Oathsworn VS Aeon Trespass Odyssey VS Primal The Awakening - BUY THIS, NOT THAT (board game review)
Transcript
We have spent the last 6 weeks absolutely throwning in miniatures, rule books the size of novels, and boss fights that lasted longer than my last relationship. We played Oathsworn, Aon Trespass Odyssey, and Primal the Awakening back to back. And I'm just going to say it, one of these broke me.
It broke both of us, let's be honest. But yeah, we've been living in these massive campaign worlds, playing them side by side to answer the ultimate buy this, not that question for boss battlers. And honestly, the answer isn't as simple as buy the most expensive one.
Definitely not. If anything, the price tag might be inversely proportional to how much fun we actually had. Let's get into the weeds of these behemoths.
So, just to set the stage for everyone listening, we didn't just dabble, we committed. We've been playing Shadoworn Games Oath Sworn Into the Deepwood, Into the Unknown's massive Aon Trespass Odyssey, and Reggie Games Primal: The Awakening. These are the titans of the genre right now.
And when we say titans, we mean it. Aon Trespass, or atto as we've been calling it, dropped in 2022 with this insane Greek mythology meets Evangelian premise. You're piloting 30foot titans against these primordials. It's huge. Then you have Oathworn, also from 2022, which is this gritty dark fantasy where you're mercenaries in a forest that hates you. And finally, Primal, which just landed in 2024 after a massive delay, which is basically Monster Hunter the board game, but with cards. The context here is huge because we played them back to back and the contrast was jarring. We'd finish a session of Primal, which felt like a tight competitive card puzzle, and then switch to Aon Trrespass the next night, which felt like managing a spreadsheet while reading a choose your own adventure book. And Oaths were in sat somewhere in the middle.
It's funny you mentioned the spreadsheet thing because that really colors how we see the mechanics. Let's talk about the core loops because playing them consecutively really highlighted how different they are. Like in Oathworn, that battle flow system was a revelation for me. Oh, absolutely. The battle flow in Oathworn is brilliant. You play cards around your player board and they cycle back to your hand based on what you play next. In our sessions, it created this amazing rhythm. Remember that fight against the broodmother? I was setting up that combo for three turns, pushing cards around my board so I could hit the cool down perfectly. It felt so fluid.
Yeah, until you decided to use the push your luck dice mechanic and rolled two blanks on a crit attempt. That's the other thing. Oath Sworn mixes that elegant card flow with raw dice chucking. It's tactical, but then you just gamble it all. Compared to Aon Trespass, though, Oath Sworn felt like a walk in the park mechanically.
Aon trespass, man. Look, the inverted combat paradigm sounds cool on paper. You get stronger as you take damage, and the boss gets stronger as it gets hurt. But in practice, our sessions were 15 minutes of excitement sandwiched between 90 minutes of checking rules.
Exactly. In our first battle with the Hecaton, I remember we spent more time looking up keywords than moving minis. You take a wound, which raises your rage, which unlocks a card, but then the primordial reacts, which triggers a fate card, which moves a terrain tile. It was exhausting. It's barely controlled chaos. Okay, but when it clicked, that moment when my Titan was one hit from death, fully powered up, and I managed to chain that god form attack, that was a high. Oatssworn didn't quite hit, but I admit it's a mess. And then you pivot to Primal, which was the complete opposite end of the spectrum.
Primal was fascinating because it stripped all that fluff away. It's just a boss fight. No map exploration really, just the hunt. The mechanics are purely card- driven deck building. You play a sequence of cards to trigger combos. It felt less like a brawl and more like solving a math equation.
A violent math equation. But you're right. In our primal games, once we knew the monster's behavior deck, which is a great mechanic, by the way, we were literally calculating optimal damage. If I play red, blue, red, I dodge the tail swipe and hit for four. It's deterministic. There's very little luck compared to the dice in Oathworn or the chaos decks in Aonto.
That brings us to the win conditions. Actually, primal is so straightforward. Kill the monster before you run out of health or time. Oathsworn is similar. Kill the boss parts. But AON Trespass, do you remember how confused we were about how to actually win the campaign?
Oh my god. Yes. In Aon Trespass, you can lose the campaign in like 12 different ways. Run out of crew, lose. Timeline runs out, lose. Doom track, too high, lose. We were constantly stressing about the metagame layers. In our playthrough, we felt like we were walking a tight rope. Meanwhile, Oathorn is incredibly forgiving. You lose a fight, you just get less loot and move on. which I actually didn't love about Oathssworn. The stakes felt lower. In Aon Trespass, I was terrified of losing because the punishment was brutal. In Oathssworn, if we wiped, the story just said, "You retreat, licking your wounds." And we kept going. But let's talk about the complexity because BGG ratings don't tell the whole story.
Yeah, Board Game Geek lists Aon Trespass at a 4.74 weight, and honestly, that feels accurate. It's one of the heaviest games we've ever played. Teaching it was a nightmare. Remember that first session? We took 3 hours just to explain the basic anatomy of a turn before we even rolled a dieice.
And we still got rules wrong. 20 hours in, we realized we were doing the knockdown reactions wrong. It's a lifestyle game in the strictest sense. If you stop playing for 2 weeks, you will forget how to play. Primal isn't light, sitting around a 3.8, but the complexity is different.
Primal's complexity is cognitive load. The rules are simple. Play cards, monster reacts. But tracking all the triggers, like when you play a red card, do X. If the monster has three struggle tokens, do Y. That fried my brain. We were constantly staring at our reference sheets. Whereas Oathworn has that brilliant companion system. When we taught our friend Mike, we just gave him a companion character. He didn't have to manage a full deck, just moved and attacked. It's easily the most accessible of the three. I felt comfortable with the rules by the second encounter.
Yeah, Oath Sworn hides its complexity well. It has depth, but it doesn't smash you in the face with it like atto does. And that accessibility really impacts how often we actually wanted to get it to the table.
Which leads me to scaling because this was the biggest shock of our playthroughs. We played these at two, three, and four players. And Primal, oh boy,
Primal at four players was a disaster. I'm sorry. I know people love it, but sitting there for 10 minutes while three other people agonizingly optimize their card combos was brutal. It's solitire multiplayer. You can't really plan your turn until the person before you finishes because the monster reacts to them.
Exactly. In our four player session, I checked my phone constantly. But at two players, Primal sings. It's snappy. You can coordinate. Contrast that with Oath Sworn, which I thought handled four players beautifully.
Oath Sworn worked at four because of the battle flow interaction. I needed you to use your ability to push my cooldowns. So, I was watching your turn like a hawk. We were actually coordinating. hit the tail so I can target the head. It felt like a team sport.
And then there's AON trespass. It says one to four players on the box, but that is a lie. It is a lie printed on cardboard.
It's a one or two player game. Hard stop. When we tried it with three, the downtime was excruciating because the admin overhead is so high. One person is rolling dice, another's checking the chart, the third is reading the AI card. It's a mess. But playing it solo or duo, it's manageable. So, if you're a group of four, Oathworn's the only real contender here. But let's pivot to the actual brain burn, the strategic depth, because AON trespass is complex. But is it deep? That's the million-dollar question. In our sessions, atto felt complex, but a lot of it was just procedural complexity. I wasn't always making interesting decisions. I was just resolving triggers. Oh, I got knocked back. Now I check for collision. Now I check for trauma. The strategy is there. Managing your rage is cool, but it's buried under so much paperwork.
Whereas primal is pure strategy. It's almost too much strategy because it's deterministic. There is a correct move. We found ourselves paralyzed trying to find the perfect sequence. It rewards skill heavily. If you lose in primal, it's because you played bad. If you lose atto, it's because you drew a you die card from the fate deck.
Hey, that's a bit harsh, but okay. Yeah, the randomness in atto is wild. Oatssworn strikes that balance again. You have the battle flow puzzle which is strategic, but the dice add that push your luck element. It feels deeper than it looks because managing those cool downs requires planning three turns ahead. I think Primal has the highest skill ceiling though. After we need that fire dragon the second time, we did it with half the resources because we had solved the puzzle. It felt rewarding in a very cerebral way, but it lacked the emotional highs of the other two. Speaking of emotional highs, let's talk about player interaction. We touched on it with scaling, but the vibe of playing together was so different. In Oathworn, we were high-fiving when a combo landed.
Yeah, Oswooper. There's no friction. We're a squad. In Primal, even though we're working together, it felt isolated. I'm doing my combo, you're doing yours. The assist cards exist, but they're minor.
And into the interaction is mostly just shared trauma. Oh god, we're all going to die because the timeline advanced. We discussed strategy on the map layer, where to sail the ship, what tech to research, which was actually really engaging. But in combat, it was chaotic parallel play. The map layer in Atto, we haven't even talked about the pacing. That game is huge. We spent 25 hours just in cycle 1, and we weren't even close to done. The pacing is weird, though. You have these long exploration phases, then a massive boss fight. The pacing in atto is uh difficult. We had sessions where we didn't fight anything. We just read story text and managed the ship. And then other sessions were a three-hour boss grind. Primal is the opposite. Setup, hunt, craft, done. 90 minutes, boom.
Primal's respect for my time was amazing. But Oath Sworn felt the most like a TV show. Episode, fight, story, cliffhanger. The fights are usually 60 to 90 minutes, and setup is fast. We could actually get a session done on a week night. atto weekend only dedicated table only.
Yeah, let's talk about the elephant in the room or the titan in the room. The table presence and components. Aon trespass comes in a box that weighs 22 kg. I threw out my back lifting it.
The storage for atto is a crime against humanity. We had to buy third party organizers just to make it playable. And the table space, we needed a 6ft table just for the map, the boards, the tokens. It took over the dining room for a month.
But the minis, wow, the interchangeable parts on the primordials, seeing the Titan actually climb onto the monster, that spectacle is unmatched. Primal has great minis, too, but the box bloat is annoying. Why does it need so many boxes for just a few cards and minis?
Practically, Oathsworn had the best production to usability ratio. The armory, where you swap weapons on the minis, is a gimmick, but a really fun one. And the standy version being an option is a godsend for people who don't want to paint 100 lb of plastic.
Agreed. Plus, Oathsworn has those massive story journals and the narration app. Which brings us to theme because for me, Oathsworn wins this hands down.
Oh, 100%. The writing in Oathworn is novel quality. The atmosphere of the deep wood, the green mud, the wire roads, it sucked us in. I cared about my character. In Primal, the theme is just kill monster, get pants.
Kill monster, get pants is the perfect description. It's very video gamey. The theme is pasted onto the mechanics. Why am I drawing cards to swing a sword? Who knows? But in Aon Trespass, the theme is epic, but it's dense. It's high concept Greek sci-fi philosophizing. I loved it, but I know you zoned out during the long readings.
I didn't zone out. I just rested my eyes during the four-page monologue about the nature of Divinity. But you're right, Oathworn felt grounded and gritty. Atto felt grandiose. Primal felt arcadey.
So cost and value, these are all expensive. Primal is like $300 plus allin. Atto is premium pricing. Oathworn is the cheapest if you get the stande version around $154.
Value is tricky here. And Trespass gives you 300 hours of content. Mathematically, it's the best value, but will you actually play it? We're burnt out after 30 hours. Oathssworn is a tight 40 to 50 hour campaign, which feels achievable. Primal is short, 12 missions, unless you replay it.
But Primal is the most replayable because it's a puzzle. I want to try it with different hunters. Oath's Warorn. Once I know the story, I'm largely done. I'm not replaying a 50-hour narrative just to see a slightly different ending text.
Yeah, fair point. So, it really comes down to what kind of fun you're looking for. Oathsworn is adventure fun. It's hanging out with friends, rolling dice, and hearing a cool story,
right? And AON, Trespass is lifestyle fun. It's for the person who wants to disappear into a world and master an insanely complex system over months. It's almost a second job, but a cool one.
And Primal is competitive puzzle fun. It's for the people who love optimizing, who get a dopamine hit from a perfect card sequence. It's intense and brain burning, but in short bursts.
Okay, moment of truth. We've played them all. We've argued about them. Let's give the people the verdict. Buy this, not that.
All right. by Oathorn if you have a consistent group of three to four friends who want a shared narrative experience without needing a PhD to understand the rules. It's the most balanced, the most atmospheric, and the most respectful of your time.
Agreed. And not that skip Oathworn if you hate dice randomness or if you're looking for a hardcore brainmelting strategy game. It might be too light for the heavy euro crowd. Buy Aon Trespass Odyssey if you are a solo player or a dedicated duo with a permanent gaming table and you want the deepest, most ambitious board game experience currently in existence. If you want to get lost in a world, this is it.
But not that. Absolutely do not buy atto if you have a group of four, if you hate checking rule books every 5 minutes, or if you get frustrated by bookkeeping. It will crush you. And finally, buy Primal: The Awakening. If you love Monster Hunter if you play primarily at two players and if you value tight, deterministic gameplay over story. It's the best boss battler in terms of pure combat mechanics. But not that. Skip Primal if you want a sprawling adventure or if you play with four people. Seriously, at four players, it's a snoozefest. And if you want value for money without replaying content, the short campaign might sting at that price point. Pros and cons debate for me. Oathsorn's pros, atmosphere, bottle flow, accessibility. Cons: limited replay-ability, storage is meth.
Rapid fire. Aon trespass odyssey. Pros: Insane amount of content, incredible minis, deep narrative. Cons: rules overhead is oppressive. Setup takes forever. Portability is zero.
Matching pace. Primals. Pros: Best combat system, high skill ceiling, snappy play time. Cons: Zero narrative immersion. Box Bloat. Terrible four player scaling.
So, the final recommendation. We've played them all. We're keeping Oathsworn.
Yeah, I think so. Oathsworn is the one I actually want to get to the table on a Friday night. And Trespass is impressive, but it's exhausting. Primal is great, but it feels a bit soulless compared to the others. Oathorn hits that sweet spot of fun, story, and tactics.
Although, I might keep atto set up in the basement just to stare at those minis. But for actually playing Oath Sworn takes the crown for the average group. Just be prepared for the green mud sucking at your boots.
Thanks for suffering through the boss battles with us. Hopefully we saved your wellet some pain, even if we couldn't save our own sanity. We're Board Game Critique and we'll see you in the next one.
Try not to get eaten by a primordial. See you.