Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 50 Board Games of All Time - 50-41

Transcript 34:00

that's a section no one watches but if you did I give you a high five thumbs up y hello everyone welcome back to Foster the meele a Channel all about games and Bo gam things exactly we are here today this year the Year of 2025 to once again revisit our top 50 board games of all time we do this series every year in January yeah and some people might say that's too many times to do it how could it possibly change that much well guess what it changes a hecking lot most years uh because I'mma go with your gut kind of list maker yeah we play a lot of games too we play a lot of games and yes some games that appear on the list we've only played them for the first time this year I don't care I don't care neither me neither okay but this video is going to be for our number 50 to 41 so we're going to count down our 50 now if you are part of the patreon community we will be releasing our 70 to 51 thank you I was like wait how does that math work so we will be releasing that over on patreon once this series is

done basically after we get through the whole 50 um so we're going to do a couple of these videos every week until we get through all 50 of them I used Pub meele to rank my games which is it it'll basically show you two games and you just click which one you prefer and I rank based on optimal player count optimal play which game would I rather play I use Pub meele and I ranked over a thousand games it was over 5,000 pairing and it took me three days to do it Jeff just took 100 games okay I'm efficient I took uh I think it was like aund 20 no dead on 100 dead on 100 I took a 100 games that I knew would be or at least had a shot to be in the top 50 if they didn't have a shot to be in the top 50 I didn't include them in the 100 because what's the point then yeah uh so I guess I kind of pre-filtered our games yeah and then I did Pub meeple and then I do slight adjustments on the back end of pip Pub me because I don't think Pub meeple Nails it not 100% would agree but it gets very close I also did some fiddling with mine but yes I use Pub meele and again I rank on the same criteria uh op optimal people optimal player account optimal situation and which game would if I given the option in those conditions on which of these two would I prefer which I'll mention is very difficult ult for my rankings for

like party s games to then it's tough make it you're going to notice a trend I think and now my friends it is time and we haven't seen each other's lists so I'm ready to be shocked and appalled just like you speaking of which I don't think you will be speaking of which now we usually we have to say this but these are our lists the usual disclaimers that no one that we enjoy we enjoy uh if you don't enjoy them that's okay and if something doesn't make the list that is your favorite game maybe we haven't played it or maybe we have and we just don't like it and all of those things are a okay are we all good excellent I'm first yeah why not my number 50 favorite game of all time is a smash them up beat them up frog game oh agrica not agria it is Cosmic frog Cosmic frog that's new to the list is it new I don't know was your number 52 last year so it's ined its way on that checks out because I got to play it a little bit more this year yeah um I think this one would continue to increase if I was able to play it more uh it's just silly nonsensical fun with some asymmetrical abilities and you're basically just trying to it's got like one of the weirdest themes in board games and I

very much appreciate DVS weasel games for doing that but um it's just a blast every time there's not like a ton of strategy in the game you know it's just basically do you want to go punch your friends for a bit and and you know that's always a good time so always a good time number 50 Cosmic frog Jee don't look at my list I'm not looking my number 50 was my number 36 last year okay and it's probably because we haven't is that right it's got you will notice a trend Jamie's going to list a game and be like that can't be right yeah but then she'll look at the other games be like no no my number 50 was my number 36 last year and that is awkward guests and I think that this is a product of we didn't play it this year and that is definitely a big factor often in these ranking lists but awkward guess is a deduction game it's kind of like Gamers clue where somebody has been a billionaire has been murdered and you're trying to figure out who did it I love it because it's so interactive and you can also unlike in clue you can also continue playing even if you guess wrong um and you're exchanging information and I just love deduction games and I think this one is so fun I did back the second one award guest 2 so I'm excited to have that delivered and to be able to play that but if you haven't played this game I would freaking highly recommend it I love it yeah not on my list um but I figured it's one of those like again it's the criteria of just not the type

of game that's going to hit my top 50 I will also mention to like understand that our top 50 well you like oh it's it's only 47 that's of like a thousand plus G yeah I ranked like 1100 games like that's you know that's the top percentile all right my number 49 is our first new to us game of 2024 um and I think this one's going to do nothing but increase I think it has a potential probably cracking my top 20 25 uh and that is Ironwood oh okay Ironwood is a 1 V one or solo experience uh it's very asymmetrical in terms of its area control uh one person is trying to complete their objective before the other person completes their objective and it's interesting because you can't get too far ahead or then you know the other person's going to start kind of targeting you a little bit more than maybe you want to um I've mentioned in previous videos it definitely feels like it gives me the 1 V one Vibes that I wanted root to give me um in a two-player root game that it just didn't uh it failed to deliver on for me uh but I very very much like Ironwood and I'm looking forward to playing more of it very cool Jeff didn't make my list yeah I figured um okay my number these are always so interesting cuz our interest in games has a ton of crossover yeah but also a completely different mhm my next one my number 49 I don't think made my list last year um and this is the first

year where I finally been like you know what screw it this game I love and that is psychic Pizza deliverers go to the ghost town another deduction game that is from allplay and it is just so much fun to play like I love this game anytime somebody wants to play it I'm like heck yeah I'm in I've only ever played as the mayor which I do think is the optimal role in the game like is the mayor on basically you are uh helping people to map out this town to find their pizza and then to deliver their pizza and as the mayor you're almost acting as a GM so you get to see the chaos that ensues in the game and it's really really funny and I just think this game does not get enough love and every time we've played it we've had a blast I always love showing it to people and so that is going to be my number 49 and I'm happy about it and it might even increase l who I would like to maybe bring that to level up and I would like to to be the mayor um I will mention it's not in my top 50 but it is in my top 100 I love that so again if you want to hear maybe where that lands you can join our Pat can join our patreon my number 48 favorite game of all time uh Jamie has never played uh and that is space Empires 4X oh wow uh I've only this was on the list last year it was I'll find it while you keep talking oh 44 44 okay so it's slipped down I guess but I think that's just a product of other games moving around and that sort

of thing I've only ever played space Empires 4X digitally I'll throw that out there I've only played it on BJ but I've played it a ton on BJ and I think it's probably my favorite 4X game I don't play a ton of them but I absolutely love this it's from GMT it's very much uh I've never won this game so I think that's a product of how good I I find it um it's a economic kind of like Space Opera that you're just going around trying to colonize planets and and upgrade your ships and destroy your opponents and and what have you I love it I want to play it in person um so so so much but I have a specific group that I play this game with um and uh maybe one time we're together we can play it but uh if you like Forex games and um you haven't played uh space Empires I definitely uh recommend it it's not maybe as robust and like miniature heavy because it is a GMT game it's basically cardboard shits but I very very much like space Empires I think it's something that's always going to be probably in the top 50 in this area if you're wondering what 4x stands for it stands for exciting exhilarating X-Wing ex Excalibur Excalibur all right my number 48 is new to this portion of the list it just it bumped its way down I don't know where the heck it was was last year didn't even okay anyways doesn't matter that is a button shy game H and that is the first one and that is Rove I love

Rove I just think that this is one of the most clever games ever and I love button shy for the cleverness of how the games are designed if you don't know what button shy is it isn't there a company that produces 18 Card Wallet games those cards are typically multi-purpose all that good stuff but Ro is essentially like a puzzle where you are given a hand of cards that have different movements on them and then on the back of those cards is a puzzle that you are trying to solve you're trying to get the little row results oriented versatile something Excalibur to to do this by moving and shifting cards around that can only move certain cards can only move in certain ways I love it I did a solo mode for this over on BGG this is probably like my one of my alltime favorite well it is one of my all-time favorite solo games but I love Rove and I think it's amazing and I just got Aqua Rove for the first I haven't played it yet and Ro Junior so even your kids can play Ro or you if you find Ro too hard does aqua Rove just change the theme yeah instead of space you're underwater okay but it's the same game mechanically yeah nice I think so I haven't played it yet my number 47 favorite game of all time is one Jamie has not played uh and another one I own physically but I've only played digitally in another GMT game which is going to be a common theme of this list uh is bayonets and tomahawks uh bayonets and tomahawks is a

