Beyond Solitaire Podcast 04: Marco Arnaudo on Games and Storytelling
Transcript
hey gamers this is listening to me I'm solitaire and I am just popping in outside of the actual podcast reporting to let you know that I've split this interview into two parts this is part one where Marco and I talk about gaming and narrative and fantasy gaming and have a great time with that and then the next episode will be the one where we talk about wargaming its future and his conversion from Marco Warhammer to Marco omnigamer so enjoy the pod and the next one happy gaming hey gamers this is Liz Davidson from beyond solitaire and I am taking you beyond the board yet again this time with my special guest Marco our nada who is a professor of French and Italian and also adjective s ER at the media school at Indiana University Bloomington high do today Marco pretty girl how about you I am doing alright I'm delighted to have you so you are not only someone who has a YouTube channel about board games but you write about them yeah would you like to tell us about your most well your most recent published book and then we'll go on to your current projects yeah absolutely I published this book came out in 2010
18 storytelling at the modern board game which is an exploration of how games tabletop games learn to tell stories I'm an academic and in academia there have been a lot of things that have been written on the topic but I was somewhat dissatisfied because many academics said well this game has this story oh what a great game that tells the story now this game is no stories but no one seemed to have started by defining what they meant by story and something so confused because some academics a would say oh yeah Jenga with a great narrative Tetris what a great story intelligent Jenga well entertaining teachers are not the kind of experiences that I did I get when I read a novel or watch a movie so I was not satisfied with the lack of definition so I started by looking at narratology what profession herethe ologists use when they define a story and I came up with a system of traits number of things that if you have in a certain cultural artifact that I think that is likely to be a story or to be perceived as a story so have individual characters a theme a setting a progression exhibited etc and then I looked at modern games that have those traits and that often players perceive as having a story and I look at the reviews online not just a male feelings but if there are reviews of people say oh this game is really a great storytelling engine so first I want to define in general games can tell stories and then I wanted
to also figure out how it happened because nowadays you have time stories Sherlock Holmes consulting detective all those games in hands buy apps or chronicles of crime you know how many games at the legacy system of course but it didn't used to be like that when I was a kid it was all abstract card games and boy games so I started looking at the history of gaming and see how gradually games experimented with including themes and narrative progression that could be perceived as a story not just you know how the designers came up with idea but then how the gamers really started liking them and then it became a major force to the point that these days it has become not just an oddity in gaming but it is a major trend people wanna games that have scenarios that have campaigns with characters we clear to progression when a game has these things they put them on the box they're proud about that because they know that people want that and so that's that's us so you have the theory element and then you have a story of how games learn to tell stories and out layers learn to like that and to me the end of the the most the clears example the most convincing example is games that the very players say yeah this game is a pretty bad game but I love it because when I play it it tells me a great story Don John Quest is probably
the best example of this which is a awful game and a great game at the same time but everybody said it's an awful game mechanically but we have such a great time seeing the stories that the game tells us so one thing I was wondering about is no another example that you used of a game that is mechanically perhaps not ideal but it's still an experience it's something like a betrayal a house in the hill yeah but my question is in order to have the best story can a game still be mechanically good or in order to kind of force a narrative out of the gaming material do you need to put the narrative on the rails do you need to break mechanics in order to create something that's that immersive mm-hmm I think that the the curse of the good story meaning that comes with a burn burden of messy mechanics and and messy gameplay its frequent I don't think it has to be because there are games that break the curse they're not bound by that so well there are two ways in which a game can include a story one of course is when the story specially scripted and so you have content that is already there that is embedded in the game and you unlock it so you play a scenario and after the scenario there are three pages of text that tell you the story but the most exciting games is when the content is emergent which is you simply have the bare bone element and the game mixes and together here's the elf it's a dragon and find the treasure and all those things have been shuffled together combined together in
different ways emergent can't emergent content mix together with the embedded content is what gives a game flavor and very often however for the story to be surprising what you have is that story can be a mess again in dungeon quest it's greater at the surprise of finding a randomly generated dungeon that is amazing but it may also be that your doctor is impossible you get stuck in a blind alley because it's two randomly generated so the random element allows you variety but it also may playability Paragon doesn't have to be because you look at the most at the highest ranking some breaking geek you know the games that that players like the most and we know number one is gloom Haven which is a very good story it also has a very strong set of mechanics people don't say uh I had to play another baron gloom Haven the excited pandemic a pandemic legacy season one again we have the gameplay of pandemic which is Solly one of the most rock-solid gameplay systems we have had in recent history but it has been also gifted with a story so the message that comes from randomness that not have to really lower the quality of the gameplay again that is just not some general statement of intent or philosophical
position it just comes from looking at the games and thinking oh but there are games that are fun to play and tell your story the one thing you have to sacrifice in most cases however is replay value and you know I was gonna just yeah about but to me that's another example of how gamers themselves start to ask in their games to give them a different type of experience back in the day you will have somebody who plays games occasionally and learning rules was such a pain so do you wanna learn a game once and then play a million times so replay that it was a huge factor still is among casual players when you have committed players that are willing to learn rules then you are the possibility of giving games of creating games that have limited replay value but they give you different things and and that's pretty much if you have a game that is unlocked in surprising twisty and better content then the game will have limited replay value and as this from a student when I teach when I teach game history a game design how many times did you read your favorite novel and so obviously already ten times we're already 20 times well by all standards a game that you can only play 20 times is pretty bad right that would be a negative so we just used to the fact of fiction can be re enjoyed only a limited
amount of times again your favorite movie people are unlikely clips in their favorite movie more than 20 times something similar people watch TV shows and everyone's the stuff that they like but most people most of the stuff that they watch is new stuff I think there are a few people that mostly re watch the same TV shows and occasionally add some new TV shows so re watching rereading is a fairly secondary element even in fiction when we experience fiction precisely because the high of the first time you see the plot twist so boy games that come out now that have great stories but limited replay value in a certain sense they're just aligning themselves to the practices of consuming fiction that we have always had that we had since the beginning of time since iris total so it's new and it seems shocking and I have students complaining if I play this game three times but then I do the story also yeah but if you watch a movie three times and only at the end of the third time you start feeling a little bit bored that's probably a good movie that's right pretty good so boy games this idea since so new because it is new in gaming but again beer finally applying standards if you've applied in fiction since forever we applying them to games now that actually makes a lot of sense although I mean a book is a lot cheaper than a game and I wonder about I
mean I suppose the game also takes longer to play if you really play something like gloom Haven all the way through that is a lot of hours yeah also you can have these days you can have print and play games you can but say for example a game that has a narrative element and you know I like it very much is fragance darkness you can buy the PDF for eight dollars and you can definitely play it enough times that you have been entertained for the time it would take you to read a fairly lengthy novel so even from that point of view that's not a problem I mean it's economically viable many games you can play with other people I can if you have four friends going to the movie theater and god forbid they buy popcorn well they spend they spent as much money as you would take it to buy a fairly good fairly expensive poor game in 90 minutes later they're done that there's nothing they they watch the movie ones the popcorn is not there anymore and and so economically oh yeah you take one single book and one single board game side to side the bargains is more expensive one you can see that bargains often collective efforts you know more people will enjoy it and how much of their hobbies are expensive in truth again is fairly I don't think that that the costs are unreasonable and most importantly it's not just me saying it we see that the market is going very well that means that your people that
are able and willing to afford the games that are being made these days there is no disconnection between games and their audience which happens say in the 1990s when you have those massive overproduced games but the main audience what teenagers didn't have a lot of money and so you had those enormous games that not many people would afford and the market did very poorly nowadays you have these monster games that come out from Kickstarter they already been paid for so that means they're not too expensive for well the money that people are willing to invest in their hobby that's fair so actually I noticed at the end of your book you predicted that not only would story-driven games continue to grow in the market but they continued to combine elements with things like miniatures games games that represent characters terrain etc on the board and I would say that over the last couple of years your predictions have borne out oh yeah I mean I nailed it if I said somebody else I predicted that all of the trends that described in the book would continue that's only two years later but the indications are that at least for the foreseeable future those predictions will still hold true I predicted that games will continue to tell stories will Jonna will become more and more successful again you look at the top rankings or Burgundy's they're still graham Haven and pandemic legacy a
fairy story oriented games and so they're still there and you have a new time story time story revolution use new scenarios for crunch sort of crime new game scene ends by hat by apps come out all the time and again you see publish advertise and there's a game with a great story great campaign that shows you that those are or transed are important so I wrote the book and puzzle in 18 detailing a slow process at the very alone in the 1970s but burst into something magical in 2010 in the in the 2010 and I predicted that it was there to stay and I think that all the indications are that that is true mainly because it's something that I argue very strongly in my book and every time I talk about tabletop games nobody could imagine 1990s that the internet would be the strongest ally for pro gaming culture we thought that that was gonna be the Terminator but the opposite was true thanks to the internet well you and I are talking about games and I don't think we would have met otherwise not not likely people that are listening to us now would have been unlikely that they will listen to this conversation people get together organize events thanks to online forums they talk about games they shape the shirt pictures we developed a proud culture maybe you are still the only person who plays games in
