Skip to main content
Loading video...

First Impressions of Kemet: Blood & Sand - Off The Table Aug 2, 2021

Transcript 1:07:00

okay cool and i think we're all good there hello and welcome back to another episode of the cardboard heralds off the table a weekly podcast recording i am your host jack and i am joined by my co-host john and we have things to talk about today but john you have some hypesicles some little nuggets of hype that you wanted to get to before we got into the main topic of commet the new blood and sand that is out that is going to be really our our main focus today what you got on the hype train uh little little kernels of hype interjection okay well here is a prop game today first of all love them or hate them i did get my copy of aries in family probably after target did i'm sure i wouldn't know don't have a target uh but i am pretty stoked about this it's still a pretty slick production you know whatever i don't have that much bad blood fur for the whole fiasco it wasn't the world's biggest fiasco so i'm still excited it's shiny the box is shiny i love it when they do can't see it can't see it but the really glossy uh cover art over top of the map finish like when they do that it's fancy yeah i'm really looking forward to playing aries expedition as well i mean terraforming mars is one of my absolute favorite games like it is up there absolutely in the top three i'm not really sure where it resides in that i mean any given day can switch that around but having a consolidated version of that

game with a slightly different focus is just a dream to me i i i don't know wh where are you at with terraforming mars i love terraformers i think it's great i think it's a good mix between heavily thematic and uh tight tightly mechanical but with uh enough unpredictability maybe it's not as dry as maybe some of the really heavily analytical euro games economic games it's got a little bit more you know fickle nature because of the card draw but you know uh that's why i love it is i think it's got a little more a little more flair uh just on a brief note since this is the we're doing a first impressions this is my first first impression it's a very tightly packed uh little box here uh i wasn't really a big fan of one of their decisions about the inserts uh the little dividers but overall this is where everything fits there's no dead weight no dead space they left me in the front of the sleeve things i i love them for it it's really put the little little instruction in and look at that such a tight package this feels like it's a good this is a good ambassador if people go to target they buy this and they're like oh this is what a board game is it's not like seven dollars worth of monopoly i would feel good about that i'll leave it at that a lot of good content in the box i haven't gotten my copy yet but we definitely will be doing a bunch of coverage of that game to come i mean it's it's just it's inevitable so next up on the hype roster tell me about your magic the gathering love you needed to do some gushing well okay but i kind of feel like we should do a hype sandwich where i put the not as good of hype in the middle kind of like a reverse oreo where the middle part isn't the best

part well i actually think that in oreos the outside is the best part i could do without the filling that's why you bring me here to tell you when you're wrong jack you're wrong it's the filling we'll have that fight later though i'm representing the cookie lovers i've got nothing to hold up this time uh but i do want to say that you and i had a conversation i just want to hype a little about dissent not third edition whatever um and i'll be honest you know i caught tom vassell's early review of it he gave it kind of a mech which for a guy who seems to rate really highly all those heavily thematic american style games you know that's that's saying something you know especially since his criticisms were more directed not at the gameplay i mean he said the gameplay he had some things he liked but the gameplay was good just that it didn't feel like he hit the price point and maybe that there were better choices out there for denture calls it could put a damper on my excitement i you know i'm still cautiously optimistic i still maybe yeah i'm hyped about it i don't know i love descent second edition i i i'm still really excited and we're getting very close to uh pre-order delivery time so descent is one of those games that had a profound impact on so many gamers out there so it's a sensitive topic anytime that you do some drastic changes to it and they definitely swung for something different in this one instead of the first edition and then the second edition

which were one versus all games and of course there was the app driven cooperative game that you could do later on but this is from the get-go it's app-driven and also it has an art style that is completely out there compared to the rest of the ffg house style and yeah one of the the big concerns about the game is that the the msrp is 175 dollars that is a big big price point and when you when you compare that to say gloomhaven one of the most beloved games that are out there in the same genre that is also a fully cooperative game that you can get an app that does a lot of the management for you you can get a ton of content in that gloomhaven box and a lot of the concerns were are you getting less content for a higher price point with dissent and old uh old vassal actually kind of called it a uh an 80 video game that wasn't his you know he would be 80 bucks for a normal video which which is true i mean it was like if i had to pay 80 bucks for a video game that's it better be a really good game he called it an 80 video game with an 80 board game attached to it kind of more or less i'm paraphrasing there but it was basically it i was like you know i can see that if that's how it feels i could see that as a crew system i also kind of see this is one of those things that a lot of people have left fantasy flight a lot of old names um you know who were around when the earlier descent editions published and it almost feels like one of those tv show moments where your favorite show changed up writers

the show runners changed is it to be the same thing i love or is it is it just in name only is it descent in name and honestly i want to give it a chance so i'm still hyped for it you know well the good news is is that the only other major reviewer that i've seen some coverage on this uh come out yet is no pun included discussed on their podcast and they they're kind of more in the shut up and sit down vein of preference when it comes to games they don't always agree but you know they're one of the other major european reviewers that kind of have those same tastes and they seem to have a much more glowing opinion of this which i was frankly surprised uh but i i'm i'm excited to see what happens when it gets to the table and when it does get to the table inevitably we will be doing something like this for it i'll talk more about why we're doing a focused episode on commet uh once we get there it doesn't seem to focus right now yeah exactly but you can't you can't keep getting nerd enthusiasm down though so let me just say this that the cardboard harold tune in because it will be the definitive place for your answer of do you need third edition if you have second i will i will happily answer that question for you as someone who has a lot of discipline yeah who has all of one and we'll soon have the other we'll be seeing whether both of them stick around or not and whether you should be as crazy as that okay then what's the other end of the cookie on the hype sandwich here

okay the other part the the backwards oreo here is i just this this deserves visuals jack do you know what this is i do this this is a beholder it has one eye and then a lot of eyes it's a classic dragon dice character oh of course yeah um jack jack do you recognize this except yes the deck master backing to magic the gathering classic bit of iconography there yeah yeah yeah nobody still knows to this day they stuck with it they made their bed and now they have to sleep with it 30 years later so uh so then so the what is that jack why why is it well it's really grainy and fuzzy but why is there a beholder on my magic card you've got because chocolate or something yeah because you couldn't resist having your toys cross over and wizards of the coast owns both and now there's a dungeons and dragons magical gathering set and you're all about it i can tell you're like a 10 year old right now i haven't played magic in forever and a day i haven't seriously paid attention to it in about 10 years or so uh oh also what is this is this classic looking like old cellar is that a mimic that's a mimic okay okay anything on the chub toad that's all i'm saying uh well yeah but i assume like d and d can have codes in it too i'm actually really hyped about this they've done it was inevitable they've done dnd crossovers they got a couple of supplements for magic stuff the reality is magic settings were okay you know but i always do homebrew

stories of my own and i'm always out to tell my own story so i'm not usually using the the settings as thoroughly in d so i'm not that excited to have magic settings in d as much on the other hand i really am passionate about various other hobbies and it's really cool it's almost like the hall of fame hollywood walk of fame kind of thing to see them get their own star as a magic card and i'm gonna zoom in a little on this one this is a lamb oh yeah is it a classic d d module absolutely i couldn't tell because it's so blurry but you know what we'll pretend this is good for the podcast listeners who don't have any visuals whatsoever they can imagine a beautifully rendered image picture a picture of bald man frantically waving a really grainy magic card for the camera while jack just looks on goes get the comment yet so i'm really excited i bought just you know a handful of cards i do i am going to admit i'm going to turn into some board game room art right mount them on the wall but in the meantime i'm going to dabble a little bit we're going to open packs and draft cards for uh knight of magic and dnd so it's a great reason to get back into magic just to you know relive some of those moments from you know your childhood or even adulthood and playing magic but also you have the excuse of seeing the novelty of dungeons and dragons being there do i want there to be like a monopoly esque world of where magic has a do we need a rick and morty magic set definitely not definitely not venture brothers yes yeah right i was just about the

adventure brothers magic okay yes yes maybe but does marvel need to be in there i no marvel can have its own game thank you uh but tell me that you and i in the cardboard hill will not be jamming down with the lord of the rings later on which is the next one of the next big themed non-magic world sets they're doing yeah it is really exciting there is a part of me that does have that bitter skepticism towards like licensing out different uh properties in order to skin your thing as like a cash in and that's a whole nother discussion that i i want to have as an eventual topic that we focus on here yeah exactly you know just going for nostalgia you know you and i are prey for the the harsh realities of the capitalistic nostalgia train and i'm always a little bit leery that they're going to take something great and just make something mediocre out of it and then it's going to feel just terrible but licensed games are a whole topic in and of themselves that that is all over the place but one of them i don't want magic to be that i don't want them to start being like man people really seem to like people jam their favorite xyz rick and morty was a great one of like do we take the pop culture hotness today and just go you know what there let's insert that sucker right into a magic set you know and uh and then like i said it becomes a monopoly of like oh we've got an additional no i don't want that and that would be like deck building games

which are the soulless cash grab of the licensing world another conversation but i'm still excited for this right and the world works cohesively like it's an expansive world where you can draw on a lot and you can draw parallels between the existing magic lore and structure with what's already in d the bestiary the world the planeswalker elements and the same thing could be said for middle earth like you have a reason why you could trade in these different environments the plane's walkers travel there jace is getting his like total edge lord thing on in middle earth it just depends on whether it becomes cannon or not or you know because we are talking about the same company that brought us minotaur wearing uh fantastic looking jeans yeah well yeah that that's uh one of my favorite uh pairs like another glued scent like it's not cannon then maybe you can get you know get around it so it needs the silver borders oh i should also say that i do have your uh i'm waving about for the podcast here weaving a big bag of heavy metal things that are not individually wrapped uh i got my cubes too so i got your cubes yeah yeah terraforming mars uh they managed to dodge the fiasco that was in the terraforming mars big box where they individually wrapped every single metal cube in its own little ziploc bag and at least that quality control error was fixed for aries or i guess maybe that that's an unintended bonus that now you don't have

sleeve cubes so maybe you should complain on the internet about it right these cubes are going to wear out faster because they're not individually sleeve yep oh yeah well we have a big box topic to talk about right over your shoulder is comment blood and sand i'm wearing my yellow hoodie because i wanted to represent the sand here actually that's just coincidental but i love this yellow hoodie comment is a game that was a a big influence on both of us as gamers uh it's a game that we played a lot uh and we kind of have separate standing on um our opinions on comment today i think we're both you know reverent of it uh but it's left my collection whereas it has stayed in your collection and you have another copy now doubled in my collection actually yeah one could say it is breeding more comments if i leave them alone in a room i'll have commit third edition before we know it well in order to supplement this i'm going to uh try and share my screen so we can get to some links here and hope that the live stream doesn't fall entirely apart if it does let us know in chat uh gracia from uh midnight board games is really upset about not having the uh the the delivery there so um want to call that out i i feel for you because you know my own experience with that one and uh i don't want to rag on anybody too hard but first just to fun again games it seems like every kickstarter that they are the distributor for or the the fulfillment center for is

