Finding the right mixture of luck and skill with Richard Garfield
Transcript
what's up my friends and welcome to the board game Design Lab today got a little bgl rewind episode and this one comes all the way from May of 2018 where I was talking to Richard Garfield one of the greatest game designers ever right the guy that created Magic the Gathering King of Tokyo and just so many other amazing games and we get into that we talk about him designing several of these games but the overall topic is Luck versus skill Richard has some really insightful advice and ideas on that dichotomy of you know adding Luck versus adding skill versus the tension trying to find the right balance of those two things in a game and some of the things he said a little a little bit controversial had some some people you know got their feathers ruffled just a little bit by some of his I wouldn't say hot takes but just interesting ideas as far as luck and what constitutes luck and and where where does luck show up in games and this is just one of my absolute favorite conversations that I've ever had on the show and so I wanted to bring it back and either share it with you for the first time or remind you of this episode if you heard it back in 2018 Richard welcome to the show hi good to be here yeah man glad that you're here I mean you've designed games Magic the Gathering King of Tokyo Robo rally Android Netrunner I mean the list just goes on and on to some of the amazing games you've put together and what I love about your games is they're they're not just like one type of game like you
have uh so many different games on the the spectrum of luck versus skill and so I'm excited to to get into it with you today but just real quick maybe people never heard of you what's your bio how'd you get into game design all that good stuff uh sure um I was aimed towards an academic career I was uh teaching at math and working on my PhD when uh I finished magic and it came out and that sort of uh took me away from uh the academic world and into game design before that I had been serious about game design but I had been uh into it as a hobby U I decided that game design was really a poor place to stake your future um I was probably probabilistically I was right but uh but the world has changed now also and so things are a lot better for uh game designers all over after magic came out I worked with uh Wizards of the Coast for maybe six years and did a bunch of games with them including uh several more trading card games and uh since then I left uh formed a consulting company three donkeys and from three donkeys have worked on game design textbook taught some uh done a lot of game design consultation and uh designed a lot of games as well and uh I've always been interested in games in
their totality I I like uh seeing games including children's games Sports party games strategy games war games I like to see them all as in one family and uh have tried to diversify myself as much as possible yeah for sure now magic came out what in the early 90s am I remember that right yeah 93 yeah and so how surprised were you that it took off and did the way that it did and kind of took you down this road I I was very surprised perpetually surprised for years where uh I would hear some report about how well it was doing and it was sort of continually exceeding expectation um I never uh I never really expect I never dreamed that uh I knew that magic was a good game because my play testers couldn't stop playing it but uh but I also knew that there were a lot of games I loved which weren't particularly successful so uh that was sort of what I was expecting yeah and Magic has done such an incredible job of bringing so many people into the hobby it was one of the first games I ever got into and I was in college that's that's what my friends are playing they kind of hooked me in and and a whole bunch of packs of cards later I had all these decks and we were playing and that's actually what led me into board games in general I know there's a lot of people who have a very similar story and so it's just really cool to see how how games have changed since then and all but I'm excited to get into the topic so let's talk about
Luck versus skill this is something you've talked about in the past but before we get rolling give me just a good definition of luck and a good definition of skill what do you what do you say that those things are well that uh that gets to the Crux of it doesn't it uh and uh they are hard to design sorry they are hard to Define um and a lot of people's confusion over luck and skill I think often comes from uh valid definitions but that are sort of self-contradictory so in different contexts they will mean different things so but in general the way I Define luck is the amount of variance in G in the game so uh uh if if there's a lot of swing in how it plays out among players of about equal skill then that's a measure of luck there's a lot of luck or sorry of dispar skill of equal skill that's all that's got all that's going on is that uh that suway and uh how consistently people can win when they're better than one another that's a measure of skill gotcha and so kind of what you're talking about the Crux of the issue you've talked in the past about this kind of false dichotomy people have of luck versus skill putting those two things on opposite ends of the spectrum you don't see it that way so tell me a little bit more about what you how you see it and kind of what you mean by this false dichotomy it's very common to hear people say oh the game is all luck or there's uh there's no skill in the game because it's all luck um and and I definitely uh see it as being more of
a of a a Continuum of plane you can have high luck High skill low luck low skill and anywhere in between now the the the statement that something with high luck can't have high skill isn't entirely incorrect what that uh what that is what that means is if the payoff for for your skill is low then it'll have higher luck if it if the payoff for your luck is high then you'll have lower skill so so the amount of benefit you get for your skill and luck do vary with one another but the thing is that that when people say oh it's high luck and so therefore low skill um and they it's usually said in sort of a dismissive way that is true your skill won't have as high a payoff but by most people's definition it'll have just as much skill possibly so to illustrate that uh I use toy games to illustrate game Concepts and toy games are games which uh um you wouldn't play because they're not meant to be fun but they do illustrate something which is really easy to see so one of the games which uh I developed to demonstrate that point is uh Rando chess and so in Rando chess what you do is you play it you play a game of chess and then afterwards you roll a die and if you roll a one then the winner is the loser the loser is the winner Okay so everybody would agree that has more luck than chess but it is also pretty clear that by most people's definition of luck it has the same skill
as chess you're going to have exactly the same if you did if you played this on a a world scale you would have the same people would high ratings would be rated high on this game if they're rated high in chess and it would be every book on strategy would apply to this game as well um and you can tweak this as much as you like right you can uh you can make it so that 49% of the time you switch side you switch the results and and so there it's almost entirely luck but still there's just as much skill so illustrations of uh games at the various checkpoints you would say that U chess or go is uh High skill low luck poker is high skill High luck roulette is no skill High luck uh and uh tic-tac-toe might be low skill and low lock gotcha now I'm I'm intrigued by this whole tool games thing this is something I've actually heard you speak on in the past I think the listeners of the podcast would really benefit from can you tell me some more of the the toy games you've come up with and kind of the concepts that you prove through those games yeah uh so here's a good one um and in fact relevant to this uh this talk of luck versus skill my definition of luck implies that there's luck in a game like chess okay not much it's a high skill game low luck but there is some and people often have uh trouble accepting that and many people even after thinking about a long time don't accept it but the toy game I developed to illustrate that point is uh uh called guess a digit
of pi and so in this game I give you uh a number say 3,470 and you have to guess what that digit of pi is the 3, 470th digit and you got five minutes now and you can't use Google or anything like that um so that is uh totally deterministic and for almost everyone uh the their chances of winning it are one and 10 it's a game of pure luck but you could calculate it and uh and you might even have it memorized uh if you were really serious about this game um and uh um so so this works uh to show how complexity luck can come about and uh so in practice this guess is digit toie is very much like chess the human brain isn't built for it and you sort of manage it as much as you can and in practice it comes down to a coin toss which uh most people accept now in chess there's this just wonderful uh set of fistic which you use to improve your game and it's it's very uh uh it's a enjoyable and addictive to explore it and improve upon it but when you make a call between two close moves you're uh using these imperfect charistics and basically you've got these two doors of complexity which you can't see through and you're G to choose one and you're gonna open it and and maybe there's a
winning game down there maybe there isn't uh you don't really know if you knew you'd be playing tip tat toe and so that's how luck comes into a game like chess and that's how a toy game might illustrate that yeah and so how much of this is just just down to people's perceptions because a lot of times they'll say oh there's too much luck in that game and maybe it's because they lost and they just hope that there was a lot of luck and and to kind of cover up you know maybe they weren't playing very well or as effectively as they wanted to how much of it is just perception well a lot of it is perception uh the too much luck in there are of course different players with different tastes and some people will like less luck and more luck can they identify what luck is often times they will be mistaken about what the luck is and certainly if they see a lot of luck they often assume there's not much skill but often times they're right so one of the one of the places where uh players might justly say there's too much luck is uh if they feel like the game is uh often decided by one luck event and that that can be really frustrating to players particularly if the game is longer and so so if they play for 45 minutes and they feel like it was all decided by who went first uh which was a coin toss or you know who rolled the six at the end that's okay once in a while but uh but if that's sort of how the game often plays out it feels bad but they often blame luck more they identify luck as being bad there which is true
it's sort of taed on but you can say the same thing about uh skill events as well you could have a 45 minute game that's VAR skill testing but then it's all tested by this one particular skill and I guess a toy game to illustrate that might be uh you you play chess but then at the end you determine who won the game by an arm wrestling match um so it's it's tacked on in the same way that this die roll in the game is tacked on so a lot of uh my design when I'm trying to mitigate the luck it's often less a matter of reducing the luck than sort of baking it in so it doesn't feel like it's tacked in so it feels like it's spread out a little more gotcha I want to I want to talk talk to you about that in just a second but going back to the toy games are these things that you come up with just for fun just kind of pondering and daydreaming or do you come up with these Concepts while you're working on a game design or something like that to kind of help you along in your process uh yeah I don't use them for game design I use them uh when I'm thinking about games in general um so if I identify something which I like in a game or don't like uh I'll often try to think about what the game design implications are of it and and uh uh I'm very academically interested in games the the the book I wrote with two co-authors is characteristics of games and we use a lot of uh toy toy games in these books to sort of demonstrate things but uh when you think
about uh a characteristic of games like its complexity skill its luck uh oftentimes you're wrestling with a lot of different casual definitions and so when you begin trying to pin down what you actually mean it often helps to come up with toy games to sort of uh see what that feels like gotcha now you mentioned that that book was a textbook is that I mean is that used in college classes or High School classes that kind of thing uh yeah it's used in college classes very cool man yeah I'm working on some things I teach High School I teach 10th and 12th grade and we're working on some gamification kind of things right now and so I'm I'm me I need to check out your your book it might be some things I could bring into my classroom with helping these kids kind of understand what we're doing game-wise sure uh and so all right let's talk about how designers can use luck to make better games now there's some players out there that say no luck take out all the luck and that'll make it the best game possible but I don't believe that I don't think you believe that so how can we use luck to make better board games well uh actually by my definition of luck I don't think they think it either um because as I said I think there's luck in chess right um so uh what they're really interested in is what sort of luck is there and this luck and chess another way to illustrate it is uh when you watch kids play Tic-Tac-Toe most of your audience has probably mastered Tic Tac Toe probably quite a while ago and uh they dismiss it perhaps without thinking about it too much but if you actually watch like kids
