About Playtester Feedback - The Mill
Transcript
hello today I'm trying something different today I am going to try just shooting right from the hip and putting some ideas out there so I was watching Jamie's Wednesday livestream on Facebook and someone asked a question I believe it was Cody had asked a question about playtesting and whether he should be nervous about presenting his ideas to the designer whose game he's played testing and Jamie had an answer forum obviously I mean that's Heidi of s and the questions but I thought it was interesting because it differs from another stone layer or adjacent employee who I have play tested for so I thought I would put that out there so when the question was asked Jamie said that he was more interested when play testing he said well don't you know worried about giving feedback that's exactly what they want don't be nervous about that but jamie is more interested in why something didn't feel right what didn't feel right how did it make you feel and you know how did that happen and that was kind of the extent of it he didn't want ideas on how to fix it he didn't want ideas on you he figured that was kind of his job now I have play tested for stone layer in the past particularly 40 matome I did play
testing for my little scythe and right now I can tell you guys I'm play testing for the new euphoria expansion ignorance is bliss and kind of interesting when Jamie gave that answer that question because my experience with Morton in Team automa was a little bit different but I don't know if it was different because that wasn't communicated that expectation of I don't want to fix I just want to know what happened how it happened and you know why it happened and so I did when presenting feedback for my little scythe and for automa oh and that's so much for not so much for a euphoria but for my little side certainly for that particular play test there was a forum and a lot of us that were participating talked back and forth and hey did you have this experience I had this experience and we kind of you know tossed ideas out there hey I wonder if we've limited movement or I wonder if this was done and it was a very collaborative effort and we did talk about hey this is the experience I had this is what this is what I think might fix it and it never even occurred to me that that might not have been welcomed it was never told to us to not include that feedback so I thought if you've never play tested before and I'm sure everyone handles it different but if you have play tested for other people or other companies they may have a list of expectations in terms of this is what
I'm particularly testing for this play test so at least in my experience with my little side then with euphoria we'd get wave emails and so you might be a part of play testing wave to not necessarily part of play testing wave 3 that type of thing and so you know we have goals for each wave and so maybe as a part of communicating with the with the designer is less about fixing it or or maybe it is I guess what I'm trying to say and this is where I would normally edit but I guess what I'm trying to say is maybe it's a good thing either for the game creator or the game developer designer to just outright tell you what they're looking for and if they don't tell you what they're looking for in that play test maybe just outright asking saying hey are you looking for just my experiences what are you particularly trying to capture are you interested in this kind of feedback where I think you know this might make the game stronger or this might address that issue I'm having so maybe asking those questions and having those expectations that early that help you in a play test perspective I guess that's all I had for you today I just wanted to kind of give this a shot where I just picked a topic that I saw and put that out there so with very little editing I apologize for any road noise and forty rambling because that's usually what the heading takes care of for me so anyway for me today it is
Sunday so I hope you guys have a great Sunday hope you have a great weekend had a great weekend and have a great week going forward take care