always a fiasco in terms of who gets what i got mike matt after having to email matago uh and and prompt them and follow up with customer service because they insisted that 100 of american backers had already been shipped out or whatever as i'm sitting there with no tracking numbers three weeks after that announcement so i feel for you and uh hopefully you'll get more soon that's the hope okay so i i want to start this out with a little bit of history on commet so uh like uh commet is a game that uh came out in 2012 and at least for me it has the unique place of being the first game that i remember seeing the release schedule of it there was an anticipation for the game on the horizon watching reviews and knowing that there was this game that was in a way a spiritual successor or a spiritual sequel to sick ladies a game that you and i both liked uh do you remember anything about like the the preparation for getting commit not really i think honestly i i want to say that it came out of my radar after it already released but not long after right i i think the shut up sit down uh review was one of the first times in which i had watched a review for like a brand new game and it was really exciting and you know the the way that where they were describing it is so visceral

uh and then uh it's the gamers game yes i remember that review too that was exactly what they said the first time that i remember hearing uh the phrase a knife fight in a phone booth used in a board game review and i feel like it has been used in a lot of board game reviews since then a lot of words like that uh you know like or phrases like that come up time and time again in uh reviews uh dripping with theme that's a common one there so uh then we have some expansions this game out to seti came out in 2015 i was big on to seti it had the black pyramids and then it had a bunch of stuff that i didn't care about and does anybody even remember what else it had like it was black pyramids and i call it old guys walking in the desert right well actually i like to think of that as just stuff to make the box rattle when you shake it like honestly it was the black pyramid expansion it wasn't tossed that it was the black pyramid expansion and some other stuff to make the box and then until i was doing some research for this uh review i had totally forgotten about seth like even coming out that i did not get it as an expansion so i really had no context for what was going on with this one did you actually pick it up you were by this time still the die hard comment fan i was in more pyramids is always cool like i really wanted more black pyramid type stuff more things and and it's great that we had the expansion discussion before this because we called

out the black pyramid expansion toscetti as being great and terrible because it had both an easily always integratable thing the black pyramid you always want to play with those um if you're playing with anybody even even first time honestly most of the time but then it had that sin of well it's got garbage in there too it just adds mini games you don't really want to think about it it's not the greatest whatever looking at the images here for seth you got some real cool minis in there like a crocodilian got a crocodile monster in there you can get your your uh your your gator thing on uh what was the main focus of seth as an expansion seth was one that i actually haven't gotten to the table and it's a shame because they haven't reproduced it in the new edition maybe they will but honestly i'm not sure if it fits i don't know so the idea was it's a one versus mini it turns the chaotic free-for-all knife fighting in a phone booth to uh group shanking in a public bathroom i don't know where i love it is that a thing that happens i don't know only in the best bathrooms right i guess i need to not go to public bathrooms if that's what i think is going on so but that's what it was is one person would take on the role of the the purple faction who would have their own independent set of abilities but would then interact with the others uh the others would also the

other the other players would then work together to defeat you which i've always kind of admired the idea of a cooperative game in which you are facing like this world-ending threat you know i think game of thrones where you have you know the white walkers and the others that are coming down from the north and one person actually controls that invasion that sounds really cool on paper uh i haven't seen it implemented particularly well in very many games although i can think of one or two that did some interesting things uh but that was the idea and it and it had some really cool pieces parts it had some neat looking powers unfortunately by the time you know i got it and it sat on the shelf and kind of laying uh languished there and has not made it off the table and i don't know that it will i i'd like to try maybe before i move on and just hang on the second edition but we'll see if that's in the cards well let's talk about second edition so 2020 we have the kickstarter for blood and sand which was intended to be like this revitalization of comet and it was going to have some expansion material but not the bad expansion material and then it was going to have a visual overhaul and rebalancing and all this kind of stuff um were you on board right away like i i don't really know where you say it as far as like re-releases of existing games there are certainly a lot of gamers out there who are like unless it does enough new i don't care i am kind of i would lean 60 40 as being easy prey sixty percent

twenty percent distinguishing and very discerning uh consumer but sixty percent easy prey if it was a game i'm really hot for i immediately i think of the possibilities and to me i immediately go well it's comment but more better newer faster stronger death funky um i imagine it was the same well maybe not but uh somewhat in the same vein as maybe how you felt about like the eclipse reimagining and maybe that's the whole topic is you know where do you land on new editions and what should they do what shouldn't they but yeah i i as far as as far as where i'm at with this is that if a game is a game that i love and there's a new better and more polished version not just from like a visual aesthetic point of view but also from like refining the rules just enough in order to make it a more sustainable game or modernizing it just a little bit then i want the best version of my favorite games i prefer having a few games that i love to having an immense collection of hundreds upon hundreds of games and in that regard if there is something out there that's going to be the the revitalization of an older game that i love of course i'm going to go after it so long as i don't ruin it along the way i mean the assumption is that it's got to be a better value prospect too than just paying all over again for the same board game and so yeah i mean i did look at it

to see is you know are they making any rules changes i mean because i am definitely keen to see if there's rules updates and you know polish on the rules not just maybe making it a new game entirely but but polishing the existing rules that you love and seeing it kind of bring it forward into the the next generation of board games that is a huge thing um and then of course the component upgrades you know that's nice but but honestly i could pass on component upgrades if there weren't any rules polishing going on or or maybe new material and like with this edition for example um it didn't tread on on a lot of new ground i mean it really it what it is it took the old game and it reimplemented it with some polish on it hopefully in theory that we'll get to that um but then it also added the the black pyramids from the toss eddie expansion didn't touch really the seth expansion at all didn't touch the extra material from hassetti kind of recognized which way the wind was blowing and did away with that um and then it did take on an expansion that did not exist which was the green pyramids the book of death uh on to this one so there was new content plus polish to the old garnet plus board game pomona so that made it kind of an easy buy especially when you told me there were green pyramids and there's like another whole other color of pyramids yes that sounds like more of what i want and if we're discussing this from a historical preservationist point of view to to no to what happened along the way there was a minor controversy right during the kickstarter where initially

they were like this is going to be the lovecraftian expansion and then a bunch of people were like oh you can't mix lovecraftian stuff with the egyptian stuff those themes are entirely incompatible and then they were like okay we'll make it the book of death expansion but we'll also make the cthulhu figures available i i i in talking with you as a dedicated like you are one of the biggest lovecraft super fans i know you are way into cosmic horror you've read tons of lovecraft and you are the person who really introduced me to a lot of other things in the vein of lovecraft when it comes to cosmic horror fiction and other games and that kind of stuff and you had one of the best takes that i can imagine on what the the overlap truly is there oh i thought you were gonna tell me because i love listening to the things that i said repeated back to me it's very gratifying um i mean the sound of my own voice is nice too but it's just so much better hearing other people um no it's kind of almost like having a mini cult of my own speaking of lovecraft but no you're okay i don't know if i'd call myself a love pass super fan i mean i'm i'm a fan of lovecraft as a genre and i appreciate it kind of in the way that sometimes you'll talk about when you talk about reading like mary shelley or um i think you're probably going to go do a read of like uh 20 000 leagues under the sea maybe

totally yeah yeah so i kind of appreciate it in that same vein as like it's got some merits to it there's definitely a lot of problematic pieces to love of course of course but but really um thinking of him as kind of a iconic four genre i really do like that genre of like what if the evil that we're facing what if what if god exists but he's not necessarily inclined to be so friendly and the only reason we all survive is because he doesn't know that we're here we're too insignificant and heaven forbid we ever actually you know he takes notice of us or whatever right so it's that concept of like wow evil is it meant to be defeated it can only be delayed and avoided um and that's that's really cool so the thing about lovecraft is um of course it was all this ancient and unknowable evil and it's been around since time immemorial and very much who built the pyramids well you know it's probably probably aliens or cthulhu monster type stuff so really the two pieces of crafty and lord that they interject or they injected into this didn't they were not anachronistic to the setting this is a mythological egyptian setting and this was just saying well lovecraft wrote his mythos and and all the other authors that participated in that a lot of that mythos existed with ancient egypt as one of the civilizations in mind among among many um so it worked in that setting you know if you're if you want to inject lovecraft it works i like that they said okay well we'll we'll make it more we'll stick to the egyptian only mythology

but it's the same powers we were going to do except that we'll give you the tiles with the egyptian gods on them and if you want to buy for like i don't know it was really cheap it was like seven or ten dollars i think you can get you can get the two minis that we were gonna use plus the two power tiles with their art on them no difference in terms of balance or play it just kind of like what theme do you want to apply to it i kind of like that i i just love the sort of gatekeeping that is involved in you know anytime we have a nerdy property again this is the intimacy that people have with the things that they love but sometimes they take it overboard where they can't accept any sort of change or any sort of mix-up and the idea that like how dare you cash in on lovecraft as a an ip that's totally available in you know the public domain and therefore you're going to wedge it into this game ancient unknowable evil is one of the themes of almost any sort of western fiction that uses egypt as a setting right and the idea that there are these these gods or mystic powers that may or may not care about the mortals that they are manipulating for their own ends is one of the most common tropes of this this pantheon as used in popular fiction now so to me it's chocolate and peanut butter i'm glad i got midnight board gaming uh agreed that the mythos faction or uh cthulhu edition was a good choice uh so so i'm not alone there were yes but i i do understand because

lovecraft is public domain good that you mentioned that so it's it's kind of ubiquitous in board gaming as a theme because anybody can do pirates anybody's new vikings you know but you got to get a license to star wars and marvel and all the all the big ips uh but lovecraft is actually kind of a big ip in and of itself or you know and he's not alone it's it's many many authors who wrote in that sort of shared mythos and um and so yeah i could see how people are like man stop jamming lovecraft and everything i think kind of like what i said about magic let's not let's not make a set for you know we don't need star wars magic but i think this was not that and it was a good fit it's a shame some people were like cthulhu in my stuff those people probably haven't actually read any of the any of the material though and it's it's funny you'd bring it up because some of our favorite stuff you know i just finished playing mass effect again uh and heavily lovecraft inspired they're literal space cthulhu machines coming from the sky space shawgus coming in i mean i guess that's where cthulhu is from so safe space is unnecessary so robot cthulu uh uh what what what's the term they use synthetic cthulhu yup exactly it's a synthetic so let's talk about blood and sand uh just uh for a little bit of perspective on where we're coming from uh this is definitely a first impressions i have only played it once i played it once with you and it was only two players but the reason why i think that is

a worthy perspective to have is that uh there are more people playing two-player games than ever nowadays and comet is one of the war games one of the dudes on a map area control games that people would talk about as it's pretty good at two players maybe not perfect maybe it's not as dynamic as higher player accounts but it's one of those ones that accounts for two players maybe better than other games and there are some unique things that this new version does even for that how many times have you gotten it to the table at this point um three total now nice and player accounts uh two three and three excellent so we are are now coming in with my first and only impressions and you actually have several plays and three plays um it's still early to make a committed opinion but i will say that like you know since this is familiar territory too i mean we've and it's actually funny that we played this at lower counts when our past plays of the first edition was at four and five traditionally those were games we oftentimes we would dedicate evenings with our gaming group where you know this is our once a month to play a heavier longer game well combat might be a choice for that and that was usually four or five people so one of my first questions for you is like when you got it to the table did it feel like the same game did you feel like you were playing comment or did

this feel like this was a distinct new thing uh yeah it's it's it's command i mean there's almost no when you talk about like a rules changing you think about um i don't i don't know if you would want to call it like uh if you could really describe a mechanic as being cosmetic it almost felt like the changes were cosmetic in nature very surface level not core i don't know how else to describe it they were substantial in that they didn't matter they did change the way the game played but the actual mechanics of how you're engaging with the game didn't change it was like do you get do you start the game with more power do you start the game with whatever you know that kind of stuff more like setup changes in some respects than really gameplay changes um so yeah totally the same game yeah i and i think one of the greatest things about comment as a game and the reason why we're so eager uh to get it to the table and also talk about it is that it is to me it represents like the crowning achievement of the old school style of heavy conflict direct area control i win by killing your dudes the game incentivizes you going forth and killing folks you know the people that you're fighting against your friends you want to murder them and murder them dead or at least a little player pieces that are on the board and a lot of the hobby since commet has looked for ways to circumvent that experience you know you have like now iconic games like

blood rage which is like if we want to battle if you want to hop in here then sure we can battle but really my objective is the thing on the board and i'm going for as many points from different areas as you can go you have games like root where yes it is lots of conflict that's involved but every single faction in that game the way you win is not points driven by the combat itself it's that the combat is your way of uh instigating uh the the struggle for the different things that your particular faction needs in order to win the game comment is old school area control war game at its finest well and it's interesting you would say that too because it's it's when i got it um it to me actually distilled one element of old school war gaming or or area control gaming had that heavy conflict area control uh the taking of other people's stuff because yes fully half the points you end up with in that game if you're gonna win are usually going to be centered on the points you get from combat that's just a fact that's where at least half your point count typically comes from there are other points and yes you do need to pursue them to win uh but you're starting fights and winning them if you're gonna if you're gonna win that game although um what made it different though is that there was less of an emphasis on

holding specific territory it was kind of king of the hillish you wanted to hold the temples but there wasn't this idea that like say like a risk or an access analogy you didn't have to capture large areas of board it was more of like i'm gonna put myself out there to get this point by holding these temples but also i know that that's going to provoke a fight and really it's about provoking that fight and seeing if i can hang on to something and then rather than capturing territory um but also that it it took the idea of like okay we're going to eliminate turtling as a defensive tactic you can't win the game if you're not attacking and travel in that game is all about teleporting from your home base directly to the action and there's no way to teleport back it's a one-way trip to the fight so everything about that game leads into start fights that you can win start fights opportunistically um and only grab territory where it's something that you think you can actually hold on to for the very short term so as the the big comments uh die hard here what are the biggest changes about this new edition like when you were rattling off like the top things that make an impact either for the better or for the worst but are monumental in how they shift the original commit what are they to you i think the little tweaks maybe i wouldn't call it cosmetic what maybe we call little quality of life tweaks um that maybe keep things from wobbling off its axis those are pretty nice um you've got a couple i'll call out just a couple

offhand because there really aren't that many but the ones they feel they feel meaningful they're the kind of things that you might house rule in a game if you had the wherewithal to spot the like this would make it work better um set up starting the game with fewer powers on the table if there are fewer players i love that all the way down to the two player account where it's like you only have two colors of pyramid so it's a much tighter selection and you remove powers from those colors so that you're down to at something it was like uh i'm gonna miss count this but it was like 26 powers available instead of what would otherwise be 32 or actually i mean if you played under old commit you would actually be looking at three full colors 48 powers available in a two-player game there's no one of the things that makes command interesting is that there's always this gold rush for powers well if you grab this one it's no longer available so i'm gonna grab this one and kind of counter that and you're gonna grab this to counter that it's all about adapting and trying to stay ahead of your opponent warfare technology wise right well how does that work if there's 48 powers there's always something to grab distill that down to 26 in a two-player game that works much better and if they continue that through the higher player counts by saying okay even at three players you're still only going to play with three colors and once you get up to the higher player count then you'll actually and it might not even be the same three you might do uh black white and blue red blue and black you know whatever um you can do it randomly i suppose you could pick if you wanted but it's intended to be randomized or whatever um but then including all four at the

highest player account you know for the full big sweeping experience that was really nice the early game setup of kind of kicking the action off a little faster by everybody starting with the power from their their one of their chosen colors of pyramid that was really nice because i felt like it just kind of got it got you rolling a little bit faster it feels like it makes the game more aggressive both the the starting with the power allows you to feel a little bit more empowered going in and the the the reduction of available powers means that everything that you do is directly denying someone else a possibility and even at lower player accounts you don't have this wide open space where you can get a little bit of everything like it brings it down to the level of what is a necessity every single action is so important to me every single power that i get is not only important to me and what it does against my opponent it's also important in what it denies my opponent from doing to me um it amps up the tension in the lower player account games in such a significant way and it adds a ton of replayability i mean if you are playing a game now at two players a blue and white game is going to feel way different than a black and red game or a red and white game that's going to create more interesting combinations and more dynamic strategies this like adaptive power set that is so great in

games like comment and what you called out earlier eclipse you know those are the the things that really make the game so satisfying beyond just you know beating up on your friends is the feeling that you are cultivating your powers in direct opposition to what other people could be doing to you well and and that's that's something interesting because i've often i've referred to command as one of my favorite asymmetric games but it's not a symmetry like what you expect from uh say root which is asymmetric out of out of the gate it is asymmetric uh what i would maybe call progressively asymmetric where you start out the same and you actually there's no way to build in the same way you progressively move forward in different directions um and yeah that was the best part so starting out with the power for example on the table it's such a minor thing you know it's one power point one energy point worth of stuff but it means that instead of spending the first couple of turns just buying powers kind of getting set up you know maybe your first couple of your actual first five action turn round uh might have some some real combat in it because you've got that first power to kind of get you rolling so i i do think it it's sort of just cut to the chase a little faster um little things like uh taking taking tweaking the uh the retreating mechanics so that instead of getting back all of the power from the guys that you sacrifice you get the number of guys minus one you know just little little tweaks to make it so that the obvious choice maybe is a tactical decision instead of an always doing the

same thing kind of thing so those are a couple of things i'd call it the quality of life changes i think we're good very minor but but very meaningful um uh i'd say the other change that i liked from this game was the um was the cosmetic aspects of it too they did a really good job we'll just say and i know we were talking rules but i'll just say the other thing this this really improves on in a lot of ways is the components i mean that your scorpion is like 30 bigger yeah i'm not going to argue with that the pyramids the pyramids they're so cool little plastic pyramids a little little awesome obvious thing she built the luxor out there you know um and the uh the new figures are all really good quality it's all the same stuff the the little army guys themselves your units those are really cool because those were always one of the things i thought in the days when i used to play risk and it was like i have a blue cannon and a blue guy and a horse and a blue soldier and you have the same thing in red um well one of the coolest parts about comet which was a game i bought probably in 2013 or so not long after it came out that was still relatively early in my gaming you know uh renaissance and so to me the fact that every faction had its own sculpt was really cool but they were so tiny you couldn't see them that well these are much bigger and you could if they really pop it's really cool that your guys your affection is anubis and your little doghead soldiers walking around with the swords are way different looking than the green

faction of the yellow faction so i really like that they made everything that was cool about it that much more visible by kind of sizing it up just a little bit yeah i think the artistry on so much of it is really great and it has a visual identity that's unlike most of the games out there right now like the gods look really cool the player board's really nice um there is a drawback to this little bonus but even the the back of the board that you play on is this like lavish illustration that is so cool looking and so like if you're talking about you know immersion and you know having this really luxurious and uh fully produced game it's outstanding uh the go ahead well i was just gonna say you know if i had to call it something thematically it really does feel like like a clash of the titans in egypt like it is if you've ever seen the old school or maybe i guess but you ever seen clash of the titans this idea of like god's meddling in the affairs of mortals it really feels like man there's some shit's going down in in egypt right right uh some of the other highlights to me i mean we already mentioned the the lower player account scaling i i think the repackaging of the best elements of at least tessetti the one expansion that i played and really enjoyed part of and didn't

care for at all uh part of um bringing in more powers that are of the to seti ilk you know having another color a pyramid that you can play with so you know you're you're playing around with the power sets that are going to be available and then the balance changes like there were some powers i noticed that were different colors in the original version they were like actually that belongs more in a blue group in order to make sure that these are are independent enough i think i only spotted one off the top of my head which was was this this neck mr snack uh he moved he migrated over to white from blue maybe to balance out the number of figures but you did call that out yeah i guess i should mention that you know the changes to powers you you the old favorites are all there you know a lot of the things that made it iconic the scorpion is still awesome the the elephant is still really cool you know a lot of those powers still do exactly what they did in the base game but then there are definitely some where they took what was easily abusable about it or maybe um was was maybe something that only people who would play the game before would know that kind of combined and they retooled some of that stuff so it they they all at least the ones we touched they all felt good they all felt like they worked and they were good improvements nothing was lost i'm like oh man i can't believe we took this out um i think the the last little thing that i want to give a shout out on here is because of convenience uh there's not much in the way of insert

for it but the power trays the trays that you can just select here's blue and it's going to be on the tail table and it's in this beautiful custom tray that's very modern and very welcome uh anything that's going to make it easier to organize your stuff and especially set it on the table and get to playing the game sooner i'm an old man at this point i want things to be easy yeah i'll just say that the um the the insert itself i got rid of it but it was still a nice attempt i mean the thing is is the kickstarter invariably comes with a few little extras um you know there's plastic monolith tokens that the monoliths are printed on the board you don't need to the the figures or the monolith plastic minis um they take a broom in the box that maybe there wasn't a lot of extra room to put them in there so i think that was kind of a well you bought the extra kickstarter stuff the insert maybe wasn't made to service all of that material like where am i going to jam catholic but if you brought this off the shelf uh without some of those extras i think the inserts do a really good job um more or less and the um uh yeah the the multi-layer boards for the for the power tracking or tracking the the energy levels and the storage solution for the powers themselves were two really welcome changes to just the cosmetic nature of the game i just want to mention though when talking about new stuff the green pyramids are not exactly like the black they are a separate expansion that you don't integrate though when you're randomizing which colors to use you do

not include those inherently they are a i think scoundrels of skullport lords of water deep type thing they introduce a faction of powers that have a corruption mechanic so if you're looking for something that is like the base game but has maybe just a little extra element of something it's you're not going to relearn the game i think i haven't played with it yet but i think it'll be easy to integrate um and it doesn't feel like too much of a minigame because it really ties back to the powers themselves so it's more of an incentivizer or disincentivizer for these things so i'm interested to see how plays but i think i'm optimist i i like that idea that there's the more of the same pyramid which is the black pyramid and then there's also this is shifting the game a little bit you know the this adjusts the structure just enough to be its own thing and also green is the coolest color to have as far as ancient evil i mean it's got to be green well i mean did you know jack that you know the pyramids have worn away a lot of their outer layer but they used to be green okay true fact there's there's no need to google that so uh the the last change that really comes to mind as something that's a minor tweak which again so much of this game the the best parts of it and we'll get to some of the worst parts of this uh but the best parts seem to be like little minor revisions that breathe a lot of life into the game uh one of the initial cards that you start with has uh it's like a overwhelming

attack a bloodthirsty card but it comes at the expense of sacrificing some of your own units uh and that wasn't in the original commit as i remembered it uh and because of the card selection mechanic when you're going into combat uh is so important uh it um it changes the ecosystem on the the very narrow set of cards that you have available to you um the i you know and my memory is failing me on this one but i want to say that the power card that you're referring to was present in the black pyramids maybe i think it was a later edition um so and if that's the case and that's what my memory is telling me but if that's the case either way it's a welcome addition it's just a core piece of the game because i do think it's an important it is a very welcome addition to the game so what isn't a welcome addition i mean this wasn't an all uh knock it out of the park beautiful expansion or expansion a re-release or revision to this game there's so look if if i'm gonna rate this i'm still gonna say it's it's if you like the original if you never played the original but you liked the way it sounded you know if you if you watched a review of 1.0 and thought well it's not available should i get 2.0 absolutely right it's a great game and anything i'm about to say you can forgive it more or less um i'd still give it an eight or nine you know in my

my book in this genre of games now that said it may it commits a few of those sins that you and i like to rant on about a little bit as gamers who are just like man how have they not figured this out yet first of all matagot is a french are largely french designed and french language games at least is where they start and get translated and usually i mean they'll have they'll have i remember the original command had like five different booklets for translations oh hey actually quick call out the five booklets they gave you this time were all of the language of whatever edition you got but everybody got a menu for powers instead of just having one menu to pass around it that was a fantastic and welcome addition thank you for giving me five copies of the power guide book instead of making me be like hey can i uh can i see that when you're done with it gone are the days where you had to waste your toner uh in order to print out your own copies of things that should have been in the box but speaking of things that were printed though getting back to the language issue is at this day in this day and age honestly when i can google translate many things not perfectly but pretty well i really expect the translation efforts on board games to be more thorough and i feel like this one mostly was but they did feel like there may have been one or two little spots and i like my board game language precise because i don't like the ambiguity of house rule i want to know what was the intent and how this was designed to play i i seek to engage with the game on its

own merits not help get it to the finish plate or finish line on on design so when i read a rule and it's ambiguous i'm like why wasn't this better worded and one of the ones that comes to mind and i can't and maybe i'm blaming translation unfairly but it feels like maybe it's it's missing something in translation possibly the end game mechanic is a little ambiguous and there was a little bit of day one errata that i'm i you know was a little bit like come on i mean i just don't know maybe i'm underselling how hard it is to get a really finely cute rulebook but i do feel like that could have been just a little small area um speaking of the card you mentioned the the big five pointer that kills you guys the iconography is largely consistent across the whole game except in like two small areas the uh when you have to sacrifice your pieces to that card it uses the iconography iconography in a way that basically no other piece does without any clarifier in the back of the book um i'm gonna call back to jack's rant on one of his videos that i re-watched recently dear designers put a glossary well this one had a glossary please also put clarifiers for your cards if you're not going to have printed text on them right if you're going to have symbology you should have like a clear definition of what every symbol is going to mean and then you know if you do things like pluses and minuses or something like that then that as well should be clear what that's intending if you have one

card and it's the only card in the game that has a minus on it then it's worth explaining what that minus actually means especially when it's unclear does this subtract from my black blood drops does it subtract from someone else's black blood drops well and the reason i gotta give him just a tiny bit of flack about that is because i'm holding if whether whether the podcasters can hear that i'm holding the the little menu that they give you and uh it's got one two three four five it's got a total of four pages back to back pretty much something on every side so it's got eight pages of uh of menu so to speak but each what this is is it's a picture of the tile and it explains what the power is right so deciphers the iconography you need that you're buying from 16 powers per color and you just want to know okay do i have one that gives me more damage somewhere like what the heck is all this symbology so this is great and they even play the back two pages actually the green expansion is in there but the back two pages are even clarifiers for uh some of the extra content uh so where are the battle cards themselves like just even just that one battle card like would have been nice um so yeah that could have been somewhere i don't know minor thing the other thing that we caught i really want to call out because largely it was a success but the other thing i want to call out was okay i i kind of feel like and maybe i don't know what the solution is but there had

to be a better way to do the board i always thought commett was interesting in that it tried it took and made a board in which everything was equidistant to all players if this temple is four spaces away from me it's also four spaces away from you if you are three spaces away from me you're also three spaces away from the other player at the table and i and vice versa like there is no positional advantage this isn't like dad took australia in the early game you know whatever another risk reference here but like never conquer asia then the other thing i know don't ever try to win asia in the land right exactly but but there's no positional advantage except that the way this this does it is a really cleverly shaped board well in the old game you had a two and four player side of the board and basically you would you would lay down the board and you would ignore for the lower player count you would ignore anything on one side of the nile and then for a three to five you'd flip it over and you did or ignore anything on one side of the nile for the three player right right uh well that you know that worked it was never my favorite i don't ever like having to ignore half of the entire board and explain especially if i have a new player explain like hey stop trying to walk your guys across you can't capture that temple pretend it doesn't exist right and then to to take it and what they but that was a double-sided board where they had a two and four and three and five player count respectively they've designed this board for an inevitable uh one of those things we've talked about a little bit here the inevitable six

player expansion because they have all the material printed to allow for six players they just don't have a sixth player in the box another lord to water deepism in there you know preempting the the expansion material that's going to come out by giving you the iconography scythe did that as well where they were like yeah there are things in here but totally we didn't cut them out of the game the game is as designed here but we're telling you it's coming down the road yeah and i had i did a double take when i counted the number of available starting sponsors like wait a minute but um either that either that or i need to get on there and double check the kickstarter and maybe there was supposed to be a sixth one in the box you never know but i i'll check that but um no the thing about it is though is they take that board and they still make you divide it down the middle but then and i'm gonna wave some more stuff then they give you these chunky things these desert storm chunky cardboard tiles um that are intended to cover up specific uh sections of the board right right they they just like become this desert mass or a storm and you just pretend as though that section doesn't exist and otherwise things are you know like you you play with that mass of the board and then still ignore another big chunk of the board it seems like an inelegant solution like i know what they're going for but at the same time if they did the luxurious print job on the back side of the board that you're never going to see except to look

