Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 29

Transcript 21:37

hey everybody and welcome to another edition of board games I got rid of and why so in this series I take a look at 10 ball games that I used to own in my own personal collection but for one reason or another no longer do now before I get started on the games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor kienda dot Co dot UK who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get a five percent off your first order okay so the first game I'm talking about this episode is the Isle of Skye so this is quite a difficult game to give a concrete answer as to why I did color for my collection because it is a game I enjoy a lot it's a game I've had my collection for many many years and I've highly advocated uh over the years I've always said this is a great progression from a game like Carcassonne if you want to go into that next kind of category of tile placement games I love the scoring mechanism in this game that we've seen used in other games such as cartographers and more race where each round a different a different pair of scoring objectives are triggered meaning that you have to pace yourself accordingly to know when to maximize each different scoring category is a very nice game it has a cool bidding mechanism where you are assigning money to your tiles and that's the money that your opponents need to pay to buy the off you but if they don't buy them you need to pay that fee for yourself another cool little mechanism there so why did I cull um the Isle of Skye from my collection

number one my friend had a copy so I did have it immediately in my vicinity to play it um but I think more significantly than that it's a game that I just lost my desire to play so much not but again not because I dislike it in any way shape or form it's just I I didn't really have that desire and that enthusiasm to play anymore because I have played it so many times and I think that's a perfectly bad reason why to no longer have it in my collection I want my shows to be full of games that I really have that desire to play and want to play it as soon as possible whereas this one that did kind of diminish a bit just simply through repeated plays so I kind of seen everything this game has to offer and um after after it this game did stand up way stronger than most games I've ever played because I played this one you know 15 20 times um again I just kind of ready to move on to other Tire placement games such as Acropolis and you know I still have games in my collection that do use that awesome scoring mechanism such as cartographers and nomalia as I mentioned before next up I have villagers now this is a fairly accessible Tableau Builder game as you're drafting these characters and building Tech trees of these characters trying to kind of improve their skills to generate you more points it had a degree of engine building to it as you end up drafting more character cards playing more character cards to be more efficient it did have a couple of touches that I did enjoy where you could pay your opponent to use their characters that you didn't end up acquiring yourself and it was a fairly

tactile game you know you couldn't always go down the same Pathways because not all of the cars would show up every single game now another game that I don't really feel like was bad in any way shape or form but and this game this game never really grabbed me I was never really impressed by it and it kind of left me feeling you know meh and kind of um a bit you know just a bit indifferent I suppose and that's not really good enough when there is so much choice in games I don't really want games that I'm kind of indifferent about to be in my own collection and I suppose that is why it ended up leaving the collection next up I have celtis so it's actually quite rare that I occult a rhino canitzia design from my collection but this one is basically the board game version of Lost Cities which is one of his most famous and most popular games it uses the same card play mechanism as you're trying to build runs of cards in this one either going up chronologically or numerically or decreasing numerically and each time you play a card in this run you're gonna climb a certain track and basically the trick of this game is trying to climb as high up of these tracks as you can to get you more points at the end there's also ways that you can utilize these combos by reaching certain checkpoints which will then boost you up other tracks you can end up chaining quite a few things together if you time things correctly and when that happened in this game it was very satisfying and a very enjoyable thing um to experience I do like the way that the cards flowed in this game you're trying to build that perfect round of hair so like clogging

your hand up too much and being careful about what you discard because your opponent could take it and use it against you love all that stuff so why did I cut it um this game had the tendency to go too long so for me this is a half an hour game and especially in the last couple of times I've played this one it ended up outstanding as welcome by about 20 to 30 minutes which I think was kind of unforgivable now not all of my plays ended up taking too long but what it ended up happening more often than not I kind of ended up putting a bit of a stigma on this game and not pulling it off the shelf anymore but again despite me liking the way it worked mechanically I do have other games in my collection that that use that such as the original lost cities and I even have games such as um you know photograph also known as why the film in my collection if I still want to use that mechanism so this one kind of lost out to these other two ones but still a nice game just sad it went on far too long next up I have Sobek two player now this is a game that objectively I can see its merits I think it's a well-designed game but this is the kind of abstract strategy game that I tend to steer away from and the kind of game that doesn't doesn't really gel with me but this is a game where you have a board full of tiles and you're moving this communal Arc piece around the board collecting these tiles trying to build sets and sell them with the bigger multipliers but the twist in this one was that whenever you drafted a tile it would change the orientation of the arc which would then kind of restrict on the tiles

your opponent could take in the next on their time basically so you could definitely have a lot of uh transparent transparency here you can look several times ahead and for me that did diminish some of the fun because if I want to take this towel I know you're going to take this one which means I know I'm going to take that one so again it's a bit too open for me and a bit too transparent where you can kind of see how the game is going to play out now the game did try to do some things to um you know mitigate that by adding these special character powers in and stuff like that but for me it wasn't quite enough to steer away from that pure um abstract nature of the game I also thought this game had a massive imbalance in the sweetness of one of the scoring mechanisms where if you'd end up picking up a towel that had these deben tokens on them you'd draw a random token from a bag and that'll give you points which could be hugely different so some of them would be worth uh as few as three points each but they could be worth a maximum of nine points each and basically you know based on that being pure luck that could leave a bit of a sour taste in your mouth if you played pretty well but you didn't draw very good tiles your opponents Drew better tiles and beat you for that reason so it was a bit of a mismatch for me in terms of the abstract nature of the game mixed with that huge swings of luck it just didn't quite sit right so that's why I didn't end up keeping this one now despite me liking the purity of the game's mechanisms it just wasn't a game that was right for me next up I have Ganymede so Ganymede is an interesting

one because for me this game reminded me of an ultra successful game called Splendor um but this one definitely didn't reach even a fraction of the success of splendor but I think it should have now this is another accessible engine building game as we're trying to shift these meeples from planet to planet and eventually send them to these spaceships to score you points and you're going to do that by drafting these cards which will again it will have a certain amount of meeples on them which means that if this color meeple or this kind of people were on this planet then you can move them to the next one and that's basically how the game flows you're trying to shift these meeples along uh bearing in mind that each planet only ever had a certain amount of meeples on them so you don't want to be wasting any movement but each time you did something in this game you'd kind of end up getting stronger and stronger at doing things and I did like that constant full progression as you're tucking things under your board getting more points and getting stronger as you do certain actions I also like that you were not only incentivized to do a bunch of the same action to get stronger but you're also incentivized to do a bunch of different actions to get you an ultra powerful bonus so it's like what kind of pathway you wanted to take do you want to dilute your strategy but get one-off strong benefits or do you want to keep kind of stockpiling the same thing and getting compounding benefits a really cool um idea there now this game small criticism I thought the game incentivized The Rush strategy a bit too much because one of the end game triggers was to finish a certain amount of spaceships and

you know if you catch your opponents off guard then you can pretty much just steal a victory but I think this game did what it could to mitigate that by making the rush strategy um at least beatable if you end up going for these bigger cards But ultimately the reason I didn't keep this in my collection despite liking the game um I thought that well personally I don't teach many new Gamers games consistently you know I I regularly play with experienced Gamers we always play together but the same group and we always play medium to heavyweight games so maybe if I went to a regular games group and I was consistently teaching inexperienced Gamers new games then this might even be one that I would consider I'm keeping around because I think it fits like Niche really nicely but I don't really see the need for me to have a game at this because it just wouldn't get played and it doesn't have um its audience but I definitely think with the wind in itself this one could have been a gargantuan hit because it has all the kind of check marks that those Evergreen um entry-level games seem to have but for some reason or another this one didn't quite take off but I think it should have so that is Ganymede next up I have recollect so something completely different here as this is a pure memory game um as the Box purely consists of a bunch of these um tokens on them where they're all unique and have a unique picture on the reverse side and all you're going to do on your term is you are going to challenge an opponent to guess what was

on the reverse side of a token after a bit of time to memorize them and if they're correct they get a point if they were incorrect then you get a point that's basically how the process repeats again and again and again until a timer runs out but each round a new token is added to the board to make it a bit more difficult have so very predictable gameplay you know games like this have been around forever um but it worked quite well surprisingly you know I think a big part of me enjoying this was because we never played games like this so just through sheer novelty Factor we enjoyed it um but it is a one trip Pony um it's not really a game we're ever going to go back to so we kind of enjoyed playing it for a half an hour or so and we're ready to move on to something else because you know it's a simple memory game but if you have say um children and stuff like that you want to teach them memory skills then this is a nice little tool to use um it is a mass Market game so the production isn't quite there in terms of its quality but it is a nice bunch of tokens with nice pictures on them and not really much else to say on this one so no longevity here no replay Factor but it was fine for what it was next up I have free ride which is for sure my favorite game out of all of these now this is a pick up and deliver Logistics Style game by freedom and free so freedom and freeze makes a wide variety of games sometimes pretty wacky sometimes very Euro this one is more of a an accessible Logistics Style game as I said as you are building tracks on this map of Europe you are picking up

contracts and then depositing them in the relevant locations where they want to go to and you're going to get points based on how many completed Journeys and you do as the game progresses you can end up having multiple contracts at once meaning that your Logistics is a bit more difficult to work out and you don't want to waste any movement essentially and it also has some cool mechanisms where if you'd use other people's late tracks then you'd end up giving them money but um then it would open up the route to everybody else so there's a good trade-off there about how you're going to utilize the map now I like pretty much everything about this game um it was very nice the way it worked you know completely pure in its mechanisms a nice free-flowing game very easy to understand in terms of the rules overhead and I did have that cool um you know that well basically they're getting purely focused on the logistics which was what I like from games like this now my issue with this game and why I ended up calling it is I suppose two reasons and number one usability issues in terms of the visuals there was no color coding in any of the um of the contracts and the board was all one color meaning that you couldn't just glance at the contracts and the locations of the board to see where things would would be and to try and map things out carefully it would always be a bit of a an owner restore to try and keep referencing or cross-referencing the contracts to the board itself which would have been a very easy fix and let's hope a second edition would fix that um I actually ended up doing a bit of a um kind of my own way of color coding things by putting colored dice on the

contracts as well as the board itself just to make it a bit easier to manage and I also thought much like celtis this game did have the tendency to go too long to the point where I would go into the game end up just getting rid of a bunch of the cards from the um the stamp to make it quicker now that probably threw the balance of the game off which it is what it is but I kind of was willing to get rid of that balance for the sake of the game being more manageable in terms of its length so this for me should have been a 45 minute game sadly sometimes it did end up going 90 minutes um I think the Box said 60 minutes which sometimes could happen but more often than not it wouldn't so yeah I think this game could have done with just doing what it could to push you forward and making it the game a bit more um quicker and a bit snappier so I was almost ready to finish the game by the time I went into the third round which again all of this is a shame because I actually really like the game itself and it almost is kind of telling me for my own collection because I like these kind of Evergreen stealing style games but this one just missed a trick on a few of those things getting that usability in terms of the color coding and also just having the tendency to go a bit too long next up I have sweet landia now I'd be surprised if you guys have heard of this one and I'm not even sure how I ended up hearing about this one but this is a simultaneous bidding Style game that uses the for sale mechanism if you know that game where you are playing your bid at the same time as all the others and then if you play the highest number then

you get a First Choice out of the scoring cards and I like the combos of these scoring cards in this game as you know some would say I'm gonna score a point to each other of these cards you have in your sets or this is just worth x amount of points all these different things you know very tried and tested set collection methods but this one would be um would also have public objectives out there which would often conflict with the scoring cards and you always have to weigh up about how to optimally score everything and I like the way that worked this game had a very simple I think it was a three round structure um and at the end of each round generally you would get rid of all your cards and start to get from scratch but some of them would have a certain symbol on which would stay in your Tableau meaning that when you drop a future cards the potential for bigger combos were larger you know you could always score more points around up the round which always felt good to make the game feel like it had a forward trajectory and um you know a good Crescendo to get more and more points um a very nice filler game very quick very enjoyable um but I think I have very similar games such as the aforementioned for sale in my collection that do similar things so I think I'd always lean towards for sale before playing this one and I like the idea in for sale that you know you are bidding for your 10 older cars or your initiative cards um in the first place in that kind of two-phase structure whereas this one you were given a preset bunch of cards with a kind of a fairly spread bunch of

numbers which it kind of felt a bit more um I don't know it felt a bit less authentic and it felt like a bit a bit fixed in terms of what you could bid rather than actually acquiring those cards yourself so if a little bit manufactured in that respect but I am nitpicking it's a very nice game but just one that I thought it didn't quite stand up to the greats in its own genre and ultimately I have hick hack in gecko whack now this is a another simultaneous selection game with a very silly theme as you have I think it's six different tiles on the board and each round there'll be a bunch of these breadcrumbs that will be deposited on them in a kind of semi-random fashion and what you're going to do is that each player is going to have a hand of cards then you're going to be simultaneously selecting when these cars were beating them and then basically trying to grab the breadcrumbs now if you are the only player to play a card with a matching color to a certain location then you'll get all the breadcrumbs if you and another player will go there you can either choose to share or you can have a bit of a dice like by Rolling Dice and seeing who would get all of the breadcrumbs but there'd also be these Fox cards and the decks which meant that if you go to the same location as a bird card you would eat the birds and then get the points that way so I had these different layers of simultaneous selection you know I know that you know that I know that you know that we're going to go to this location therefore I might go to this location to try and get avoided you thought I think that so you've got that location you know the kind of games I'm talking about here and this one was a lot of fun but it was a

bit of a one-trick pony and it did require higher player counts to get the most from it now sadly and more often than not I am playing with two or three players this game starts to shine up at least four players so I never really pulled this not a shot because I didn't really have the opportunity to do so so um sadly for that reason I couldn't really warrant the Shelf space um we definitely had some good times with it um but again the longevity wise it doesn't quite hold up to the to the great games like as I mentioned again for sale which uses that simultaneous selection system to um you know to The Highest Potential which you know I think it's such so difficult when there are such amazing games out there that feel so um you know really good utilize the mechanism perfectly and when another game comes out and does the same thing it just struggles to hit those Heights so despite me liking a lot about this one I did have a good fun Factor some laugh out loud moments but ultimately again the longevity wasn't there and it did require those higher played accounts and the final game I'm talking about today is Denita this is a flip and right Style game that to be honest I don't have too much to say about so not the most exciting game to end the video on this is a fairly standard flip and right game you know ticking off boxes um you're filling in things to get to the next things to get to the next things um this game did have a kind of a cool color coding system where the more you take a certain type of card you get more stronger abilities um but you only were limited to do the

same action a certain amount of time so if you wanted to keep spamming the same action um for the sake of those follow-up bonuses if you wanted to go to that card later in the game when you really need it you might not have the capacity capacity to do so so sometimes spreading yourself thinner was the better um idea there were public objectives here trying to discover these dinosaurs and get better technology you know very standard stuff here and this game was definitely released during the time where uh flip and write and roll and write games work saturating the market this one was slightly more advanced than a lot of the more popular ones and the Stellar games that I enjoyed a bit more you know the role and write type games I tend to like very accessible ones ones that take no time to set up or explain and take 15 minutes to play this one you're looking at around half an hour to 45 minutes to play and did take a little bit more to wrap your head around so it did struggle to find this place in my collection um I didn't think it really had that extra spark or something special to make it stand out from again at such a saturated space and despite me not really having much bad to say about it I don't really have anything exciting to say about it either which is not a great reflection on the game Saturday so it's just a sign of the times being so many games out there this one didn't quite hold its own and I think that reflects not many people talking about this one um at all so I actually have reviewed this one and I still haven't uploaded it so I think I reviewed it at the same

time as I did Ganymede so hopefully I'll release that video soon so you can get my full thoughts on the games but that concludes the video hopefully you have you enjoyed it if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe uh to my channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved