Botanicus, Bomb Busters, Gardlings, Junk Drawer, Animalcatraz Reviews
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video this is why I take a look at the last five new to me board games that I played and I rank and review them in order of preference now I have five very interesting games on this list at least in terms of diversity because I have uh amerit trashy games I have puzzly games family games Euro games and even a co-op game to talk about but before I get into the games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor k .co.uk who are my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order additionally be sure to check out my new game Thalamus that is now available for purchase and send me an email if you'd like a copy but let's get started on the five games at number five I have anim Alcatraz so it's very rare that I cover these amera trashy style games on the channel because they're not normally my jam I'm much more of a euro gamer and and a card gamer um but the designer reached out to me and said Dan do you want to cover this on the channel I think you might like it and I thought you know what I love the name of the game I love the theme and I love the artwork let's give it a go and go in with an open mind so this is a sandboxy kind of prison simulator as you are taking the role of these anthropomorphic animals that look fantastic you know so much character um great great character work here in terms of the artwork and how they all have their own personalities and abilities uh you're us using those character characters to
navigate your way around the prison collecting certain items to help you fight better and give you special abilities I'm trying to collect particular items to try and sneak your way out of prison by trying to increase your odds to roll a certain configuration on these dice um starting fights with other inmates to increase your reputation um so again very amerit trashy stuff you know just skimming the top of decks collecting items and having rolloffs with the other players but it's the attention to detail here that really did impress me um you know every little tidbit in the game is so interesting you know how the how the weapons are designed how the guards move around how you can bribe the guards with certain items which you know has good comedic effect in this game um so yeah I mean mechanisms wise it's not for me it's a lot of dice rolling there's a lot of top decking um very you know boisterous in- yourf face Style game play and while it's not for me subjectively objectively I can see why a lot of people would enjoy this and I'll say if you enjoy games like dead of winter uh this one definitely fits that camp and you know the immediate game I thought of when playing this one was dead of winter and I know how successful that was so I'm sure there is a huge audience for this one again it's not for me it's just a bit too lucky and a bit too you know roll to resolve style gameplay but again a lot of care has been taken here and I only played the real kind of basic version of the game and there's lots of different add-ons you can do by getting kind of cellmates and smuggling things
into your um into your cell or hiding things in your cell and setting traps riots and so on so kind of really have thought of everything here so yeah while I can say it's not for me it might be for you and it might be worth checking out and it's definitely going to be a contender for artwork of the year because everything in everything in this game just looks spectacular so that is anim Alcatraz at number five at number four I have junk draw so this is is a polyomino style puzzle game as you are placing the shapes depicting these different pieces of junk into these four separate grids um so unlike a lot of polyomino games where you have you know your own Big Grid and you can fill it up as you like this one you have four separate compartments um that you need to very carefully manage because they are a lot tighter and there really isn't much wiggle room now the order in which you draw these shaped shapes is based off this kind of bingo style mechanism as you're drawing a card from the top of the deck and then everybody will play place the item depicted on that card into one of their draws and you cannot choose another draw again until you filled up all the other drawers in that round so again you have to spread yourself quite thin before you can go again on the same draw and then each of these drawers will be assigned a separate rule in how they score so some might say We'll simply score x amount of points for each item in this draw some might say score x amount of points for every empty Square uh score x amount of points for every item that's in the draw but not touching each other and there's a lot of variety here so you can you
know have a lot of different ways to experience the game um It's Perfectly Pleasant I have nothing against it really um if anything I think maybe the drawers are a little bit too tight so you don't really have too much um ability to be creative and Slot things in in as you'd see fit um but it's super fast it's so easy easy to jump right into again impressed with the variety in the game um my only concern is that this is fighting for the same space as a lot of other polyomino games and puzzly games because there are a lot out there and I even have some really good ones in my own collection such as you know Patchwork if you want two-player game Alice's Garden um and even I've recently acquired a game called um take a seat which is another poly omo Style game so it's you know it has a lot of competition but while saying that I can still see this one hitting the table and I certainly want to play it some more to see some of that different variety um but it might just miss out a long term because some of its competition just has the edge but still it's a good example of the genre and I like those additional twists but I would have liked it to be a little bit more maybe a little bit bigger just so I had some more ability to uh to move the shapes around as I sell fit but that is junur at number four at number three I have guard Lings so this is a push your luck bag Builder game that I didn't really know too much about about going into it but I had heard it directly compared to the quacks of quber and after playing this one I
