I don’t understand my favorite Stonemaier Game
Transcript
I've usually respected but never really enjoyed Stonemaier games that much until now, but also I can't really win this game. This is a two-player Scythe vs. Expedition game. Yes, it's literally just these two games smashed together and I just cannot win playing one of the sides in our, yes, our favorite Stonemaier game ever. I would give Duel of Melok a eight out of 10. I think it's great. It's my favorite Stonemaier game that I've played. So, this isn't a review. It is a first impressions after like six plays, which is a lot, but I was just breaking my brain thinking about this game and going like, wait, is
I can't really draw any real conclusions cuz I don't feel like I really understand it. Like, I can't get into a good enough comprehension to talk about balance and all the pros and cons we usually do, especially to get it out by this July 7th deadline, especially with all the stuff we have to do.
[clears throat and cough]
We're putting this out there for the YouTube gods, but this should all be a hopping off point for more discussion. This is not a review, okay? not see that in the comments. Duel of Melok is literally Scythe the board game with Expeditions the board game added in. The problem for us is that we are kind of Scythe veterans after making the review and then I played this game with my buddy who is a Scythe super fan, but we have zero experience with Expeditions. And so, we had to learn that from the ground up. The game is also meant to be interchangeable with all Scythe factions and Expedition cards, but there's no way we could test all those in time for this video. But anyways, real quick explanation of what each side is. The Scythe player is playing a mini civ game. They have workers to produce resources. They can move around their main dude to explore things. They can put down buildings. They can build and move mechs. They can get upgrades. And they can even get more actions via a factory card. It is also the Scytheism of having your pawn and you do the top and bottom of a column and you can't do the same column twice in a row. The Expeditions player is playing a euro plus RPG as they have their one mech going around to gather from places and explore things.
But they also have cards in hand and workers of which they'll play to complete quests, get items, and build stuff. And at some point they'll probably have to refresh all the workers and cards. These two factions are now on a smaller board with no victory points. Rather, the first player to get to four objectives first wins. Game is about 45 minutes. So, the pros are Well, we're not doing that. We're not doing pros. So, actually a lot of the stuff about this game I was realizing is just fun from my perspective as a Scythe player, like a personal enjoyment. So, yeah, this isn't so much deep mechanical analysis. Like, let's get into this first section where I'm saying that Yeah, a lot of the stuff this game does, it feels like it improves the Scythe experience for me personally. Number one, there's so much less downtime compared to most Scythe cuz this is only two-player, as opposed to normal Scythe is usually three to four players cuz you got to fill up that entire big map.
Number two, you're guaranteed to get the cool factory if you want it and there's only three cards and you nab one, so it's pretty set probabilities. Number three, the map is small, so it forces combat and raises tension. And most of the time the Expeditions player can threaten resources. Number four, combat itself occupies a large proportion of this now 45-minute game. Scythe didn't have that much combat. So, yeah, let's get into why combat feels better. You can get one to two combat stars depending on what scoring mode you play on, which is huge because two stars is literally half the stars you need to win. The Scythe player has more to lose because they can lose resources, get way more stuff displaced, and also have difficulty moving because they might not want to move. But for the Expeditions player to attack, they have to do the vanquish action, so they have to make sure they have that card and also the worker to do it. Oh, also, when the Expeditions player wins a combat, they get to start immediately without having to do the boast action, which can save them a lot of time. I also quite like the included Scythe faction Constantinople being versatile at being able to spend it on play star to get any resource. So, if you spend more than two stars, you'll have to be paying for some back eventually to eventually win the game. It's essentially a little loan system to help fix my early game woes.
And my Scythe veteran friends said that this faction wasn't anything that special or interesting. The big question mark for me is the expedition side, which actually had a ton of decision making as they can tuck three types of cards to permanently store them so they don't get refreshed. They have to decide whether or not to get combat or normal cards. And within the normal cards, they can get different talkables, like say the quest again, and quest ask you to go to certain region on the board so that informs positioning. So while the Scythe player is playing a Civ-like game with making more workers and occupying more space, the lone adventurer is doing a bit of a worker replacement with area control ideas as they move their mech, do the thing on the space, and or play a card from their hand, in any order. Just depending on what spaces are uncovered on their board as they move this one wooden cube around. And to supercharge played cards, they can play differently shaped meatballs called the workers. So then they might want to look for more of these so they don't have to refresh as often, but then sometimes refreshing is good because it lets you do every single action, not just the two uncovered ones here.
Ah, but then sometimes refreshing is bad because you have to refresh your cards that have passives, but at least you get your worker back. Yeah, so the expeditions player is like the euro larping around the board that is pressuring the Scythe player's resources, grabbing quests, and even clearing corruption from the land, which is another type of resource. But I don't understand how to actually win with them. But Alex won with them before and he just said it's easy. Just do the objectives, they're right there. But by looking at their win cons, it feels slower than the Scythe player because they have to boast to actually place the star. And what's really neat about placing a star is that after you place one, the other player can't grab that column. It's very much a race that keeps the game fast and is Jamey Stegmaier's favorite mechanic. Good taste, mate. So while playing, this mechanic means that the heavily contested easy columns, like money or certain amount of cards, will want to be grabbed earlier. The Scythe player is at an advantage to get them because they don't have to worry about boasting. And also the included Constantinople is really good at generating combat cards. This is easily like five cards here. Generating combat cards might also be a problem because you can always discard them to get something on the top right corner, which can add up to more money to get that win con, or even straight up refresh your faction.
For the Scythe player who has more cards in hand, that's removing the pawn, or if done mid-action, lets you do a different bottom, which is cool flexibility. So, yeah, I don't know. I was surprised that one of the win cons for the Expeditions player is getting seven corruption tokens. Like, seven? Alex and I both agreed this is basically impossible to get, or maybe impossible to get our skill level. Because it's seven actions to grab these corruption, as well as spending from your tracks to get the corruption, and then you also have to boast to finally get the star. Also, your mech is encouraging you to trash corruption to do other things. So, it feels kind of unaligned here. But, this might just be what they included explorer, so who knows if this is really that hard with other explorers in Expeditions, the game. Another thing that was weird is that the Scythe player can now do a really big move once come end game to occupy seven territories and just immediately get that win con. And this feels bad as the Expeditions player, especially because you're only have one guy and they have so many, and they have so many combat cards. Oh, yeah, I can't believe I didn't mention the theme yet, the duel of Moloch thing in this game, like the Moloch guy. So, this is a pretty pasted on theme where the Expeditions player will be hunting for this demon that is around the world, and the Scythe player just doesn't really care about it. So, it's a good excuse to have awesome art for the Expedition player. And really, it just feels like it's there to have quests.
However, there's a Moloch system that is this deck, which I think is awesome and fits the two-player duel system well. It's like a catch-up system that really catches a player up too much. So, when someone places a star, the other player draws a card from this deck and orients it towards themself and gets the benefit of both icons facing them. This is super clean component-wise, and by turning the top card a certain way, not only do you determine your immediate benefits, which might help you come back, but also turning this top card determines the bottom card for a later turn. Just getting a couple resources or a at the right time really can help someone get an additional star if they're really lucky. But yeah, it's not enough to suddenly win you the game and it still rewards planning well. At worst, it's something to soften the blow of getting scored on. The rest of the cool stuff is just how the game looks really good. It has an insert and the wooden pieces and mech are the same level as Scythe, so awesome. The not so good component stuff is how the rulebook is confusing as heck as it barely explained each game and instead just give you summaries. I mean, it was really telling to us when one of the setup guides was talking about an expansion pack and we went "Well, we have no idea what that expansion is, so this is confusing." Luckily, my other friend knew what it was cuz he owns Expeditions. This made us initially think, "Oh, well, this game is just for people who play Scythe and Expeditions already. They they don't really care about the rules." But then upon further investigation, no, this was probably meant for everyone, not just people who have played Scythe or Expeditions before. Like, it was even playtested by people that haven't played any Scythe or Expeditions. So, why are these rules so minimal? So yeah, we're just at this awkward state where it feels like I've
put in close enough time to make a review by now, but I can't even draw any real conclusions. Namely, I strongly think the Expeditions player just feels underpowered. Alex doesn't agree and the content needs to get out there. I can't really say the game is unbalanced if we just suck at playing Expeditions minus genius Alex. It's our job as a reviewer to say if a game is unbalanced or not because it's part of the good and bad, but in general, that's a hard thing to do and I feel like if I'm just not playing this game to the fullest extent, then I can't make any claim there. It's just how it is. Like, there's a handicap in the rulebook that says, "Oh, well, if you have some imbalance in skill, just have the Expeditions player play two three stars instead of four." And that felt just right. At least for me. I also don't really like how swingy some combat cards are. Like, I don't enjoy munitions to spend seven power to also have it be seven power, so that's 14 power which will probably win you any mech first mech fight. But also, that's probably just so late in the game that amongst good players, if you If you to that point, then the game should have ended anyways.
