Beyond Solitaire Podcast 160: Trevor Benjamin, Roger Tankersley, and David Thompson on Co-Design
Transcript
it's ad break time I'm proud to announce that the Beyond solitire podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations although the kickstarter campaign for their next game hydrologic cycle has ended you can now pre-order copies of the game so go and support science games if you are so inclined their next Kickstarter campaign for eyeball to eyeball a cold war simulation game will launch in late June clgs also continues to offer classes in partnership with Gen Con their next course will be intermediate roleplaying game design with a ly Las Santa which starts June 19th I know it would be fantastic reports from his students have been nothing but glowing and if you want to support this podcast please visit patreon. / beon soliter and help me keep the lights on but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davids from beond soliter and this week at the pot I have not one not two but three very special guests uh I here with game designer Roger tesley game designer Trevor Benjamin and I guess game designer David Thompson so how are you all doing today gentlemen doing good Liz yeah ditto very good yeah good and that pregnant pause is the awkwardness of all of us waiting for the other one to speak first we'll have a lot more of that yeah don't worry I'll just conveniently edit it all out till we sound totally smooth like there was this perfect flow uh but for those of you who are out there uh the reason I have brought Roger Trevor and David on today um is because uh we all are various codesign relationships so David and I are on our
second codesign Trevor you and David are on I don't even know how many Cod designs we can talk about that and then Roger you have designed games with David and Trevor both right so actually let's uh let's let's peel that apart for people so um Trevor let's start how many games have you and David done together at this point oh God I if I I should have thought this I should have counted beforehand how many has it been I don't know 12 something yeah double digit Jesus yeah nice yeah it's a lot oh my God yeah how many are we going to hit double digit undaunted soon we I think we hit six this year six this year this will be the six one yeah and there may or may not be more in the pipeline so yeah it's it's keeps going so War chest there's four War chests six undaunted uh partridge in a pear tree general orders or CL there's a lot yeah I think yeah I think it is 12 anyway a lot too many not enough not enough David never enough uh and then y'all also did war chest y That's you to right y excellent and then Roger where do you fit into all this what games have you worked on with David with Trevor with both so with David do Sniper Elite expansion of Sniper Elite couple other things going on in the background right now and then uh all three of us together resist Witchcraft
and then another new thing going on in the background so yeah it's getting up there six or seven now so yeah yeah not bad excellent yes what about you Liz what about you Liz oh we're daveid and I are number two now but honestly night wishes was such a fun process that we decided to do it again so I had to I had to meet the other people who are as crazy as all that and then David how many Cod designers do you have oh this is just three uh it's a lot it's a lot I don't I don't know because I've designed quite a few games with just one you know with one person right so I have worked with Chris Marling on a couple also from Cambridge part of the same group that that Trevor and I were were a part of and then quite a few historical war games where I partnered with somebody specifically because they're like an expert in the topic right so oneoff uh codesign Partnerships so probably probably five or six more individual oneoff kind of partnership and I've um I've done about God again double digits number of games with um another UK designer Brett J Gilberts and then Matthew Dunston and I have done a game together and then of course Matt and Brett have done 20 or 30 games together so it's all very incestuous but you know that's the way we roll in
Cambridge I'm just gonna as a quote there you know so when when Roger and I first met it's when when we lived in the UK at the same time obviously Roger and our Americans uh I mean it's it's a little unfortunate that Roger We Didn't Start collaborating together earlier so that Roger could have attended some of the Cambridge meetups because he was there but but wasn't part of the the rest of the Cambridge cabal that Trevor and I often reference yeah really had no aspiration to be a game designer I got I kind of got hooked in because we were playing a lot of games and then we were testing your games and then Sniper Elite is what what out when we started right you said oh he knows I love hidden movement games like hey you want to make a game sounds fun sure so for me it's definitely the camaraderie and fellowship with these two guys you know more than the desire to publish a lot of games so yeah it's funny to say that because I also swore up and down for years that I would never be a game designer that I was not interested in designing games The Lies We Tell that can be that can be my lot I'll bring in people that have no desire to be game designers that can be my My Little My skill the game design evangelist oh my God all right so one of the things I'm sort of curious about and I thought it would be kind of fun to have this conversation is what do y'all's design relationships look like and let's just start with like when do
you typically meet and how often I'm just curious oh where do we start again pregnant pause where do we start okay so um so let's do the three of us first so with so for me David and Roger um with our things it's pretty it's not regular right um I would say so um it you know when we're sort of in the process of working on a game oh God even that it varies it's pretty sporadic I'd say for us as the three of us it's pretty sporadic and when it's three people as well it's interesting because as all saying a minute David and I meet regularly and I assume David and Roger meet probably more regularly and then they know each other outside of the game design world so they also meet so we have this weird thing where we'll talk about it feels always feels very naughty Fe talking about um you know the the the the game we're working on as the three of us when not three West in the room but it's just it's just that's just the reality when you have three people um and the time zone the time zone makes it tough right yeah so I'm in I'm still in the UK um and then obviously Roger and David are are back in America um for David and I we meet pretty regularly it's Sunday um afternoons um America time evenings for me and then um Tuesday same
thing and then Thursday we regular we quite often meet um and that's super early in the morning for David and you know reasonably decent time for me in the morning um and then periodically we'll meet um other times but it's generally two or three times a week quite regularly and that's been going on for yeah basically since David has moved back from the UK to to to America yeah I think one thing that's interesting and this this kind of and yeah I'll Echo exactly what Trevor just said right so Trevor and I meet super regularly Roger and I meet regularly but not as frequently right and then when the three of us are collaborating it's it's irregular meetings that come in spurts right and I think that that um the frequency of our meetings reflects an interesting difference in the design Dynamic of a trio work together versus like a a Duo right so when I work with Roger when I work with youz you know this and when I work with Trevor just as like a a codesign just a two person codesign almost no design work gets done when we're when we're apart like all of the design work happens when we're together and then we always break apart and we take like actionable tasks that are not really game design tasks they're like write the rules or work on the TTS module or make or whatever but no design