at it once and be like oh wow guys let me show you this exactly you can't like frame it and put on your wall because then you don't have the board to play on it really seems like they could have done a like here's the two to three player specific version of the game on the back of the board and then here's the four and higher player count version and then maybe you don't use sections of the board or whatever i don't know it seems like a step back i do think i do think you probably and again i'm not proposing that i know the exact best solution but maybe something like that a two and three where you use the storm to cover up the third because that's really all it is is you're mostly you you don't use the other half of the board because you don't want to have too many temples available again you got to reduce the choices so those storms were actually not the part that i minded the most the storms worked i felt like they more i mean they're they're a little busy looking in my hands brightly colored swirly chaotic storms of sand but when they're on the board they weren't actually uh hard to to figure out visually what was harder was to have things on the board that you just were supposed to block out your mind covering up the the starting spot or whatever or covering up covering up one of the pieces didn't was was less confusing than having pieces you didn't use for elements i guess is the point so i really wish that they had maybe thought of a different solution i that was one solution i was hoping for going forward where i feel like i don't know if i'd call it a step back but it was a step sideways where it's not necessarily better or worse in the old game it just kind of that's still the same basic problem of

ignore part of your board well and reminding players like this temple isn't played these ones are not i agree with you that this is the best version of the game i you know like and this is a beautiful version of the game uh we talked earlier about how commett left my collection it left my collection mainly because it just wasn't seeing play but it was a really hard game to let go of my collection because to me like i said earlier it's the best version of what this game does best that's out there and i i've let go of uh many other games uh and commet is still one of those ones where i'm like should i find the play group to play it more i mean when i saw your version of comment blood and sand i was like oh this is so cool i really want a copy of this but fortunately you and i live close to one another and i could just play it with you and i have someone to play comment with so i you know like my style tends to be in the more subverting what the the traditions of the genre are by you know like i really love games like root and blood rage i and when i'm wanting a big stompy game like uh in a more traditional sense i like the really big stompy game like game of thrones as opposed to like i i just i'm not going to get commit to the table as much as it deserves still huge respect for it and i think this edition is beautiful and if you didn't have it and i played it like at a convention i'd probably be like all right commit you're

coming back to my collection well i do just want to call out one thing uh before before we kind of move on to the to the wrap-up and it's just that the chat is breaking my heart right now um pumpkinhead knock it off please um because i was just having a conversation with jack about another hot release ankh which it should be delivering to its backers or has delivered to many of its factors now it is also in that egyptian gods theme and is also kind of part of a a pseudo trilogy-ish type you know you got your blood rage on crisis son and you've got sick ladies and gent and in-ish is these sort of mythological area control trilogy type settings and ankh i actually passed on and it was a tough pass because i really love blood rage i was i really i do really enjoy rice sun but it also is hard to stay in my clutch because i have so many of that type it's at risk so did i need one more to put even more games no i didn't but man that was a hard and look at all these obelisks and all these pyramids and like a little coin slotting into this other thing oh man john you missed out and you had to settle for no i think commit is uh to me it is one of the games that is iconic of our friendship and it's one of the games that i i think of as uh what does jon love most about games and the adaptive strategies uh having to do with all the powers you

know the the sort of organic asymmetry that develops throughout the life of the game uh the really aggressive play style and the uh the the emphasis on the actual uh exchange between players rather than turtling and just holding on to one thing uh those to me are a lot of what i think of when i think of the games that you love best um i agree with you the the low points uh are um some of the rule clarification things that we hit on the errata i just want to like go to this bgg page like come on guys like here here we have the revised rules are available in a file section and it's not just clarifications like straight up we need to define and maybe even change some things right away on a brand new game like do you have blind testers why isn't this being addressed in advance of things especially with how much of an influx of money is going into this project right away this is a kickstarter they were given money in order to work out all the stuff in order to make the best possible version of this game get into your hands you know if we accept that kickstarter at this point yeah it's like a pre-order service or whatever but the the the point of it being that even big companies even the matagos of the world want it so that way they can make the best possible game that shouldn't only be put into the

heavy cool ass plastic that you're going to have which is very cool it should also be making sure that this is the most polished version of the game to date that said the clarifications are out there and you have it and now even if it wasn't in the the game as actually released in the box all of it is defined and it is the most polished version of the game it just had this little stain on it uh when it uh came out um but other than that is it just it crushed it i i think this is one of the best revitalizations of a game out there that i would put up there with eclipse as just like if you like this genre game this deserves this new treatment and it is one of the best um one of the best versions of this style of game to ever come out which is a great thing to say about a game that came out in 2012.

yeah i agree and uh honestly i you know as giddy as i was about my dungeons magic cards i was probably more giddy to get the experience how often do i get to reopen a board game for the first time that i already own and i kind of am a sucker for that sometimes like okay here take my money you know because i i get the chance to unbox something and play with the toys for the first time all over again and it's been almost 10 years since the last time well it has been fun talking to you about commet and i think we're going to wrap it up here uh thanks to pumpkinhead and uh midnight board gaming in the chat it's always nice to have some folks uh joining in asking questions and having some things to say i if you want to ask john and i any questions uh outside of chat then you can always uh hit up the cardboard herald on twitter or better yet uh join the discord and you can talk to us about all sorts of stuff as i hit the microphone that probably sounds really good as you're listening um and uh i think we're going plan on doing one of these kind of more elaborate but open-ended discussions about descent legends of the dark when that comes in uh if you have any ideas for discussion points for the show in the future or feedback or anything we'd love to hear it uh john doesn't take well to any sort of criticism uh he just wants to hear how he's right all the time but i'll try to convince him in

a way that is more palatable to his taste well i thought that's why i kept you around is to tell me why i was wrong oh okay yeah exactly that's why we keep each other around we keep each other uh the the the worst tendencies in check or that's the hope uh so once again it's been a pleasure john and i will talk to you next week man all right i'll see you next time and

ending the stream there bloop all right how many people are telling me how great

Progress saved