I don't know. Also, I don't like flipping over the top card from the deck from this card. When you have a range of zero to five, it just feels weird. Anyways, yes, this is a lot of meandering, so I guess if this game is balanced, the recommender score could be like eight or nine, especially if they clean up the rules. But if the game's not balanced, then it's like, well, what's the point of playing this then, right? Like, I don't know. I don't know. I just don't know. I don't know, guys. I'm I'm actually I don't know. All I can say is that my friend who owns Scythe and Expeditions beforehand and is a super Scythe fan but wanted to sell Expeditions said, "Oh, you know, this game might give me a reason to skip Expeditions as more factions to play in this dueling game." But then he just dropped that thought after our three games. But I have good fun with this game. Yeah, it's fun. Like, this is my favorite Stonemaier game that I've played ever, so it's a seven out of 10 for me. I enjoy it. Even though I keep losing as the Expedition side, I want to keep playing, and I wish I had more time to make this video, but yeah, it's it's fun. Like, there's so much variance in game space that happen because I didn't put cards here. Anyways, yeah, there's so much variance in game space that happen because there's cards here, you're drawing different cards, the Scythe player is moving differently, at least in the six games I've played, and it's just fun to do the things here.
Now, again, I don't know how to win, but the fantasy of just moving one guy around and managing these cards is enjoyable. Like, every turn is enjoyable. Movement really matters in this game, deciding what to refresh. Yeah, it's a neat puzzle. I'm pulling at so many Euro levers from the get-go with some threat of combat. So, I feel giddy with all the possibilities and actual interaction. I mean, gathering twice on a strong space feels good, but I'm also puzzled on how I'm doing so many things but not really getting any closer to winning. For the Scythe side, well, we always felt like Scythe was a very tight game in reality, as in, there's a very set way to play the game. But now with the one-v-one, I don't really think that's so much the case anymore. With the Expeditions player romping around with all these random card retrieval, and then the Moloch deck isn't forming, well, how you play stars. There's just more counter play and overall positioning. So yeah, this game could shoot to an eight out of 10 personal score for me in the future. It's very possible and the side side, it's fun.
It's it's fun. It It just takes like the best parts of Scythe for me and no downtime again. So yeah, I don't really get expedition side, but maybe in the future I'll get it, but hope this helps. Bye-bye.
So the first time I played this game, I played it as the expedition and I was very confused about what to do, but gradually over the course of the game, I started to figure out the play pattern. Um and interacting with someone else who was playing Scythe is really cool. Uh I think the game looks great. I've always thought Scythe and the 1920 plus world looks really good. The art's amazing. Uh the components are really nice. I like the catch-up mechanic of the Meloch cards uh cuz it requires you to give some thought about if you want to score an objective early because you might be giving your opponent a really powerful boon that they need um and you can't really account for what these are going to be. I wasn't really a fan of vanilla Scythe at all. I thought it took way too long to play uh for how complex the game was. So this is kind of perfect for me. It's quick.
It's a only a two-player game, so it's much more conceivable that I could find someone else to play it with me. Uh and if you don't like playing Scythe, then you could play Expeditions instead um or vice versa. You don't need to you know, love both games in order to find this game fun. But actually, I think I'm coming around to Scythe or maybe just the Scythe mechanics by playing this particular smaller scale version of it. I really like these combat cards, specifically the change to them cuz I don't remember this in vanilla Scythe. So I I think this is a a change um where they have an effect that they do in the top corner of them. So, collecting these is never pointless because it's always accelerating you to a goal and it's cool that your opponent can only guess what the cards in your hand may help you with. Like for example, I played a game of Jewel of Maloch where I was trying to get 12 coins, 12 gold as the Scythe player. I scored the objective for getting a bunch of combat cards and then I was able to immediately turn that into coins because the cards now had no value anymore to me. I just won the game very quickly and that felt very satisfying to pull off.
Um cuz I remember in vanilla Scythe collecting these cards was uh not not as multifaceted. My only negative is that the rules are useless nearly cuz it's like they just don't tell you how to play. They tell you go read the rules on the internet or go watch a a video. So, I think that sucks. I would like to play either side for sure. Even the Scythe side. I found that fun. Maybe just because it's faster, there's less time to for people to stall to AP their turns. So, it feels more satisfying to play. Game's good. Game's great.
Great.