Skip to main content
Loading video...

Mesos, Bebop, Night Soil, Greed, Chip It - Ranked and Reviewed

Transcript 19:42

Hey everybody and welcome to another Chairman of the Board ranking video. This is where I take a look at the last five new to me board games that I've played and I rank and review them in order of preference. And I've got some good ones to talk about today. But before I get started on the games, I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kienda.co.uk who are my go-to online retailer. And if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code, then you can get 5% off your first order. Also, be sure to check out my first game, Phalamus, that is now available for purchase. But let's get started. At number five, I have Bbop. So, Bbop was a game that I was quietly excited about because the designer of it openly said that he was directly inspired by the Rhinitia rootb building style games that I am very fond of. you know, think of games like, you know, Rebirth, Samurai, Through the Desert, Blue Lagoon. All those games just hit that sweet spot for me and are the style of game that I really enjoy. So, I was excited to see a new designer's take on it, just to see what they could add to the to the mix and to the recipe really. So, the difference between this one and those other games I've mentioned is that this one does not use tokens to spread your influence on the map. It you actually use dice. So, there is a random element where you're drawing dice from a bag you're rolling them and they're going to be the pool you can draft from or of course you can just do a lucky dip. But you are going to have a I think a

display of three in front of you that you can play with as any time. Kind of like your hand, but instead of a hand of cards or a hand of tokens, they are a hand of dice. Now, what you're trying to do here, and the theme is a little bit jarring, I'm not sure if it works too well, is that you are trying to get these matching instruments um surrounding these matching stages. So, the the idea is that we're at this jazz festival. Um let's say there's a band with a with a drum and a keyboard. You want to try and get your drum and keyboard people close to that stage or at least chaining from that stage to get I think points in one of three different ways, I believe. So the first way you can get points is that you can kind of compound the same logos together. So again, think of something like um Havalandi or Rebirth where once you put one token down, it's worth nothing. You put the second one down, it's worth two.

Next one's worth three. So it builds up and compounds on itself. And Kit's used this mechanism several times in the affforementioned games and also games like Millie Fury. So, I tend to really like that because, you know, you do you want to go for the quick grab or do you want to go for these slower strategies? So, the slower strategies are mainly due to creating clusters of the same instruments of of certain colors. So, for example, you want to have the biggest or the the most of your pieces within the biggest blue cluster. And if you do, you're going to get some bonus points um at the end of the game. But the the third way you can get points is to completely surround the stages where the um the tokens on those stages will go to the player with the most pieces touching it. So again, much like Samurai or Babylonia. So again, you can certainly see how directly this game is inspired by those other Kitian classics.

Now, a bit of a nitpick. The game I think looks a little bit too busy for me. You know, there's dice everywhere. um some zones are in play, some are not in play based on the player count, which is fine, but it would have been nice to have a bit more of a hard line drawn um on the board, and it's just a little bit daunting and overwhelming when you look and scan at the board with all these iconographies and dice of different colors and also um markers of different players pieces. Also, as you'd expect with a dice driven game, luck is a huge factor in this one. And unfortunately, I think it played a bit too much of a part in who does well or not. Um, there are mitigation tools where when you claim a seat, then you can roll one of your dice in your pool, which is fine, but often you don't get what you want anyway. So, that was a little bit frustrating. And, you know, for me, although Kitia does play with some random elements, he normally makes the pool of resources you have balanced so that everyone has the same amount or roughly the same amount.

At this one, you could just get shafted based on the the roll of the dice. Now, my biggest issue with this game is that the game actually adds one phase too many for me. And I understand this is a difficult thing to overcome because of the game. So, as I mentioned with those most classic Canian games, you just take a token from your pawn and you place it on the board and you move on to the next player. This one, you do not do that because of course the dice roll neutral. you have to have some way of showing that the dice are are yours. And in order to do that, you basically take one of your little cardboard cutouts and you reserve your place on the board before you place uh the dice in it. And although that sounds like a very minor step, um when you think about it kind of mathematically, it actually just doubles the overhead on the fussiness of the game because instead of doing one thing um in the game, you're doing two things which kind of completely kind of throws the flow of the game off because generally speaking, once you've reserved your spot, it's yours anyway. Yes, you can hold off on what dice you're going to put in there.

