Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Witcher: Path of Destiny - Discussion

Transcript 26:51

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. and Brian and I are doing a discussion over the Witcher Path of Destiny designed by the one, the only Lucas Votnak, which I probably butchered that last name. I think it's just Wasnjnak. It's it I I some for some reason don't think it's Wniaak. That's what he says. No, no, he's that's he's saying it for the American people. He's like, you guys wouldn't get it otherwise. Uh but yeah, this is a his other Witcher game cuz he designed the other bigger um Old World. What? Wer Old World. Yeah. Which is set years before the events of the one that the video games follow. Uh which I thought was a relatively good game. Probably the his better design out of every game of his I've played.

Uh now he says this is the best Witcher game created. So, so he must hate his other one, which is which is weird. Um, this is, you know, at some point we we got to we got to band together and just not let people get away with it. You can't keep getting away with it. This game is so painfully painfully mediocre that it's it's almost I think it's a troll. It's a troll game. It has to be. This one is is it's almost like you know what you know what it is AI.

This is ChattB Chat TBT designed this game. There is no way a human being put effort into making it. Now, I'm obviously I'm being exaggeratory because to be fair, I don't like any of his designs. This is not a designer for any of his games. Just But like I just do not enjoy I still enjoy it's not my favorite game in the world, but my favorite game by him still is Valhalla. When was the last time you touched that game? A couple years ago, but I mean it's still my favorite game I've played with. His better one is the other Witcher game. Uh, and even that game is a bloated uh, mess. Uh, this one is just it's set collection. It's it's symbol matching the game with the most pasted on theme that I have seen. Uh, it it does nothing with the source material except, oh, there's Geralt, Dandelion, and the cards have art from them. that honestly could have just been purely ripped from the video game and with a with a a watercolor filter on the and the reason why I'm saying this feels like AI designed it is because the writing is serviceable but it feels like the rings of power to the Lord of the Rings where it's like there's no heart or soul behind it.

Well, and I think and this may be giving them more credit, but they're trying to fit the story onto these little bit of cards, too. So, they're probably trying to cut a bunch, you know, like cuz the books, have you ever read any of the books? I've read the first one. They're very um indepth and stuff. So, I mean, so I'm not concerned about the writing as much just because they're trying to fit it on those cards through that whole book gimmick. Yeah. And it's like it's it's like you're the whole game is you are literally playing two cards in front of you. Draft two, play two. Yeah. Draft two, play two to put in front to get symbols to make to either have the most of one side and depending on which one has the most is where the story goes.

And whichever side has the most, you get victory points for that. And then the other side you don't have the most of. You get XP which unlocks whatever abilities that there like whenever you were doing one of them I was like that's so cool. Like they these abilities are so lame. And it's like oh what was your final one? Cuz mine says during playing cards phase you can play an additional card to your timeline then draw a card from the main deck. So I mean I may have three cards I guess if you were trying to do something. was lose one active symbol of the type I have more of to gain three active symbols of your of of uh three active symbols you currently have fewer of. So, I turn in a sword to get three magic, right? But that's literally it. Every single chapter you're you're competing between two symbols and then everyone gets points for that. You might get more than them and then you get XP which unlocks a onetime ability and then potentially victory points at the end. Rinse, repeat that for three chapters. It was a really fast game. It is a really fast game. I will give the guys stop it that you know uh I said this earlier. I mean this timeline we we played another game before this. Yeah. That was a game that we didn't really have it was very minor setup, very easy light setup, but we actually got a lot of gameplay out of it. Yeah. And stuff. This is the exact opposite. Yeah, there's a lot of stuff out here, but the game play was way smaller than it need than it was supposed to be. It's an overlo over

stuff of it's just a simple like this didn't even need to really It could just been a deck of cards and and stuff to just toss stuff out and play a simple game. Yeah. I mean, that's the thing. It's like in terms of presentation, it's nice. Components are nice. Uh the boards are nice. Like I mean I'm not going to knock him on any of that, but yeah, you have a a bigger than necessary box for a game that is way too short and offers there's zero depth to this. The the the abilities on the cards are so whatever. Oh, have one blue banner in your timeline. Get three XP. Boo. Well, in the I think the theme of it is weird because it's like he had the IP indirectly, right? But the indirectly what it is is because this if this would have been a more difficult cooperative game where you we're working together. This is a lot tougher of a situation up here. None of that crap where we actually there's more interaction. Yeah, that would be something. But having this as a competitive game for one and it's kind of like you're seeing who the best storyteller is. That's that's really what it is.

That's the that's is you're and and that's odd to me. Like I I bought I I I'm the idiot that this game and yeah, thank God I didn't I didn't buy put money into it and I backed it cuz it's Witcher and you know and I I go on board made it and I was like well I was like I'm going to give it a shot. It was a card game. It wasn't super super expensive. I was like, I'm just going to go for it and see what happens. I didn't I went into it without looking. I assumed it was going to be a co-op co-op game. Yeah. You know, and then when I started seeing stuff, I got it. I'm like, oh, it's competitive and it just didn't I that just didn't hit with me. And then you're telling the best story and it's like it's weird. It's like you're sitting around a campfire telling stories. Nope. Dandelion said that better. He's the winner. Yeah.

This feels like that he was commissioned by Steey Project Red and he had to he had to scramble to come up with another game. Um because the other the Witcher the old world is competitive as well which I al also thought was kind of weird but you're from different schools. Witchers in the in the lore conflict in the lore. Yeah, they do because it it's like oh we we got to make money so it kind of made sense and and every now and then they'd fight each other. So it made some like that game was more solid especially with its card play. This game could have relatively worked. You nix the stupid [ __ ] narrative part that is like king's dilemma whatever of oh the symbol went that way and then oh I just happen to have the mo the most of that symbol so I get a slight benefit into the next chapter that is again mediocre but like if the card abilities were really cool where it mattered almost like a far away kind of like time that's what I was going to compare it to like if these compounded that way because from chapter you get to keep some, but the only cards that matter are the ones you play that turn, except for symbols.

I think it would be cool personally. I mean, it would change the whole way that worked, but it would almost be cool if you were leaving them face down like and then you revealed your story and like you play all six and fire off like this fires off and that way you don't know who's ahead on this until until the end, you I mean that would be because the other problem right now I'm seeing and you were running away with one so I'm just going to you know try to do the other end. And that's kind of the problem is the way that the game works is if one person is really ahead on one side. Now to be fair it's not that it's not how many of a symbol you have, it's just your majority. So if you're playing multiple people, it's like let's it's like I have more swords. That's one towards swords, you have more magic. The the other person has more magic. And then you know two more people he plays a five. I don't know if it goes up. I think it goes up to four. It might be five, but it's majority of the symbols is what lean is what leans the the story. Um, I mean, I will say at least you're not completely hosed. You still get XP. Uh, you get something if you don't win out on the side, but you win by you win by um victory points. So, the XP, it's not necessarily a catch-up mechanism except for the end of the game where you might get some victory points depending on how far you go, but I find the abilities extremely lame. Uh the the the whole portion of the the timeline element gets scrapped. All all tokens

you gain get scrapped. And then you don't even have the excitement of like, you know, a means to an end where it's like, okay, the gameplay is kind of whatever, but the writing is really good. It's a quick blurb of whatever depending on which which book you picked. Like we just played the Strgo one and it's like, yeah, there are choices. I guess you can replay it and but but in compet and that's my problem with narrative driven I guess I narrative driven is very loose but competitive games did you ever play my father's work? I owned it but I never play it. Okay. So that game uh had kind of a similar thing. You picked a scenario and then there were a bunch of different decisions that could be made um to alter the way the story went. The problem was if you wanted a different outcome of that game, you had to either play suboptimally to make different decisions so the narrative went a different way. So when it's competitive, it's like, well, do I want the story to go a certain way or do I want to win?

And some people might be like, well, winning is not everything. It's like, I understand that, but to appreciate and respect the game, you should be competitive. Well, and that's what because there's Lucas puts a lot of videos out on this and the one deal he was talking he was, you know, talking about replayability and he said he played I don't know which one of these books like over a hundred times and still is fresh. I'm like now that I've played it, I was like there's only so many branches you can do. It's like I I don't know how you would like even if we went the left and even a totally opposite. It's like just a handful of plays and you're going to know everything. They are literally It's like no, it's not fresh. It's the writing's on the wall. It's Oh, do you in this case, do you kill the stria or do you cure it? Oh, man. Do you what?

Investigate like the the bookshelf or or interrogate one of the guys? No. Like that? He is a fantastic salesman. That guy it seems to be like just what what could could what's the saying? Could sell you the shirt off your own back. Easic suits. Huh? He can sell iced Eskimos. Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. Because somehow he's getting games published and I don't I mean his next game is Tekken. Yeah. Which I mean, funny enough, I follow a YouTuber who is big on like the fighting game scene and the whole Tekken community is like awful because apparently the Tekken 8 patches are terrible. I don't even play Tekken. Out of all the fighting games, Tekken is the one I played the least of. Um, and I this one blows my mind. Well, and and you know there's a lot of stuff came with this. So there was there's the stretch goals box has I think three more three or four more stories in it. Some more gameplay there. It has more characters. Mhm. Some charact There some most characters you'll recognize. Um I would imagine it it's mainstay characters. It is. It is. There's And then um but then there's the uh legendary creatures box and I'm haven't really looked at to see how that's used cuz they're they're big monster miniatures.

Okay. So, I don't know if they're just to sit by the book or I don't I don't know. I haven't really Do we fight the stria? No. Well, and then there is the uh I think the one that's the most intriguing to me, which is the one I'll probably do next, will be the um the Wild Hunt box because it has its own little playmat and its own little stuff. And um I'm curious if that's turns it I'm almost wondering if that turns a co-op, turns into a campaign. Well, no. I mean, I'm just wondering like because the Wild Hunt everybody's fighting against Yeah. You know, so I'm almost wondering if that ch I don't know, but it has its own they have their own boards. They have Yeah. You know, all this stuff. So, I'm I'm going to try that one out just to see what the Wild Hunt does. So, the only There was one other little expansion was like a ghost ship, like a ship. Remember the ship that the Wild Hunt used like whatever that was called? It started with an inn.

Um, but that will let it go. That lets the Wild Hunt enter other scenarios. somehow. So, so we'll see. The old world, the base game of that one, um, made the monsters pretty much exactly identical. Yeah. But there was an expansion to that one that gave them like a large sheet like you were just talking about that made fighting them actually like have their own AI deck and made the combat of fighting the the because that's one of the big things about the Witcher is, hey, I'm going to go fight a lean. It's a whole big deal and it fights differently than a stria. Um, that would be the only thing that would make that fresh if it integrates any type of combat into this game. To be fair, we only have played the base game. Yes. But, and I knew going in I I I will be completely honest, I didn't even really try to give this a pass. I I knew that I have played enough of his games that to know that it it I stay far away from it of any design that it has his name on it or the go on board publishing. I'm like nope. I'll play them because I need games of the year to play. Yeah. Uh but I will never give them money. I don't care what IP it is.

Um, in fact, if it's an IP I adore, which I love, The Witcher, uh, it's just going to make me mad. Like, if he was like, I'm making a Bloodborne game, I'd probably like sue like, no, no. Actually, that's the one silver lining. Sony would never let them. But yeah, it it would just it would make me so mad to watch his design touch any any IP that I absolutely loved. Uh, more so than The Witcher. If he's like, "I finally got the rights to Nintendo gave me The Legend of Zelda rights." No. No. You're gonna ruin it. Yeah. It'd be a rolling move. It It Man Oh, man. What's this? Competitive rolling move. Um like legendary Legend of Zelda Monopoly. Oh god. No, that would actually probably be better than whatever he would make. Uh man, what?

Yeah, roll and move with other systems would just be awful. Uh roll to resolve. Uh combat. It has combat. You roll a resolve. Um, no no mitigation. Yeah, no mitigation. That would be that would be it. Yeah. But I mean, yeah, in terms of production quality, again, the art is nice, although it's it's un it's unneeded. I I know it's unneeded, but I I really like the watercolor type art until you realize that it's like six different just cards, different six different art on on a 100 cards. Yeah. Uh, I didn't really care about any of the abilities. You unlock them and they were onetime use and it's I mean I get it now that they're one time use because the game is over so quick. Mhm. But that's the problem. The game is over so quick and it's so bloated. It almost feels like felt like it took longer to set up than it did to play. It didn't. Well, that's what I was meaning by, you know, compared it to One Hit Heroes. I know. It's exact opposite.

I know. More setup, less gameplay. That one was less setup, more gameplay. So that was the the this game has the IP like dragging it along. That is that is it. Um and it's a shame because it doesn't do anything with it. And I mean the Witcher video game, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, uh is one of the best video games ever made. And there's not a board game that even comes close. I mean, again, his other one, the Old World, is not bad. It, in my opinion, it's his best one, but he still has weirdass designs around it. And even from that one, I've heard a lot of people are like, I don't touch any of the extra stuff. It's bloat. Yeah, it's the epitome of Kickstarter bloat, which we've slowly gotten away from for a lot of projects to a lot more concise gameplay. And even if it is more bloat, it's it's or even if it is more content, it's manageable content. Like we were just talking about like a game like Chronicles of Drew Druidor where it's just so much [ __ ] that's like this is now chaotic and I don't really feel like setting it up versus other games where like on Trespass Odyssey where it's like yeah I have five cycles of a bunch of stuff for it but I focus on one cycle.

Here's all the stuff for this cycle. Don't touch any of the other stuff. So there's a way you can handle additional content and I see no world where I have any interest in touching any of this expansion stuff. Yeah. I'm interested. I just want to I'm going to try it solo just so I can see give it its fair shake that way. Maybe that's where it's at. I'm going to go and try it and see. I don't even know how it works, but I'm going to try it solo. I'm going to try the try to integrate the legendary creatures to see what it does and then do the Wild Hunt and see what it does just to just to see. And I know that's how Valhalla was. Valhalla's base game was so blah, but then there was a bunch of mini modules you threw in. But I mean, at what point is it like, okay, so your game design is lacking until I throw in 15 things to make it good? It's like, hey, this this, you know, this this uh yeah, this main course meal is kind of whatever, but throw in 10 different spices. I It's like, okay, it's not the same game anymore. Why don't you just design the first game?

I I I'm mad, but I knew it's like I knew it like as soon as we were like you were telling me about the game, I'm just like, "Yep, yeah, this there's there's nothing I can do to alter my mind state to find any real positives here." Um, but the worst part is is I can't give it a low score. I mean, I'm not saying they're going at a two cuz it's like it's not it's you can play it. How much did this run? The whole the all in the whole thing. Give me keep talking and I'll I'll uh um look. Positives positives positives. Uh let's see. The minis are very nice. Uh the playmat's nice. You can play as dandelion. It all fits in the core box. the the the playmat goes in there, too, but all the expansion stuff doesn't. They say it will. There's a video that says it will.

