Discordia, Nocturne, Planted, Katarenga, Queen's Necklace Reviewed and Ranked
Transcript
hey everyone and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video this is where I talk about the last five new to me board games that I've played and I rank them from my least favorite up to my most favorite now before I get started on these five games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. co.uk who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order at number five I have planted which is a fairly straightforward Drafting and resource management style game where you'll be participating in a closed draft uh collecting resources and trying to aim towards these goals that you are drafting I suppose the um the cool part of this game is that you can forfeit your turn in the pass and draft in order to claim a new objective card to aim towards which you'll obviously be collecting these resources for um and you can even collect these kind of engine building style cards to make your um other abilities better or more efficient to get resources quicker you know and more efficiently um other than that there's not too much more I can say um it feels like I played a lot of games like this and I suppose my only nitpick would be that it's a little bit too loose for me I think like you can get too much done I believe um all myself and all of my opponents got all of their objectives done each turn um so I tend to like my games a little bit more challenging you know maybe I had a forgiving session um but I did find that left me feeling wanting for more and wanted it to be a little bit more
difficult to play um but you know a fairly nice um visual product nice Breezy gameplay definitely works for what it does and you know no real criticism here I just think that it's a maybe a little bit too lightweight for my personal taste but still you know a fairly solid pass and draft resource management style game that is planted at number four I have the Queen's necklace now this is a difficult one to talk about because there's so much about it that I like yet there's so many things that L it down in my opinion um if you're not aware of what the Queen's necklace is it's a a bidding Style game as you're um bidding on these CS that come up for draft each round and then you are essentially collecting these different gems and then trying to donate the most gems in a kind of a blind bid to get victory points at the or whenever a scoring round um comes into play now the drafting system or the bidding system I think is fairly dated and a bit clunky so for example um there'll be a number of cards on display play and they'll start with these little price tokens on them and each round a card is neglected then the prices will shift down which is fine um but the currency mechanism in this game is what I did not like because you have 10 kind of virtual coins to spend each turn um and what that means is because because of the turn order sometimes players can get very little bang for their buck and yet the next player because of the way the kind of denominations of money filter down can get so much for their for their money on their turn and it's
very frustrating when that happens and it doesn't work out in your favor and it does work out in your opponent's favor so I would have liked to have seen some mechanism where you can actually carry money from one round to the next so that you can you know actually start to build up some funds and get some better cards on your turn um the scoring mechanis in this mechanism in this game is actually really interesting where you will be participating in this blind bidding system and what you're trying to do is you're trying to have the majority in these gem types but the problem is the more common a gem type is amongst all the players the you know the less rare it is or the more common it is and that'll make the value of those particular sets worth less so that's a really interesting push and pull where you want to have the majority but you don't want to contribute too much because you'll just make those gems more common and make them worth less victory points but still some really cool ideas there now my only other little thing I didn't like was that some of the um characters that you could draft I thought they're a little bit too swingy you could save them up to the last round and really hurt your opponents and them for what they maybe intended um so I think maybe they could have been a little bit more subtle in the way they worked um but maybe that's more of my personal taste being more of a of a Euro gamer I don't like these big bombastic powerful cards that can completely derail the game and hamstring your opponents um but yeah still a real mixed bag of emotions about this one so much I like so much I didn't like I would love to see it some more now I know what's going to come up in that deck of cards cards but still it's it's a clever design it's an interesting
design but I think those problems I have with it are going to prevent it being you know amongst my very favorites so that is the Queen's necklace at number four at number three I have discordia which is a mediumweight euro strategy game with a very cool Victory condition so the idea of this game is that you want to be the first player to get rid of all of your meeples by committing them to different objectives and things and getting them out of your supply so first off I love that idea I love it when games come up with um you know fresh Concepts and different ways to tackle and T tackle the game essentially um the gameplay here is fairly generic I think where you are going to be drafting uh these Dice from this communal board and that will dictate the actions you can take such as um you know creating new worker placement spots in order to put your or commit your workers to them they come in different colors uh you can improve your engine so when you take particular dice colors or dice values then you can dispose of even more meol so you're constantly getting more efficient and I do like the unique player boards here where know there there's going to be a number of these symbols on them which will show how many more meeples you're taking each round and the idea is you want to be covering them up as quickly as you can so that you're not getting a surplus of Maples each time um and there's even tracks you can go up to get combos and I love this kind of um this bottom track where they will actually reduce the number of meeples your taking each round so different things you need to manage here so um overall I did like
