Ra: Knizia's most impactful game - TCbH Retrospective Review
Transcript
Like many kids in the 90s, I spent my time and free money haunting my local comic shop. Specifically, in my case, Boss's Cards, Comics, and Games. Beyond superheroes and my first taste of imported anime, it's where I got my first minis, Magic cards, and general introduction to a broader hobby of tabletop gaming, eventually landing a job there. Yeah, while I'd played some more eclectic board games from Scotland Yard to Hero Quest, the smattering of strange boxes hiding just beyond the green and black wall of 40k was largely a mystery to me. But it wasn't until I was stocking those shelves and also having a German stepmom that it actually dawned on me that a lot of these bizarre boxes dawned names heralding from Germany. And one name in particular came up more often than the others. That being Rear Kitia.
Before Katan's Dominion and TTR was just a twinkle in the eye of Alanar Moon, Kitio was putting out legendary bangers still in production today. Now coveted cornerstones of young publishers hungry to show legitimacy by carrying a deluxe reprint of these same games I pondered decades ago. Even just one decade ago, or at least close enough for me to be alarmed at how time has flown by when I first interviewed Kitia for a small startup podcast called The Cardboard Herald. A very generous gift of time I still would greatly appreciate. Kitia boasted over 500 published games and showed little sign of slowing down. The beauty and and what I really love about it is apart from being fully awake and being really concentrated in the morning because I am a morning person is the peace, the quietness, no telephone calls, uh nothing happening and I can sit there and really creatively for a few hours think about new designs, think about new games. Uh mainly what happened the last evening when we tested games. um and really have that peaceful peaceful time with my best concentration to work on what I want to do most. For all that, if push to name one game that represents Cania's enduring impact and legacy within this hobby, just a handful of
titles are more than likely to come up. At least for the gamers that care to know all this history, which I assume you do cuz you're watching a video with retrospective in the title, I venture to say at least half are probably going to say Tigris and Euphrates with good reason it being one of the most celebrated games of all time. And there's the hotly anticipated reprint by 21st Century right around the corner. But I'd say the other largest chunk of games that people might say are the enduring legacy of Cania would be either the entirety of or at least one of the titles in his auction trilogy, 1992's Modern Art, 1995's Medici, and the first game he worked on after early retirement from his successful career in mortgage company management, Reiner's 1999 9 Magnum Opus Raw. All three games feature the designer's trademark minimalism with tense opportunity costdriven gameplay, featuring only light touches of randomness that set the stage while inherent almost intrinsically felt probabilities drive the vast majority of the gameplay itself.
And while all three of these games stand tall with merit, I'd argue that it's RAW where all of this is felt most keenly. Raw's structure is simple. Most turns have players picking a token from a bag, putting it on display. However, if a RAW tile is drawn, the round times track pushes forward. And if the time in the round hasn't run out, an auction is held where all players can make exactly one bid to earn all of the tiles in the pot, each of which falling into one or another form of set collecting miniames, with some lasting the duration of the game, some only lasting through the current era. What makes it really work though is that on their turn, instead of drawing anything from the bag, a player can voluntarily invoke RAW. I'm invoking RAW [screaming]
without pushing the time track forward with the catch being that if no one else has bids, you must sacrifice one of your number tokens to win the bid. Since rounds eb and flow with the limited bid capacity of players tokens and the uncertainty of what'll be pulled from the bag, there's constant analysis of whether or not to invoke raw. Test your opponents. See if you can go them into spending a precious bid on something you know they want, but maybe would rather sweeten the pot first. As three rounds go by, tension rises. There are climactic bids and surprise upsets, all with minimal rules overhead. And what makes it beautiful is how intuitive the value assessment is for each of your decisions. It's extremely welcoming to new players while also being really satisfying to uber dorks who have been slinging cardboard for decades like myself. There are a few other systems at play from disasters that come up, destroying affiliated tiles, if won, and how the prior winning bid token is exchanged each time a bid is won to be refreshed in the next round. both of which end up playing into the simple but potent network of decisions. To borrow from the narrative philosophy of George RR Martin, who himself is borrowing from Falconer, the drama really is driven by the heart being in conflict with itself. While numerous editions of RAW have come out
over the years, some with slight varants and component changes, great and small, like many older games, there have been periods of unavailability. With this most recent and easily most definitive edition being released by 21st Century Games in 2024 to great acclaim, both affordable and beautifully produced with tight flourishes like some marvelous graphic design and UI to account for probabilities and the obscenely large RAW token. It is the best the game has ever looked. But they didn't stop there. Along with Raw Proper, 25th Century leaned kind of hard into RAW, publishing a new edition of Ratzia, a more condensed card version with Mobster Rats, first released in 2004. Then in 2025, release Raw Traders and Raw and Wright, two new titles in the lineup. The first being, well, the first expansion of the game in the 25 years since the release.
an excellent and dare I say essential addition adding ship tiles to RAW that incentivize early purchases in the round acrewing value as other players purchase ship tiles too. And then raw and right a condensed pencil and paper implementation that cashes in on the fad though honestly isn't any more accessible or that much faster than the OG. So if you're going to own one, I'd say go for RAW proper. And then to not leave any games behind, they have a new printed 2009's Raw the Dice game on the horizon.
SPACE BALLS THE FLAMETHROWER,
leaving out only 2009's other spin-off, Priest of Raw, as the only release not in their catalog. What I'm going to admit that the sheer quantity of all of this and what's to come is kind of staggering, which in itself is a microcosm of the unintended consequences that all of us gamers are dealing with is being part of this whole rhinance. The ubiquity of so much output getting repackaged means you got to be really selective even with the good stuff, but the availability, especially from a preservationist standpoint, is so incredibly welcome. I actually talked about this recently with Nick Murray of Bitewing Games, who has partnered with Kitia on several new releases and remasters over the last couple of years.
As someone who loves games and tends to want to have all the best games, I'm starting to feel like I I don't even have room for even a tenth of the Cania games that I want. Is that something as a publisher that you have to be concerned with?
Yeah, that's a tough question. Like on one hand um we at Bitewing especially we've we've focused very hard on building the the Rander Kinesia fan base and and marketing him as a designer and a style of game and things like that. And that's a double-edged sword, right? On one hand, people take notice and they're like, "Okay, if I like this Kinesia game, I'll probably like this next one from Bowwing." Um on the other hand, you're exactly right. Some people might be like, "You know what? I have enough Kinesi games. I'm good." And on my end, it's like, you know, I'm I'm just looking for games that are like the most interesting and promising designs that we can possibly publish on our end. I think it's a hallmark of of Kenia that he's able to take something that's usually a little off-putting or hard to get into and make it approachable and just simplify what you're doing on your turn, what you're able to do on your turn, and and keep the game, you know, moving along at a nice clip. What I really love is that 21st Centuries Edition feels kind of like a Criterion release codifying and preserving one of the most foundational and impactful titles in our hobby using beautiful art and stupendous component design. And now with the release of Traders, honestly, RAW is the best that it has ever been.
Seriously, I'm kind of flabbergasted how this expansion so many years after the original design feels so organic to the game and intrinsic to disrupt the conventional strategies. Now, if push came to shove, it would be hard for me to decide what is my favorite Cania game of all time. Be it Tigris and Euphrates or Raw. Or maybe my judgment is clouded by the myriad of other complete bangers having been released in recent years. From the new Gold Country on the horizon to the really quite excellent Cascadero and of course the awardwinning Quest for El Dorado. But without a doubt, I think that Raw is his most emblematic, singular, and most impactful design, setting the bar for what auction games can and should be, as well as forever shaping what we think about minimalistic, meticulously crafted, and highly interactive game design. And that's our video. But let me know what do you think of these retrospective reviews that we've been working on. Do you dig them? Do you hate them?
Do you want to see more out of them? Put it in the comments. And as always, thanks for watching, supporting. It really means a lot to us that you go out of your way to help out the channel because no money exchanges hands from publishers to us. We are entirely audience supported. So those likes, subscribes, shares, comments, and of course checking out our Patreon all allows us to continue doing what we do. So if you value us, those are ways that you can support. But above all, thanks for being such a great community. You know I've been Jack for the cardboard herald.