Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Game Pleasant Surprises - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 19:53

hi everyone today i'm talking about my top 10 pleasant surprises when it comes to board games so these are all games that i wasn't necessarily expecting much from i was kind of expecting to get them to the table and pretty hastily move on from them however i thought these are all pretty damn good and at least much better than i was expecting so i've ranked these in order from the the kind of difference between what i was expecting and how good they actually were so these aren't necessarily in order of my least favorite to my most favorite but still all pleasant surprises before i get started on the games i want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kianda dot co dot uk who are my go-to online retailer here in the uk and if you use my link in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order but without further ado let's get on with the video at number 10 i have elements which is a small box card game and this is essentially a micro game because i think there's only 18 cards in the entire deck and these cards range from value one all the way up to i think it's value six and all you're going to do on your turn or throughout the game is play cards either in the middle of the table which is this kind of target value you're aiming towards a bit like a game of blackjack but with a moving target and the other option you can do is to play cards in front of yourself with the aim of trying to be as close as you can to that target without going over and there's some additional options you could do as well such as discarding value sixes from your hand to try and get thin out your deck to give you a bit more agency to give you a bit more accuracy when trying to reach that target um but i love this tension

and how delicately balanced this game is and the kind of the the trigger to end the round is all in your hands because if you're content that you are in a better position than your opponent you can call the round there and then and if you are in the best decision best position you will score at x amount of points but if you incorrectly call it you can give your opponents even more points and then it's essentially a race to get to a target value of points um but i just love how simple the game is some of these rounds take about 30 seconds to play but it is pretty damn tense and it's almost like one of those um like traditional card games you could play in a pub or something very breezy you know you can sit back and relax and enjoy the game but there is still some tension there and that balance is quite finely struck and i do enjoy the game in its entirety so it only takes about again 10 minutes to play and i think it's a pretty damn good experience for that that i really wasn't expecting much from and um yeah very pleasantly surprised by elements at number nine i have a favor of the pharaoh by tom lehmann so tom lehman is generally known for his engine building style games such as res arcana race for the galaxy role for the galaxy and more recently dice realms and favorite of the pharaoh is actually another game that uses dice but this uses dice in a more traditional sense more in like a yahtzee variant as at the start of the game you're going to start with a basic bunch of dice you got to roll them with the aim of trying to get you know pairs or three of a kind that kind of thing and as you do this you're going to start acquiring more dice and more mitigation

tools all of the aim of using these powers and dice to get to i believe it's seven of a kind and it's gonna be the first person who gets that seven of a kind will be the winner however everybody else does get a chance to kind of trump that if they can but i love the way that as the game goes on you're getting more and more powers there's limited options available to you so you want to get them first to get the best ones and every single time i've played this game the end game has been um extremely exciting as you know somebody reaches that target then the next player bets you know betters it by just one and then the next player betters it again so there really is that kind of ruckus tension and that real excitement at the end of the game and you know what i'm really impressed with the variety that the box offers because you get a ton of different power so every single setup is different and you know if you want something that's you know it is pretty much a pure dice chucker but you do have some good choices to make here and you have that you know a big buffet of options on how you want to approach the game so that is favor of the pharaoh by tom lehmann at number eight i have sweet landia which is another simple filler game um all with the idea of trying to collect sets of cards to score as many points as you can over three rounds and all you're going to do on your turn is you're going to select one of these cards that are basically pre-determined bids that you have ranging in different numbers players bids are going to give you first draft when it comes to drafting the cards that you want and of course lower ones are not going to give you that priority but they can actually give you bonus points so sometimes it's good just to sit back and i'm not so bothered about these cards here let's play a low card and get those extra few points in my pocket

