OWN It, PLAY It or SKIP It | Episode 9 | Maui, Libertalia, It's a Wonderful World (& More!)
Transcript
foreign how's it going everyone I am Dylan this is my cousin Carlo this is all you can board and this is own it play it's skip it we're back for I think this is episode nine I feel like I'm gonna get everything nine or ten something like that I always get it if it was 10 we had to make a big deal about it the 10th Avenue yeah we always forget to look it up before we start going but um and we've got six uh really cool games to talk about here some um well slightly older I was gonna say old slightly less cool maybe yeah maybe slightly less cool uh I think what's the oldest game here 2017 is what uh 2019 is one of mine yeah so 2019 all the way to really really recent and we're going to give you our thoughts on whether we think you should own it play it or skip it in our opinion and I'm gonna kick it off to you first to start us off all right so the first game I'm going to be talking about today is the release from 2020 comes in a little metal tin and this is a game called Abandon All artichokes so this is a two to four player card game uh it's deck building or deck destruction uh depending how you want to look at it so this is designed by Emma Larkins which I believe it's her first uh as of now I think it's still her only design published by game right so it's a very quick little game it says right on the tin here 20 minutes to play that sounds about right um and before I go any further if you want to try this out for free it is also on board game arena so you can try it on there but the basic idea of the game is everyone starts with a deck of 10 cards they're going to be 10 identical cards they're artichokes they don't do anything they don't have any ability um the whole point of the game is you're gonna have five cards in your hand on your turn there's going to be a row of veggies out in front of you you're going to be picking a card to add to your hand then you can play as many cards as you
possibly as you want in your hand once you've resolved all those abilities you're going to discard what's left draw five new cards to reform your hand and then the next player goes the way to win the game is if at the end of your turn you draw five cards and none of those cards are artichokes you immediately win the game that's the only way to win the game is to have successfully abandoned all of your artichokes so they might still be in the deck but the whole point you're trying to draw a hand without them so you can do this by you know adding a bunch more cards to your deck so that you have this big over inflated deck so you have a higher chance of drawing more of the cards you've bought you can do it by trashing more of the like removing more of the artichoke cards that you're thinning out your deck you can do a combination of both there's little interactive abilities where you're you know either removing artichokes from your hand or randomly comparing a card with the other player with another player at the table to see maybe you're going to swap cards or maybe you're each going to get the trash and artichoke so it's a fairly interactive game each of the veggies has their own little abilities uh some are better early game or late game or whatnot or depending what your deck composition is um so it's a very very simple game plays very quickly um there's a lot to like here and especially for a game this simple to do deck building and to do deck destruction in this way where you're basically trying to just like the whole goal is you always give me a hard time but in deck building games on trash and cards but yeah this whole game is about destroying you know the stuff that you want to get out of here it's probably what Drew you to it honestly it was a big part of it I was like it's like a family weight game that's a deck builder that's meant to be more about the trashing so it just felt like there was no game that I had played that sat quite in that space so
for me this one is going to be a play it um and the reason for that is that it doesn't do enough for me to be a game that I feel like for me myself is worth is like a must own or something that's going to stick around in my collection forever yeah I always knew when I uh from when I bought it that it wasn't going to be something I'd be playing with my you know when I get together for my like the game nights I'm most looking forward to with my friends who I play the most games with I knew this wasn't going to be a game we'd play often but I thought it'd be a good kind of family weight game to have around and over the holidays I had a chance to play it a couple times uh with a couple of my nephews and some other family and the game it's not that it fell flat but I was playing it with my nephews who are I believe 9 and 14 and I thought of all the people who I ever do kind of play games with I thought if it's gonna land with anyone this is going to be kind of The Sweet Spot for it and we played a bunch of games together over the weekend we played like crash octopus and like Lord of the Rings the confrontation and hot lead and all these kinds of games and this one just seemed to be the one that they sort of took to almost the least and it it seemed like sometimes I don't know if it was maybe there was too much text on the cards or whatnot it just seemed like a lot of games went over a lot better with them and I was expecting a game like this you know the friendly artwork the sort of relatively low rules set but you know sometimes you're doing things at the top of your deck or your discard pile sometimes certain things are random sometimes you have a choice so if you're playing with younger people who maybe aren't reading the cards in full there can be some kind of glossing over stuff there so it's enjoyed it every time I've played it I've played it to all player accounts I do think it's best with three or four I
don't think it's particularly good with two I think if you're looking for a kind of light uh you know family weight game and something that does deck building or deck destruction you can't go wrong it's definitely worth a try but it's hard for me to recommend it much more than just saying it's worth kind of checking it out if you have a chance yeah I played this twice on BGA um and it was it's been a while since I played it but I just remember my thoughts being that was fun but it's more it felt like more of like a fun distraction than it was something that I was going to like sit down and like and it it almost felt like a game that I will play online but I will not often want to play the physical version yeah for me personally unless again like you're saying like if you're playing with kids if you're playing with a more family oriented uh audience or whatever maybe then it's yeah I'd have a reason to get it to the table but for me it's like I could see myself like because I play BG games even on my phone sometimes like kicking back like on the coach or embed and playing a couple quick rounds of it but I didn't think like I'm gonna sit down at a table like put out the cards and play I bet in all artichokes but yeah I just remember that being my impression when I first play it but I did like it like I did leave going I see what the fuss was about when a bunch of people it was like one of not the most played game on BGA but it had a lot of games played on yeah or something for sure and again because it does a couple of those novel things and so I think it's definitely worth checking out for people who haven't played it yet but like you said like I might try it every once in a while on board game arena but if it's on my shelf I'm not going to be the one suggesting to play it so yeah um yeah that's Abandon All art jokes all right the first game I'm going to take a look at is a fairly new game A pretty new game actually and that is Maui and this was sent to us as a review copy from Plan B games next move games I think it's under the next move games
Banner but it's that's part of Plan B games which is part of asthma day yeah which is part of yeah it just keeps going it's like one of those uh Russian dolls yeah um so yeah Maui is a pretty simple game we play this uh once I played it twice be beyond that um essentially what happens is it's a game where I think you talk about it from the start you're like how if I made a game where the theme is towels which is essentially what this is it's like laying your towels on the beach um and you have a a horizontal board that is moving from left to right and you're having to lay these towel tiles down and a towel tile has um three different patterns represented on it and you can place your towel tiles so that they're completely you know in in tune with each other or you can offset them so that all you have to do is make sure that one of the patterns that you're connecting matches and you're building from left to right to fill your entire board and so your towels are going to start moving upwards or they're going to start moving downwards as you go and you're trying to cover umbrellas to get bonuses you're also trying to match those patterns on specific rows in the horizontal board because the further down you go or the further up you go the more points you'll score for that pattern each pattern has its own scoring track and you're moving up all the scoring tracks which is like I think the thing I like them the most about it is that like certain scoring tracks will get you more points and it's like how heavily do you invest in that or can you invest based on what you're buying from the market the market is like really um straightforward like it compared to other games that have markets it's you have uh two options uh or two different like vertical uh areas to buy from and
each one has one that's free one that costs one sand dollar one that costs two uh two sand dollars depending on what you're working with in terms of currency you might be limited to what you can buy you can also have the option to take sand dollars from the two Banks to you know replenish your income to be able to buy other towels so really your turn amounts to am I going to take a bunch of sand dollars or am I going to take one of the towels that I can either afford or take for free and add it to my board every time you take sand dollars you're potentially setting yourself back because if I go the whole game without if I go the whole game without taking sand dollars and only placing towel tiles but you've taken sand dollars you might Place less towels than me because the in-game is triggered as soon as you place that last uh towel and then you might not have an enough score to keep up so very very simple game plays in like I would say like really once you know the rules and you've played a couple times I could see this being played in like 20 to 30 minutes no problem um and I we've talked about a lot of like next Move games and plan B games in general over over the years that we've had this channel like from all the different Azul titles to Yak um to Men at Work under the the something pretzel I always forget is pretzel games pretzel games Okay um and and then there's other ones I'm forgetting and all of them have like one of the things that has always stood out to them in them to me is just the production value like from these will tell Steve Yak I think is the biggest one that I just remember thinking like this is ridiculous production value yeah and so I have to say coming into Maui I guess I had that expectation that it was going to like that was going to be the area even just based on like the amazing I really do like the the box art just
the colors and the vibrancy of it um but the the tiles are nice like they're it's a thicker cardboard on them but I wouldn't say that there's anything in this box when I compare it to like other games from Next Movement Plan B that really sort of keep up with that production value thing yeah I would agree there's like it's still good and it's better than other games we've seen like if it's not like they're trying to like you know make this a really really uh cost efficient game by like reducing the quality they can components but it definitely isn't up there with like Azul and yak and stuff like that yeah so my thoughts on Maui are if do you if you are like looking for a game that specifically you're gonna play as a family game that has really simple rules this is a game that I could see really Landing because it will not take much to learn and it won't take much to like in terms of length to play and you can come back and and you know I could see kids having a lot of fun with this me as someone who has like you know 170 games 150 games whatever's in my collection now um I just remember leaving all my sessions thinking there's some things I found some moments I found fun but generally I just don't know what would bring me me personally back to it it was it's a pretty simplistic game there's nothing that's like it's not like it's a simplistic game that has this one hook that I'm really buying into so for me personally this is a skip um and I just think that it just has a lot to live up to in terms of other games under this under this um this publisher and design and uh you know uh in terms of like components in terms of gameplay and it just didn't hit those those those notes for me those bars for
me but again I'm I I don't have kids I don't have like a family that could be playing games with I think of like you know your son was like you know seven or eight or whatever maybe this is one of those games where it's like hey it's easy for him to understand and it's not my favorite game but I enjoy watching him play it the way he gets out of it right although I don't think you're ever gonna get over the towel theme and that's the thing is for me is the the towel theme is a weird kind of choice and setting just because this whole like kind of you know welcoming family slash Gateway game kind of genre is very crowded there's a lot of games out there that have you know nice artwork nice components play pretty quickly kind of thing and so I I understand like the kind of beach and Island theme is something that's like a huge draw people like that the colors the kind of you know it makes you feel like you're on vacation or whatnot yeah I think honestly the what's gonna make this game potentially stand out over others would be the theme in the setting is like there's not a ton of games in Hawaii and you're not like there's nothing about this game that's inherently making you feel like it's like a Hawaiian themed game it's not like you're gonna be like oh I'm so proud of my Hawaiian Hawaiian Heritage now that this game like it's not like there's anything really on display yeah but I think that would be the one thing to set it apart in the field otherwise in terms of the gameplay yeah I have to agree with you I did only play it once but there wasn't enough there for me either to want to really go back to it but nothing inherently wrong with it is just not terribly exciting yeah I would say my favorite things about it are the multiple scoring tracks and having to navigate which ones are going to move up and certain ones it makes sense to get to a certain point to get a big Point jump and then maybe you can transition to another scoring track
