Skip to main content
Loading video...

Patrick Leder & Cole Wehrle on design, development, Oath & Root's next expansion - TCbH Interview

Transcript 1:23:57

hello and welcome back to another episode of the cardboard herald my chance to talk with creative gamers and game creators and today joining me from leader games i have patrick leader and cole worley welcome back to the show to both of you hey thank you yeah you're you're living in remote locations this ain't no leader office going on right now how's uh navigating this whole uh office dynamic during the coveted pandemic working out for leader go ahead cole oh yeah i i'm actually i'm at the office right now so but it's it's not quite the office as it was so we uh we do a lot of work together and in close proximity i mean usually there's ten people in this office are nine um and over the course of the pandemic we shut things down uh pretty quickly and it was so funny i mean not funny it was uh like in the case of oath i had just spent like an entire day building these four oath play testing kits for the four local groups that we were running we ran one night on that wednesday night we had you know the office was filled with people play testing stuff and then i think we like the patrick the office was closed like the next day or the day after yeah yep so something like that it you know it's it's been interesting we we're running right now with like a skeleton staff at the actual office our office is in a highly trafficked building it's really easy for us to social distance so we can still sort of share the facilities but a lot of this pandemic we've spent just doing remotely

which has meant i don't know starting a company discord and moving all of our play testing to tts and really changing how we do development i mean all of us are pretty hands-on folks when it comes to the creative work and so having to move everything to a digital platform has been a little tricky but i think we've mostly adapted pretty well to to its challenges tts is a bear to learn yeah yeah so we uh we i mean we're nine months into this and i showed a couple of people how to resize ponds today in tts so i was like wow um but like but like the joy of just like taking a prototype and scribbling on a card this now does three reinforcements or whatever whatever the card you know whatever you need to do you just can't do that in tts you got to be very especially for me my style of design it i just play and change until i have something that i like and i just that that is just not gelling with tts right now yeah and there were i mean one one thing that i will say about tts is it it changed our workflow and in in one thing that i've been reflecting a lot on is when like when it came to oaths testing um our play testing is exhausting especially for the testers i mean they have to go to kinkos or go to their work printer or something or their home printer they have to create a kit they have to build it cut it all the pieces so in in the normal course of play testing remote groups have a lot of friction it takes them a long time and every iteration you do exhausts your

core group but now that we have to build these tts kits we are taking all of that friction on ourselves so now that we like basically we have to do all the work of building this kit but when we release the kit all the play testers all they have to do is click on it so it actually made like in the in the case of of oath which was developed i mean about the second half of the game's development was online um it felt a lot more like managing a video game release and like we'd have patch notes and it it kept it was a really useful like backwind that kept the enthusiasm among testers up that we knew that like i could update the cards and none of the playtesters had to worry about anything because it was just instantly in their kit so there have been some advantages too and some lessons that we're taking into our general process as we start to imagine what game design looks like after covid tracking oath's development since the original announcement and then the kickstarter one of the unique things about leader games to me is just how transparent you are with the overall development process and that you announce things so much earlier and you you make it available for people to see i'm wondering if your willingness to show those kind of changes the the immediate iterations is influenced by the the lockdown here and is that something that you intend to continue even after we're out of quarantine well one thing i'll say about oath is the so when it came to play testing i have a few local groups

here in the twin cities and patrick does and and then we have our studio and then we might have some remote groups but and oath was oath was different because because all of these groups stopped meeting we suddenly had access to a pool of play testers that we had never had before so like there might be like one of my favorite people who i'd love to have as a play tester maybe he's the only person in their group that wants to play an earliest game but because that group's no longer a meeting i can take him again like he can he can come join join our crew so what i mean i've run a lot of play testing forms in the past but i have never the oath testing discord which was it was a private discord but basically anybody who asked could join so it was kind of like there was an open door used to open it and there was such a spirit of camaraderie that developed in that group and it was clear that everyone was just hanging out there that that discord has like a pet channel it has a book club there's like all these like funny side channels that that started spawning and it was clear that like during especially those early months of covid these folks were just like kind of hanging out and helping work on the game um and i think this is a place where like the kind of like open development process which like patrick has been doing since fast and those those work in progress things um it fed really beautifully into the the challenges of what we're running into it because this is i mean this is kind of old hat for you patrick right yeah yeah i don't much said

well you mentioned that there's someone in your group you're like oh man this this guy would be great to have as a play tester what makes for an ideal play tester for each of you oh um i so play testing has two very distinct phases for me and i i almost wish there was two terms right because when you say play testing a lot of people think it's the latter and i like in my early design process i am very open to change and changing on the fly and obviously that is not how you want you know you're not gonna have the dress rehearsal you're talking about the actor with notes about how they're gonna act you know you should be you should have that locked down by then and and so that like there's those two phases where it's like i'm creating and play creating and then i'm play testing and my my closest group to me is very comfortable with changing things on the flyer suggesting uh changes to make on the fly and and um i like that we actually haven't really met since the lockdown unfortunately uh that group that wednesday group it kind of fell apart like during the oath testing because they were gonna go do some you know some of them went to do with testing and and uh it just you know distance with the with the block down also my like one of my primary playtesters just you know his spouse works for the minnesota department of health and she's been working a million hours a week so he's had to change re-prioritize games but the games aren't as important right now so take it

yeah i mean i i would i would i would second that especially patrick's uh comment about like there being these two phases i i find that you know with the second phase i'm kind of happy to have anybody come join but with the first phase i'm very careful because there's a lot of trust that um i you like everyone at the table is going to have the ability to steer the game towards their own preferences and so you just want to really make sure that you are careful with who you invite to like the dinner party right because that's going to determine the character of the conversation around the game otherwise your preferences yeah yeah exactly you know what i'm usually looking for in a playtester they're kind of like two things um one they have to be like engaged and be able to be able and interested in like talking about games and to be thinking about better ways of talking about them and putting their feelings into words and kind of sorting through that um and so i want like a i want a good um a good participant in that conversation and then the second really important qualification and this becomes especially critical in the second half of the process is they have to be really good at losing and being dispassionate and that is that is a hard thing because you know i mean i i think about when i've been playing a lot of um a lot of apex legends lately and get some other competitive games and you just like lose a lot and it's really easy to get like tilt yourself you start you know attract putting emotions like oh i just keep dying in the first drop i wish i could like live past the first minute once and then

as soon as you think that it's over because you're gonna keep dying and you're gonna start getting agitated and ramping up so i'm always looking for folks that are just really good at rolling with the punches and not like playing with spirit but also being able to distance themselves and i think you know our one of our staff uh graphic designers and developers nick brockman is great at this and i think a lot of it comes from the fact like he used to play a lot of competitive card games and so he's just very used to the idea that he's that you know you you you default to the position that you're probably going to lose you'll try hard to win but it doesn't matter too much we just uh uh case in point we just call wasn't at the computer yet and we we sent the the new uh the new uh root faction after his keep uh before he arrived at the table and it was uh the dice just didn't come out but you could have lost your keep before which is the thing we got to fix but right sort of but also like those situations will happen right yeah yeah yeah and any any fought back and didn't obviously he came to the game and didn't really care but it was i thought it was funny like someone else could have been like dang it and loved the game yeah it's like it's a funny bass because you do you don't want people who are totally dispassionate like you want them to care right but you also don't want them to get too you know emotional about what happened it was a bad play for the him anyway because yeah it was blown out yeah especially with feedback and criticism being such an essential part of testing anything

if you can't kind of disconnect yourself from the the feeling of being you know the loser in a game then you may actually look for reasons either consciously or subconsciously for why the game made you lose and that may affect your feedback and i imagine that that that has to be something that you guys take into consideration whenever you listen to feedback or look at feedback forms or anything like that speaking of feedback the the transparency that you have with all these iterations uh with oath i mean it is awesome that you can make the the tts version of this game so broadly available and get all kinds of feedback and response from fans and interested parties and the woodland alliance you know the people who just want to be die hard leader games fans but do you feel like that kind of transparency can undermine some of the original creative vision for a product that you're working on you know a lot of the reason why some people wouldn't be transparent about this is because they might be worried that the audience isn't necessarily going to get it if they don't see it in a more polished state oath is going to be an interesting experiment in that regard because it has it is it is so much more available like usually when we're working on testing once we're done with the game we don't do the tts or the print and play until

the game's retail release and you do that because you kind of well one you do you don't have time to prepare a game for print and prepare print and play release but the second thing you want to do is you want to kind of like shut the pressure valve yeah and like build up anticipation for release and because of covid uh and for other reasons i think maybe uh we just have kind of like kept it going with oath and so people are playing like pretty much very close to the release version right now they're not getting the wonderful physical production but they're getting the game and all the art and everything and uh it'll be interesting to see what happens because a lot of the the what we think of as like our core audience they've played a lot of oath they've played 20 30 games of oath and so are those same people going to be excited when the game actually arrives on their doorstep or because i mean to me i i it is i i won't fault anyone if they say like well i've already played that game 20 times like my goodness i'll certainly take that um so i think there's a little bit of an experiment uh going on and we're not you know we're not totally sure uh how it'll go but you know root was much the same people kept playing their print and plays during root and that was no substitute for the game's physical release and i i think that in general um a big takeaway from oath has been that like the community has made that game better we did something with the oath that we had never done before um which is normally when the game goes into when we start preparing the production files for a game we freeze everything and we do this

because we don't want to generate any like editorial liability or like put in a typo in the last minute i i would often tell people that we you know a graphic designer rehire something that whenever you make a change in the the press the pre-press process there's a 25 chance that you introduce another error so you don't want to make changes in general because you know that you might screw something else up but with oath we had some extra safeguards in place we had a full-time editor and a full-time graphic designer just doing pre-press and so because we had more um more more safeguards more structure uh and we really wanted to and we had an active community we made the call to do something different with our prepress which is way prepress works is you submit the files and then there's going to be like a month of back and forth of the factory for oath it was even a little bit more than a month because it's a complicated big project where you're just you're just like fixing the colors or an icon got messed up it's very very mundane but while we did that we kept updating the tabletop simulator and when somebody would ask a question about a card interaction our editor josh yearsley could say like okay actually this would be clear if we could put a little clarification on the card let's go ahead and do that and then we would update the game's print files so it was it was a strange thing that happened that we made a lot of very last minute changes to oath no design changes but they were just like clarifications very very small adjustments and we were really bringing in the community so i think that you know the the flip side of this is you can

exhaust the community doing this kind of work but if the community is active we wanted to capture as much as there of that energy as possible we've talked a lot about the the road to oath and the testing and the availability of it at this point but i'd be remiss if i didn't go back to like some of the original creative vision so can you tell me cole what was like the original spark for this game because conceptually it's so different than a lot of games out there so oath is a lot it's like a lot of stuff i've worked on in that there's like no single moment there was like no single moment where it made sense because i think better i've talked about this a lot like there are lots of we've both been thinking about campaign games for a long time i had been especially like fretting over um the way games end it's funny i haven't actually talked about this strand i feel like whenever someone asks me about the beginnings of oath i give them a different answer but the the guy this guy i think his name scott westerfield he wrote he gave a talk at shucks about why victory points are bad and he used the example of root and and he wasn't wrong but uh you know he had this comment that uh the game didn't always build to a meaningful climax and he was he was um he was making a category error like books don't behave like novels right so don't ask them to have like that beautiful whatever that curve is called that has the rising action and the climax and the falling action so but i was thinking about that a lot and i was just thinking like is there a possible way to build a conflict game that is is very attuned to narrative

structure and that has like climaxes and you know so i was thinking about that kind of stuff and then a couple but at this point like there were lots of different inspirations and it wasn't even clear this was a game it was like just a bunch of scattered thoughts and then there were a couple moments that crystallized it one of them was when patrick and i were driving back from a convention and we were talking a lot about campaign systems and it's actually in that conversation itself was an extension of a very early conversation probably i had been on the shop for maybe a month when we had the first conversation where you patrick you were talking to me about some stuff and path and it was so exciting because it reminded me of things that i've been thinking about from this game i was working on called scion a million years ago but just like the idea of a game that changed with its players was just absolutely thrilling and i think it was it was just a place where pat and i both been thinking about a lot and comparing notes and that conversation was extremely generative and but then after that you have this like very long gestational process i kept building versions of oath that like kind of worked but i don't even think patrick played any of them it was like i would you know he might come in the office and i was just like goofy you really like you'd be like messing around with like this hex map yeah yeah with a couple like political boundaries on it and you'd be like these are roman giants are and i'm like cool cole yeah so when you actually had something for patrick to to see or the whole team to see patrick were you on board at that point oh yeah i mean that's on board at the hex map point

so uh especially after the successive route i was willing to throw the keys to cole pretty early in the process anyway um yeah it's kind of funny because i really wasn't in the office much when you turned on oath really yeah yeah because oath was kind of in a bad it wasn't a bad it was just it wasn't it wasn't moving when you left yeah yeah yeah yep yes you know so i had a baby you had a baby in september yes of 2019. i had a baby and not me personally my spouse did uh in november 2019 and um it was a rough transition for us and it's our second child but uh or he is our second child but um it wasn't yeah it was a little bit tricky of a delivery and um yeah and so as i was just gone you know and then and then i come back and like you guys are like six weeks into playing this game and it's firing and i played it and i was like oh i feel very old but but you know it's a combination of sleep deprivation in in the game uh itself um and then and then just jumping into this meta that that nick and cole and josh had already had going basically because they had been playing it so uh but no no i'm i was very excited about it right away um and then you know he talks about that conversation which is important maybe we should just drive somewhere for six hours again cole and then we'll you know i haven't finished path yet

though so yeah so we could be it can be the the path trip uh so we gotta we gotta finish path but then uh we can have another conversation and we can start to work in a game together and then realize that we can't work on a game together and go work on two separate games um both in path it's kind of weird they're like one letter off from each other uh strange um rosie so yeah i i bought in really early cole like what cole doesn't tell about the story too is there was this amazing pitch meeting very early on where like cole comes in and i'm like show me what you got i need to know soon i'm getting tense about this i think this is when we're at the vandalia building still and we sit down and we have this big company-wide meeting which at the time was not that big and and then like kyle starts talking about the art and you start talking about the the the different groups coming together and how they'll come into play and you know and that was back when you still had like if the demons ruled again it's going to be victory condition and this so-and-so rules it would be this victory condition and it was an amazing pitch because neither of them had really coordinated it i figured out later and it was it was the closest thing analogy i can say it was like giving a high five in the dark the it was so smooth i thought that they had planned it out and and it was basically like well kyle's like i'm gonna do all this and we're gonna have uh these guys are going to be the wizards that control the setting which

turned into the player characters not really they're not wizards now but but that's what they were then one of them even retained they think that red pawn is still kind of a jackaly looking uh person and and that all that all came over and that was the point i was like all right if you guys can deliver that then i'm i yeah i'm on board so it is it is it's so funny looking at like that that conversation was crazy uh because kyle and i had like lightly talked about something going to work but i was not aware of the existence that of this game that kyle had been working on that fed like just beautifully into i mean it was it was really remarkable about the title they were calling it back then and i i i was like uh works pretty cool oath is very cool has there throughout the development ever been points of actual contention between you two about certain aspects of the game uh not with oath i've been pretty hands-off yeah i mean i i think oath it's like you've been working on a lot of other things you've been playing oath but and but i i think that you know i mean you're gonna run into disagreements like i actually i it's like i um when i think about the the folks who were spending a lot of time working on oath where it was like it was so it's mostly developed by myself and josh and nick and we definitely got into some arguments um and i i think part of it is like you just care too much right i i mean i but i had to i'd have like um

there was there was more than one time where either i had to give this talk to someone else or someone else had to give it to me where they were like hey you are too focused on something that's very small right you have to like back out and let's like take a look at the whole picture and i think oath oath was so complicated that there needed to be not as a design but just as like a project that there just had to be a lot of people helping and so i felt like my my design works so for for the oath card base so oath has 250 unique cards or so and i've did the primary design on like probably 160 of them or 170 maybe uh and then the other the other design was done by either josh or nick or patrick had a suggestion or like a lot lots of people the play testers um and there i think for the second half of the project i felt much more like a conductor than like an author in a cave it was it felt a lot like okay everyone's doing good work i just need to mostly make sure that everyone's contribution is gelling with the full thing and putting those together yeah yeah and and plays together i think you know that like that uh so conflict is then part of that process but it's a part that you just have to you know you you can't avoid it you just have to be able to work through it i think there was a point where you we play tested it you were like i'm concerned about this and then i said here's the solution for this and you were like yeah and here it already is laid out and

and it was it was putting drag on the players turns based on number of armies i think yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah it was was in there and and i was like oh you just gotta you know and i was like well all right then yep so sometimes i'm glad we agree yeah yeah yeah that that that definitely happens too was there any aspect of the game that you were super passionate about but you had to sacrifice for the sake of making a better game oh that's a hard question for oath it's like i can i can give that question for your title well let's hear it for ruth that let's look at that well so okay so oath is very funny because what happened with oath's development and this is unique as far as any project i've worked on is oath had a simple initial design it got very complicated and then it got reduced back to kind of that simple core in a way that was like sometimes like eerie how it was like oh wow actually we are just going to go back to that very simple basic system and so like a lot of stuff did get cut out of oath but it got cut in a way that i was like not sad about i was like gleeful when we got the rules down to as long as they are with root there were lots of things cut i mean the the example that i think is on patrick's mind it's on mine is like the alternate win conditions in root um which is yeah i want i want them to work i just want them to work i don't know i got a message from somebody i bet patrick got this message too who was like i really miss them

i miss these alternate conditions i will like buy you lunch if you can put them in well it was like it was you know and and this person said like hey um i like root just fine i think it's a great game but my favorite board gaming experience ever was played with like the second to last play test kit or like the kickstarter like this in the cube that's always my like yeah yeah there's just always room to bring it back in you got expansions you even have an expansion just on the horizon oh no no come bolt it on people will buy it that's how you make money right just give the people what they want who cares about balance i think i i agree with cole i think it's it's good to keep make sure that the like root is quite very flexible as it is and to make two sets of rules is kind of dangerous yeah totally yeah um yeah i missed i missed those those those alternate video conditions so like i said there was the woodland alliance could win by storming the keep or sieging the keeper or something like that if and that's kind of where the dominance one came from is you want to put a lot of pieces in one spot and um yeah it was just it was you know narratively just hilarious like it was like this moment we were like ah you know like i i have to throw and the wooden alliance had trouble getting troops on the board too back then so it was it was very special moment when you get that many guys on the board and then do it or folks on the board you know though i mean really you kind of explored that with oath and

then i think you're gonna explore that that sudden victory death or that sudden death space and and voidlitch um and you know vast definitely had yeah yeah totally i mean that's it is funny how much the the the leader games games are like direct they're they're at such conversation with each other like like and i think sometimes people miss this about root because root is such a reaction to vast yeah and not not like a critique of it it's such like a okay what parts of ass work what parts don't work as well is there a way that we can square these things and then when i think about oath oath is like a complete reaction to root and uh and you know voidlish is very much like a wrestler i heard you say things about voidlitch that are like layers responding to oath yeah i'm like yeah clearly trying to like you know process that stuff through i mean it and i like we i think that both of us have a design sensibility that um is pretty liberal with like harvesting parts from previous work so it's so funny because i used to make the have this be a point of contrast between us patrick because i always thought like i really only have like one active project and then maybe like a future project whereas you have like several projects but i i but i think that we we both like are really aggressive about taking stuff from things that hasn't quite haven't quite started work yet and so like you know just to get back to your question um about systems that i was sad to destroy in oath i had a combat system that i

really liked that was very much like my critique of dunes combat i thought it was dope i thought it was really interesting it just could not work it was like fundamentally unworkable and i was very sad to see it go but it was it was just completely obvious it had to go and though that system has already informed other stuff that i'm working on um which won't work which won't work then i'll get sad again and throw it let's talk about the lineage of leader games i mean i know that before vass came out that leader had put out uh games but vast was the big breakthrough and then there was root and at the time a lot of people probably dumb people like myself would be like yo leader games they're the people who make asymmetric games that is the identity the core that leader games is going to put out but now here at the tail end of 2020 you have four you have oath on the horizon and i i don't even really know that much about voy blitch i feel like you could make a lot of assumptions about what a leader game is going to be or or supposed to represent a couple years ago patrick do you feel like the the identity of the company has shifted and maybe your intent of what leader scope is yeah i you know and i don't like i think the identity was a little bit assigned to me

and i played into it of course because it was a good angle to market the company when we were growing but now we have i hate to say that maybe we have the clout to publish other we definitely have to i mean we've definitely published other things uh at this point as you as you just said so yeah um for me it was the you know i was working on i did publish trick-or-treat i was working in more complicated designs and trick or treats goal was to just teach me the publishing process right because it was it's just a double check box it's nothing complicated to it there's still like 100 left in the warehouse if anybody wants to get one it's it's almost gone um and so like and so coming out of that i was working on a some dungeon crawler thing and i discovered vast and um of course made the pitch for it right away and um out of that though david initially said no and he wanted to work with another publisher and so what i did was i started talking to david about thinking that david was some like design guru but it turned out that was his first design and he just kind of like he just kind of like i mean and that was great because it's like it's he designed something original because he had no frame of reference about the rest of the industry and so he was like how do i tell this very complicated story we're all divided up among the players to each take a role in that story and so

i started working with him on other designs and uh i was working on this game called giant at the time and just think if a giant had been published we'd be doing five letter um and uh and so we're working on giant together and he kind of like laid out for me the structure of how he like you know how he made every every group atmosphere with the other group and how you block the other you know how you block the other groups and like that seems obvious but at the time it was really informative and interesting and so i designed um giant and then giant started breaking down into other projects because it was too big it was too unwieldy so i started like figuring other things and path actually does come directly from that work on giant giant like like there was a there was a version of giant where the players are controlling the victory conditions by spending influence on the factions in the game and then as they do jobs like the like you know if for to use the root setting which is where path is now you know if you do if you are if you are famous in the mark marquises court and you're doing bounty hunter missions then you get more points or if other players are doing bounty hunter missions while you're well invested in the cat's court then you still would get be getting points for that and so that was one of the like that was one of the aspects of giant that split out of it so um so yeah but then of course you know he came to us and said let's do vast together and he unfortunately had to drop out of

the process due to some family issues and um but then i you know i took over and um created that that asymmetric design um i mean what it did teach us though was that it is and especially working on tmm afterwards if i maybe uh cole will agree it's just it's just a big teach i love vast i in fact i worked on vast three last weekend uh for funsies and um or to gain experience points or whatever however we wanna uh however we wanna talk about it and um but it's just it is it's when you get to a convention and you're spending 20 minutes just explaining the four turns to somebody it is it's it's a bit of a bear to teach and so one of the i think one of the goals of root in my mind is the producer and and cole walked right into this and started working on it was how to make the asymmetry so that there's a common enough language that that's easy to express between the roles which is you know movement in combat is very similar so you just have to explain that once you don't explain combat a million times and then there's just things that change it and then you know having a scoring system versus a sudden death victory system allowed players to track the game state much easier and so that's i think that's the canola ninja garage but from there i i you know like i think one of when i started designing voidlitch one of the one of the goals of it was to make a world where um the to reduce the asymmetry of root

even further and and and i i i at the time i said the my intent with the symmetry was to make it somewhere between twilight and pyrium and root where the you still play twilight imperium generally very similar but there is enough asymmetry between the uh what are they called nations factions yeah i don't know right so so between our races maybe yeah so between the between the species there's enough there's enough rule changes that you could still you still feel that the asymmetric wheel turning a little bit especially i think of the the players that really play with the action cards um but it's not but you're still playing a very similar game to each other so some are a little bit past that but before root for asymmetry um and then you know i think now the goal for void lich is to make the asymmetry emergent is kind of how i would describe that is that yeah yeah that's that's fair i mean i i yeah and with oath it's emergent too in in some sense yeah yeah i mean it's you know i i see discussions about oaths asymmetry a lot on the uh the will and warriors discord and and in other places and it's interesting because if you were to just line up the powers in oath and the victory conditions it is closer to vast than root in asymmetry just because like if you ask someone how do you win and root there there are some commonalities about how the victory points work generally right and when you're playing oath it's like okay i win if i can sneak into the castle and steal the scepter and run out to the desert and he wins if he can start a revolt like out you

know in this area and so like they they're just really different player positions um even though it's relying on a kind of shared set of uh of rules the way i i've tended to think about the company um the companies like governing style or mission is that fundamentally we do thematic immersive games right and and vast fast is is one and root is one and oath is one um and a lot of companies that are our size uh tend not to do games like this because they're expensive they're expensive in terms of development in terms of art they're expensive in every way a game can be expensive basically um but our our our our ethos our styles that like the players get to drive a lot of that theme that it's that's immersive that it's gonna it's gonna put the players first and we i mean i you know it's funny when i first started working here i remember telling patrick one of the things i was so attracted to about the way vast um was was was the way it comported itself vast has um a seldom commented but i think it's very charming like kind of a retro feel mm-hmm yeah yeah yeah i i i just i don't see people talk about it but i look at the vast books i'm like this kind of looks like an 80s role-playing game just in the way it like imports itself but of course it feels like an 80s game sometimes yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah and i think part of that is that the art is so hand-drawn that you really see like

it doesn't look too polished it doesn't have that like sheen that like a lot of modern game art has um not there's anything wrong with it of course but it like just in its whole spirit it has this like kind of like spunky like 80s school design to it despite the fact that on the other hand uh vast especially the first the the first um game in the series it has a very modern design sensibility like the way the different factions behaves like patrick i i could see you doing a lot of the like reaction to first and second wave euros in that design and so like it had a modern design sensibility but it's like heart like the the song it wanted to play was like an 80s song mid-atlantic yeah yeah yeah exactly so it just to me like that so when i think about like what does the the the company do at least right now i mean of course it's always changing um when we're at conventions and stuff and someone asked me like oh what kind of games do you guys make here i always say like well these are games that are really immersive they're really player driven very story first but the you are going to be determining the story and uh they're really interactive and ultimately like and i love turning away people in our booth the question i'll ask them is like hey do you like to play one game a lot of times because that's kind of a bag we just we just have to own it a little bit because it allows us to play by a different set of rules than a publisher that knows that they're trying to win you in the first five minutes so uh but to piggyback on that what i'll say is when i was getting into the market

i felt like there was a real push so kickstarter and not you know kickstarter is my bread and butter so i'm not not criticizing it but what it was doing i had a friend who went to like a meet-up in austin for designers and this guy several people showed up one meeting he'd never met before and one of them just launched into this long thing about how his game is going to market and how he's going to produce it and it's it's kind of like raising your hand on the first day of a college class and saying what do i need to do again a in here instead of saying what do i intend to learn here like i felt like i felt like they were they were like way way the car was way before the horse if they were talking about the marketing of the game because they're like i'm not focused on making an authentic fun experience i'm focused on how to make it as a producer in this industry and i i and i i always want to focus on the experience that the players having i like the money is great but you know the money just lets me continue building an authentic experience and um and so that so like where am i going with this um and so he um and so that like when i got into the industry i felt like if you looked at people were always bemoaning whenever not promoting when they'd play a game with me and they'd say why can't you make a simpler game why can't make a ticket to ride why can't you make a a carcassonne like which just gets down to the essential elements of that design and they're great designs i love carcassonne i'll uh i'm a little over carcassonne but i'll play ticket to ride any day of the week

that's fine uh and that's just because they play like carcassonne so and so i think what we did was we i said i'm just gonna embrace like i'm not gonna keep racing towards easier simpler and that is a great aesthetic embrace it if that's how you want to design or if that is what you're what you were skilled at doing but what i wanted to do was to to answer the call of people were saying i get burned out in games really fast and i'm like well yes because you're playing something that is very like it has a repetitive turn structure repetitive flow i want to make a game for you that you can you can sink your teeth into and get into and keep playing over and over and enjoy for a long time and i don't want you to keep filling up your shelves as i stand in a room full of games um i don't want to keep filling up your shelves with with games that are that aren't going to satisfy you um and then the other the other part about the aesthetic i wanted to talk about was that the um there's an interview with peter melio who designed who's a british is that the right yeah quickly british yeah uh lionhead studios ryan had studios yeah he made fable he made frankly some of my favorite games from my childhood when he was working for bullfrog and when he designed uh fable he was talking about how there was behavior people were taking in the game that he had not anticipated when he designed the game and one of them was he would get people drunk so players would get people drunk and get them to follow them outside of town and then they would impress these people with spells or something like that until they were in a stupor and then they

and then the player would run back to the town and steal everything obviously that's just game breaking that isn't very interesting to me but he then talked a lot about emergent gameplay and that notion has always been interesting to me and i think it is hard to pull off in a in a computer game because you can see all the parts much more easily than you can see the math in a video game but um for me that is like that's kind of like where i want to go to by the end is i want to get to this like world where i see someone playing it go i had no idea you could do this with the game but it's not off the rails yet so that is a very nice summary of like when i feel like i know a game is getting close to being done yes is when i start to see players do like there was a late stage um oath play test where players uh there's a card called the tinker's fare which allows players to trade relics and negotiate for them normally you can't do that it's one of those those rules of game design that's like be careful don't let players trade things they'll break your game so an oath there are powers that kind of open up that type of gameplay but i i saw notes about a game where players were renting their relics to each other so they'd be like hey uh two dollars you can borrow this for a turn in half and then you gotta give it back and it was just so delightful because it was not really how that car was intended to work but it was clear that the the players had found like an emergent character for that game uh that fit perfectly within the general theme and it wasn't something i anticipated i'm like okay we can we can shut it down game's done

i love it we've talked a lot about the the stuff that's just about to come out i mean oath is on the horizon i know it's still tbd as far as specific date that is going to be available in retail but you also have a lot of projects in development patrick you mentioned you were dabbling with vast three i mean is that a reality on the horizon is that just no no no a little tinkering project for you yeah it was a little bit of tinkering i um i had i had designed so back when we were working on mysterious manor i had approached it as i was making crystal caverns and i i wanted to like try to see what would happen if i just made a true expansion for crystal caverns so i designed this thing about an ice cave and everything had an ice like sort of shift to it so the ice dragon ice or a creepy cave i think is what i called it and so what i did was i basically kind of just designed it like similar but slightly more not complicated but slightly deeper rolls based on uh the crystal caverns so that was the and i was going to call that the the uh um the depth expansion and then i also designed mysterious manor which was width and that was if you if you just take the roles over to a new game and rewrite the game what do you end up with in mysterious manner won that moment you know like that's that's the one we ended up going with and um turns out that it was tricky to market because people wanted the expansion and not the thought it was

not the and not a new core game and so as we realized as i got closer to realizing the core game was going to work there was there was a a day maybe 2018 where i rewrote all the fearsome uh i'm sorry the the frozen fear which is what it ended up being called i rewrote all those rules to work independently of uh the crystal caverns but i got stuck on the setting horror or the fear you know like the actual setting and how to make it because before it had just been like a flavor of the cave and so now i wanted to make a new setting and i have i have notes oops ah good good interview and ship here patrick keeping your phone on um hey we're all in 2020 experiencing this this is the norm now i mean that's flavor that's what that is that's what the people want to see well i could have done this upstairs with kids in the background um and so um yeah and so i i just uh i i'd redesigned it and i and i just like okay well i'm just gonna shelve this and someday i'm gonna have an idea for how the the fear works and then this weekend like my brain was like here you are two years later this is how the fear is gonna work and so i just sat down and redesigned the fear and then that led to me redesigning all the other roles because i was like well it's it all has to fit together and i did that very like it was probably less than six hours of work uh to design it now of course i gotta prototype it and build it but yeah so uh that's that's just for passion but we're working on um route four uh which will be the next we haven't decided on a title we already

discussed a title for yeah we haven't even started that and so we're kind of dividing up the uh responsibilities here and making it more of a studio project and so right now i am working on two more militant factions for the game as you know militant being a faction that has to police the boards the game state to make sure that they can get to victory yeah i i think of those as the factions that stabilize the board you're going to need one of those in place someone has got to be the moles or the cats or the eerie and that was the participation behind designing them was we figured well if if you're going to target high reach groups in the game then let's give players more options uh in case in case that's what they want it also allows stabilizes two player a little bit because both of these should work as an anchor for a two player game uh i think i don't see any reason why neither would work yet they should both work just fine i would look forward to playing the rollers versus the cats across the entire board um and not not next door um and so that was that was one goal and then we talked about um well and so then cole is designing uh we talked about uh making a extending the player ranges a little bit so making two player a little bit more satisfying and making a five or six player which we i think we've kind of dropped from the project i don't i guess we're kind of i don't i think it's still there maybe yeah okay yeah we had like patrick had a good idea for like kind of a way to extend the board potentially and have you know like a bigger maps for the groups that want to

play on the bigger map um because there are people out there it's not me but there are people out there patrick who like like rooted the high count yeah right i mean i you know i may not have commented on it patrick but i read dan's thread i read that about uh dan thoreau the reviewer was like i kind of want to play root with eight people um and it's like well you know you can't really do that on the the 12 clearing map but a 15 clearing map yeah i might yeah maybe maybe um so you know like you know as patrick said this this way this root content is definitely like a studio project and what we mean by that is it's like it's all hands on deck everyone's open everyone's got ideas we're all putting stuff in the broth the thing that i'm mostly working on is um the other side is the two oh yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah sorry sorry sorry i didn't want to don't want to see your thunder um so yeah the other side is the the the two player and the two player has an interesting prominence basically um many elements of root are very modular and very easy to expand but there is one system part that is not that does not expand very cleanly and that's the game's setup it works fine but it just doesn't it just doesn't like uh it doesn't sock it as neatly as the other ones do when it comes to having a lot of content so i am in the process basically uh there are i kind of looked at looked at the problems uh you know as we were kind of giving up tasks and thinking about different ways of going

and patrick had been working a little bit on the the two player and i was working on the setup and then it it occurred to me that actually i kind of wanted to work on the two player as well as the setup as well as helping with any balance adjustments to the system because all those issues were like very tightly interrelated and so i i'm working on a new advanced setup system which will plug very seamlessly into the tournament style draft that a lot of people who run root tournaments use we're basically going to adapt that system make it official and then build it directly into the setup so that you can get around some friends you can very quickly make a pool of actions and then draft those factions and as part of the draft you're setting up the board and then if you're playing at lower player counts we have these like little minor factions that players will fight control for control over that allow the low player count game to still feel populated and it's a little bit different than the bots like when you're playing with the bots there's a there's a very subtle like cooperative element when you're playing with the bots right right right because yeah and i think that that's actually something that the bots are very good at and i don't want to don't want to take any of the bot's thunder when it comes to like what what they add to the game when you play with the minor factions it feels like you're playing more of a war game okay so this is blowing my mind minor factions are going to be in root so like give me kind of like a practical example to the extent that you feel comfortable sharing

