Great Western Trail: New Zealand Review
Transcript
this video is sponsored by game Toppers turn your own kitchen or dining room table into a premium portable game solution at a fraction of the cost hey everybody Welcome to drive review 781 today we're going to take a look at Great Western Trail New Zealand which is the third in the trilogy I believe the final game in the in the trilogy of Great Western Trail Great Western Trail Argentina and now finally New Zealand uh so what I'm going to do is I'm going to go down to the table I'm not going to do like a whole big old walkth through I just kind of kind of talk about some of the differences between this Edition and some of the previous ones and what I also do in the review kind of in keeping with sort of the style that I do but also kind of give you like my top ways or favorite ways to play Great Western Trail so I you know I'll order them and kind of my favorite you know variant of of what all the system is bringing us uh so let's go to the table talk about some of the differences and stuff like that and I'll kind of come back and give you my general thoughts okay I've got things kind of split out here all over the table uh as you might see it during gam playay couple things to note you can see the main board you got the different trails and stuff that you're going up to make your deliveries and your delivery track there just like the kind of every game so far in this particular game instead of trains you have these little ships that you're going to drive around to give you little extra places to make deliveries so you have the normal kind of deliveries at the top but then you can also make deliveries here but in this game since we're dealing with sheep instead of cows we can Shear them and
then make like effective deliveries to certain spots over here on this board which I'll show you so that's a little bit different and then over here I'll zoom in a little bit closer here you you can see we have kind of two separated areas here one is strictly for workers and workers kind of have a more I don't know stable cost in a way it's very much a supply and demand so as you get more workers that are get drawn out of uh these bags over here the more of them that are drawn out the cheaper they are as they get bought up they get more expensive so they're not really dictated by this somewhat it's not really random but kind of random uh setup over here now what you've got down here you can see the cost kind of scales up and down based on you know kind of how far along in the game we are we have these different bonus tiles that you can pay for uh with money and there's different actions to buy those and this is what drives that endgame triggle which will knock off that little fivepoint bonus marker similar to the other two games in this series so the workers aren't involved in that process it's just these different bonus tiles although I should say you do have here this concept of a wild worker you can see that blond haired looking person there and you can see those are wild workers so if you buy one of those as an example you can put it down here here we have the shear here and you can also buy one of these as a a wild worker and put it wherever you want there and act just like a normal worker you can put it out to get a bonus tile and all that kind of stuff now a couple differences here we can see couple of things to keep in mind you have kind of your general idea here where you're making deliveries getting rid of discs
and stuff like that unlocking some of the extra abilities and the double actions and better movement and and more cards drawn and you have your uh certificates here which you can see that's all just like the other games here you have like this gold nugget track here you always start with one of these and then as you collect nuggets you can see these different symbols here there's certain extra cards outside of you know the Sheep cards or the cow cards in the other game and the endgame bonus cards there's these other kind of called deck building cards that you can spend and you'll Shuffle up some random ones uh from the game and there's a I don't know there's like 12 12 or so different maybe it's 10 different uh types and you'll Shuffle up four of them and then put those out for purchase and they're purchased here by gold and then as you spend that it'll go down here like so and then the other thing you can do here is if you want you can instead of spending these exchange tokens to kind of shuffle through your deck you can spend two of them to get rid of the one the cheapy shopshire sheep who nobody wants to draw that one you can get rid of one of those trash that from your deck and then also gain a gold and gaining and spending the gold here is kind of like a free action it's not really tied to any part of the game and then down here you have these little houses here which will unlock different bonuses now these houses will go over on that little C board which I'll show you in a minute and as you unlock these you'll get different bonuses either endgame points or extra gold or certificates or shearing bonuses or little tokens and stuff and so that's a
new little thing that you can get those to go out now speaking of shearing we mentioned that a few times we'll take a look at some of the sheep up here and this is kind of the the market where you can you can get at these just like you could the cows in the other games and it's the same idea here you've got here kind of the value that they are when they kind of go to market and the shearing value and you can see sometimes those are different so this Lincoln sheep here is a little bit better for shearing a little bit more woolly uh than it is to deliver to the market at the end of your your Trail there so when you take a shearing action you're going to do it based on the number of shearing workers which I just showed you down there so in this case we've got three so I can then at do point discards three different sheep and it's the same kind of set collection you know idea that you're building for the main delivery but you can also do this there's a special building on the board that could be the beginning of the trail the middle or the beginning or the end and then you'll discard those so if I had two Shear workers I could discard those and I would get $7 CU you can you just add up the shearing value and then you can if you want you're not forced to in this case like you are with the main delivery to put out a disc but if you want to you can put out a disc in one of the other locations that accept like a delivery of wool let's say and here at the top of the board these are kind of built in by default everybody has access to that so you can see 139 and five so if I do a delivery there I can put a disc out there's a cost you get some extra points this bottom one here this 13 you can put as many discs on there as you as you want it's a little bit
difficult to get to a higher number of shearing as it is you know for delivery because you need to actually have the shearing workers to even really participate in that at all but keeping with the theme of this board here as you move your ships out you can put these little houses out see I've got my little yellow houses out there and that gives me access to those little locations now you can see this one here if I can zoom in that five there that's a normal delivery location but I've got these two up in the corner the seven and the the 11 the seven is actually a normal one but you see the 11's got the little white background right so that's a shearing look now I can have access to place a disc when I do a shearing action there on that location if I've got a house there now there's other spots on the board here that just accept a house you can see this one's got a cost of $3 and when I do that I'll put a little house there and I unlock a little spot my board and then it'll give me four points at the end of the game and you can see the Bell there which allows me again to do one of those deck building card purchases which I'll show you in a second now the way that the boat movement Works they'll be different actions that will allow you to move your boat based on the number of the different types of workers that you have or spending money and that kind of things to move them similar to the trains in the other game and so you move them around to these different spots but once you get to a spot that has like a little dock a little Port there you'll spend one extra movement and then at that point at the cost of that extra movement then you can go ahead and put out one of those little houses there and then that cancels the movement for that particular action now sometimes little spaces will give you two movements you know or two groupings of movements so
you can try to kind of manipulate that in a certain way so you can like move a little bit and then put your thing in then if you you get another movement action on the same turn that you can take that kind of trounce around there you can see there's some like dead ends and stuff like that so there's certain sort of planning and strategy that you have to go into to do these different routes whether you're going to be shearing you probably want to go up this way maybe try to do some really big deliveries and you'll kind of come down this way or get out over here and you just you know want to get a lot of houses out and purchase some of the more expensive deck building cards that's kind of out here so investing in that kind of movement uh early will give you some options there as as well now before we talk about the deck building cards let's talk about this uh this bird track I should call it by its real name the Pathfinder track and so everybody will choose one of their actions here to start with and pull a disc off so you have kind of unlocked maybe a double action or uh some other action that you have access to at the beginning of the game and you'll put your disc there at the bottom and then as you get different symbols through card play or buildings you'll start to move up this track here so you can see you get gold and stuff like that and then you'll get more and more points the higher you get and the other thing you're going to do is kind of unlock Extra movement so let's go down here so you can see just like the other game you know if you pull one of these discs off you get extra movement there but the first time that you go past and it depends on player count a certain part of the Pathfinder track you add a plus one and then you have a choice actually you can actually add a plus two there or instead of adding the
plus two you can instead flip this tile here so you can see normally remember if you hit the different um obstacles and other player buildings that have these little hands youve got to pay at Cost either to the bank or to the other players now if you go up that Pathfinder track far enough instead of taking the plus two I can instead leave it at plus one and flip that over and now I don't have to pay anything when I go through those tracks so that you could you know you could kind of gauge that based on how many buildings people are dropping down cuz there's not always a a big building frenzy depending on how people are what are they're doing okay so now let's talk about probably the biggest change in a way to the game from the other systems is the deck building side now again before we slide all the way over there you also remember the bonus tiles I talked about some of these will have you engaging with purchasing some of these extra deck building cards and then you'll have different things that will allow you to pull off some of the obstacle features out here there's two types of obstacle features you can see there's the mountain one and there's River ones up there and when you remove those you get those tiles for the points but then you'll also at the same time be able to grab some of the standard deck building cards that are out here uh so these three are always in play there and then you've also got this one here the Romney sheep uh who will also be given to you when you make some of the shearing so if you do a lot of shearing you're probably going to be collecting a lot of those Romney sheep that's I think that's the only way to get them most of the time and so you can see those are worth a good amount of points they're a low cost
