Board Game Red Flags!
Transcript
hello and welcome to board stupid my name is Wayne and I'm Matt and sometimes things just don't seem right sometimes there are reped flags red flags and you're going to nope your way out of there and that is the topic of today's episode we're going to do something slightly different from from usual we're just going to have this is going to be more like a conversational and um talking about our feelings about what um put us down in the board games yeah what are those things that you hear about or see about or know about board games that kind of put you off them uh what are those red flages where if you see that game might have that you might think no not for me not for me Fam not for me Fam and again we're not it's it's not like naming any games in particular these are just like our G General red flags what we don't like um into the into a ball game then a lot of time it happened to me a lot of time I said oh I would never play that game and then playing it and be like oh my God this is a fantastic game that is very true so that happens to me all the time but I I do recognize a pton that things that I don't like and I know you got it pton as well you don't like but it doesn't mean that those are bad games just for us so going to be a little bit of a flag and if there's more than one of them together I'm like oh no no my this
was very long and I've cut it down to five yeah but before we start um what do they need to do you need to hit that sub rectangular red flag down there that big subscribe one floating here floating there uh hit that one and uh after that yeah let's start that conversation let's have a little chat let's talk about it what is what is one of your rep Flags when you when you hear about a game you watch a review or you just simply read an article what is the first things that you like nah this is not for me if this got this long setup times 100% for example I mean we said we weren't going to talk about games but the game I was very excited about was void fall then I read that it was like an hour setup and I went not for me Fam I I can't well you see you see this is why it's very it's very different it's like to me setup time is it's fair enough it's part of this part of the game I cannot stand it sometimes you need to put a little bit more time into into prepping but if you think about it we really love play 40K for example and to prep a table for 40K that requires more than an hour it's pain in us so but it is defin okay so for you for you something what for me that is not really not really a thing maybe because I like more like bigger games like a big like Productions exactly yeah yeah you like the shiny
shiny like the shiny Shin but here's the thing it's like a cost value proposition where you know if I'm setting up a game for 30 minutes yeah and the game takes 30 minutes and I'm like oh my goodness no no no that's absolutely I I do agree I do agree with you but if it's a game that we're going to play for I don't know 4 hours and I'm very much happy to prep for an hour and a half I'm absolutely happy with that but hey yeah um yeah now talking about this production bits I'm going to link to you to my first big thing that as soon as I see the production quality that is not up to the to the level to the Italian standard I'm I'm pretty much not impressed okay I'm pretty pretty much not impressed card stock or as as soon as I start seeing like uh cars a little bit too like thin or the the cardboards that is done in the in the cheaper way where you see that it's not thick enough that that it can sustain any any bending or anything um or yeah those kind of things really really puts me off on on a game that's the yeah I can I I feel it I mean production quality again I can kind of disagree to some extent but not a huge amount I mean I I feel you I think these days game production quality is so high
no no no have to say that in the last 10 years at least probably 5 10 years qual General quality went way way higher than uh than than before which is where stands out when something bad comes right when you yeah exactly exactly and sometimes you see things that not really done properly or they're not been they haven't been thinking about it like truly um so yeah that that's normally is one of my my biggest one I can uh I can link off of that for you whereas for me um basically poor art design or a lot of a lot I call it a lot of brown so too much Brown too much Brown does bug me okay yes I I will call it too much wi for me fair I know you're talking yeah he knows he knows and I'm sure that you know too if you watch the old media um when you just got like a massive like wide board with a few lines like that it's just like not not for me but yeah I know what you mean with the with the brown it's I'm very much talking about the same thing yeah it's the same principle but I think it's the same thing with the production Quality Art design is so good these days where you have some amazing artists working in the board game Space where when you start to see stuff that isn't by Vincent DET trit or Ian or one of
these amazing artists or the mo for example you think ah maybe they could have got one of those guys to do it and made a made this game which could be a really good game more appealing and more enticing yeah for me the artwork of a game is really important and not that for a lot of other people you let me know what what you think about it is much more like the mechanics and whatever is on the card I don't I don't care instead I like yeah as you say I like the shiny shiny I like seeing like um nice artwork and nice graphic Styles um I I'm not fixed with a a gener I like yeah a lot of time like I don't know wingspan I I find like beautiful it's not my General in terms of like style of whatever the art is amazing yeah um or yeah if you take there's so many games there that the outwork is absolutely fantastic like heat that's probably one of my favorite with with Rat L I would say that that is one of my favorite um style of of artwork but um the other things that I'm seeing that are saw a few times now A few when we were spio and a few that are coming out now there is a lot of AI generated artwork and first of all I am all about AI I really no no I really like the idea that something that is tedious and boring stuff the AI can help you I'm all
up for if you're not an art designer whatever trying to get inspiration by by what the the AI can give you but from that to cut down all the artwork process all the all the study days profit I guess right it was a where the problem just to to go with AI generated stuff that is lately for me it's been um it's been like um it turned out yeah very much see some AI artwork okay very much that was uh that was son and um but yeah you you you let me know what you think you like do you like this I AI generated things and uh Hey everybody does whatever they want to do but uh then the game M could be great it just like appe it just tells me like this you know the Spiel Andel got into trouble because they used an AI generator yeah there was all that yeah there's a whole about that but here's one that you'll probably disagree with one of my red flags is if I see that a game is a campaign game to me if it's a campaign game how do you want do you want and here this links back to the whole setup and tear down okay I've always been concerned about how about the time value proposition right so I want my my time to be uh treated well by the game I'm playing I want the game to respect my time yeah fair enough see
it's like I can never really feel like I can commit enough time to play a campaign over like a long period of time I feel like it's a real struggle and it's partly for lack of desire and I think it's I think it's the thought of it oh could be playing this game or this game or these other four games but now I have to play just this game for the next two months or whatever I I do understand what you say but I I come probably from um a background of like um DND D or or like very much campaign like when I was when I was when I was a kid yeah we would play DND d uh most of our time and so I like that um um that feeling that a camp gives you a story that develops and you can't wait for what's going to happen next and seeing your characters taking uh taking shape um so I I think that's very much what why I'm I'm I'm I'm attracted by Campaign games is trying to get that feeling back when I was a kid of the of the DND adventure of the RPG's Adventure I think that's uh very much what what is for me but at the same time this not like playing a video game a video game will have I don't know a 560 hour span you still dedicated 560 hours that by myself I guess I it's slightly different I feel like yeah for me at least I'd be carving that time by
myself in the evening when I'm alone or whatever and I'll play play my video game for a few hours couple hours every every evening or every couple of evenings but I think for my board gaming I always think about it in a certain way I think I think it's it's my social experience I've got 3 hours let's play a couple of games yeah that's kind of agree instead of playing four hours I think um I'm very much like halfway cuz I do love like playing like okay tonight we're playing this game this game this game that's what we normally do H but all the times it be like all right this weekend we're playing I don't know whatever it is is oxward noise something big and I have enjoyed Campaign games it's not say I never played them but I'm just it does make me cautious just because of the time investment yeah but it sounds good and um I'm linking back to we were talking about video games and probably this is my biggest red flag ever MH ever when the ball games use Video Games IP ah okay I'll see what you're saying as soon as I behind that and I'm sure there are very good games out there um they're going to be very good game I'm sure that there is the the the one like the seimon is coming out with the um God of War one I'm really excited to see what they what the guys can do but normally as soon as
I I be like oh we're launching the new brand ball game is and it's about this video game or that video game or that video game is uh it's the Pizza Guys who's this I don't know back to the video games IP and all those things um so yeah my my biggest things is like it's always there's never been something that it was that good that made me be like oh this is a great use of an IP yeah um especially because probably my favorite IP is they never actually received like a very good treatment um and I'm talking about you Final Fantasy 7 uh your game uh that came out as SP was probably one of the worst things I ever seen and that broke my heart after waiting for a couple of years like without knowing what it but anyway um yeah I can't really say that how many um ball games video gamees translated very well into the into the B game I'm always more like if it's a new IP something that someone create different Universe a different thing um
I'm very much draw to it all the time at least I want to know what what they're talking about if it's um if it's an existing IP movies as well I'm talking about video games but this applies to movies as well it's very hard to make like a good game from a feel I think you're right it's interesting how IP can be such a mixed bag you and I think that's almost a topic by itself isn't it I mean like because I think you're right the the video game IP games that I've played again not naming any names I haven't enjoyed no no not really I mean I can tell you one that I know that is good and it's movie related and it's D Imperium great game that is that so far it's probably like the the most because it's a it's a so good such a good um ball game linked very very well to the theme of the movies and that that works but when they trying to recreate especially with the video game they trying to recreate the video game experience onto the board game and always funny like that it doesn't work for me no no you tell me if you got any yeah if if you played or you own um some b game some V game IP that became Bard game that you really like yeah I'm more I'm very I will be very happy to try but I'm always like very reluctant to to go even near to to those that's entirely Fair uh let's switch gears then and uh
I'm just going to talk about just poorly written or floppy rules it's such a problem uh for me I know exactly what you mean yeah yeah yeah my rules with that is if I need to check on the internet more than three times about about in this in the same like game I need to check three times on the internet cuz I can't find the the rules on the on the rule book or in the Fue to me that is just like I'm hating this it's a big old red FL I mean there can be some amazing game experience buried deep in the rules mess yeah um and I'll give you an example of a great game that I think has terrible rules as Nemesis I'm sorry but the the the rule book is a hope with the new version it's going to be it's going to be better we'll see but I don't know I think it was a bit of a bit of a terrible mess but the game is a great experience so it's such a good game but it is it is absolutely a red flag for me if I'm like you say I'm like oh god I've got to look up again and you I've had another experience recently and it seems to be the case with big Kickstarter games or big crowd games where I don't know what happens with the rule books in those processes I think it was more like yeah I think it was more like a thing um of a few years ago on Kickstarter Stu like that where the publisher will only put like a nice picture of what the game does and more or less explaining it now
it's very much more useful for for all the designers and the publisher to publish the rule book almost immediately and keep it updated to during the campaign and during the the things so and and it's and that I think from them is very clever so they get the immediate um feedback from the people that then are going to play in the game now I really like that but I do not really like yeah a b rule book it just I want to see lots of examples you know I want to see I don't yeah why this not give examples I mean you you've done 50 pages of rule book put another 10 with a couple of like oh if this happen into the game cuz they must been play tested so yeah yeah yeah yeah um I I I agree with you yeah absolutely yeah so yeah floppy rules or bad rle books is an absolute nightmare for me man how about Matt have you got any other more red flags um I think for now we can stop here'll stop there and we can ask you guys what what are your red flags stop me now or I will keep talking all night no no no that's it and well well the next time with the next episode we're going to talk talk about what actually turns you on in the game there's going to be and then we double check on what we say today cuz I'm sure there something that he saying he doesn't like oh my God he like the campaign I'm like yes um so yeah no thanks thanks for for keeping up with us and let us know if you like this um this new format this
more like conversation and uh yeah next time we should have a whiskey or something like that that we need to do that next time more if you like this content you know what to do check out the rest of our stuff hit that button and definitely the big red one with a subscribe to the channel uh cuz that's really help us like bringing you more content more often and uh doing in a better way that's what we're trying to do for you try and do every single time so thanks for watching and we'll catch you again real soon ciao