Corporate Cardboard - Episode 13 - November 11th 2021
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another episode of a corporate cardboard a board game variety show where we talk about all things board game as always um i'm here with my um my co-host mckenzie mackenzie how are you today i'm doing great enjoying a great cold day but things are good here i've got some coffee and i'm ready to talk about some board games fantastic now with that being said let's go on to our first segment which is what we've been playing so this is what we talked about the ball games that we've been playing in between last episode and this absurd and giving some brief um kind of uh initial thoughts on those games so mackenzie what have you been playing okay so the first game that i've been playing is just got delivered two days ago this is role player adventures so this came bundled with cartographers heroes and so i found this i was like wow i just i want to jump into it right away so role player adventures is a campaign system where you're going to be importing your characters from the original role player so that character you rolled up you actually will take its stats as well as its items and create a hand of cards now this is ultimately a dice placement and hand management game and i had no idea going in i didn't really really understand what sort of game this would be so you're going to be going through this adventure which is all text based and you're going to be doing skill tests as well as combats now the skill test is kind of the meat of the game as well as the combats and what you're going to be doing is assembling a dice pool you'll have different stats stamina charisma and you'll spend your little points in there so say i have three charisma i'll
spend one of my charisma points and that will become fatigue once you have enough fatigue that matches your health you become exhausted and that's kind of how you lose the game so unfortunately sorry sorry fortunately there's failing forward in this game so even if you do lose you will continue playing so there's a death section at the back so when you do become exhausted essentially you resolve this special death encounter and they do some healing and they push you back in so you're never out for good you do get to play out the story but i'll be straight up with you these dice tests these skill checks are brutal we played the first mission and the the second mission and we died in both of them it was insane it's these skill checks so the way they work you build that dice pool you spend your stamina so you take damage every time you add specific diced pool if you don't add dice you'll draw random dice and then you'll see these numbers here these are the exact numbers that you need to roll on that exact color to fill them in if you're doing a fight like you have here you'll have three rounds to do so but every dice phase that you don't cover you're going to lose something whether it be money or wounds or xp so you really want to kill these things as fast as possible and you do this through card play so you have a hand of cards that are from your item cards and you'll play them one at a time up to your card play limit and that allows you to modify your dice so maybe you'll flip dice you'll do re-rolls but this reminds me a lot of one deck dungeon where sometimes you just don't roll well and sometimes your cards in your hand are just not gonna work for the dice that you pulled or sometimes you just pull dice that don't work for the values one it's especially prominent with lower
player account games because your stats are that's it you have those stats for the entire campaign that entire mission so you have to do what you can with your limited amount of stamina and every time you do put in work you're taking extra damage now luckily that fail forward system is there so you still progress in the story so it represents like you tried your best but you failed so it's not totally lost you still get to enjoy it's still fun i really like the way it plays and there's a lot of creativity in the card play and you're constantly adding new cards to her hand there's no card limit so you have lots of choices when you're playing and the way that the cards work is every every fight you can re-pick up all the cards that you used in each fight essentially same thing with skill checks and so there are some cards that are like once per encounter and then they'll be gone for the rest of the encounter and then there are some cards that are like once per cycle so you can rest and get all those back so there's some cool choices in here but ultimately i'm i like the system but man i think it's difficult this is one that i'm just so subject to the dice that um i don't know how to approach this one i think i'm doing the best i can i've read the rules multiple times because sometimes i get them wrong so trying to just make sure i'm doing it correct but brutal what do you think of the role players series the role player adventure series i actually haven't played any of the role player games i remember um a couple of years ago when role player came out it came out pretty much at the same time as sagrada did if i'm if i'm right you were correct and i was kind of like crossroads which ones do i go for i chose to go for sagrada rather than role player um and
then since then i've kind of not looked back at either of them um so i haven't played either of them i thought maybe um i'm going to play a game of that weight with probably my family or someone and they're not going to be into the whole meta dungeon and dragons theme and something like sagrada they would certainly jump on board with um but i've heard really good things about it this one um is it is it more of an experience in terms of going through the storybook rather than the mechanisms himself um and that's kind of a more of a not tacked on thing but more of a taking a backseat to this story i think that they're both pretty present because you you're you're spending time on that skill jack it's definitely something that the game is built around of gathering these things and the card system makes a lot of sense so it definitely feels like they were both equally strong in this game and that's the game so the game really is the story and the skill checks so that's that's the game as a whole so if that's not something you're interested in stay away from this because that's all it is but for me this is one that i'm i'm enjoying it's challenging it's fun i don't know if i'll keep coming back to it because it is that brutal but yeah it's one that i'm enjoying uh if you want to add the expansion in it is extremely easy it just adds some backstory so nothing too crazy it doesn't add new maps or anything like that but it allows you to have some more fleshed out characters so luckily the expansion isn't too crazy as well you can put that in right from the get-go so that's my thoughts on role-player adventures so far go ahead is there a lot of content content there mackenzie is there a lot to go through or
so there are ten missionaries there are ten missions and a side quest mission and you can play the old scenarios because there's very much branching paths so the first decision you get is like hey are you going to go to this place or this place and that your choice is going to drastically change what you decide to do so i love that there's so many choices and because those tests are so brutal if you do pass a test you're going to get something really cool out of it so and that's going to completely change too so i i think that the story system works really well actually and so i'm enjoying the narrative aspect if i was just getting crushed by skill checks i probably wouldn't continue because it's just i don't know i probably would just to finish it but we'll see okay cool real pro adventure i know there's a big following for role player so i'm sure it's going to be a successful game okay so i've been playing uh witchstone which is actually the 20 20 21 release and i with a co-designer um called martino if that's how you pronounce it properly um this one if i didn't know this was a um a ryan cancer game i would never have ever have said this was by him is so out there and so different to anything that he's or that i've played with his before anyway i know the kind of core system in terms of playing these titles um onto the onto your player board and trying to kind of connect these symbols together to get more powerful bonuses has been used before with his designs but the rest of it is really um or as i said it's so out there
it's like a point salad style game that makes me feel of a steffenfeld's game it does if this is put in front of me with no with no designer accreditation on it i've said this was 100 percent a separate game so basically this is a um a bunch of mini games where you are trying to either go around this pentagram here and get these little tokens and points along the way and the more you do that you kind of get the first dibs on the most powerful ones you've got this big this big kind of a crystal ball in the center of the table here where you're trying to connect these routes and get points for doing so and then you can spawn witches and travel down these routes and kind of deposit other witches there to get other kind of follow-up bonuses but the more you're doing these very simple actions the potential to trigger follow actions or kind of that domino effect um just is quite remarkable and there's you know by the start of the game by the end of the game the terms you're taking are just pulls apart as you know you make strength you know it's taking place initially taking straight to one or strength two actions and then by the end of it you're taking strength you know four or five actions then you're getting a strength three actions are full out of that and then you're getting a straight two actions there's a fallout for that you're collecting cards to getting gay bonuses you're trying to manage your player board in order to get in order to line up these tokens and the release gem away which become a bit of a pain because you have to move them out of the way um as you can see here these gems are like blockers and as you more you place these two tokens down and they just get in the way so you can actually use this other symbol in order to push them off the board to get that
bonus as well i'm just so much point salad goodness in this game and i really impressed with it um initially i thought that the rules were so digestible and so simple thinking is this going to be a bit too simple but while the rules themselves are easy it's that again it's the potential to string those bonuses together and just to get that edge on your opponent it's it's a real blast to play and um i'm really enjoying it i'll be very surprised if this one doesn't end up in my top 10 of the year i think it's it's that good that is um yeah which stone that's some recommendation for a for a 2021 release um ryan can it game it's it's really good this one mackenzie whoa so that's high that's high recommendation from you that's pretty awesome yeah like you said it if it has a simple rule set sounds great right like if it's got that much depth into it so i'm excited so do you do you notice any reiner can it see a design the more you play it do you notice little things that may hearken back to his earlier stuff or is this do you think it's completely influenced by this additional designer um i know i think the the um tar placement system when you're getting it matching the symbols on your own player map that is taken from one of his games called ingenious i think um i've not played it but i've heard that's what it's taken from but it's such a such a clean mechanism and one that's so puzzly that it doesn't feel dated you know it still feels fresh um but the rest of it but again all these mini games it it's just it's kind of a pulls apart from what he normally does um so as i said it made me feel like a
stefan fells game some of them even felt like direct almost not copies but very similar to some of the minigames in trajan um but yeah i think the way these things come together is it's so it's so fun and i played this with my mum the other day um and she absolutely loved it she's so so much fun and um again particularly when you start making these runaway combos it's just it's just an absolute blast whoa okay so very low barrier to entry this is that's pretty sweet i like this yeah excellent yeah recommendation if you like kinesia and you like your point solid euros which stone is one to look out for holy cow what else has been playing against all right so the second game that i've been playing is the mad titan shadow expansion for marvel champions so this brings thanos into the marvel champions world essentially along with four other scenarios now if you don't want to know anything maybe you skip this part or tune down but i won't get into any heavy spoilers on mechanics or anything but in the box once you start slaving things you'll see them there's going to be four five new scenarios and three of them have to do with thanos you've got the black order so you have ebony maw and then you have this tower defense scenario you're fighting proxima midnight and corvus glaive at the same time and then you have thanos himself and they do something really cool with thanos where they use the infinity gauntlet and the infinity gauntlet is its own encounter set and i think that makes so much sense because you can now give the infinity gauntlet to any character which is really cool it just makes them super
powerful and i think that's great i think that's a great way to introduce it into the game because you can now increase the difficulty on any character you see fit by giving them the gauntlet and that's very thematic it makes a lot of sense here in addition to that you also have two new characters that are based off of asgard so you have one character hella that you'll be fighting against as well as loki and you'll have a lot of fun very challenging missions in those two so i was quite surprised i thought that uh thanos was not the hardest character in this entire set so it was cracking me up that i was having so much trouble with some of the other characters instead so have fun with this one the scenarios are fun and they're well done i was quite surprised and this is one that i'm really enjoying but the other thing that i really want to touch on are the two new characters so you have spectrum which is photon and she has this ability of form changing and she's very straightforward what she does she'll be switching back from the form each form is better at attacking or defending your thwarting and then you also have um adam warlock which has a very weird deck restriction where you can only have a singleton in each for each card in his deck so you can play all the colors but you can only play a single copy of each card which means that you get a lot of options however this game is all about consistency so it kind of sucks because you're looking through your deck but it's a deck of one of so man you're not gonna get the cards you want very often so you have some big choices here with which character you want to play someone is a bit more straightforward or someone who's a bit more random but has a lot more toolbox nature so some interesting
choices here i'll be straightforward not my favorite heroes but the scenarios are really really cool there are also some really great player cards so if you're a fan of marvel champions this is a no-brainer by oh having a great time with it okay yeah i mean marvel champions seems to be going from strength to strength really obviously it's been a massive hit for um for the company so you find that sometimes these um big ip games go one of two ways they have a five-minute you know they're five minutes in the sun and then they tank but marvel champions clearly defied that and it's again still going extremely strong so i'm i'm glad you're enjoying it and i kind of almost feel like i i should have played this when it came out but i feel like i've kind of missed the boat now and i'm not really that willing to go into it personally i want to play it but i'm not gonna i'm not gonna start acquiring the stuff for it but um obviously it's a really solid design and more content fantastic i think that's my favorite part of these cooperative lcgs is that you don't have to have everything so you really can start whenever you feel like like i started lord of the rings the lcg when it was like seven years in or something like that which is ridiculous so you can really take it at your own pace so i like that that model exists and i think that's why the cooperatives are so successful yeah absolutely definitely more yeah um inviting model than i said if you've missed it completely you can still go and get these expansions and get the same get the same stuff as everybody else you've got it originally okay i'm just a comment here from enrique i'm talking about which stone i think ingenious plus plus failed influence i'm connect serious genius
yeah i couldn't agree more and that's exactly my taste of gaming i'm enrique and it'll be interesting to see if he was actually um influenced by kenichi mechanically it seems like he did but maybe he wasn't i don't know okay so um i've also been playing um a feast for odin i say i've been playing i've played it once i played it last night for the uh for the first time of course this is um quite a quite a beast of the game um i've rated it here initially 6.5 i think that might be a bit unfair i think i will up it to a seven um is well the name of a feast frodo this is like a feast for worker placement spots so there's so many different options in this game um it's a uber rosenberg pretty full-on one there's quite a lot of going on in this game but i think actually the game does quite a good job of holding your hand through the game but by the um by the parade board it really runs through all the phases and most of them are pretty simple and the bulk of the actions are just nipple worker placement but it's a game i suppose the complexity is ramped up in terms of its scope and kind of width rather than the actual intricacies and um complexity in the game but there are so many different things to do here i kind of feel like i'm really kind of scratching the surface because i i don't feel qualified to give a final thoughts opinion on this one and because i was really lost in this one because uh you know we started the game not really knowing where to go because the game is so sandboxy offers you so many different things you can do you know do you want to go for these boats
and start hunting and go whaling do you want to start acquiring these new islands and filling them up these different pieces to get more income more bonuses i do you want to start breeding livestock do you want to try and um get all these unique towels and put them on your board and convert goods to others there is just a plethora of options at all times here and mackenzie and i were actually discussing before how i was a little bit apprehensive with this one because um you know workplace one of the key hooks type of games is the is the um you know the rush to get to the spots that you want to go first and i thought because there were so many options in this game potentially that magic might get lost and i can clearly say now that that's not the case there is a real tension to get to the spots that you want to get to and just because there is loads of spots here the game is bigger so it's almost like playing four worker placement games at once and if you're diving into one part of that game then the um you know the incentive to get to this spot is going to be just as high as if it was a regular medium weight worker placement game but with the game with so much going on basically the key mechanism in the game or the clean way of getting points or not losing points is by trying to fill up your player boards for these different shapes so you've got like that classic polyamino uv rosenberg magic which he's known for um and i will say the more i've thought about this one um it's starting to starting to fit into place or something yeah that was better than i thought it was at the time you know the first half of the game i was again i was a bit overwhelmed she didn't know what to do i felt very sandboxy
i'm just not getting anywhere here um we didn't we didn't do terribly well in terms of points but i think that's actually actually kind of intrigued me a bit more i want to do better than the previous game so i'm actually quite happy that i didn't do well on the first game because it gives me that reason to go back to it and um try and explore what else the game has to offer but very very brief initial um thoughts there and of course like the more i play i'll be able to kind of um articulate my thoughts better but for now definitely intrigued and i will be playing it again and um yeah so that's that's a feast road and obviously a massively popular um worker placement game so super excited that you finally got a copy and i'm so happy that you are ready to try it again i mentioned earlier when we were discussing that those island boards are really really important because that's a great way to get amazing bonus income and this game surprisingly not just with the work replacement and the tenseness of where to allocate your workers it's also about getting good income bonuses because a lot of those are going to give you more tiles to cover more places and it's kind of like a chain of events so you've got some good choices here so whenever i teach people this game i always make sure to press that hey don't worry about putting all your pieces on when you get them just gather as much as you can get a good place to put them and then when it hits that income phase then everybody kind of starts and places stuff so that's usually the best way that i i jump into this it helps with the ap and it also helps with kind of just a general arc of the game yeah and that's good that's a good point actually yeah one of the things i'd like to like about this game was the the freedom to play around with your
tiles regardless of turn structure you can really put that on your board when you want and you're not just like it's not as rigid as going to the spot to place tiles you can just kind of play around with it have a think and when it gets that crucial stage as mccandy said that's when you can commit to something so that was quite nice i did i did think that was a welcome addition so yeah still initial initial thoughts there and i'll give it a few more plays before i am before i get our final racing locked in and um get a review out but yeah a feast reading finally got to play it and um and yeah enjoyed it what else so the last game that i've been playing is the newest expansion for western legends this is western legends blood money so this is just a week of crazy story driven goodness lots of luck fests are you ready so this is western legends this is a game that's actually surprisingly i guess less lucky less dice rolling that that's not true you're still drawing cards there's still a heck of a lot of luck in here so western legends has you playing as cowboys you're going around and blasting each other you could be a marshal and be working for the sheriff or you can be an outlaw and do your best to rob and steal and cheat for your way to victory so you're trying to generate these legendary points and you do so by just doing standard western stuff and that includes all sorts of things you can participate in the story that's going on you can go gambling to the casinos you can rob the train you can go hang out with the bandits you can rustle cattle there's pretty much anything you can think of this newest expansion has added that so the biggest new components that were added are deeds
so first off you can actually buy the locations in the game um this is surprisingly not as impactful as we were thinking so it costs about like 80 bucks or something like that to buy a location and that gives you a one-time action that you can use in order to kind of use that location for example we own the gambling den so you could spend it to draw a couple cards and then you could transport to the gambling then each of these deeds also has endgame scoring so that's kind of neat and you could build a strategy towards that and score all your points at the end as opposed to during the game but we felt that if you were focusing on that then you weren't really scoring these giant heaps of points and you were waiting on others to end the game as opposed to yourself so it didn't seem that powerful with the deeds the other thing it adds is the traveling tradesmen which i really like because they sell these legendary items they're really cool but that traveling chase man is going to be moving around the boards you actually have to go find it so it's a little mini quest and the last big thing that it adds uh is the new story track so the way that it's changed is they add these gigantic cards and these cards have a bit more flavor they have events that immediately impact the game for example when we played uh one of the cards that got played was hey the sheriff has has died and so they're looking for a new sheriff so he's he's on his way so the sheriff is going to come back when these two things happen but in the meantime remove the sheriff from the game so all of a sudden there was no sheriff to stop any of the wanted players so everyone was just like it's a it's the wild west let's go and so in like that span i went and robbed the trade i robbed the bank i got to the top of the what a track this
is the first game i've ever won playing as the wanted player it was so funny so i really really like the new story system i was quite surprised so i think this is a very welcome expansion just for that story system it works so so well and of course they with the newest kickstarter they've made a consolidated rulebook that's really nice it's just this big index it's really easy to jump into the game now and if anybody has a question there's these great player rates that'll help you out surprisingly impressed we played a four player game of this and it was so smooth we had a great time i'm quite happy about this one the last thing i want to touch on is the card system when you're playing you're going to have a hand of cards and those cards are all multi-use they have actions on them as well as you can use them in combat or you can play with them as poker cards when you're playing poker so you have lots of different choices and i think that card system as a whole is just really really good because you just it's all multi-use and that's just really appreciated but it's done in such a simple elegant way i really like that so that's western legends blood money lots of new additions but one that i'm enjoying have you had a chance to join this western phrase i have not but despite you saying you know there's some quite a significant element of luck in this game this is one i really want to try actually i think it sounds like it's um a game that really does almost guarantees that kind of memorable moments and the moments that we know away from the game and years to come you'll remember what happens and you can discuss and have a laugh in that so yeah i actually do love the way that you know all the different things you can do and what that sand boxy thing you know do you want to do this do you want to do that and it just sounds like a really good canvas to kind of you know
to play that and enjoy that kind of experience so i like the theme i like kind of western themes in general and as i said i love that idea of the multi-use cards trying to make poker hands in between poker but i think you you play poker hands and actually do to fight as well you play texas hold'em if you're playing poker so you'll add two cards from your hand to the game and then if you are fighting you just pick a card in your hand because all the cards have a strength value which is aces high or you can use them for effect so some of the cards will have like reactions or ways to prevent wounds you might pick a lower card to get a better ability in combat so there's a cool choice there okay cool yeah i mean definitely want to try it um hopefully one day that will happen but as for now yeah definitely one on my radar that i definitely want to experience myself but i'm glad you're enjoying it okay so the the final game i'm going to talk about is one that my good friend here mckenzie recommended to me um and what a man what a man what a game this is this is absolutely yes yes it is capital generation um this was a game that wasn't even on my radar before mackenzie um started um tapping it to me and saying how good it was i know mackenzie's already kind of well versed in these kind of card games um and this game is so good it's not even yeah it's it's blew my mind how well some plays i'm sorry with such a simple system um i've only actually played the um basic
setup and i think even alone is uh you know an amazing game um so this is a game which basically you have a hand of cards you're drafting um a pair at a time and you're going to end up with six cards i believe and then you're going to be playing them either in front of you or in front of the capital and the idea is that you're basically trying to get as close as you can with your cards to the value of the capital so almost like describe it as a game of what we talked about um texas holdem it's a bit like blackjack but with a moving target um but but when you go to these certain spots in the middle because of course you're going to have to go there otherwise you're not going to get any points yourself you get a a bonus or some kind of power that you can use so in the very basic setup you've got one that you know the blue target or the blue place in the city lets you kind of change that target by either moving the value up on that value down so you've got a bit of play there but only you know it and not your opponent knows it so maybe you've tanked that value so they're going to go bust when they think they were safe or you've got ones that let you draw cards which can be a double edged sword because drawing cards is not always great because if a person plays all their cards then you're forced to play yours in front of you which could in fact make you you go bust again um you've got ones that will just give you coins which are a great kind of mitigation tool and just pure points themselves and um the other one actually lets you take a card from the city uh the lowest value kind of put it into your personal town or your personal board and the the
fallout of these actions although it might sound very simple on the face of it is is huge like this is a game where it really does put you in a hard position of managing your hands sometimes you don't even want any of these cards and you're gonna have to play them um but doing it doing it right and and you might think you know i'm a bit stuck here but if you play at the right place at the right time you can actually get yourself out of these horrible conundrums by you know by using that and using those powers to your to your benefit and i love this also ongoing tension where there's three rounds in the game you've got to try and keep your cards alive from start to finish because if you keep all of them alive then they're going to be pure points at the end but as soon as you go over that bus limit you're starting again from scratch which can of course be be devastating um it's it's remarkable i mean if you like these clever card games um the simplicity and elegance of them like you know hannah makoji comes to mind um this one does fit that niche for me i think this one feels timeless and the fact that there is so much replayability in the game because all the different locations are are variable so they're like modular you can take them out and put new ones in so all the locations do something else it is what a game that says this is fantastic i mean i can't believe this one as i talked about more um yeah outstanding game outstanding so happy to hear that you're loving it um a couple things to just add really quick that modularity piece i think is so cool because as you play this game that is going to change the value of certain cards when you draft because now all of a sudden this effect does this oh
my gosh i better hold some of these in the draft or the effects may get better as the game progresses that is so awesome and then speaking of the game progressing i love the fact that if you're winning these districts from round around you take cards from the center and put them into like a bonus scoring pile but that also changes the amount in the center so now all of a sudden your target just become lower and you had to try to get as close as possible so now all of a sudden you have more incentive to play to the center so there's so many cool things that just make so much sense and as you said elegant system it just works so well and there's just so much variety with those different modules this is a timeless classic in my opinion this is one that i'm always going to be excited to play yeah amazing so many so many layers so many yeah it really is a game that evolves and you realize you know at first you might not think there's much to it but then you quickly realize that there's more to it than you than you initially think okay i'm so happy about this yeah yeah i'm happy as well so that's um that's which stone feast for odin and capital lux for me and role player adventures marvel champions that mad titan shadow and western legends blood money for mackenzie and i think generally i think we all have positive things to say about all those games which is quite nice okay so let's move on then to the next segment which is crowdfunding so um i know this um this month mackenzie or this this episode we've actually both selected the same game and it's the game that you just mentioned so what have what haven't we been what we've been interested by this um this month
so this month is home to some great projects this one in particular though is one that we know is amazing this is you could back this on you know how how did you come up on this dan um so yeah i literally just uh i knew it was coming out but i didn't do any research on the on the actual game mechanism itself i don't even know what it was different about this and the original um simply because i had so much praise of the original game and i love it that much that this was an instant back for me um because the name hannah makoji just for me so hanami koji geisha's bro is the project here super super excited this is a new standalone game using the same core hana mikoji system but it also includes lots of little expansions that you can also use for the original game and this new version so hanami koji geisha's road runs the same way on your turn you're gonna have those little action tokens you flip them and that's to allow you to play a certain number of cards however in this one the points of the different sections are tied to locations on the board so you'll be moving this the these tokens around and if you land on specific areas that's going to add points to them so not only do you have to worry about placing specific cards for specific values but they're also tied to that board so you want that geisha to land on the spot so it's actually gaining points and then the sooner a geisha moves the more points it's going to be worth but that being said you're giving more information on that so think something like this is a weird comparison camel up where the sooner you commit to something the
better it is going to be for you but the later you'll have more information onto knowing what you're actually going for so there's some really cool things going on here i'm shocked that it's not doing gangbusters here it is pretty cheap so that makes sense but i think that this is just like like dan said this is a no-brainer like if you enjoy if you have a person to play two-player games with jump into this i just taught this to somebody yesterday and we had a blast with it just the way it changes the way you think i i really like this game dan what are your initial thoughts on this one um yeah i mean staying true to what hanumankoge is is is welcome um it's got certain type of brand in it although it looks like it's ramped up its complexity and more things going on in this one i do like the way it's trying to um get to remain true to what the original game is in terms of being simple but still brain wracking agonizing decisions so um yeah it looks like a step up from the original where to be honest the original is pretty much as simple as it gets in terms of its mechanisms but again that thought decision is there but this one looks like it's maybe built up a bit and um more going on just to add even more brain burner goodness but yeah really excited to see what this game has to offer when it's actually on the table and i'll be honest the thing that i'm most excited for is honestly the expansions for the original game um the new version could become too cluttered it could not be something that i'm really excited to play over the original and that's okay that can happen sometimes with these sql games but as long as you have additional components and expansions for the base game that
that's a win for me so you can use the tiles in either version and these tiles are basically replacement tiles for the actions so they're going to change up the way the game plays by giving each player an identical set of these action tiles so i'm excited to see how that works and that's really what i'm probably more excited than the sequel is for those additional expansions yeah that's a that's a good point and as i said you know the fact that it does try to stay true to that simple formula but it can well because a game like canon because it is so delicately balanced i feel like maybe putting too much into it could be it could be a recipe for disaster who knows but i've got to try and trust into it i'm going to try and go into this game with well just trusting in the design because the original was was that good so yeah um guess both of our support this one we both chose the same game for our crowd funding that is hanamakuji geisha's road okay so moving on then we're going on to the news section i will say i've got no news to cover here but i know mckenzie wanted to touch on something i thought that was just uh i thought this just was a really fun talking point just in general and this is specifically games about games so very meta but this is in a very unique way so this is from the unlock series and so unlock is published by asmoday and they are jumping in to their other properties which is really really cool so what does that mean well you're going to be playing this unlocked escape game very similarly to like the star wars
version where you're in the star wars universe exploring but this time you are in a board game universe so this original one i believe it has ticket to ride as one of the featured games here and you actually are going to be in that ticket to ride space exploring the trains trying to solve the mysteries on this now i don't really know the lore behind ticket to ride so i don't really know what to expect but you have some really cool games you're gonna be jumping into you also have as you can see they're pandemic and mysterium and so three big hitters that you're gonna be able to explore and see the world so i'm excited i don't know how excited i am to jump into pandemic and relive the uh you know the virus so that's probably the one that i'm probably least excited for but i think mysterium and trying to get clues from a from a ghost sounds like a great idea for an escape room and same thing with the train system so one of my favorite escape room experiences was the murder on the orient express from the exit game so i'm excited to see what they do with the unlock system for ticket to ride so curious to see how this plays out but i think this is just a really fun concept of taking existing games that you enjoy and kind of opening them in a new space it's almost like a weird sequel game but not at all but you get to enjoy the property you love in a new unique way what do you think dan what's a game that you would like to see in the unlocked setting um ooh most of my games don't have anything whatsoever okay i'm going to have a quick look around let's say oh that's good one grand austria's health that'd be fun nice swanky hotel there we go um but
yeah the this um this idea of as you said meta having or having ips based on previous board games and using those ips for for new board games i think this could be a new trend because i know um jamie stagmeyer from stone meyer games he'd released a new role and write game and i believe all the the theme in that game is the other game he said there's like a like a scythe section there's a um euphoria section so it could be a thing and this i think is probably a good you know business move and a good strategic move to promote your games with other games so i think it's quite clever and something that's probably going to be um you know a forward trend so interesting enough so i'm not terribly interested in unlock itself but the um but the concept again using using your own games or existing games popular ones of course um is a win-win i think for these companies i think so and i think even if they went like the extra step and did like maybe additional promos or something like that i think that'd be kind of cool to have it become even that more cross-compatible so very neat super excited absolutely okay moving on then i'm gonna go on to our component appreciation so this is what we talk about a particular um card or physical component from it from a board game and talk about why we like it why we don't like it or just what we find it interesting so um mackenzie what have we got today if it's your choice all right so i've been playing a lot of terraforming mars recently go figure a classic engine building game of creating
project cards and moving around but the thing that sets this game apart are the corporation cards at the start of the game you receive a corporation that determines kind of your special unique ability as well as some prelude cards and some starting project cards you kind of form a hand based on these things and that's your initial strategy so as you play you're going to draft more cards into your hand and be able to build towards this corporation's ability so what i chose was a corporation that i had never seen before and i imagine it's from some of the new promo packs so maybe the big box i know when we got terraforming mars aries expedition we ordered some of the promos from the big box and this one in particular is the price star corporation surprise star starts you off with quite a bit of money but you actually are going to lose points at the start of the game in addition to losing cash at the beginning sorry losing points and these are particularly from the terraform rating the terraforming you gain whenever you help the planet every round that you don't help the planet you get extra money and you get a point so this is such a weird faction because it inc actively encourages you to not help terraform mars you're focused on money the points generating things that are outside of the planet it's such a fascinating corporation and one that i had quite a lot of fun playing with because it's very different from what i like to do when i play this game i generally like to finish the game as quick as possible because a lot of people are sitting there building their engines and they're focused on oh if i play this it'll pay out in eight turns like ah too bad there's only four turns left because i'm too busy throwing asteroids or things like that so i tend to like to uh you know rush the game a little bit but
this is probably the longest game of terraforming mars i've ever played because i didn't help the planet at all there was one round where i did and it was kind of one of those things where i saved a bunch of money was able to do it still got my bonuses but then just in one turn i like helped to play like 15 times something ridiculous so it was that way at the end of the round i didn't get penalized as much so i just got a single penalty so it's it is so interesting because this is one of those cards that's going to change the way you play from turn one and i love that i love that about terraforming mars how they can offer that through their corporation cards so that's price star such a strange card but one that i really enjoy okay cool it's hard it's hard for me to comment on this one because i've got not got like grounding of playing terrifying while i've never i've never played the game so oh i don't know yeah i don't know how different this one is to the other ones but yeah i quite like the idea of you get well you're not wanting to contribute at all which is quite quite funny um okay so i don't know what to add on that one because again i don't know i've not played it but i know it's a massively successful game and um the corporation seemed like they added a lot of flavor and a lot of spice to the to the game itself cool so that is the was it the pristine was it yeah christopher yeah pristar pristar corporation for terraforming moz okay my one is not quite as um as clever as mckenzie's purely based on um on looks and the kind of novelty factor i'm talking about a game called celestia um celestia a very light push your luck
style game um i'm just trying to get a picture up here what i'm going to talk about i'm going to talk about the airship of this game which is a physical cardboard air ship where you have player pawns in them because the idea of this game is that you're trying to almost lure your opponents because it's kind of kind of a semi-cooperative style game and you're trying to lure them into staying at this airship for as long as they can um with the idea of trying to make them crash and burn because if you run out of these certain cars to overcome these different elements and things getting in the way then you could potentially crash or crash and burn and not get any points or choose to jump out earlier and to collect points for doing so but the actual physical once my internet catches up is um it's really impressive it's so cute looking and i love the fact that it's a a cardboard construct but the actual player piece itself are just your standard throwback you know your normal pawns you'd expect to see and that the mix between the elaborate cardboard component with the oh sorry from the wrong screen that um with the um with the traditional board game pieces i think is such a cool blend of um of things i think it's just wonderful so if i can finally catch up here sorry my internet is not good at all it's all good we'll get there anyway i'll get the picture up but kenzie if you played them have you played played uh celestia before this is a blind spot for me actually so
i've heard lots of good things as you said i've seen the piece before i think it's quite cute uh but this is one that looks very inviting the theme is whimsical i like the idea of you know sailing around in an airship it's something that just hits me right so this is one that i do want to try i've been trying a lot of these small games here i've tried 10 the other day and i just like push your luck mechanisms as a whole ah oh cool yeah there we go there's a picture there so you can see you've got the airship with all the different player pieces in them you're seeing along these different um different tiles along the way um but again i love that i love that mix of the old traditional and the new flashy board game components it just looks really cool it pops off the table i'm interested to hear that you played um you played ten what was the initial review on that one i thought it was fine um nothing crazy we only played it two but it was it was enjoyable i mean i've heard some polarizing opinions on it like some people love it some people hate it i thought it was good i didn't think it was i didn't think it was uh too far in either direction okay cool yeah certainly on my radar that one i'll pick it up when i get my hands on it okay so there we go apparent appreciation we've got the pristar corporation for terraforming mars and the um and the little zeppelin from celestia okay so moving on then we've got this or that so this is a section where we or a segment where we put two things in the board game in space against head-to-head mana and i decided what was the um what was the result because we put these a poll on our community pages on our on our youtube channels and let let you do let you make the decision to see what was the outcome so
what was the question um this episode mackenzie so our question last episode was tactics or strategy so that's the that was the audience question here and i know that we said that we really like to blend of it but i personally like to lean more into the tactics portion i like making quick decisions and i really like kind of bending and being flexible to the flow of the game what was your quick refresher what was your answer for this one yeah so yeah with you i was with the with the blend but if i had to choose between the other i like having not for strategy but i love having the need to plan ahead because i think that's a a cool thing that kind of introduces a whole new thought space into um into into gaming really it kind of stretched or exercise a whole new muscle that you don't normally get to explore so yeah i went for strategy you know you went for tactics and here are the results yes so as as you can see even one of the comments here we have michael newson he pretty knew some he basically agrees with you to a t he says he likes strategic games that require long-term planning something satisfying about forming a plan and executing it successfully absolutely when you see your hard work pay off and so but he is learning to like more tactile games and as you can see the poll here is more leaning to tactical games so you see tactical being the forefront particularly in these large adventure games with dice chucking and rolling and then in more of these euro games you're focused you always have some element of strategy so i think is a good healthy mix of the two make a perfect game in my opinion i think
having both of those is very key but um yeah what are your final thoughts on this one dan yeah i completely agree that makes the two is the is the ideal thing um i i don't know i don't know your thoughts because i think do you think that the more you start to explore this hobby like dive deeper and deeper you start to enjoy that um that level of strategy more and more or do you think that because obviously more when you start to introduce people to the hobby most games or lighter games are more tactical where you you react to what's in front of you um or do you do you feel like even even people who've been on the hobbies years and years and years and years would would still play games or games to a point where they can they can do without any strategy whatsoever i think there's a reason that those lighter games are classics because there's something just satisfying about plane tactically i mean it's it's a rush it's a high it's something that you have been presented with the decision and you've made a great one and that feels great it's instant reward over a long term reward and so if they hit different spots of the pleasure center of your brain i'm sure and that's why they're so successful still so i think that both are going to stick around and i think that you may appreciate strategy more the more you play just because you're being introduced to more games that focus heavily on it so i know that uh even now like i play mark kaibo the other day and my strategy was get cards that do this but i don't know what cards are going to show up so throughout the game i'm getting cards and i'm playing them technically based on the cards that i'm drawing as i play so
you have those little highs that many those mini rushes and then that that's super high at the end where you're you're executing that strategy the fullest so uh i think that it's both here yeah absolutely so yeah the winner was tactics so the question we're going to forward for for the next episode is a one more based on um the physicality of a board game so we're going to ask if you have the choice between deluxified versions of games or components or the standard retail version which normally you know strips back the the elaborate stuff that the flux games normally offers which one would you choose now are you willing to pay that extra to get the polished um you know against superfluous um lavish versions of games or are you happy with just the bare bones functional components that will do what they need to do now that doesn't mean that they're going to be unattractive it doesn't mean that the components from retail versions are not up to scratch and they're poor quality but normally the deluxe fighter just take that take that next step and really go above and beyond so if you had to choose between the two mckenzie would you be willing to pay the extra to get a deluxe version or would you be happy with just the standard retail version i think you know the answer to this but i pretty much always go with the deluxe version uh even when it's not necessary you totally nailed it on the head there i think a prime example of this is atlantis rising second edition the retail version of that game gorgeous beautiful the deluxe version over the top like holy crap but naturally we're still gonna get the
deluxe version so it's i don't know there's something because board games are so tactile and it's it is about that presentation and the things you're interacting with i think that it's prime to put that extra money into to have this elevated experience um i really like any type of customization to make the game pop out to make it more thematic to make it more special of an experience so i'm always willing to do the extra things to make it deluxe in addition if the game is garbage it's usually easier to sell it if you've got that alexa version so that's usually my take on that and so it usually ends up pretty well how about you know i to be honest the more as time goes on i am starting to lean away from deluxe versions i seem to becoming more and more popular in more games even even games that sometimes are average at best to come out with deluxe versions where i think for me deluxe needs to be needs to be but my preference for deluxe games would be games that are tried and tested they've been around for ages they've got a massive fan base and when you know the game is almost in a position where you know say like yeah we we will have a deluxe version it's a treat to all the people who like it but sometimes you get games that are completely untested you've got unknown maybe unknown publishers unknown design and they're getting all these stuff out there it's just completely unnecessary like i understand it's complete yeah it's a nice to have and it's a nice luxury but that that feels like a bit of a disconnect for means and even um well particularly because i play so many different types of games now and i'm constantly getting new stuff the table sometimes i'm not getting the
full the the benefits that i think is deluxe version probably warrants having and needs to have um so generally speaking i think more often than not unless it's a again a class i'm going to have forever until the rest of my days um i would probably choose a retail version now which has actually been proven because i had the option between backing a deluxe version of the marrakesh new stefan game or the retail version i chose the retail version um additionally with the um with the voidfall voidful we had choice between the deluxe version and the standard version i chose the standard version because i'm i'm content with it damn damn so i don't know i think especially when it comes to kickstarters you like the backing the deluxe edition is the thing you gotta do like that's the only reason in my opinion to even go for the kickstarter because if you get the standard edition you might as well wait to retail because it's gonna be marked down significantly so i think i mean in our space we're trying to get these copies early so that makes sense that way we can get them played and get our thoughts out but oh man so that's another thing that kickstarters lead you to go into those deluxe editions because you know you're getting all those incentives from the stretch goals and whatnot and that those additional buys that sometimes get unlocked so wow the interesting okay okay okay so you know maybe my mindset's gonna change if i didn't have the side game llc library maybe i wouldn't care but i do try to make it a priority to say hey our library is amazing come borrow our games and that way it's going to be an experience that's worth that that extra
so yeah yeah and yeah kind of touching what you said there the the idea of the deluxe kickstarter stuff and you know always being a no-brainer always go for the deluxe one um but i found that yeah i would always completely agree with you but i found that probably this year the gap or the bridge between in the deluxe version and the standard version the price point is becoming wider and wider and wider whereas before the older kind of campaigns would be like by the standard version for 40 pounds by the deluxe amazing edition for 50 pounds so it's like well obviously i'll choose the deluxe one because there's so much quality difference and the price is not that much whereas now like there's deluxe versions that cost 100 pounds more than the standard edition so and that's that's kind of behind my decision about if that bridge was narrower then i would always lean towards deluxe it's a nice thing and as you said resale value is always going to um hold up better with the deluxe version because normally that's what people want hey so it's an interesting um debate in this topic and i think i'd be quite interested to hear the results for this one so um what are your thoughts what do you think the actual result of the people is going to be i think deluxe for sure i think that most people are in that mindset if if they have a chance to get a game if they're even interested in a game most people that are interested in the game are they're putting that money forward anyway right they're probably going to be looking for that best experience even if they've played it already if they're looking to buy it from a past experience it's probably going to be good enough for them to get that deluxe edition because there's so many games out there that if you're playing and
buying a new game you probably want the best version of it that's that's what i'm thinking yeah yeah i think deluxe is going to win the poll but i think i think we're going to be surprised about how tight how tight it's going to be i think i think retail is going to do better than we think it's going to that's my opinion who knows it'll be interesting to see so there we go that's the master this all that question of the week deluxe version or retail version we'll put that poll out in the next few days okay so moving on to the next segment which is mechanism appreciation so this is where we talk about particular gaming mechanisms in a game well any game that we like um can be as complex as you like or as simple as you like so um what are you talking about this episode mackenzie okay so this is a great idea and something that i think is so cool that comes from mansions of madness second edition so manchester madness second edition is a kind of mansion crawling game where you're gonna be going from area to area doing this investigation of some sort in the arkham horror universe but it is completely app driven which is really really cool so the app replaces the need for a dungeon master it controls a lot of the randomized setup the combat everything is handled by this app so we played the last mission that we had not tried yet so we've completed all the content now for this game and that was the forbidden journeys this is the traitor the traitor scenario so this is basically the theme of unfathomable the new fantasy flight game where there's going to be deep ones on a ship and it's your job to suss out who the deep ones are while doing your best to kind of
save the crew members of this ship so that's the the blurb from the box so there's no spoilers here but what's really cool is in this game everyone's going to be given a trader card and those trader cars will basically say that hey you're trying to sabotage the mission or hey you're trying to win the mission and they'll give you kind of specifics on what to do so right off the bat very cool very different because generally manchester madness is a strict co-op so i like the idea of implementing this trader system into a game and i think it does it in some really cool ways so this scenario is not my favorite i had some issues with the water a lot of times on your turn you were just like moving one or two spaces and that just feels really bad but they had some really interesting and really cool mechanics that i hope appear in later games and those have to do with how the trader is handled in the app so sometimes the app will say give this to player x and that player takes it and they will secretly do something in the app and then they have to read out loud the text after their choice and that could be anything maybe you set fire to something maybe you sent a crewmate out to go find other crewmates and they died so it's you you have no idea what that person put into the app and they can lie they can say whatever they want the thing that they type in the app might not do anything right now but maybe in like two turns or you know three turns down the line something will happen based on those decisions another really cool thing is they'll sometimes have you do skill checks where you'll take the app and the app will say roll up to this many dice based on whatever your stat is and then total up your successes and no one gets to see you and so you'll everybody closes their eyes you roll the dice and you do your thing secretly and then
afterwards you say oh man i rolled really poorly i only got one success and maybe you didn't roll any dice or something like oh i whiffed oh i don't have any clues and you could really you could really sell this and be like oh yeah and it's it's so it's so well done because no one knows exactly what you're doing and you have this opportunity to be very manipulative using the app as a vessel for that and i think that is so cool it does a lot of neat things with this with this trader mechanic and i'm excited to see it implemented in new systems in new games like i said i wasn't super impressed with this scenario as a whole but i am excited to see how it continues further on so that's matches of madness horrific journeys so that's particularly the traitor in the app so any ideas have you played manchester madness no i've never played manchester madness um not normally the cup of my you know my cup of tea um but i think there's so much potential for using apps in this in this way um i think you know despite more and more games using um using apps to benefit um stuff like creative ways like this where you can introduce that whole new element of social deduction or you know deception or as you said i love that idea of stuff you do now effects turns and turns and turns later and the fact that it can be managed and kind of facilitated by an app is again the potential for stuff like that is just fascinating i think it's just again scratching the surface with stuff like that to be explored and i know like manchester madness is leading the kind of leading the charge of
integration in games i've had nothing but huge praise for the way that this app works adds so much life so much potential to a to a cardboard and um you know plastic game it's just it's fascinating i know some people are against it i'm not because of reasons like this so yeah i love that idea um and yeah absolutely yeah quite impressed with the system as a whole not my favorite game by any means uh not one that i am recommending to people really but it is a very unique experience and i think it's definitely worth the try cool yeah understandable okay so the game i'm talking about is pulls apart from uh from manchester's madness this is a very simple card game called q birds and i suppose like this i'm talking in particular i'm talking about is um well one of the main mechanisms you use and one of the only mechanisms you use and that is this idea of the way you acquire the birds in the first place so this is a simple set collection game as you are and you have a hand of cuts all depicted by these different birds and it is you're trying to collect other birds in order to play them down in in sets in order to race to get to either seven different birds or in order to play i think it's two sets of three birds and but the way you do this is quite interesting because obviously the birds are gonna be points in your winning criteria but in order to acquire this you need to play them on the table to collect other ones so you basically have this row of
um or this bigger like a set of four four rows of three cards and it can get more than that and then you're going to use these cards in your hand to almost trap the birds in between them so if i have a pair of parrots i could put one on this side of this duck card one on this side of this magpie card and collect all the ones in between them and add them to my hand and then the market is going to be filled up with the ones that you've just played but i love the fact that when you when you play these cards you collect the ones in the middle you have to play all of them all of them so if i had um four parrots i'd have to play four of them um at once you know maybe two on the side two on that side in order to collect the ones in the middle and that of course will leave opportunities for my opponents in order to capture the ones that i've just played so even though i've already maybe collected my power that i need for my set then i'm leaving an opportunity there for my opponents to play a pair of their birds and collect my parrots so it's got this real dynamic market feeling which actually really does um ring bells or remind me of a game like jaipur where you have this constantly changing market but the fact that this one is player driven rather than you know top decking from a deck and refilling it back up i think it actually has quite a lot of depth here and initially i was thought you know this is a this is a fine game um it's it's okay a simple stack collection game but the more i played this one i thought oh actually the decisions here i'm making are much more meaningful than i thought because for those reasons you know i'm playing these cards here sometimes i only have one of them um which means i can maybe trap a couple of birds and then i have another one in my
hand which let me capture another set of birds so you have this kind of four momentum where you want to be collecting birds not just to play in them but you want to be collecting birds to collect other birds and it's something to explain but the the way you kind of string three turns together at times and still being wary that the market is changing and other people are digging into that market as well is actually really interesting and um it's actually growing on me quite a bit and i think this is quite an underrated little game because of that capture and trapping mechanism of the birds so yeah one that i definitely recommend checking out if you like your simple little card games it's very affordable plays ultra quickly and again has that good um that good market hustle and bustle feel to it as it's constantly changing and that's all driven by the players so have you tried this mckenzie or are you interested in trying it i have not but that set collection on multiple levels sounds really really cool i really like that i also really like the art it's whimsical and cute um yeah looks cute looks like somebody took a lego set and went at it with a bird watching book so i'm excited this looks fun looks cute and i'm always a fan of trying solid filler games yeah that's how i'll describe it it's definitely solid um and i think it's um one to work worth checking out because again it's so cheap and just uh just get it on your repertoire and see what it's like because i think i think most of the people who played this do actually rate it quite highly and it's a bit of a bit of an unsung gem that is that's cubs okay so moving on from mechanism appreciation we're going on to the random game generator so this is where
we hit the random button on board game geek and see what we come up with normally it's something that nobody wants to hear about but it's still fun regardless so let's get started and see what we have this episode so as always we kind of take a bit of a speculative guess and see what we're going to come up with are we thinking some obscure promo card again mckenzie i'm thinking an expansion of a game that we know that's what i'm going to guess that's a that's that's pretty unlikely but we'll go for it expansion to a game we know i'm going to say it's going to be a war game that is also pretty good that's uh that's pretty significant yeah mike spin that wheel here we go okay um if it'll spin is it it might be jammed here we go what is this we have a game called dog it's actually okay 6.4 out of 10 1997.
and this is oh okay so i don't hear the desire this has got dennis lauhausen as the artist who who actually is the artist to a lot of euro games nowadays a lot of steffenfeld games um okay so this is well let's read the description here so we've got management movement points take that team-based game and track movement okay so it says yeah it looks like it's sorry that's what it looks like okay oh yeah yeah sorry family of games but with a few notable twists um similar to tak super talk four super top six toxics and super talk eight all those famous games so yeah so it sounds like a simple take that game is that right i'm not actually sorry so i don't know so sorry is essentially you draw i don't think you you may draw or you may have a hand of cards you play a card you move along around a track if you land exactly on somebody's piece you say sorry and you send their piece home and that's that's really what it is you move around you're trying to get all your characters back to the start um parcheesi style you go around the board if you make it all the way back you got to get into your home section once you get all your people back in your home section game's over you win so very simple straightforward okay yeah i know you've said it i think i have played it when i was a kid um we've got some decent ratings here actually some people liking it um some people certainly not liking it no believe it or not i had a friend that um he was he and his wife actually played a
game very similar to this i don't know if it's called this but very similar to this and they love it this is like a game that they consistently bring out with families and at parties and stuff i couldn't believe it i thought that was so wild and that was just something that they played and when they described the game to me i was like it's sorry right it's part cheesy and they're like i don't know what you're talking about i was just like i was like what this is it's maybe that's a thing this is a big hit because it's so straightforward you just move the pieces and this one looks like it's card driven as well so there's a bit of control so it will i don't know uh yeah interesting i should read this comment just going to read this comment here from lallyboom it says he got dealt a hand of cards without the option to leave your starting area and there you go do nothing for a few minutes and watch your team lose what a horrible horrible game design surely can be fun under the right circumstances but i'd rather play many other games there we go so he's not a fan but there we go that's it that's dog uh and as mike cross says here i think we're all agreed today it's an instant purchase there we go so there we go that's the random game of the um of the of the episode which is a variation of the game sorry so moving on from the random game we are going to go on to why is in your collection so this is a segment where we talk about a game that either of us owns so i'll pick a game from mckenzie's collection he'll pick one from my question and we'll explain why they're in our collection for for one other just do they not like them do
do are they curious about them so that's normally what this um what this goes back to so mackenzie what have you got for me okay dan so this game appeared on your top 50 list recently and i couldn't believe it i could not believe that this was so high on your list i i really couldn't this is one that we had for a while tried to do my best to enjoy it try to do my best to play it i ended up selling it because i i just couldn't find the pleasure for it it just did not do it for me i i really want to know why this is in your collection and why is it so highly rated for you this is tawatinsuyu in my opinion the weakest of all these t games just because of not only the complexity of the game because there's the ridiculous amount of choices but also just the not very satisfying payoff of those complex choices i felt like this game was not worth the effort this game was complicated for the sake of complexity and i felt like the things you were doing the tapestry weaving the battles i thought they were very underwhelming not something that i really want to enter the engine building was not that exciting and i thought that the game was it was not worth everything that you had to do to put into it i tried i was playing it solo a lot just see if i was missing something because the solo mode works extremely well tried playing multiplayer and i was it took about five hours to play with four people and it took you know two and a half to play with two and i couldn't believe it and the things we were doing were not that exciting and incredible tell me tell me explain to me explain to the audience explain it okay so to be honest all the stuff you've said there were concerns of mine i thought this
this is a massively um intimidating game um there's a lot of symbology a lot of iconography some of it isn't the best um there's some rules here that probably could have been left out um but because of that every time i play this one i've had an absolute blast with it i think it's great um i've tried to go into that so i like the idea of the the idea of um you know when you when you take what place worker placement spots you can build around them get more and more um more actions when you when you claim the sports around them so the gate does have a forward momentum where you're again getting powerful actions the game is on um i like the passive victory you can go down um there's again you can do the tapestry thing you can completely ignore that if you wanted to there is a bit a bit of luck element to i suppose but you've got some mitigation tools there where i believe you can draw draw a few and then keep a couple so you've got a little bit of flexibility um and i like to i kind of like that engine building where at certain points in the game you just get a little little kick of resources nothing nothing major and but i think the the thing i liked about or kind of pushed it over the edge for me was i like the card system where you got to have the matching cards with the matching spots and that merged with the um with that idle mechanism where if you collect these idles not only would you get to use the worker placement spot you'd also get the bonus on the card as well and i thought that it all kind of built towards this crescendo and as the game went on you'd start being a lot more
stronger than you were at the beginning and i also like that that switching point where you want to start selling your idols in order to climb up the tracks the temple so i thought it actually did all come together quite well i i do agree with you that it's probably my in fact it is my least favorite of the um of the t series but that's that's still high praise i mean highly ooh spoilers for the rest of your top 50. yeah that's true yeah but i think people know that anyway um but yeah it's it's it's definitely a a complex gamers game i don't this is a game that's ever going to change anyone's mind in terms of not liking euro games this is going to just make them it's going to enforce through some of those decisions isn't it it's not it's it's quite stuffy at times as mckenzie said it's not the most um it's not the smoothest it's a bit clunky in space there's some rules here that maybe didn't need to be there um but i still enjoy the experience as a whole i'd like it it's to stay around i was i enjoyed the first play of it when i played it again i liked it even more so normally that's not the case i kind of i'm interested by things than it goes down but i i don't i still love it one last question for you dan yeah so my last question has to do with the randomness in this game so this game has some randomness in it that reminds me of something like paladins of the west kingdom where you have this very tight system and then you're drawing like some random cards for resolution so
the combat cards there are some that are just clearly better than others and every time you get a combat card usually drawing just from the top of the deck same thing with some of those action cards there are some that are just have clearly better rewards than others and then the tapestries as you touched on earlier there are some that you sometimes you're just gonna get one that doesn't fit how do you feel about that you can you can oh man you obviously i'm holding back my my big thoughts here like it's i just feel like you can sack into some dumb stuff in this game and that's how it feels like get this very solid crunchy thinky thing and then you can also sack into these very key aspects of this game yeah i completely get you i suppose maybe up to this point i've i've not been burnt by that maybe that might be the reason why i've not felt myself ever in a position where that's that's affected the outcome of the game um but obviously doing this um or playing this time and time and time again no i haven't played it a tremendous amount but when i have played i've enjoyed it but maybe play testing it more and more and more that those issues might become more apparent and that could could sync it for me but as for now i've not experienced it and i like the way the game works so okay i completely understand your criticisms i can't really dispute them but i still enjoy it regardless of that so yeah i hope you have a great time with it and i hope it's when you do continue to enjoy like you said i hope it keeps on going up for you yeah yeah i think i don't see it ever being amongst my you know top 20 25 anything like that and where it gets to the absolute incredible games
but just just on that bracket below i think it's i think it's fantastic so yeah fair enough okay so i've got a game for you that i would have thought i would have looked into this but for some reason i haven't this game this bunch or i think it's a series of games has completely um evaded me i don't know anything about them from the name of it itself it sounds like something a kind of game that i'd enjoy this is a game called uh margraves of valeria okay okay what is this game about and is this something that i would like okay so margraves of valeria is actually kind of built on lots of pre-existing systems and mechanics margraves in particular is based on the concordia mechanic so on your turn you're going to be using an action card in your hand to navigate across the board pretty much every action card has some form of movement on it as well as potentially like a resource or a bonus or something you can use it for so that's the first thing you can use a card for otherwise you can use the card for its printed effect so each card is multi-used it has an effect and then it has like a movement option so that's the core of the game you play a card you do one of the things in addition each of the cards has a symbol that's going to be scoring for you at the end based on these influence tracks that you're kind of whittling up so that's the core system but the game itself has you moving around this board collecting resources building these large outposts to gain influence and you're just trying to gain influence on all these tracks because these tracks will multiply the number of your symbols for that score now this is an incredibly highly ranked game for me this is a probably a seven-ish in my
opinion i think it's good i think it's fine i think that there are a lot of good systems but this falls into some of the pitfalls that games like this do normally fall into where normally you're not really caring about the cards that you're drafting uh you're just carrying about like their effects you're carrying just about the scoring and that definitely is present here it's why i like aquatica a little bit more than this because you're taking the cards for the powers of the cards as opposed to just the scoring but the system here is very solid you move around you interact with the board and you're collecting things that work to move on lots of different tracks so it's got this really cool battle system as well where you can move and attack these characters you can spend nights and when the knights are killed you actually place them into this grid and once certain columns and rows on this grid are filled you're going to get some extra resources and bonuses and so i really like that system here i think that's pretty fun but the game itself is move your pawn around do actions and just kind of explore it build up stuff collect symbols and resources it's a fun time it's one that i enjoy i think this is a solid game this is from the the valeria series so valeria has like a machikoro style game where you're going to be rolling dice and collecting resources it has a card version of like lords of waterdeep where you're collecting these different adventures and quests and trying to match it to your lord and this one is more of like their hey this is a bit heavier style euro game that uses some mechanics that you're familiar with so this is a neat one that has a cool theme fantastic artwork i really like the miko's art i think this is great it's really the biggest reason that i was like ooh let's go check this one out uh but a friend introduced me to this
one and it's one that i do enjoy i think it's fun so that's margraves of valeria i don't know if i'll change your mind i wouldn't be a very strong recommendation for me i read this and manchester madness about the same i think it's a fun experience but not one that you necessarily need to prioritize okay yeah cool i don't know what came first but this almost looks like it's trying to capitalize off the success of like the west kingdom games or the shen phillip designs because they even obviously got the same artist it's got the same kind of tag line um with that we know with the sub sub line as well maybe it's trying to do that but it just it just for me looks like i don't it just doesn't look like it has anything incredibly unique or interesting about it it looks like it's i don't know trying to yeah trying to almost capitalize off of that kind of the success of those games is that the case or so i think that this one in particular is more i think this came out around the same time as architects um but this is just the miko's style like this is how he draws right and in particular in this like night setting so i think it's very similar there but i think this is taking a lot of familiar mechanics um but i think the most unique thing it does is that battle system so i think that battle system is probably the most unique in getting those rewards from your combat so i think that's probably the newest thing it does but if you're looking for something extremely fresh and different this is probably not what you're looking for okay okay yeah just yeah i'm not being not up my mind changed on this one so that's that's fair enough i mean some sometimes these only has like a weight of 2.5 out of five or something so
generally a bit a bit lighter than what i'm generally looking for but obviously people who do like it like it a lot because it's rated 7.7 out of 10 which is pretty damn high um for you know for an average rating so hey there we go that's my graves of valeria at least i know a bit more about it now okay so moving on then so we have the a2z sections this is where we talk about a uh a light game and a more involved game of a certain categories so this episode we are on letter m so mackenzie what is your light game beginning with the letter m so my light game is one that does not get talked a lot it's older brother does so this is the mind extreme this is the sequel to the original mind a game of trying to have this psychic link between the other players at the table where you'll be playing cards into a pile at the same time trying to go from lowest to highest so the standard game that's it that's really all you're doing you're doing your best to kind of get the cadence of the game play cards and good timing this one amps up the difficulty dramatically so what you're going to be doing is you'll have two piles of cards one is going to be going up one is going to be going down it does sound like just a convoluted version of the first one and it is however my wife and i have crushed the first one and so we really like the challenge of the second one and that's what we really like about it is that it is difficult the challenges are really cool because sometimes you'll be playing face down into certain piles sometimes you'll be playing with certain cards face up it's it is a very very unique no i wouldn't say unique it's a very good twist that increases
the difficulty of the original mind game so i do like this system i think it makes a lot of sense and i think that this is the one that i'm going to be pulling out because i normally only play this game with my wife so this is the one that we'll end up pulling just because we like that challenge we like that additional twist to it so we have not beat this one yet we consistently make it to like the second to last level but we always lose on that second the last one so it's it's one that we still have are trying to finish but one that we enjoy that's the mind extreme yeah cool i mean i'm with you with with the mind there i think i had that that moment when you know when the mind came out where i paid it a lot and we got to a point with it where i played with my girlfriend and a couple of our uni friends and we got so good at it that we actually beat it at four players and since then i've not really had the intent to go back to it or at least lost that that level of interest you know when you when you want to or have the desire to beat something whereas i suppose something like the mind extreme could just add that next layer and to um to keep that interesting along but i actually like the mind i think um people who criticize it are a bit unfair on it because it's it's just a really fun experience and creates a lot of fun moments so yeah the mind ex from there um a lighter game that i want to talk about is a game called um if i remember what i put down oh yeah mandala a game that i've talked about a lot oh yeah oh yeah yeah oh yeah i should know this one really this is um this game is outstanding i know never talking about one so apologies if you've heard me um go on about this game but it
is that good so mandalas is a a two-player game only for two players you know you can't play solo or any more than um and it's a very simple hand management style game and almost a set collection style game as you were trying to um acquire these different cards which are these weird looking square cards with different mandalas on them and then you are using these cars to play in the middle of the table which kind of is the the area where you're gonna get your cards from to get points but you're also using cards to bid for those um in the first place but you can never have duplicate cards so if you're bidding with something it means that your opponent can't bid with that type of card and it means that have a card can't be in the middle either so it's a quite easy to get your cards submitted to a certain spot before because you can get locked out of areas and when you end up getting all these different colors on these different mandalas then that mandala will explode and then points will be divided out in terms of collecting the cards and the order in which you take these cards is fantastic because they get allocated to different spots on your board and the first cut the first card you take gets you a single point the second type of card you take gets gets you two points for each and then three points and so on so it has this really cool scoring where sometimes cards aren't worth much to you but it can be worth loads to your opponent and you've got to use that to your advantage and you know try to burn off cars that you think your opponent might want and it's such a smooth game one that has a tremendous amount of depth but still feels like it's a nice filler fun experience only takes about 20 minutes to play and it is just an absolute gift of the game
so if you like two-player games this is in my opinion an absolute essential um some questionable production choices here with the old tea towel as a playing mat and then the cards are a bit known because they are square and don't you can't hold them you know as well as you'd probably like to but the gameplay completely transcends that it is remarkable to play a game that is mandala a high high recommendation so i've been trying to find this game and i can't and i'm so mad because it feels like this is in that upper echelon of two player only small games and so i've i've been looking for can't find it so when i find a copy you'll you'll see it being covered here so i'm excited to give it a try and get my thoughts on it because i hear nothing but positives from you from others i i gotta get my hands on this one so super excited to give it a try it looks great i love i love this it looks super awesome super excited confident you like it perfect okay all right my heavy game is a huge dice chuck fest giant fantasy world this is madara unintentional malam act one this is a huge story driven game where the book itself is about that thick it's gigantic you're gonna be reading probably like 20 minutes of text in between missions but they have this amazing narration app that comes free with the game so coolest thing you just hit play listen to it while you're setting up the scenario super awesome so i love the story the story is actually compelling something that i enjoy listening to characters are fun it's a great great cast and you'll be taking these characters from mission to mission
so the game put starts you off in this um very unique world it takes place in the other side of this portal and this portal connects the real world to this fantasy world and it's kind of neat the they've got this really cool government system where they regulate the use of the portal they say hey you know if you're going to come into the portal you have to be ready to be able to fight and so they have like a citizenship test essentially and everybody is having having to train to be able to actually go out into the fantasy world because they don't just want to send you out there and have you die to something it'd be a shame if you just got to this new place and got killed like a slime or something so they run you through this series of tests before you can claim citizenship to this land so i really like this idea of all of these newcomers to this fantasy world doing their best so that they can take their place in this area and so you're doing your best to get through this and that's the that's the start of the mission i won't get anything else but the system itself is a heavy dice driven game on your turn you'll have stamina points that you'll spend you'll use them to move attack and when you attack you look at the values on your item cards and those are going to correspond to the dice and the stice start weak and get stronger so the numbers get bigger you're also going to have symbols on them so similarly to games like imperial assault you'll roll the dice and you'll use these icons on the device to activate the abilities of your items we talked about this before there was a t-shirt that i really liked in this game where you can spend your items and exhaust them to use abilities like free counters or to dodge you also when you attack can trigger the symbols to do extra damage so you have these cool choices when you roll you have an option where you can
kind of over exert yourself to roll an extra die that's just full of symbols but it can potentially make you miss so you always have these choices when it comes to prioritizing damage or effects and i really like this system so you have that idea of do i go for the accurate hit or do i go for extra damage and potential swings so this is a great system it's very quick but it's a little bit of a beast to learn because the first scenario you have to know everything for that first scenario it's not difficult it's just you need to know the procedures because everything is available from turn one and i really like that about this game because it allows you to learn in a non-threatening setting as opposed to something like gloomhaven where a lot of people die in that first scenario in gloomhaven in the original so i've heard a lot of people just stop playing that game because they found that first scenario brutal so i know that i'm experiencing that right now in role player but it will play adventures but it has that this that has that failed forward system so i guess it's not as awful so that's uh midara unintentional malam act one in fantastic story dungeon fall game one that i'm really enjoying okay cool and despite being um so nice driven um i see the weight on the um on the btg page is four out of five so quite heavy quite involved it is it is very involved not only do you have the dice combat but you have like these ai cards that are going to be pretty crazy with how they react you have lots of little exceptions to things lots of tiny effects so i think that's where the majority of the weight comes is from all these extra little effects here and there right okay but there's still the um by the sounds of it the gameplay still
warrants all that extra learning i agree it's pretty dang fun it's it's the gameplay itself is very straightforward you move you hit stuff and so that's that's it and so it's it's about the the small things i think aren't what make it exciting to make it thematic there's even rules in the game where you could throw each other like over crevices and be like here go and so and you could you know if you trip you fall into the crevice and you die or things like that or if you have someone on the other side of the crevice they can catch you so there's rules for like everything that you think you could do it exists which is really cool so i i like this one it's it's it's pretty nice okay cool that's midara the involved game that i want to talk about is a game called monasterium therium is a game that actually comes to relative or fanfare laughter i think there might be some distribution issues with this one um i think it's available in europe but i think in the states it's might not be the case so this is a a mid-weight euro it's a dice drafting game and uh and it's a i think the way that the dice drafting works in this game is is pretty unique and i've not seen it done ever before so therefore it's completely unique um but you are basically rolling a bunch of of dice and then you're picking one of those pit values that you've rolled then you're allocating it to the bottom of the board here on these different locations and then it'll go to your opponent's turn so between you between all the players you are actually building the action pools of the um of the drafting spots before the game or
before the round even starts so that's a a whole new dimension of a um of a dice strapping game where again the dice ports are normally just all rolled and then they're allocated but this one you actually have a bit more control and a bit more mitigation to what you might want to build towards and then in turn you're gonna be drafting up to three dice from these different spots and taking corresponding actions such as um you know traveling around down this main road here visiting these different churches and monasteries trying to send your kind of clergyman into them in area control style things and trying to collect these um stained glass windows and add them to your individual player boards here where you can start to get kind of connection bonuses um and more points and but what i really love about this game is that when you choose to take a certain action or when you choose to invest more and more in your player board when you take a particular value of um of die from the from the drafting pool you can actually increase your options as the game goes on by removing these workers from your board and therefore you know each you know initial your your four die um might only be worth a rosary bead but as you unlock more of these workers you can start you know maybe doing a double move action or taking one of these picture frames so you have more flexibility as the game goes on um it's three pretty concise rounds in this game so it does have a nice forward moment where you have to get things done pretty quickly and if you don't you're gonna go without there's some public objectives and which people are racing to get and it is a really nice game that's well-rounded it's um
it's a one that i think again gone under the radar should be more appreciated nothing really wrong with it at all um is it the best of the dice drafters probably not but is it go enough going on in building and just how quick and accessible it is so i think this one is a trick to play and um i would recommend giving it a go if this is your style of game so that is monasterium i'll be honest never seen this one never heard about this one so all news to me i do like that system of dice drafting though i think it looks like it well it looks like it works well here yeah it's just something a little bit different to um you know to give it that that edge amongst the vast competition of different euro dice drafters out there so yeah that's monastery and one that uh yeah gone a bit underrated um i know the people who do like it like it so that is our a to z for this episode so we're just going in to the last segment now so um we do we have a poll question from the last episode we did have a poll question it was how do you find gamers to game with so that was our poll question there so it could it be from your large group of friends that you already have could it be from internet websites so things like facebook or gaming groups you just walk into your local game store and see what's up so the poll was how do you find people okay and i know that last time oh go ahead with outcome okay let me pull it up one second so i know that last time we talked about
our personal experiences where you kind of evolved through playing magic with your friends and then i move all over the place all the time so i tend to use websites like facebook to just find games to play with so here we had that 78 of our population here found their gaming groups their pre-existing friends our second place was other with 13 and we even had some comments here kind of explaining what that meant a lot of people say they just game with whoever they ask people hey do you if gaming comes up in conversation they'll start talking about it and then we had some people saying that their group is solo so that makes sense that that would be on the other category and then game stores and online gaming groups were in the bottom there with non-gaming community centers at the very bottom so i guess if you're looking for gaming people you're obviously gonna go into gaming areas so that makes sense so yeah there we go sounds like um most people are most bored game fanatics are evangelizing their friends and family from different parts of their life which yeah which was kind of the case for me i suppose okay so i think mckenzie and i made an agreement that we're going to try and we're probably moving forward we're going to just stick with the one segment with this or that section and um i think because we've run out of questions basically um we will but we will be kind of dwelling on our next section a bit more spending a bit more time talking about what we're kind of looking forward to playing before the before the next uh so because i think you're particularly
interested or eager to play before we get together again so right now i'm pretty excited the new expansion for paladins of the west kingdom should be here i hope that it it increases my opinion of the multiplayer game because right now i find that very lacking but i enjoy the solo mode i also have i do want to dive more into role player adventures to see if you know i it does get better over time by increasing my character's abilities and whatnot so hopefully it's not just a i'm going to die every round because there's like this death marker and you cross it off every time you die and i i hope that i don't get to the end i don't know what's gonna happen so oh geez so hopefully that that ends up being okay and then uh cartographers heroes i've been enjoying that so hoping to play more of that as well i think it's just a very simple twist so i'm excited to dive into the expansion maps for that so excited for those games in particular lots of new kickstarter deliveries um i also want to get my hands on gollum i want to try that one out uh my friend that brought us copies of boon like and messina also has a copy of gollum so i'm going to see if i can get some games of that in as well so excited to give that one a try amazing yes gollum's still unavailable here in the uk so just waiting for it waiting for it to be printed by somebody i know it is coming sooner or later but yeah i'm i'm with you actually with them cartographers here as we did we did get that um box in but we haven't tried it yet so it'll be interesting to try some of the new setups um but individual games um i got the new creamer and key sling the vanna park so i'll be trying that tomorrow i believe you're quite excited to try that one very family-friendly puzzly style game
but normally we're cramming keystone games they have a bit more to them than might first appear okay they're quite very simple mechanically but because of the puzzle aspect to it it's a bit more to it um also i think we're going to be trying service which is an older alexander game um in the next few days never tried it have you tried it i have not that's another one on the list so my friend that has gollum has broom service as well so that's like on our docket when we go play so excited that's awesome a bit different for the game yeah not the um not the normal big sprawling euro it's more of a pick up and deliver style thing so with some card play it looks quite interesting um and we still need to get jewels of the line to the table so hopefully by the end of the next episode i'll get jewels of the lion played and hopefully a couple more games of a feast for odin too so i can lock those thoughts into place
well for you to answer as well mckenzie um that ryan put or submitted so um ryan asked if there's time for a question and when you play uh when a game plays better at a specific player count um do you rate the game based on the experience at that player account or an average across all the player accounts a good question um ryan um how do you approach this um this idea mackenzie so this is a i agree i think it's a great question and this most recently came up actually on my review for tsukiyumi full moon down i think that game is not very good at one or three or more but i think a two-player game is really really good so i made sure that i when i did that i even did a separate review for it i gotta i make sure that i give the game it's due credit and really take it for its best approach i'm not going to rate a cooperative like social deduction game at a two-player account right it's not going to happen i'm not going to put it in a losing position i'm going to play the game and rate it based on where it's best and where it shines and then make sure that i explain in that review say hey it doesn't work well at these usually i'm going to rate it at that player count that i enjoy it at because that's the experience i'm going to play it i'm not going to play it as a crap player account it's not gonna happen so i definitely will rate it at the player count that's ideal and the way that i have fun with it so i'll rate my enjoyment on there so my rating for tsukuyumi right now is an eight actually uh because i think that two player game that's the way that i play it i enjoy it as a two player that i ate but if i were to rate it on kind of just the other modes it'd probably be like a five or a six i really don't think it's that good so yeah it's yeah i definitely will rate it based on
its ideal situation yeah i'm the same yeah i always do things on the optimal play account um because that's where i'll play it i have so many games so if i want another play account i'll play something else but it's a yeah a really good question because but i wouldn't yeah i wouldn't consider lowering a rating um because all the other player counts aren't optimal but i think that's a that's perfectly valid approach to do it so no criticisms to anybody who does but yeah personally i'll always base it based on the optimal you know for example my favorite game of grande is amazing at four or five players i'm not so good at the lower player counts so that says it all and i still rate it a 10 out of 10. so let's answer your question there ryan um and uh just a just another comment here from enrique saying i think this was i was talking about the deluxification of some games yeah so he said games like in the year of the dragon kalas grande are beautiful just the way they are um and kickstarter introduced toys to the hobbit i suppose one way of saying it and which are impossible to resist so yeah i'm completely with you enrique i actually love the um really strip bare bones games that are just no frills just not not ugly but they've not got all this bling and stuff that it doesn't really need um so yeah i'm with you i think they have their own unique style of beauty um what are your thoughts on games like like that mckenzie do you think there's still a space for it or do you think that time's and it's gonna hurt itself if it doesn't look as flashy as some of the newer games i think there's definitely room
for both so i'm a big fan of games that are very stripped back i love card games that are just like a single deck of cards i love stuff like that but i also do like that big you know that overproduced version of a game i like the kickstarter components i like being immersed in this world through the different things that i'm interacting with on the board so i like both i think there's definitely room for both and yeah i think that you can definitely pick the one that you enjoy more which is cool yeah absolutely that's the thing nowadays there's so many things coming out there is something for everybody so pick your poison choose what you want and um you'll and certainly you know even in some games you have the choice you know do you want to go well which is the next question do you want to go tell so you actually have that freedom and you're not pigeonholed to go a certain route so yeah that wraps up another episode of corporate cardboard thank you so much for joining us again i appreciate that we do this live um very early if it's in the states and thank you for mckenzie's always for getting up very early um and i really appreciate it not any of you guys have joined us but also for the guys who watch and slow time when you can so yeah thanks again and we'll join we'll see you next time on the next edition of corporate cardboard so goodbye for me see you later everybody thank you so much for watching bye bye