your town but you don't feel like a weird anymore because you see all the people out there Kickstarter Kickstarter gave us a new way of producing games online stores gave us ways of buying more games BoardGameGeek gives us way of learning about the history of gaming so the internet really is wanna start gaming to the amazing culture that it is now and there's no prediction that we're gonna stop using the internet anytime soon the machines haven't tried to killed us yet we may get to the point where we have to you know cut back on digital advancement in a eyes before now it looks like we're gonna be digital for a while and for as long as the internet is out there then tabletop gaming will keep benefiting from it and that's to me one of the strongest reason why I make that prediction because I think they in turn is gonna be here for a while and since the Internet has made poor gaming as great at this now then I think that great synergy will be in place for a while yeah I know that I could not have the gaming life that I have without the internet I mean especially because I'm a solo gamer you know you need to talk to other solo gamers to find out what are the best things to play and what's coming out and what was your experience of this game and oh I got confused about this rule because there's no one to teach you or argue about with at home if you're playing solo you absolutely need the Internet and I think that's you know the solo guilds are some of the worst ones on the internet right now so yeah
my entire internal life in my gaming life would be different without that yeah yeah another thing is back in the day there was just so that information about games so a lot of stinkers would be published and it's not just that well the games were bad but of course people looking for games who get a lot of negative feedback a bad game and it sucks a buy another game it kind of sucks I got a game it's not good after a while I'm gonna stop spending my money that way but you know in the 1990s you go to a store there's so many games out there and you know most of them are bad you don't know which ones are the good ones then you may spend more money and buy a magazine the reviews some of them but not everything nowadays with the fact that every game has so much information about it people more easily find the games that they may want to play so more times when they spend money they find a game that they like that makes them happy make them want to go back and this again the availability of a lot of reviews for virtually every end and comes out to me is one of the major factors why the Hobby is now well so pleasant because people find against that they want and they're happier people that people also publishes now now that it's much harder to get away with a sneaker because well people will know they look it'll be known very soon I think that also is given an incentive to publishers to to up their games and to me that's also one of the reasons why in the last 10-15 years it's not just
that we're happy about games we find better games I believe that objectively via better games I don't think it's precisely than now thanks to the internet people can be feedback to the publishers so quickly I remember when the game you both leader you both leader came out by DV g there was a fairly strong a problem in the rules and then people figured it out and a week later after him out a variant had been proposed in the forums thanks to that a hundred people test today and a week later after that the variant was perfectly tested and became official and the game was fixed that easily back in the day you at the game that rule is wrong and you're stuck with that one so that's that's one of those are some of the reasons for how and why which is why I believe the Internet has just made gaming better has given us a culture and that's actually objectively improved games that are now more engaging so you are also now working on a new book about interactive storytelling in board games where are you going in your work on I mean it's clearly another book about games and tell stories the next the next step no actually no there must have been some miscommunication I have two book projects one is we're supposed to come out while two have been completed by June and it's not happening because because of the pandemic had become a full-time I stay-at-home dad now I have
a book that comes out the title it's probably gonna have the word engaging in it because besides the ultimate to what I just spray explain how games became more engaging and the subtitle is going to be something about innovations in 21st century game design so that is sort of since I teach about games at the University I thought of this as a sort of manual introductory manual to what is changing game culture and so again it's a book about 21st century game innovations in game design and culture and some of those things will appear very obvious to many of us in a sense is not mainly directed to them although people will be able to find games that they and I heard of or maybe see interpretations that they're not there's but outside of our hobby of course many things that happen are still not well-known for example video game scholars there are a lot of people studying video games it's a it's in academia that is a lot more developed than tabletop game design and you still see people that talk about the last video game and as soon as they want to make a comparison with a boy game they talk about monopoly they talk about chess they talk about checkers they just have no idea of how innovative how revolutionary gaming has been the last ten years and a lot of undergrad students
I can't they just don't know how much fun stuff has happened and how much fun stuff is available so it's mainly this game about innovations in 21st century game design is mainly geared as an introduction to the hobby for non-experts but still you know for non expert but still mainly undergraduates grad students and academics again I was at the conference before everything was shut down for the pandemic I thought to describe a student who was very knowledgeable he's writing a dissertation on videogames he tried to be knowledge about the history of coding and everything he says they know one thing that of course is different between video games and boy games that really only video games can give you the Soul Eater experience so I leave to youtube to see why a book like the ha1 will have a readership I believe because of course that's that's the way we played video games in my life he knows so much again I'm not saying to disparage him I'm pointing this out to see how there is a disconnect between different fields of game studies what you tend to think of a single thing but those are specialized in digital video games or just normal average video gamer is simply not aware of so many amazing things so that is for the game about innovations but it will have a chapter also about storytelling if you want you