well they're a no cost sheep uh but they give you a lot of points and you know that can kind of help with your diversity so here you've got this display of all these deck building cards and they have these little tokens here like this so you can kind of group them based on the different things so they have different like purchasing power based on the the gold track that I showed you so these four over here might be kind of shuffled up in different ways these are always in play uh most of these have this little symbol here so when you get these in your hand you can play them immediately and then you do the effect at the bottom but these means you get to immediately draw a card right after the top of that so you could use you know build up your hand with the Sheep to score for points or trade him for money and that kind of thing so for example I play this one I get two bucks this is worth zero points then I can go draw another card off my deck this one here will give me another certificate temporarily and they have the bonus cards here this is the same kind of idea here again you play these and then they stay out you don't get to immediately draw a card you'll draw more at the end of the turn and then you know you're kind of committing to having this kind of end game situation for bonus points or losing points if you can't get there and then I talked about the Romney cards now these over here these four these again these all be different and so some of them might be bonus cards like you can see this is just a different bonus card and one thing to keep in mind these are all three points positive or negative any bonus cards out here are four points positive or negative and then you also have some of these other cards here like this one for example these are all worth a point at the end of the game so it's good to just buy them anyway and if you play this you
will get one point for each of the bonus cards you've already played and they get to draw a card this one here is a nice you know different kind of sheep here and this one for example allows you to either uh collect uh a coin or what this means is basically any cards that I acquire this turn go immediately on top of my deck instead of discard pile and so there's a lot of interesting ones like this that allow you to kind of do little cool activities like upgrade your player built buildings or put out those little houses on the Seaboard and that kind of stuff so this whole little thing here is kind of like the most different uh part of it but that's pretty much all the differences let's go back to my talking head okay so that was a very brief overview of some of the differences between New Zealand and the other two uh Great Western Trails uh so let's just jump into my review like I promised at the beginning I'm just going to quickly jump into kind of my favorite ways to play um player count wise same uh I think the play time is the same about an hour and a half 2 hours or so a little over 2 hours probably depending on player count so it's going to fit right into the same thing so if you like Great Western Trail you're probably going to like this uh there's it's not really deviating in any crazy way shape or form so let's just cut right to the meat of the chase for my final pillar of review which is what is this game like which will lead me to talk about which is my favorite and I'm going to kind of work my way up to my favorite way to play now now my least
favorite way to play Great Western Trail is the original game with the expansion I think to a person my entire group does not like the expansion uh it just does too much like completely different it's just such a drastic like complete paradigm shift in terms of like how you play the game so that would be like I'll call it my number four so we're doing my top four number four is the first game with the expansion now I think what they did it was something these later games is they've kind of corrected what they were trying to do with that first expansion I mean I don't know this is all my opinion right so that's what it feels like to me so my third favorite way to play Great Western Trail is the original game by itself so I really like that game it was been in my top 50 or whatever uh so I've really enjoyed it but I feel like the next two games on the list uh really have improved upon it and kind of like highlighted things that I was like oh I didn't really know know you know this was an issue but I feel like oh they give you these extra little tools and stuff like that to kind of work around some of the ways and made it more thematic and more you know integrated in terms of how everything works together and it really hums and it doesn't really disparage in my opinion the first game but if you pin me down and I'll get when I get to the end of the list you'll kind of see what I'm talking about but I would say you don't really need the first game uh anymore although you know it's it's the most simple to play the game
for sure the base game just the original Great Western Trail so you could skip the expansion all together but if you wanted to kind of like you know baby stepp it into it I think that's a great idea and I think after a while you probably will let that one slide off to the end but there's definitely a little bit less going on in that one so I can kind of see why if you jumped into one of these other two I don't know it might just be too much it's like what's all this stuff happening although we we'll we'll talk about more than a minute so that's my number three now number number two is New Zealand it's not my favorite my favorite is Argentina and I'll kind of explain why cuz right now I'm just going to talk about both New Zealand and Argentina because to me that's kind of the top ways but I will start out by saying I think there's more of a reason at least for me you know and and I I don't know I would kind of expect others to feel the same but you never know that there's more of a reason to keep New Zealand and Argentina in the same collection it feels really redundant to keep all three at a certain point but like I said you might baby step your way into it cuz again especially with New Zealand I think New Zealand's the most complicated of them has the most going on and if you just jumped right into New Zealand you might be like what's all this crap you know all these levers I'm pulling like what is all it's like so much mechanics so many different little you know resources that you're tracking you know all these different things you have keep keep track so might be a it might be a tough first outing for your first Great Western Trail game and that's going to depend on the person and how much they like a game for mechanics