I don't know if there's a solo mode I'll check uh is a one to four player game which I was not aware of I think I'd only want to play this at two to be fair uh it is a war game based off of the French Indian War which is a theme and War that's very prevalent in our geographical region of the world which is a theme that I'm always going to resonate with uh B tomahawks is a I think simpler uh war game system than some of these more robust war games that are out there uh including Wilderness war that I was going to say has the same them that has a similar theme bayonet and tomahawks you are effectively either playing as the French or the British and you're trying to complete your own specific objective by supporting your troops with ships and that sort of thing but what I like most in this game is the troops are either Square tokens or triangle tokens and you're going to be playing out in order to take actions and those cards will tell you which types of troops you're going to be activating whether they're triangles or squares um so there's not a really ton of you know you have to do this and that system goes down kind of like coin coin it's not like coin games or you know like I said some of these other more robust war games but bayet tomw I think is the one's going to Skyrocket up this list the more I play it the more I figure out because I'm kind of just stumbling through it at this point but I know that this is the type of game I love yeah that's a new one to the list Jeff's got a lot of new ones entering the list I wonder what got bumped out we will eventually do like we did last year what games fell from our list sure yeah just scandalous my number 47 is new to this

list and that is the search for lost species yeah surprised me another deduction game I love deduction games this one in particular I have not played search for Planet X I have played search for uaps but that I don't like as much this one on the other hand it's fantastic basically you are searching for the Lost species and you're doing that by deducing where the species is based on um placement rules of all of the other different species so it's like you know that it can't be next to X species because X species has to be in align with this and the birds have to fly together and all of these different things uh you are moving around this map trying to get different Clues and then you're going to be making guesses and doing some research and it's so much fun it's fun solo it's fun play together it's uh when me and Nick get together we play this game because it's our jam and we love this game and last time we play uaps and guess what it's not as good as this one fair enough anyways I love it I haven't played any of them I think Jeff would hate it I think I would Doo I don't want play it's so it's so challenging it really is and you can make it's it's leap in logic City you're like I know this is here and then you're like why would hook about my your limit my ceiling for those types of games anyways that's my 47 I'm very happy to have it on this list welcome search for l i feel going to keep oh yeah 100% my

number 46 favorite game of all time is another one that's probably going to continue uh to climb as I play it more uh I do believe it was one we re we dis we discovered the first time last year um and that is oron okay that was your number 47 last year oh okay so we did play a l year okay I was I wasn't sure uh so it's like right on the same spot so it's increased a little bit yeah one up um oron is a really really great bag Builder game where you are effectively just trying to strategize your different unit types because they let you take different actions there's like a shared board that you're trying to like area control and time at the at the right instance in order to score extra victory points um and again you're just trying to build up your bag in order to take more powerful better actions uh in the future um oron was one that I know Nick and Mike absolutely adore over Brothers murf the reason why we first played it yeah and they're the reason why we tried it out and I absolutely adored it and I think if we played this more um it would probably increase uh but yeah I I'm looking forward to playing it more um and I want to play more of it in person yeah it's on BGA now so that's where we've played it recently yeah I think I think it would be more enjoyable to play that one uh in person just because there's a little bit more of like you're doing your own thing aspect to it and I'd want to interact with people around the table while that's happening but and I'd like to try the expansion yes my number 46 hold please let's see where

this bad boy was last year it wasn't even on the list last year okay it wasn't on my list last year but it was the year before this one is going to jump all over the place it's a Zool yeah um I think it didn't make my list last year because I think I was played oat on aul and I haven't been playing it as much but recently I've been picking it up again and recently I had a chance to play AO duel what we just played Azul and I crushed every yeah Jeff had a good game night the other night but recently played AO duel which I really loved and just so everybody knows I Clump all aules together yeah I mean I do that with any of the games on the list like like villainous or whatever it's just like I and I've played some Pavilion I have played stained glass aul duel regular and I think they're all they're all fantastic this is a modern classic for a reason it's just like it's so mean and it's so like for sure yeah we play kind of mean and it's like puzzly and it's beautiful and I love the acrylic tiles and I just really enjoy it so that's my number 46 aul yeah uh my number 45 I'm a little bit surprised that it's this far down but again I think it's just the product of the type of game it is and the type of game that I really enjoy it was new to us last year and we've talked about it a ton on the channel it's probably the lightest game so far on my list and that is Dice Town oh now we played that for the first time this year that's what I said oh I keep saying last year because it's

currently 2025 I'm still in 2024 I'm living in the past um so dice town is a dice chucker uh dice roller where you are just trying to roll the best poker hand and I say poker lightly because it's not super pokery but there is a varying degrees of hands that you can roll with your dice and then depending on who has the most nines tens Jacks queens or Kings you're going to basically go through town dice town and activate each region to score a bonus whether that's to get money to get gold nuggets to get yeah bonus cards to get property cards in order to score victory points we've talked about Dice Town a ton um so feel free to go check out many of our other videos where we talk about this game it is a blast to play I've had a blast playing it every time hit it's hit the table and again I think it's just lower because again it's still top 50 um it's at 45 just because of it's competing against heavier games that I enjoy yeah I don't have that issue when I rank things but uh di town for me 45 say dice town is going to be one of the games that we are bringing to level up so if you see us a level up you want to play dice town we're going to be playing some dice town I have a sneaking suspicion I'll be teaching that a lot yes we need to get the expansion yes and I just wanted to mention speaking of level up if you haven't signed up for it yet there's still time it's at the end of January beginning of February we are going to be there a lot of people in our

Discord are going it's going to be a great time so if you're unsure there's been quite a few people in the Discord that have been like I'm going alone is that okay I would say of all of the conventions to go alone to this is a perfect one to try because I know our Discord members anyways will you in yeah just a a quick like disclaimer if you're going to level up or you're thinking about going and you don't have anyone to go with and not in our Discord Community join the Discord Discord Community if only to find other people that are going to level up because there are a fair amount of our Discord members that end up going to that one and they will play games with you what are we on 40 what you're doing 45 well guess what it's my only other button shy on theist list numers it's numers of course numers is my favorite button shy game and this is actually I would categorize button shy as one of those types of games that is very hard to compete yeah with a full like big board game so fantastic for what they are oh yeah and numers is the best of them so npers is a solo only button shy game where it's basically playing off of the old joke 789 why is eight scared wait no wait why is nine scared why no because seven eight nine yeah why I don't know what the joke is but that's what it's playing off of anyways smaller numbers are eating big numbers and they have to have the number eight in between them or why is 10 scared seven eight n yeah something like

that anyways um and you're just trying to get your stack down to just just the eight and one other card and I will sit I'll play this game in my hand it comes with me everywhere I go if I travel and you could just play it on a plane anywhere you are play it in your hand play it on table it's it's the perfect button try game and it's really bright and vibrant fun and funky uh I did recently get the Infinity expansion um so I haven't played with it yet but I'm really excited but I love numers and it should be on this list and it maybe should be higher but it's just not I think numers is my second favorite L squabblin goblins is your first no rol Noir oh revolver Noir obviously my number 4 four game of all time I think has probably dipped uh significant amount just due to lack of playing tried to play it digitally but the digital app is not great um but I was enjoying playing it uh with uh some friends and that is a Game of Thrones I feel like it was pretty high last year it was your 55 sorry your 16 yeah okay so I think what happened was we played it last year we played it on New Year's yeah and so it was fresher in the mind game of of Thrones will always be my top 50 and it might be at 20 it might be at 40 it's just going to be have I played it recently because it's one of the games that got us into the hobby it's game um we've talked about it a ton on the channel our love for this game is always going to be there it's just going to be have I played it enough for it to be fresh in the mind and on

this list at a high point um so yeah number 44 A Game of Thrones if you haven't played it um I highly recommend it especially if you love the books if you like the books you like the theme and you have you know it's not overly complicated um I think it's a pretty simplistic system even though it's very big and robust on the table so it might you know people might bounce off it when they see it and be like Ah that's too much it's very simplistic but 44 Game of Thrones my number 44 is an uve game some may say our first best uve game no the best U game I know it's not ever create it and that's New York zoo no now New York Zoo last year for me was my number 26 so it has dropped a lot but that's because we played so I play I played on BGA though I do be playing it on there but we haven't played physically anyways New York zoo is a poly polyomino tile placement game where you're building out a zoo by collecting different animal tiles and those animals are going to do uve breeding which means five Mir cats make one very uh key key part of the70s exactly so anyways I I love this game it's so cute it's fun it's quick you could play it on BGA which is where I primarily play it I don't know if you could play it solo if you can I haven't tried and if I figured out that I could then I probably yeah let's look it up that's the thing about the internet

information at the fingertips it does I'll have to try it solo because that might even push it up even more but yeah it's just competing against other games like I said I rank based on gut feeli in the moment so if I did the same ranking today it'd probably be different my 43 uh favorite game of all time is Brian Buu from ospry games it was your 24 last year the these make sense so I've played a lot of Brian Buu at this point um and our most recent play wasn't a huge success I think there's some people around the table that weren't super into it which impacted again I rank off of experience um and our recent play of Brian buru wasn't as great I mean again it's still top 50 I love Brian baru um but I think it is a game that has to have the right group that fully understands what's going on and knows how to play trick-taking games I I think knowing how to play trick taking games is super important in Brian buru um because you have to throw off at times and other times you want to win um but it's a beautiful production uh I love trick making and the theme Just Hits I I Brian breu is another one that's probably always going to be in my top 50 just depending on what the recent play was like y um where that the rank is going to fall that's fair it's a great game I freaking love it all right my number 43 has dropped this year it's actually dropped every year over the past three years that it's been on the

list and that is Cascadia we just don't play it as much anymore and I it's tough competition now it's got a lot of tough competition I still think it's an amazing game though m obviously like this game is well-loved for a very good reason um so we did actually play like the roll andri version of it this year and so we just haven't played like Cascadia I did enjoy the role yeah same anyways that's my number 43 it was my number 31 last year and then my number uh oops sorry it was my number 40 last year and my number 30 the previous year so it hasn't really Fallen that much but Cascadia you are building out a habitat terrain and you're putting out animals you're trying to score the animals based on the goal scoring cards that you have placed out for them for the Bears and the foxes and the Eagles and all of that I think it's just it's it's a great game and I really love it yeah it is my number 42 I know was much much higher on the list last year uh and that is London another ospre game it was your 21 last year uh London is a engine builder card engine builder where you are basically building out London and then you're going to to trigger your city um at certain points in order to activate each area in order to score victory points effectively you're trying to build out your town your city but not build it out too grandiose because then you're going to start taking like is it plague I can't remember uh no poverty yeah you're going to start taking like

poverty tokens which are negative so basically you need to build your engine efficiently enough that it's not such a sprawling City M but tight but big enough that you're going to score enough points and not have to take poverty or at least be able to overcome that poverty uh round over round um London is one again that will continue to be on this list it's just going to depend on how much I've played it um we don't get to play this game nearly enough um it's so good it is very very good and I think one that will continue to kind of Bounce Around depending on how much we've played it it also plays great at two that's another like benefit of it yeah my number 42 has dropped a little bit this year as well it was my number 35 last year my 33 the previous year and that is paint the roses and you want to know why because nobody will play it with me and it is on BGA but I just find it really really difficult to play this async and I don't really play BGA games lot Ben s will play with you if they move here when they move here they will play with me pain theosis another deduction game obviously with where you it's obviously Alice and Wonderland theme and you are trying not to get your head chopped off by this ilol queen and basically what you're doing is you're going to have a card that tells you kind of what you need to have placed onto the board and then you're going to be giving out Clues using cubes uh it is very very difficult but I love this game I think it is so hard that it makes my brain