the idea I'm a bit concerned that it's a it's a bit of a gimmick rather than being as unique as maybe it tries to make out and because know gameplay wise it does feel somewhat similar to a lot of other midwe Euro worker placement dice drafting style games so you know it's a solid game it definitely works but I'm not convinced that there much more than a gimmick and there's actually not that much variability in terms of mix setups and things like that so um you know I liked it I think it's solid you know it's a quintessential six out of 10 um I think some people are going to be really sold on that Meo shedding mechanism you know I liked it um but sometimes it can feel a little bit punishing at times you know when they're throwing mles at you each time especially at the beginning part of the game when things are moving a bit slower it feels like you're fighting a real uphill battle um but still there's um there's some good twists and turns here there's some good potential to make up um ground on if you're falling behind your opponents know in this last game I played I was very far behind and you do get rewarded by being first player in the next turn which can actually be really powerful so uh this game is quite a strong example of games where turn order is very very important because there's normally one ideal spot that you'll want to do in terms of drafting the dice that you want um and if people go before you and they took the dice you want you're pretty much left with a an inferior action to take but still you know that comes part and parel with games like this um maybe would have liked to seen that maybe a little bit mitigable um but still that's that's
nitpicking I liked it um I don't think it's a great one I think it's a good one that is discordia at number three at number two I have nocturn now this is more of a family weight Style game as you are drafting these tiles using a very cool bidding system um It's A system that was actually I believe stolen from another game called Metropolis which has also been recently repackaged as highrise I believe uh so this is a game where you have a big grid of these tiles um each turn you are going to be um well the starting player is going to start their bid on a particular tile and then in order for the other players to become involved and raise the bid they are going to have to choose an adjacent tile to the one that's already been bid for so if you raising the bid you are not raising the bid on the ti that the previous player chose so you're kind of navigating around this Bard until nobody is willing to increase that value anymore you'll claim those tiles those tiles will score based on very simple set collection mechanisms the most of these have two of these you know the more of these the merrier and so on but I do like this game ingame system where when you claim a tile you'll be putting one of your tokens on there um and they can contribute to other goals that you're trying to aim towards such as having you know particular shapes created you're trying to control different areas that kind of thing thing so again I tend to like games that have systems within systems and this is a nice clean example of that and there's there's also some quite cool um incentives in terms of
holding back on placing your bigger bids out there uh because if you have the higher value tokens left behind you going get some really powerful tokens next turn and hopefully get the exact Toes that you want so a really well polished game um I don't think it's going to set the world on fire but again I like to see those um those mechanisms well integrated well harmonized and this game definitely showcases that so I think this one's going to be um very appealing to a lot of people it's got lovely artwork and simple but interesting mechanisms and I think it's going to do quite well long term so that is nocturn at number two and finally at number one I have katarena which is a two-player only abstract strategy game and this is a a variant on chess now I've probably lost a lot of your guys' attention by now but I'm really getting into these games at the moment so you'll probably see a few of these games popping up on future lists but this one as I said is a chest variant but you only have I believe eight pieces each and they're all of the same type and the board itself is made up of all these different colored squares and each color is going to dictate the move that those pawns can make as long as you're stood on that particular spot now the idea of the game is to try and get at least two of your pawns over and past your opponent's side of the board um and it has a great degree of for planning because you can see all of the potential moves that your opponents can make you can plan moves in advance you know I'm
going to go here then I'm going to plan to go here and so on but it's not overwhelming say to the point that chess is where there's so many variables at this one you know you can very clearly um get a nice scope of the board see what all the potential moves are keep your pieces safe try to trap your opponents that kind of thing even try to win games or kind of Wars of attrition to try chip off your player pieces or your opponent's player pieces um in order to you know Whittle them down and then win that way very interesting and different board States all the time because these different squares are variable so you know each setup is going to be different create different opportunities and for me this has a real addictive quality to it the stakes feel much lower than a game like chess um games are only about 10 minutes long yet still very they feel crunchy and think key and I'm absolutely loving this game at the moment I think it's fantastic one of the best games I've played this year actually and it's going to be a candidate to being one of my favorite two-player games of the year for sure so that is karanga I definitely recommend checking this one out if you're a fan of abstract strategy games and of course if you are a fan of Chess so that's karanga at number one so that concludes the video generally a high quality bunch of games here with some highs and lows of course and but if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye