Beyond Solitaire Podcast 211: Carly Kocurek on Coin-Operated Americans
Transcript
It's ad break time. I am proud to announce that the Beyond Solitire podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through Games and Simulations. Their new backer kit project, Art and System, is now live and it features updated editions of three fantastic tabletop RPGs. Liam Burke's Doggy Dog, Anna Anthropy's Princess with a Cursed Sword, and Timothy Kleiner's The Mountain Witch. You should absolutely check them out. Also, if you want to help me keep the lights on over here on the podcast, you can support me at patreon.com/beyondsolitire. For now, though, let's get on with the show. Hey gamers, this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitire. And this week on the pod, I have a very special guest. Uh, this is Dr. Karly Koserk. She is the director of the game design and experiential media program at the Illinois Institute of Technology. How you doing today, Carly? I'm doing great.
I'm super happy to have you on. Uh I actually read your book Coin Operated Americans, uh which I thought was really really interesting. Um and so just to kind of like give a sense of what kind of stuff you work on. Um tell us about that book, but then maybe just like a description of the kind of work you're doing in general because you do a lot of video game stuff.
Yeah, so um my background is in American studies. So I do kind of like US cultural history as my my primary training. Um, Coin Operated Americans is the book that came out of my graduate school project, my dissertation. Um, and basically I got really curious about why we think video games are for boys and men. Like that we don't talk about other media that way and I I became like I really wanted to figure out why that was. And so I ended up doing a cultural history project that looked at video game arcades, right? And I think video game arcades are important partially because they're where video games become kind of part of daily life. Um, computer games, console games are happening around the same time, but we actually have a wave of coin op games that hit before the consoles really take off. Um, and computers were, you know, pretty expensive at that time. So people have them, but not average people. Whereas the quaint machines were really everywhere and they become part of um public discourse and public debate in a very particular way that then helps shape how we talk about video games.
That's really interesting. Um so I just want to say when I just first started the book I felt an immediate sense of recognition because my mother bought me a Game Boy on which I played a lot of Tetris for years and then most of the consoles after that were bought for my brother. Yeah. Yeah. That's a I mean that's like a really interesting problem and I'm I'm cur I I would love to see some updated research on this because um Carolyn Cunningham uh did some work about it's now been almost 10 years I think. Um and you know she found that one of the major impediments to girls playing games still is actually access to hardware. And when Brenda Laurel was doing work on this um in the mid '9s right like why don't girls play video games? was access to hardware that basically if um if something's bought for, you know, if there's many children in the household and one of them is a boy and the rest of them are not boys, the boy will dominate the console. Um and not even necessarily maliciously, right? Like this just kind of happens. Um it could be malicious.
Who knows? But Right. And so if if it wasn't like a thing specifically for um a child who's a girl, like that child would not play with it. Um, and it wasn't, you know, and so it was really about hardware access. So that's a problem in the '90s. It's still a problem like 20 years later. I'm curious to see if that is still actually something we're seeing a lot of. Um, I I don't know. Um, I'm I'd be curious about that. But yeah, that access to hardware is like a really like fundamental issue.
Yeah. I'm also really curious about maybe like the you fly, I watch and comment phenomenon. Uh because I do have a pretty good understanding of video games up through like the PlayStation 2 and then a gap. Um, and then I started up again later in life because my brother and I, he would play and I would watch and like pay attention to the dialogue and help with the clues. And so like I, you know, I was there and I also wonder about like how those relationships function. And then, you know, even across gender, like if those sorts of relationships prepared us to watch people play video games online like we do now.
Yeah, that's a really good question. I know specifically with the in-person aspect of that, um, uh, Jud Reguel talks a lot about this as co-play, right? Because often like if you're helping with the clues and you're like coaching people, like they're not actually playing alone, even if they're playing a single player game, right? Um, and you even see this in arcades um, sometimes. And so like, yeah, often we're thinking about a game as for one person, but it's not experienced in that isolated way. Um my colleague Jennifer Dwinter in the book she wrote about uh Shigaro Miiamoto for the series we edit um one of the things she really goes into is that when he was working on Zelda like the original game, right? Like his goal was partially that it become a game people would like meet up and talk about like if you were like ran into someone at the water cooler, you would like talk to them about like playing Zelda. Um, and so even though it's the single player game, it was always this idea of it being part of like a social kind of like activity or a social engagement that it was like a point of departure for conversation and connection. And so there's like a lot of different ways people experience and play games. And I think now too, it's it's funny like I try to explain to my students about how you used to be able to buy like paper books that would guide you through a game and they're like, "That sounds completely unhinged." I'm like, "Yes, I I I don't know how to answer that question other than yes." Right? But like that was quite common. You would get like strategy guides and stuff like this. And so like and I I think all of those like speak to, right? Like the
idea that like maybe the games weren't actually like you they're really hard to do alone, right? And like even now like how often are you playing something you're just like I cannot figure out this puzzle, right? Like I you know my friend and I actually during the pandemic we were playing Fable like the reissue of Fable and we were playing it's single player but we were playing it on headsets so we would both like be talking to each other like and playing Fable and we would like go the same direction so we could have like the similar experience and every once in a while we're like I don't I don't know what to do like or like we'd hit like we're both like not super into the fighting part and we'd hit like a boss battle and we're like oh she's like I'm going to make my husband do this and I'm like I'll go do it I'll go do mine tomorrow and I'll meet back up with you next week and I'll be past it, you know? Let me like figure um and and so like it was this funny thing where it's like it's social but it's also like the reason we were using the game was different. Like there's all kinds of ways people play video games and like some of that's designed in.
Some of it's the affordances of it and some of it's just like
you know do you want to play a game to be good at it or do you want to play a game to experience it? And those are like two very different positions and they're both approaches people have.
Yes. All right, I'm going to tie this background, but just as an aside, it heartens me so much to know that Zelda is meant to be a game we talk about because I had a legendary game of Ocarine of Time with two of my friends in my dorm at college and it was like Harry uh Brent and me and we had Habla is like the name of our link and we would just go and swap off the controller and we played through the whole thing and it was amazing. So I guess this goes to show right like we are women. There's lots of people in our age range of all genders who have had this kind of gaming experience and yet as you talk about a coin operated Americans um gaming is perceived as a very male pursuit even though like very obviously like kind of not on the ground. Um one of the one of statistics you bring up a lot is that 40% of Pong money was coming from women.
Yeah. Um, and so, um, the other thing I I want you to kind of like talk a little bit about the book, you kind of frame it though as instead of talking about how women got excluded, you wanted to focus the book on how men were included. So, what made you decide to take that angle and where do you think that it took you that's kind of like different from other discourse on this topic?
Yeah. So, in some ways like I think well always I think the hostility is less interesting, right? like we know how people get pushed out of stuff like it it's it's like pretty like that's how it works right um and we also know we have broader a broader culture around technology and business and leadership and like all these things where it's like yes of course women get pushed out of things like I can like that's large in our in our culture and in our history um and so I was like more interested in like how how did this become so male like not how did we push everyone else but like How did this become like this like signature like experience of like boys and men of a certain age, right? And I I think I was really curious about that partially because a lot of the work that looks at the gender disparity, it looks a bit later um and it's it actually looks like kind of starting around when my book ends, right? So after that early um that second crash in the industry in 1982 and 1883 um the companies get much much more um conservative, not necessarily politically but business-wise where they're just not willing to take risks, right? And so they kind of like zoom in on like a core demographic who they see spending money and they're like we don't actually need to worry about anyone else. Like if anyone else buys these that's fine but we don't care about them. Um, and so like that's that's like this weird moment. And so then a lot of the work on gendering games is looking
at the wake of that. Like how do you change that now that this has been established, right? Um, and so then you're dealing with like, okay, we know that the industry became more conservative in this way. We know that um the the money was being made in these particular ways or like they were unwilling to take risks in these ways. Like we know all that, right? And so a lot of the focus was like on getting girls and women back into games, right? And there's really important books about that. Um like from Barbie to Mortal Kombat um and a number of other things and like all the work that Brenda Laurel does with Purple Moon like the the like tremendous success of Barbie fashion designer, right? Like there's lots that happens that's really interesting. Um, but that story is really different than like, okay, but like why why did we take like this cutting edge media technology and be like, you know, who's at home here? 13-year-old boys and nobody else.
Like that's so weird. Um, and so I was really interested in that. So, a lot of the work at the point that I started working on this project, a lot of the existing research was was later, like it was focusing on later points. And it's it's funny now because now that book's been out um over 10 years and like you know people will like or about 10 years I guess. I don't know. I'm very tired. Uh you know and people will say like oh like this is like this really important early book in video game history and it like makes me feel like a fossil. But also like I wasn't it makes it sound like I did something really like intentional and important and really I just like had a question I couldn't let go. And I also think like any project I did was going to end up being cultural history because of my graduate discipline and it just like is almost I mean it's not a coincidence but it's like I could have done similar work about a number of different other topics and I happened to land on games and I happened to land on video games at a moment when like most of the historical work had been done by um enthusiasts um fans amateurs like and I don't mean that in a dismissive way but like people that were not professionally trained historians. And so it was an early book that was taking a really really different approach. And so it ends up like being this weird kind of touchstone in this field, but like that wasn't it wasn't like set up to be a touchstone.
It was like set up to like answer one very specific question. Right. Makes sense. All right. I want to come back around to a lot of the social aspects of the boyishness. But first, one thing I thought was really interesting that just I didn't understand as somebody who thinks about games when I was reading this book is that early video games were kind of associated with things like gambling machines, slot machines, pinball machines, like little horse race machines. Because when I think of video games, I think of computers. And so, how did you kind of handle that like perception split in terms of treating your study? And like when we look back at arcade games like what should we see?
Yeah. So I think Yeah. What what should we see? I mean I think I think recent history is hard because there's always like this heavy veil of nostalgia and personal experience, right? And I I always think about like and it's from this very different thing but someone saying you know when when people are defending like a terrible person because that person wasn't terrible to them and it's like not everything that happens happens to you right and so like something can be like very statistically common and also be something I've never experienced right and and so like you know it's interesting because people occasionally will be like really angry like I I um actually one time a former Atari employee Like it was really funny cuz I just like had was not paying attention to Twitter at the moment. It was like this was years ago. It was before Twitter kind of um became a a uh a dumpster. But um you know and I had tweeted something about like the weird timing of um an award that was going to go to Nolan Bushnull and N it basically eventually they decided not toward it.
Bushnull's very gracious about it, right? He's like you're right. It's not you know they were right. It's not the time for this. But then there's this like a woman who had worked at Atari and she's like, "I loved working at Atari. Everyone was amazing to me. I can't believe that people were being sexually harassed." Like she wanted to argue with me and I didn't even see it. And also I wouldn't have argued with her because I'm like, "Cool, you had a good time. Not everyone did, right?" Like and and like those are true at the same time, right? And like I think, you know, I think that's that's always the case. So there's many people that had a really good time in the arcades. There's people that went to arcades that were, you know, wholesome and friendly and lovely. There's people that went to arcades that were like seedy and everyone was stoned. There's pe, you know, like they're not they're not all the same experience. And so like I think sometimes I think sometimes the work I'm doing like makes people feel uncomfortable because like their own experience of it different, but like I'm actually not talking about kind of like individual experiences. In most cases, I'm talking about this kind of like average or cultural experience or even not even an experience, but the story that our culture tells about it and that becomes like even another layer removed. Yeah. I mean, like I did experience arcades in like the '9s as very familyfriendly and like in I can't even imagine them as a CD place because it was just never my experience. Um, but I also just want to touch on like you mentioned um kind of like freedom of speech arguments uh and like early conflicts about whether video games are appropriate for children.
Um so could you say a bit more about that? Like especially about like at one point in the book you mentioned that it was not so much always about freedom of speeches but about freedom of like marketing.
Yeah.
And how do we get away from
right?
Yeah.
Yeah. So, there's an early case. Um, there's a couple Supreme Court cases about video games that are really interesting. Um, and the the one that I I talk about the most in the book and the one that I find the most interesting is City of Mosquite uh versus Lens Castle, Inc. Um, Mosquite is a town in Texas and they had passed this like kind of wild regulation that like if you were going to open an arcade or have any coin operated machines, like you had to get like a special permit to do that. And like the chief of police had to review it and decide if you like were attached to any criminal elements. And also nobody could access the arcade under a certain age unless they were with an adult. But this was put in after Aladdin's Castle had already gotten um they'd already done all the work to open. So like they had already signed a lease, they'd already decided to open there and then like the law and regulation changes. And so they they sue um and they sue over a couple different things. And one of them is that like you've got this freedom freedom of association, right? So like in fact, if I'm friends with a criminal, it doesn't mean that I'm a criminal. Um right or if I like any of those things. And then additionally like there's there's not actually strong precedent in the US broadly for restricting children's access to media.
Um in unless it's pornographic, right? And so um you know this idea that like children couldn't go in arcades is actually like kind of interesting and that it it shows up in lots of places and there are bands on arcades in many places, but it has to be a full band. It can't just be a ban based on age. Uh so this this goes through the courts. At the time Alens Castle is like the largest operator of arcades um in the US, possibly the world, right? Because they become associated with they become part of a larger Japanese conglomerate. Um and they win the case at the Supreme Court, but it goes all the way to the Supreme Court. Like it's like meandering through the courts for years. And the Supreme Court says like, yeah, like this like idea that the chief of police decides whether or not you're a criminal based on like who you know and they don't have to provide any evidence is not like that does not follow due process. Um, and similarly like this thing about the age restriction like it doesn't follow due process and it's a violation of free speech. Um, but what's interesting is like the children aren't the ones making any speech, right? And so it's really about like their access to the games that are ruled to be free speech, which is really interesting, right? Because it's it's a consumer product. So like their right to access a consumer product. Um, and it's interesting because years later when we get like Brown versus EMA like and they actually end up making a very similar decision. Um, and they don't I
think if I recall correctly, they don't cite the mosquite case. like they come to like a similar decision and maybe they're both pulling on the same precedents. I don't know. Um and so like there's really really not much precedent for restricting youth access to media in the US. Um and there's different points where people are uncomfortable with it for different reasons. And like I think we're actually in a pretty interesting moment with regards to AI. Like I um was talking to a friend this week and she's like my kids school keeps telling them all to use AI and they're like 12. And I'm like okay. So there's all kinds of like learning reasons I would say not to do that. But I'm like the thing I'm actually really concerned about is like the the whole idea of there being like an age of reason and a point at which like you have the information literacy and sophistication to like decide what's accurate. And we have adults that are having like AI induced psychosis and they're much on average, right, more educated than like 11 year olds. And are they getting training saying like, "Hey, by the way, don't talk to the AI like it's your friend. Hey, by the way, don't ask the AI for advice." I mean, we know these systems allegedly have guardrails, but they're still giving out like advice on suicide and stuff. But then I also don't know how we would regulate this because I don't know that we would uh you know legally find
grounds to restrict access. So it's it's this like thorny messy issue. Um and we see it with games that are online too, right? Like my my kid plays a lot of Minecraft and it's like on a on a server out of our house. So like only at home, only with our family. Um, you know, and and like my my friends are like, "Oh, like how do you let her do that?" I'm like, "She can't talk to anyone." Like the second she could talk to anyone, I'm concerned, right? But but I also still don't know like in some ways like what what's happening in this very expansive system. So it's it's just really complicated. Um, and so it's it's funny because like now the arcade games like always look really almost quaint,
right? It's like, "Oh, how charming with their pixels and and their buttons and such, right?" Um, but I think it's important to remember that like people in the past aren't dumber than we are, right? Like they're they're like as sophisticated as we are in terms of how they understand the world they exist in, how they think about things, etc. And so like yeah, of course people are terrified of games. Like it's it's an interactive media form. It's not something people had a great deal of experience with. Like and we didn't know how that would affect people. Um, and so like being afraid of that, like it's not just reactionary, like it's also maybe a a moment to be like, wait, wait, wait, we should think about this, right? Um, and it's, you know, I think it's so easy to paint people who want to restrict access to some of the stuff as villains. Um, but I don't I don't think they're villains. Like, I think they can be wrong sometimes. Um, but other times I'm like, yeah, maybe maybe we should be careful, right? Like um one of the big things that gets brought up in one of these cases is that uh children were like spending their lunch money at the at these um games that were at a like corner store near the near the school, right? And they would show up to school and they didn't have lunch money and like the PTA like fund that was there for kids that couldn't afford lunch would cover their lunches, but it was like running through the fund really quickly, right? And like I understand why they wanted to regulate to fix that.
But I actually wonder if like a quicker fix would have been to like you know nicely talk to the the person that ran the machine and just be like hey can you like unplug it until the kids are in school so they don't stop on in the on the way to school. Like if they play after school that's great right? Nobody that's fine but it's causing this like very specific problem. And and who knows maybe that guy was like yeah screw you. I want their lunch money. Or maybe you or maybe he would have been like yeah that's a good point. right? Like you don't we I don't know. Um and so like I think sometimes regulation is like this like go-to solution for what are kind of like neighborhood problems and you can see that play out. But
we have bands on arcades that last into this century which is totally wild to think about. Um, you know, I love thinking that like, you know, it's like no, you can't play Pac-Man in the year 2012 or whatever, you know, like it's just this like really but but it's a long long history and it's a really fraught history.
Do you think that talking about freedom of speech in terms of freedom to market and freedom to spend money impacts the way that we talk about video games today as art? Because like I I think of video games now as an art form and like you know Pentiment made me cry
and oh yeah
like I like sobbed at the end of the game but like and it's not the only game I've ever cried in. And so like I think a lot now about like we kind of talk about games as like a lesser media form.
And do you think that that kind of beginning in kind of a more consumeristic set of arguments has impacted that all the way until now? I think we're always kind like it there's like a period in which a any medium is not accepted as art, right? And like we see this with film, we see it with photography, we see it with television, right? Like um it takes a long time for things to start being taken seriously and you can even see this with like digital art, right? Like a lot of the early stuff people are like they made it in a computer, you know, and like who knows like who knows what conversations we'll be having about current technologies in like 15 or 20 years. I don't I I don't know. Um, you know, I I do think that idea of a right to consume does have some weird implications um in terms of how we think about free speech. And like one of those is I think a lot of the discourse about free speech is like very abstracted from the actual principle which is a legal principle which is that the government can't restrict you, right? Um, but like a random business can. So, like I my students were always shocked to learn that like movie movie ratings actually have no legal weight. Like none. They're not required. I can sell you a ticket to a movie that is R-rated and you're three. It's fine, right? Like movie tickets to a baby, right? But what what actually is at play is that like the movie theater would fire me for selling them. Um, right? the this is
largely an industry-driven self-regulation that has this kind of like quasi legal veneer. Um, and that's true of almost all media rating systems because they're all modeled on that rating system on the MPAA system, right? Um, and so that's kind of this weird thing where like we often assume things have legal weight and don't. Um, and people talk about freedom of speech and they really mean something about censorship or and this is the one I think is even weirder, they don't just mean the freedom to say things, they mean the freedom to be heard like that people must be compelled to listen to them. Um, and so I think that idea like something gets muddied when freedom of speech becomes the right to consume and then like goes one step further and suddenly it's an obligation, right? that it's not your free speech is being infringed if people aren't listening to you.
Yeah.
Um and I think that is very very peculiar and I see it come up quite a bit and like I think there's been a shift in internet culture around this because like there used to be this idea that if you were like blocking people you were somehow like not like infringing on their free speech in the legal sense but that you were like engaging in censorship, right? Um, but really like I'm not obligated to listen to everything that like randos yell at me on the internet and like like that would be bizarre. Um, and so like I I've noticed that there's been a shift on that, right? And and like so I'm curious to see if that's just like us starting to understand these things as something else or if like there's been some real changes in how we're talking about them.
Um, but I do think that idea of freedom of speech as a right to consume also has like I think it's entangled with like some of the decisions we've seen around um campaign funding and like lobbying and things like this where like we start giving rights to corporations and to for-profit entities in particular ways that equate them to or put them in in like parallel to individuals humans, right? Yeah.
Um, and so there's just like a lot of weird stuff there. I also want to loop back to this idea that like a game making you cry is like the most powerful thing it can do because like I think we all like tend to do this and and like the game that makes me ugly so is Gone Home, right? Like I assign it to students uh pretty regularly in my in my uh interactive storytelling class and I tell them I'm like I've played this game like three or four times. I cannot play it anymore right now. Um, I find it emotionally devastating. The character is almost the same age as me. Um, and grew up in a very similar like this isn't about my my family, but about like the town I grew up in, like a really um like pretty repressive and homophobic area. And like I find it like emotionally devastating to revisit that, right? And and um so I'm going to make you all play this game, but I'm not I'm not going to play it again because I have all my notes, right? And and I still
I will note that Pinsman moved me. It did not make me sad. So
Oh, yeah. It wasn't even sad. Like it was cathartic, right, when I played like I played Gone Home and I finished. I remember I was like going to the gym, right? And I like pulled myself together and like walked to the gym
so that I could like not be crying in the gym. And then I left the gym and I just started sobbing again. and my my partner's like, "What just happened to you?" And I was like, "I was holding it together for one hour so I could finish lifting weights and I'm done now." Right? But um you know, like but but that idea of like a game making you cry is so profound. And I will I just have to tell you my favorite thing a student has ever said about a game in my class. They're like, "I was playing it and I kept waiting for there to be zombies and then it was about a dysfunctional family and that's worse, right?" And I'm like, "It's worse." like like but like that idea of a game making you cry and like Roger Eert says this he's like he's like repeatedly says games aren't art like at the point he's writing and first of all I don't know why people kept asking him about this I actually find it very weird and be like going up to a random like fine artist and being like please tell me what you think about animation and it's like that person doesn't know anything about that why are you asking them right so um and he actually at one point did write he's like I don't know why I kept getting asked weigh in on this and maybe I shouldn't have because in fact I don't play games like I don't know but he kept saying like I can't imagine a video game that would make me cry right and it's like is that the point of art is it like this idea that like it's not art unless it like makes you cry and then if that's true or melodrama is like the highest form of art like I don't know
I think it might be more about feeling touched like it's about a feeling connected in a specific way right like laughing could maybe be the same too
but so like I I'm really happy we've I feel like this conversation in some ways has kind of mimicked the shape of the book in that we haven't talked much about gender at all in a lot of this conversation. It's the factors that are kind of at play when we decide like what a video gamer looks like. And so kind of like to do like a similar wineback like what does this have to do
with boys? So we've got a a world where corporations have rights. Um we've got a right to consume. um we've got kind of like socially questionable activities trying to be presented as wholesome. Where do boys come in?
Yeah. So, I will say one one thing that I think is a good bridge here is that for about like the past 75 years, um women and girls outspend men and boys on pop culture. Like they do more consumer spending. They spend more on music. They spend more on movies. They spend Right. And so like in fact if you're trying to make a business out of any kind of like entertainment medium in fact the the demographic you should go after is not men right like they spend less money on it. Um but I think where you start seeing like the interesting stuff happening with men and boys is like some of the things that happened here are much longer historical trajectories. So the coin op business has like a terrible reputation. um less so now I think but but definitely in like the mid-century and into the 70s like they have and and forward right there's this reputation of it as being kind of like associated with organized crime and being kind of like operating in legal gray areas and some of that's fair and some of it's not fair, right? Like so there are many people in that industry that are absolutely just like small business owners. there that are like, you know, trying to be community members who make money doing a thing, providing a service. Um, but there's also like the reason we call it money laundering is because coin operated were used to la like to like clean money, right? Like dirty money and um because it's a these coin businesses don't like the machines don't track how much money is coming in and so like you could just be like, "Yeah, that machine took in $200." Like
throw all your money in there, right? like um this is associated with Al Capone which is very Chicago but um so you've got that factor. There's also and and like actually if you watch like Happy Days which which is a nostalgic version of the 1950s like its representation of pinball is of like kind of like semi- delinquent teenagers playing pinball and it like being somewhere that like youths loiter and do teenager things and like we as a society have decided we hate teenagers. So, anything associated with teenagers is bad, right? Um, and so, and and often pinball is associated with like drinking or like gambling. Like the reason pinball's initially banned is that it's classes gambling fairly or unfairly. Um, again, I'll give you more Chicago fun facts. Chicago is the hub of pinball manufacturing for like years and years and years. And for most of that time, it is illegal to to um operate a pinball machine in Chicago. You cannot. So they make all the machines but they cannot be running in businesses here at least not legally. Um
because it's classed as gambling, right? And so the coin op industry like occupies like a really fraught cultural position and I think video games give them a moment where like they could be something else. Um right because computer technology is very exciting and forwardlooking. Um the machines look different. they look like flashy and electronic and like beautiful. Um, you know, there's a lot of really interesting design that happens. Rafford Gwen has written about that extensively, particularly at Atari. Um, and the player base is suddenly like younger and more suburban um, and more affluent. And so a lot of there's a lot at play, but part of it is that like the coin op industry like wants so badly to be respectable and being able to say like look look at all these like wholesome young boys. They're learning how computers work or like learning really good hand eye coordination. They'll make them excellent pilots in the military or whatever, right? Like there's all these like rationals made like gives them an avenue to a certain kind of respectability. And so the industry like tends to lean in on that and you see it over and over again. And so it's not necessarily about who's actually playing but about who's seen as like a pathway to legitimacy in a a certain way.
Um
right. And we've always talked about new technology in this kind of like strange masculine ways masculineized way. Um, so like Inventing American Broadcasting, which Susan Douglas wrote, it's this like book about early radio, um, has like a whole section about like all the coverage of early like ham radio operators is about how clever these young boys are that have learned how to operate ham radio. Um, right? And it's like they're like these boy geniuses, right? And so that idea of a boy genius is is really really seductive. And then you get into the post-war period, right, into the mid-century and the cold war and we're in like a science like a science fight with the world and want to show how like technologically sophisticated we are. And so like of course children using computer technologies and these being everywhere is like very appealing. Um, right. And so that's and then you start seeing those kinds of narratives crop up in Hollywood. So it's it's it's really this like complex of factors, right? And I think that's in some ways like both like the the thorny problem of doing cultural history and also the true joy of it is like nothing ever happens for one reason.
It's always all these like complex factors and the intersections of them will result in some kind of particular outcome. Um, and so it's like, you know, my goal in that book and like in general my goal with any historical work is like the things that our culture produces and that we as a culture do aren't natural or inevitable, right? They're they're a set of they are consequences of decisions and policies and economics and like human and inhuman factors that get something. And so if those things aren't natural, if they're not inevitable, we can change them, right? We can make different decisions.
Interesting. So, one thing I want to talk about too is like when we talk about video games is for boys. I feel like we mean that culturally for a really extended period of time, including well into adulthood. So, like one of the examples you brought up, and I got to laugh at this because I just watched the movie because I'm going to watch the new one, is Tron. I've never seen Tron until like a couple weeks ago.
And it's like a crazy Jesus allegory, which is wild.
Yeah. But like Manboy Jeff Bridges is like hanging out with a bunch of kids in his arcade and he's presented as like the coolest ever. So like what is what does this do? Like when we talk about boys and video games and like that extending into adulthood,
like what are what are we doing in terms of like extending like what is so good about boyhood in a man?
You get to play, right? Like I I and like there's power in that and like there's um there's a lack of consequences, right? I there's a chapter in the book about this about Tron and War Games and and like I talk a little bit about the last starf fighter which is interesting because it operates quite differently. Um but like you were rewarded for what you do well and you are forgiven for what you do poorly, right? And so it's only rewards. Um, and so like in war games in particular, I find it really telling because like he does something that's like super duper triple illegal, right? But then he saves the world and everyone's like, "Never mind. It's cool that you like hacked into a government facility secure database and almost started World World War II and ended us all. That's fine, right?" Like they you get to retreat back into boyhood um and be absolved. Um, right? And so like I think that's a huge part of it. Um and so you're you're given this leeway. It's not available to proper adults, right?
It's not available to women or girls because the consequences of mistakes are always much higher, right? Like this is like why women don't get diagnosed with autism is because like the social consequences uh or ADHD, right? is like the social consequences of in enacting ADHD in a stereotypical way are so dire for girls that they don't do it um and develop instead other problems like chronic anxiety right um so boys are free in a particular way but specifically white boys specifically middle class boys right like there's very different consequences for everyone else so like of course you would retreat to minimal consequences that sounds great right um and so I think that's one part of it I do think there's also in in like a less kind of like dire and upsetting but still sad way. Um, culturally in the United States when we talk about play, we're almost always talking about children. Like adults don't get to play. And that is part also of how um, you know, video games become classed as for boys because like playing is a child thing and so adults don't do it. Um, and that's also part of how like regulatory conversations happen where I actually think it's weird to assume all games are for children. That doesn't make any sense. Like I'm not going to give pentiment to my seven-year-old.
That would be deranged, right? But like but right like can you imagine doing this thing um right? Like that's wrong. That's not the right thing. Right. And like we don't assume all movies are for children. That would be bizarre. But like for some reason with games for a very long time all games are assumed to be for children. And so, like, when we're arguing about Grand Theft Auto in the '9s, it's not an argument about whether or not Grand Theft Auto is okay for adults, right? It's actually an argument about whether or not it's okay for children. And it's not actually made for children.
Um, and so like, of course,
although my my brother and I had it young because nobody thought about it because it was game and so clearly you could buy it for children. We turned out okay.
Yeah, you can buy children. I think it's fine. I can buy my ch child R-rated movie tickets. um you know, it's fine. It's legal. Um I don't know if it's fine, right? And so like I think I think like boyhood comes to dominate like for particular reasons. Um Derek Burrell has a book called Die Trying um about video games and masculinity. And I don't 100% agree with like the all of the book, but like he makes this really powerful point about like the kind of masculinity around video games lets men retreat back into boyhood. And so it gives them this kind of like shallow defense against adulthood, right? And I think in many ways like adulthood is the land of consequences. Like childhood is the place where nobody dies and childhood's also the place where you're always forgiven.
Yeah. I also thought it was really interesting like you talked a lot about kind of video games and competitiveness being tied with athleticism. But so like there's that iconic picture, right, of like the boys lined up behind their arcade cabinets in this in a mainstream America street and there's like some cheerleaders in front of them cheering them on.
Um, but I guess one thing this has made me think about is that the other thing about athleticism, athleticism also has a natural endpoint because your body gives out. Yeah. So you can be like the young star like Friday Night Lights, you know, or like, you know, you could be in the in in Major League Baseball, you could be in the NFL, but eventually you are forced physically to grow up.
Yeah.
With video games, you're not
although your Twitch skill does actually deteriorate, right? Like that kind of thing. Um, but I know like my favorite example of this actually is uh Roger Sharp who's very famous if you know about pinball. Um, Roger Sharp uh played the pinball game that convinced New York City Council to legalize pinball in New York. Um, because it was banned because it was a game of chance and he his his play was so masterful that it proved to them that it was a game of skill. Um, and he went in on to work in the pinball industry for many many years. um he'd been a journalist before that. He actually like I read reports of him playing he lives in the Chicago area and there'll like be a be some coverage of him every now and then. There was a biopic of of him that came out last year of a movie. Um and people still talk about like the beauty of watching Roger Sharp play pinball, right? That like he's so good at it. Um and now you know he's he's elderly and his sons like work in the industry like you know really charming story. And so like you do get certain people where it's like, "Oh, I can see what you were and you still are." And it's amazing. I think about this sometimes when you see like um aging dancers, right, where like their style of dance really changes, but the the like you can still see the grace, you can still see the skill and the refinement and the power of that. Yeah.
Um, and so I do think games offer some potential for this, but I'm also not convinced that competition is or should be the sole purpose of games, right? Like, and indeed, like as we've been talking about games that like we both played, like many of my favorite games are not competitive at all,
right? But it made me think of King of Kong, which actually as if I if I recall like inspired your book, but I also remember watching the the film and feeling simultaneously like very charmed by and like kind of sad about the culture that was like depicted in the film.
And you know, it can go on and on like the return to boyhood.
Oh yeah, absolutely. And it's interesting because I I interviewed Walter Day um who's a very um very very nice man, right? Like, and I don't think anyone would argue about whether or not Walter Day is a very nice man. He's a very nice man. Um, and he organized that iconic photo. He's like the referee that's in King of Kong. And, you know, I think the there's definitely like a lot of kind of hurt feelings around that film, like fairly or unfairly, right? Like I think there's a variety of of things that happened. Um, but the one that I remember and I believe it because nobody has ever told me anything different and like I it would be a weird if like if I was wrong I think somebody would correct me if Walter had misremembered. Um, but there's like a video that shows like Steve Weebi eating alone and Walter's actually sitting next to the cameraman because he had left the table to go sit by Steve to make sure he wasn't alone.
And like that really hurt Walter's feelings that like it made it look like and I'm like yeah that would hurt. I get it Walter but also it's just like it's it's okay. He's a grown-up. It's just a funny story, right? Like like it's just a funny shot of Steve we eat eating alone. But it's also very sweet that like Walter Day is such a nice man. He's like I would never leave someone to eat alone, you know? So like I I don't know. People are complicated and messy and like I you see the best and worst of us at any any community. So when we talk about kind of like this culture though of like boyish full of mischief super talented like genius kind of stuff that's coming out of that's like the narrative right of like the young arcade wonderkin. Um, do you see that narrative persisting in tech narratives now, including like, oh, the brilliant AI CEO who I actually probably think is an idiot or like
who or who just got or who has been sued for sexual abuse by his sister, right? Like
um Yeah. Right. Like I think there are certain people we see as above consequences. I think when we talk about CEOs of tech companies, particularly tech startups, um, and not just CEOs, right, but like founders, people tend to talk about them like they're young, like way past when that makes any sense. And it's because they were young when they started. Um, but also because I think the narrative of them being young is much more appealing, right? So like nobody's like, "This amazing man, his 10th startup, finally took off and made money." even though like something like a huge percentage of startups either fail or close before you really ever hear about them. Um it's a much better story if they're young, right? Like Bill Gates, captain of industry, not a good story. Bill Gates started his company in his garage. Yes. Right. like and and so there's like a lot of that I think
still and like when I wrote that book I remember where they like people were still talking about
Bill Gates and Steve Jobs like they were like kids and I'm like that man has millions of dollars and is like a grandfather like what what are we doing right like um or like are we sure Steve Jobs is a genius he thought you could eat only apples you know like and I don't know that seems like an important question to ask sometimes I'm just like,
oh, that's hilarious, actually. So, and then I guess like kind of a a next question before I want to ask maybe about video game history in general and how this fits in is where does this leave women and girls? I feel like there is a desire a lot of the time to like get more women and girls to play video games. Um, it doesn't seem to happen in our larger perception. It's clearly happening for real in the sense that like probably half of women I mean probably half of gamers are women at this point like if you count cell phone games and like if you count all games we're at parody for sure. Yeah.
Um but how do we how do we change that perception and like you know is that something that's important to bother with is as a cultural historian like
is it prescriptive or is it descriptive you know?
Yeah. And I'll answer this one and then I apologize. I'm actually have to jump off because I have another a meeting. But um so in some ways like I'm not sure that that perception will change because I think what happens when we start having more girls and women playing games um is that actually we just like the the the the goalpost move, right? Where it's like oh not those games or like oh not it only counts at this it only counts at that right like so I think there's a lot of that that happens. Um, but also like in some ways I think that perception is less important than like what ends up happening in reality, right? So if women and girls are getting access to cultural spaces and around gaming that meet their needs that in that let them have sufficient and equitable access to culture, then like I don't think they need to be part of the stereotype of who plays games. Um, but if that stereotype is being used to exclude people, then that's something worth dismantling. But I think that there's been some real shifts in how we imag imagine technology as part of daily life. I think like the the normalization of cell phones and tablets has helped shift that like the real popularity of of mobile game systems including like the Nintendo Switch and the Switch 2. like, you know, I think I think like who plays and why they play has has like kind of moved in our popular in popular imagination and I I think that's really important, right?
And I think that's um that's good. I'm optimistic that we will continue. I think the makeup of who's making games has changed a lot and I think that's given us a lot of leeway.
Nice. All right. And so, thank you so much for coming out. I'm gonna we're gonna do some wrap up questions today. You got to go. One, um, what is a game you've played recently that you really enjoyed? What is a game I played recently and really enjoyed? So, I actually have just been playing like not very good match three games because I get stressed. Um, I will say I actually play a lot of Twine games and the the game I've been most recently thinking about cuz I was having students play Twine games. I was actually thinking about Christine loves Even Cowgirls Bleed, which is like so bizarre and grim and lovely. So, like I would if you haven't played Even Cowgirls Bleed, I would recommend that. Fantastic. And then if people want to follow you and your work online, where do you like to be found?
Yeah, I'm Sparkle Bliss on Blue Sky is the easiest place to find me now.
Fantastic. Um, Carly, thank you so much for coming on. I've really appreciated your time and this is a really fascinating conversation.
Great. Thanks so much. And I have to bump, but I will talk to you eventually.
All right. Bye.
Happy gaming, everybody.