Skip to main content
Loading video...

Marty's Musings - Our Philosophy on Game Reviews

Transcript 10:09

oh recently scott morris or talks from chris happen asked the question on his youtube channel he wanted to know what are the commandments for board game reviewers like what are the ethics or what are the things that you look for in a board game reviewer what should they do in order to remain ethical and fair in how they do their reviews now i haven't read any of the statements yet and i didn't want to because first i wanted to come on and share what our philosophy is when it comes to reviews on rolling dice and taking names so here's the thing if you haven't seen that video you need to go watch it real real quick and then come back here and then i'll tell you our views in fact here's a link to the youtube video right here or it's also down below in the comment section so it's about eight minutes long so go watch it and make sure to come back here and so basically i've got about eight minutes to fill while you go do that and um so go and i'll i'll be right here waiting on you um here i'll sort some some netrunner cards

so so

every time i play this game i have to go back and reread the rules why can i not get above level 5 in star realms

oh that's funny pair of paradise is so funny classic chazz i don't get it rado how do you lose you know exactly what jen is gonna do

gotta get ready for the next game insert video keep it in the box keep it in the box box i get it kill myself sometimes i really don't need to get into another lcg man this looks good

no tony really the dnd attack wing from whiz kids looks really really good no i mean i'm thinking about getting it maybe you should too so we can play together no i promise you i mean it this would be the last thing i ask you to get promised this is it we're going to play this game for years to come really

okay that's eight minutes so hopefully you enjoyed his video maybe you left a comment so before i give our philosophy let me discuss what tony and i wanted to do with this show we never intended for it to be a full game review show we thought we might touch on a game here and there but there are many other shows and channels that do a much better job than what we could ever do there are people that are more qualified to do so that can give better production values on on doing board game reviews and maybe are more knowledgeable have more gaming experience than what we do we're just a couple guys who started the show because we enjoy talking about games and the hobby and the culture and as part of that we also talked about games that we like and don't like so we thought well we'll also include those every so often now we do have a formal review type of mechanism called the five minute initiative we started this soon after we started the show we had individual episodes of audio versions of games that we recovered that we liked and now we're starting to do that on our youtube channel also and starting to put out a few videos of the five minute initiatives yes i know the last one was seven minutes long give me a break while make sure to not have to change the name to seven minute initiative so that's kind of where we stand on reviews we never meant to have that as the main foundation of our show now let's just talk about the re reviews that we have done there was the question in there that scott asked about you know some board game reviewers may get free games and

many board game reviewers not many some board game reviewers get into board game and strictly for getting free games others is just part of the thing they just enjoy making videos and as a result they get the free games tony and i have received a free game here and there along the way but typically it's because it's been with a company that we've talked to and really enjoyed or a game that we've been hyping up and as such they may send us a copy to check out so when it comes to our five-minute initiatives all our five-minute initiatives except for one we bought the game with our own money we did not ask for review copies these were just games that we were already interested in we played them and we thought hey let's share with everybody else and give our formal faults in that five minute initiative format now as such i know there was a question of whether if you get free games we'd be biased towards that game because you want to keep getting free games that you want to give positive reviews and never a negative review so like i said that's not really an issue for us because we've bought all of our own games that we review and discuss and talk about on the show as such there are people who have told us that we will have a bias because we've spent our own money on the game and we're going to tend to like the game more because i've invested money into it for me that's not the case in fact if there's a game that i've bought and do not care for i'm more likely to be vocal about it because if you happen to have the same interest in games i do i don't want you wasting your

money on a game that you may not like that's why i always usually end our reviews with play it before you buy it that's with any game game reviews are very subjective what i may like you may not like and vice versa that's why i try to be so careful when i talk about games it's i use try to use the first person i like this because i dislike this because you may not like it because of this if there's a certain type of genre or mechanic that you dislike you may not like it and vice versa i try to make it very subjective and look at it i can only give my own opinion obviously you will have yours but i'm just saying that when i do the reviews that's why i will never say this game is crap do not buy this game because somebody out there is going to like that game even if the majority of people don't somebody probably will so that's why i always try to be and tony tries to be is like i don't care for this for this reason but you might because xyz so that's the way we look at it again so when it comes to money we're not requesting a lot of free games because we're we're just that's not the main purpose of our show where others are all about reviews next yes we on the ones that we buy we will review them but we try to still try to be as subjective a pot as possible even though we have bought them now let's talk about previews on kickstarters like most channels we get a lot of requests for doing previews on kickstarters there are other

channels and shows that are set up out there to charge for doing previews for kickstarters we do not do that the only previews that we will do are games that we think that we might be interested in and in that case we will try the game and it's not a review it's just a preview of here's our thoughts and opinions and how it works and you may like this again because xyz we are not set up we do not have the time to invest in a lot of kickstarter previews so that's why we do not charge for them if we started to do that it would consume most of our time and we would rather commit most of our time just to doing a fun casual chit chat show on our on our podcast and now we're going to do little videos here and there so that's really pretty much about it that's how we look at it now i have not read the comments yet and now that this is done i will go read the comments on scott's video to see what you thought but if you would like to share your thoughts on how we do things or what you think the commandments should be for board gamers please leave comments on the sections below and i promise i will respond in some shape or form there you go that's just our philosophy again if you ask 10 other different reviewers they're going to have a totally different philosophy from us but at least you now know where tony and i are coming from

Progress saved