playing for the first time and even for years after that it's it's actually a real game and uh you see this uh progression that they take which seems like it has to be analogous to how we we're playing chess they begin out and it's random and you know it's totally random it's frustrating to see well the first kid that sees they can get the third the third uh EX in a row that they're going to win oh they missed it right or they didn't see they could block it block something and uh and and it it feels like chance and then they begin uh learning things like uh how to spot a threat how to spot how to block a threat how to set up double threats and eventually uh they get to a point where they've mastered the game and whoever goes first either wins or or or gets a draw so it's really not a matter to me of how much luck there is it's well it's often a matter of how much luck there is but uh it's uh for most people who are critical of luck is what sort of luck it is uh they often don't like dice um they often don't like cards these are overt luck elements but then there's game theoretic luck uh for instance uh where where we both secretly choose a strategy at the same time so rock paper scissors most people would say uh has a lot of luck in it uh but it is if you look at it right also totally
deterministic and there actually is skill to it in practice uh if you're playing against somebody who's rolling and die there's no skill but if you're playing against you know your little brother or something uh and you're trying to uh out guess each other there actually is skill and when you extend game theoretic things to uh to more broadly to other games uh then there's a lot of this uh predict what your opponent does and uh if you do that correctly you'll get some sort of advantage that's luck too that's often very acceptable to the people who don't like uh don't like luck in their games or don't like air quotes luck in their games yeah and so it's it's about the luck that the these people prefer like you said it's it's lucky if I guess what strategy you're going to do or what you're going to pick and all that that that's a lucky guess for the most part but I guess I would say if I did that then I I had some skill-based knowledge and I made these good decisions and all that assuming I got it right and if I got it wrong I'd say oh this is all just luck is that kind of how it would work that that certainly can be how it works uh I think all these things wind down to uh people like when I say there's luck in chess that's deeply disturbing to some players because they're very tied up in this dichotomy of uh if there's luck then there's no skill or or that it somehow reduces the skill right and and all these games sort of have this uh game theoretic luck is is marvelous because it's uh it's it's so hard to gauge how much of it is skill and how much of it is luck and in the end it's
always going to be some percentage like you might be a very skillful player which means you guess correctly 80% of the time and uh but that but that's really 80% of the time that means sometimes you mis guess and you know is that luck uh is that skill well the fact that you get it 80% of the time is is certainly skill and the fact that you sometimes fail is part of the luck yeah it's funny I'm sitting here thinking about like I come out of a a athlete football background and just thinking back like it seems that the the guys that had the most skill also tended to be the most lucky like the ball bouncing just the way it needed to to them to you for them to make a play or score or something like that and so it's kind of interesting to think about how we say oh that was just a lucky play but it tends to happen more often to Skilled players than it does to unskilled players well that's a when when you Embrace uh luck as something you work with in your skill you get a a very rich area of games and uh and I I think oftentimes the people who are very interested in deterministic games don't really appreciate that part of gameplay which is is okay you know there's lots of games out there for everybody but uh I personally uh like games where crazy unlucky things can happen and then as a player uh I have to figure out how to deal with that I don't just flip the table and say oh this game is garbage right um and uh and know maybe I lose but maybe I have an epic comeback and and maybe I put all my eggs
in one basket and I'm hoping for the lucky rooll that'll bring me back into the game and then people will look at that one lucky role and say you got lucky and and and I'll say say well that's true but the only reason I had to get lucky is because I got so unlucky early that's a a sort of a common a story that comes up in card games a lot early on they were announcing the first big tournaments of magic and we got on some of the announcers because they they were following the game very closely and they were saying oh he has to top deck the right card to win here he top decked it it's crazy how did he do that but if you looked at the previous like 10 turns he could have drawn that card any time during there and won the game yeah right and and but they're just looking at this last one event and saying oh it was all draw all determined by that uh uh that one top deck it was entirely a win of luck but it you have to look at the game as a whole not just this one event right absolutely and and it's also a skill to build a deck in Magic where you have the opportunity to win like that I mean that is very much a skill in and of itself yeah yeah that's true and another illustration of luck in a game like magic uh uh early on we were playing seal deck games so those games were are ones where you're uh given a deck and some uh some boosters and you have to strip it down to a deck and you play a tournament and we were trying to make that a part of the pro tour and uh and
and get people to play it seriously we did it for a while but we had some uh I remember having some French players who complained that this for format was all luck and they always lost and they they did not see that that's uh that that is a contradiction right there if it's all luck you can't always lose right right there would be some kind of percentage of you winning at least some of the time right definitely all right so earlier you talked about mitigating luck and and finding ways to bake it into the game so it's a little it's harder to see it doesn't feel tacked on give me some ways that you do that or some good ways that you've seen other people do it but just tell me about how you how do you bake that luck mitigation in so players enjoy it without even realizing it there's there's a lot of different techniques and it takes a lot of different forms and and you might uh it's it's actually analogous to uh making it so that there's no strategic element which dominates either so uh but that's often easier to see so for example if you have a card game and uh you score single points for the first two hands and then the third hand because you want want the game to be exciting at the end you make it count 10 times points well that's not going to sit well because the first two games are kind of almost a waste of time right um and so you mitigate that by making it so well maybe it's two times or maybe there's just a bonus for the winner a flat bonus you try to soften that and so it's a similar thing with luck where uh you're making it so that uh a particular
card isn't the I win the game card but uh but that it can give you an advant under the right circumstances in particular if you uh uh plan for it or or something like that so you you make it you make the powerful cards ones that you have to plan a little bit more for and uh the the uh very lucky events not dominate the game but give a person uh time to uh recover from things like that or you can make the game short uh which is often a way to uh deal if you've got a game where uh the luck feels uh like it's tacked on then sometimes what you just need is a shorter game because you can make it about play the game assuming there's some skill you know maybe you get your 60% chance to win and you uh roll the die and you win or not and then you go on and play another game and uh over the course of the evening you uh you you sort of stitch them together into a one longer uh session which is inevitably more strategic also a little less luck gotcha now a moment ago you mentioned how luck can bring this drama to a game and and I that's one of the things I love about games is how they they emulate real life it's a little bit chaotic there's lucky things that happen lucky breaks and chances and all that but talk to me about how you kind of use luck to build that drama in in some of your games I'm thinking about like King of Tokyo it's like okay I just need that one this one die roll and then I'll have enough damage to kill you and then I'll be the winner like what are some ways that you've really brought drama into your games through luck my games uh I often try to just uh make sure that
there's a certain amount of luck involved um and and I think that when you have it and it's integrated into the game in a good way you naturally get this uh dramatic element the players can get lucky or unlucky and uh if the game progresses longer that fortune can reverse um this is in contrast to a game where uh it's low luck and you often and sometimes in those games uh if you aren't as skilled as the other player you get off to a bad start you feel like you can't catch up MH uh luck is a marvelous way to get come from behind victories uh and and to see that happen is is is very satisfying often uh and that's you know really when you start thinking about what makes drama in a game uh that's one of the big things is can your plans be disrupted that's drama and can you come from behind and actually win that's drama and luck really helps both those things happen yeah for sure I know one of the worst feelings in games is if I'm playing a game and I know it's over and I know I have no chance of winning but I still have to play out the next five turns just to get to the end where you win or somebody else wins like that's not enjoyable where luck can kind of change that a little bit and if you think about what a story is at its heart it's tension and resolution and luck has a great way of just introducing tension into a game that can be resolved in some really dramatic ways there's a game I I really like called quad radius and uh it's a it's a computer game you can play
it on the web um and it's got a small dedicated audience and uh every once in a while I play it and I get really into it for a month and then I have to quit because it's too addictive but it is a huge amount of luck in it you've got these chest pieces and you're basically moving around and trying to squash the other person's chest pieces but then these powerups appear randomly and you jump on them and your chest piece gets a special power which your opponent doesn't know about and these powers are very swingy and so then there's bluffing because uh if you've got a power up piece and you move into a particular area it might be a they might interpret as a threat and retreat but it's not a threat because you got garbage a garbage power and uh and I've taught this to uh other players or I've got them to play it and and oftentimes they'll play it and they say oh you know like my opponent got this power up and I just lost it was ridiculous it's just too much luck the thing is that the more you play it the more you realize that what the luck is doing for the game uh for example when I'm playing against a better player and I get the upper hand it's like I cannot slowly win the game like uh be play the sort of game which I'm really comfortable being doing which is is sort of slowly tightening the tightening the Noose because the longer I go the longer they have a chance to pick up the to to pick up something which their skill uh will allow them to uh turn into a weapon against me and and bring bring themselves back into the game and so you get these situations where uh just a game a normal game if
there was a very it was a low luck game you look at it and say oh this player has definitely won the number of times in this game you've seen that turn around is just it makes it uh very exciting yeah definitely all right so talk to me about like your process when you're working on a game you got to design of of balancing the luck and the skill and trying to tweak things so it's at just the right place where you want it to be not that it's you know one or the other but that it's kind of in that place of of your of the experience you're trying to create right I don't see them as a dichotomy but but I do see Luck versus skill as a uh how much the the payoff is for the player like how much you can leverage your skill yeah and uh I look for the the some of the key things I look for is if players frequently get into a situation where other players don't feel like they can catch up I begin to wonder if there's too much skill in the game because because that's sort of a sign of too much skill and uh and if players don't feel like a matters what they do then that's a sign there might be too much luck in the game and uh this is going to change from audience to audience but uh but that in my play test groups that's that's what I look look for that reminds me of a uh another uh toy game sort of a since I Define skill the way I Define skill is that the more skillful player should always win uh and if they don't that's bad luck uh that makes sort of of the ultimate High
skill game being a game like who's taller and uh and uh so if I've got a I'm I'm 5 foot 10 and I've got a six foot three players every time we play that I lose and uh that's and and sprinting is often another example of like a very high skill game the better Sprinter is almost always going to win and against me they will always win yeah definitely all right and so when you're like in that play testing process what are you what are you looking at are you looking at like how players respond to certain elements of the game or or kind of their experience like as you watch them around the table like what do you look for when they're experienc in your games and and how do you kind of tweak things accordingly oftentimes with play testers there's a lot of interpretation to what they say they often think something's wrong with the game and if they think there's something wrong with the game there is something wrong with the game uh but but often times they can't put their finger on it and their explanation for it isn't exactly what it is so I often try to listen to what they're uh I listen to what they're saying but then I try to think of what the underlying problem really is and so uh with regards to Luck versus skill the way it might come out is that they're trying to play a particular strategy and it isn't working and they don't feel like they can play it any better to get it to work now there's no rule saying every strategy
has to be usable and in fact that's a formula for a non-game because of every strateg is useful then then there really is no strategy right um so uh for example in Magic if I want to play the strategy of all lands you know I'll lose but there's no reason why that has to be a viable strategy but if in Magic I want to play an all spell deck and I really feel like like that should be possible um and I I can't do it uh because the Spells don't you know all say they all reference creatures or something like that um then I might start saying being frustrated and saying oh the Spells aren't powerful enough now what I'm uh I'm saying the Spells aren't powerful enough but what I'm uh really responding to is the fact that I want to do this thing and I can't do it so as a designer you've got to understand you've got to sort of decipher that and uh decide should this thing be something which is a part of the game uh and oftentimes it's like oh that's a cool idea I hadn't even thought about trying to do that let's you know throw some elements into the game uh tweak the the point payoff or the types of cards out there to make that more viable and uh and and then uh uh get that strategy to be uh to be something that works yeah definitely now were there any cards or or I'm trying to think of the right word for in Magic like any kind of themes or mechanisms that you came up up with they were just way too lucky they were just way too
swingy and players just hated that you had to like pull it out uh I I have had many many different magic cards which are pulled been been pulled for many different reasons uh like I remember I think you've talked about like the Pixies or something like that in the past it was just like this crazy kind of thing yeah the Pixies uh the Pixies were ones where that when they hit the opponent you would swap two cards between your hands and uh I wouldn't say that got pulled because it was too much luck it was just because uh people began to Value their cards and they didn't want to be you know trading their whatever $30 card for uh for the other person's sticky land right because it was permanent right it wasn't like just doing the game yeah yeah yeah yeah so so uh that's an example I've had again many many many cards pulled uh uh for many reasons uh uh I wouldn't put that on luck but uh but that was was was one that was pulled and uh I I I'm actually I'm sure there there is a a correct answer to this that that that I've had some that were too too luck dependent the thing is that with magic you can often tweak it so that it does work and I'm I'm pretty sure there were some cases where we couldn't figure out a good way to tweak it but like if you came up with something which was uh a coin toss card which is too powerful well you can just increase the cost or make it so it's a little less powerful you tweak it and then you can get it in right and and oftentimes that that's all it is in a game like magic it's just uh
um it doesn't have to be a card which is uh uh luck luck based like a coin toss card uh but it can much be like a you know a super conditional powerful card uh like uh you know if if you draw this and your opponent has a swamp and a mountain in play and uh then then you do 20 points of damage right that's you know it's like that that would be like if I chose to play that and I was playing against the right person and I drew it at the right time that would be too much luck yeah um um and and if you uh lowered it to the point where it was uh where it wasn't too much luck it probably wouldn't be worth you know interesting to play so yeah it would make for a fun story and it would be quite dramatic though just be like hey I win uh now you talked a moment ago about the kind of ratio not just the ratio but like thinking about the time a game takes if if it is heavily luck dependent on that do you think there's a certain like ratio of time and luck tolerance for players uh yeah I players different players will have a different tolerance usually the more luck in the game the shorter they'll want that game to be um but I think that's something which is sort of a cultural standard we have right now I'm not sure that it's uh it's in stone that that's the best way to be and it actually ties back to one of your examples or your comment there's a lot of luck in life there is life has a lot
of luck it certainly has a lot of skill and is longer than most games and it's very fascinating and so uh using that as a model uh you can think well you can probably have a game which lasts a long time has a lot of luck and a lot of skill and I can think back to you know growing up uh games that fit that description like uh um Titan Titan is marvelous uh game Avalon Hill uh early 80s I think it came out and you you accumulate these armies of monsters you move around the map and then you uh when you attack somebody you zoom in and you have a little little tiny war game now there is an enormous amount of luck in the game uh because you're rolling the dice to move and because within the little battles you're rolling dice to see if you hit or not and uh I've had situations for example where my opponent had an ogre which uh rolls six Dice and hits on a six and I had an angel which has six hit points and they hit killed in one blow right they rolled six sixes right an insane amount of luck but there's uh the the more skillful players will win that game which often lasts three hours much more often than anybody else so it's a um so if you've got a large long game with uh lots of luck it has to be like it is in Titan and as we talked about earlier sort of baked in where you might notice
wow that was really unlucky for me to lose that angel there but the thing is that during the course of the game I'm rolling hundreds of dice right and so you know it it you might get 10% more lucky than me or 10% less and sometimes you get might might in a particular place get much more lucky than me and if you're skillful you might be able to leverage that to Victory but if uh if you're not then you know I'll get you know I'll be able to work my way back yeah for sure I think poker falls into this category because I mean you have poker they have those World Series of Poker Tournaments that last days but and that's a lot of luck in there but yet at the same time the people that get to that final table it's almost the same people every single year it's it's very very similar that top you know top 20 30 people that that are there and so is it just the amount of time like talk to me about poker like help me understand because poker and has a lot of characteristics of other you know board games and card games and so how can people kind of capture that same thing there's a lot of luck and a lot of skill that you know for their own games prer is probably my favorite game uh it illustrates uh so many really cool aspects of games um and a lot of them aren't really uh in the mainstream design sensibility right but it it uh it's it's very modular for one so a hand of Poker is uh there's a lot of luck in it anybody can win uh I can beat the world champion in poker in one hand um
but you begin stringing them together and the fact that the world champion in poker has whatever 65% advantage on me doesn't take long for 65% advantage to add up to wow they're going to win an enormous amount of the time and uh and so you you start putting these hands of poker together what you Define as being the game is uh is really important like is the hand of Poker a game well that's a very short very high luck Affair or is the session of poker the game or is the tournament of Poker or is your uh season of Poker right all these things uh are related to this hand of Poker but they've all got very different skill um and very different lengths of play and uh that that is one way you can uh really always uh bring out the skill in your game is play multiple s sessions um in a game like Titan you don't have to because uh the game is long filled with luck and the multiple sessions are very baked in it's all these different battles you have um and uh but in a a game like magic uh one hand isn't as satisfying as playing a match uh and playing three out of five is even more satisfying than playing two out of two out of three often and playing a tournament is more skill testing than just playing against your buddy and uh and so there's all sorts of ways to mitigate the luck by stringing together your play sessions definitely and I think that's going back to sports this is where we look into okay you have the season of play and then that leads into
you know there's there's skill there's luck there or all sorts of things that happen there but to determine the champion it's usually like a best of seven series like can you win four games and not just get lucky for that one and I think you know because any anything can happen for during one specific basketball game or baseball game and different you especially baseball goodness gracious like the way the ball bounc it's crazy and so but the the more you play the more you kind of get into the better team typically is going to win yeah the uh one aspect positive aspect of luck that we haven't really touched on is that it allows uh wider audiences to play against one another yeah and uh and that that's one of the things I really look for I I get I I I very much like high skill low luck games games where luck doesn't have much payoff but for me to play those uh if I'm playing with friends who have already sort of gotten into the game it's a while before I feel like I can uh can compete with them um but if they're uh High luck payoff and ideally for me high skill as well then even if they're entrenched I can play the first time and get lucky and uh I may not win but uh I can make them sweat which is nice and then that gives me a chance to sort of build up um I like games that you can play uh with both Advanced and beginning players and that
they can have a good time together and that's one of the reasons why poker is so amazing uh certainly is that case with poker yeah definitely I'm thinking about King of Tokyo I have brought so many people into the hobby of gaming through King of Tokyo because anybody can play that game you just sit down here's the you know the five rules of the game you know the five main rules and we're going to roll some dice it's going to take 20 minutes and we're going to have a lot of laughs and fun and then those people are like oh I didn't realize this was gaming and then they start kind of getting deeper and deeper and and you know then they're hooked and then they're buying a bunch of games and so like like you said it broadens the the audience it broadens the Horizon Ticket to Ride you know how many millions of people have played Ticket to Ride because of it it it's so easy and the luck of you know it's luck of drawing the right cards and getting the right routes and all that stuff you know but it it brings so many people in what are you what would you say are some of the other benefits of having games with a little more luck than than skill uh I'd say the main benefits for luck the ones I uh think about most often are the it allow a game with a little more luck allows broader audiences to play and it gives players unexpected play situations um at the uh a game a game which is more deterministic will tend to follow more similar routs over time a game with a little more luck you'll spin into unexplored territory more easily and then uh I usually list a last uh advantage to luck uh having luck in your
game which is it gives somebody to blame the losses on um I'm not sure how important that is I mean I guess it's important may maybe I've just moved Beyond caring whether I win and lose that much but uh it always uh amazes me when players sit down to the first game the the first game and they can get really upset about winning or losing it's like games are so like like one of the one of the amazing things about games is that they you you just can't master them I mean most games immediately and that any game worth playing is going to take repeated plays and uh um so so anyway but uh but yeah uh having a little bit of luck in the game says oh I just didn't allows the player to say oh I I just got unlucky I played perfect strategy it protects the ego B and I think in our culture our society winning is so important we put such a premium on winning and I think it just kind of spills over into gaming in some really kind of ugly ways sometime well Richard do you have any advice for somebody they're they're working through a game design right now they're try trying to figure out the balance and and you know put the right amount of luck and the right amount of skill what advice would you give them just in general I always look at what sort of uh variance or luck is in the game and uh
and I would advise them to think about what is there and how they're going to use it um so uh some something that's really powerful and uh I I would I would uh tell them to try to use uh game theoretic luck so game theoretic luck is um where you know something that I don't know okay so this can be added to a lot of different games uh um you can have a little secret go card uh where you're trying to do something and I don't know what that is and you get a little bonus there um and uh but anytime you've got a hand of cards or a single card or anything that the other person doesn't know um you can make the entire rest of the game deterministic and that that little bit of hidden information will uh will help add a little bit of variance that people won't even recognize as luck uh if they don't like that sort of thing and uh so oftentimes if you're trying to do a low luck game high skill game getting a little bit of that game theoretic luck in is uh will will give you a lot more replayability and uh spread your audience out allow wider audiences to play with each other if you're going with uh dice dice are um often times hated by many players I I think if you uh use the dice often enough that's okay that's getting back to this uh Titan experience where you roll the dice a thousand times over the
course of three hours but these days nobody's doing three-hour games so uh then uh I've begun thinking about uh using dice more often as uh instead of a fail mechanism a choice mechanism an option mechanism so what that means is is oftentimes in games uh in like in Titan this this happens uh uh you roll and see whether you succeeded or not um a lot of players hate that uh and with a short game you know if you're playing 45 minutes it's often frustrating because you don't like to try to do something and then fail but that doesn't mean you can't have dice what you need to do is have it so that the dice are giving you options instead of uh succeed and fail so that's what's going on in a game like well y or King of Tokyo where you're rolling the dice and they don't have uh necessarily a fixed fail state they're giving you an opportunity you can take a higher risk opportunity you can take a lower risk oftentimes you can get some little payout even if you failed failed uh in some ways and uh and uh players uh tend to like dice more when they're giving them opportunities and choices rather than just fail and succeed yeah definitely that's one thing I found I've been working on a superhero game last few months and it's dice based but you roll the dice before you act and so you roll these Dice and they give you certain icons and that kind of gives you your options for what you can do on that turn and so it's not hey I'm I maybe can do this it's okay I can do this and how do I Mo what's the most efficient way I
can use my actions use my my Dice and and so I guess that's the difference between input Randomness versus output Randomness and kind of what what people prefer now Richard do you have any kind of closing thoughts any any final ideas or something you know you want to lead the listeners with yeah I guess I guess uh uh my general advice would be to try instead of to trying to uh systematically remove all the luck from games would be to uh uh try to leave some in and uh even crank it up and see if your players will accept it uh games are definitely not one size fits all uh there's different audiences will respond to different things but uh um everybody likes to be able to play with their friends and if game's audience is too narrow they may not be able to do that and uh uh using luck in the right ways can help mitigate that awesome well Richard man I really appreciate you coming on the show we're about to head over into a bonus round we're going to talk about Richard's advice for designing a collectible card game something like magic or uh one of the living card games are out now so I'm going to get his advice on that but Richard again really appreciate your time and good luck with everything you got going on right now oh thanks a lot it's been fun all right so bonus round let's talk about collectible card games the thing you you really got going you know 25 years ago it's kind does that seem crazy to you that magic was like 25ish years ago uh yeah it does seem crazy is uh it
does seem crazy um and it uh it's been all I think exactly 25 years now since it was released um yeah games have come a long way since then yeah all right so let's let's get your advice I mean you've been doing this a long time time you worked on I don't know how many sets of magic I know you're not you're not in on all of them at this point but you still come along and kind of consult and help out and do different things so tell me give me some good advice if let's say I wanted to come up with a collectible card game Or I guess living card game is kind of the model people are using now and so maybe that's a better way to go but what would be your advice to somebody working on one of those kinds of games I've got lots of different go-to uh concepts for uh putting these things together um the first uh which I learned uh maybe on my third game no my second game uh vampire the eternal struggle I I learned um is that you want to make them short when Magic first came out I was actually pretty lucky that I made it as short as it is uh because my standards at the time was this is a board or card game boards and card games that I'm used to playing are 45 minutes minimum and two hours is certainly okay um it turns out and this is uh pretty obvious now is that uh is that these trading card games uh really want to be short and the reason why is because you want to play The Once and then you want to tr change
your deck and then play them again and uh if you make it so that the length of the game is one sitting you're not going to be able to do that in one sitting um but if you make it so that the the uh length of play is 15 minutes 20 minutes half an hour uh then then you'll be able to play it and say oh I wonder how how this would have worked if I swapped out this card that's very satisfying for players and it's a it's a a large part of the reason why people play doesn't mean that the longer one can't work it just means that it's going to be much uh it's going to uh be harder for people to get into and require a lot more of their time yeah it seems like deck building I know from my experience back in college deck build building was so much of the fun is is finding these cards and and putting them together and figuring out cool ways for them to work and then so playing a game against my buddy wasn't even necessarily like oh I need to win it was like okay I'm going to play test this deck and see if it's as good as I hope it will be and I can tweak it is that what you've kind of found early on with the play testers way back win and you just kind of kept that going oh yeah yeah that's uh a lot of how it is in fact uh some players I think many players even uh uh aren't even using the decks as a stepping stone to a winning deck what they're doing is they've got some deck concept and they're happy if they win you know one in five games uh they feel very good about that um and uh so it's
sort of a game world to explore in fact their attitudes uh often allow for some really interesting things where uh they intentionally play these things whether the underdog and the other person person has a much stronger deck or stronger players um that it it feels it's it's uh pretty cool having a game where one person has a 20% chance to win and uh it feels very special when they do win and uh you know the other person gets to dominate them four times out of five um so uh that can be a win-win situation so the uh the other thing I look for when I'm uh making a trading card game is it's very important what the ele the cards are you want to make it so that the players uh want to collect that element um so that is why a game with a bunch of creatures uh or a bunch of objects or a bunch of places is more interesting than is is is probably going to be more successful than a game where You' got a bunch of Moves Like left punch Right Punch um uh these uh more abstract things don't translate as well into cards which don't make because they're not as and and they're not as tangible so uh it uh I think is uh is is stronger to have uh people putting together decks of things they find cool yeah definitely now what were some of the rules that
maybe weren't in the original concept of the game that as more people got their hands on it and started to kind of break things and do things differently what were some of those things that that you learned there for instance like having limits on the number of the of a card a specific card that someone could have in their deck was that there from the beginning or was that something you kind of had to do later what were some other things like that uh the limit on the number of cards was added later um and in fact uh originally the way I anticipated trading card games being played was that people would buy uh one or two decks and some boosters and uh and that was the end of it they trade was it people yeah yeah and so and so there wasn't any need for any uh limit and to boot uh I thought that if somebody traded and made it a deck made a deck for instance of all lightning bolts and mountains whether or not that was a dominating deck it's pretty good yeah um and but it's not fun to play against right and so you know that would be like uh if if I went to somebody's house and they played a game with a with a a power that was you too broken we'd say okay you can't play that anymore and so I expected people to do more self- moderation but uh I came from an era where there were a lot of house rules in our games and uh but as the game became played more seriously and people had larger collections we had to take this balancing more more seriously and uh
this rule of a limit of four uh in the deck really helped a lot later on in Netrunner in fact I tried to get rid of that and I tried to design it from the get-go so that you could have as many as you liked of a particular card and uh people did not like that even if it was possible and it took me a little while to get it through my head that that that it just really help people by giving them bounds like that they uh that they didn't have to worry whether they needed six of these things or seven or 20 of them uh that having a limit of three or four is is very helpful to players so that's another reason to put these limits in gotcha so giving players constraints actually helps the game uh actually helps people enjoy the game more yeah yeah it makes it seem less overwhelming and and I mean trading card games are crazy overwhelming to begin with so if you can give them uh some walls uh it's often useful so another uh thing I would advise for somebody making a trading card game is to try to aim for cards and strategies that are loved and hated as opposed to ones that everybody thinks are just okay there was a lot of pressure at the beginning to make it so that magic there were some groups who felt like magic should be uh creatures with spells as spikes and they didn't
like to see land destruct they didn't like to see card discard they didn't want to see uh uh Decks that were almost all spells and uh I found that the that the that anything which anybody hated uh if there were people out there that loved it that it was uh it it just made the game much richer by putting it in there but making sure that it didn't uh you know it didn't become so common that people had to deal with it all the time so if it's out there the people who hate it it's sort of this dangerous spice that's out there that occasionally they have to play this game they hate but for the people who love it it's like the entire game they love it yeah so you're saying have some polarizing strategies yep yep yep have polarizing strategies just make sure that the ones that are uh are super hated don't dominate right and uh and then and then that's much more exciting I think than just stripping everything out so that everybody so that it's more the whole the entire game's more vanilla gotcha all right one one last question before some final thoughts how do you play test one of these things like what have you learned about play testing over the last 25 years for a game like this well uh you you need a broad a broad group of play testers uh there's no one answer and uh you need to make sure that some some of the play testers are represent all the different uh psychographics so you need some people who are taking winning very seriously
and you need to have have it so that some people who are playing for big swingy effects or combos are are playing that don't care necessarily as much about winning and that you have uh both good players and bad players or I should say experienced and inexperienced and that's that's daunting but uh but it's really important to get these things broadly played tested um the second thing is that it's really hard to catch everything um and if I I I would go so far as to say that if you've caught all the problems with your game you probably have not been ambitious enough uh games are very complicated games like these are very complicated and part of the joy of them is exploring the wild unknowns of these games so you want to make sure they're in the game and uh the combinatorial nature of it is such that that you just can't get all the combos uh uh if if you're aggressive with them um and and so uh I would be easy on yourself and just have some method of uh correct ing mistakes after release uh it's painful to do but but um but I think I think if a game launches a little more aggressively with the combos and some of them are a little broken but you can tweak them back that's going to be more satisfying than everything is sort of more rained in and in fact at one point at Wizards we have a design teams and development teams and the
design teams come up with the design and the development teams uh make sure that they're not too broken and balanced um at one point we were talking about how to uh measure the design the development team's success and the obvious thing was no broken cards the idea was put forth and uh I still subscribe to it that uh that actually the ideal thing is that there's a couple broken cards every year um if you have 10 you know that's too much but if you have none that means they're just not trying gotcha man this this has been awesome do you have any kind of like closing advice or you know closing thoughts for somebody working on a ccg if you're working on a TCG I would say uh Begin by nailing down your vanilla stuff just uh uh in in Magic that would be the very simple creatures with no abilities and the very simple abilities uh just get those down first before trying to do anything super fancy and then once you've got that down and it feels like a a a pretty good uh structure then it's uh really easy to add in cards that tweak those add to them subtract from them uh and uh spin the game off hopefully into wild and unknown areas gotcha Richard man really appreciate your time thanks for coming on the show and good luck with everything you got going on right now hey thanks for the interest it was
fun