happy and when you do get it which I think we've only won one time I don't even yes we did we did one we won one time I remember it well um when you do get it just feels really good and I just yeah I love it and it's a beautiful game also it is all right last one up for me my number 41 well last one up for me of this section 50 to 41 imagine we just stop didn't do anymore trolled everyone uh is Watergate another one that I know was much higher on the list 35 last year okay so not too bad uh Watergate is a 1V one tug-of war game where one person is playing as the Nixon admin rtion and one person is playing as the journalists that were trying to uncover uh and discover the Nixon um Scandal effectively and you're doing that through card play all of your cards have like uh certain events that they can trigger or actions that you can utilize in order to play out investigative tokens in order to pull the track towards you or away from you um and that's basically it it's like this grid movement thing of investigative things that you're putting out and basically you're the journalists are trying to draw connections to Nixon right and Nixon's trying to battle that by blocking off regions so they can't draw the connections it's incredible but again it's just a game we haven't played as much of this year as we have in the past um I have a feeling like this is on BGA now it is um we played it on BGA yeah and I feel like I didn't like it

digitally um it's another one I feel like you have to play live I don't like it as think yeah you forget what you're doing and stuff um again Watergate is going to continue to be on this list it's it's an incredible two-player experience um and one I very very much enjoy uh I know people don't like the theme so much but doesn't matter to us they're Canadian don't know nothing about it um my number 41 is Parks Parks has been all over my top list last year it was 19 the year before it was 44 the year before that it was 11 uh and so it'll just probably continue bouncing around but I think it'll always land somewhere on my top 50 because I just love this game we got to play the roll and right version of it this year um I believe here's probably one of the main reasons they took it off BGA I don't know if it's back but somebody told me it was coming back or it might be back or whatever um why would they do such a thing because that's where I played it the mo most of all I think it's coming back I think I saw it in Alpha yeah and so anyways adding an expansion I just love Parks you're like hiking along the the trail and you're taking actions and you're trying to collect the resources in order to visit the parks and I just love the theme and this has been a game that we have kind of had in our collection since we really got like deep into the Hobby and it's just has a very like nostalgic feel for me and I I really love it y yeah but those are the first 40 wait the

first 10 10 that was the first 40 did you did you catch them all anyways we are going to be back again our next video is going to be our 40 to 31 okay and then actually I don't know if it's going to be our next video that comes out but the next one of the series is obviously we're going to go in numerical order so we would love to know in the comments below was there anything on there that you were like H I wasn't expecting to see that on the list remember not like why did you put this on the list you idiot we don't want to hear about that anything else is welcome but that is everything that we have for you today now if you're interested in bind board games like any of the many that we mentioned today you should first start by checking your friendly local gaming store and for us that is the boardroom Game Cafe and if you like what you see Please Subscribe we hope to see you again soon and now we say goodbye goodbye later it is you're adorned with dog hair yep wish that I had head hair spray or something cuz my flyaways are flying 50 to 41 right yeah nailed it nailed it Jeff let's get into it Jeff would you like to that's the section that no one watches that's a section no one watches but if you did I give you a high five thumbs up yep I can't remember the polisher name uh weird weasel something weasel

games Wicked Weasel no weird weasel the weasel of wesselton the wesselton devious devious weasel why wasn't this on my 2024 list because you didn't include it because you didn't play it okay let me go back let me redo it because I thought it was 2024 all right

Progress saved