and stuff like that um and that's kind of where this one sort of slightly I I don't want to say misses the mark but it doesn't achieve to me what Argentina does now Argentina adds a couple extra mechanics and it kind of seamlessly does it because you've got the whole um I can't pronounce the name the extra worker that you get in Argentina that you can kind of like boost the grain deliveries with and they can kind of like help you out along the way so instead of like running into obstacles you're like picking up helpers and so that's kind of a cool that's kind of a nice twist and then it makes the delivery part of it really cool and interesting which I thought at the time when I first played Argentina I was like okay this is like a fixed version of the first game's expansion where you really had some you know say in terms of like what you're delivering and you know kind of what what everything is about because the interesting most interesting part about all three of these games is you have this movement game cuz it's all movement about how fast you move and the pace that you're kind of cycling the board and you really feels like you're traveling back and forth on this Trail and you're like touching base with all these businesses and these different buildings and stuff that you're establishing in this whatever region the game is set in and then you're making these ultimate like deliverables these these payloads that you're trying to get out into the market so all of the actions are kind of in service to that
and it feels like you're you don't have your hand in like just one industry like it feels like a more holistic view of the larger economy in some kind of very abstract way about like okay I've got buildings and establishments that I'm putting in place and that's going to help me or maybe hinder other players and think like caus like a tax or a rent on them in in a in a kind of very abstract way and you've got your main sort of product that you're delivering but also on the back end of that in terms of like well what are my different markets that I'm delivering to you know what are the kind of the different expectations of of not just an abstract like oh my deliveries are getting bigger every turn which is what the first game kind of just does this one has some like working out it feels like you're kind of making deals and stuff like that and setting up contracts and so that is what really sort of pushed Argentina above and this has that same kind of thing where instead of the train deliveries and kind of the overseas grain shipment type of things where you you have to build up the grain to help feed the cows and stuff cuz they're going far away um this has that with this with the kind of combination of the shearing because you got the Dual use of the sheep and then also the little sea track thing and getting those kind of things out there and so both of those games really kind of like they're right there with each other and you can kind of pick or choose uh how you want to do that and so this has all that same stuff as Argentina but then it kind of adds a little bit more to it and so like with the shearing it's kind of akin to like you know getting those those helper workers in a way CU you're trying to get
it's a little different though cuz you're like shearing and getting money making these other deliveries whereas in Argentina it's like you've got the extra grain sort of on the side but to me it's more integrated and more balanced across all the different sort of strategies in Argentina where is this cuz you're like so depending for like go heavy shearing which is viable for sure but it's also like if well you know some if workers don't come out and you've got to like change your strategy and stuff like that and that's kind of part of the game anyway but it seems like a little bit like anchored on that side which is which is not a problem but then it goes and introduces this whole deck building card concept with the gold track and you've got that that bird track the Pathfinder track so you got to like maintain that a little bit so this this extra place to dump your money and then you have these deck building cards and so my one caveat what that is is I've played games of this where the deck building cards have been really cool and it like feels so different and I was like oh this is this is the best one this is out of the three because it's just got this extra layer and dimension and you can change this but then you got deck bling cards I'm like oh that's another bonus card or it's just another sheep like I don't even care about that and it's like we maybe you can opportunity buy certain things like okay I got some going you know I'll gold I'll put it in there it's worth the point any anyway and I can kind of get that but it's not interesting it's just boring but some of the other deck building ones the ones that like upgrade your buildings buy Cards on your dis on
your draw pile or um you know other ones that'll put out like your little houses in and the think you can put them out like three spaces away those kind of comboy types of things those are really fun and that that makes it a lot pretty interesting but then it's just like then they kind of like pile more on it so they have these bonus tiles that you can buy which are separate from the worker market and you know it's like uh I don't know it's very strange because sometimes it's almost like you have a dir of workers in general because if you have games where the uh the wild worker comes out then it's pretty okay because you're like H you know they bought up a bunch I can pay a little bit extra and get the wild worker and then use that where I want it but if those don't like come out and you kind of generally have a game where workers don't come out as much it's like more of the obstacle then it's like pretty tight so it's cool cuz it's different but it's also like ah this isn't what you know I was kind of trying to hope to try the strategy this game like that's not going to happen um and then if you don't have like cool deck building cards it's just like I know just all these moving parts and so it's all this negativity that I'm saying but I like I said I'm going to keep both of these the New Zealand one and the Argentina if you pinned me down you said what's the best one Argentina easy like it's easy call but this one is cool because it's like ah I don't know let me change it up see what happens you know because you just have like this such a random injection
of stuff at setup with the deck building cards and you know it's not really during setup but you kind of like no you're not going to be able to predict the worker situation and that kind of stuff how that's going to come out um and there's already enough kind of random variables with the different you know uh bonus tiles you can get at the shipping and how the different sheep cards come out and you know shuffling up the buildings and seeing what kind of actions are available you know so there's already like a good I think I think a a right amount of Randomness here but this is just like piling on top of of stuff and so be it's it's strange to compare these games because when you go to like review a game and it's like this game it exists I know what other games it's kind of like so I can kind of compare it but this is like this is being sold as like here's a set you know what I mean and it's hard to to like pick this apart because I would say if this one existed all by itself and the others never existed which is not the world we live in so you can't really make a comparison like that I don't really know like how you know how that would work like how how would I feel about it how would people feel about it cuz they would probably just be like this is a mess and you know and maybe they they it's hard to know that but I feel like a gut feeling and say that this would be a mess people would be like this game is cool and there's a lot of stuff going on but it's a mess but because we have the other Great Western Trails sort of in the Lexicon in the the
knowledge you know that you have of it then it's like okay this is Great Western Trail for Great Western Trail Fanatics right and I I am one of those I love Great Western Trail love the first game I think it was in my top 20 games and then Argentina kind of replaced it now that's in my top 20 and and so this is just like a crazy wacky variant for when I don't really want to play Argentina I don't know it's it's just more of the same but with just all kinds of just stuff thrown into the kitchen sink and I would say unless you really really really like the other two Great Western Trails I would not start with this one but I would try one of the other two and then if you're like okay I played that you know 20 times or whatever it is then I would say okay that now you take this step up and you know and I think you're going to have games of it that are like really fun and satisfying and like I said I was kind of debating I was like I think this is the best one because it just has all this stuff but then you have other times where it's like I don't think this thing knows what it wants to do it's like what it's so many different things I like okay why do I have to spend nuggets on this why can't I just spend money to buy these cards cuz then I could in why can't we have more cards why can't we have more like funky cards that are like gamebreaking you know what I mean and maybe that's part of my problem is like when I play a card game I'm like oh I want the card that is just like the Master Card everybody wants
that card and I want every card to feel like that but maybe that's not possible and I can also see I I know I said why don't you just buy those with money but it's like you got enough other stuff to spend money on in the game because you got to build buildings buy workers buy the bonus tiles spend money to get rid of the obstacle tiles you know put money to get your disc out and you're so you're already spending money you can't just have more stuff to spend money on CU then nobody would ever buy those cuz he wouldn't have any money and then you'd have to inject a whole bunch of money in the game and then that would break something because then everybody would have too much money for the other things so that's the whole thing it wouldn't work so you need an extra resource there so it kind of makes sense but it's just like man I wish yeah and so it's like like a little module so I wonder if you could play this without the gold track and the extra cards and it would probably be fine I mean let's see I I don't think I've ever played a game where I did not buy any of those cards but I've played games where I bought more of those like a lot of them and then um in the games where I bought like almost none so again and the the feel of it is just going to be very elusive so that's why it's a little bit a little bit of caution coming out of here so anyway that's kind of my general sort of vibe of Argentina is the most solid like I think just top to bottom that game just all sort of flows makes sense and you can still play it different ways um but there's not a whole lot of like just what oh I forgot about this system over here you know um it's just not overload and then this one is kind of like if you like race Western
Trail and you have played it to death I can emphasize that I think that's important then this is what you get to kind of just go let's go to outer space with it right and then I've already talked about you know the base game so that's where this sits I think you know for now this is one that's going to stay in the collection um but if you pinned me down and said oh Jo I want to try one of these Grand Western Trail games get get Argentina then you'll be fine no big deal okay so that's great was Trail New Zealand really enjoy it but I'm comparing it to something I think is transcendent in Argentina so tough tough act to follow there guy okay thanks