work gets done that's different when we work as a me Roger and Trevor work as a trio just because it's it's impossible we would never get anything done if we're were waiting for all three of us to get together to do the design work so we actually do have a different um creative process when the three of us collaborate versus any of a like a Duo collaboration and I will just say following what Trevor said anytime two of us meet when we're talking about a project that the three of us are working on and we follow up with an email or a text or something to the other person that wasn't there it's like it always begins with an apology you're like P like we we talked sorry uh yeah make sure you have you don't offend the third party who wasn't present we're here to inform you of this decision we made about your game so here's a question Roger Trevor do y'all ever meet with each other and not David no never I I don't even like Roger so I mean I mean and he's so he's so far away I mean I assume it's it's already Monday where you are or something right yeah exactly no we've we we haven't have we Roger no I don't think so no we've never worked on anything just the two of us U saw each other a few times in person playing games and things when we all lived in England but yeah yeah yeah that's really interesting so um we could talk about just the the two person design stuff first maybe then I do kind
of want to know how things get divided up so yeah I mean David what you're saying tracks in terms of like our relationship so basically for me cesing with David means that we both meet online at like 5:30 in the morning because we're both into being up very early and then we go on tabletop simulator and move pieces around and talk and take a lot of notes and then play through stuff um and make changes and then we come back and do it again in like one to two weeks so that's that's how night witches got made uh but when you're doing it with three people and you have different people like having different conversations do y' all split the work in some way like how do you how do you portion it out when you're not just doing it all together I think we do a pretty good job of when we are together we real quickly say okay what is left to be done what are like the big decisions that need to be made and so we'll we'll kind of talk about those who come up with a plan we're going to try this we're going to try that and then when we go away it's okay I'm going to work on option A Trevor's going to work on option b we're gonna see which one feels best and and then come back I don't know that we really I guess we do divide the work a little bit but mainly it's that we go we all go off and think about whatever problem we tackled and then we get to a point where we're like hey we need to talk again we kind of have some some ideas of what we want to do but let's just hash it out and be done yeah I agree with that think what's interesting is um of all the design Partnerships I've ever had I've never
once had a conversation where we explicitly discussed roles and responsibilities right like we've never said like I'm going to be the person that us XYZ um Trevor and I because we work together so much have organically sort of evolved into roles and responsibilities that we clearly have right like CL Trevor will clearly write the rules like there we don't even talk about it anymore and will take notes and I will do all the TTS Stuff Etc um Roger Trevor and I have because we worked on resist and then Witchcraft and now we're working on another game um we've sort of interestingly evolved into a similar relationship where like Roger leads all of the Thematic stuff and the historical stuff I'll do like the initial like sort of game design surge just to get us something to start with and Trevor um will again he'll read all the rules and stuff like that and Trevor I would Define as kind of leading the development and refinement of the design but we never had that conversation it just organically like we clearly have strengths we clearly have things that we like to do and it and it seems to have worked out pretty pretty well for us excellent so when you decided to do a project among the three of you what made you decide that it was something that you should all work on together was it just sort of like a hey we should all hang out and we should do a game together or was there a specific project sort of compelled the collaboration so we we first started
working together with resist um and what happened was that resist is published by salt and pepper and salt and pepper had reached out and asked for probably almost a year to two years saying basically hey we want you to design a game for us we don't care you can design whatever you want and I can't remember what it was but Trevor and I had just finished up an undaunted I think probably it's always always that it's always like between undaunted we have a window of opportunity and so um there was a a brief window like a couple of months and we looked at what possible themes would be a fit for a a Spanish publisher that wanted to break into starting to do their own English and Spanish language games that was interested in historical topics which led us to the topic of resist um but when we had that moment of opportunity I emailed Trevor and Roger both because I like working with them both and I said are either of you interested in this that was I I basically laid it out like hey this is gonna be the theme or whatever and they both replied with like yeah sure and I like oh I guess the three of us are going to work on this so that was it worked out really well but um it was just it was exactly that I was just basically hey I've got a couple of months this is a game I want to make are either of you interested and it turned into resist which obviously was was you know well received and so witchcraft was kind of a an obvious follow on and then the three of us like working together so uh yeah just kind of spawned from
that nice any other comments y'all no that's pretty much it it kind of fell right in Step Right David described what salt and pepper wanted to do we said oh we need to we should do resistance he hit on a couple of key gameplay mechanics right away we started looking at the history and yeah just kind of took off I know you know what um one thing that I I don't know how much of a of an effect this had on their desire to want to work on it but we knew that Albert Monty was going to be the artist of the game before we started on the game and I mentioned that in my email to them so they would have been idiots to say no because we had the opportunity to work with this amazing artist on the project yeah it's a no-brainer for sure yeah yeah I'm feeling spoiled right now with artists so I guess I could say I get that yeah when your first game lives as IO tool you kind of like that's yeah you know where I
go so here's a question then have y'all ever had a serious disagreement about the direction that one of your games should take not about I mean I guess it depends on how you define Direction I don't think we've had a serious disagreement about direction we we have disagreements about particular mechanics or the way things are done uh so good example early on in resist it made sense for the cards Albert did this awesome prototype card that was vertical with this kind of slash through the two personas of the person but you had to turn the card and so David had had some experience with that so other game design and to me it was like we're not doing that we're not turning the card over it's got to be side by side and it didn't it wasn't a disagreement for long we kind of like yeah okay that makes sense and moved along so otherwise no I can't remember times where we kind of hit roadblock that we couldn't just quickly talk through one of the things that I think we do pretty well is somebody have come up with an idea we'll try it a couple of times you could tell pretty quickly that works that doesn't work and we just either abandon it or move on you know so I think that probably cuts down on the discre is for sure what about for undaunted yeah well I was going to say that I think that usually what'll happen happen is that one person will care more about something than another person and if we're at a point where the decision is largely like a subjective decision
then we give difference to the person that feels most strongly about it I I would you guys yeah you would agree with that yeah yeah for sure yeah yeah it's you you kind of yeah I mean cuz generally speaking when you're in this sort of relationship right like I mean you have the shared goal you have this shared you know um you know and you have you have a shared goal to get the thing done you want to make as best as good as it can be and on top of that like you know a we're all friends and B like these are longterm design Partnerships right like you know that they are far more important than any particular project so like I don't think anyone's going to like throw you know throw their toys out of the pr just just for one particular game right so I think I mean that that's the the the core bit of the background is that you know yeah I mean we have had like David and I had for a game we worked on recently um just the two of us it was probably the closest so it's not out yet it hasn't been announced so I can't say give specifics but like we we we we have since framed it as chasing Trevor's fun because I just wasn't finding it fun enough and I think David would have um you know let it move forward but I just I wasn't going to have it and so we did we did have a and
we and led to us grinding our wheels for quite a bit longer than I think we would have either of us would have liked but um but I mean I was right in the end so it's all it's all good David do you agree yeah I think so no I mean what Trevor is saying is true so this has happened a number of times and I can't I'm sure it's happened at some point with undaunted I think probably with war chest certainly with the game he just mentioned but also um Trevor and I have worked with Trevor's most frequent design partner Brett on a couple of designs now that we're pitching and um in that case too there have been examples where we get to a point where I probably am like yeah I think it's good right I think we're we're at like the the 90 whatever 9095 % solution like I think we should move on and in some of those instances Trevor is not ready to move on and they does get to be a point of frustration and it's so it's not about a specific point and that's the that's the the the the the issue of the frustration or the origin of the frustration is that um oftentimes we can't articulate the problem we just know that there's a problem and and so it becomes like a bit Yeah annoying right yeah yeah yeah and I think one thing thing that that worked really well so in that game that Trevor's talking about that we can't talk about which is annoying for the conversation um we Trevor and I just literally just ground through it like we just kept hitting it and kept hitting it and kept hitting we finally had a breakthrough
and we're both happy with it a recent example with a work a game we're working on with with Brett we put that game away for months many months and that game has taken a complete like we took it out for the first time we played it we saw some of the same problems and then we like regrouped and we just kind of reimagined that game and it worked really well but that was just a we had the the luxury because it's not for a publisher wasn't already signed we had the luxury of just put putting it away for six months or whatever was and coming back to it fresh interesting would youall say that you all three of you prefer Cod design to solo game design at this point so I've never done a solo design I think I prefer it I don't know that I'll ever find out the difference because I don't have any plans to do any solo designs yeah same I've never I've I mean I when I first started um so like in the early days um yeah I I had solo designs but the second I started working on code designs I instantly discovered how much you know how much I enjoyed it and how much more productive I was in it so I basically just like I never I never tried to pursue things on my own I used to tell myself that I would do it once just just to sort of to to show that I could but
every time I've had an idea I'm like I could probably just do this way on my own I'm like yeah why bother just it's just it's like it's it's just not a it's not as it's like I said it's not as fun and it's it's It ultimately I think Cod is signs lead leads to better games and so you know why do it I mean I know that lots of people have different ideas about these things and I don't think some people are interested or in some cases particularly capable of working in a group but certainly for for me and and well like I'm I would have no interest in doing my own yeah there's a lot of there's a lot of practical benefits in codesign right um not to go find play testers for through the design itself especially in a two-player game which which I do a lot of two-player games or what are effectively two-player games but I mean honestly for me it's like what Roger and Trevor have kind of already hinted at it's just way more enjoyable like we're not in it for the money that's for sure and so you know why are you doing it well this is I think for all of us it's because we enjoy spending time with people and so I would much rather be working on this with with my friends right I mean the this group of four people is three of my closest friends in the world not my codesign partners right so um yeah not making heart with my hands uh but I mean that's you know that's why I'm here is to to spend it
with the people that I care most about and have fun and you know now having said that one thing Roger and I met when we first moved to the UK as co-workers for our day jobs and we both we we were our jobs where we moved to were to basically lead like um sometimes like challenging difficult conversations in group settings and we were basically almost always the two leaders of those discussions and people so we we didn't know each other so we got to know each other really well really quick and and we definitely became fast friends but we also uh would have very tense conversations and people would leave those meetings thinking like those two dudes hate each other right why do they even talk to each other what is happen yeah oh oh we were like the old Bugs Bunny cartoon I don't know if you guys remember this there was like a a sheep dog and the wolf or something and they would like clock in when they'd go to work and they were Arch enemies and then they'd leave and they'd be best buddies after work that's right at work we had the tense tense conversations and we go home and play games so well and it was I mean we both realized we had respect for each other because we we knew about each other and that we were good at our jobs and then the things we were working on were important right we actually had to deci something and we just figured out the best way to do that is okay this just argue right one of us will convince the other we don't do that as much with game design stuff right we don't really get into into discussions like that need discussions I was actually gonna ask because you know honestly you know okay
David I think you and I have been doing codesign stuff regularly for two years now has it been that long yeah yeah I think so like we're hitting two years in July yeah of like routinely meeting to talk about night witches and now our next game um and I don't think that we've ever even gotten heated yeah I think it's what Roger I think it's what Roger hinted at earlier so like all four of us are are talented I would say in what we're doing and we all bring a different perspective um and all those perspectives are important and informed and so Roger hinted at this earlier like if we have a thought or dis even even a disagreement we just play test it you know that's what we like if one of us has an idea we don't none of us have ever told the other one like that's a stupid idea right it's always oh well you know I'm not sure and we'll talk through it like hey I don't know if this sounds good or not but let's test it we'll figure it out like Roger said it's gonna come it's gonna you know make itself known whether it's a good idea or not whether it's the best path forward so I think it helps too that the three of us all have the same game design goals none of us want layers of crunchy rules none of us want a bunch of book to read to learn how to play the game we want slim easy to understand rules that let the players interact so since we have the same goal a lot of those decisions get made oh what about this and you go well that'll have these three knock on effects okay then let's not do that so that helps a lot I
think yeah out of curiosity do youall spend time at the beginning of a game project talking I guess extensively about what the golf is about what weight you want it to be at um what what you're trying to evoke from the player like when David and I started night which is and actually we start our next game too like we have a lot of conversations about what we're trying to do before we start doing it um is that y'all's way or do you just kind of hop in and then talk about it
later for sure if not right at the beginning very early on for me I I do talk a lot and they give a lot of thought to what do I want the player to feel yeah so we've adopted this this idea usually starts with a loose theme and then David usually has a good concept of these are kind of the general mechanics and then I'll start thinking okay since that's the theme and that's the mechan what do we want the player to actually experience what do we want the person to feel when they're making a decision um I don't know Trevor I don't know if you kind of have the same oh it's a tricky one because yeah this is this is interesting so I like I we've alluded to the fact that I I probably do half my design work with David and then half with this guy Brett um and um we have very different processes so we when I'm working with Roger and David um very rarely am I the one who sort of originates the idea right so um I mean obviously with undaunted well okay I me undaunted is different right CU it's like with undaunted like we must make a new undaunted game and then Dave and I will brainstorm my new ideas that we'll work with Osprey that publisher to brainstorm new ideas um but yeah with Brett we're that's where I do a lot more of the sort of just out of nothing ideas and and there and there I so I I very seldom I think come from the idea of like what is
I'm trying to get the the player to experience it's more just a case of what it's like so what you know like the idea can come from anything it could be an idea for a component or an idea for you know I want to make a card game that's suitable for this type of you know people who like you like trick taking games or whatever so it's yeah it's I don't often come at it from that sort of experiential perspective I think except in very broad terms like I want something that's you know quick and fun to play um but yeah it's it's it's a tricky it's a tricky one that the whole where where is what's the origin of of an idea and what is it that you're focusing on in in those initial stages um yeah I'm yeah maybe I'll just leave it there it's it's um like I said basically with David and with Roger I'm usually sort of playing more of a development role for sort of their ideas rather than originating um you know sort of my I guess yeah there there are some there are some very common themes that run across all the games that we've all worked on together which is to say and Roger hinted at this already like quick playing low complexity games like every game that we've worked on is going to be like a complexity of 2.5 on BGG or lower they're all GNA play in an hour or less like and that's there like I think I now
Liz I know you of all of us you play longer more complex games as hobby like you you'll indulge in that more than the other of us right um but for the rest of us I know for a fact I speak for Roger and Trevor when I say we all like lighter quicker playing games and so our designs reflect that but other than that it it will depend on the game right so there are some exceptions like general orders which the entire permise was to make a worker placement War like that was it that was the origin resist was literally let's make a game about the Spanish Maki right the more the game that we're working on now was we could talk about it because it's not with a publisher I mean literally was we want to make a game about a regular Warfare during a period a time period right what does that look like so there's like a a very like a kernel of an idea that it may be sort of an abstract concept or may be just literally mashing up two you know gameplay mechanisms or whatever but without us saying it none of us are ever going to indulge in a four point you know go complexity thre player crunchy hero like it's just not going to happen yeah so speaking kind of on that note then so when uh one of you comes up with an idea how do you decide like oh this is something that's like for us this is an us thing like this is what we want to move forward with because I feel like everybody has lots of ideas but then choosing which one you want to do and who to do it with is like a more complicated choice and so how do y'all
know when it's like you know DAV Trevor how do you know when it's a you project that's not undaunted and then for the three of y'all how do you decide what you're going to do next that's an interesting one that's a really interesting one like let me I should think about this CU yeah um because so basically if it's anything conflict which I'll I'll go to David or David and Roger like that's just that's just what like and if it has any it's funny that we said all these games we work on our light and you know like if it has any degree of complex because for me it's ridiculous but undaunted is like probably the most complex game I'll ever designed right so if it has any degree of complexity from my perspective it would be something that I would I would bring to David or David and Roger right like a lot of the other things that I do are like you know know like family hobby at the at the highest and then increasingly I'm working on things trying to get things into like even more sort of like super casual Mass markety stuff and for that um I almost always will bring it to Brett I mean David and I have experimented with that a few times um and but yeah generally speaking I will take those ideas with Brett because
very much his sort of his his interest and and bag too so yeah that's I mean for me that's kind of the the bation of the things now like as David said me him and Brett David and I have worked on a few things together and I'm trying to remember the origin of all those there's only been a couple none of them are published yet but I think it was did yeah what'll happen is you guys you and Brett will work on something that has like a clever mechanism that I want to expand into something more thematic and a little more complex so I'll bring the idea to you guys and say hey this is a riff on Cafe fat all right like or whatever what some game that you guys have worked on but Riff on that and turn it into something bigger yeah yeah but but so you know sometimes so I haven't really given this much thought but like if I wanted to work on something that is is based on like a historical theme or something that I think Liz that you would appreciate or Roger would appreciate I would approach one of the two of you about that and if it's something that's less concerned about the historical theme but more like general orders I would go to Trevor um but but sometimes things take a life of their own in that decision-making process so for example this current project that the three of us are working on I already mentioned is regular Warfare it's a it's a topic that Roger and I had discussed it's a topic we like we enjoy historically we enjoy games in it so it's a thing that we had just
abstractly talked about like hey this would be cool blah blah blah for like years a year or two um and so finally there was a a trigger point I was like okay we're gonna work on this game but that's as far as it got we're gonna work on this game I haven't really started any work on it but then I was meeting with Trevor and I walked Trevor through a concept I had for that game with this godforsaken convoluted combat system and Trevor's like you're an idiot take that all out and it had such a found and like literally I think he almost said that um thought we were nice to each other in these relationships nice you don't know but it's good to be direct right there's a fine line between direct and unkind but he was right I mean Trevor's point I'll speak for him on this because I think I I think I can do that in this case he he was basically like through this combat system you're coming up for this game this is not this is like not part of the game that you and Roger want to work on this is totally adjacent to it it's not necessary it's convoluted it's just going to it's going to distract from the actual point of the game and it was such an important point and impactful point that I was like why don't you work on this game with us right because I would feel I mean it wasn't that he like provided some advice during a play test like it was a a foundational contribution to what the game would ultimately go on to become I weasel my way into my 33% that's what I he five five%
it's funny to David you mentioned the the Catalyst for this one because David and I have talked about this uh topic for a while and we I think we were both kind of hoping somebody else would figure out to make the game that we wanted to play until we finally were like well it's obviously not gonna happen so let's just make the game that's exactly right liter yeah and and there was a game that came out recently we thought it might be the game and it was not and so we're like screw it it's it's time we game we want play yeah so actually you mentioned like the percentages how do y'all negotiate contracts together and is there is it more complex with three people just everything by thirds it's that simple yeah yeah I I I would never I couldn't imagine working in a partnership where that was a point of discussion and now I mean that being said I know these things happen and obviously that's you know but I mean especially when working with friends like it's just it's it's just it's just always been the default that we split things um but yeah yeah if I was you know if I some if I reached out to someone else or someone else reach out to me then I guess would be something you have to you know be grownups and talk about but we it's never been an issue yeah one thing I really appreciated about David doing my first game with you is that when it was time to do a contract like I've never done a contract before so it was really nice to like be to read the contract talk to David about the contract and then we had
for like really Minor Adjustments there wasn't anything crazy that we that we didn't like about the contract but it was really like nice to have somebody like be able to bounce with about that so that I wasn't just walking in to something I had no idea was doing yeah yeah somebody who's experienced some bad contracts in the past so hard hard one experience yes that's right that's right oh man um so I would be real like I know that I have slighted Cod designers in the past like when talking about games because you know it's just it's just life how do y'all deal with the fact that David is famous and um and uh a lot of a lot of games we all work out with him get referred to as David Thompson games to what extent do y'all care that you're willing to been on camera anyway um and uh and how do y'all how do y'all cope So speaking for myself don't care at all and usually what happens is because it's a David Thompson game the David Thompson's W get up at four in the morning recording podcasts so so it it doesn't bother me in the in the least and I'm happy to just you know it's just fun to to make games with David so uh the fact that he is well known and has so many good designs means that if he and I come up with an idea we're probably going to be allowed to
make it which is awesome so I may think it's great yeah similar I mean so it's slightly trickier because I have had some degree of success with Brett um and Brett you know has but the other thing is I'm always I always have always felt like I'm the other guy in the two Rel in the relationships I work on right because um Brett and Matt have had you know quite a bit of success with um you know like games recommended or nominated for sh yaras and things and obviously David's a rock star in sort of you know the history his this historical world so I've always just sort of accepted being you know the other guy um and you know I'm I don't really care and David deserves it right like like like he's the one who's willing to get up and you know be his own marketing and go out on on podcasts and he's on Twitter about stuff you know so like you know it's fine I'm I'm I'm I've I've come to terms with being the other guy well so so here's so here's an interesting I look this up just now to confirm my suspicions so the thing is like when you say um whatever word you used was popular whatever it was like all of my so I'm looking at I'm just going to list my games in order of games that I've coded on in order of rank this is all games that I've worked on so I'm not skipping anything undaunted War chest undaunted undaunted resist Sniper Elite
it's not until the P's house which is like my sixth or seventh game that is a game that I worked on by myself or away from Roger and Trevor and so it Trevor Has mandala um I me Trevor Has other games that are that would be higher ranking for him that he did not work on with and so from a purely like if you just wanted to try to quantify s quote unquote success in terms of just games commercial success Trevor would be I would consider Trevor more successful than me um now in in the niche that I live in in like the historical war game Space which is a niche within a niche of course I'm way more well known because I'm way more active and part of that Community uh and I think that bleeds over into like the larger war game space and like both Roger and Trevor said I'm just way more active right like I'm engaging people on Twitter and because they're my friends and so you'll see me being active and stuff like that um but it it reflects the fact that you know it just reflects what it means to be active in a community right you take it takes on this this uh appearance of success where it's actually I'm no more successful than than than Trevor right and you could argue that Trevor is more successful than I am if you're trying to measure that and quantify it so would I be right in saying that you Roger and you Trevor are just relieved that David's the one who does all the front- facing work definitely defin yep we'll guiltily sometimes accept doing some of
it but mainly it's like yeah David go sounds good whoever you talk to yeah David how much did you have to bribe them to come on this podcast this is fun right this is different oh man no it's always fun to hear the perspectives because like because I'm sort of like a YouTube person who's gone into game design I'm more than happy to do the front- facing stuff um I would say that I'm not always entirely chill about it but that that also is more prevalent when I'm the one demoing the game and somebody does it to my face yeah oh man David I will say you are always a Class Act about it all yeah I'll call people out I mean you know it doesn't doesn't bother me make sure to call people out I could be a jerk if I need to be yes so David is such a jerk it's funny because because um I mean yeah obviously you know it happens all the time with undaunted or War chest other game day night but it also has happened the other way where sometimes um Brett will get credited with undaunted or I get un credited with some game that Brett worked on with someone else so it's all you know it's it's it's it's just the way it goes but you know all the power to them David you are uh all the power to you so for people who are trying to
design games and are thinking about getting into codesign relationships I would say that everybody in this chat agrees that codesign relationships are great probably because we have great codesign experiences so you know I'm working with David Ricky Royal is somebody I'm working with on some stuff for oath right now for leader games and he's a delight to work with um I have a friend that I'm working on actually a much heavier game with um like a Mach Val it's going to be like a coin or regular conflicts type game um so I I've just decided to follow the David model and like make lots of friends and make games with them but what would y'all recommend for people who are kind of starting out about choosing Cod designers and then growing and maintaining relationships with them for maximum success both like in terms of the game and in terms of like personal Joy like would any friend be a good code designer because I think no but how do you choose I I think something that could put stress and pressure on it is like I think Trevor a couple of us said a couple times for us the money side of this is basically irrelevant it's nice to get paid to make games but none of us needs the money to to live or if so if you had someone who was trying to actually make a career of it that seems like it could be stressful not a reason to avoid it necessarily but it would definitely be different yeah that's a really good point I not I had not considered that because that would just be one extra variable and what is like I mean I've
talked this is not the point of this conversation but trying to be a board game designer as a career has all sorts of stresses because you're so dependent on other people just to get paid right the royalties o something that basic and so yeah adding another codesign partner into that mix is just one more potential variable like like you said Roger I wouldn't I think you just need to approach it much more carefully because you have a lot more to to lose right that's a good yeah definitely I think so for yeah go ahead TR I guess S I totally agree with that the sort sort of the Counterpoint to that is that you need to find someone who takes it seriously enough right because I think this is one of the things that Dave one of the ways that daveid kn you know from the beginning have been quite has worked really well for us is that you know although we're not financially dependent on it we want to finish games right right and we take it very you know we take it seriously and and we hold each other to account these sorts of things and you know again like everyone has their different reasons or motivations or whatever or different desires when designing a game and there's absolutely nothing wrong if you want to sort of you know iterate on the same thing for years and years and years but if you want like you just need to make sure that you and the person you want to work with want the same things from it whatever that is whatever that
is right and so you know you know knowing that you have the same fundamental goals and direction I think is is important right um y this that's a that's a really good point and this goes back when you ask us about our schedules at the very beginning Liz and Trevor said that we Trevor and I meet on every Sunday and Tuesday afternoon just to be clear we don't schedule those meetings like that's a recurring if if one of us was to miss a Sunday or or Tuesday that's highly unusual like and we would let the other one know and that would be an exception to the rule uh and that's every Sunday and every Tuesday all year long right um now when you and I work when Roger and I work it's it's we schedule regular meetings based on the project we're working on at the time but um taking it a step further like that's one of the most fundamentally positive things about a codesign partnership is holding each other accountable like that's a huge huge huge piece of it that I know for myself when I'm working on a project by myself I don't hold myself to that same level of accountability because I don't have anybody you know responsible to to you know meeting whatever that obligation is so it's a very different thing but so yeah to Trevor's point you whoever you're gonna meet with you need to have whether it's a spoken thing or the sort of unspoken agreement are we are we co-designed because we're just kind of having fun and we're just meeting every once in a while and working on something that's fine that's okay or is this like something we care about that we are
truly trying to deliver on and we're meeting regularly and those you and the whoever you're partnering with need to be that needs to be in alignment right for sure um I think you had asked at the beginning of this question like you know does it me need to be friends or whatever I think you need to find the right balance between a friend or some person that you think could be a friend because you're going to be spending a lot of time together um but also like a person who you have a good sync with right so of all the people that I met co-workers that I became friends with when I lived in the UK and when you're American abroad and you're working together you become really close friends with a lot of people right only one of those people despite being in game groups and playing lots of games would I ever say like I'm both I both became really good friends with them and I think they would be a good design partner and that was Roger right so that was a lot of people and of all those people one person emerged that I felt both of those things strongly enough so I mean you just gota it has to be both of those things together interesting so have you you don't have to name names obviously but um have y'all ever entered into a design relationship that you realized was a mistake and had to back out of it or have youall entered on a project that you realized that you needed to stop doing and how did you communicate about that I can so I can talk about a project Trevor you want to talk about it or you want me to no you go ahead you go ahead you're you're much better at polit
putting things politically than I am so well well I'll say this you know you know when you hear people like this is often used in like the movie making industry whereever they're like oh we split ways because of creative differences and you're always like that's total they don't something happened behind the scenes and they broke up or whatever um this would like Trevor and I actually were we were designing a game for a publisher and we literally did split on good terms because of creative differences right and we finally reached a point where the the relationship the publisher wanted with us was not the relationship that we typically do is like as designers we this is an oversimplification but we basically go off we design the game and we turn it over to the or when it's ready for development that's it right now we are totally happy to receive feedback from them and iterate or whatever but what we don't do is have like weekly meetings recurring meetings that kind of stuff and that's what the publisher wanted and we just couldn't do that and so it it unfortunately came to a head where it was causing like actual personal problems for us right like in our personal lives and so not with each other but with our what independent personal lives and so we just decided like this has to stop and we just went to the publisher and said hey we wish you the best you can take everything we've done for you up until this point but we have to stop now and I think that's important like we waited too long honestly we did we spent a lot of time and wasted a lot of time for both us and the publisher we should have stopped it earlier but um knowing that like this is
not a relationship that's going to work is you should not continue down that path right um so that's yeah that's without getting to into more specifics we we have had that situation how much time do you give something before you decide because I can see doing it too long it's like well maybe if I do this maybe if I do that can I fix it like well like I said we gave too much I don't remember the exact amount of time it was six months maybe nine months I mean it was a long time uh we gave it too much time we kept talking ourselves into oh it won't it'll be fine etc etc and like I said it required something bad happening to us in our personal lives like affect the the pressure of the situation affecting our personal lives for us to say like this we have to stop now we can't do this anymore yeah interesting don't let that's for the people listening that's the lesson don't let us you know learn from our mistakes end it sooner would you say that that would also apply to like a a design with another person that you don't think is working like I sort of feel like interpersonal obligation is really strong so one of the things I'm afraid of and I to be really careful about agreeing to projects is I try to really make sure I trust the other person to have a good experience with me um and vice versa before starting yeah um but like you know how much vetting contemplating waiting do do before starting a codesign relationship with someone and you know if you if you end
up in a bad one do you finish the project and just not do it again or would you recommend pulling out that same way you probably got more experience with that David I mean I I have a story I can tell but maybe you should start and so I mean I mean certainly I would suggest if possible and again this is like don't enter into a project with someone um like the first project you do with someone be let it be one that doesn't have time pressure or like you know I would I what I what I wouldn't want to do is or I would be very careful about doing would be working on something that was sort of like commissioned or what with another design partner that i' never worked with before right because I've definitely been in situations where you know I it's only happened a few times where I sort of work with someone and just yeah we didn't gel in some way or something you know and and then you know the the the projects just sort of fizzled out and you know there know was no problem because it just yeah it just it fizzled out but certainly if you're in a situation where it couldn't fizzle because there was someone else dependent on that design partnership working to complete that project that that would that would be stressful um but um yeah I've never I can't think of those few situations
where it's been a fizzly type thing where it has gotten to the explicit point of saying this isn't working is it like and maybe that's the probably the more grown up and better way to do it but um I've never done that and um yeah but I don't know what what about you David have you ever had that happen so I I would I would Echo exactly what you said I would never so there's I'm gonna so technically there are situations like Sniper Elite where Roger had and I had never worked on a game together uh the Rebellion reached out as me to work on a game I went to Roger and said I have this all I said was hey this this is the IP I think it would make sense for hidden movement you love hidden movement games do you want to do this together with me technically we had never designed anything though Roger had play tested stuff for me we were really good friends I knew him as a gamer so like in that situation yes technically but in general I would do exactly what you said Trevor I would would I would never enter into a contractually binding situation as a Cod designer with somebody had never worked with before because that's all sorts of crazy pressure with a person you have no idea how you're going to collaborate with so I would strongly recommend getting into some sort of low stakes you know play test group where you're like hey do you want to work on this with me this is a spec game if something comes up it we'll pitch it right that's a much better approach um than you know some other situation I I have worked with people
that I mean even to con conclusion that ultimately you're like okay we we're done but we probably won't need to work together and you don't have those conversations I think typically both people are gonna kind of feel that way coming out of it and you're like okay that was that was an interesting experience but we don't NE necessarily need to collaborate in the future I've only ever done designs with these two right uh the only kind of edge case that's a little bit different than what you two have described is I have an idea for a game about music where you're riffing back and forth with Cards doing some kind of Dueling Banjos kind of thing right so I've talked to a buddy of mine about that who I don't think he has a degree in music theory but he's a musician and he understands music and so there's no pressure on it to get it done right we don't have it before a publisher but he is so passionate about music that it's kept us from making a game because he'll he'll come back with all of this super crunchy music theory and I I say that's cool I understand about a third of what said and it doesn't sound like a game and then we kind of wrestle with it for a while and and so we've been talking about it for a couple years we might get there at some point but but it kind of fits the mold you guys have described where if we make something that's great we're still buddies there's no pressure for us to make the game but I think if you're trying to do something where one person is like super passionate and and nerdy on a part of the topic it makes it a
little bit harder to turn it into a game possibly interesting David would you say that um in that situation you have Cod designs that look more like you're the designer and then you have a very strong historical consultant relationship yes you will see that with games like soldiers and postman's uniforms and by stealth and C where the code designer was a person who's a gamer who is a historical expert in the topic right and so I was going to them more as like they're probably more of like a historical consultant than they are a co-designer but you'll see me like like when I worked on um ler Ridge with Neils because the way we worked on that game where technically he's the artist and the graphic designer but because it's a game that's so much based on the geography of the situation like I felt like in all those cases that person did so much to contribute to the game that the only thing you can really do in the game design world is give them codesign credit right so you know we live in a world unfortunately where the game designers are sometimes their names are on the front and other people's aren't that probably should be and so that's an easy way to to say you know in in each of those cases I felt like the person did work that was easily worth reaching that that same level of credit yeah like if game designers are authors then they were definitely a co-author right yep yeah interesting all right any last uh any last tips for people who are who are
looking to co-design and enjoy it we talked about this already I I would just say you know if you're if you're interested in designing or if you've already started designing your designing or whatever the obvious place to do is work you know reach out to a play test group go be an active member there find a person who you have like you know that you work collaborate well with and let that build up over time right um don't I would not try to force it certainly like we talked about not under a contract you're initially um let it just evolve over time I think is the best suggestion I would give yeah um I guess the other thing I would add is that um even if you're not thinking about doing a design codesign like if you have an idea or you know have worked on games on on your own I would I would just strongly recommend trying it um for all the reasons we just like it's it's just it's it's such a wonderful experience to the point where like I mean my strategy very quickly when I joined this um this sort of Cambridge play test group we all you know for daavid I sort of start it was just you know don't don't like don't be over precious about your ideas like you know bring them and be willing to S you know just throw them at someone and say you know do you want to work on this together because almost always it's it's and especially if it's someone who's who
you know is more experienced than you and even if it's not like something something almost certainly something better will come from that collaboration than that you could do on your own um so yeah I mean just just just give it a go but at the same time I mean you know try to find someone where you some you know there like again it's difficult but some you you know you can see that you have a similar attitude towards games that you know you're you're you get on with sort of interpersonally quite well and yeah just just just give it a go I think you said something earlier Trevor that uh you prioritize the relationship it's not so much the the current game you're working on and getting it to be exactly right it's more okay I'm going to concede a couple of things because I I want to keep working with these guys and it this is fine and we'll move on to the next thing because great things will happen if we can make their relationship so just think of it that way I think is is good advice fantastic all right now for the softball questions uh the first one is um what are y'all playing right now that brings you Joy all right I'll go go I'll keep waiting um okay I have two two answers to this I was ready for this question Liz um we've done this before uh basket boss okay so for for years I've been wanting to
design play games that play Super quickly I mean I in my mind it's always American football but it doesn't have to be in this case it's basketball that let you like take a franchise through multiple years where you're the manager or whatever um actually that was the origin story of the first game that Trevor and I ever designed together or Olympics was going to be this idea of American football you know franchises blah blah blah and it turned into or climic but anyway basketball is a game I played recently and it does exact that you're you're managing your your basketball um Team over six seasons it plays in like 45 minutes super fast um really good game it's an auction game so maybe not what you would expect and I'm a horrible person I should have looked up the um the designer so I could actually credit the designer and the publisher but BGG as I'm typing it it keeps uh correcting me to basketball which isn't helpful as I try to look this up oh that's so respectful I know I know okay cor van morsel is the designer and it's published by board games table board game tables so uh super good I loved it I've only played it once but I've got a very rare game day coming up uh this coming weekend and it in Versa 199 were my two requests so it's it's in some good company um so that and then the other thing that I have not yet played but it's on literally just opened it up and super excited about playing with my daughter is uh flam and Fang so
from Michael Kelly W and Peter Gus over on OneStop Co-op shop who stole the golden geek they stole it I'm start the controversy right now it should have been soliter but besides besides we all know how many of those episodes I appeared on too so they should just yeah we know yeah that's right so so Liz was on One Stop Co-op shop but they were not on your podcast so we now know why no M Mike's been on no that's okay for for those of you who are out there just you know like what's up Co-op shop is great and we were all just like but we're all we're all we're all we all love each other very much we all love my computer no so this is a game that actually Liz and I we play tested this together um it was so good it's yeah it's an awesome game I got to play tested in person at Gen Con so it was an auto back for me uh this is like the exact kind of game that my daughter and I love to play so I I have it sitting on my table uh ready for us to play this week so I I finally after a very long wait you can probably see it in the background there on the Shelf I finally got a copy of heat so I've played it once or twice right uh my family loves racing games so I'm super excited to play that with them I think it's GNA be a good one uh and then the other one uh my old I have two kids my older son's home from college I just got home this week and a couple of years ago we landed on 51st state as the one that he and I would always play and so we can get that one out we both
entirely know the rules and we can just sit and play and it's it's just fun and relaxing so those are the two things that I'm that I'm playing right now excellent and uh for me um I'll mention two so um one I know that most of you guys played which is um prey another day which is um a game that um like Brett Gilbert and Matt Dunston designed and yeah I have played that game game I don't know 150 times this year I absolutely love it and just just to be clear I don't like a lot of m games I love them both to but no I'm just going like I I I honestly love that game and I play with my family all the time and I played it with like my broader family and other people so absolutely love it highly recommend that and another one that I played quite recently um which I don't like as much but I really do like is um Trio I don't know if anyone's played that so it's a this weird memory matching game um it's been making the rounds um so it was nominated for the Azo so the um French game of the year and it's weird because I'm I have an absolutely trash memory um and so consequently hate match memory games but for some reason this game I ABS it's it's really good it's good fun so that I would mention those to so as you can see yeah no historical games no games of any complexity these are the things that I
know I know I'm terrible this is the last time I'm going to be on Beyond saler I'm sure you know the first and last exactly so yeah I would highly recommend both those games um yeah so you know for pray another day I when when Liz and I were at Circle DC I introduced Liz to it and then Liz was like the bad drug dealer and she had everybody at the con playing like pray another day took over Circle DC and um uh so yesterday I was at a war chest tournament at the C you're a good drug dealer yeah it's fine it's good so uh so yesterday I'm at the Capstone store in Cincinnati I'm supposed to be there for a war chess tournament right and so the idea was I'm there to help with rules and meet people and blah blah blah but what I was really doing is at any chance I could get I was introducing people to pray another day and just playing it the whole time so it's really good it's so good what a good game oh man I love it all right and then uh so I what have I been playing I'll add um I've been playing as much as I want for reasons that will become clear shortly um but uh the game of Play It's called Sphinx it's by David perkus but the person who contacted me about reviewing it was actually shotty torbet because it is from impatience so it's like the same publishing house that's like reprinting all the oniv verse games and so is not by shotty torbet it's by um it's by
David peras but it's got that same kind of like really tight like it's got a really tight design concept that it hammers home and this is like a tile manipulation game where you're trying to like get tiles of certain orders and configurations to solve Riddles In order to like get through the mysterious gates to go to the land that is run by the sphx um and uh and learn about the deeper Mysteries of the world I'm not actually sure it's a pretty thin theme actually but it's cool like it's like you know your manipulating tiles is very nice um I'm small stuff like I got the um the next uh the next um kire delve game so I'll be playing that um a lot over the next couple weeks I've been playing a gentle rain because like that's come back out into print uh and that's like a Kevin Wilson um incredible dream production so all the all the it's actually another kfire like publication house thing but a R is like a totally different thing it's a cozy game so I've just been playing lots of like easy cozy stuff and the kire the new kfire delve that's like the two new characters you can play in kfire delve right yeah and a new evil bus yeah my daughter and I loved it we really enjoy can fire delve so I'll I'll pick that up too yeah this one is scorns Stockade um my friend Andrew and I will be playing it uh before graduation this Wednesday because we are stuck at school waiting for the graduation ceremony so like I'm lucky the Latin teacher I teach in a joining classroom with is another solo
gamer and we are both really hardcore about it so I'm pretty sure our plan is to just like hang out until graduation and goof around so teachers have friends too ay yeah just to mention a gentle rain is on my list like it it's like that's totally my sort of shtick like it look it looks beautiful I'm really Keen to try yeah super simple super Charming um I am not good at it but that's not really the point so all right and then the last question for yall is where can you be found online if people want to follow you and uh and see what you're up to don't follow Roger Twitter because he doesn't do anything there I used to tag him I used to tag him but then he just realized he ignored everything so um no it's not even ignored it's just don't ever log in we we we started using Twitter because were at a con and the people we with wanted to communicate meetups by TW I guess I'll get a Twitter account but yeah yeah uh no you so I'm on Twitter that's probably the main the main thing it's djack Thompson though um Board Game Geek also right so you can look me up on Board Game Geek and that's good too yeah same with me so Twitter and Bor Game Geek I'm um Trevor and Benjamin and both of them so yeah reach out there King and for me only Board Game Geek I'm not really on any social media platforms at all but I am active on board game be so you know such a
healthy internal life if somebody wants to reach Roger they need to reach out to me or Trevor we're that's our job that's our lot in life is to be his communication i s back in the shadows right and then I of course be found anywhere online as Beyond Soler gentlemen thank you so much for coming out this is super fun uh I really liked just getting to hang out with y'all yeah thanks for having us thanks for setting it up all right everybody out there uh please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy Ging