Skip to main content
Loading video...

Wyrmspan, our fave tabletop events (guests: Elizabeth Hargrave, Connie Vogelmann) | Ep 130

Transcript 52:51

hey everybody Welcome to the going analog podcast the show where board game industry guests bring their own topics and games to discuss I'm Christina your host and you may have noticed that dragons are so hot right now they really really are um you know books movies shows especially games about dragons especially worms ban the new game by Connie vulgan developed by wingspan designer Elizabeth Hargrave and published by spto games it's the spiritual successor to a wingspan the classic bird engine building game and a fantastic Standalone game on its own of course I've literally taught and played wi worms span five times since we got it last month I just played it two nights ago nights ago two nights ago yeah and so every time I teach it people are like like so into the art from Clementine compardo um they're into the the dragon fact like compendium that's amazing and the gameplay is fantastic so I've played it with people who are new to gaming people who are experience with gaming and universally everybody's really loved it so uh we're excited to welcome back Connie and Elizabeth to going analog we had K Connie back on in December to discuss a Avary her apiary which is a different thing apiary the space Bees game that I also love we had a great time talking to her um so welcome back conie yeah thanks so much for having me um I really appreciate it I'm excited to be here yeah I remember at the end of our podcast I asked you hey so you know what's coming up for you and then I could tell you were holding something back and that something was worms span yep yep absolutely um so I'm excited to

get to talk about it now yay I think literally uh it got announced just like not even a month later after her show so we we barely just missed the announcement just trying to catch you just in case you you know forgot that you weren't supposed to talk about it you know and then we had Elizabeth on not that long before then a few months before discussing Fox experiment and undergrow and nerding out also so we can't get enough of both of you so uh we're glad to have you on hi Elizabeth again hi thanks for having us uh what will be your topic for us today uh Connie and I just spent a weekend at unpub the unpublished game convention and so our question was what's your favorite event of the year game for gaming not just in general but or in general yeah yeah talk about that too uh we have our opinions too we do our our you know traditional several or handful every year um and shu is here too joining us so hi Shu hi that was a little bit of a late introduction like an afterthought introduction but I mean it they're our guests right so you have to be polite they go first actually well it's funny because uh I was playing games earlier today uh but I had a hard cut off time because I had to make it to this podcast recording and then my friends were saying like it's your podcast can't you just reschedule it I'm like you don't understand we have important guests on uh we scheduled everyone together to show up at this time to record and then

um later uh one of my friends was telling his wife he like oh Shu has to go because he has a-listers coming on their podcast I'm like yep can't miss it and so what is our topic going to be today well so it's interesting because as you mentioned worms span is the successor to wingspan and then uh but uh you know a lot of people are like oh what does Elizabeth Hargrave think about this who designed the original Wings band because it wasn't secret she knew about this yeah but but like we we met some friends who like don't follow industry news closely they're not watching everything and they they're like they if some people thought it was a ripoff some people thought it was a clone or a copycat they didn't even realize this were on the same publisher and then they're like what is the original designer thing and so it's like oh well the uh Elizabeth also worked on this game so uh and so we to ask some questions about the making of worm span and how it kind of developed off of the sort of Bones and the sole of wingspan so that's our topic very excited to learn about that backstory uh and in the beginning we like to just talk about games we'll we'll each each pair of us will talk about some games and and chat about some recent gaming highlight some stuff um and what game do we want to discuss today Sho so our game is Roth It's pronounced or it's spelled w o t h and then uh Christina and kept making a joke like oh we're going to go play a game about our Roth IRA or something like that uh but it's not that Roth It's Roth with the W uh and it's designed and

illustrated by Manley Trembley uh most famous for the dice Throne series of games uh but in this this is an area control game uh with really cool art like you just have to go online check it out uh we played an early version of this at Dice Tower West which is a convention and then uh chip Theory games the publisher demoed it for us uh shout out to Amanda Panda and banator for uh letting us crash their demo but basic Andrew for running the demo yeah Andrew for running the demo uh but basically everyone had there you have different factions uh that all have different powers and different units um but it's fairly simple it's it's just like okay I have maybe three different types of units and then uh so at the beginning of a round there's a bunch of dice that are rolled and then we take turns Drafting and then whatever is showing on the dice will show the action we could take so sometimes it's like bring in more troops to your sort of headquarters before you launch into the battle or moving the troops across the area or attacking and things like that so it's very simple like it doesn't take long to learn how to play uh but then all the strategies in like okay when do I attack when do I move I might not even be able to move or attack if that dice uh isn't available to me so we got to play this it's like really beautiful like a lot of people stop by and just want to check they're like what is this cuz it's so colorful but it's it's a little edgy in I would say in terms of the art style um a little bit like alternative alternative like very modern comic book kind of style art almost like Punk maybe little punk yeah I I don't have the right words

to describe it but uh uh yeah it's a really beautiful game to look at and it but it's it's super mean because it's not a big map it's a very tiny map almost everyone is as soon as you enter the B uh the sort of main map you're almost immediately adjacent to everyone else so you have to kind of watch everywhere that's going on on and then what's neat is like one faction that we played one faction that was played can set traps and then so you you just like if you go into their area you don't know what kind of traps you're going to set off uh one is like it's more powerful the more of a certain type of unit is on the board they get to attack more uh and then I forgot what your faction does I forgot also okay well I did okay with it as all I remember yeah well we kept trying to pick on Christina cuz she was like as typical for an area control game you try to take after the leader or take down that was Amanda though Amanda was in the lead for a very long time but so uh yeah and a lot of that and a lot of arguing at the table of like why are you going after me go after Christina she's ahead of me or go after Amanda there's a lot of that and then a lot of like you hoping you don't get attacked and then people start ganging up on you so it has to be the kind of game you're very mentally prepared to just be like people are going to be mean to you at some point you're going to get attack uh you're not going to like it you're going to lose territory you're not going to gain any points uh but it's very streamline gameplay uh other than the fact that uh similar to other games like root where uh a lot you probably won't be good at the game unless you can understand what everyone else's powers are it's it's luy they're fairly they're

very simple they're on the player mats which I appreciated and Manny's like goal when he designed it was he doesn't actually like area control games so he wanted to design one that he would actually like so I see like a lot of the sort of very annoying minutia of some of like those sort of bigger area control games were sort of smoothed out so I'm excited to see the F how it looks in the end yeah I I will I point Amanda Panda who's a content creator and one of our guests on our show before she made a good point of like uh she's not sure what Manny tremley means by that by saying like I want to make a game for people who don't like air control games it's still very air control it's still a very Aira control game it's still very mean uh so we're I'm not sure what he means by that maybe he wants it more combat Focus maybe just prettier I don't know yeah it is prettier definitely yeah but it's a it's a really neat game but it's it's very aggressive you have to have people who are like they're not going to get their feelings hurt they're going to be okay getting attacked and they're okay ganging up on each other uh to try to take certain people down uh but the yeah the I the main thing I really liked about this game is that as you play you start to feel really powerful you start you get more income you can use that income for special powers and things like that you're excited to see the dice roll and see what kind of actions you can take and all that so like it's it just feels very fastpac and very moment to moment like there's a lot going on there's not a lot of downtime in that maybe that's what he means he do like the slog yeah anyway cool cool and then you two also had a game that you decided on to bring uh to

talk about and what was that yeah so we decided to talk about Nar uh spelled k n a r r so that one I think also needs I know right um so Nar is a it's a very short maybe 20 minute um I'm going to call it like a tableau building game but that might not be quite accurate um basically it's it's Viking themed but it could be just about anything um on your turn you do one of two things you either play a viking um you know from your hand into your Tableau then those Vikings go into one of five Stacks based on color and then when you play a card you activate all of the benefits in that stack or you are basically discarding some of the cards from your Tableau to sort of buy these other cards and the other cards either give you some kind of an ongoing income or they give you some kind of endgame points and it's very quick it's a race to 40 points um and it's one of these games that for the first you know five or six or seven turns you're all kind of floating around between like zero and five points now all of a sudden you just shoot around that track um and so for my for my um for me at least I think it's a really interesting game um because I've played it about six times at this point I keep introducing it to folks um six times already when did you because it's so short when did you get well we've just played twice this afterno on board game arena so and it's on board game arena now too oh yeah right yeah I picked it up a couple weeks ago at um awesome conon which is a local local board game convention or actually it's not really board games I think it's just sci-fi in general but they have a a really nice board game setup there um but the interesting thing is I think your starting cards uh really influence your strategy and I think there's a lot

of different ways to get points so as much as the game is like very short I think you can really kind of pick a lot of different paths um so at least for me it's like has very interesting decisions on each turn M the thing that about it that was so interesting to me as a designer is how few car are in the deck yeah it's got like 20 something cards in the deck of Vikings but you're just rotating through them and if the deck Runs Out people have to return cards from their Tableau which happened I think in both of the games that we played y so like you're building up this little engine in front of you but it can't get too good because eventually you're going to have to either spend those Vikings to score points by buying things with them or you're going to have to return them just because everyone's hoing their Vikings a little bit too much this is an interesting Dynamic well yeah we just got oh sorry go ahead Connie oh no I was just going to agree um with what Elizabeth was saying I think it's really interesting that there are you know these kind of different tracks you can go down different types of income and different kind of points you can get but there are so few Vikings that give you those benefits that sometimes they're all just in somebody's Tableau and you're kind of out of luck and I think you really have to look at their Tableau and say oh they have all the Vikings that give bracelets or they have all the the Vikings that give recruits um I better go do something else because because I know those cards are in somebody's Tableau they are not in the deck any longer MH yeah we just got a a copy from pandasaurus uh for full disclosure about a week ago and we've already played it a couple of times but as you mentioned it's really

fast it's like it takes no time to learn no time to teach uh but one of the things I like is uh I feel like it's this fits really nicely in a category of like hey uh people who are like maybe they've already played their Gateway game you know of like the super really beginner friendly game and they're ready for something with a little bit richer but that's not too complicated and doesn't take too long I think this game fits really well in that category because uh what I saw was like every once like as you mentioned there's different engines you can build there's different uh sort of ways to score points and you feel really clever about it but it's never too complicated you're never going to it doesn't feel like something where someone's going to outsmart you uh really cuz kind all the options and all the strategies are open to everybody uh besides what you said you you know you could spend those Vikings that you've been collecting that builds your engine and then you spend them to buy lands that might give you points but these lands that you buy also create a new engine on your board where you could spend bracelets to tra to trade and that's a free action that you can take on top so then you start to feel really clever it's like oh if I do this and then at least of this and then I spend these tokens to get these trades and all of a sudden you're like I just scored 15 point points out of the 40 that you kind of need and it feels really rewarding so that the very end uh it gets the last couple rounds gets really really exciting I feel like with people like taking big swings and getting a lot of points uh so yeah it's it's a fun game M what you think CHR yeah I I've only played it once but I

really enjoyed that ALS that aspect also where just there were with playing with four players I think definitely you're going to run out of those cards as people are hoarding those Vikings and there's ways we like oh well like we had a friend who was Bing a lot of Vikings so when she had to discard it you know it had what I like about there's this like uh I don't remember what it's called that one card that is like a separate like bonus every single game where you randomize it that like black card oh the artifact the artifact yeah so with the different artifacts there's things that trigger them and so we had one where if you like um get all five colors you get a little you get a particular bonus and so she very strategically was like I'm going to discard this one color because there's only one card there when I get it back then I know I'm going to be able to trigger that benefit again you know so I like that there's a lot of variety where I could see a lot of other artifacts coming in and changing the gaml um I got started a little bit late with my my points but even by the end I was scoring like a lot of points at a time it just was very satisfying even though um I was like not winning well I'll definitely have to check out the artifacts I haven't actually played with them yet I know they're in the I saw them in the base box but I haven't done anything with them yet and I don't I don't know if they're available on BTA or not but our game didn't have them oh okay yeah it's very you just pick one for the game and then uh like Christina mentioned it adds new strategies that you do and I I don't think it complicates the game uh that much like I would even for like a firsttime player I think if they're worth putting in yeah so I so you've been showing it to a lot of like new

players like like inexperienced players very experienced players like for me I've just been showing it to folks in my game group so these are tend to be folks who are very experienced Gamers um but it's you know folks have have reason liked it I think I've been maybe the highest on it for something for some reason it has just really clicked with me and I've just really enjoyed it but you know it's been well received so yeah it's a really cool art too it's like very they have the giant kind of Taro side cars and and stuff so it's a it's a really appealing game it's just so nice to have a game that's that that time length right that actually has some meat to it that you actually are making really interesting decisions right because even with people that want to get a really weighty game to the table you're waiting for everyone to show up or everyone has you know we could squeeze in a little something extra at the end you know it's that perfect filler game right now I think so uh but we brought you here to talk about wormers span of course so um so when did development on worm span start for Connie for Elizabeth like how did this start well what was the kernel that began everything yeah so I can I can pick it up in the beginning of 2022 I don't know if Elizabeth can go back farther than that um but from from my standpoint at least um I had been working with um Jamie on Jamie STM on apiary and he basically reached out in early 2022 so about two years ago and said hey I don't even know if this would be possible we're looking at designing something

else in the wingspan series we'd obviously need to talk to Elizabeth and get her sign off um you know that's an important prerequisite but would you be at all interested in designing a spin-off to wingspan featuring dragons um and I said yes why yes in fact um and then we kind of ran the idea by Elizabeth and then we're sort of off to the um Off to the Races at that point but Elizabeth I don't know if you have any background that goes back farther than that yeah I mean I don't particularly remember the interaction that much I think I just got an email from Jamie asking if I was okay with that and okay with you doing it and um we there's like a set of repeated requests that we get for wings SP spin ups and Dragons is one of them oh interesting from from fans yeah oh okay and that sort of makes sense to me because the when it was announced finally worms fan I was like first is this an April fo stroke and then second I'm going to buy this automatically so that was my my my first time impression um and that's amazing that jie thought like oh you know Connie is going to be a good match for this too and then you you two are both in the same game group play group you in the in that area yeah we're y we're both in the DC area and I know Elizabeth a few years ago started a really wonderful uh game design a group for game designers so we had I knew each other from that awesome awesome and so was it a lot of pressure to go into this wingspan world for you

Connie uh yeah absolutely I mean you know at this point in time I had designed apiary but AP wasn't quite done yet and I didn't have any published games and recognized that a spin-off sequel to you know one of the most popular Euro games of Our Generation Um by a relatively new designer by a female designer was going to certainly get a lot of uh attention um you know for both good and for ill and you know there's a lot of pressure to kind of keep up the brand name and everything and not to let Elizabeth down and not to let Jamie down so it was definitely there was definitely some thought that went into signing on onto the project I mean it's it's it was an opportunity that was too good to to give up for for any number of reasons but there is definitely a lot of I definitely had a lot of trepidation about it as well yeah and Elizabeth for you I you obviously you signed off on it and agreed to it but is was there a bit of you that's like oh I like I would have liked to have designed this game or made this game no I think Jamie knew not to even ask me oh really why why is that I mean I I am happy for dragon a dragon game to exist but I I have like no connection to the whole fantasy sci-fi genre at all yeah yeah and you know in the past we've talked about in your design sort of process a lot of like the theme really helps inform how

you design that game and so if you have you know dragons aren't real I get it so it' be hard to inform that for you too it's really interesting yeah yeah no and I I think also you know Jamie knows I have my hands full with the expansions for wings span and if he had had me work on this it would have delayed those even more so there's just so many birds out there so you know yeah and so like one one thing I love about worms span is how you know I definitely get the Same Spirit of wingspan in a lot of ways you know there's the same objectives per round you have um you know you're enticing these dragons and as you put these Dragon cards down you're getting a better engine all that stuff but there's like really key differences that I really appreciate to make it a very different game so you know the first thing was that sort of coin economy of like using coins for actions or also very expensive dragons was that an early sort of decision or did that come about later for you yeah that was actually pretty early on um so it was actually wors band was an originally conceptualized as a bag Builder where you were essentially building a bag of tokens and then you would draw out the tokens which would allow you to take different actions um including exploring your caves and we found two things one it didn't feel a lot like wingspan um but the other was it I think it probably ratcheted up the complexity level a little bit higher than we wanted it to go especially for a game that is you know supposed to be a little bit more approachable for new

Gamers I mean it's certainly supposed to be a little bit of a step up in complexity from wingspan but we didn't want to take it up three steps and it turned out that if you added a Jo engine building between the bag and the Tableau that was a lot and especially for people playing with newer Gamers were for kids um if you fell behind it was just uh that was the end and so we realized that we didn't want that uh really in the game so so the bag building came out pretty early on but that kind of more flexible coin and action economy was basically a hold over from that interesting and then uh obviously as you mentioned wingspan's one of the best in most popular games around uh what was the kind of directive either maybe self-imposed or from Jamie you know the founder of uh ston Meer to keep it similar to and familiar to wingspan players right like like how how how does that decision come about of like we wanted to feel this much like wingspan but we need to change this much that doesn't feel too much like wingspan I feel like that was the sort of intuition like how do you articulate that right and so it was I think that was one of my big roles working on the game was that Connie and I sort of met periodically and play tested together and went huh like it does that work and like had a lot of actually really interesting conversations about what makes something feel like wings band like what is the

core um you know and the going through your Tableau obviously is one of them but also sort of that feeling that no matter what you do you're moving your engine forward a little bit um so the way the mat Works in worm spin is pretty different from the structure of the mat in wingspan but it still has that fundamental thing that as you build stuff no matter what you put in the spaces on the mat as just so because you have built stuff on your mat you're getting access to more stuff um and so that was one of the things that we figured out that is like part of the Special Sauce of what's what makes something feel in the family and then there's so much other stuff going on in worm span that's different and the and the way you know the specifics of all of that even is quite different from wingspan but but the structure makes it feel related yeah this is a weird question but like Elizabeth if you had to say worms span is like a family related to wingspan how close of a family member would it be would it be like a sibling a cousin you know like what would you consider it that's a good question what do you think Connie sibling or cousin I'd say maybe like step sibling can we go like halfway in between okay okay I see that halfway in between no no blood relation

yeah there's half of a blood relation there's Elizabeth so there you go right yeah but oh sorry oh I was just going to say I mean I do think just to to really kind of emphasize what Elizabeth was saying is you know I think I do remember a couple times where she was like Connie this is interesting but this isn't wingspan like this doesn't feel like wingspan anymore and for a while we had the a very very different kind of math that you were building out um didn't look anything like the wingspan mat and I think that was really when it started feeling a lot like wingspan is when we basically made the worm Cav mat a lot more similar to the player mat in wingspan and that seemed all of a sudden at that point in time it kind of clicked and we were like oh okay this is starting to feel this is starting to to feel like it is you know kind of maybe the appropriate relationship um to wingspan and Connie did you get any I'm curious I have no idea like what it sounds like but just like I said our experience was from like our people we've talked to our circle of friends who are familiar with wingspan has heard about wingspan did you get a lot of uh any kind of heat about like hey you're ripping off wingspan and people don't understand that this was intentionally designed to be part of the same family I think my favorite was this was you know after it was first announced I think a lot of folks had a had a similar reaction to you guys which is like is this an April Fool's joke no wait it's January um I think my favorite though was a thread that somebody posted on BGG and it was titled something like will there be a lawsuit and basically and and the body of the the

thread was just does the designer of wings know about this like you know that you're ripping off that game or something like that and so I think there was a little bit of um you know that kind of stuff right at the beginning I think at this point in time there's enough copies of the game around and and you know there have been enough reviews that anyone who wants to know about worms span and you know has any kind of desire to actually find out the information it's it's there um I will say there is still a certain amount of skepticism and I think criticism coming from some of the heavier gamers in particular that that has been something that sort of come out um you know oh it's it's just a cash grab you know etc etc and it's like well there would have been easier ways to make it a cash grab without hiring someone and an artist and designing a whole new game um but I think some of that has to do more with sort of personal taste than anything you know I mean folks who didn't particularly like wingspan see this as a little bit more of a cash grab but I think there's a lot of an awful lot of folks who have been very very excited about it yeah there's like just even every single dragon card is unique and different and there's that's not a quick fun little like thing you can do out of nowhere no of course not um I think anyone who's who's obviously spent a lot of time you know spends any time thinking about it sort of knows it it's not we just didn't you know we didn't just pull it out of thin air it's not something that we just kind of willed into being and then all of a sudden it it existed it's a much more complicated process than that and I'm super nering out but like I do love the dragon handbook that you have and there's like

really fun little notes about each Dragon like you know I for now I'm not nerdy enough to remember which Dragon it was but you can summon it with an amulet but it finds it extremely offensive when you do and so I really like that the little flavor there did you write all of those did you have a group of people writing all these descriptions like how did this happen uh so I enlisted some friends and family for assistance um you know I thought I was doing pretty well and then I realized I was at like 35 or 40 and I was like oh no these are all St to sound the same especially because I tend to come at it from a you know I have a science background and so I tend to come at it from that and so they sound you know like like real facts you know as if the dragons lived in the real world and then I was like wait a second these are all there's only so many fake dragon facts I can make up about their diet um so I enlisted a bunch of sort of friends and family and then spent some time spent some time reconciling them but I think it was a much much easier I think this was a much easier task than coming up with the actual the real bird facts in in wingspan and its expansions I think I think this was the easier task of the two by far yeah I I think there's pres definitely being able to make up the dragons is easier cuz you can just make the characteristics all line up and like the way you just in the right count of every characteristic crossed in all the right ways um but I don't know for that for the facts feel like bird I have to go find them but they're out there instead of making them up from scratch I I I I would think for bird

facts it'd be tough to decide which fact to put on to the card it depends on the bird depends on the bird some birds don't have a lot of interesting stuff going on are there uh were there any sort of uh media influences uh for the some of the Dragons whether it's story background or their powers or anything like that so not exactly so we really tried to I mean at you know full disclosure I'm a huge Science Fiction and Fantasy nerd um so kind of ask you those those influences soon too gu sure absolutely um but we tried to sort of set worm Span in its own kind of unique World um you know it was it was not obviously going to be an IP game I mean the thought of getting you know 200 Dragon IPS I would guess that as an insurmountable task um so we tried to kind of almost build it from the ground up I mean as if it was kind of its own world it's the world of you know worth spelled w yr t h in which dragons sort of evolved just like our present day mammals or present day Birds did um and so kind of built out that lore um but obviously you know there's a lot of references I mean there's you know Waddles and ampop teers and wyverns and worms and dragons and Fay dragons and there's a million other types of actual dragons that are you know pulled from lore um but we kind of tried to make them a little bit unique so how do you I was curious amphib teers like you do pronounce the P I don't know so I was wondering when I saw those cards so it's like I think it's quasi a silent PE and this is where like you're going to get comments being like Oh my God she doesn't know anything about dragons this

is one of those words that is written a lot more than it is perhaps spoken yes cuz I don't say that every day yeah right right um I I think it's like mostly a silent PE but I always put like a syllable break there but that just might be my own my own weird spin on it it's been so interesting to me that people are like nitpicking at Connie's Dragon lore they're fake don't know what to tell you well I was going to say speaking of that we've gotten a couple of those comments and I think one is we've gotten the Box Dragon isn't a dragon and that is because in you know the kind of um most strict European Cannon a dragon has four legs and two Wings the dragon on the cover of worms span is actually a wyvern um but some people are like that's not a dragon and I'm like well if you want to say it's not a worm that's a semi Fair criticism but if you want to say it's not a dragon I don't know I have a hard time with that one the other one um we've gotten a lot of comments on is Dragon Milk um you know dragons are reptiles they're not mammals they wouldn't produce they're also fake and also wanted a resource it was going to really kind of shortcut the idea that it was used for the young and so milk kind of works out well with that but also my kind of response is that if you have like a warm-blooded giant flying creature it's going to need a heck of a lot of nutrients so if you think about it from like an evolutionary standpoint it's not insane to me that they would have evolved something kind of similar way to get their young those kind of nutrients but anyway I will get off I will get off mix boxs now no I like that Soap Box first of all and

then the hatchlings I just want to point out they're super adorable so sometimes I get a hatchling just cuz it's really cute they're they're very cute um are there any like one more like fun story of the development that you thought was like really interesting while working on it or like about worms span not a not a fun story but I will just say that really to emphasize how key Elizabeth was with all of this too I mean in really keeping the boat on the correct and I think really hitting that you know one of the the best pieces of feedback that I think I've gotten about worms span is that it seems like we really hit that balance well of it feels like wingspan it feels like an homage to wingspan but it also feels like its own game and I give credit for that like 98% to Elizabeth cuz I think she was really kind of steering that ship as I feel that completely actually making any of the game but the steering I think is important okay I we had some conversations But Connie made the whole thing be clear about that okay okay yeah the biggest thing that like sometimes I hear is like oh is it just wingspan with dragons and I just can't say no enough basically after I played that game um it's it feels like it so people will feel it's familiar when you're playing it but it is it's definitely its own game and I could see very different cases for playing either one of them depending on you know what we're in the mood for who I'm playing

with and um I still I still love both of them so I'm so excited thank you for making it oh of course we do want to leave time to talk about your topic also so what is your topic Connie and Elizabeth today um I for I this came up because we just got back from my favorite event of the year I I love unpub happens in the Baltimore suburbs every March what is it maybe 150 game designers come and play test their games and it's open to the public so we get lots of people that come just to play all of these unpublished games um it's now become like a 4 day long thing there's a couple days worth of seminars on like Thursday and Friday and then it opens up to the public for play testing and um it's a place that we get a lot of work done but also like it's just awesome to see what other people are working on and to hang out with other designers um outside of the context of like the big cons where it's crazy and a lot of us are working at booths if we've got a game coming out or something and so like this is just a much more chill opportunity to really uh get to know other designers and and maybe influence the next big game it's an event that I definitely play tested wingspan at for a

couple years before it came out so did you either of you play test any of your games you don't have to tell me if you can't but uh just if you had any there uh I took a game that I threw together because I had reserved a table at unpub months ago and then realized that I needed something to take and I've been working on a wingspan expansion at this point I don't take wingspan expansions because ston Meer is so secretive about what's coming out and it's this venue is a little large to keep secrets in um so I put together a little game that's about um walking down the beach and collecting seashells and there are tiles that you have to put in a bag um so there it's like a tile placement sort of tety uh thing with things falling down into your bag and and uh I don't it worked better than I anticipated so I'm kind of excited about it and are are you testing game games that generally aren't signed yet yeah it's mostly unsigned but there are Publishers that will come and and play just stuff they haven't development it's a real mix there's people that are like just about to go to Kickstarter with something but then there's people like me that bring something that they made a week ago it was actually sort of cool though I was play testing a game it was actually it was a really great game it was sort of an ant um almost like a tableau building worker placement Hive building game where your workers aged over the course of the game so no familiar but it was it was a very very different game than apiary but um it had

some obviously some similar mechanisms um I thought it was a really brilliant game it was a very early stage but when I was playing it we actually had a one of the cge folks sit down and was very interested and asking the designer lots of questions so I think there's definitely some Publishers who are there you know going around to the table sort of seeing what's out there testing the waters and stuff so I think it's just an absolutely absolutely wonderful event and you know I hate the dreaded networking word but it is an awfully good place to do that in a very kind of chill relaxed environment um and it's always been very very welcoming I mean I've been showing up for a few years now and everyone's always been incredibly incredibly nice and welcoming so it's very wonderful event are ants going to be the new bees maybe see there are a few ant games out there now I don't know if I've how many of them I've played but I'm I'm excited for this one I'm really really hoping this one goes somewhere is is unpub your favorite also Connie or do you have another event that you like actually so this is going to sound a little bit shallow of me but I think my favorite event is actually Gen Con and I think there's a certain amount of nostalgia there as the first of these events that I ever went to but there's a big part of me that also I just love the glitz and the Glamour and the giant Hall and the hustle and bustle and you know the big connected network of hotels um and I think for me and know this is going to sound silly because a lot of people criticize us about Tenon I actually really like how well scheduled it is in the sense that like I can go ahead of time and sign up for all right I know Saturday at 10:00 Saturday at 1:00 Saturday at 4:00 I'm going to have these three games to play these are games that have been on my list of games

to play for a long time they'll be set up someone will be teaching them you know here's a new hotness you can go demo whatever games are being released the flavor of the month and I think there's just something about that like I don't know the glitz and the glamour that I really enjoy so that's probably my pick although I unpub is absolutely wonderful and I'll give a little bit of a shout out to paxu as well which is another wonderful event what about what about you guys to be on the other side of the glitz and glamour this August I know yeah I I'm going to I'm guessing I'm going to like that less to be honest with you we're also specting that but we'll see we'll see is it like what's the from your point of view I Connie I don't know if you had enough experience with this yet but uh like say unpub demoing an incomplete game and sort of getting feedback on it and kind of gauging people's reactions versus demoing something that's pretty much finished and you're just trying to sell the game as oppos it like what's that kind of difference in terms of like the energy your excitement about doing those kind of demos what's the difference so yeah so the thing is that at a place like unpub you basically do you know a full play test or you know sometimes you'll do a round of a game or something like that and so you kind of you're on for maybe a 10 or 15 minute period where you teach the game and then you kind of sit back and relax for an hour or so while people play um at pxu last fall that was right after um aary had come out um I was working the booth um big big shout out to my partner David who was there with me and it was one of the most exhausting things I've ever done in my life um because we were demoing doing

basically a talk through on repeat every 3 minutes for the entire time that we were there and about halfway through your voice starts going out and then it just keeps going and keeps going and keeps going um so that for me was was much much more difficult I know Elizabeth if you had the same experience I haven't had to demo my own game that much oh really okay yeah um because wingspan got so big that they decided I would be better off just signing games it was very weird and that's fun I love games that's easy yeah easier than talking every get to meet all the people that are playing your game they're already convinced that they like it as opposed to like demoing where you're like trying to convince someone to like your game yeah oh that's a good point yeah they're all already it's like a pre-selected audience that lik your prodct yeah that's great I think it's just so funny though because I totally get what Connie is saying about the glitz and glamour of Gen Con but it's still a board game convention so like Glitz and glamour is like very different relative relative right exactly I guess that's why I've never been to Essence so I always feel like oh I wonder what that's it's even bigger than Gen Con and Gen Con is like the biggest thing to me right now so um I know Shu agrees with you on Gen Con that's his favorite event right you yeah I I def same as ukani were a little bit of a uh uh like just fondness because

that was one of our first big conventions so I always have some fondness for it um I think the more we've done this like going analog and the more uh companies reach out to us to have meetings to have to do demos uh the less I kind of like it like I I appreciate we definitely appreciate like publishers reaching out and wanting to meet with us and show us games and things like that uh and so we're we're fortunate you know uh for that we're appreciative with that but it's also like I love Gen Con when before we were doing content we're just going for fans uh no work obligations whatsoever so we're just free to do whatever we want like whatever caught our fancy uh I love the feeling of walking up and down the exhibit aisles and I'm just like uh that game looks interesting I I don't know what it is never heard of it it just the visually caught my eye something about it caught my eye or uh I'll hear someone talk about a give an elevator pitch and I'm like oh that sounds interesting let's sit down and do a 10-minute demo and just to kind of get a taste of what this game is about and we've also had experiences where I'm like I was really looking forward to this game and we did the demo I'm like I now don't want to buy that game because that was way different than what I imagined in my head but I I love that kind of experience of just getting a little taste of a million different things and then kind of figuring out what you might want to buy what you might want to play later with your group or you start thinking like oh this friend will really like this game and oh I this group will really like this game I can't wait to bring it back and I just love that

energy and then um so Gen Con is definitely my favorite game I I also like that it's in a downtown of like a a decent sized city that so there's like a lot of restaurants you can go to uh interconnected hotels that are exciting well if you're lucky enough to get one of those hotels too yeah yeah this year we're like out airport so we got an unlucky draw for the hotels but yeah I I love that energy and then uh and then we always come back uh from Gen Con with at least 25 to 30 games so we bring a giant uh empty suitcase with us and fill up each have our own empty suitcase on top of our regular one so it's an issue but I know that's not your favorite con you like it yeah but your favorite con Christina um I actually like BGG Con in uh fall in D Dallas yes it's in Dallas area um for me I feel like it strikes a really good balance between um being a con with events that you can attend and panels and uh you know a pretty small exhibitor floor but you know sort of fun you can wander that a little bit and mainly it just feels like board gaming summer camp to me where I get to go everything's in the hotel you know I play until whatever time I want and then go to sleep and wake up and repeat um and we I also really really love the past few years we've been hosting our board game quiz show live sort of like a pub trivia thing and I was just telling Elizabeth before we started that um my club trivia

team made our state championships in our division this year so I just finished that and I did not win but I love Pub trivia so I like being able to to host that for other people too so um I like I like the vibe of Bon it's chill um and we have some friends from you know the East Coast that come and you know we come from the West Coast so it's sort of semi in the middle and there's barbecue so I like barbecue yeah definitely I am much more suited to the size of BGG con than Jen like I find Gen Con just too huge um but yeah BG con I love that you can just go like literally just play game after game after game out of the library yeah I think this year was I started a three-player four uh three-player game with the Marine world's expansion of Ark Nova at 12:30 in the morning so which people were questioning but I do not regret it so I had a free time Connie have you been to B no I haven't but you know I've heard similar takes from a lot of a lot of folks now so I think we definitely have to add it add it to the rotation I'd really like to check it out yeah that's that's a very close second for me uh for the reasons Christina said be cuz you can still at Gen Con after your the exhibitor hall closes uh after dinner you still have plenty of opportunities to play games like every hotel has rooms open up for you the the hall itself at Gen Con they

open up halls but you're you're generally more exhausted where B con is just like very relaxed you're just like take your time stroll downstairs you're you're at the you usually are staying at that hotel and they have such the biggest library I've ever seen um I I like Dice Tower West as well uh mainly because it's closer to us we could drive to it in Vegas uh so it's about 4 hours away from us we could sell a bunch of games there and be able to drive those games there to sell and then um and it's Vegas which has its own energy in itself right like of like places to go eat uh places to stay out late and and party or drink or like we have friends who who like gambling and such uh so it's like a very more party environment but uh B kind I definitely really really love just because it's like it depends what I'm in a mood for if I'm like I just want to hang out with my friends I don't want all I don't want to do anything else but just play games B con is the best for me and I feel like um someone brought up paxu PA unplugged uh I've been to that as well I I do like that because it's in uh Philadelphia there's a lot of good places to eat nearby uh and it's I feel like if you can only go you want some of Gen Con you want some of B con PX you is probably somewhere in between I don't think it does either as well um but if you want like I want a fairly big exhibitor Hall it's not big quite as big it's nowhere as big as gen con's but it has a decent sized exhibitor hall and then uh lots of places to play games as well so it's sort of in between those

two I think haven't been yeah and yes the I think the big thing is I I just can't not go to Gen Con I think I don't know I think we're too much of the early adopters and want to know the new things uh so we're always there so yeah hard not to get a little bit caught up into that too especially I think as a designer too I'm always like oh what's the new hotness what are people playing what does everyone like what are the trends you know um yeah but yeah one day I really hope to make it to Essen too I mean just to just is kind of a bucket list item I mean just to you know sort of see the OG OG giant con um out there but not this year but maybe some year have you been to Essen Elizabeth yes yeah I went in 2019 oh the yes and so what can you tell us about it cuz we are all just curious you know how't been um it's a if the exhibitor hall feels like gen kind but bigger spread across multiple Halls um it is harder to sit down and play a game has been my experience there's no open play area Okay um and the publisher booths are generally demos where you're not playing sometimes they they're playing a full game it really depends but because that's the only way to play games there's a lot of demand for the tables at all the publisher booths if a game has any notoriety at all um so I find it really hard to play games I pulled rank

at one publisher I love hearing this so tell us what happened yes well it's just like I went and introduced myself to the guys working the booth and like found the the owner of the company and was like I really wanted to check out this game and he was like oh you're checking out this game that was rewarding but I try not to abuse that too much other people want to play the games too just here and there here and there I think you you're allowed to do such a thing like we don't sense a big ego coming from you Elizabeth so don't worry the final one I wanted to talk about briefly was just we did we did do uh one of the Tokyo game markets when we were in Japan last year and that was fascinating too um it was a lot of very small small games people de like demonstrate like demoing their own games that they've made um a lot of really quirky interesting stuff obviously language was a bit of an issue for us cuz we are not Japanese but you know for the one for people who could sort of describe the game or we could look at it or they had some English instructions um it was really fascinating I bought this tiny little game called n code um and it was this little cat programming game where you had to like program your moves out for your cat to get the golden fish and then take it back to your your house but along the way a truck randomly spilled a

bunch of tires and so you have to watch out for the tires along the way and everything was just so fun and fascinating and people were like just really really welcoming at that show too we had a really good time there yeah yeah there were a lot of games that like oh this looks really cute I if like if there's no English instructions we're kind of like H I don't know if we can really play this game but uh you look for the games that look like they're simple enough and they have some English in them that we could kind of work our work itself out but yeah that was a cool show yeah we also went in the wrong line like three times and took forever to get in there but anyway that's our problem we know better now uh but thanks so much for joining us we had so much fun talking with you today um and I would love to know you know where can people follow you what uh if there anything that we can look forward to that you can talk about we'd love to hear it um what about you Connie where can people follow you again yeah sure so I'm uh at Connie VDC on both uh Twitter and blue sky and not particularly active on either though I am trying yeah and there's not um really anything that I could talk about um right now but you know hoping to hoping to design many more games exciting I will definitely be paying attention to that and you Elizabeth um I have a website Elis Hargrave decom El iow grave.com um and and your newsletter and right you that's sort of there's a link to my blue sky into my

newsletter and to the form for requesting wingspan birds and all kinds of different things on there are there ways to request dragons Connie I don't know work on that guess I guess I have I have some homework mhm um thanks for listening to all of our listeners you know give us a rating if you can and definitely check out worms span cannot tell you how much fun we had with that recently um and something's happening sounds like a cat's like destroying things in the B no it's actually my automated cat feeder that goes off at 9:00 so I'm sorry about that ah which means you get the food and then you get the cat scrambling to go get the food um our editor Mike Zipkin is the best ever of course and we promise we are working on season five of the boram quiz show right Shu yeah it's it's all set but I just uh having trouble getting one of the guests to kind of get her schedule nailed down so okay um now you can stop listening and go play a game everybody bye bye bye all

Progress saved