Okay. Well, so I don't know what that means. That's a positive. Uh let's see. I just I can't even recommend it as like a Oh, if you like set collection because it's paid 160 for everything for everything. All the the because a stretch gold box has a lot of [ __ ] in it, too. So, that's why I got it cuz I was like 160 for everything that came. I was like, it was it was worth the risk. I just nabbed it. Thought I'd see, you know, and and that's 160 pre-tariff money. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Turn around. This game is $400 all of a sudden to bring it into the states. It is I don't know. And unfortunately it the only silver lining for me that could have made this work is if this section the the story whatever um was so like yeah I'll play I'll I'll do this whatever [ __ ] to kind of make different decisions because this was so interesting. It's not. It's it's really really not. Yeah. One, two, three, four, five, six. They have eight different endings. Interesting. I guess I guess if you took if you went the left instead of right on the one, maybe it like maybe that would be Well, it really it's because each side tells you to go to a different page. So, because you're going to a different page, there's a different set of two choices, right? which then

give you a different different set to get to the third set of two choices, which then gets you to one of the eight different endings. Uh so that's that's neat. Um the ending cards all have art on them. That's cool. And oh god, there's one uh where she's topless. Just her back though. But one of the art cards in the trigger one, you get to see their feet. So, if you're into that, there you go. Um, then really this is a game for you. I'm gonna go ahead and hold on to that one. There was another like I wasn't a first date backer. If you're a first date backer, you got another hero board and it was uh on on his horse. Oh, it was uh it was it was him on Roach. Oh, cool. And it was a whole another card with a whole another village or a whole another It was a whole another character, but it was him on his horse. Did you get a horse mini?

Did you get a roach mini? Cuz I wasn't a day one backer and I Well, I meant with the day one backer. Did you get a roach mini? Well, it was he it was all one. It was him riding roach. Cool. That's pretty cool. But I didn't I didn't It wasn't day one backer and I didn't want to p spend $10 on it cuz I didn't get there's an acrylic tokens. Like I actually considered getting cuz I almost posted looking for acrylic tokens. Oh yeah. Add-on but I was like I don't need I mean it's like because Yeah. It had more premium stuff, but I'm not I'm sure it did. Uh, just imagine this in the Fudal Japan deal with the Ronin box that I didn't back because it would have been weird. I mean, it following the source material, that would be dumb as hell. Uh, but in an alternate universe, I think it'd be a bad badass to see Geralt as a samurai. Well, here here's what was cool. You know, instead of it being a neoprene board in that one, it was that wood like the slat stuff that that rolls up. Yeah. Funny enough, um I got a board game in called Shadow Tactics that it's it's card mat. Is that is that exactly?

Yes, that's what the board is for the Ronin. So that's neat. But anyway, oh my god, I went Japanese crap. So yes, you do. Yeah. Yes, you do. Uh scale of 1 to 10, would you give me the Witcher path of a four? Four, right? Well, I'm going to do four now with the base game. Yeah. Like I I'm I'm going to explore the solo. I'm going to explore all the wild hunt and the legendary creatures. see if that adds anything. I don't think it's ever going to get up up. I mean, it may get to a six. Maybe if I if I like those Well, if I like those and they add enough stuff to it, but with what this base box does for me, I'm at a four right now just cuz I think that's the highest I can do as well. I think three is a little too harsh. Um, I'm sure Lucas as a designer is a very nice person. Um, because there's some things we still didn't even understand. I mean, didn't even know. It didn't say in setup. So, like I missing things from the rule book that it doesn't explain. [ __ ] I don't even know what the hell that stuff is. Again, that's probably all from uh from just choices where where it throws that in.

But I like I would like to know what things do in a story book that before just being bombarded with it. Uh yeah, three is a little too low. Five feels high. So, yeah, four is kind of where I'm at. But boy, you would have to really come at me and be like, Seth, I promise like the the legendary monsters in Wild Hut hunt. Um, the Wild Hut. That's a it's a wild that's a after hours game about the Witcher. Um, you I be like, it's it's a toy. It's not even the same game. But yeah, that's it. That's our thoughts on The Witcher Path of Destiny. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like comment, share, and subscribe. And have a wonderful, whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching, and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon, and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other runthroughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on.

Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe. And have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved