Citadels Duel Review – Better Than the Original Citadels?
Transcript
Citadels has been around for a long time. Originally released back in the year 2000 is a game of building cities, recruiting powerful characters, and, of course, occasionally ruining your opponents plans. Over the years, we've seen different editions, expansions, and even a pretty substantial update in 2016. But there's always been one challenge with Citadels. While the game technically accommodates two players, it really shines as a large group game. Well, now we've got Citadels Duel, a brand new version designed specifically for two players. It's being published by Asmodee, who sent me this copy to review. And instead of just squeezing the original game into a smaller box, the designers have reworked quite a few things to create a head-to-head experience. So the question is, does Citadels Duel capture what made the original what it was while giving two players a reason to build a city together or more accurately against each other?
Let's take a look. In Citadels Duel, two players are competing to build the most valuable city. You're constructing different districts, collecting gold, recruiting influential characters, and trying to gain control of the city's council. But unlike the original game where each player builds their own separate city, here you are actually building one shared city. That's right. Your buildings and your opponent's buildings are all going into the same growing city, and that creates some tension and some interesting decisions. The city begins with two starting districts, one controlled by each player. From there, you're going to gradually expand outward, placing new districts into the shared grid. There are four different types of basic districts, noble, religious, commercial, and military. Each has a different cost, and those different colors are important because several characters reward you for controlling particular types of districts. You also have a unique type of district. Uh, their special buildings with their own abilities, and can provide some pretty significant advantages. Some give you council seats, others provide additional gold, and some offer protection or opportunities to build even more efficiently. And here's an interesting part of the city building. When you construct a district next to another district of the same color, you receive a gold bonus. So where you place your building matters just as much as what buildings you're choosing. You're not simply trying to build the most expensive districts.
You're looking for opportunities to create combinations, generate additional income, and position yourself to take advantage of the characters that you're recruiting throughout the game. Of course, if you've played Citadels before, you know the characters are a huge part of the experience. And that remains true here for this one. Citadels Duel includes nine different characters, each with a special ability. These characters can help you collect gold, build districts, take control of your opponent's buildings, or gain influence over the council. At the beginning of each round, both players receive four character cards, and you secretly choose two to keep and pass the other two to your opponent. Then you each discard one of the four characters you're holding. That means you're not only choosing characters that will benefit your own strategy, but you're also trying to figure out what your opponent might want. And that creates some really fun mind games. Maybe you really want the merchant because you need gold, but if you pass the warlord to your opponent, you might be giving them exactly what they need to take over one of your valuable districts. Once the characters have been selected, they're resolved in numerical order, one up, from the assassin all the way up to the queen.
The assassin can eliminate one of your opponent's characters for the round. The thief can steal gold. The king helps you gain council seats and move the king's guard. The abbot provides a little financial assistance and helps you build districts at a discount. The merchant generates gold, the architect lets you build multiple districts, the diplomat can control an opponent's district or gain council seats, and the warlord can also take over districts or reposition the King's Guard. And finally, the queen rewards you for having a variety of district colors in your city. Uh there is a lot of familiar character design here, but the abilities have been tailored to this new version. One of the things I appreciate is that the characters aren't just different ways to collect resources. They're directly involved in that tug-of-war for the city.
For example, the diplomat and the warlord give you ways to take control of districts that your opponent has already built, so that expensive building they worked so hard to construct might eventually become yours. And you have to think about protecting your buildings, too. The King's Guard protects the district it occupies and the districts touching it. That means moving the guard can make certain areas of the city safer while leaving others vulnerable. There's a lot of interaction packed into the nine characters, but there's another important element to Citadel's Duel, and that's the council. Think of it as a second battlefield. Around the council board are nine council seats, and these are divided between the two players. Throughout the game, you're going to have opportunities to flip council seats to your color by using certain character abilities. Why does this matter? Well, whoever has the most council seats at the end of the round gets a pretty significant advantage during the expansion phase. The player with the most seats receives three gold and gets to build a district. The other player then has the option of taking two gold or building a district. So controlling the council gives you more opportunities to expand your city and potentially pull ahead. The council seats are also worth points at the end of the game. This creates a really interesting second competition happening alongside the city building. You might be focused on your construction. Uh there's valuable districts, but if you ignore the council, your opponent could gain an economic advantage and start building faster than you. And sometimes the right decision isn't necessarily the one that gives you the most immediate points.
It's the one that gives you control of the next round. The game continues with players drafting characters, resolving their abilities, and expanding the city. Eventually, the city will fill its 4x4 grid, and that will end the game. At that [clears throat] point, you're going to calculate the value of the districts you control. Each district is worth the points equal to the building cost. Uh you're also going to score gold coins based on your districts and points from the council seats. The player with the most points is going to be the winner. So, even though you're sharing a city, you're really competing to control the most valuable pieces of the city. And that's a clever way to bring the city building theme and direct player interaction together. I'm going to give some critiques, some things I liked, and then some comparisons to other games. First, critiques. If you're a long-time fan of the original Citadels, you might miss some of the variety. 2016 included 27 characters and a much larger collection of those districts. Duel pairs that down to nine uh characters and 10 districts. Now, I understand why a two-player game needs to be focused and have a smaller collection of characters makes it easier to balance that experience, but it does mean that you're not getting the same character variety from game to game that you might be accustomed in the larger edition.
Another thing to consider is that this is a game with a fair amount of direct player interaction. You're stealing gold, eliminating characters, and taking control of buildings your opponent has constructed. If you're looking for a peaceful two-player city building game uh where you can focus on your engine without worrying about your opponent messing it up, this is probably not going to be your game. But if you enjoy that back and forth interaction, that's exactly what you're going to find here. So, some people might complain that the available districts aren't the ones they really want to build when it's their turn to build a district, and that can build some be some randomness in the game, but I think it's okay. Let's move to my likes. One of the things One of the biggest things uh I like about Citadels Duel is that it really does have a genuine two-player experience.
This isn't just the original game with players sitting around the table. The shared city, the board, the King's Guard, the drafting all work together uh in this new game. I also really like choosing the characters. It's pretty much the heart of the game and I really like it. Having four cards, choosing two, passing two, and then discarding one gives you some really interesting decisions every single round. You're constantly weighing what you need against what you think your opponent might want. And because there are only two players, you have a much better opportunity to anticipate what your opponent might be planning. I also like how the shared city creates some of those spatial decisions. You might want to build next to a matching district to gain more gold, but you also have to think about what you're giving your opponent access to. Uh that becomes especially interesting with the King's Guard and some of the characters, too.
Another commendation is the council system. I like that there's more than one way to get ahead. You can build those expensive districts and focus on the value, or you can concentrate on getting council seats and controlling the tempo of the game. Of course, you want to do both. And the council tokens are clear white and black. They kind of look like Oreos, but maybe that's just me. I think the game does a nice job of keeping the experience approachable. There are only nine characters to learn, and while they have some interesting interactions, the basic concepts are fairly straightforward. So, how does Citadel's Duel compare to the original Citadels? Let's start with the 2000 edition. The original game was designed by Bruno Faidutti and introduced the character selection system that made Citadel so memorable.
Players secretly selected characters, each with unique abilities, and used those characters to build their own individual cities. The 2016 edition expanded that experience a lot. Uh brought together characters from the original game and the Dark City expansion added new characters and districts and provided a much larger box for players to explore. Uh Citadel's Duel keeps that recognizable character selection system, but changes the way the city works. Instead of everyone developing their own city, you're fighting over one shared city. And instead of relying on a larger group of players to create uncertainty, you're making decisions directly against your opponent. And I think that's one of the big distinctions in the game. The original game is at its best when you have a group of people trying to read each other, predict character selections, and occasionally make some decisions that ruin someone's entire round. Uh Duel takes that same spirit of intrigue and focuses it more of a tactile head-to-head competition. Now, if you're looking at other two-player games, uh there are a couple of comparisons that you could consider.
First, Seven Wonders Duel. Both games give you that feeling of competing to develop something while keeping an eye on what your opponent's doing. But Seven Wonders Duel is much more focused on that card drafting, building an engine, and racing toward the different victory conditions. Uh Duel here, Citadel's Duel has more emphasis on the character abilities, uh the resource management, and uh direct interaction between the players. Another comparison might be Jaipur. Uh Jaipur is a much lighter and quicker two-player game, but both games create that interesting tension where you have to balance your own needs with the opportunities you're leaving available to your opponent.
Citadel's Duel is certainly more involved with more ways to disrupt your opponent and a much bigger focus on the tactical character combinations. And if you enjoy games like Coup, you might appreciate some of the character-driven mind games in Citadel's Duel. You're trying to anticipate what your opponent selected and figuring out how to counter their plans. It's not the same kind of bluffing system, but there are similar enjoyment uh things going on and trying to outthink the person that's sitting across the table from you. Overall, I think Citadel's Duel is an interesting direction uh for the Citadel series. What I appreciate most is that the designers didn't simply try to recreate the original experience with two players. They took the elements, those recognizable elements of Citadels, and reworked them into something that feels much more personal and competitive.
Uh the character selection is still here, the gold management and the city building, they're all there. And of course, the opportunity to mess with your opponent definitely still there. But the shared city and the council system gives the game a different personality. If you're a fan of the original Citadels and regularly play with two people, I think this is absolutely worth checking out. And if you've never played Citadels before, this could be a great way to experience a system without needing a larger gaming group. So what do you think? Are you interested in seeing more board games reimagined specifically for two players? We got a lot of them already out there. Let me know in the comments which one uh that hasn't been made yet you think should be made into a two-player game. Thanks for watching. Let's keep spreading the love of board games.