that's me had some potential to be interesting and I do like how as you place your towels you have to decide do I want to abandon these umbrellas that'll get me bonus points to you know instead place it somewhere that's going to get me more points on the point track right that was that was the most fun decision making that existed in a Maui for me was you know how many umbrellas am I willing to abandon if I'm trying to get the pearls that are underneath or if I get the first three and I get it's the pearls I want maybe I just don't go for umbrellas anymore right that was a cool decision space my other recommendation would be if you're gonna play it and you are somewhat of an experienced board gamer already I would just include the the variant yeah that's the code they call the crab variant it doesn't doesn't make it much more complex and honestly I think this game could use like other elements going on so you can I mean at least try it and if you don't like it then eliminate it but I wouldn't say it's gonna it's like I don't I can't remember if they call it an advanced variant or anything but I would definitely say it's not like an advanced or anything like that but yeah that is Maui it's a skip for me but if you have uh uh families that you're looking to play games with or you're just a more entry level gamer I think you'll release the play it at that point just to see if it's for you yeah we are very much not the target audience for that game yeah all right next up I'm going to be talking about a I guess not quite rolling right it's a flipping right game uh this is Castle parties so this is a 2021 release I believe this is published by deviator games um plays in about half an hour it's a two to four player game where every player has a little dry erase board with a marker uh the basic theme of the game is you are um representing monsters that are
arriving at this party a that takes place in a castle so your dry erase board is going to have a castle that's surrounded by a water room I guess a moat and then there's going to be a little drawbridge that connects your um I guess the path over the water to the castle so there's the spaces on the board are important for that um and the basic idea behind the game is you're going to be so every player is going to have their own little deck of cards and you're going to be um or you're going to be drawing cards from I guess from a common deck but you're going to be taking turns going around the table playing cards to create um to basically create the shape of the polyamino that everyone is then going to lay on their board so everyone is going to be basically taking turns playing a card you're gonna well you flip a card over a deck first and it's gonna tell you what shape you're gonna create and then one at a time you're going to be playing cards to create that shape in whichever configuration you want and which with whichever tiles you you have in with whichever symbols um that represent the different types of like monsters at this party and then once the shape is created then everyone's gonna place it on their board and you kind of play through the flow of the game like this throughout the deck there's going to be these three cards shuffled in that are scoring cards and when they get pulled you're going to have three different scoring conditions you can score throughout the game one of them is uh it's called like the the what is it a rival of the pumpkin king or something so it's this one the basically three unique scoring conditions to score at one time throughout the game and whenever these little uh clock cards come out you have to choose which of these conditions am I going to score now am I going to score the conga line or am I going to leave the conga line for the second or third scoring later maybe I
can get more points out of it there maybe I'll score the Pumpkin King now instead kind of thing and then you also have these three one-time abilities that you can always choose throughout the game uh at the end of it or after the shape is done being composed by all the players you can choose do I want to use this one-time ability to modify the shape or modify what I'm taking before I actually put it on my my board so between the three abilities that you have and the three scoring conditions there's some play throughout the game to kind of mix up doing what not having to do the same thing that other players are doing just taking the tile putting it somewhere on your board and then at the end you're basically trying to score together all of your biggest chain for each of the different types of monsters and all that kind of stuff so fairly simple game uh there's in some ways it it feels a lot like other rolling rights or or um I guess what is it called flipping rights in other ways it does a couple things differently the main thing I would say is it kind of goes in the direction of cartographers where these games usually involve you're just looking at your own sheet you know some games there's rolling rights out there where you're obviously drafting Dice and determining what your opponent can or can't get but um there aren't many rolling rights out there that really let you mess with your opponent's actual sheet and cartographers was one we talked about and I know it's a conflicting thing and and uh sort of divisive not Everyone likes that but the idea of handing your sheet over to another person who's then going to write something in there and then hand it back to you is a level of you're giving the other players a level of control over your own little worksheet that doesn't really you don't see that in a lot of other rolling right type games and in this one the whole way that you're composing because once that shape is composed you can't rotate it so where you're sitting at the table is
important because when you put that shape together with the other players you have to place it directly onto your sheet in that configuration that orientation you can't rotate it but what that means is that the game ends up if you're playing the game properly and trying to win as the goal of the game is should be always you're basically being asked to look at other players sheets and when you're doing the card placement thing you're kind of thinking well what where am I going to place this so that it's hard for them to place on their sheet so it becomes this thing where if you're not handing over your sheet like in cartographers but you still have a lot of control over what's going on on the other player's sheet but it's while you're working on your own and that's that's what I don't like and that's why I'm going to say it right now that's why this game ends up being a skip it for me all the other things about the game there's nothing spectacular about the game but the the way the board is laid out with your you know there's also like this fireworks scoring where you want to be near the windows you can see the firework shows like there's these little things with the scoring conditions and the one-time abilities that are cool and that I really wanted to like this game more but the way that you have these cards to put together the shape and then the shape may or may not be ideal for your opponents just feels like I don't want to be staring around at everyone else's boards during the game to try and figure can that tile fit where could they put that tile on theirs and I'm but there's also no way to house rule around it because you don't have a deck of cards or you can just say we're gonna place this tile or we're going to place this it's part of the game and it just feels like it's cumbersome it gets in the way it slows things down and when I'm playing a rolling right or flipping right I don't mind saying like drafting
dice or whatever but I don't want to be actively staring at everyone else's sheets trying to figure out what I'm doing to deny them moves it just doesn't fit for that type of game for me so for that reason it's a skip it if you're the type of person who really likes rolling rights a lot you really just like seeing what's out there um couldn't hurt to just play it it the game costs I think like 15 and it takes again 20 30 minutes to play so very low barrier entry but um it's hard for me to recommend anyone go buy this or or try it ahead of you know there's so many other rolling rights out there that I would recommend ahead of it so yeah for me it's going to be a skip it cool I haven't played it I'm going to take your word for it I still like to try it because we don't obviously agree on every game yeah but based on what you're saying I can I I don't think it's going to land with me off in a very different way than it did for you yeah but I'm curious to try it either way because I heard about it before actually I think I'd heard the name before you like bought it or whatever but I knew nothing about it and I until you just started talking about it now I feel like I didn't know much about the rules so and I had I don't remember where I'd heard about it but someone had kind of talked about it as a bit of a Hidden Gem like oh a rolling right that does things a little bit differently and I think part of the reason why it's a skip it is that it's just a crowded field there's just so many rolling rights coming out every year that to say go try this one ahead of you know 20 others or whatever is just yeah it's crowded field so that is Castle party all right next game I'm taking a look at is uh what I'm really excited to talk about and that is Evergreen so Evergreen um is a kind of spiritual successor in many ways to photosynthesis which is a game I really really like um it's over there on the shelf and
maybe you can't see I actually think it's hidden down there um but it kind of reimagines photosynthesis by changing some elements so in photosynthesis and and in Evergreen a lot of what's going on is you basically have the the light from the sun shining from a certain direction on the board and you're manipulating the placement of trees on uh in photosynthesis it's a shared board in Evergreen it's a personal board to be able to get light points based on which of your trees are getting hit by um the sun whatever green does differently is again the biggest thing being you have a personal board instead of a shared board you're working with but they've replaced the like lack of a shared space that we're occupying with this shared card system so essentially we're drafting cards there's going to be say one more card than the amount of players so if you're playing a two-player game when we play for instance since you're gonna have three cards that come available to draft I'm going to draft one you're gonna draft on which everyone remains is going to go to this sort of um I don't even I can't remember the name of what it's called but it's essentially this Collective area and that Collective area based on some icons that are on these cards is going to determine what every different terrain type on your personal board scores for so your personal boards divide into different colors and you're planting trees and Sprouts or um seedlings or whatever they're called to grow into you know mature large trees in each of these different terrains you grow in different trains by the cards you draft the card you draft will have a different terrain color on and almost think like a kingdom Builder being allowed to build in specific areas that's where you're going to be able to take your actions to either grow trees plant new ones or a whole bunch of
different things that come up but the card that gets left like I said when it goes to this Collective area has these icons on it and it's going to determine in that terrain type how many points that the large trees are going to score for at the end of the game and that's where you get a large portion of your points so I can get I can hold draft a whole bunch cards that focus on the the snow area and plant a whole bunch of trees there and get a bunch of large trees in that area but if I don't let a lot of those snow train cars go to the collective area maybe all my large trees only get me a single point and maybe you planted a whole bunch of trees in the desert area and that desert area is every large cruise with five points and suddenly you clean up on points from that one area and that it's too hard for me to overcome that right so it has this amazing thing of it has the elements of photosynthesis which is how do I place my tree so that that's the other thing I didn't mention is from photosynthesis if you have a large tree for instance in front of a small tree and the light shines on that direction the large tree covers the small train you don't get points of the small tree but only a certain number of spaces away yeah so your the position of where you're placing the trees like in photosynthesis matters and the sun's going to move every single round for the four rounds so you have to keep thinking okay maybe this round the light's going to shine in a way that I don't score as many points but when it gets here I'm going to clean up on points and you have to kind of plan when do I grow my trees to try to get as many points as Sun rotates as I can something cool I'm going to just point out real quick is in because I think in photosynthesis the sun did three full laps right yes and in this one it's just one lap so it's only ever going to be on one side once each so you're really planning ahead in terms of well if it's a blocking one way this way
then when the Sun goes around it's not going to come back and yeah anyway in many ways they kind of like streamline some things with photosynthesis and just cleaned up some things they can tell they learn from photosynthesis not that it had like a ton of mistakes or anything but they just said it's almost like how can we make that experience different and better because it seemed to be a popular game or whatever and uh and they've even though photosynthesis had an impressive um table presence with like the all these cardboard trees that you have to build and everything I almost not even almost I prefer Evergreens uh table presence because even though they're like little plastic pieces they feel very satisfying to fit into your double layered player boards which I I'm always a huge fan of dual air player boards um so putting them into those spots replacing things there's River little Rivers there's little bushes um everything like has just they put a lot of care into the table presence of this they didn't they didn't that that's not something they lost from photosynthesis and translate into this new experience um and on top of that I just find that that Collective area whatever it's called I can't remember where you're determining what every terrain is going to score for in terms of the large trees at the end of the game is so much fun to consider because one thing I didn't mention is there's also cards that you cannot draft that go up that go there that will cover the existing um card that say say you have a card in in that area that is the same uh adding three symbols to the grasslands which means that that's an additional three points all large trees are gonna score for if that's the most recent card in that area there's this uh again I wish I knew that I'm really bad with board game terminology I just call things oh it's the green things or it's the red things
whereas you seem to know the names of stuff usually um but there's these cards that are essentially like these Dead Zone type cards that will cover the most recent card that is scoring points at the end of the game and so if it's worth three points and it gets covered you've eliminated um something that's going to score for maybe someone else at the table at the end of the game so if I notice that you are really cleaning up with planting a lot of trees in your grasslands and suddenly there's a card available that I can choose not to draft that is going to eliminate points in the grassland I might purposely not draft that so that it can go there and eliminate points that you're going to get so you're even though it is now a personal space that you're focused on instead of this like shared space we're fighting over that card system makes it very interactive in terms of like keeping players around the table all concerned with what everyone else is doing I was constantly thinking about okay where are you um establishing you know trees compared to where I am are we going to fight for that area am I going to let you have that and try to sabotage you in in the scoring here so that was really cool and then the very last thing I'll mention is that you have a set of actions you can always take on the train uh card that you're drafting but there's also a bonus action on every terrain card so not only do you have to consider do I want to draft this for that terrain do I want to leave it for the area the collective area that's going to score points you also are looking at the bonus and saying do I want that bonus uh action and that bonus action every time you get one it upgrades on your player board and now that bonus action will be better so maybe when I take this bonus action it's plant one uh or grow one tree if I do that enough and I upgrade to the end maybe it's a grow Three Trees now and
because the game you get less and less turns in every round it has this kind of it balances very very well like everything has feels like it's been designed very very strategically and very well so it just feels really satisfying to play and honestly like it's not that this was a surprise to me because I I had I featured it on a new games video it's a game I was really anticipating looking forward to getting and when I found out that it was here locally I went and picked it up but I was surprised still how much I liked it because there was a party that's like oh maybe you won't live up I've played photosynthesis like it's just gonna feel like it's scratching I thought it was going to be way more similar than it was yeah and it's similar in some ways but it also like I don't want to get rid of photosynthesis after playing this and I thought I would I thought I'd want to get rid of photosynthesis but I actually would still love to play both because they still kind of have enough of a difference with the shared board and the player boards that I could see myself being like I want a little bit more Cutthroat like let's fight for positioning here let's play photosynthes so at least right now that could evolve over time but regardless I think you can tell this is an own it for me this is actually one of my favorite games that I've played in 2022 or the key mode in 2022 um my plays came right at the tail end of the year so I honestly didn't even consider this really for like my top 50 or like list like that but I think that you'll probably see this game in my top 10 games of 2022 when I do it because as of right now it is one of my standouts and I just had a really really good time with Evergreen I've played it at two and three player counts I I don't think there'll be much of a difference plan for a a gravitate normally in games to like the three player count just based on like length of time and everything
but it played great at two and three um and the people actually have showed it to which is like you and my other friends um that I play when I play with three have all like when I play the first time with three players both of them are like can we just play it again like it was immediately a hit so I think four would be interesting because you have even less control over which cards go into the scoring area right and just having another an extra player to be divided across all the different uh biomes or whatever they're called I think would be an interesting terrains you know okay again I was I had the advantage of looking at the back of the box while you're talking which is upside down back here yeah anyways but yeah I really I've only played this the one time with you but I really enjoyed it I was really impressed with it um I didn't expect to like it as much as I did I thought it was going to have a lot like even just looking at the back of the box and reading some about the game I kept thinking like is this really going to be that different from photosynthesis and it somehow like has that common DNA while still feeling like a very very different game and um just another shout out to the production like the artwork the quality of the player boards you mentioned they're dual layered but even just the way that everything is like the reminder of what the actions are the iconography the little spots to slot in the Sun as a reminder to like everything just seems like it's been very well thought out for this game um yeah really impressed with it I look for forward to playing it a lot more too awesome game that is Evergreen and that is an element nice all right the last game I'm going to be talking about here today is from 2019 I believe it is and that is it's a wonderful world so this is a uh I guess drafting game uh for one to five players
I think yeah it says on here plays it for 45 minutes that sounds about right I think once you've you're familiar enough with the game you can probably get it done in about half an hour um so I've played this at all five player counts I've played this yeah so I played it in when I first got it I played it in person uh solo and then I think I showed it to you as a two-player game yeah then I played it a whole bunch on board game arena and I've also gone played it in person since so I've probably gotten about 10 or 15 plays total probably split half and half from uh physical as well as the BGA version so basically if you're familiar with games like seven wonders or sushi go um that's the kind of core of this game is you it plays over four rounds and every round at the start of the round you're gonna get Delta hand of cards and you're gonna pick one card pass the rest to the person on your left and and then you're going to do that again basically pick another one pass the leftover cards and you keep doing that until you've drafted all the cards but unlike in games like seven wonders or sushi go where you draft the card and it immediately just goes into play you automatically play the cards in this game after you've drafted all like when you draft a card you kind of hang on to it and after everyone's done their drafting phase you look at the seven cards that you've drafted and you have to decide whether you're going to construct them or recycle them so you only have those two options for your card so you can either put them down in your construction zone in front of you which means you're committing them to your construction zone where it means you're going to start working towards building them throughout the game and they won't actually do anything for you until they're like the building is complete or you can recycle it basically the resort the card is going to have its
building costs on one side but on the other side it's going to show which resource you can get from it if you recycle the cards so anything that you recycle you put those resources immediately on the cards in your construction zone as soon as the cost on any card fills up in your construction zone you basically build that card it goes into your little uh Empire and then the last phase in the round is basically a production phase where you go through these five resource types and everyone simultaneously produces resources based on how many um resources that type are showing on their initial Empire card along with the other cards that they've built so at the start of the game there's these double-sided uh faction starting cards where you can start where everyone is on the same page kind of thing everyone has the same starting resources or you can play with the asymmetric side where everyone has a slightly different starting kind of um Direction they're going in so this game is it's very clean very streamlined very focused there's there isn't like you know when I compare it to a game like seven wonders Seven Wonders you have you know you have your military cards where you're uh like fighting with your neighbors so at the end of each age you're comparing strength with your neighbors on the sides and you know there's cards that score in different ways you've got your science cards that score one way and you have cards that um you know make other cards easier to build because of the cost is factored in there's all those kinds of things in Seven Wonders this game doesn't really have any of that it is really focused on the Drafting and the engine building aspect of it because for the most part you're going to be getting cards that you know it might cost three or four resources to build this card but every production phase you might get two or
three resources out of it sometimes a different type so you're thinking is it worth it can I get this thing built early enough in the game that I'm gonna see the return on this investment if I spend four resources to build it now am I going to get six or seven by the end of the game to kind of make that back then you have cards that'll say you know this gives you three points at the end of the game for every a green card okay well then how many of these green cards do you really want to try to build or what direction do you want to go with your strategy so it really is just about getting the cards together to kind of synergize off each other in combo there isn't really a whole lot more going on in the game other than you know every uh when you're doing those the production of those resources you're comparing with other players and whoever produced the most of that resource gets a small little benefit that gives you one point at the end of the game basically so the you pretty much already know how to play the majority of the game it's it's something I've enjoyed every time I've played but I've always had this slightly empty feeling at the end of like I was expecting a little more I don't know what it is about it um I think it's the fact so before we go any further I'll say this one is a play it for me and it's pretty square right in the middle of like it wasn't really close like it would I would say closer to own than a skip for sure because I think it is a really solid drafting game one of the better drafting games I've played the reason why for me it's a play it is that the player interaction is very low um a lot of the time with these types of games and I've mentioned this before with regular Seven Wonders I mentioned it with seven wonders duel when we talked about that in another video but a lot of the time these types of games the longer the game goes on the more obvious your decisions become and especially I found in this game you know
you have this starting Empire that gives these green resources okay now you start getting these green cards now you have one green card that says three points for every Green Card you've completed then you know get another one you start building that says two points for every green card so now suddenly realizing every green card is Five Points yeah why would I ever draft a card that is not green for the rest of the game unless it's something that I know I can't build right so sometimes the game points you in a direction where you look at a hand of seven cards and I'm like oh that's obvious I'll take the one green one because why would I build this gold card that does nothing for me so too often I find it's just pick the one card that obviously works past the rest a lot of the time you're not gonna see a lot of those cards coming back to you and in drafting games if I'm going to be doing what's called hate drafting like drafting to deny my opponent I would like there to be some other interactive aspect that comes into play where I can see the results rather than just knowing haha Dylan's not going to get that blue card and he'll never know because I'm just gonna recycle it or whatever so I mean that feels good too I'm sure yeah there's there's a part about it that feels good but and the reason why this ends up being a plate and something that I don't think is going to last in my collection forever is that it's for this kind of um level of rules complexity the play time a predominantly card based game that plays in that kind of 30 minute to an hour range there's just too many other games that like it's this the competition's way too stiff like race for the Galaxy res Arcana Innovation or all kind of card based games that fall in that time frame even if I'm gonna play something that isn't drafting like if I'm gonna play a card game I might rather play something but ends or Arboretum that has more player interactions so yeah it's fine I've
enjoyed it every time I've played it it's just it's not something that I think I'm going to be the one to suggest anymore so we'll see how much people suggest that when they come over to play it but um otherwise yeah I don't know how much more of It's a Wonderful World I'll be playing but um yeah it's a very clean smooth playing game yeah it's been a while since I played it with you I remember liking it I remember the one of the only reason things that kept me from like even considering getting my own copy was I thought at the time I'll just wait and get it it's a wonderful Kingdom because you'll have a world in our kingdom looking great and whatever um one question for you yeah is it a Wonderful World then I mean or is it just a fine world the so I would say the world that it creates is a bit like uh what's the word I'm looking for not generic because like the artwork is really nice it's nice to look at the card and kind of Imagine but it doesn't it's sort of what you've said about what game was it was it ethanos where you mentioned that it doesn't feel like it's its own world it just kind of feels like a sort of this it kind of feels like generic futuristic art kind of thing like yeah I don't know the world that's our alternative I think it's a great word it's a great game it's just it's not a must own and it's never going to be you know one of the first games I pull off the shelf but uh it's solid and if you haven't played it I highly recommend everyone at least check it out so that is it's a wonderful world and that was published by Lucky Dog Games nice all right last game I'm taking a look at here is libertalia the Winds of galecrest and I do have to thank stonemeyer games for sending us this copy uh to review
um we have featured this on the channel in multiple different ways this showed up in my top 50. I'm not going to tell you where you'll have to watch the video um but it was uh it was pretty high um and I think I mentioned in another video of games I was playing or like games I played last month or something like they should have been I think it was our first impressions of cabin weekend games or something like that because yeah we got to try it we've talked about a couple times um I'm not even gonna get beat around the bush I'm just gonna say right off the bat this is one of my favorite games period um after playing this I never played the original libertalia um so I came into this without having that experience to compare to I'm not sure if like I had played the original libertalia and if that already would have been like one of my favorite games then this I would have had either different opinions of or maybe it wouldn't have hit me as hard as it did whatever the case is libertal wins a gale Crest is some of the most fun I've had with board gaming um since we started this channel like in a new game that I've started playing and not only that but we've played it at three and we've played it at six which is I guess the lowest not the lowest player I think you can play it too but I don't think I never recommend it isn't there even a solo mode too yeah one to three right um but I feel like three is probably like the least amount of people I'd want to play with yeah the max player account and I loved it at both and I actually think I preferred it at six and I I almost wonder if it sticks might end up being my favorite player account maybe not like it might end up being four or five just based on it definitely the most chaotic and fun yeah that's it and that's the thing is like libertal is at its most fun when it's when it's chaotic uh just a little overview of what it is essentially you
you have this row at the top of the board everyone's gonna start the game and the end cards go in this road that you're gonna be playing from your hand everyone's gonna start the game with the exact same amount of cards it's gonna be randomized there's 40 characters you're all we're going to determine which of these 40 characters which six we're gonna all start with we're all gonna have that same hand of cards they're gonna have that knowledge but once you've played a character except for certain abilities that might bring them back it's essentially going to be the one time you play that character in the game um each round you're not going to get through all six of those characters so some people are gonna wait to play certain characters and carry them over to Future rounds hands are going to start to deviate in that way where I might have played a certain card early you might have held held that character into like round three or something but they all have an ability to associate with them the abilities will leave the trigger during the daytime phase which triggers left to right at the top of the board and that's the first thing we're going to calculate then we go right to left backwards which is the the even your desk phase or whatever it's called and we're going to trigger um any abilities on those cards that happen in that phase as well as at that point when you trigger that ability you're also going to pick a loop token that's available on that round blue tokens have a variety of abilities you can change from game to game what abilities those blue tokens are going to have there's two sides to the board there's tiles you can actually place on the board so you can customize and have like some from the one side of the board some from the second side of the board and just be clear loot doesn't always good there are some bad yeah there's some bad loot tokens that you want to avoid which makes it really interesting because then you have to play a character and think I want this ability to trigger early but if it triggers early and I'm the last one to pick loot I might get stuck with a loot that I don't want it so it's that kind of decision making that makes
libertalia so much fun is you're thinking about things not in like a straightforward uh level like oh this is a good ability I'm going to play it it's it's maybe a good ability but is someone else going to play a character that you know is in play because you have it in your hand and that ability would cancel yours out and now you have to try to lead the people around the table and say who's going to play that now and do I wait to play this character until everyone's played those characters and then later on I cash in there's a character that has been in every game we've played called the win nymph that specifically has this effect where if there's only one Wyndham uh in play at a time like because once you play it to the the board it'll eventually come back to your ship in front of you if they are the only wind name if you're gonna cash in every single round and be getting income from you getting gold from that but as soon as someone else plays a win nymph those two win nymphs cancel each other out and get discarded but that means someone has to play a win of essentially just to get rid of yours and depending where if most people go and play a win nymph the first one might cancel the one out and then next person might get to put there wouldn't even play and have a win nymph so like that makes more sense than you play but essentially this is the kind of decision your decisions you're thinking about it's what is everyone else going to do who's played what character cards what's still left in play what do I like you're trying to read everyone around the table while also managing which abilities you want to trigger how much gold do you want to or how much gold you can collect which loot tokens are available um there's just so much stuff about it that is so much fun like to to do like every game has decision making every game has like multiple not every game but like lots of games have other like
multiple things you're thinking about and multiple decisions at the same time or what's this player gonna do for some reason libertalia just feels like such a marriage of all those elements in a way that is so satisfying to me and so fun it's a pure fun experience and one of the big things that they added into this version that I've heard wasn't available in libertalia is the reputation track and be that the reputation track is essentially a way to have a tiebreaker for when you play character cards that have the same number if I play a character that is 25 and you play 25 normally we order them on the board in terms of initiative now if you have two the same I can't remember I don't even know what decided that the tie the tiebreaker in the original libertalia but the reputation track is a really interesting way to do it because if you have high reputation you'll break ties but you get less income less gold to start each round so it's a balancing act of can I be in a certain position when I want to do one thing and then can I switch my reputation to maximize how much gold I'm getting inside around built-in to play off of that like lose a bunch of reputation but get a bunch of gold as a reward or little things you can play around with your reputation throughout the game too yeah it's a it's a chaotic game but yeah it's like what's a chaotic game that even when you're getting completely screwed over by it's not luck it I mean some of it is like there's definitely luck yeah but but it's but a lot of it is also like trying to say you remember things like oh how many I think it's the brood like how many brutes are left or whatever which are gonna kill my character like I remember doing that in Alaska play being like I think five boots of in play which means I'm the last brute and and that means I should be able to play this
without worrying about someone else destroying my character yeah but have I remembered that correctly and if there is still on brood and play is someone gonna play it now like yeah there's so much yeah when you lose I end up just laughing I remember Brayden getting having the worst luck with a lot of stuff when you play a three-player game at the cabin and it seemed like he was having a blast with it still because it's still such a fun experience yeah so because it's mine it's not just bad luck as in like I rolled the dice and the dice was a bad role or whatever the luck comes from like the Mind Games with the other players and you might feel like you were unlucky because someone else played the same card as you but like again you didn't just roll dice someone had to make that choice it just didn't work out for you but it all comes basically from the Mind Games right like this is uh this is an emphatic own it for me uh I love this game I think it's gonna climb over the years this might end up being one of my all-time favorite games I mean it's possible that after multiple plays I just start to tie rapid but it's not like it's not often I play board games unless they're on BGA it's not often I all play like a single game in a year like you know 20 30 times or something and I feel like that's what it would take for me to Tire of libertalia because there's a variety of player counts it's it's different enough that each player can in terms of like how combative it is and the decision and how much you're thinking about other cards of the table that I I could see myself enjoying a four player game or a three-player game much different than I would at six six is like I'm just like I'm feeding into the chaos I'm okay with them like this is going to be chaotic I'm gonna try my best to plan but I'm not gonna be able to plan very more well at three you're you're it's easier to keep track of certain cards and you're maybe being a little more tactical
thinking I know this card's the only place so I'm gonna try to bait that card out and right so I just it even changed the dynamic of the loot tiles when there's like three instead of six right because just changes how badly you either do or don't want to go for them or yeah it's it's just it's a phenomenal game in my opinion I love it um I think that if you haven't played the the original uh definitely I would just start with this version I haven't played the original I'm not saying the original is bad but from what I understand and based on what I've read this just seems to improve on different elements of the original to make it a better experience and I just think that it's more colorful inviting package especially if you're wanting to you know include a lot of different types of Gamers the original has a more gritty like pure realistic pirate look to it yeah when this is just a bit more fun and colorful and I think you could convince more people to at least give it a shot because the rules aren't very complex in here like there's stuff to teach But ultimately it just comes down to learning all the the characters and when they trigger the biggest thing is when do these abilities trigger and what goes left to right and what goes right to left but it's good because that you don't even have to teach that stuff in advance the the abilities are on the cards and even the loot tokens are on the board so you can explain the basic rules and then get them reading the cards or the loot token abilities as the game's already going so and in some games you have to some someone's like I want to ask you a question but I don't want you to know what's in my hand this is so easy because you can I can explain every single card and everyone has the same hand right so every time we draw new cards in each round I can say let's go over all the character cards does anyone have any questions you can kind of teach those things as you go very easily so I think one of the most valuable things about this game too is like you mentioned at the start the
player count and playing really well from three to six we haven't played it with two yet or solo yeah and the play time too is like the fact that it's I think it says in the Box even 45 yeah 45 to 60 minutes and the fact that it's all simultaneous play there's no down time like there aren't many games that fit into that situation where you don't want to play a party game you want to play kind of like a meteor game still but you have five six players there right so yeah yeah that's a great game last thing I'll say is this is also cemented even further Paulo Mori is one of my favorite designers yeah it's one of those accidental finds like I forget that I'm playing palomori games whether it be like Caesar I was gonna say 2022 is that the year of Paul O'Malley between ethno Caesar and libertalia those are three games I like I love all those games not just like I love all three of those games he's also done via Magica which isn't quite as good as those but still very good yeah no it's a it's solid game I I can't recommend it enough check it out it might not be for everybody but I think that uh more than not people are going to get a lot of fun out of this game and really that's just what matters the board games is if you're having fun and I've had more fun with this than I have a lot of games you just have to embrace the chaos and uncertainty and if you can do that you'll love it it's a really good game those are the six games we're covering let us know in the comments what you think of these games if you've played them do you agree with our verdicts do you disagree which ones surprised you the most which games do you want us to cover in future owner plants gifts let's recap our verdicts real quick for anyone who might have just uh skipped we had abandoned artichokes was a play it Castle party was a skip it and it's a wonderful world was to play it for me yep and for you I've got Maui was a skip it for me Evergreen wasn't on it and libertali once again Crest wasn't on it as well to
own it and a skip it and you had two players and a no yes two players yeah cool nice little variety yeah so yeah let us know in the comments what you think otherwise thank you so much for watching and we'll see you next time foreign