah overall though I'll tie back to what Tyler said earlier is I believe like I think I don't know tell me if you agree I think these four are the strongest and probably the best series of Roland Marine games I can't think of any other series to be published so far yeah and I do always get really excited knowing when the designers from this game say oh there's another game we're working on here it's coming and when we learned about French Quarter we were over the moon and they keep getting better there's layers and aspects of them experimental trying new things and it's really exciting to try and participate in a playing of these games
yeah I mean like I said we own over 50 Roland rights these do not fall below at least the my top 20 for sure like none of these fall below the top 20. um and like that's saying quite a bit uh we play a lot of rolling rights we do it's definitely one of our favorite genres and these are some of our favorite games yes but for our question of the day which one speaks to you the most is there a particular Roland right of these of the loaded Roland right series that you're the most excited about uh do you agree with some of the things that we were saying do you disagree do you disagree yeah are you looking forward to French Quarters there's a lot that could be talked about here just what do you think about the loaded rolling rights series what do you think and is it rolling race that you recommend we always love talking about rolling rights so if you wanna Jump On In there to be be like I love this rolling rate I recently played we'll probably say oh my goodness we have played that one or we have not and we want to we want to find more rolling so it's always a joy but thank you so much for watching if you want to chat more rolling rights feel free to check out our Discord the link is in our description and what else can you do for the YouTube you can hit our thumbs up button or that like button because we love to make board game content and if you're new here of course you can hit that subscribe button we're making a weekly board game content about all the games that we like and we want to find help you find the game for you so if it's one of these that's very exciting yes have a wonderful rest of your day bye
thank you