Skip to main content
Loading video...

Which of these 14 games are good enough to keep? (Keep or Cull)

Transcript 26:34

Hello everyone. This is Johannes.

And this is Senaman.

And you are watching Board Gaming Ramblings.

And welcome back to keep or cull, where we play all the games and decide if we want to keep them in the collection or get rid of them.

Yes, that is true. We are back. It's been a while since we've done this. We usually do them every week. So now it's kind of like, oh, how does this work again? Oh, there's two sides to this. I said one to three, boom, we show them. And we have, I think there was like 14 games. Might that be the correct one number of games? I don't even know numbers anymore. 14 games, most of them are Spiel releases that we played either at Spiel or when we got back from Spiel. And now we're ready to share them with you because that is a thing. Couple of them are not Spiel titles, but we'll let you know because it's probably not important for anyone watching it. But I just want to buy Spiel titles if they're good. I don't want to buy Oh, this other game was fantastic. I'm not interested because it wasn't a Spiel title. Nobody cares.

Okay. Are you ready? Do you want to begin with your game on your side?

I will begin with Zodiac Duel.

Let's do it. This is a review copy. Are you ready?

Yes.

One, two, three, boom.

It's a double cull. This is a two-player head-to-head duel game where you play cards and you basically like start with drafting cards, both fighters that you use to basically play a two-player trick-taking game.

A duel. Yes.

And also stars that you can use to boost your fighters to break some rules or add power to them so they win the trick. It's really straightforward, but it wasn't for me anything interesting with this game. Like

felt like I I think that if you play this like a lot, it would be could be fun. But in the category of this kind of game, it's not very similar and we didn't even keep it, but I would rather play for example Duel for Cardia, which has the same kind of feel, even though it doesn't have the draft, it has more of like a oh, oh, I got did this, you did this, like the the blind bidding. but I felt like it was during the same thing in a better way. But if you are heavily into dual games, maybe it might be for you. Let's go somewhere extremely different. Let's go to Music Nonsense. This is one of the Funbrick series. Uh this was not a review copy. Are you ready?

Yes.

One, two, three, boom.

It's a double keep.

Easy keep. This is fun. If you hate fun, I don't think you're going to like it. Basically, what you're doing is that you are making a xylophone. I'm not going to do it. You are making a xylophone because there's pieces in here that you make a little xylophone on the box. And then you will get uh a letter and a number. And that letter number will compare to something put on the table which has like the name of a song. And it's not a real song, which I thought when I first heard about it. It is just like nonsense. Like it could be uh heartbreak butterfly wings. That could be a song.

That could be a song.

And then I'm supposed to play that song and the other players guess what song I played. Then we move something. Uh so it's like a half of the song it will be the same or half of the name. And the other one I will play it again. And then you guess again. And you will get points if you manage to guess it. And it is really fun. And also, it surprisingly, I would not say easy, but surprisingly possible to guess what song the other players are playing.

we were really good or this like system works really well. I'm guessing maybe both. Uh but but yes, it was really intuitive to um especially like when you listen to it the second time, you really lock in. But it wasn't like an it wasn't obvious what they were playing either. And like this worked really well.

And a lot of laughs, a lot of fun. If you like fun, really recommend it.

Next up is Dystopia.

This is another review copy. Are you ready?

Yes.

One, two, three, boom.

It's a cow from me, a keep from you.

Do do do do do.

I do like this though.

I'm not sad to keep it because this this was fun. It is a two-player style game where you have like two sides. Yeah, one each. And on your turn, you will take one of the piles of cards on your side and you will around and there are some rules that you need to follow about like the items and the robot guards. And what you're trying to do is make a big enough stack on the other player's side so that you get the excess cards as points. And also you could get negative points that way. And this was like fast, it was fun, it was easy to get into. So it's overall an really enjoyable game.

And also it has some variability with some missions and associates that adds up a little bit of difference to the rules. I really enjoyed this one and it is a simple one that I could see myself bringing out and play with other people only with one other people because it's a two-player game, but it was a fun one.

Yes.

Next up is Pleaches. This is the one we did buy at Spiel. This is a little trick-taking game. It even has cards that has like fur on them. I can't even get it out. I don't know why I did this. Oh, now I'm get I don't And the thing Oh, I see in the bottom inside And also you couldn't feel it. It also have They have fur on them, the cards. And now we do the thing with the battles. One, two, three, boom.

It's a double cow.

This was fun. I enjoyed it. It is a trick-taking game, but on the pile of trick-taking games, it's not up there for me to keep it. It is basically what you're trying to do is that you are trying to win every card of a specific type. So not a color, but every color has different animals on them. Not every color, but every card has different animals on them. And you try to get all the cards with one animal. There are easy ways to try to stop the other players from doing it. So you're trying to play your hands in good way so that you end up winning the cards that you want to win.

I thought it was okay, but I agree. We have better trick takers that I'm more keen on keeping. And also just to clarify, not all of the cards are like fabric on them. It's just like those indicating your player animal. Or else it would be horrible to shuffle and handle those cards. Next up is Dead Channels.

This is not a real copy, but it is a trick-taking game. Are you ready? One, two, three, boom.

It's a double key. Daniel Newman makes great trick takers in general, and this is one of them. This is in the beginning a must follow, but as soon as somebody cannot follow, then you will turn the cards upside down and they have different numbers and then it's a must not follow. And you're trying to like see what cards you need to keep for like the other mode so that you will not win more than the indicated number of tricks or less than. So you want to win like exactly the amount that the game says. So this was interesting. I feel like I've played other trick takers that does something similar. For example, Prey or Predator, that one has also the cards that you flip around and also for example like Ghost Elevator and stuff like that where you're changing kind of what is what are good cards and what are bad cards.

I really enjoy the fact that you you want to win two tricks or three in a three-player game and you are trying to, as you said, like you have two sets of hands basically and the role will go back and forth. So if somebody can't follow, it will become must not follow. If somebody then have to follow, it will become must follow again. And I really enjoy those changes in the game. And it's one of those that is simple enough that you can play with people and still be interesting for people who enjoy trick-taking games.

Yes.

Next up on the pile is two boxes. It's Combo Creatures and it is Combo Creatures. And this is not a review copy. We did buy this. And now let's do the thing. One, two, three, boom.

It's a double cape.

This is a a very very quick light filler, but it is fun. Basically, we have already taken all of the cards in this and put them in here. And as you can see, that did work kind of okay until I turned the box on its side.

I need to cut into [clears throat] the insert to make it work, but yeah.

So this is a very simple game. Basically, you would either play a card from your hand or you would draw two cards from a display or top of the deck. What you play on your player card, that card does an ability, and that ability might let you do other things, like for example, draw cards, more cards, or activate a card, or play another card. And that is basically the game. The game will end when somebody has played eight cards. I think it's eight cards. And then you will score points for the the basically what I'm saying basically a lot. It is not only basically, it is how it is. You will get points for every um cost of the cards that you played. There's a lot of different cards in the game, so you can mix and match because you're only using seven different creatures each time. A really really fun one. Happy we ended up picking up this Spiel. So this box is going out. And this box calling an empty box. Do you have another game? Do you have another game?

It is Tricky Time Crisis.

Another trick-taking game? Are you ready?

copy?

No.

No.

One, two, three, boom.

It's a call from me, a cape from you. This was a different one. It is really unique. In this game, you have three suits. One is like the villain. Maybe it's more suits where you more Yeah, that makes sense. And also like hero suits. And in this game, you will count up the sum of the heroes and see if they have beaten the villain. And the winner of the trick can choose if they want cards or not. The losing part needs to take a card. And the thing about this game is that some of the cards will give you points, but if you've got too many of them, they will score you a lot less points. So you want cards, but you want to not be greedy. And it's so hard not to be greedy. You really want because like there's some really like potential to score high points in this game.

But if you go there too early,

Yeah.

but but also you need to deny your opponents those like yes. It's an interesting one.

I think this is really good. I enjoy it. It's a must not follow so that you have to play every single suit as soon as somebody can't do that the round ends and you will score. So it's also kind of like a gamble of how can I make the game round end? But that was very hard. I think the game was really nice. There's also an expansion that has a couple of more heroes and a new villain that I am excited to play. This is one This is one of I would say like the more unique and different trick-taking games we've played in a while. So that's one of the reasons I want to keep it and I do want to play it again.

Yes.

Okay, so it's my turn now. I have another game. This is Bear Necessities, another game we bought in Spiel. Are you ready for the paddle?

Yeah.

One, two, three, boom.

It's a double keep.

Double keep. This was a big surprise. A very light, very easy drafting game. And we only played two players so far. So you And it worked very well for two players even though it's a drafting game. You are drafting two cards. One card that you're going to play this round, one card that you put in your reserve. I really like this mechanism. And then you play that card into the tableau. First time, of course, it's only going to be one card and you activate that card. Next time you play a card adjacent to it, you activate the card you play and the cards that are adjacent to it. So you want to put up your cards and something says like, oh, you get points if it's adjacent to something or you get points if you have these symbols or you get this that's kind of thing. And then it's also a mechanism that the player who got the least points in a round gets a B. And those are worth points depending on the number of honey like the bee hives that you have on your cards as well.

And the card that you put in your reserve, when you get the cards from the other player, you add that. So you basically you play a card but you also can reserve a card. It doesn't mean you have to take it, but it is a very interesting and unique mechanism. It plays, it's a 30 minutes. It plays in less than that, especially with two, maybe 15 to 20 minutes. A really great filler, one I would love to just This is one of those games I could play again and again and again. Highly recommend for me.

Yeah, me too. Uh Bernice said as it is was like Yeah, it's so enjoyable. And as you said, you could either like have a card in your reserve to deny your opponent a card. I did that a couple of times. Or you can if you have a hand and just like, oh, I want both of these cards and they're really great in the combination. I can keep the one for later and then play my card now. And the B mechanism is really interesting because sometimes you're going for a strategy with a lot of bees. So let's say that each bee is now worth 10 points because of the cards that I played. I'd rather score fewer points on my cards because I will get those bees. So yeah, I I would like to play this again and I think this is super easy to bring to the table because uh it's simplicity and also the the short playing time.

Highly recommended from both of us then. Next up we do have

Bank or Bust.

It was a review copy. Are you ready? One, two, three, boom.

It's a double cow. We knew this already because we played this and complained about it at Spiel. Well, I like the idea of it though because in this game you are basically pushing your luck. You are playing cards, but you have like a row that you need to play in descending order and a row that you need to play in ascending. And if you get numbers that doesn't work with those rows, you bust basically. So you want to keep it going, but like I didn't see much too much decision making at all here. I've already I think uh in our live pickup vlog from Spiel, compared it to Up or Down, which is a similar game, but you have more stacks and you have more agency of what you do yourself.

I felt like it was like very many games are in companies are trying to make the new Flip 7 because Flip 7 exploded. Uh this feels like a less exciting Flip 7 basically. I don't need to play it.

Oh, it's a Cal.

Next up is Walking in Kamigawa. This was a review copy. Are you ready?

Yes.

One, two, three, boom.

It's a double Cal.

It is. This was was fun. That was my my my my my It's one of those games where I'm like I am happy I played it once. It is a very quick one. Still Walking in Burano is is the the game to beat in the Walking in series. But there's not really they don't have anything much in common even they like just a themed around Walking somewhere. In this one, you will be playing cards into a row. That row will have uh beaches and bridges and you're trying to do like oh I'm trying to have four different animals in between these so bridges for example. I want to have five of the same animal and then you will be able to score something and you get more points if you have more things. Then you have kind of used up that area and you're also trying to be the person who has the most of the things you get at the round score card because that's going to give you some points. And then you also have bridges which has bridge scoring on them that score for uh score for animals in the same row as that bridge. Uh and that is what you're going to do. So it's like a very very straightforward game. It has some like you can get some bonuses and stuff like that, but all in all it was a decent game but not one I need to play again.

I agree. I um I think the the scoring timing was interesting because there's different reasons you want the cards because there is many things to go for. For example, having most of one symbol at the end of the round or like unlocking scoring some bonuses. But overall, I didn't find it too exciting.

Mhm. Do you have

game? How many games do you have left?

I have two. One of them is Ladybug.

This is a review copy. Are you ready?

Yes.

One, two, three, boom.

It's a double cow. Although I enjoyed this game a lot. It is a set collection kind of game, but you're collecting different like there's yeah, different reasons why you want the different cards. So you have a bunch of these ladybugs on your hand and when you play one, you you have a like specific type of ladybugs life cycle, yes, that you can then draft from. So you want to play a card because oh, that let me get another card there that I need, but also you want to have all the different life cycles in one colors. You get a scoring card for that specific color. You want to have all different colors, preferably multiple times because those will also give you scoring cards and you will also be able to buy scoring cards for the different like actual ladybug types.

But it was a little like random what ladybugs came out. There was something that I was trying [clears throat] to achieve like set collection that just like it would I wouldn't get an opportunity to because it never showed up for example.

You're playing quite a few rounds, 15 rounds, so of course like the randomness is going to go down because of that. But I felt like both in the display and also in the display of things you could buy because you can buy these feeding tosses that you give points to specific lady bugs and those cost a like a little bug and some of them has the thing where you can buy multiple and if you end up and in your turn to be oh, you're first this round you ended up oh, you bought one, flipped it. Oh, I can buy that as well and I can buy this. I flipped it. Oh, I can buy this one. I flipped it. So there are and of course those gives a little fewer points, but that also compared to then when I oh, I have points for this, but I don't get anymore cards of that type. So a little bit too much luck for my taste, but a solid game nonetheless.

Yes.

But not one we are going to see. Yes. Next up is Hard to Get Pictures. I didn't even know this existed before I saw it randomly on the web store of Outland when I wanted to buy some games because I do check there from time to time if there's something interesting. And I got a couple of things and I'm like Hard to Get Pictures. We like Hard to Get. Let's check Hard to Get Pictures. And now we're going to do the paddle. Are you ready? One, two, three, boom.

It's a color from me.

Oh.

A keep from you. I'm unsure about this, though.

I think it works really well. I think that it works in a different way.

Yep.

It feels different from the normal one because you have like a diff It's it's a It's the visual basically where the other one is the oh the factual factual. Uh I'm still [clears throat] feeling that I am a bit burned out on Hard to Get because we played it a lot and I I'm usually the person sitting doing like the the game mastering thing.

that yourself now.

but I am I'm getting like I'm getting done with doing that because I just end up waiting off of the game. Uh but I I still think this is what I want to play a few times more. Uh I don't know if we need to keep them both, but for now this is a keep because I need to explore the pictures of the Hard to Get.

The thing about this one, which is good, is that it's language independent.

It has pictures.

Uh and also I was thinking maybe we can fit everything into one box. Uh but I don't know.

It might.

Yeah, actually. Uh and that I'm inclined to keeping it. I'm I'm okay with keeping it for now, but so far the original has an edge over this.

I do agree.

Uh

Last one on your side.

Is Bolonia.

Bolonia. This is a review copy two-player game. Are you ready? One, two, three, boom.

It's a double call.

It is.

This is a very unique and interesting two-player like spatial area majority game. So in this game you have these um wooden pieces that you can Yeah. You can also yeah like you can place them like lying down or standing up and when you're placing in them lying down you're basically trying to um surround an area and you want to be the one surrounding it with a majority because then you will get points for the area you surrounded. And so the timing is really crucial but also you want to place them standing up so they become towers because [clears throat] then when the game is ended if somebody hasn't won before that you will get points for the area at at the end of the game. So [snorts] this was a really interesting one. I can see that you have a lot of variability here because of like the player interaction. Um but we don't play these abstract two-player games too much and in that category I have ones already that I really really love.

My favorite about this I also have to say I think it's really funny the notion that you said that at the end of the game if somebody hasn't won earlier like I really enjoy like the fact that like halfway through the game you're going to win but we're going to play the rest of the game even though you won. I really enjoy that that notion of that. So what I really enjoyed about this is that as you said somebody can win before the end of the game but then that will be the end of the game but somebody can win by like getting 15 influence more than the other player during the game. And if that happens then they win the game. And you do do end it. You don't play to the end of the actual game. But what I really enjoyed is the fact that you you can't just focus on the end game scoring because if you do that the other player can easily then win before the end of the game and end the game before the end of the game as a round. And that was like the because I was I ended up winning the last time we played and I was so sure you were you were because you were making these and you got so many points and I just had to stop that and also win the the influence at the end.

That was the my my most favorite part of most favorite part, not favorite part of the game, but not one we need to keep in the collection. Is this the last one?

Yes.

Okay, last of of today is another review copy. This is Shugendo from the Veer Games. Are you ready?

Yes.

One, two, three, boom.

It's a keep from me. Oh, I wasn't sure though.

And a call from me. This is a it's a good game. It's a push your luck game, but it has one of those things where you you don't like you when you bust you don't just like oh, I'm out of the round now. You are playing rounds, you're flipping cards, and if you see these yokai symbols, if you have too many of them, then you are you bust your head can to stop picking cards or drawing cards. And if you don't bust, you get to do like two things. You get to both develop and build things on your map and also and get resources and also buy new cards. But if you bust, you only get to do one of them. But many rounds in this game I'm in a position where I'm like okay, I could bust on the next card, but if I don't, I only get like two resources. I can't really do an action.

Then I rather try to get some more so I can buy more cards or get that cool thing that helps me in other ways in the game. And those are the things I enjoyed the most. I am not sad by keeping it and playing it again. I don't think it's for me like in a forever keep.

Yeah, me too. I think what I did enjoy is that when you're busting, you don't get the resources. So because in this game

to do the other with your bust you can do get the resources

but like yes. So if I'm choosing not to take an action, I will not get the resources. If I choose not to play the card or buy cards, I will not get money. So because in this game when you first do an action, you can spend as much resources as you haven't do like that action multiple times, which I do enjoy, but that means that you need to actually and bust to be able to save up those resources as well. What I did enjoy especially with this game is that it really reminds me of Mystic Vale in the the it's a that's a card upgrading system which is really cool. In this game you add new cards to or you replace new cards in your deck. So you're not upgrading in the same way but it feel gives me the same feeling and also what I do enjoy here is that like the things around that mechanism is more interesting than in Mystic Vale which I really do enjoy. Um so this game I would love to keep for now but I agree it might be one that will leave the collection because of space in the future.

Because of the outer space.

Outer space.

So those are the games we kept quite a few this time which is good because it means we played good games. I think like that is like sometimes all we kept many games but that also it's because we played games that we enjoyed. So we ended up keeping 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Yeah and we have

3 4 5 7

Oh that's not too good yeah it's fine.

It is it's like it's not very often that we end up having more games over here than over there but that also means that we played some fun games this time.

Yes.

Anything you can do I can do better. I don't know what I was going to say so that just what came out. That's not the truth because you often win in board games so anything I can do you often do better. So that but that is going to be the end if if if you have any questions any questions let us know in the comments uh uh and and and this is music nonsense. Really think you should get it and also get bare necessities. And that is going to be the end of the channel no the end of the video.

I hope not.

can

Subscribe.

do it because it's

Keep.

It's you can keep the channel or call the channel. We would like it if you kept it. It helps us a lot if you do subscribe even though I don't like to say it every episode. And that is the end. Thank you so much for watching. I'm Johannes and you've been watching Board Gaming Ramblings and bye-bye.

Progress saved