Quadropolis vs. Between Two Cities vs. SimCity - Part 3 of 3 (Going Analog: Episode 8)
Transcript
all right and I swear back this time we're gonna compare the last two games we reviewed that are SimCity like right so we're talking about droplets from Days of Wonder and between two cities from stomer games with their respective expansions public services for quadropple is in capitals for between two cities just as we've said before we're co-workers at an undisclosed video game company you work in creative services and a huge board game here we've spent a lot of time chatting about board games yeah now you work at double fine super indie publisher extraordinaire hope to a lot of good games you worked on broken age and I could not like a lot like really classic yeah by the way we're gonna have your we had your boss line one of the past episodes and he's gonna come back and I fired from this show so we did four reviews if people want to catch up they could watch the last two episodes but let's just compare the two now directly now the one thing that came up a lot was our so you're the designer well I just not specifically designed by I worked in design yeah but yeah just comparing the two games from the past reviews I did prefer quadropple it's over between two cities thinking back on it it was because of the way the games present cuz I feel like for me I'm a very tactile and visual gamer so if a game is well designed in terms of the art and and it
functions well the theme functions well with the game itself then that really hits home for me and I felt quadropple is did a better job of that in terms of the art and again I described it as an elegant design something that was that just worked and it just looked good and then the pieces you know just everything it's just everything about it was just good to me and with between two cities solid game skills well for a lot of players but just the way it presents and like ICO's complaining a little bit about the scoring board but it's not a big deal but just that overall presentation it just didn't really do it for me okay we'll get back to that what do you think about the art real quick i yeah i agree with what just said about how jobless had great clarity like you everything you never really struggled to know exactly what you're building and it looked exciting like it look very colorful and it just it was very inviting right so where's between two cities which is a game that actually like more was a little bit drab there's like some things that it did really well like I think I really like the individual pieces like that did have color and like yeah the wooden pieces are great but then like it's so inconsistent like the iconography was very clear but every single tile kind of looked the same in a lot of ways for sure yeah so even though I preferred the game I thought yeah the theme just or the presentation just wasn't as solid yeah I totally agree with you guys I give the edge to quite droplets when it comes to art it just pops its way poor color flow is way more inviting the buildings kind of look like a lot of video games that you see like village
building gains were maybe clash of clans like in a way where this is drab but now that I have these two boxes in front of me I actually realize I like them between two cities bucks better part of it is because we have this special edition that has the gold foil that's very nice though I will say function wise with the insert quadropple this is fantastic this box barely fits everything once you have it all piled in there like I'm always like kind of squeezing okay so in terms of just gameplay general gameplay how do you compare the two which one do you give the edge to just I mean based on my review I like the gameplay quadropple is better just because the choices that you get to make the construction-site how you pull from that and bring it into your city it just with the theme it just feels like a solid you know game in terms of matching the theme with what's going on in the game whereas with between two cities didn't feel that as much you're just drafting and placing and and again it goes back to presentation for me so how about you so it was it was interesting to music I'm trying to understand why one game stresses me the heck out whereas the other one I feels just like like I walk away out of like you know buoyant afterwards and I think there even though so they both kind of score at the end so you don't get the payoff immediately but I feel like the payoff that you feel every single time you pick the tiles and present them to the other players it's just like so it feels so good to be like it looks you like I got this and they're
like yes you know like it's just there's something about that interaction that is a much more pleasant experience like I find quadropple is very stressful okay I feel like every single time I take a turn I'm just like people hate me because I'm just like god what am i doing what am i doing with my life no no thank you guys yeah I was really hoping with just the decisions I'm like the doubting might like I feel really bad about my decisions when they play like when I take my turn for quadropple is because invariably I like mess it up and I see with like a move that I could have made that was far better like immediately as soon as like it's just astern you know and that is not the feeling that I have with between two cities like I feel like I've done the best that I could have given you know the options that I had and so just because I think there's even more desert like which piece do you give to which player I think the tougher decision and where am I gonna place this in my city but yeah it's an interesting point I don't quite agree with you on the stress but I agree with you about like the dynamic between the players for me I love the gameplay in between two cities just like that one thing that they designed where you're working with people on each side and how do you decide who gets which piece and you're hoping to convince them to give you the better piece because they're all working with other people I think that's super awesome part of between two cities real quick so how did you guys think these games compared to the SimCity video game like there's one do a better job no that's ultimately not the most important thing about whether this is a good board game or not but being SimCity fans how did you think these two games
