Skip to main content
Loading video...

Wargame Rules Are More Important Than VIBES

Transcript 10:52

in this video I'm going to tell you why finding the right rules instead of the right Vibes is most important in wargaming I'm going to get right to it I see a lot of people complaining online obviously about war games that they love but they generally dislike the rules either things are too crunchy you know like incredibly detailed rules nearly trying to act as kind of like a simulation and drastically slowing down play or to streamlined simplified and kind of abstract rules that don't have any flavor is a term you hear a lot as well you've probably seen this as well if you spent any time online it seems like a common complaint people might Delight in The Vibes of a game you know the art and the setting and the models of the game system but the rules adding to this problem is that one person's crunchy rule set is another person's streamlined and simple rule set all of us in war gaming are on kind of different Journeys if you will so there's never going to be a definitive opinion upon any specific game and whether it's got good rules or bad rules that said a game that has good rules in your opinion has good rules for you someone else may think differently about the rules for that game and then it has

bad rules for them opinions are not truth they're specific to each person Games Workshop is obviously the biggest game in town as it were uh so there's a lot of opinions out there about their rule sets also the majority of the opinions out there for games like Warhammer 40K and AIA Sigmar come from the competitive play crowd people who are hyperfocused on the rules and the abilities of the units aailable in the game this is to some degree exacerbated by Games Workshop themselves with their kind of regular rules adjustments we just had one for 40K like yesterday I think and and focus on kind of watching The Meta as it's called so if there's generally a lot of negativity towards the rule sets that Games Workshop makes and we do see a lot of it online then why are they still such popular games well part of it is the internet and its kind of amplification of negativity people who don't like something or the way that something is will certainly talk about it online whereas people who are content with a rule set generally kind of don't make posts about it therefore you don't hear about it in my opinion more people should post about things that they like maybe I don't know but that's that's kind of a different topic however the main reason why Games Workshop games are so popular of course

is because of the intellectual property that they've built the world the art the stories and the models The Vibes this is what draws in new people to Games Workshop and also keeps plenty of people playing who don't actually seem to enjoy the rule sets they would play something else potentially but then they feel they'd have to you know like leave the world that they love behind this is of course not true at all there are plenty of ways to stay within the Vibes of Warhammer obviously you could just keep reading the novels they're filled with lore that's kind of the point of novels really uh you could even keep buying I guess the rule books and the codices if you wanted to they have lots of story and art and all that kind of stuff these things and then of course like the licensed video games and then eventually there's going to be maybe a TV show and all that Games Workshop is very good at their intellectual property but if you're not a fan of their rules to play their games and I understand that you can still keep you know Warhammer in your heart and on your mind but if you enjoy playing games as well and the perfect ideal is to play your games in the world of Warhammer for example you could always take your stories and your cool models and fancy terrain and all that and play with them in a different rule set some folks don't believe it but the rules are are actually important

they're how you interact with the story and the models and the other stuff but that doesn't mean that they're intrinsically linked rules matter and for some folks the rules matter even more than the official fluff and the fancy models and the corporate meta my good friend Vince ventell and I make games well I mean we make rule sets for the most part we want you to use whatever Miniatures you'd like to use for our games maybe miniatures you already have so you don't have to like buy and build and paint new ones or maybe some new Miniatures that you've always had your eye on but didn't buy because you didn't have a game to use them in this type of gaming is called Miniatures agnostic gaming and it's been around far longer than the whole kind of buy these Miniatures to use in this game mindset I say this all the time you've probably heard it before every game is Miniatures agnostic if you believe in yourself you can play games Workshop games for example with weird models that you found online or 3D printed or kit bashed or whatever and you can use your fancy Warhammer models in other rule sets do you love BattleTech minis but you don't like the rules use them you know those those Miniatures to play steel Rift from Death Ray designs maybe you don't like the BattleTech minis but you want to play BattleTech well then use the Max from steel Rift to play out your games in the inner sphere you can use your Warhammer 40K models obviously

the you know the most popular wargaming system out there to play in great systems like Grim dark future from onepage rules and also star breach from slow death games uh you know just for an example but links to both are in the description below these are very different rule sets from each other and from 40K but they're designed to play sci-fi battles Star breach is probably a little bit more Skirmish oriented so maybe it should be compared to Grim dark future firefight from onepage rules but either way they're both easy alternatives to move your 40K models into and did I mention that they're free now two things yes Warhammer 40K also has free core rules that you can download from their website and that's very good they didn't used to do that this is relatively new having free core rules to look at and to try out is really important for you finding rules that you actually enjoy and not just you know buying like whatever rules are attached to the model line and The Vibes that you enjoy secondly both star breach and the onepage rules systems that I mentioned also have non-free versions of their rules with advanced stuff and whatnot but they're still even at that level very much cheaper than the non-free versions of Games Workshop rules of course like I said checking out the rules to see if they're right for you is really important before deciding to purchase but you know like what if

the rule set doesn't have a free version for you to check out sometimes the rule set is the entire product there's companies that will give you the rules for free because they want you to buy Miniatures and then there's folks like Vince and I and we're just selling the rules so there is no free version what do you do then welcome to the wonderful world of battle reports if you ever want to learn about a rule set and see if it might be for you and you can't get a free version of the rules find a good battle report for it on YouTube for my money Ash Barker's battle reports on Guerilla miniatur games topnotch for teaching me about a rule set and whether or not I'll end up enjoying it the biggest benefit he doesn't just focus on Games Workshop like a lot of battle reports do he hits so many indie games out there chances are if you've heard of an indie Miniatures game Ash has probably already made a bat rep for it if you just like to you know think about lore and story just you know spend your day daydreaming about what Space Marines are doing right now well then then the rules don't really matter to you you don't need them if you just love like collecting and painting miniatures and getting your hands dirty and all that kind of stuff then again the rules don't really matter to you you can ignore them and just continue to have fun building and painting but if you love both those things and want to play even semi-regularly then it would behoove you to explore other options to the rules

you're playing if you don't enjoy those rules you can find other rules to use for your story and models and if you've made it this far in the video and you're going to bring up that Old Chestnut of like yeah but nobody plays those other games they only Play Games Workshop stuff well then you will just have to like Play Systems that you might not like I guess or you know you could start teaching your gaming group to try out something else there's a good chance that if you don't like a specific thing about a specific rule set your friends might not like it either because you're probably on the same page with a lot of that stuff so be the change that you want to see in your local gaming group and try out some rules you might like better what popular game has rules that drive you nuts what's your favorite war games rule set past or present have you ever used Miniatures from one game in a different game was it fun did you live to tell the tale let me know all that and more down in the comments below if you liked this video it'd be very cool if you like hit the like button down there it helps out the channel and I think it also makes tiny fireworks go off or at least it used to only one way to find out I suppose also if you subscribe which is free again button down there you'll see a new video from me every single Friday thanks for watching

hey

Progress saved