what this is so the way the way it works and you know this is again caveat there's all the stuffs in development it could change a million times um the way the minor factions work is they are color-coded to the major factions uh they use different pieces maybe that the piece shape might be different and they'll come in a little tuck box and they are kind of like a flavor of the major factions so like for instance uh the woodland uh the woodland alliance one is called the spring uprising i love this right and basically what it does is it's this little minor faction that players can bid for control on using a currency that i'll talk about in a second and then on your turn you get to like put little unrest tokens down which behave mostly like sympathy and then can also cause revolts but you know they don't have warriors they don't score victory points they're just a they're just a pawn but you have to be careful because you could build a bunch of sympathy webs on the board and then you might lose control of the of the spring uprising and now it's the other player who's holding the gun that you've been crafting for the whole game um this is powered by a pretty simple sort of zero-sum influence economy that pays players uh who are struggling in the game so if you have the fewest points you've been getting that's not kicked out of you in combat you're gonna have more of these little influence points which you can use to bid for control on these different factions uh the other element to this is uh you can also bid for return order um for for who gets to go first and they and it gives it gives the game like it

gives the players a lot of tempo control which is actually not something that players have ever had in root right like root is a game about tempo where you don't get to control the tempo and you just have to understand like the you know what the natural balance of the table is depending on seating order and factions and when you play with the minor factions it gives players a lot like do i want is it more valuable for me to take control of like the weird lizard minor faction or to be first player next round i'm excited about this because the i i've been watching a lot of 40k lately and i like the because it's not a b a b returns now it's you have to roll for initiative each turn there is this like you cannot leave yourself in a position that's vulnerable because someone might double you double up on your turn and so i i'm interested to see how that sort of behavior translates to well this is a pretty fundamental shift because root isn't a game that has rounds built into it from the the get-go so is this going to be the the default way of playing from now on if you're using any element of this expansion is this a variant so this is a thing that i uh i have very mixed feelings about but i'm growing more comfortable with it as i as i live in the space it is essentially like the first modular option for root so all of the existing setup stuff all the existing setups rules those all are still there and then players can make the choice to play with the advanced setup which then

brings in minor factions it brings in the tempo stuff and all so but for i should be very clear about this for the new expansion uh you can play with the factions in any form yeah you could just draw like that we are not we are not upsetting the apple cart at all there you know if you want to play with the new factions or if you do new maps all that stuff still works just fine but then for the players who have gotten really into the game especially like on the competitive side you uh will have these sort of the sort of advanced setup system that plugs in with the minor factions and it's not it's not really that complicated but it does change the character of the game a little bit and the minor factions they could be played at any player account it just enriches two-player which is one of the more lagging ways of playing we're like still trying to figure it out precisely it probably will be something like three minor factions in the two-player you use two for three and four and just one for five and more uh i haven't like quite we haven't quite figured out those numbers most of the testing i've done has been with two and three players we're still we're still pretty early on and you know it's so interesting i feel like with the design of the minor factions this has been a place where um we have been playing so we play a lot of games in studio and i think this has been a place where um like so i like this has been a good place where the studio system has uh been a real strength so for instance like the bidding for turn order thing came from um playing a lot of undaunted with with the development uh our developer nick brockman and we were just talking about the importance

of tempo and war games there are these old civil war games where i think um the gmt's the civil war has this great mechanism where when we decide who goes first we both roll a die and then the higher role goes first and you take as many actions as the differential between the two guys it's a great mechanism it's a great mechanism because you could play a very aggressive and dangerous play hoping that you're gonna get to go again right and so uh but um you know also you know we've been having um conversation like patrick had made uh when patrick was thinking of the the two player he made a comment about like the problem with roots combat is that you know in a in if it's just me and you and i roll really well there is no third player that can like help fix that problem totally right and so that led to a way of getting influence where if zeros are rolled on the die the defender who's the one who was hurt by that zero is going to generate some extra currency which they can use to then take bids that are going to improve their their their setup position so the so far the advanced setup has been very very very tight and a lot i mean one of the weird things about root is that not many games of root get to the end game it's it's a rare thing a lot of games have rooted in at the seven turn mark or before and the end game of root where everybody has like 23 points but no one really has the ability to score that last seven it's my favorite part of

the game and it just doesn't happen that often but this so far has been taking a lot of the games i've played to that in-game uh which is really exciting that's cool are you can you send me some photos of the game in progress oh yeah i haven't even seen oh yeah i will die i should take you send me the assets and i'll load them into tts for you yeah no i i was gonna i was gonna put them into tts on monday so they're on okay cool all ready to go patrick you said that you're working on two militant factions are these only factions that right now you're planning on having in the expansion yeah i think so i yeah i i mean i i know so i mean i i did want to like give there's other major factions at the studio we should probably give a shake to also but we haven't really uh i just kind of how the timing of us going back to work from home worked out it made sense for me just jam on the two melted factions alone but yeah for right now that's it now what what they know is also exciting to me is is some of the kind of half half factions you see from the fan factions or from even the studio generating stuff can plug in very easily as a minor faction and so you might see an expansion someday that's just here's two minor factions like i think that's a brilliant way of incorporating all kinds of new fun stuff into what is otherwise you know a really simple system i mean that's one of the things that i love most about root and i i've found that you know your your guys's hope of having games that reward repeated play has absolutely come

true with root the more that i play the more that it kind of elevates in my mind of you know my favorite games and part of that is that i like that fundamentally root is kind of a simple framework and the complexity comes from two things one is of course the asymmetry and and you know all the different things that a faction can do but two is the strategic possibilities that are left up to you in that simple framework i mean it's almost shocking when you realize how simple movement works and combat works and that kind of stuff but by the amount of interaction that you can have the possibilities are pretty numerous and as you're describing these uh these minor factions uh it's just sounding awesome but i want to know about the new major factions you know the these uh two militant factions what can you share about them first do you have the animals on lockdown yeah yeah uh so you know i gotta uh i gotta kick one thing back to cole cole real quick and you start a new design do you start with the root movement and combat rules yes a little bit oh man that's why yeah no it's so so so funny i've been working with networking yeah i've been working on this uh and uh um well i i will probably talk about it a little bit more but i wanna hear you talk about the

new factions but um when i started working on a a design take for the space game that we've been working on i literally was like okay i have a new action framework let's just play root with this action framework yeah because i don't want to think about movement and adjacency and combat like let's just play with the new action framework and then as soon as i got that working i was like okay now i can start to customize the rest of the chassis to meet the action framework um but yeah i use that system all the time now all right so we are working on two factions right now the um warlord or the rats i don't i guess we gotta come up at the top warlords is great because it's it is the structure of their their society like warlord yeah yeah yeah um but they'll be represented by rats in the game with personalities like the vagabonds is there's a single piece that is the warlord itself and uh and they'll be you know they'll have a character card that has a personality or a different ability that's how that's expressed uh in the game and so the the faction tends to focus on um hedge enemy like ruling uh clearings completely and it focuses on the motion of the warlord across the board and how um they're the ones that are the son of the fighting and they're the ones at the center of the action and as they move away from you um you know they you they lose that presence basically uh and so

everything has to kind of take place around the warlord and if the warlord dies there's we want a player to take risks we i think we head on the right formula for how much it's going to hurt to lose the warlord which is not as much as losing your government and uh as as the erie for instance so um so that's working on that and then uh we had announced that we were doing a turtle faction um and and it was gonna be another militant faction and they um they depend on public buildings and building public roads uh and and slow levying and a kind of a defensive play um but i i think we're gonna go with badgers instead so i'll just go ahead and announce that i haven't i i feel bad this is not final

i feel really good about their design where they're at i mean they're really interesting um it's weird sometimes i feel like you know sometimes the animal comes first and sometimes the design comes first well tell me about how badgers play uh yeah so they um and they're they're not quite we have not played nearly as many games with them yet because uh they just just came out second and we're trying to get the warlord uh looking better first um and the warlords frankly i i think it's testing well um yeah i think i think it is like a few weeks from being able to drop some some some public testing yeah yeah absolutely uh and so the uh the badgers then uh they just have a few buildings that they can build and um to represent kind of a slower form of governance they have action tokens that they have to put down on the map um and then um and this is all work in progress so so they put tokens down on the map and those will be their orders in the next turn and so they have to kind of plan out there and players can see what what they're planning on doing next turn there's still orders in their pool that they can play if they need to and but those aren't as strong as the ones that are on the map so you really want to use you really want to lean on the ones in the map uh when you're playing so and then a little bit defensive but a slower guys on the board and uh and that seems to be the right combination i'm really enjoying them there's a lot of um when i've been playing them there's a lot of like there's a lot of cost of movement and so it's like how many do you you have to make your invasion forces not b6 guys jumping on a space you want to make your invasion two or three guys

jumping out of space taking it down and then bringing in more troops uh afterwards for free and so um i that's i like the the tension that creates because there's a lot of like do i go for it and risks risk losing this position or do i hold back and wait until everything's a little bit more solid so and they have this awesome system that patrick came up with for like public infrastructure so like they can build like roads that other people can use so you they're in this funny like so it is so it's interesting i see the warlord is very much like an interesting like take on an eerie style invader pow invader style uh faction and the the the badgers are like what if the otters what what if that kind of faction had grown up into a bigger a bigger you know uh more militant faction and want to take care of people and they want to take it yeah i think that they will pair really well against each other in the in two-player matchups but they also like gel well with the other factions i mean i think when when patrick was soliciting ideas for the expansion and everybody was adding to this google doc i wrote this like tiny little paragraph that was like what root faction should do and it's like one they should be aware of what other factions do so that they're scouting out new territory right uh and then the other thing is that they need to make the the whole game should feel that they're present in a way that like when you play with the otters you're playing with the otters this game is different and it would feel very different if the

otters were the wooden alliance instead and i think that's why i think it's funny you said the game's finally modular the rules are modular because i'm like well the factions themselves are modular but yeah yeah it's almost like there's a variant maybe that's the yeah yeah there you go the ickier word that i don't want to say but you know like i i do think that there's um both of these factions that patrick's built like they clear that those marks very very easily and there's still a lot of a lot of work to do on them but like the warlord is like pretty much ready to go so hopefully we'll have some print and play you know you know just going back to that first question about process like this is another development that we're going to be doing publicly like people can join the woodland warriors discord and uh and they can get to see this this stuff early so when is this going up so i i'll first start seeing the i i are about the animal changing yeah yeah i'll probably have this up in about a week and you can expect all the hate mail then it'll be frogs by then i'll get it yeah i'll get it so the development i imagine has had to have evolved as root has become more and more complex because initially you're only testing four factions against one another and you know different player counts within that you had two player the original mechanical marquees and then three and four has it become exponentially more difficult to you know figure out how to get factions into this game do you see an end of the road where root might

be complete because it's just too ridiculous to introduce more factions into this thing so may i call no go ahead i i'm tapped out i it was i felt like it was a stretch to get to where i met with these two militant factions and it was good i like the constraint of the i had two constraints because i have the constraint of the design of that we have right now and i also have the constraint of my three constraints i also have i see notes for cole from cole about what he wants to do in the future and i didn't want to violate that space at all and there was i think there was an original take i had on one of the militant factions that we could have done and i was like i could see where both these could play together but let's let's not let's not cross that bridge because i don't want to limit cole's design in the future because he's not done and then uh and also i'm pretty active with people talking about the fan factions and i didn't want to um i like the creativity of the fan factions and i like there's a lot of interesting ideas that aren't quite complete there yet or are far more complicated than say the vagabond and so it's like yeah you got it like um and i you know i mean the warlord still has plenty of rules to cut but i i and so i i felt that constraint too because i didn't want to be like oh yeah i played this faction a couple weeks ago and now here's this thing i used from this uh you know even though some people have even said to me go ahead and use parts of this if you want to

um and so like there was those three constraints of how do i uh how do i get under that and actually to be honest that the fan faction thing was a little bit rewarding because it taught me it gave me a ceiling for complexity that i was very aware of and am now very under um and so i think that was i think that was actually a good experience uh doing that so so yeah frankly i i um maybe have one more insurgent faction than me i have notes for the rlf um but i which could be a minor faction very easily and uh and i i'm out yeah i you know when we were working on underworld i wrote this little script that just generated like so we had we had the reach system uh which you know values all the factions and then there are minimum targets you have to hit for each player count and i i use that to generate a big list of just possible games and then what i would do is i would go through that list and i mean it was really it was like many many pages maybe like 30 pages and i had them in my office of all these games and i just went through them and i would like circle ones or i'm like ah this one i'm worried about you told me you played everyone yeah well i not all of them i i did a pass right so i went through her and i like circled all the ones i was worried about and then you know out of those we had like about a hundred that were just like these are different combinations and also like things like maps and deck combinations like all that can take that into account and then i had about 100 games that we wanted to run and i was like well we can't run

all of them because like that's i mean we just can't run all of them because i mean we are going to usually usually the rule in my mind is the game gets played about 200 times by its development crew before it's done uh and that could be that i play a hundred times patrick plays a hundred times it can be different combinations but i knew that uh this was a lot to get through and so i went through it again and i was like okay if this one works these other ones are also going to work okay and so you like you like kind of map it a little bit like that where you're like well you know the the woodland alliance is a little bit more irritating to deal with than the corvids so sometimes they can kind of stand in for them but there are these other faction mix mixes where the corvids are a lot more worrisome like they're playing against the erie right whereas the woodland alliance is a lot more troublesome for like the lizards maybe right so they're different alchemies and so out of that we got this big list and then uh when we were testing it we hired a bunch of people to come in we ran about three tables every day from like nine to five they played about four games each day played four games a day and i went in there like i was conducting a seminar with little clipboards i've got them somewhere in my office and i said you know i had a little data merge spit out like okay here are the factions here's your map here's your deck and it just spit out all these forms and i would give every group their clipboard and be like all right get these into me by the end of the day and because i just need to see like what they're like when they get played now i don't know exactly how we're going to adapt that system to covid yet because it is even bigger than oath's testing system

but i imagine i'm going to be doing some tricky work with google forms and trying to set that stuff up yeah we'll just make do it yeah that's what a team is for but you know as we start thinking about like oh boy what does this look like if things get really wild right yeah and and some of the thinking behind the advanced setup is making the different combinations a little more resilient so that for instance like in the game we played today the warlord jumped on my neck as the cats now which i directed him to do and it was a good pull yeah yeah it was not a good play but it's also a thing that can happen and i was cheered by the fact that i started thinking about how the current draft and setup system works so i'm like this probably couldn't happen in quite this way sure so like i think there are ways that like by adjusting that we can make the game a little more resilient and maybe generate some more content but i agree with patrick i've got like a couple more root factions in me but i just there are so many there's so much game way more space for that void glitch and oh yeah yeah yeah and and i you know one thing i'll say about that is i um i don't have a copy of root at the office my copies at home and i try not to use it for development because it'll get messy uh and so one of the first things i did uh the beginning of this week was build my development copy of root so i went around and was like oh is there do you have a full set of wooden alliance meeples and that said okay i'll put that in my because i just need to like we have all these half copies right right right and

putting everything together i was like oh boy there is a lot in this box there's a lot of factions there's just like i think that the system could probably handle a few more but my goodness and unfortunately as someone who's monitoring like benefits and shipping stuff from china and to people and managing people i'm probably have to lean on call to do some of this some of this work well i'm i'm super excited about this this is you guys is next kickstarter presumably that uh you're going to be putting up i i i know that i'm going to get grilled if i don't ask a couple of those like real cut and dry business questions on this are you guys going to have the clockwork expansion 2 as part of this upcoming kickstarter yep it's almost done already you know i was playing it today that's awesome and then of course the question i bet you guys get a million times what about a big box we need something to put all these things in uh it's a funny so i i feel like i i don't know i don't really want one but also there have been times when i feel like both patterns have been like more accommodating about the idea potentially like for a while it was like hey at the end of the line we'll of course do one i have started i don't know if i'm just reacting to people asking me about it or if i actually feel this way earnestly i've started thinking about it as like an act of harm yeah like like i wouldn't want to do it even if we could make money doing it um i don't i don't know i i i feel like

i have to recuse myself from this conversation as i get too uh the moment i stopped caring about it like i did care about it i for a long time i was like oh sure man i need the big box i need the big box the moment i stopped caring about it is the moment that i got the play mats i was like well it's not going to fit in one box anyway no no no it's going to be this big okay no i mean i think i i said this last time federer and i did a design chat but i'll bears repeating i play a lot of commanding colors i used to play a lot of commanding colors in the playoffs with my wife and after we finished the austrian expansion i got this like giant tackle box and i organized it all i put in the giant tackle box and we stopped playing it because it was too intimidating it was too heavy right it was like just it was just nonsensical and then i i re i sorted everything back out into their boxes and it gets played now like i mean it was just i think part of it i don't know it's a complicated thing and i do think there are ways of designing a big box that make it easier to play but root is so like you know that word again it's like so modular that i kind of if i'm going to game night i kind of just want to like grab root and then like the expansion that i think i'm going to play that night so my take on it is first of all in my cold dead heart if i make money on it i'll make money on it so i gotta sell it for that reason but um i think with i wanna see how the response to oath and that's the whole

design box because maybe there is a better curated experience than just having a large box maybe there is a way we can present a tray that will help the people and i think that's what people are asking for ultimately yeah they're not saying big box they're saying we want to trade a store everything and i think now that we have a better um we don't have a better product designer what we have is time to work on product design and and and the expertise to work on it and so maybe maybe like from from years ago when i was like ah to to now there might be some room to uh to to run it my concern about it and what i always say to people is that um scythe which has sold 300 350 000 units which is almost double of what root sold um jamie wrote a piece about it and he said you just didn't make money on it and i was like well if someone at that scale with that business acumen cannot i mean he said he broke even and so it's like i can't i can't afford to keep paying benefits if i'm breaking even i got a i got a uh i got to create a world where we continue to generate money i mean i get it like you could say well you break even it's okay but no patrick leader is then gonna have to take time away from doing something else marshall's gonna take time away from doing something else to break even and that's not as exciting yeah well one it's interesting i completely agree with you patrick and i think that um the oath big boxes the oath box is gonna be a really interesting case on it because

we spent a long time on that box yeah a long time like it took staff days to figure out how it was going to work that was time that could have been spent in other places and it was important for the the product but in in oath's big box is funny because it's not flashy any uh yeah oh it's big oh got a picture of a pig on it okay but it's not it's not a flashy box design but it is a bigger form factor and it was the first time as a company we've made a really active attempt to get the insert to be like post game functional right yeah like i feel like a lot of our inserts are like the insert works great if this is the only product you buy if you have an expansion you're on your own she'll have every kickstarter that comes with expansion out of the gate um yeah oath actually has an insert that people are going to want to um want to keep i challenged the meeple realty people to design a better it just sounded better i like you know it's funny though i do like the the sentinels uh box it's ridiculous i was gonna see if i can get a picture of it quick it is enormous but i played the game more since i got it because yeah that's cool all the heroes are together so well cole patrick i could talk to you about a million things one thing that i'm personally very excited about is void glitch on the horizon i mean i i know that you've put up some pictures of the development you've talked about it and so as a hopefully 2021 release

have you guys back on to the show i i mean i could just talk about business i could talk about game design uh but at this point i need to let you guys go so you can actually make some games so let's leave it with getting the the the question out of the way here uh the root kickstarter when can people find or expect that so are we talking about that yet yeah we've talked a little bit we're going through with you we need levels of permission here yeah so our our general plan is that the root kickstarter will happen in q1 and it's going to be a blast for folks who had a good time with the underworld kickstarter this is going to be you know just it's going to be fun i'm really looking forward to it um so that that's our q1 oath hopefully will be um having its retail release like potentially sometime around june uh kind of end of q2 um void lich which is really like it's gonna be an awesome studio project i i we could gab for a long time about how it's going uh what will be our second kickstarter hope maybe sometime like around may we're not really sure april or april i think that like the main thing i want to communicate to folks is like we have been uh oath so like the studio was growing after especially after root i mean it grew through vast it grew through root uh but we spent a lot of that growth on oath oath was a complicated project that took a lot of the bandwidth we had built

out and this is going to be a year where instead of doing one giant project we're doing kind of like a bunch of medium-sized projects and uh they're all very different from each other and it's so we're gonna have a lot a lot to share and that'll start getting rolling kind of like right as the new year turns well very excited about glitch because the three of us are meeting about it if you you know kyle like so if you're talking about the senior creative staff it's it's us all uh kind of chipping away at the at it right now and so i uh i'm just you know i think it's gonna be like a culmination of a lot of efforts coming together and i think it's gonna be very cool to uh to that kickstarter is very cool very cool to see how it turns out yeah it is uh both very unlike anything that we've done before and also like a clear continuation of some of these lines of thought yeah as it turns out because it's a lot on cole's desk right now yeah it's super it is super on my desk right now it's been it's been so fun to work on it like i you know oath one thing i'll say about working on void lich is oath was a very deliberative and kind of slow design because the design had to accommodate just like tons of tricky things so it was like i i couldn't design quickly which i like to design fast but oh that was like not allowed because if i if i was hasty i would like break like four months of work and so i had to be careful and void lich is not like that void glitch is a the

core action system is like very flexible and strong and so the design i think the design is going to like i mean oath i think of is a very special unique game and nothing game no game does anything like it void lich is as dynamic but it's a simpler game to learn how to play and i think it's going to have some really wonderful stuff in the box and yeah i i can't wait to to talk more about that game so i have to stop myself we'll find a time to do it well thank you so much cole and patrick for coming on to the show this has been an absolute blast thank you very much for having us thank you yeah yeah that's great you

Progress saved