Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 18:02

today's topic is he who house rules cool or fool welcome to table scraps short discussions about board card and tabletop gaming submitted by the viewing audience and discussed with the viewing audience hey there everyone and welcome back to another episode of table scraps the show where we discuss a topic on tabletop gaming with the live streaming you YouTube audience and I am your host Chaz Marler and today's topic is all about house rules what are they when are they beneficial and when do they go too far well as I was putting together my thoughts on today's topic I came up with three different ideas and examples of house rules which I will give you in just a moment because first I'm going to actually present the actual real question that was presented to us before I completely forget let's get to today's topic which is from Trevon Taylor who says house rules are you for them against them are they disrespectful to the designers and the play testers are they cheating do they ever actually improve a game or are they just quote unquote free parking well I thought that this was an excellent question there uh Trevon so as I was putting together my thoughts on this episode I came up with three examples of House Rules and kind

of how they affected the the games that we played and kind of three levels of house ruling so I wanted to present these and get your guys' uh feedback on it the first type of house rule is a house rule that really doesn't change anything it it doesn't have an impact on the gaml or the strategies it's just something to streamline and and maybe reduce downtime in a game an example of this would be a carcone I think the standard rule is drawing the little tile that you're going to play at the begin of your turn uh however there is a very common house rule of drawing the tile at the end of your turn so you can look at it and kind of figure out what you're going to do with it as everyone else plays their turns if everyone's doing this all it does is change the amount of time you have to look at your tile doesn't really change any mechanisms of how the game plays or anything else it's just something to give you more time to think and also then reduces downtime in the in the game and if everyone is doing it this way everyone has the same increased amount of time to think about about what they're going to do with this tile so I think that that is a house rule that doesn't isn't cheating isn't disrespectful to the game designers or play testers I think that's just uh something that as people use a product sometimes whether it's a board game or a socket wrench sometimes they'll find out ways of using it um in Practical applications that during development testing just weren't seen because it wasn't a real world environment so that's that's the first type now the second type of house rule I thought of

is modifying the rules slightly maybe even could be considered creating variations on the game um game that wow just this last weekend that was the prime example of this is um over the weekend I played a game called speculation which is a stock trading game um by Queen games I believe and it it's very simple you just have this stock market track that goes along and you have about eight different stocks that are going along and each stock will go up in value um at different rates so you're just trying to buy and sell these stocks at the right time by playing cards and the each player will play cards that will manipulate which stock stocks go up and how fast they go up on this track and you're just trying to buy low sell high now everybody has a a a deck of like nine cards the same nine cards and like you draw two and you choose one to play and during this game I could not stop thinking about House Rules of what if you drew like five cards and you chose two to play and then burned the rest so you're going through your deck faster but you get a few more options so the players can actually manipulate the stock market a little more or what if uh we had other abilities to determine how far stock goes up or maybe each player was in control of one stock and they got to modify one of them each turn or something and there was just all of these layers of house rules that were coming to mind and it wasn't because the game wasn't enjoyable I think think it's important to note that at least in my own experience when I am playing a game

and all of these house rulesyoutube

kind of fit the bill of variations of the game it wasn't like changing the mechanisms or well it was changing the mechanisms it wasn't changing the goal of the game per se it was just changing some of the uh variations on the mechanisms that you're playing so that was kind of the example of the second second scenario the third scenario fits more into changes that change the goals objectives strategies that you'll play in the game completely and the example I had on this one was another game I played over this weekend called via nebula and in this game players are building little cities and buildings uh across this map that's kind of covered in a fog and as they're doing these things they're clearing out the fog to open up more spaces to transport resources and eventually build more buildings by uh transporting those resources over the areas that the fog has been cleared away so you're kind of increasing movement on the map and building new things on the map and and unlocking resources that everybody can then uh transport down these open roadways that are opening up as the fog goes away well as I was playing this game I was enjoying it but this one fit into the category where I was like well it would be really interesting to see what would happen if like say I opened up this little cluster of resources and sure everyone can still use them if they have access to them through the roadways that are being opened up through the fog but what if the person who opened up the cluster of resources was a ble to like

charge a tax or something on everyone else that took one of their resources that way they're they're gaining victory points or maybe even a new currency that's used in the game and just little things like that maybe as you open up a roadway through the fog you know having a toll booth or something that you charge other players attacks for going down the roads that you open up and this kind of fit into the category that I think is maybe the closest to what trevan was talking about of things that weren't even in the game designers um thoughts or for lack of a better phrase best interest when the game was designed things that really change the game and almost turn it into a completely different game is that level of house ruling even house rules anymore or have we then crossed the threshold into just completely different game and is is it disrespectful and is it breaking things and at that point should you just go and you know create a completely different game uh with those different house rules so those are the three examples I have so what I want to know from the live streaming chat here is what house rules do you do what are your thoughts and what do you think about those three variations of house rules are there others out there and would you use these or would you not use these because of the levels that they would change the game let's turn to the live chat and let's see what people are saying right now our first question comes from Colin who says I think if a house rule makes the game more accessible you know provides an interesting variant or adds custom

content without breaking the feel and balance of the game then the house rule is all right I think in that scenario the first two examples that I gave would fit in that and the third one may maybe wouldn't be compatible with what you're saying Colin and and I think your approach to it is completely viable and um and makes sense so that that that's good let's continue on to see what others are thinking Homemaker Hobbies who says we use house rules to alter the game just a bit so our six-year-old can play the games with us as he learns the game we take away the house rules oh here is a whole new perspective on house rules where house rules can be used to help younger players get into gaming and I I have to admit with my own daughter especially when she was younger I would do this same thing as well and as time went by uh take away strip away more of the the house rules to reveal the actual more complex game under underneath as she became old enough to appreciate it I I think that that can make for a really good way to advocate for house rules a really good use for them so I'm really glad that you brought that up Homemaker Hobbies because it's definitely a very practical application of house rules the next comment comes from Christopher who says the best house rules streamline play like drawing Tiles at the end of the turn for tiing games now I think I've mentioned before that uh Christopher is a really good friend of mine we've played a lot of games

together and I just want to say Christopher that I think I'm going to have to respectfully disagree with your comment there because in the games that we have played together and the games that we have hous ruled together I think some of the most interesting and best stories that have developed from the house rules that we've done have come from us doing house rules that have done far more than just streamlined the game um I remember the variation that we made on Settlers of Katon which I actually still want to make a video about one of these days but that game of settlers of Katon where we added the little Warlords and um the raiding the cities and stuff like that still stands out to me as one of my favorite Settlers of Katon gameplay experiences and definitely one of my favorite house ruling experiences and when we did that we definitely went in the complete opposite direction of um streamlining the game Sasha joins us to say that Games should be fun you know it's your game you should have fun if you need to house rule in order to have more fun do so there is no disrespect to the developer in doing that you can't make the perfect game for everyone I can see the argument of not wanting to be disrespectful to a game designer by changing their game design but Sasha I think I do lean more towards your point of view of this is a game that you it's now in your collection have fun

with it any way that you want I mean I I'm a big Advocate also of you know harvesting ideas and components from games you know and tinkering with game designs as well and I think that aligns with that so Sasha I I I see that and I can agree completely with your attitude of it's your game have fun with it whatever that entails so there we go Kabuki mentions another carcone variant which is another car own house rule is taking three tiles on your turn so you have a hand to play with to pick from to place on your turn this should be for more experienced players obviously so the question becomes there Kabuki in drawing three tiles instead of one does that cross the threshold of changing the game so much that it's now a variant or is it still just you know a way to play the same game how much change do we have to make to a board game before it crosses that line where we have actually created a completely different experience that someone who is unfamiliar with the game would be playing a completely foreign game uh and not playing the game that they would expect to have been playing in the first place um be interested in knowing people's uh ideas on that in the comments as well but for now let's continue on to the next comment here by Toyota wolf Toyota says I'm all four house rules because in some cases it allows you to do things like shorten

overly long games or adjust difficulties to lower the Beatdown that you suffer especially in co-op games sometimes house rules serve to fix broken games in this respect there was a couple episodes ago uh there was someone was mentioning uh house ruling co-ops specifically and wondering if that was cheating uh because a co-op is designed to be everyone playing against the game and if you modify the rules of the co-op game the co-op the game itself which in a co-op scenario you know technically is a player well the co-op game itself doesn't have a say in the decision to make those house rules so are you cheating against one of the players in the that case the player being the game itself but I I think that it's one of those things where people need to not NE necessarily take things that seriously I I I think it still falls into the camp of have fun but again it could change the experience for someone who's never played the game before and if they went off and played the game with someone else they could be like whoa what's going on this is a totally different game which would kind of be jarring to that player so I don't know what I do know though is our next statement is going to be from Stefan who just says if house rules make it better use them and if they don't don't I think then that that falls into the uh way of thinking that a lot of us seem to

have here that if it's a general consensus that's going to make the game funner go for it which which is nice because it reduces some of that anxiety uh that trevin's question posed of you know is is this you know disrespecting the game designer so I I think the general consensus here is then you know no you know games are designed to be fun you know and the people playing the game should have final say on what is being being fun for them and I think that's cool mm says when it comes to house rules I think it's fine but if you have people new to gaming or to your group you should explain them as house rules and let them decide if they want to partake I agree uh I think that's the kind of that's a much more eloquent way of stating what I've been trying to say um if it's someone who's new to the game or the group kind of letting them know up front setting the expectations of hey we are going to add a Twist to this game this is not the out of the-box way it's played so they are aware of that fact I think that is if you're going to house rule I think that's a really important thing to do otherwise you could end up in a scenario um where the person plays the game again and they're like what's going on or they're completely lost because the game is nothing like what they expected and that could tarnish the experience for them too because they are um not getting the game that they thought they were going to you know they're not getting the play experience that they thought they were going to get so very good point there let's go to our last comment for the episode which is from Peter who says we tend not to house

rule very much oh good here's a good opposite perspective we tend not to house rule too much we'll work around some Oddities in the rules or look for ways to streamline play but we try to indicate that house rules are in play if we're playing with others so there's a good perspective that you try to mitigate the implementation of how rules as much as possible which I can respect because again my thoughts on it are if you house rulle a game too much you eventually get to the point where you're playing a different game and so trying to play the game itself as much as possible and get as much out of it as possible certainly has Merit a thing that also has Merit is all of the chat comments that unfortunately we're not going to be able to get to this episode but I appreciate everybody who's joining the disc discussion and if you have thoughts or ideas or comments or questions still left on this topic you're more than welcome to post them either on our Facebook page or in the YouTube comments below and while you're doing that make sure you subscribe for more board game news reviews and commentary and I also want to let everybody know that episodes like this are made possible by viewers like you who have been supporting Paradise paradise's pod pledge fundraising campaign it really does make a difference and it's really appreciated so thank you very much until next time I've been Chaz maror who along with the YouTube live streaming chat have been serving up some table scraps talk to you

again soon now this is the this is going to be the first recording session of our new batch of table scraps episodes so I apologize I'm a little out of practice but I think this is just like riding a bike everything is going to come back to me so what does this do

Progress saved