can think of it as a summary of the previous bug because I'm talking about innovations - somebody doesn't know about those I need to talk about the story talent but actually to make sure that then there is not much redundant people have read the previous box you'll get something in this book I'll quickly summarize how a game can tell a story but I will mainly or only use examples from the last year and a half that is from after the freedom spot which rather it tells you there enough that I can feel a whole chapter about I can give an introduction about storytelling in gaming on using examples from 2018 2020 which again that's data book about interactive fiction that some manuscript that I have in the works I wrote I have 660 like three pages of manuscript I want a three right three more so just as a cool number and one day I just have to take a semester off and work on that one clean it without it's it's just a very mess manage messy Nancy so disorganized manuscript about interactive fiction in particular about analog that is the game book choose your own adventure books lone wolf way of the tiger all the good game book of fighting fantasy out of the old interactive fiction that we have interactive fiction that can be printed on paper which lo
and behold is making a huge comeback thanks to the internet because now you have series of game box that ended in the 1990s because the company crashed they were left interrupted they are being continued and finished now supported by the same people they've read them as teenagers now as middle-aged adult they are there back in the the Kickstarter and so they get to finish those stories that were interrupted 20 years ago so this is a comeback this example of another analog form they just like board gaming is making a comeback and actually is coming back even stronger and better than it used to be so not only are you an enthusiast for the history of game books but you are in the process of publishing one of your own if I understand yes um I don't that's a game book usually the difference to me between a a game book in a book that as a story is again that the game book will have most of their content is embedded he's written their word of the word and cannot be changed but you make decisions and you move along the tree of decisions combining in different ways so for example choose your own adventure book in which you read three pages you're given a choice you go to page nine or go to page 10 then you go there you read more make another decision and then you go and read again another part of pre-made text with that is most suited
when reading is what so what you do then I think of that as a game book and that's the difference to me for example between a choose your own adventure book or a lone wolf book and a dragon's darkness try against darkness although it is published as in book format it looks like a book the technology is a book most the text is not the main element the textual elements are minimal and the game quotable shuffle Simon recombines them a lot more so I think of those as a game rather than there's a game book the you don't have attacks that the scribes are seen in detail activity etc so in that game that tells a story the text element is secondary in fragments darkness which is again Cissna like very much is more of a narrative game than a game book and yes I'm publishing a game in that system it's going to be called for against the great old ones so it combines my love for storytelling gaming wait Mela for Lovecraft and it's gonna be you're gonna have four investigators let you start with don't get too attached to them because it's love curse world people go insane get this integrated get swallowed by gates eaten by monsters or go insane very often you study for investigators you can customize your group further by recruiting helpers don't get too attached to them either even less actually and then you have
forty days you're traveling around 1930s America so there's a map and you're trying from location to location Boston Providence the great cypress swamp New Orleans Sam Lewis in smile it's a teacher looking for clues you have 40 days and you keep track of things activity will cost time you're 40 days to find three clues that will tell you where the great tree trail is going to take place which great old once it's been summoned and you have to get there and stop the ritual before it happens now one thing that I want to point out that I just because I'm very happy and very proud about if I can of course we have other games that have a locker theme where you collect clues but those games usually those clues are just tokens we're told it or clues and yeah you're collected two of them then you collect the third one and you're told you found the thing but those Clues have been clues they were Tomatoes or chicken or whatever else it is they would be the same so in my game I wanna clues that actually work like clues in real life that is they give you partial information and so when you have two of three you can have the full picture but you should know more than when you're at zero however when you had one the way it did is that there is a table that will tell you which is the final horror that you need to stop east and the table goes between 3 and 18 each time you find a
clue you roll a 6-sided die and you make a note of the result so when you find a clue you have a four and then the second clue maybe it's a six and then the third clue is a two you put them together and it is are the twelve you're meeting catullo the way this captures how Clues really work is that of course the table certain monsters are on the low range and sometimes mostly in the high range so when you find the first clue and you roll a six then you know that the Dagan is unlikely because they're gonna see four five so you don't have the full picture but each clue allows you to exclude some of the possible endings and once you narrow it down to some other endings which you can take into account well they can muscle from what we know from Lovecraft we have a sense of is likely to appear we know is not dagan so maybe and we chose likely to be this other ancient one so now that we know it's possibly one of these we're gonna travel on the map in the area where they're more likely to appear so it's a simple system because you're rolling a six-sided die and writing down with your role but as it allows you to exclude possibilities and give more weight to other options then it works in my opinion the way clues work in a mystery and I'm very happy without that came up I really started to try how that came out that sounds great it's solid they're friendly so you're friendly it's cooperative can play RPG light so I also
say to play your like yourself I think you may enjoy let's hope for both our sakes okay hey gamers this is Liz cutting in to tell you that this is where I've ended this particular episode of the pod if you want to hear marko and me talking about wargaming you will have to stay tuned for the next one so I hope you enjoyed this episode I hope I see you again next week and either way happy gaming
you you