but as i said you're going to collect these cards and these cards are going to have different powers or abilities on them they're going to give you different kind of scoring synergies um and so you're going to play three rounds of that and the person with the most points at the end of the game is going to be the winner but i love the way that some of these cards have this everlasting ability on them so they're permanently in your tableau of cards so that you can constantly you know keeping increasing or you know compounding on your previous scores to give you those extra points and it's just a very simple game that flows very nicely it feels something like a game like for sale but maybe even a little bit simpler than that but i do like the pure variety of cards that you have here sometimes you see cards that you haven't seen before so every game does feel kind of different and i also love these restrictions of these public and private objectives that you have because there's always going to be two public objectives which might say things such as you know have no yellow cards at the end of the round or have at least three blue cards and because everybody is competing over those then again that's that extra attention to get the cards that you want but additionally you also have a private objective which could kind of conflict with those public objectives so you need to decide which ones you want to go for and maybe even adjust your strategy as the round progresses because you just you know you're limited your options might be completely limited and you cannot achieve everything so i really like this one there's really not anything i can criticize about it it's just a pleasant experience that every single time i've played i've ended up feeling satisfied and just enjoying it in general so that is sweet orlandia at number seven i have rustling

leaves which is a roll and write style game however this game uses dice in a way that i haven't seen before so as you'd expect at the start of the game you're going to get a player sheet and that player sheet is going to have a bunch of different symbols on it and this big grid essentially and all these different symbols going to score in different ways but the way the game works is really interesting as you roll this pair of dice and this dice i think it values up to one up to value four and basically all you're gonna do is you're going to square off a bunch of these symbols on that grid equal to the dice value so if you roll say a three and a four you have to draw a three by four grid on your sheet and then tick off one of those symbols or one type of these symbols within that box that you've just drawn and then you're trying to score as optimally as you can and these symbols might be as simple as um you know score a point for each tree you take off or it might be score you know five points of each pair of birds you take off or it might be things such as don't don't box in these type of animals so there's a ton of different variety here and the game also comes with four different booklets that score in different ways each representing a different season so a very fast game and one that's just again very pleasant to play not too thinky but thinking enough um and i just enjoy this one every single time i play it and it's been a kind of a regular um thing that i pull off the shelf and get played so often because it does only take 15 20 minutes to play and you know when you get to the end of a game session and you're a bit you know your brain's a bit fried this

is the perfect game for that so a kind of a quintessential filler really that's um yeah definitely cemented itself into my collection at number six i have alice's garden which is a pretty straightforward polyamino puzzle style game as you're trying to fill up your sheet of these polyamino tiles however within those polynomial times you've got a bunch of different symbology all of which again score in different ways so essentially what you're trying to do is you're trying to get these like chess pieces on this strip of chessboard on your player on your player sheet you're trying to get these mushrooms in columns you're trying to get these trees in rows but trying to keep them as far apart as possible because you can get more points for doing so you're trying to get these cars next to each other because each time you do that you're going to get this you know individual square that you can be really flexible with and fill in gaps in your sheet because if you have gaps it's going to mean negative points and to be honest generally generally speaking polymer no games are something i kind of stay away from because i'm a bit you know a bit bored of them really but this one somehow managed to bypass that it managed to really impress me because it is so breezy it's fun again that puzzle within the puzzle is so enjoyable to try and map out and the drafting system is again quite enjoyable because each round play people are going to choose the polymer shape that they want to place on the board which means that every other player also has to place that shape however the game immediately ends as soon as somebody cannot place that shape on their board so sometimes you have to look at other players boards and think you know what everybody can place the shape so therefore i will choose this one because you know i'm not ready to end the game yet because i