compared which one did a better job yes hmm I'd say I mean I think when I thought about both games both of them do the the different types of buildings and how they score that reminded me of SimCity in terms of like you have your commercial area you have your residential area and that's you have to build your city that way in order to kind of maximize you know what you're gonna be doing in the game and I think both games did that well in terms of that's the city that you're building right you have to build specific buildings yeah together and other buildings affect you know the ones next to it in both cases so you know I thought both of them did do a good job in that but ultimately I think we all agreed with the games that in some ways lack that city building spirit right yes something like when we weren't shooting which is that you said like the simcity on pause or something like that I think that was yeah I was something ingenious that our cameraman actually said is that quadropple us was kind of like a Sim City on pause like you basically you know you said everything out but you don't get the payoff and it's like okay and go and then like your score there yeah but what both games kind of do is that they delay the it's a game that delay is the scoring aspect of it but I think between two cities it's such a fast game takes less time to get to the scoring part and you have like it feels like a team spirit thing risk quadruples it's like got it it's so badly on this one scoring
thing and like you are now I'm thinking the score so think you know us or whoever is doing it and there's this is zero for me the SimCity comparison I think I give him a draw because they both do the whole thing about like okay you want to play styles next to certain tiles to score certain districts maybe Quadra plus gets the edge there if you're looking for the SimCity experience just because on your map itself they're districts to build in maybe this a little bit more so much since City where you're like tied to certain areas or zone yeah quadruple O's has the management thing that's booked both of these games that are missing the management thing which means that what I mean by that is that you can build certain things in the city and then they may be like produce you get more money or like you get more people or something like that there's no like there's a there's way more management when you play a game like that and quadropple is has you get additional resources that you can then place that's a good thing that's the most in terms of similarity I would say it has a little bit of manager yeah and then going back to presentation you get a little more cartoony gamey look with click appleís yeah wait you guys changed my mind a great quadropple is better since city you know log alright so we're gonna do a real quick d20 more your final thoughts on how the two games compared to ones into the gods alright so ten one nine all right let's take a couple minutes okay now you have
this is the final words you're gonna say or word I'm gonna say no matter between these two games what did you think just you had would you roll a ten so quadropple is great presentation strategy between two cities good for groups all right second place I had nine words to make my final thoughts are droplets fine this better say this better fast and fun give it instead of just for this yeah these three words
like off-camera you're like what do I do what am I gonna do this one we're not like that so what is you know what do I have to capture here so whom my first war my first effort at this I'm just gonna read two of these but my first effort was cities is supposed to be a reference to between two cities yeah yeah I said this but I didn't know you could point this yeah illegal not either but really would the real word that I wrote is co-op okay in reference to when the reference to between two cities because I thought that that was the cool thing that had had you all right we're not gonna vote with our thumbs we're just gonna pick one game finally I think it's pretty obvious but just to be clear your final pick between these two games monopolist quadropple is your final pick I'm in between two cities from you as well so this wins two to one alright thanks guys now Sean baby is back after a brief hiatus and he's gonna help us wrap up this episode with a discussion about the game 18 welcome to another episode bad gamer ooh analog this one is a team ba lends a hand in the race for the formula now you would think in an 18-game the conceit would be that you yourself are be gay or sergeant Bosco Baracus bad attitude that's actually what the BA stands for in there but he has gone in ahead of you because
you know he's the master of undercover work since he's a six foot three men with a mohawk and 80 pounds of jewelry you want him to do the undercover work he set up this up and you're the rest of the 18 they got I got Hannibal they got the scrounger they got face and Howlin mad Murdock and and a woman they yeah the whole team is there but you're not ba and you pick up these ba cards like ba tells you where it's at which I think it's like like the Chicago Street Lang Street clang from when he was a child so it's sort of like ba tells you what it is and like that's a good thing this one as ba smooths the way and roll again there's like 50 of these basically the whole deck is ba smooths the way this card was blank and I don't imagine that was intentional so maybe I got a bad one I don't know but this one doesn't do anything the point of the game is actually really great when it says the race for the formula it's actually the formula for a popular soft drink they don't say whether it's Coke or Pepsi but it's clearly one of those two and you're actually racing to protect the intellectual copyrights of that soda so that's like the whole game is you're doing this military infiltration of this place to stop people from stealing the formula for Coke and you're not ba Baracus and that's the game there's not a single choice you make in the entire game you just roll dice sometimes you get a card that says ba tells you what
it is and sometimes you get a card that does nothing and that's the a-team ba lends a hand in the race for the formula