Roll & Write Review Special: 5 Roll & Writes Reviewed In 15 Minutes!
Transcript
hello everyone you're watching board of it this is tally i'm farrell and welcome to our quick fire roll and right review where we're going to review five different rolling rites four of which will make excellent stocking stuffers one of which is like getting coal in your stocking now rolling rights are a terrific little genre they make excellent filler games usually because they have low complexity and a short play time and they're also the perfect travel board game because they don't need much table space and come in very small manageable boxes and we reckon everyone should have at least one in their collection so let's discuss a few yep the games included are lost cities rolling right cartographers railroad inc metro x and roman roll for each one we'll do a short little review and we'll time stamp this video so you can jump to the games that most interest you if you're after something a bit heavier we also have full reviews of the more complex roland rights welcome to new las vegas and hadrian's ball yep and let's start with the newest game here which is lost cities roll them right
lost cities roll and write is the newest game on this list having emerged this year and is a reimagining of the game love cities both by acclaimed designer rhino kenicia it's also the most approachable on this list essentially you roll six dice three of which will have numbers from one to ten and the other three have different colors and symbols on your turn you'll be the player that rolls his dice then you'll take one number die and one symbol die the symbol die is going to tell you which track on your sheet you're going to start an expedition on and the number is going to tell you what number you're going to put in the box on that expedition and once you've done that you want to be filling up the same expedition as much as possible because the more boxes you fill the more points you're going to get at the end of the game but the twist is that you can only put a number in the next box that is the same or higher than the number in the previous box then once that player is gone all other players will share the dice that remain in the middle and do the same thing what's great about lost cities is that it's easy to teach quick to grasp and generally simple but with some tough dilemmas there are some great combo mechanics at play in that if you fill in a certain box and each track it will give you a boost which then might give you another boost and you can create some really nice chains and really get those endorphins pumping it's also surprisingly savage and interactive because often the two dice that are taken are the best ones leaving everyone
else pissed but importantly this keeps you focused outwards and you even have to keep an eye on what all the other players are doing as there's a bit of a race mechanic at play in it the first player to get to a certain position and each track is going to get bonus points and these mechanics what make for particularly interesting decisions and just generally game play moments and why we've enjoyed our time with lost city so much however it's not all perfect we do have one main criticism which like a lot of dice games the role of the dice can decide the winner and we only mention that here because it's a little bit worse in this game in that there's a mechanism where you can spend a 10 not to fill in the box but to double the points on one of your tracks the caveat being you can't have started that track yet but if somebody rolls multiple tens on their first few turns of the game and nobody else does it's clear they've already won and there's not a lot anyone can do about it but in summary lost cities is a great game for any level of gamer is full of interesting decisions it's particularly interactive for a rolling right and is surprisingly cheap like 10 pounds cheap recommendation full recommendation from us and it's a great game to take out on the town and play at a cafe or pub which i have done multiple times five stockings out of five five seconds out of five
cartographers is a well-respected map drawing game where players will attempt to score the most points as dictated by scoring cards while mapping out a magical kingdom on a turn you'll flip over a card that will show a tetris-like shape or shapes and you'll also have a terrain type or types you'll pick a shape and a terrain type and then draw it somewhere on your map where you'll put this on your map will often be in relation to the four scoring cards which will ask you to do specific tasks in order to score points however the different cards score in different rounds so what you do when is also important well the core of cartographers can be easy to learn things get a little more difficult with the introduction of the scoring cards and this is because often they're confusing and sometimes just hard to do and when you combine this with the fact that you have four and play and they all score at different times it means it's not the friendliest game to newcomers and it's definitely a game that if you had an experienced player teaching it to say family the experienced player would always dominate the scoring we do like about cartographers is the choice that it provides the fact that many of the cars that you reveal give a player multiple options of what they can draw on the map means that players can pursue their own unique strategies and you often end up with quite varied maps there's also a certain level of player interactivity in that one of the cards will have you draw goblins on another player's map with the aim of putting it in the most annoying place and maximizing their negative points but whilst this is a fun mechanic it's still primarily a heads down focus on
your own thing game in conclusion although cartographers does feel unique within the genre it's maybe just a little bit dry and not as dynamic as other roland rights don't get us wrong we do love playing it but it doesn't call us to get it to the table especially when compared to some of the other rolling routes in our collection that said it is often our first pick to take away with us when we're traveling due to the minor table space that it requires so recommendation this is probably worth a space in your collection if you really love roland rights but it's best for those that prefer drawing over rolling dice for me 3.5 stockings out of 5. nice what about you i would agree 3.5
now we come to an absolute icon of the roll and write genre railroad inc in this route building game you're going to roll a bunch of dice into the middle of the table and each of these die is going to have little roots on them so you're going to have segments of road or railway the right turns straight lines and whatever you roll you have to draw each and every one of the dice into your little board the long term aim of the game is to connect as many orange exits as possible in one connected route what's terrific about railroad inc is that each player has to use all of the same dice must use exactly the same shapes and you get wildly different outcomes at the end of the game it's a really fascinating study into how people's minds work railroad inc is also easy to teach has minimal rules overhead and is a really great introduction into board games or to play if you just want to chill out we personally had a really nice moment when we took this over to a friend's house and everybody there was absolutely bamboozled and fascinated with the dry erase boards the markers and the dice there's also just a lot of great gameplay decisions i like that as well as connecting exits you also score for your longest road and railway because these are very easy tasks to aim for and attack particularly if you're a new player i also think the inclusion of special routes which are little routes that you can use in a pinch or maybe you want to use them if you've created a perfect route and that's all you need to get it all
together and it's worth noting that every edition and there are multiple editions of railroad ink in different colors they're all absolutely gorgeous and the box size is of course to be commended so in conclusion railroad inc is an absolute masterpiece of the genre it's easy to teach it's got interesting decisions and it's full of chunky gameplay but if that wasn't enough for you every edition also includes two unique dice that you can throw into your game to shake up the gameplay and create whole new problems in your route planning recommendation it's a must-have it's perfect for taking out on the town or if you just want to warm up to a game tonight for me because it's kind of like a legacy roll-around game like in terms of long-standing i'm gonna give it five out of seven santas five out of five oh i was just thinking five out of five stockings based on the previous scale but that's boring now yeah there you go five out of seven santas and five out of five stockings
now we come to metro x which like railroad inc is a well-respected classic of the genre here you'll be flipping cars with numbers on them which will tell you how many stations you can fill in on your metro lines on your metro map you score for completing the metro lines and you score more points if you're the first to do it however the wrinkle is that all of the metro lines interlink and the most common cards that you're going to be revealing don't allow you to skip over stations that you've already filled in this means that if you complete one line it can be extremely difficult to progress down another line without getting the specific cards you need but you could also score a lot of points by drawing transit cards out of the deck and these will have you fill in the very next station on any one of your lines and then you score points equal to double the number of lines that run through that station this was such an instant hit with us because it has such a varied decision space should you hold out for a transit card at the expense of completing a line or should you go all in on completing a specific line this is probably the most complex and taxing out of the four games that we've mentioned so far so we probably wouldn't recommend it to beginners however it does have the perfect play time of around 15 minutes so you can get multiple games in should also be commended because it comes with two distinct maps which of course will increase the replayability now i'm in two minds about how the deck works because in a game that's all about planning and being careful and not
trying not to trip over yourself i would have thought that the way the deck would work is that you go through the cards and the more you play you become familiar with them and then eventually you can really plan around what's in the deck but that's not what happens there's actually a card that has the deck reshuffled which can obviously come up at any time meaning that you can't plan in a game where planning is very important it's i'm in two minds about it because it definitely does though create uncertainty chaos and it makes the game infinitely replayable because you know you just have this different stuff every time different problems doing different things in conclusion metro x is a tricky little puzzle of planning routes and trying not to trip over yourself which thoroughly deserves its place in almost every top 10 best role and rights lists so our recommendation is for people who maybe want just something that a little bit more complex out of role and write or for people that have a real thing for looking at metro maps which i actually do yeah so i would give this four stockings out of five oh i'm going four point five four i want to play it right now yep
now we come to the black sheep of this list roman roll this is the one that we said was the equivalent of getting coal in your stocking but to be honest it couldn't be a stocking stuffer anyway because the box is too big this is an attempt and a more expansive more interactive roll and write in this game you'll be rolling dice which will provide you with resources and actions and then you'll spend those resources to do the actions which include building buildings conquering far-right territories and generally bringing glory to rome it's very rare that we play a game and we actively just like playing and as harsh as it sounds that is what happened here the symbology on the dice is crowded and confusing none of the systems link together particularly well and the decision space just isn't particularly interesting often in games the driving force is the acquisition of powers that will kind of let you break the game a little bit or get bonuses when you do actions but here none of the ones you could unlock through your advisors was interesting to us just the whole game felt rough and clunky to play not to mention the choice of aesthetic design which looks like they stole the artwork from a 90s cd-rom educational game about the romans and all of this is compounded by the poor quality of the components the design of the main board is so poor and combined with the odd colour choices of the dry erase markers it makes it almost impossible to see the buildings that you've drawn on there which is ludicrous
considering how important seeing the buildings that you've drawn is to the gameplay in conclusion this is a game that tried to create a heavier and more interactive role right but it just didn't stick the landing recommendation 100 give this a miss instead look to hadrian's wall for your heavy roam roll and right fix and that game made both of our top 10 top nine best lists best games of the year so i would give roman roll three calls out of five because i'll give it five out of five calls all right five out of five goals and there you have it so hopefully you found some stocking stuffers that piqued your interest in this list honestly besides roman roll you can't really go wrong with any of these games if you've never tried a roll and write before you're probably best starting with railroad inc followed closely by lost cities rolling right if you prefer heavier games then you can check out our reviews of welcome to new las vegas and hadrian's wall both of which are complex terrific heavy rolling rights and they'll appear somewhere over here at the end of the video but we hope the video was helpful and thank you for watching please tell us your favorite role of rights and if you haven't already it would really mean a lot to us if you subscribe and the dogs will get treats treats you want some thank you
bye