Skip to main content
Loading video...

Rate My Shelf - Keep or Cull - Board Games - Episode IX

Transcript 25:35

hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and this is the broken me a show devoted to board games where I sometimes tell you to buy games and sometimes tell you not to just not necessarily in equal proportion so this is my rate my shelf series I think this is the ninth one I've done now where I basically take a random calic square and talk about the games that on it it's kind of keep call kind of not it's it's more talking about the games I've got here why I have them why I like them and whether they would be Keepers for life or potentially calls when I come to have to find space for new games cuz there's only so much space on these shelves therefore usually when new games have to go on the shelves I have to think well which game can I now get rid of the idea with this though is also to kind of tell you how they stood the test of time so some of these games I've had not for too long some of these games I've had for years and so you'll be able to kind of get an idea as to whether the game can stand the test of time or whether they're starting to get a little bit too old so we got five games here on this shelf which is literally over there it's by the wall on on the side next to where all my lcgs apart and there's quite a mix of games here although predominantly they are kind of a mixture of zman games and Mayfair games uh with the exception of raw here 21st century games this is the new reprint version uh let's see let's see five game why don't we try just moving it all like that and to the side for now and we'll stick with ra so this is the new version you know tools artwork it's not the like ridiculous deluxe version I think had like metal pieces and stuff like that

but it is still pretty damn good quality components for what you get I mean seriously do you need better components when you've already got this giant sack full of stuff here I mean it's huge I don't want to take it out too far though cuz trying to get this packed is a little bit of a pain with this bag you have to kind of flatten everything down in order to get it in there but I've got cardboard tokens and I've still got the boards but the fact that you still have like ridiculous Mammoth pieces of wood like this I mean it is kind of insane that is literally just a marker for the player nothing else me remember me and then you've got this marker which is equally just thick wood for you know effectively around tracker and then everybody's got a bunch of these things which again I feel like I should be like biting on them to check how many carrot gold they are it's insane and then you've got all the pals themselves which okay as I'm nice I'll get a few of them out here we go so again chunky cardboard tiles I think you get like ridiculously thick versions possibly even blastic ones when you have the real big version which has a bigger box but seriously that's just Overkill you really don't need that version especially if it's going to cost you a bomb now this is an auction game where basically you draw tiles out of a bag and you know you take it in turns take a tile out and you place on the track and you may decide to start the auction or it may just happen automatically and essentially everybody gets to bid with these little round tokens that essentially are your bid values so you've only got three of them in a round I think it might vary with player accounts but typically three and they're different values and there's one

in the middle and basically you go around in order you put a token out if you want to whoever has the highest wins all the tiles in the middle as well as swaps their token with the number that was in the middle so it might be a higher or lower value and these tiles do different things they score in various ways and it's mostly occasionally set collection and avoid the bad stuff with a few elements of who's got the most of this at the end of a round thrown in you basically rinse and repeat this for free whole eras where there's a little timer for how long an era can take it's variable and then see who's got the most uh points by the end it's a pretty decent game overall and I do I'm not well I do like it but I'm not the biggest auction fan typically I really am quite picky with auctions there are some games I cannot stand that are auction based I hate uh power grid I really don't like that one I don't particularly like uh QE whatever it is the weird one where you can write whatever you like that that one I just find breakes every time I play it it's yeah there are some of them I'm like and isn't modern art oh yeah Modern Art is a auction game as well that particular fan of that but there are a couple that I do put my stock behind I do like this one and I do like a high society little filler auction game I think that works I like biblos which is down there although I don't know if you'd call it auction maybe that's more bidding it's it kind of depends if the auction is just simple bidding I quite like it and the three games I've just mentioned are pretty simple bidding I think when an auction is too open-ended it can go to stupid figures like power grid and QE it stops being that enjoyable for me that being

said raar is not without its problems because as much as it's you know a relatively straightforward game and not too long there's not a huge amount of variety in it I mean all the tiles that are in here you're going to see you're going to draw out most of that giant bag so it's really just a case of the timing and everything apologies if you can hear traffic outside but the other thing that kind of drives me nuts with this one is the passing of the bag that gets really annoying and really greaty basically this giant bag as soon as it's your turn you take the bag you draw a tile out put it out and then you're passing the bag on and it's just constantly having to circulate that bag around a whole table endlessly for the entire game gets a little bit annoying I mean I swear turns take less time to fulfill your turn in terms of your choice of action or what you're going to do than it does to actually draw the T out of the bag and pass on in the first place it can be like that and it's I know it's a like a little weird quibble but you know it does get grating over time constantly having to pass his bag around you mean you have to use your hands that's like a baby's toy that alone is not enough to kill the game for me it's just one of those annoying things I have to bear with but that being said as as much as this is a recent version and it is a pretty decent game I don't know if it's one I'm going to hang on to Forever it's like I kind of I'm in that camp of I like it but I don't love it and my collection kind of needs games I love not just games I like so usually if I want a game of this somebody else will

have a copy and I can just play theirs it's possible that game cafes might have it or game libraries uh having to store it in the box is a bit of a pain because the the bigger box that I think is Bigg enough to hold everything in without problems but here I have to put up with constant box lift because trying to get that bag flat on top is just an absolute pain so there's some little quality of life issues that do get him away but also I I I like it I just don't love it so this would probably be on the coal pile you know not not so not not because I don't like it but it is an old auction game yes it's been modernized for this but only in the sense of the pieces look great and they do they are fantastic but the game hasn't changed it's the typ it's the same Rhino cono game it was before and I'm just kind of like h want to move on to something else so raah potential C but it'll stay in the collection for now but it's definitely on the lower end of enjoyment all right now most boring title award goes to Majesty for the realm it really does this is such a boring title Majesty for the realm I mean why do we even need for the realm is there any point to put for the realm in it like I wouldn't recognize it and if majesties do boring will then come up with a better name for your game but this is essentially from the same designer who did Splendor and Splender is on my shelf it's still going strong I still think it's one of the best Gateway Games there is but this one was a sequel which is not that far off in terms of complexity to Splender it's not much more but it's a very underrated game and the mistake it had was that it came out in the UK I think around

December after Christmas yeah you know that tiny little slot so trying to get people to even recognize this games a thing was kind of impossible and they didn't do a very good job of you know advertising it but it's a very straight forward game and I've even pimped it up slightly because one annoying thing it did have was not enough money um it's got these like really cool chips for the money which is nice it's nice that they've got these chips the only problem is there's nowhere near enough of them for like three or four players you are changing up constantly so I took a bag of spare like cardboard chits from the like last time I had villagers you know these ones and basically because this game doesn't come out that often I figured you know what I'll put a bag of these in and these are the replacement money because whether I'm using chips or not I don't really care it's like as long as it's functional money but this one's very straightforward I mean it's one of those games a bit like canvas that I was reviewing where essentially you have uh like locations in front of you and there's a and b sides for a bit of variety but where's the rest of the cards oh yeah the the small ones you idiot and you've got these characters that are essentially like different various like royalty or peasant or chef and that's Chef I'm sure is a different name probably the inkeeper but the idea is is that these will be laid out in a row and it's that typical game where you can pick the first one for free and then you got to pay to pay to pay to get the other ones afterwards and you pay with these basically little white meatles so it's like Sentry spice Road and things like that and basically when you take one it goes underneath a location it might trigger other effects but basically they all score in different ways you have to worry about uh people coming around with knights because if

they do they could kill off one of your like lowly peasants effectively but you can defend against it with guards and there's a couple of other weird little scoring variabilities here but it also rewards you for diversity and like loading up on something you'll get a decent amount of points if you get like a ton of inke Keepers but if you a if you're able to get like one of each on all your things you'll also get a lot of points that way and depending on whether you have the a or the B sides of these locations will vary how many points they're worth for those as well as what they are and there's an element of if you put somebody under there opponents will also get a benefit but it's a very simple game and we've seen this mechanic used in several games but this one's just a very nice quick 20 minute effectively a filler really 20 to 30 minutes two to four players no solo mode just shoved in for the hell of it no stupid five player nonsense the artwork is drop dead gorgeous I mean really solid nice artwork I wish there was actually more of it in the game and it's very easy to teach and very quick to play it does a good job is it as good as Splender probably not you know Splender just manages to scratch that itch of a really solid Gateway game but this one is still pretty solid it comes out every now and again now do I want to hang on on to it forever that remains to be seen but because it's a nice quick game to get out and because you know you know it's a mechanic that pretty much everybody knows it's one that I know I can get played if I need it to even though it is a bit of a hard cell with that stupid cover and title canvas I reviewed recently and it uses the same mechanic would I rather play this over

canvas hard to say canvas is a lot easier than this game I mean canvas is float away light even with the expansions although this is a lot less of a pain to stored in canvas so there is that but you know maybe the two of these will start duking out for Supremacy at some point but for now I'll hang on to this you know I'll keep it it does the job and you know if I if I do get rid of it I'm not entirely certain I'll see another copy of it ever so it's certainly worth uh keeping tabs on it but yeah I'll hang on to it for the time being right let's move on to a of Sky I have not played this in ages and I remember playing it quite a bit in the past but lately I just really haven't done much with it it's an Alexander Fister game although it's also co-designed with Andreas pelican pelican one of those two and it's a tane game I like tallan games I've got carcassone of actually no I don't no I sold carcassone ages ago wow I don't even have carcassone but I do have small Islands that's it yeah CU small Islands killed carcassone for me that was it but this is another cool Tyle Lane game and it has the Druid expansion in it why does it not have the um the other one before it because the one before it uh which was called the journeyman expansion is complete dark garbage oh yes I hate this it is revolting Druids adds basically a couple of extra types of symbols and another type of buying phase like a second TI you can get in the buying phase and essentially they score for various different things you know it's a um that's the rule book for it and it's very easy to throw in it's a very easy to play with and it's pretty much an auto include even if you're teaching the

game so Druids was a good expansion journeyman pretty much changed the entire nature of the game and made it stupid overly complex remember Alexander fister's like kind of stick where you see all these like flow jars and all these player boards with the ton of symbols and arrows pointing everywhere and stuff well take that and shove it into this game it's like taking something out of his three hour euros and Bunning it into here and it really doesn't need it so do not get journeyman and you can tell it's popular because everybody plays with it yeah no it was stupid now here what do I got oh I've got a folded space insert for this as well so it's a bit easier for me is set up but the premise is quite simple you essentially have like a little buying bidding phase where you you've got objectives that you have to like try and score points for as the game goes on but essentially you take these tiles and you'll have a bunch of them and you're like oh yeah these roads can connect or this has symbols or this has animals that I want and then you put them behind your screen with cash effectively to sort of signify right this is how much it's going to cost for another player to buy the tile off me and so you might see a tile that you really like in which case you might need to price it quite High to stop people taking it off you if you do retain the tile you've got to pay it so you're trying to find that balance between not spending too much of your money but also not having a player take a to you really want it's a really cool angsty decision and it doesn't take that long to figure out you know these turns don't take long but once you've sorted out what tiles you've got you then build

up your map and you build up in such a way as to score a lot of points I mean if you played Carone you kind of know how this stuff works but with The Druids thrown in this is a very cool game but I have not brought this out in ages the fact that I'm doing this video now actually makes me want to shove this in the game back for next time so this is definitely a keeper it you know it is a solid game but I guess it's just sat at the wrong end of the room for too long and I've just never fought to learn it again and bring it out I me it's not like it's a lot of rules to learn it would be easy enough but yeah maybe it's time this one got a little Resurgence actually because I do remember liking it you know I mean I do like some of Alexander Fister stuff although I must admit this and broom service yeah I do tend to like more of his smaller co-design stuff than his bigger stuff although there are the old exceptions but you know this is a really solid talling game I think it still goes strong it doesn't feel dated or anything and definitely a keeper for me in fact I reckon this one might even hit the game bag at some point so uh good to remind myself of that little gem right this one right Pillars of the Earth pen fet based on some book book who gives a crap because it really doesn't matter it's like yeah best based on the bestselling novel by Ken fet bestselling I mean to be honest I can't really comment I don't read I literally do not read that is why you fail I mean I've got an Arkham Horror short story book in the other room but that's about it but honestly outside of work the only things I'm reading are R books for games and uh

cooking books yeah that's pretty much it I don't really read anything else I don't have the time and I just don't have an interest in reading stuff I used to listen to audio books now and again like I listen to the Lord of the Rings trilogy The Hunger Games trilogy uh Ender Game and a few other like you know fairly well-known IPS but never Harry Potter apparently but the yeah the audio book was fine I could put it on in the car and I could listen to it while doing other stuff but even then I just feel like listening to music now or watching YouTube because this was very much predominance of YouTube I think when I used to do audible but you know I digress Pillars of the Earth is a box that's way too big for what it is and I'm really not kidding cuz look at it I mean for crying out loud I take this out and yeah there's the board there's the pieces yeah this was a box way too big you could get the in the a of Sky Box if you just made this board a little bit smaller we just make boxes here that being said oh my god do I love this board it this has to go up in like the top five prettiest boards look at this this thing I've used it as photos for like game clubs nights and stuff you know like to advertise things and oh my God it looks so gorgeous this is Michael Menzel and you know this is what he does best when it comes to board games not necessarily designs the best he did the legends of Andor and that was kind of me but when he's when he does a board like in terramara or this one and various others oh man I want the game just to stare at this board look how beautiful

it is the artwork the detail you can see people working in various places there's little Easter eggs like you might see a cat somewhere or a piece of another game and it's just such a joy to look at when you're playing this but the game is actually pry decent and fun and very simple basically these action spaces will resolve in order but first you have to get your builders on the space which are basically uh porns drawn out of a bag they're drawn out at random and when it's drawn out you either pay as much money as the space it's going on to to put it out onto an action space now or you leave it there another one gets drawn and it be cheaper and you basically carry on until all the pawns are put out so if you want to put out early to get an action space you want you got to pay a lot of money and gold is very limited but then if you leave it for a while you don't get to pay that much money but then maybe somebody's taken the card you wanted or the space you wanted and so again you got to strike that cool balance it's a neat little game but H it is starting to show its age I think this one came out in the '90s I think I think it's that old uh I don't know this might be worth a look in the rule book would the rule book actually tell me how old this game is uh oh copyright 2007 okay I thought this came out a lot earlier than that maybe it did and I just not aware of it but like I say this is a fairly oldish game by today's standards and it is starting to show its age a bit I mean it does work and I know people are going to ask what about the expansion I have played this with the expansion I do not own it cuz it's impossible to get old of and

honestly the expansion is fine but I don't consider really a must buy it it functions and it's it does the it does what it sets out to do but I don't consider it to be a oh the game's broken if you don't include it but it's very simplistic I mean you got action spaces are just take a card get victory points and the rest of the game is just basically convert resources into a card engine build and get victory points you know and it it does it fine but the other aspect is this drawing the porn out of the bag you have to understand that this is a light game and there's a decent amount of luck involved because there's no way to really mitigate drawing the pawns out of this bag you have to just accept that sometimes you might get hosed on that front you know I've got the money to go to a space so does my opponent we both want the same space they draw theirs out of the bag oh look they draw another one of theirs out of the bag where are all mine oh they all come up later you know so sometimes the game literally just like just just likes to punt you in the face and there's nothing you can do about it which does off put me a bit and as much as I love the look of this board I just don't know how often I'm likely to want to play this again because whenever I feel like oh do I want to take a light game out this is very dry it is very mechanical I just think maybe it's showing its age a bit this is going on the cold pile potentially but it the problem is trying to get a hold of this is non impossible these days I'm not aware that they reprinted it or anything so this is kind of like it won't sell for very much on a on a bring and buy but it's not one I'm ever going to see again let alone play again if I do get

rid of it so part of me things thinking that but then the box is twice the size it needs to be and if I'm not playing it why do I own it there is that maybe it's worth giving it to a game Cafe instead of selling it in which case then I could actually play it if I want to unless I move out the area that might be a better idea actually but we'll have to see as I say I think it's fine it's a decent worker placement it certainly gave me a lot of enjoyment but I think since 2007 the game is starting to show its age and probably needs to move on so it's decent but yeah a product of its time right and then finally the only pandemic game in my collection I am done with Legacy game pandemics I've played all three of them check out my review for pandemic leads in season zero to find out what I think of that one as well as the spoiler video which talks about my rankings for all three of them but pandemic Iberia is the one normal pandemic game that I have retained onto because out of all the spin-offs and believe me I am getting sick and tired of these wretched spin-offs with this game constantly just basically trying to cash cow out I mean full of Rome full of Rome a you know an invasion into Rome set in like BC times and it's got pandemic on it for crying out loud at least give the Invaders a cold or something but you know I dig agress this one is my favorite of the spin-offs though I've tried Rising tide pretty me very fiddly um I've tried the culu one it's fine probably one of the better ones that there is but again it's just kind of weird that it's pandemic culu I've tried the little dice

spin-offs not particularly much to shout about um I tried fall of Rome bit bored with that one I wasn't particularly into it were there any other ones I don't know there been a pandemic for everything there was that spin-off pandemic Air Force One thing or whatever it was where you were basically flying Logistics around the world that was pretty me so most of the time the pandemics are you know fine in terms of their spin-offs but I would rather play this one definitely over the original pandemic the original one even with expansions is fine this is definitely the better and I love the fact that it says limited collector edition and then suddenly you could find one on every store on every shelf yeah limited it's like very limited but this one is still a very solid game I mean you can play it like prettyy much normal pandemic it's got a very nice looking board you know very nice sort of elegant board but you know you can play it and I've even got a folded space insert for it apparently like oh nice but basically the main difference with this one is you can sail around the island which improves maneuverability and you can build railroad tracks on the island in order to go from certain spots a lot quicker obviously it takes action points and stuff to do but it might be what you just need and I like the fact that it does help to increase the maneuverability of it because in normal pandemic you do find yourself a little bit stuck on one end of the world sometimes unless you've got the convenient City card to get you somewhere here you can build the tracks or use the ports to try and get round and it does enable you to kind of like you know do a lot more with the board

other than that the rest of the game is exactly the same you got four diseases and you're trying to cure them but you can even use some of the variants in the game which uh one of them involves like people you've got to heal which is fine adds a challenge but I don't desperately use it but the one I do like is um it allows you I don't know where they are the cards are in here somewhere but they basically allow you to vary the diseases so they actually act like chera or the plague or whatever you know they act like they're you know actual ones they're based on and so each disease has a special all it's a decent edition of pandemic and I think I'm still going to hang on to this one because it's pandemic is a game that a certain group of friends of mine the ones I played the pandemic legacies with do enjoy so occasionally I do want to bring out a game of pandemic Iberia and even for Gateway Gamers this is a good one to bring out if I just want to enjoy a co-op question is I've forgotten if my friends own this one and if they own this maybe there's less reason for me to own it but then again it's nice to have one pandemic in the the collection and this is definitely my choice of all the pandemics that have ever been released I don't think there is a better version of it um I mean the legacies don't really count because once you're done you're done and even then the Legacy games do get to a point during the campaigns where you're like okay it's this over now so this is definitely the best of the lot it's it's nice to hang on to I'm I'm going to hang on to it this will be a keeper for now I'll see what my friends have got in terms of their copy of Iberia and maybe I'll just have to bring that out sometime you know as something a little bit uh simpler on a

night I mean yeah you can play it solo but I got other games I could play solo so Panic Iberia still worth it right there we go five games off that little shelf there for zman and Mayfair for the most part and with we have three Keepers and two potential culls yes raah could you know could end up leaving the collection eventually and Pillars of the Earth is certainly debatable but you know Majesty for the realm is still worth hanging on to Iberia is still a good version of pandemic and I actually want to get is of Sky played the next time I go to game club it's a nice simple little game so I better relearn the rules to that over the weekend but that's it for me on this episode of the broken meeple if you like what you see then thumb it up on YouTube and let me know your comments down below talk about these five games do you love them do you hate them have you had them and decided you they didn't stand the test of time you know or have you never played it but you really want to let me know your thoughts and whether you agree with what I've said about them until next time remember regardless of which shelf you're thinking of killing it's still only a game so bye for now

Progress saved