can certainly see why that is the case because mechanically you are essentially doing the same thing diving into a bag putting out tokens but in this one you are not placing them on a track or anything you are simply building up this map of these kind of domino shaped tiles trying to connect these gems that run along the edges of these tiles so the more edges you connect it means that you can um get more current points which will allow you to buy better tiles from this Market to add into your bag to of course increase your odds to score more points in future rounds and it's going to be a race to get to this kind of Master token that's quite expensive to buy so really simple system here I like the kind of map building and the puzzly nature of the game trying to keep your options open and fit things in just perfectly to score every single gem on those tokens and even the tokens have some really cool abilities such as you know you connect these two particular gems together and you'll score an extra one or you get some compensation points or some gems might be wild which will of course give you some more flexibility so they're all very simple in their own right but they have definitely have their own uses um and it just has a very nice flow to this game and despite being so directly compared to quax and quinber I do think there's space for both of them in the board game World um you know qua is a little bit more involved more combos a bit more variability this one is more boiled down to the fundamental systems of you know that that bag building system and but I do love that
puzzly nature of the game it it's just a really Charming fun family weight experience and I left the game fing really impressed by actually and I did thoroughly enjoy my plays and I will certainly go back and play this one some more with with a smile on my face so um I think this one could be a slow burner um it's going to be again it's always going to be compared to quacks and of course quacks is well embedded in this hobby now it's going to be hard to knock off that Podium but again I think this one is just streamlined that much more that you could end up having both um because this one's a bit more pick up and play with a lot less setup as compared to quacks whereas if you want that real kind of more involved Pusher like experience you might go for something like qua instead of gings but both of them really enjoyable uh that is gings at number three at number two I have botanicus so this is a puzzly euro that only takes around an hour to play and and this game uses a mechanism I'd love to see more of that actually reminds me of one of my favorite filler games called floriferous and that is this Action System where you're choosing an action based on this column and the further you dive down on the column you know generally speaking the better action you'll get but it means you'll get lower turn priority for the next turn in terms of you know initiative so sometimes you might want to take a week action and make sure you're at the top so that you go first the next time and get the exact action that you want now the actions in this game are actually very simple generally speaking they're
climbing these different tracks that will give you abilities as you go along the way you can unlock these animals that will give you ongoing benefits um but the general idea of the game is that you'll be trying to fill up your personal little garden of these flower pots that come in four different levels so you got level 1 2 3 and four um they start at level one and you can improve them by watering the FL flowers um and increasing their level and you're trying to essentially um complete these objectives based on these um goal Tils that are assigned to each row of your garden so you have two different levels some might say um for the basic level you want to complete a level one objective and a level sorry a level one plan and maybe two level twos and as soon you as you've done that you'll get some points and you'll replace it with the more advanced one which might then say you want three level threes and a level four which of course is going to be much more difficult to achieve but it grants way more points but it has this kind of contrasting scoring system where of course you want to be scoring these goals as quickly as you can um but at the end of the game you'll score points based on your best plan in each column um so again you don't want to be neglecting your columns either because there's a lot of points you could be sitting on just by having you know a single Gap now the game itself is actually very easy and simple simple to understand but the difficulty lies in the fact that you cannot always build exactly where you want to build you will always restricted to where you have your Gardener and your garden is going to be
moving around this um your your garden on particular spots and you can only have a plant or water the four plant pots surrounding where your Gardener currently is so you do need to think ahead and move your Gardener to the right spot before you take your main action so that really does amplify the um the brain Burness of this game exponentially um as compared to if you could just build wherever you wanted at any time the game has a lovely flow to it again you're just climbing these tracks um planting new plants collecting money you know you need to make sure you always have money in your supply to do what you want again um Watering your plants and whenever you reach the top of a track you can score some instant points and go back to the beginning so you are rewarded to fly along the track as well um again I like the abilities of these animals you'll get which will score your points based on know if you unlock a certain animal it might say for every other animal you unlock you get x amount of points or this particular animal will score you more points if you complete an objective uh this one will unlock a new track and so on so all of them are really inviting and you want to unlock them all but you can't and when at the same time those animals are blocking particular flower beds and you know you might need to unlock a particular animal so that you can actually score that particular row or column so as you can see see here that all of these um moving parts of the game come together to create a simple but quite an engaging game here and I love the way it's all boiled down to that floriferous initiative system now the