don't think i'm winning that kind of thought process comes into the game and another game that takes about 20 minutes to play i'm engaging from start to finish and just a really solid filler that massively impressed me at number five i have first rat which might be one of the most deceiving games that i've ever played because on the facebook this game looks like a kids game it looks you know nice and fluffy and silly really and it is those things however there is much more meat on the bones than first meets the eye with this game so essentially this or the kind of premise of this game is that we are this bunch of rats and we are trying to build this spaceship to go to the moon because we think it's made of cheese so quite a cute and charming little theme there but there is some again some game here as you are essentially trying to move all your rats of a certain color up this track um as you're stopping on these different spots along the way you're collecting resources these resources allow you to share spaces with other people they also let you to let you buy unique abilities when you reach these certain checkpoints i mean you're also trying to climb another track which will kind of increase your yield of resources when you land on certain spots up to that point um i love how powerful these abilities that you can get are because some of them might let you you know move a lot faster some that mean you might not have to pay cheese if you share a spot with somebody else some of them let you use the tunnels for free and little shortcuts and all of these things are so so inviting there's a bunch of different strategies you can go down and it's one of those games where if you do things fast you get compensated you know more than if you go there later so it's a race to do all the different things

before anybody else does so you get that bigger chunk of points but you can really specialize in a certain field as well and it's just again a bunch of options there's always something good you can do uh very simple mechanically but there's a ton of things you need to think about and again everything just feels fun and it takes about 45 minutes to play and if you want that game that bridges that gap between you know being inviting and almost gateway level but still having more here then um that will keep you coming back to i suppose is what i'm trying to say so it's maybe not the perfect game for brand new gamers but as a next level kind of gateway plus game this game just really does fit that niche perfectly at number four i have acropolis now this light tile placement game really did come out of nowhere for me wasn't sure what to expect but you know what this game is rock solid and it's almost like a hybrid of a bunch of tar placement games that i already love um so this is a game the way you're building a city but not only are you spanning out this city you're also building vertically by placing tiles on top of existing tiles not only to increase your multipliers when it comes to scoring but also to get stone because when you lay on top of these quarries you get stone which means you get more flexibility in drafting the tiles that you want and all these different um kind of colored um segments on these tiles are going to score in different ways such as you know if you want these temples you want them surrounded by a bunch of other tiles so they're completely you know landlocked or you want these kind of barracks on the outskirts of the board where they're you

know they have at least one edge exposed or you're trying to get these shots in isolation or you're trying to get these residential areas all together so again you've got that kind of spatial puzzle there but the scoring system works a lot like king domino if you're familiar with that game where you have to try and collect these multipliers otherwise you're not going to score anything and there really is that tension of trying to grab the tiles that you want to get those bigger you know big outputs when it comes to the scoring phase um this game really is like a mishmash of a bunch of my favorite target placement games such as miyabi where you have that vertical aspect same goes with the ginkopoulos and also again king domino which we've already talked about but yeah this game just really manages to harmonize a bunch of these things together and plays in about 25 minutes um just a really good puzzle and there's even two different levels you can play this game with you you can do the basic mode which i kind of explained or you can do the advanced mode which places even more restrictions to make it even more difficult to make those different criteria score but really breezy game ultra fast turns and it's just been a massive pleasant surprise to me that i'm just you know really enjoying playing so that is acropolis at number three i have garum which might not look like much because the box cover and the artwork and graphic design might look a bit beige and boring to a lot of people however the gameplay here is fantastic as this is essentially like an abstract tile placement game as each round you are going to draw this um draw this tile which will say um in this round you're playing in this

particular segment on this big grid which is you know the main board and what you're going to do is with this hand of towers that you have you're going to place your tile within that segment within the grid and within that tile you're going to have another grid which is going to consist of logos of your color but also all the other players as well and what you're trying to do is you're trying to build up either rows or columns consisting of your color and after you place your tile you have the option to place a meeple aligning with that row or column with the aim of scoring more points at the end of the game so the more the more colors of your type you have that row or column the more points you're going to get however if you don't reach a certain threshold you're going to score negative points so it almost has that push or luck mechanism as well so you can kind of secure your spot early and risk people sabotaging it or you can wait a bit longer until you've definitely got a good amount in that row or column and then place your meeple to you know kill those points but if you do that you're going to risk losing that row or column to another player because they might claim it before you do so some really cool decisions there um and i just love that interaction because no matter what you do you're not only helping yourself you're probably going to help somebody else so you've got to think like you know this way helps me but it's going to help this person more and maybe i don't want to place it there and i'll use that hole a bit later down the road but so simple um you know as simple as it gets mechanically but again the decisions are there it feels quite unlike anything else out there and the rules on its surface are very dry um but the gameplay is satisfying i've

never had a bad game of this i've always had people leaving the game thinking you know what that is way better than i thought it was going to be at number two i have docmus now docmus is a root building style game much in the vein of the rhino canister classics such as you know blue lagoon or through the desert i mean in this game you're trying to kind of expand your route out trying to get next to these temples and these temples going to score you points at the end of the game um the difference between this game and all these others i mentioned though is the fact that the board the main ball that you're playing on is modular so it consists of these i believe there's nine different tiles which you'll get these different segments but before you even get to expand your route you're going to draft this kind of god ability i suppose and that ability is going to allow you to manipulate the board to you know to your favor so you can like slide these tiles along either vertically or horizontally and you can rotate them all that kind of thing so what you're trying to do is basically trying to move these temples closer to you so when you expand out you don't have to expand too far but of course as the game goes on everybody is messing with this board meaning that your your pieces are constantly getting shifted around and getting kind of separated i suppose giving you more spawning points to to move from so that's pretty much what the game consists of so it's very abstract quite puzzly um but it just works for what it is and i was expecting this to be subpar to those community games but i think it is definitely as strong as those and that extra dimension of that draft and again that modular board just take this to a different dimension so

really enjoy this one very pure in the way it plays and you know definitely a hidden gem and a massive pleasant surprise for me so that is dockamus at number two and finally at number one i have east which is a euro strategy game and it's a bidding and air majority set collection style games you've got quite a lot going on here however the game play is very streamlined and i actually bought this game as part of a job lot so i bought a collection of games because there was something there that i really wanted and each just so happened to be in that collection i thought you know what let's give it a go it probably won't be much let's get it played tick a box and move it on and however when we started playing the game we all just kind of stopped and looked at each other and thought is it just me or is this game absolutely fantastic and i still feel that way now so in this game you have a bunch of these different cylinders ranging from value zero all the way up to value eight and you're going to use these cylinders to blind bit you know you're going to put them face down so nobody knows what you're bidding on these or on the board and this board is divided up into quarters and you're trying to control these different quarters because if you do you're going to get these gems of different colors and those gems are going to score you points in you know at the end of the game it's going to be the many way you score points however each of those quarters is going to get divided further into three segments and if you control the segments within those quarters then you're going to get another bonus such as collecting a different type of gems which will score you points on a on a sliding scale so you want to collect as many of those as you can or they can even give you things such as unique powers that you

can use any time throughout the game so there's so many different things and different fronts that you're competing on and on top of that you have a kind of a commodity speculation style of the game where you can bid on another part of the board meaning that you're not bidding on collecting the gems in the first place but this segment will kind of manipulate the value of those gems so say you've collected a bunch of blue gems and you need them to be worth the most you can bid on another section to basically move up the value of those blue gems to try and make it the you know the hottest commodity so i love that i generally like commodity speculation games and this one might just be one of my favorite examples of that get so many different things you have to compete in you have to bid for turn order and all of which how they sacrifice to it because if you're bidding here it means you're gonna lower your bid somewhere else but you can use those you know value zero syringes as a bluffing tool to try and you know almost deter people from competing with you so yeah really like the way this game works i it sounds more complicated than it is um criminally underrated you know nobody talked about this game anymore might be because it does look a bit beige a bit you know a bit boring i suppose to the naked eye but the gameplay here is absolutely fascinating so much fun and um yeah one of my favorite games actually so there we have it those are my top 10 pleasant surprises hopefully you've enjoyed this video if you have please be sure to hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too i'd also love to hear what games have been pleasant surprises for you so please be

sure to leave a comment below but for everybody else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved