Mastering Expansion: How to Transform Your Board Game into a Full-Fledged Product Range
Transcript
the goal of this video series has been to explore product design principles and see how they could assist us as board game makers so we've covered topics like design thinking empathizing with our customer creating customer journey maps onboarding executing our products effectively and much more and in this video we're going to be looking at the growth of a product
i'm adam porter i'm the inventor of the games picoco throne doodle rush big bazaar compromise quasal and zuligans and a great commercial product grows with its user the experience becomes richer and deeper as they explore all the different features in the product use of the product becomes habitual before long the user can't imagine life without it for a board game maker this raises a dilemma we want rich experiences we want our games to be played over and over revealing hidden depths but we know that when it comes to securing a sale that first playthrough of our game is everything at a board game convention a player will give the game one shot if it doesn't hold interest they'll move on watching a video review online the viewer will tune out if they're not hooked by the gameplay within seconds and if the player has a bad experience when they get the game home they're unlikely to give it a second chance and you can be sure that their friends aren't going to be going out and buying their own copy so how much of our hidden depth do we reveal on that first outing how much do we hold back can we hint that the pleasures contained within without immediately putting it all out there this is our full experience this is where we know the players are going to feel the most fulfilled where they're going to be able to pull all the levers turn the knobs push the cubes and explore but is a new player prepared for all that will they be overwhelmed could it actually put them off playing again a newcomer is really ready for what your game has to offer some games are uncompromising it's all or nothing it's
going to take five to ten plays to get to grips with the game and if you haven't got the patience well too bad you can play something else but most games try to be a little bit more welcoming to new players they feature alternate strategies which may not end up being the most powerful but they're easy to grasp perhaps the game has a catch-up mechanism to prevent new players from falling too far behind perhaps it takes a few games to really get the full experience but at least in those games in the interim you're going to have a really pleasant introductory experience some games feature alternate modes of play perhaps some beginners rules to ease players into the experience i really like this approach isle of cats does a really great job of it it's got a fantastic proper game as i call it and a really good beginner's game as well some games introduce the full game over a series of modules one rule at a time as an aside i personally find this approach a little bit frustrating i'm never really sure what level of game i should be playing should i go with no modules just the base game or should i incorporate a single module or should i use all of them or will that be too much if you're designing a game in this manner you'd better be ensuring that your focus is on every single version of the game if your game only truly shines at the full experience well how many players are you losing at each preparatory game along the way many of the best board games get deeper the more you play them you familiarize yourself with the strategies and the card combinations and each new session throws up a new variation to challenge yourself
with some games achieve this by using different selections of cards boards or differing objectives in each game a relatively small number of alternate modes of play creates a huge number of possible combinations and experiences but some games offer a deep enough strategic challenge each game that they're extremely replayable even with an identical setup in every game yinch is very replayable because your skill level is going to improve every time you play there's always a new challenge we should remember of course that a game which is being played over and over again isn't directly generating fresh income for the game maker but if a game is being played it's probably being talked about both in person and online new players are being introduced to the game and they might buy their own copy and introduce it to more people chasing that stellar first run through might drive an initial surge of sales but if the game is not fun to play many times over then the success will soon falter once someone's hooked on a product commercial entities need to ensure that they have more products available for that user to purchase mobile phone companies revamp their phones on a regular basis making the old versions obsolete and ensuring that hooked customers keep on buying subscription services such as software and apps become so central to consumers lives that they'll keep on paying even if prices rise this might all feel a little bit grim to a board game designer we're creative people generally we're not hugely money
oriented and to be honest if you are motivated by profit the board game business is not an obvious path to take there are probably easier ways to make your millions nonetheless there are parallels to these business practices in the board game industry most notably in the world of collectible card games and miniature games and board game expansions collectible card games such as magic the gathering and pokemon also known as ccgs are games where you gather cards to create your own personal deck before the game commences and then face off against an opponent the marketing ploy is that generally you purchase the cards in small sealed booster packs and you don't know what you're buying some of the cards are rarer and more powerful than others and when you rip open a pack to randomly reveal one of these desirable cards the accompanying dopamine rush drives you to make more similar purchases in the future oh and they're also great games or so i'm told i really don't have very much experience here miniatures games such as warhammer and x-wing are similar in that players build their own army pre-game constructed from the models that they've purchased over months or years these games don't generally feature the blind purchases seen in collectible card games but the purchasing habit is cultivated by a constant stream of new releases often the newer models are more powerful than those that have gone before encouraging the purchasers to keep on buying to keep up with their opponents miniatures games and ccgs are often called lifestyle games because
players often devote all of their hobby time and money to a single game rather than playing a wide range of different titles like many board gamers do now i don't know how viable it is creating a collectible card game in the 2020s i'm no expert here so please let me know in the comments if you have any insight on this topic but my experience extends to collecting a fairly mediocre collection of star wars destiny cards and dice a game which i've only ever played with my friend tom and a game that i don't think i've ever won but my perception is that unless you're already an industry heavyweight or you have access to a huge intellectual property from movies or video games then you're unlikely to make any sort of headway with ccgs i'm a little bit more experienced with miniatures games although i'm still very much a dabbler i played a lot of warhammer 40k a number of years ago and i've recently built a small silvernet army for age of sigma playing these games has opened my eyes to the huge number of other miniature games on the market the lesser known titles i see players playing these and talking about them but i have no idea how easy it is to have a commercial success creating a lesser-known miniatures game perhaps there are loads of minor ccgs out there too which i'm just not aware of but are doing just fine thank you very much all of this is a precursor to something which i do know about and that's board game expansions i'm a sucker for an expansion and i do mean sucker because the expansions that i purchase and i purchase a lot they rarely get played it's rare that i come across an expansion which genuinely improves the
game experience for me expansions present another dilemma for a designer how much focus should be on expansions when you're designing the base game now i don't know the answer to this and i'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments i certainly wouldn't suggest spending too much time on the expansion design before the base games approach in publication but equally leaving scope for expansions is just good business sense so it ought to be floating around somewhere in your head expansions are a tricky concept if we return to our earlier graphic what does the expansion achieve does it enhance the game offering the players the full experience if so then why weren't you offering that in the base game giving players a lackluster initial experience just so you can hold back expansion material isn't good business does the expansion take the full experience and complicate it with more strategies and avenues to explore as designers we all know less is more streamlining is often better than adding complexity and if you've genuinely created the optimum experience in your basic game why are you risking tarnishing the experience with expansion bloat or does the expansion simply offer a different experience more variety maybe additional cards for me these are the best sort of expansions they offer a similarly full experience but in a slightly different flavor of course there may also be logistical reasons for an expansion perhaps producing a five to six player base game wasn't financially viable the expansion could rectify that with additional components
perhaps the expansion offers upgraded components or additional material that was just too expensive to include in that base game of course some board games are built around expansions from the outset fantasy flight refers to their expandable card games as living card games where players can purchase new expansion packs of cards on a regular basis the packs are not randomized like in ccgs but they're similarly desirable and players are incentivized to collect all the expansions to keep up with the other players i think this model gets to the crux of the issue i've already confessed that i buy a lot of expansions which rarely get played it's stupid isn't it and i think the reason i do it is because i love the games buying expansions gives me the thrill of discovering the games all over again a new box new components new artwork with a hefty slice of nostalgia an alternate route to expansions for a publisher is to produce a new addition of an old game with revised rules enhanced artwork and components and this might be just the thing to make your game relevant again and to allow it to compete with the rapidly changing aesthetic of modern board games or some game makers produce sequels to their earlier titles and these games tend to have related settings and similar gameplay to the original game with significant enough changes to motivate owners of the original game to dip into their wallet once more i think sometimes this can prove confusing for purchases two or three very similar games from the same publisher with similar artwork and a
similar setting presents your potential customer with a dilemma which game should i buy i don't want to make the wrong decision which one's better this one can be played with six players but this one has a solo mode this one costs five pounds more but has a prettier box this one contains six expansion modules but will i ever play them i don't want to waste my money nobody needs this sort of stress in their life and i mean you might get lucky they might buy both but i think it's just as likely they're going to look at your confusing games and walk on by to find a game that they can get their head around now i'm not sure there are easy answers to any of this there certainly isn't one approach which is going to work for everyone but i do want to try and leave you with some actionable messages so here's my brief summary make sure your board game makes an outstanding first impression but make sure that it also continues to surprise and delight with subsequent plays give some thought to expansion potential but don't waste time creating expansions before the base game is even complete you could also consider whether your game might work as a range of games but again don't get ahead of yourself publishers are going to want to see your base game being successful before they start thinking about sequels i hope some of this has been of use to you please do take a look at some of the other videos on my channel hit like and subscribe and speak to me in the chat the comments are my favorite bits about making these videos so do indulge me stop by and say hello and until next time all the best