game itself comes in two different levels you got the base the base game which is kind of more your familyfriendly version and you have the the advanced variant now I'd say probably if you're watching my channel you'll probably enjoy the advanced variant as a as a standard edition because you do have an Amplified version of the puzzlin of the game um and it's still easy to digest but there's enough going on to keep you satisfied and enough for you to sink your teeth into and and all in all I think this game is really enjoyable now when I first played this one I did certainly give it a accommodation I I was thoroughly impressed now I played it again since and unfortunately I was playing it incorrectly and that did somewhat hampen my um or dampen my um enjoyment of it because I played one round too many and I found it a bit too Loosey Goosey so that's on me I'm not the game at all so I do want to play it some more playing it two rounds instead of three rounds as you should do um which will certainly tighten up the game way more um but I want to give it a little bit of breathing space before I go back and revisit it to really solidify my thoughts but I'm sure you're going to get a lot of enjoyment out of this one if you like your puzzly medium to lightweight Euros this is a great example that has been sadly flown under the radar but I think there's going to be an audience for this one there's a lot to enjoy that is bo uh botanicus at number two and finally at number one I have bom Busters so this is a Cooperative deduction game now that's
kind of an oxymoron for me because I love deduction games but I generally don't like co-op games U but as you can see this is one that I really do enjoy because it is of course number one so this one you are of course working with your teammates to try and diffuse a bomb at the start of each round you're going to be given a rack of these tiles that will come with these different like wires on them as well as a number only you can see your rack of tiles and you are trying to find pairs of the matching numbers um at the start of the game you're going to give these kind of vague Clues out by showing which number is um present in your row which might show that or he's got a bunch of very low tiles or this person's got um really high tiles and you can use that information to take some of speculative guesses on where certain numbers might be and whenever you make a mistake then you're going to go down on this track which will of course count towards your your doom and lose the game um but if you find a pair then you're going to remove those from the game and it's going to know reveal more information and make things a bit more clear when it comes to other players actions the game does does come in this kind of leveling system where you're playing through these missions and with each new Mission there's kind of a new spanner thrown into the works by maybe these wires that will instantly lose you the game if you select it um special abilities uh more tiles and so on so there's this game's
got a really nice flow it's very satisfying when you work out exactly where these particular wires are um when you add in these kind of decimal numbers that really does increase the difficulty level because you need to proceed with that little bit more caution um and you know I wasn't sure what to expect going into this game because again I normally don't like deduction games no I want to like sorry not Cooperative games I should say I want to like them but I just seem I seem to bounce off of them this one is exactly what I'm looking for in a deduction game because you are in charge of your own t because again you can't share your own information so you know you're in the hot seat and you actually have some autonomy you're not going to be quarterbacked by another player um each game is super fast so it's not like if you make a critical mistake the blame or you know the pressure of being blamed isn't too much because you can just rerack and go again um I like the way that although there is a tier system here in terms of the missions you're playing through you can't just play the same missions again and again because the arrangement of tiles is going to be different so you might find that sweet spot for you in terms of the you know the missions and you might like a particular one and just play that one again and again easy to teach you can drip feed the information and all in all I don't really have a single bad thing to say about this game um other than the fact I might say I'm not always in the mood to play it um but if I am feeling like a deduction game a Cooperative game
a low pressure one that's fast and fun then bom Busters is definitely going to fit that Niche perfectly so um wonderful game I can see why this one has blown up it's going to be very successful and rightly so super clean system doesn't have these kind of silly devices and Contraptions that you're trying to mess around with to work out what the answer is is all in front of you and shared amongst the players at all times just a wonderful experience so that is Bomb Busters at number one so there we have it that concludes at the video as I said a real uh nice mix of games here and hopefully you've discovered a game or two if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye