Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is Castles of Burgundy Still Relevant After 15 Years?

Transcript 10:48

Welcome to the review of this classic board game, Castles of Burgundy. It came out 15 years ago, has sold thousands of copies, made millions on crowdfunding, but is it still worth it? We're going to tell you everything you need to know about this game, as well as is it still worth in 2026? Or should you look at the new and shiny version? In this review, we're going to go through the best things of this game, why this game might not be for you, and of course, the best modern alternative. First of all, let's talk about the player count. It's for two to four players, takes around, well, up to two hours, and it's quite medium weight. It's not the heaviest, but it's also not super light. Welcome to the 15th century Burgundy, where you'll be developing your plot of land with buildings, ships, animals, and different kind of goodies.

And you will be doing all these things in order to get victory points. All this grandeur can be achieved with just these little two dice. You will roll them and then use each of them for a different action. Easy. These actions might be picking up tiles, placing tiles into your area, and then selling goods in order to get money, and then get more tiles. We like tiles here. It's all about the tiles. So, by using those two dice each turn, you will fill out board to get points. You will reach objectives to get points, points, points, points. And the next point for us will be the three the papa things about this game. Best things.

Yes, one of the best things is that the box actually is pretty sturdy. For me, the best thing is this sense of accomplishment. I always want to say look what I did. You start out with an empty board and when the game finishes, you have your own city that you built and you feel so cool until you count the points and lose by 100. But until then, you feel cool. It's always great starting with nothing and then building up. It makes you feel good even if you lose the game. My third best thing about this game is the controlled random. Remember those dice? It's not that bad as you think it is. So when you roll bad, you might think, well, this is over. I can't do nothing with these dice. But that's when these little guys come in and help you out. So by using these, you can modify your die up or down one. So I can make this one into a two. And just like the earth, these dice are round. So, I can go from six to one.

Even though it feels solitary at first, there's actually tons of interaction in this game, which I love. This game brings out the best and the worst characteristics of humans. For example, noisiness. What do you do?

Come on, man. Do your own.

I think he's creating the biggest farm ever. So, I'm going to take some sheep for myself.

I don't need it. But he's not going to get it.

But I need it.

Because you're only rolling two dice. It's really easy to follow along what other people will be doing this round so you can plan accordingly and steal some of that thunder thief. I might be and there's no shame in it. These tiles on the board will not reset until the beginning of next round which means I have to plan beforehand. I have to take this tile before others. Hey, I wanted to take it. I think interaction is the thing that makes this simple game feel epic. just as variety. There's so much of it. Let me show you. This game comes with different many types of tiles. Each of these types of tiles will be shuffled, drawn, and put on the board. So, the order in which they come up and are placed on the board will be different each game. No two games are alike. Not convinced? How about selecting a different board entirely and trying to fill that out? On top of those two dice that tell you what you can and can't do on each of your turns. This has such a huge variety. No two games are going to be same and always a lot of options. And that brings up my next point. My favorite thing about this game is that all that variety and decision making comes from just rolling two little dice. I roll two dice and then pick something. Wait, don't rush me.

There's just so many options.

Come on, man. Don't take the sheep. So, just don't take the sheep.

No. No.

I will definitely take the sheep

again. Not just rolling the dice. Also, just picking up those tiles, selling goods. It all feels so simple yet decisions. Ah, maybe I should just take two people that modify dice. That's also a wallet option. There's no better combination in board games as simple rules but complex choices. It's just chef's kiss. And the favorite thing for me is going to be the accessibility. It should be up here. Oh, thank you for accessing that. Yes, this game has a ton of tiles and ton of choices, yet it's very accessible. You could play it with a non-gamer. That's why it's at the top of our best things list. Exactly. The two dice, decision-m, accessibility, all good things, which makes this game for you. But there are also some other things why this game might not be for you. Let's talk about those said things.

Here we have three things why this game is not for you. The biggest one being a dealbreaker. The last one being it's probably not a big deal. Let's start right there. Is it for hands? What? All these tiles have little drawings on them and you need a magnifying glass to see them. What does it do? I don't know. It just has. Oh, some of these will give you some power. Some of those will give you some human resources. And some of those will give you victory points. Which one? I don't know. I don't see anything. I might be getting old. I am. And my eyesight might not be what it was. It isn't. And but I think it's just too small. Too small. Make it bigger, please.

They did up up there.

Well, I mean, the tiles, not the box, man. Come on. Yes, it might not be the prettiest game after these 15 years. Not sure it was the prettiest back then as well. No,

but that doesn't change the gameplay. Well, this does. So, you roll those two dice. And remember, we said you kind of can control it, but sometimes you just stuck with these two and then it's random. So yeah, you can control those dice a little bit, but the random will get you eventually. If you don't like random, then it will not be for you. Just like it will not be for you. If you think this is going to be a super short thrill, it's not. The game takes five rounds. And in each of those five rounds, you take five turns. That's a lot of turns. That's 25 turns. Uh, exactly 25 turns.

Yeah.

Yes. On your turn, you will roll two dice and use them. But how to use them? Which tiles to pick up? Those decisions just could take a long time. If you're playing with four players and there are three players in between your turns like this, it's not a quick game.

It's not. It is prone to analysis paralysis.

Also, if this game is not for you, so who is it for then? We think this game is for collection starters or someone who's ever said, "I love those strategy games like Katan." And you've gone, "Oh boy, let me tell you what a strategy game is." I think this is a perfect game to be introduced to people who think Katan is top of the strategy game genre cuz their minds will be blown with this game. And that's also the reason why I think it's great for collection starters. If you don't have your own collection, this is a good place to start because I feel like it fits a lot of situations and for a lot of people, most people enjoy this game. And I should have been running all over here. Wait, Sy, can you film me? I'll be right here. And then the next step on our journey is I lost myself. Oh, the final rating. I knew that. I mean, how many of these we've made? Like 100. At least 100, I think. So, this is our ranking scale.

Well, if after 15 years of it being published, we don't enjoy it, we're going to rank it at hangover. Or if we really like it, we're going to put it as must-have. Must have it in our collection. That is ready. Yes. Three, two, one, move. It's a must have. It's a modern classic for a reason. It's really, really great.

We already have it in our collection.

We have it. We're going to keep it. We're going to play it cuz it's awesome. Yeah. And we have it in a special edition. We'll show you in the next segment.

Yeah, that's the best alternative. Let's go. Remember at the beginning of the video I told you there's a special edition that made millions in game found.

Yeah. Is it worth getting this big boy or you should just keep the original? So, this is a sideby-side comparison of the both. This for sure is better. It looks better. It feels much better. It's great. It's better, right?

Yes. But also, it's more expensive. This costs three times what this costs. Also, if you want these shiny acrylic tiles, that's €30 on top of that. Is that worth the price? Game-wise, no. It's absolutely the same game. If you have the extra pesos and you want a more textile and better looking game, sure. But you don't need it. This is just as good as this, except the looks and and feels. So, if you already own this version, don't feel bad. It's already a great game. But if you can afford it and don't have it yet, go for this one.

It's just about looks versus money.

Indeed, it is. But if you're talking about a modern alternative that's another game, I would recommend Cascadia. You also are building your own thing by picking up some tiles and creating these combos for points. It's very similar game yet quicker, easier, works great, much cheaper, and much cheaper as well. And for me, the best alternative is going to be Planet Unknown. This also has that choice between two things, like two dice, but with two tiles, and you're building your own planet, and it also feels great. You started with nothing and ended with everything. Yeah, we started with the overview, finished with raiding an alternative. This was mine. And also, we're finishing this video with asking you to please support us. Send us a little bit of money because it makes sure we can continue making these videos. Thank you so much. Thank you, Mr. Yiannis. Thank you, Mr. Cy. Goodbye.

Good night. Love you all.

Progress saved