Board Game of the Year | Kennerspiel des Jahres 2025 | Who Should and Who WILL Win?
Transcript
There's been a snub. Oh, you think there has been? Yes, I have. Correct. So, there's a game right there. Hello everybody. My name is Ilia. My name is Tyler. Together, we make up Cal, a couple that loves to play board games. And today, we're going to be telling you about the Kenner Spiel Dearest nominated games. And we're going to tell you who should win and who we think will win. These are some good games. They are. They are. They are. They are. Okay, let's bring them out and let's tell you about it. Do you want to do it in order or should I just bring them all? Ah, so these are the nominated games this year for the Kendra Spiel dearis. Now, what do you what is this award? It's like the spiel but for heavier hobby games, I guess. Exactly. Kenner actually, I believe, translate to expert or connoisseur or something like that. Uh, so these are more the expert games.
They're more geared towards people who play board games. They know how rules work. They're not accustomed rules. Well, they do cuz a lot of the spiel folks like this is could be their first game. It's a family game. They're learning to play games for the first time. But people know how to play games now and this is the category for those types of folks. This award is actually like pretty new comparatively to the spiel at 2011. 2011. Seven Wonders was the first winner of this award. Mhm. And amongst other winners includes Wingspan. So I wrote some other ones down. There's the crew which we all know and love. There's Quacks of Qued Quedlinberg. We're Quacks now. Uh and then last year Daybreak one, which is a cooperative game. Yeah. Yeah. And now we've got these three that we're going to talk about today. Before we talk about them, I do want to say there's been a snub.
Oh, you think there has been? Yes, I have. So, there's a game right there. It is called The Gang. The Gang was nominated for this award or recommended for this award. It didn't quite make the nominations, but this game has won the world by storm and it is such a fantastic game. And I'm sure you've heard us talk about it, but I will say this game at le I don't know if it should have won, but it should have been nominated. Honestly, fair. It should have been nominated. It should have been. But with that out of the way, let's tell you about each of these games. Let's tell you about what we think of them, how they work, and then we'll tell you who we think should win, and who we think will win Mel. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. Let's start over there with loot. Now, this is loot. Now, loot is a fun worker placement type of game. You have a collective map and in your turn, you're placing workers adjacent to either your own worker or any worker or the little Viking pier. Yeah. And what you're trying to do is you're trying to collect different resources and tiles for your own map so you can surround tiles and score victory points. Now, every turn you'll have an option to bring in a Viking ship, which is new objective, adding to the objectives you already have on your board. And that's essentially the game. It's a puzzle of trying to collect various tiles and objectives. There's conditions for collecting various tiles. Uh and if you collect and surround your goal tiles, you'll score those points. You can increase your scoring. There's levels of kind of layering up. There's some asymmetry between the boards. But in general, it's a really fun game with that worker placement mechanic that
really teaches you almost as you go. Yeah, it's interesting because it's like a I would call it like a map builder. Uh because although the worker placement is like really important to the game, I think where it really shines is that like puzzle of making sure you take long ships or goals uh when you're ready to because at the end of the game they're actually worth negative points if you don't finish them. But if you take one that isn't good for you, then you're not going to score a whole lot. And then there's like this multiplying combo effect that really gets going that is exciting and different from what you would expect from like a again I don't want to call it a worker placement game cuz it is just like you placing them out on empty spaces on the board and collecting whatever resource you land on. Is that so? Yes, but there's no like there's no like elaborate action with it. Well, you're also blocking people from the worker placement spaces. Yeah, I guess. But like that's more of like a route build anything for blocking cuz you're blocking for cast. Very against worker placement to this one. Are you? It is. I get like I don't know. It's just a different way to think about it, I guess. What did you think of Lu when playing the game? It was fun. I don't know if it's my type of game. Um yeah. I I don't know. It's unique. That's and that's what I like about it. But I just like I it didn't feel as grindy as I had hoped. Oh, you wanted it to be more. I want Yeah, I wanted it to be a little bit more. Fair. I We recently replayed all three of these kind of in preparation for this video and at first
I was kind of lukewarm on this game, but playing it the second time I really really enjoyed it. It's better at a higher player count. Yeah, the puzzle count, the blocking of like people's meoles cuz I think I was trying to make routes between the watchtowwers and people kept blocking my routes. Um, but then just like the fun aspect of that like area control with your own board control with set collection with satisfying goal achievement. It was a really really good time. The only thing I will say that I don't like is the cover of this game is gorgeous. It's such a beautiful game. But on the table it is ugly. It does not. It is just one green blob of things. And I wish like they had even like a character on the player board cuz the characters are so like they're full of characters. So neat to see like they could have reused that art and put it on the player boards. Um so I think that was a missed opportunity and I did not enjoy that aspect of it.
But if you enjoy that that's loot. There's this is probably a good time to mention cuz I did mention this in our spiel video is that all three of these games are pretty dang good. It's just that we're talking about who should win, who will win. So, we're going to be a bit nitpicky on this and things like art translation from box to board is something that we really like think is important in like being top top level tier. Yeah, definitely play all these games. They're fantastic. In no way there's we're saying that none of these are, but it's fun to nitpick, especially when awards are on the line. And that is loot. Let's talk about Far Away next. Tell us about it. This is a card drafting, not tableau builder, but line builder. Let's call it a line builder, where you are going to be building and drafting cards from left to right. As you play them, you'll get bonuses for playing ascending numbers. You'll get bonuses for or and each card, well, not each card. Most of the cards will have goals on them and things that you need to be able to activate the goal. The thing about this though is you play left to right and then at the end of the game you'll flip everything over and score right to left. That's where this game gets really interesting. And I'll both applaud and um push it a little because I think that it can get very confusing at times and then it feels really bad when going back through scoring
realizing you didn't actually achieve one of your goals and then you score zero. That being said, zero in at least some of your cards is almost feels necessary because you need those like you need those things to be able to activate later on cards that will get you more points. So, it's like this cool little balance that you need to strike. In essence, it's this very simple set collection game, but the mechanism of planning ahead and revealing kind of backwards and scoring. I love the way it tickles my brain. Uh I feel like still I play this game and I'm so confident that I have it and I flip the cards and like how did I miss that? I knew I needed the cycle and I knew I should have drafted that. Why didn't I? And the art in this game is really inviting. The simplicity.
It's only eight rounds. Yeah. So you do eight rounds of drafting and then you score and then you can play again and you can come back to it and you can kind of see how the game evolves. They also recently had a mini expansion that throws a few more cards into the mix of and how you can experience the game. Um, my overall thoughts with Fireway have been fantastic. It's such a fun game to show to people because that first game is going to break people's brains. Yeah, you almost need to play this game twice cuz once you understand how the scoring works, then you're like, "Oh, okay. Let's try it again." But it's also fun because you can play that very first card. you're like, "This is what I'm gonna try to score for the most because I know this card is being revealed last and you build your strategy around it." Sometimes you forget about it, but then you come back to it and you just feel so good to kind of compare and see the scores game to game. And then we forgot to mention about the artifact cards. You did you mentioned them. If you play cards in a row, you'll get special I did I mentioned you get a a special effect for playing ascending cards, but you do get these like artifact cards that are always part of your scoring set. So, at the very beginning when you start scoring, it'll be one card plus all of the artifacts that you've been able to collect. Yeah, they'll apply to your and they can meet the requirements and really help you out. And that's another layer of the game is like a lot of the lower cards, they don't give you as much scoring. A lot of the higher cards do, but playing cards in ascending order gives you a bonus. So, you're kind of weighing that. And those artifacts really help you finish the like restrictions on the cards that are are required to be able to score the card.
So, that's so good. And that's far away. And last but not least, we have Endeavor Deep Sea. Now, this is a big game and this is a big box full of components and glory. It's a table hog. It is a table hog, but in a good way. In this game, what you'll be doing is simply following your playerboard and all the steps. You'll be acquiring crew to explore the deep sea. You'll be sending out your little discs to take various actions with your little ships across the board. Uh, these involve potentially exploring more of the board, potentially helping the wildlife conservation. Uh, what other actions? Journaling, diving, moving. That's like the the five main ones. Uh, and then as the game continues, you'll see the board come to life. Uh, and you'll have a little player board that gives you more discs more every round. It will give you more opportunities to take discs back from your workers, let you explore in the deeper areas, and overall grow your engine, as we like to call it. A little bit of an engine building. Yeah, it's like an engine builder exploring Tableau thing. And it's got like a lot of different layers to it. I will say I say this with every engine builder is that an engine builder that starts off really slow so that people can get like invested into their strategies and kind of learn how the game sort of flows ending in that point where you're really really like spending a lot of time in the last rounds like deciding what you need to do and then hoping that you need one hoping you had one more round is like sound for a great engine builder
and Endeavor's Deep Sea does do that I I think uh and I really really appreciate that. I think what this game has is one of our friends said this and I really liked the analogy. It kind of has like three acts like to a movie almost where you have act one where you're like we're all here. What are we going to explore? Like we're only going to take one action in the first round. That's all I'm going to do is sonar. That's it. Uh and then the middle of the game where you're just like ooh things are beginning to happen. And then closer to the end of round six, you're like the game is ending. What can I do? going to make sure I leave an impact to make sure I explore all the games. Uh the other thing I really like about this game is each of the tiles in the different depths are essentially a mini puzzle. Yep. You can journal like primarily journal and if you journal maybe you'll get this bonus. There could be a a combination of conservation of the wildlife and diving and how do you kind of mix those two and potentially find a worker or find one of your crew members that specializes in that. Uh your story really gets built throughout the game. the more ships that you have, the game really evolves. There's also various different missions. We've played through a few of them now already.
They're all very different and they do tell the story itself. Uh this game truly feels like it has it all. Yeah. So, just a point on the missions thing, too, is like the setup is different, but the scoring is different. And instead of having like that sign where you like you shuffle a deck and then flip up three objectives for the end of the game, like this is missions that add to the thematic presence of this game and also change your strategy completely. So although the three missions typically do like interconnect somehow, it's really interesting to see how from mission one to mission two to mission three, how you have grown in the way that you play the game, but also how you change your strategy based on those goals and the tiles you end up revealing. Cuz maybe maybe the entire board is a lot of conservation spots with not a whole lot of sonar spots. It is possible that that is going to happen. So, how do you decide what crew members you're going to take? Decide what um pillar or row you're going to grow in faster? And it's just really interesting decision spaces that I have come to really appreciate.
Every one of these games has felt incredible. And I think the last thing I'll add that I really, really enjoy was I remember one of the days we were playing this game like, "Oh, is there a reference card?" But you don't really need it cuz it's all on the board. The board tells you exactly what to do. It's very like intuitive of how everything flows into the game. Uh there's there is iconography present throughout this game. There's quite a bit of it, but none of it is overly confusing. Most of the time we looked at stuff and we would guess what it is and then we check be like, "Oh, that is correct." So, the game just feels intuitive. The design seems really clean and it's been a fantastic game at our table. Mhm. Now, this one is based off of a previous game as well, so I should mention that. Um, we've never played the other game, Endeavor. I think it had an icky theme. Yeah, this theme is really interesting.
Um, along with all of these, I know um, Far Away doesn't like have a super solid theme that's being integrated into it, but it is about like building and walking and traveling through um, these different spaces. So, it it it works. And those are the three games that are nominated this year. Now, on to the part that you've all been waiting for. All been waiting for. We're going to tell you which one we think should win and which one we think will win. Let's start off with should. We're going to point to the game that we think should win. 3 2 1. Nice. Now, I think the reason it should win is it is a little I will say it is a little bit heavier. Yeah. Than some of the other games that have won this game in the past. But this game does such an incredible job at introducing you to the game. You have everything laid out in front of you. It's not no one really needs to study the rules and get everything down. You can jump in. You can really get to play the game, get to experience it. There's a story that comes about there. There's uh memories that are built. There's strategies that are formed. And every game will feel very different. And because there's so much of the game that's left that's yet undiscovered with those face down tiles, you'll want to come back again and again without that necessarily campaign daunting feel that some other games have. Yeah. Yeah. I think everything that you said um just adding on to the fact that like because there's so much replayability in this box, as somebody
who is maybe just getting into the hobby, this game offers a lot and you don't have to have a lot of other games. It introduces a bunch of different mechanics. Um, it it stays light at the very beginning and begins to get crunchy, not just through like round one all the way to round six, but as you progress through those missions, it gets a little bit more uh complicated and complex in the way that you are making your decisions. I think that's really really interesting. So, it's in my opinion really inviting while also still being able to maintain like the heavier side of what gaming is. And I think that for that alone um like that it should it should win. It should it really should. Now who do we think will win?
Ready? Do you have it in your brain? This one was hard for me, but I do I I do know. Three, two, one. Okay. This is the first year actually. Uh pause for a second. If you're interested in learning about the spiel jar uh awards and who we and our opinions there, you can check out our other video. But yeah, Ilia, we'll put it there. But this is the first year that I think me and Ilia have both had different answers. Oh, for both of them. For both of them. Yeah, we always do a spiel video. Uh this is actually our first year video where we're doing these as a separate video. Um but it's interesting. Let's tell me why you think it will win. I need to sneeze.
Bless you. That's it. That's why I think it will win. The sneeze. The sneeze. No, I think I've talked about it already. I I have a hard time I don't I'll do this. Why I think the other ones are not as good as this one. I think Far Away um is an interesting choice. I I think the creativity and the ingenuity is there, but I also think that it lacks a little bit in replayability. Um, yeah, we can argue all of these points. Remember, I'm being I'm being nitpicky. I'm being nitpicky. And for that reason, I think Endeavor uh Deep Sea has no I I will get there. I think Loot is also one of those games that I think is really interesting, but it's like I don't know, maybe for me it didn't hit the right spots. So, I have like a bit of a bias opinion there. I think that like most importantly there is an the theme is there, but it's not like it's sort of to your art point. It's not like super integrated into the actual game.
That's fair. And I felt like we're talking the these awards capture a lot of different uh categories and rubric. So like that's important uh when it does come to deciding who should win. I think Endeavor Deepc does a good job at checking all of the boxes. Uh and that's kind of why I think it should win outside of or will win. That's what I would say it will win outside of what I said should win. That was a complicated way of saying it. Um, I like that. I hope it does win because I think it should win. Uh, but I think Far Away will win for a few reasons. Um, one of the reasons is just the accessibility of the game. Uh, it's so first of all, it's affordable. It is. It is also really easy to teach. It's also really easy to play to the table and play in 20 minutes. You're going to be spending 30 minutes per player for this game. It's also a little bit more expensive. Not saying that it's not worth it because there's so much content packed in this game. Uh it is definitely worth its value and any gamer would love to have this in their collection. But these are the things you have to consider when you're Exactly. Cuz we're talking about like what's kind of what can be throw in there. I think I always like I think innovation for me is a really big factor. Uh looking at the historic kind of winners of these awards. uh with both I feel like both the spiel and the Kenner spiel they celebrate new things that just have not been done as much and although none of these are new concepts or new ideas uh I think Far Away does
something out of the box more than the other two and I think it takes that really simple element and condenses into that like brain burning experience and I do think there's a lot of replay-ability in this game because I think you come back the way that you have the cards your story is always going to be looking different you're never going to go through the entire deck. You're always really exploring what is going to happen there and where and there and all the realms and about. Um, but I also think it's going to be really close because I think this one does such a great job of integrating various mechanics in such a light way but in a way that it makes sense and is so easy to show different people what games could be. I think that makes loot really exciting. Endeavor does a very similar thing but kind of of a level up. Uh, the table presence is absolutely fantastic. Exploring all the sea, exploring all the tiles, it's so wonderful. But I just have an inkling that Far Away will just slide in there by a hair. Um, and I think it deserves to as well. Uh, of course I would love to see Deep Sea win. I think all these could win, but that is the whole point of this video is to talk about these games and tell you how about crowd great all of them are. Yes. Yeah. I can't wait for one year where one of them is just not good and we're just like, "Get out of here game. We don't like it." I don't think that's gonna happen. We're talking three games that get like nominated a year and there's so many games that come out and so many games that don't make it even to the recommended list that are good. What would The Gang replace?
For me, it would have to replace Loot. Same. Yeah. The The Gang should have been in here. I don't think I said it would have won. That's a hot take right there. Actually, I I maybe could have said it would have won. No, it should have won. I think you probably would have said it should have won because you really like that game. The gang is just it takes such a institutional moment in life of poker, which everyone institutional moment. It's an institutional moment in life. People know what poker is. People have played poker. They have some sort of experience with them. And it gifies it. introduces a huge but maybe that that's that's a case to make it for a spiel instead of a kinder spiel because it's more of like the broader audience but I digress. Yes, we are talking about these three games and we have given our opinion. Both Tyler and I think that Endeavor should win and I think Farway will win where Tyler thinks Endeavor should win. Now will win. Will win. Yeah, correct.
Should and will win. Should will and maybe can. Well, definitely can. that's nominated. Now, any last thoughts? Uh, no. Well, yes. Go on and try these games. Go on and try all three of these games. Uh, take a look at what the Ker Spiel actually is and maybe make an informed decision yourself. Like, which game would you like to see at the top and let us know down in the comments below because that's our question of the day. Which of these have you played? Which do you think will win? Which do you think should win? Is there another snub that we didn't talk about? Maybe, maybe, maybe, maybe, maybe. And also to Tyler's point, uh, recommend these games to your local game store, to your board game cafes, cuz they're wonderful and they represent a good status of the hobby right now. Exactly. So, we'd love to see them played. We'd love to see your experiences about them. And with all that said, thank you so much for making it this far in this video. Mhm. And if you enjoyed it, make sure you hit that thumbs up button, hit that subscribe button if you're new here, cuz we love talking about board games. And the more that we talk about it, the more videos that come out and you can hit that little bell so you know when every one of our videos comes out and you can jump in. You can answer a question of the day. We can talk to you. You can join our Discord. We can have Keep an eye out for giveaway. Beautiful time. We do have giveaways. Yeah, do have giveaways as well. Well done. Well, good good little smooth transition in there. And with that transition, I'm leaving. We'll see you in the next one. Bye.