Um but kind of that decision is not there anymore. It's reserved. safe and you don't have to worry about it and it just adds a little bit one step too many in a two-step game which is kind of saying something really. Um, so I would have liked to have seen maybe each player have a their own personal pool of colored dice and play around with the cutters that way instead of having an extra step to reserve where the dice will go. And for me it completely kind of drew the or cut the legs off from under the game. Um, I found it a little bit laborious, a bit tedious. And there's kind of under no circumstance would I rather play this one uh over any of those other games I mentioned. Again, if you like the look of this one, try The Canitians, try Babylonia, try Through the Desert, you know, try Rebirth, Havalandi, Samurai. This game doesn't do anything better than all of those games do on their own. So, yes, sadly, it was a bit of a dud for me. I mean, in its own right, in a vacuum, it's fine, but again, a little bit too fussy and a little bit too busy for my liking. So, sadly, a bit disappointing for me. That is BBOP at number five. At number four, I have Chip It. So, this is a card shedding game where, as you'd expect, you are racing to shed the cards from your hand quicker than the other players. You're going to do that in a pretty tried and tested formula where one player will will play either one or more cards of the same number. Then everybody else has to follow either playing um you know the same quantity of

cards but a higher number. Um but the twist on this one is that you are not only using cards, you can actually use these chips in order to bolster the strength um of your hand. And depending on the color of card that you assign it to, those chips can have different values. So, I think it's the green cards. If you put them on there, they're simply worth an extra point each to, you know, to boost your value. But if you put them on, I think it's the red cards, then it will basically double or multiply the strength of that card. So, you might ask, why don't you just keep on taking chips? Well, the twist is that you need to not only shed the cards, you also need to shed the chips on those cards. And the only way you can shed those chips is by passing. And whenever you pass, you can get rid of two chips from your supply. So, it's pretty straightforward stuff, but I do like that extra moving part in the game. And sometimes, you know, if you're doing really well, um it just comes around comes down to a matter of just waiting for it to go around and you just just shed those chips in your turn and racing to get uh to zero. So, it's pretty simple stuff. I mean, it's nothing really new I I haven't seen before. But again, that small twist on the chips, you know, I suppose separates it from the pack a little bit. But again, if I'm comparing it to some other shedding games, I think maybe some of the twists on those more famous shedding games are maybe a tad more interesting. You're thinking of games like, you know, Linko or Scout. Um, don't get me wrong, this one's still perfectly fine and enjoyable. I do think it's quite up to

the caliber of those, but I tend to like these styles of games, so this is one that I'd never really turn down. is in a small box, quick and easy to play, and you know, it's just fun really. So, if you like your small little card games, maybe check this one out if you want a shedding game with a with a small difference when by using those chips um as well as cards. So, that is Chip It at number four. At number three, I have Greed. So, perhaps a bit unfair being placed at number three. Um, Greed was just unlucky that there was two fantastic games I played this month because on its own, Greed is a really well-designed little card engine builder and with a mafia or criminal underworld theme. So, this is actually designed by Donald Vakarino who is most known for Dominion and Kingdom Builder. So, there is a designer of good pedigree here. And I think maybe this one has somewhat faded into obscurity because of its more adult theme. you know, this doesn't shy away from um what it is. You know, there's there's killing, there's prostitution, money laundering, all the stuff you'd expect with a with a mafia theme, which I personally like. I think it's um different to the other stuff we're seeing out there. No anthropomorphic animals or nature theme.

This is a bit more gritty um and a bit more adult, which, you know, I know it's not for everybody, but I think it's nice to have something a bit different. But the gameplay itself here is actually um super refined and really clever. So this one you are partaking in a closed draft initially building up a hand of cards and then it'll be a simple one andone system. You draft a card and play it and you have basically I think three or four different types of cards. You have the kind of course the mob members themselves which will give you kind of benefits as well as being the prerequisites to play the more powerful cards. So you have like little symbols on them that which some cards will require to be played. You've got your holdings, which are your buildings essentially, which will be a bulk of how you get your money, and you the more you play the kind of the same symbols, the more money uh you can build up. You've got instant abilities, um as well as other things, too. So, really cool blend of cards here that all synergize with each other in weird and wonderful ways.

Do I want to play this card first, wait a few turns, and then play this one and duplicate the money there? Do I want to steal money off someone else? um but wait until the right time to play it. But perhaps something might change by that time. So there's a good sense of, you know, how do I prioritize my actions? Um which card am I going to take? Which cards can I let filter through to the next player and perhaps get back when it comes to my turn to be drafted again? Now, it has all the the drafting elements that you'd want and expect from a good card drafter. But what I really like is the the quantity of cards in the game here because it's quite a thick deck to play with and each game you only play with a fraction of that deck. Meaning that each time you play it, you can't really go into the game with a certain strategy in mind. So it has a good idea of um acting tactically with what's available to you, but you can go with at least a loose thread of what you want to achieve by the end by acting strategically too. So, I think it strikes that balance really nice of being unpredictable but predictable enough where it's not just wild throw caution to the wind. Now, because of that, I'm not I'm not entirely sure it's perfectly balanced, but the game is kind of quirky enough that that doesn't really bother me. And it's also only a few rounds, so it's pretty quick. And again, if you like these games that um are pretty easy to explain and all the fun and the juiciness of the game is on those cards, then this is one that I think has been definitely overlooked for a long time.

It's certainly fallen into the shadow of more modern engine builder card drafting games. And I think maybe a big portion of that is because of the more the more adult nature of it. You know, this doesn't shy away from what it is. It does really embrace that kind of criminal underworld, that mafia, you know, Sopranos theme, you know, you know, killing and stealing and money laundering, all those stuff you'd expect. So maybe it's not for everybody in that respect, but I personally like it. It's good to see something that's not so um, you know, repeated again and again by being aframorphic animals or nature theme or anything like that. So this one super nice. Um, I actually remember looking at this one many, many years ago when I first got into the hobby. I just never secured myself a copy. But now we've got it. I'm really happy we have because it's um it's actually a really nice well-designed game. So that is Greed. At number three, at number two, I have Night Soil. So I've actually already reviewed this game as an independent review. Um so be sure to check out that video. But this is an upcoming game by uh by Grail Games and is based on the TUDA sewage system in in TUDA London. So we are basically these contractors. We are trying to um shift all these poo cubes out of the city and throw them into the temps in order to get points. Points being your money in this game. And the game essentially is a worker placement system, but the workers are neutral. So all the workers are the same color. Um, and you need to be careful to try and make sure you always

have an income of these workers because sometimes you can be left out of pocket, meaning that you're going to be having a very weak round. So, I like this economy of workers that you need to be careful of. And you're going to do that by um, again, initially using these worker placements, climbing tracks, gaining influence with different institutions to get you special powers. Um, and then in the second phase, you are going to be playing cards that you've collected as well as some car starting cards to shift these cubes around and manipulate the board state, try and clean up certain areas and get the contract for doing that in order to gain money as well as gain gain workers back. But the longer certain locations on the board are neglected, um, the more money it's going to build up and the incentive to collect those is going to be uh, built up. But I do like the the levels of gameplay here.

where, you know, do I want to be placing my big worker here to put more poo cubes down to block someone else going in there? Do I want to keep going to the same spot again and again by placing my small workers there? Um, do I go after a certain power to give me an advantage? You know, perhaps I want access to the to the northern gate where nobody else can get to make me more efficient at shifting these cubes around. So, for me, this is a really cool throwback Euro with a quirky theme. Um, you know, I said in my full review that this one reminded me of the Estari line of Euro games where there's good decisions, but the gameplay is clean and formulaic. And for me, this is the kind of Euro that I enjoy, especially considering it's only around 60 minutes to play. Um, you know, it has a simplistic but nice look on the table and some good decisions based on on a pretty simple framework of the game. So again, instead of me banging the drum too much more about this one, again, be sure to check out my longer review and where I'll go into more details about the decision space and the autonomy of your terms. So that is Night Soil.

Thoroughly impressed and I hope this one does well when it does come out on the uh on the crowdfunding platforms. So that's Night Soil at number two. And finally, at number one, I have Misos by the great Simone Luchani. So unlike most other Luchiani games, this one is not some grandiose complex euro. It's a pretty straightforward set collection card game. And the drafting mechanism here reminds me of one of my favorite set collection games called Floriferus, where the initiative plays a huge part in what you can take and also where your standing is in the next round. So basically, you are going to be placing your token somewhere along this kind of one-way track. And the further along the track you go gives you access to more cards. There's two rows of cards.

There's kind of a top row and a bottom row. And one of these spots might say we'll take two cards from the top and one from the bottom. Some might say we'll take only a single card from the bottom and so on. And again, depending on how strong that is, depends on how along how far along the track you go. you know, the more cards you want to take, it generally means you're going to go last in turn order. Additionally, if you do go last in turn order, then you might have to pay some extra food and go last next turn. So, sometimes taking less is more here. Now, the cards themselves, they're all pretty simple and what they do. So, you've got these like shaman cards where you want to collect these stars. The more stars you have at certain stages in the game, the more points you'll get. um you're trying to get these kind of inventors where you're getting set collection bonuses. You're trying to um get hunters that will let you gain food which will let you feed your workers at certain stages or the foragers that will give you discounts. The builders that will give you discounts off the buildings that are very powerful in-game abilities as well as endgame scoring. So the most of the cars do things that we've seen before, but I do like the way that you um draft those cards in the first place. Now, additionally, this game is pretty tight um because every kind of few rounds you are hit by some events that will come out um that will kind of dictate what the players need to do. So, as I said, some of them there might be like a sha shaman ritual where at that point where the event is resolved, you want to have the most stars. So, you have like a buffer turn to prepare for those events

to resolve. Some of them might say, "Well, all your hunters now are going to gain you food." Some of them might say, "Well, now's the time to feed all the cards in your tableau." So, you need to be very careful about um the order in which you're taking things, the strategy you're going for, spreading yourself a bit thin so that you can tailor to all of the, you know, the events that are going to happen because, you know, if you leave yourself without food, you're going to get punished by losing a lot of points. And this is, yeah, this is the kind of card game that hits that sweet spot for me where you can plan ahead, but you're still acting tactically based on the cards available to you. Um, all the symbology on the cards is very clear. Um, and again, it's familiar, but different enough based on that drafting system, which I think is is fantastic. And I think the game strikes a really nice balance of not being able to do too much because, you know, you are put under constant pressure here to feed your workers. Um, you know, some people might find it a little bit tight at times depending on how these events come out. So, it can feel a little bit punishing, but I personally enjoy that and I think it hits the nail right on the head with what I want. So for me, this is like a hybrid between games like Floriferous, games like Palopony, all boiled down into this one simple, clean, fun, and familiar card game that I thoroughly enjoy and would highly recommend if you want a good card drafter in your collection. So again, this one kind of going from strength to strength for me at the moment is exactly what I want in my collection. That is

Misos at number one. So there we have it. That concludes the video. Hopefully you have enjoyed it. If you have, please be sure to hit like and subscribe to the channel and check out my other content, too. But for everybody else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye-bye.

Progress saved